Actions

Work Header

the same deep water as you

Summary:

Billy has his first Change when he’s nine years old.

He hadn’t really been normal before that, though. His mom would take them swimming and she’d Change, and even though he didn’t have a fin or gills, he’d be able to keep up with her in the water. Would hold his breath for far longer than the typical two to three minutes; he could pop up to the surface a half an hour later without his lungs aching at all. He knew that it wasn’t considered normal, but it was his normal. Both him and his mom. And sharing something like that with her was worth the lifetime of secrets he knew came with it.

or, the billy is a secret mermaid au

Chapter Text

Billy has his first Change when he’s nine years old.

He hadn’t really been normal before that, though. His mom would take them swimming and she’d Change, and even though he didn’t have a fin or gills, he’d be able to keep up with her in the water. Would hold his breath for far longer than the typical two to three minutes; he could pop up to the surface a half an hour later without his lungs aching at all. He knew that it wasn’t considered normal, but it was his normal. Both him and his mom. And sharing something like that with her was worth the lifetime of secrets he knew came with it.

He wakes up that morning, skin feeling tight and dry while his mouth is absolutely parched . There’s an ache in his legs that only doubles down whenever he moves the slightest inch, so he just lays there, trembling. His mouth feels like it’s full of cotton, and he can’t call out for his mom no matter how much he desperately wants to. Luckily, she comes and checks on him about ten minutes later, and when she sees him her eyes go wide.

“Oh, baby,” she says, rushing over to his side, “Let me help you. Don’t worry, I’m gonna make it all better.”

“Make it all better” means bundling him up in his bedsheets and gently placing him in the backseat of her Jeep when she’s sure none of the neighbors are outside. He’s squirming in the back the whole drive, itching at his flaky skin and pressing shaking fingers to his swollen gums. Distantly, he kind of knows what’s happening, but he’s still confused—it never looked this painful whenever he saw his mom do the Change.

She keeps one hand on him the entire drive there, her arm bent back at an awkward angle as she reaches through the sheets to rub his shoulder. She coos and shushes him the whole ride over, trying to calm him, and by the time they get there he only feels worse.

That is, until his mom flies out of the driver's seat and yanks the back door open once they’ve parked. Billy breathes his first breath of salt-air, so close to the sea he can practically taste it. His mouth tastes a little like blood and spit, and he realizes his fangs have dropped. Shorter and blunter than his mom’s, but still painfully growing past his human gums. His mom is quick about it at least; scooping him up and running to the secluded alcove they usually swam in, tossing him unceremoniously into the water, still bundled up.

The second he makes impact he squirms free of the blankets, and takes what feels like the freshest breath of air he’s ever taken. Well, minus the actual air part. He can feel the odd sensation of his gills opening; quick pinpricks of pain at his sides and neck, although the ache passes quickly. Actually, most of the aches in general have subsided by now, replaced by a rush of endorphins that have him trilling and swimming circles around his mom, who just laughs.

“Slow down, you little marlin,” her laugh sounded like tinkling bells underwater, somehow the same and different all at once. “Now, we have to talk about some stuff.”

She’d given him a bit of a placeholder explanation before; revealing just enough, but also saying that dreaded phrase, “I’ll tell you when you’re older.” Now, when she spoke, he could finally understand. After she was finished, he ended up bombarding her with questions, asked in rapid quickfire, but she never lost her grin as she answered—always patient.

Yes , they’d be able to change whenever they were in saltwater, no, it didn’t have to happen every time. Yes , they could stay down there however long they wanted, no, they couldn’t stay too far from the water, or else. Yes, there were others like them out there.

“How many?”

She gave an easy shrug. “I don’t know, baby, but it’s a lot.”

His mind is still whirring a thousand gears ahead of them both. “Are there different kinds? Like, in different kinds of water?”

”There’s many different kinds of us, saltwater and freshwater,” she explains, placing a hand on his side to try to quell the restless kicks from his fin. “None of us are quite the same. We all have unique… qualities.”

He chews on that for a moment. “Okay, so then what kind are we?”

She gives a mischievous smile, smoothing back his hair before giving a loose curl a tug, “The pretty kind.” Her smile drops a second later, though. “We’re the foolish kind, too.”

He had a feeling she was talking about his dad. His dad knew it, all of it, and still curled his lip in disgust whenever his mom brought up swimming in front of him. Dad was different from mom. Some days were okay; on those he’d spin Billy’s mom around the kitchen and they’d dance and laugh and everything felt like maybe it could be alright. Other days… most days, it was bad. Screaming, crying, getting sent to his room but still able to hear everything through the paper-thin walls. He could hear whenever someone threw something. Or when someone got hurt. His mom had thought she’d put Neil Hargrove under her spell, when really it was the opposite.

“Billy,” her voice snaps him out of his thoughts. When he looks at her, she’s closer than before. “ Never be foolish, understand? Never be foolish, and never trust the mainlanders, alright?”

“Yes, ma’am,” he blinks back, having never heard his mom sound so serious towards him , “I understand.”

She stares a second longer, like she’s trying to see if he’s telling the truth or not, before she folds him into a hug. “Don’t be foolish like me,” she says one more time, softly into his hair.

The next year, she’s gone.

It shouldn't be a surprise. It was bound to give, one day. He’d already pictured them making their getaway together a thousand times over; heading into their little alcove and swimming away and never coming back.

What is a surprise, however, is that he’s left behind.

“Please,” he pleads on the phone. Desperate, fat tears streaming down his face at this point. His throat is scratchy, and his nose is so clogged from crying he has to keep breathing through his mouth. “ Please come back, take me with you.”

“It’s not that easy, seahorse,” she says miserably on the other side. Her voice is thick with tears, too. “I’ll find you, baby, I swear I’ll come find you. It won’t be forever.”

It might as well be, though, because it’s just silence after that. His dad doesn’t let him swim on his own once she leaves, so he sneaks out at night and takes the forty-five minute walk that leads him to their alcove. For two years straight he comes almost every night, sits on the shore to wait for a couple hours. It’s their spot. And she would know by now that Neil’s keeping him away from her during the day. If she were gonna show up anywhere, it’d be here.

But she never shows up. Every night he sits in the sand, letting the sea foam run over his toes, watching the moon’s reflection in the tides—but she’s not there. She’s never there. He probably would've still kept going, anyway, but Neil moves them further into the city in the fall. He can still get to the ocean, sure, but they're not as close to the alcove anymore. It’s not even the same beach. He tries not to give up hope, though; figuring his mom would probably make sure to check the whole West coast if she wasn’t able to find him.

It doesn’t matter, in the end. She never finds him, he stops looking, and stops going to the beach altogether. 

~

Hawkins, Indiana is painfully landlocked. 

He almost wants to congratulate his dad on a job well done; he managed to find the perfect place to make Billy miserable in every way. Not only is he being punished by having the water taken away, but apparently he loses modern civilization privileges too. Hawkins, Indiana has more cows than people. There's not even a mall . When they cross the county line he feels so heavy; sunk like a stone in the sea.

When they actually get to the town of Hawkins, he’s momentarily thrown off. Walking out of the car he’d been expecting that same farm-manure smell to carry over there, but standing in the driveway he’s taken off guard by… something different. Something so different that he’s stock still for a couple seconds; frozen while he tries to place that odd feeling and the trembling in his fingertips. Instinctively his gums begin to swell, and once he snaps out of it he’s quick to draw back the teeth and claws. Neil would kill him if he saw it.

As it is, he gets a shove from Neil for lollygagging anyway, so he decides to just put that off feeling out of his mind until they’ve settled. They’ve never been anywhere other than California. He’s probably just… allergic to all the stagnant air, or something. It needs more salt.

It’s better to put it out of his mind, anyway. Anything involving that is a sure-fire way to get Neil started. For the next year and a half he’s going to have to stick to the script, not step a toe out of line. For multiple reasons. 

And he’s able to do that… for like, a day or two. 

Then? Well, then he meets Steve Harrington at a Halloween party. And everything goes to shit afterwards. 

He leaves the party early at the end of the night—earlier than what’s expected of the newly crowned keg king. But he leaves early, and has to catch himself on the porch railing outside to catch his breath, a little. It feels like he’s been breathless since—since he saw him . Steve Harrington. The one he’s supposed to be usurping the throne of. 

Distantly, he can admit the appeal. Well, more than distantly. There’s nothing distant or uncaring in the way his heart picked up a couple beats when Harrington slid his sunglasses down, disinterested eyes already catching on his face. Billy usually doesn’t let himself feel weak. But at that moment? He was afraid his goddamn knees were gonna lock, or something. 

The drive back home is in a daze. He barely registers it. All he can think of is the way Harrington had slid those glasses down his straight nose, pinned him with those brown eyes, and—

Fuck. It’s almost physically painful to tear himself out of it. The windows are all rolled down in the car and the cold air is verging on painful when it braces against his skin but he still feels too overwhelmed, too heated. It’s dangerous. The implications. Never trust a mainlander , he desperately tries to remind himself. But it’s too late at that point.

Not only is he an actual freak of nature like his dad has told him time and time again, but he’s a freak in this way, too. Not for the first time, he’s overcome by just how fucking unfair it all is. He’s not even fully human, and he’s a fucking faggot too ? It’s a cruel sort of irony that makes him feel hysterical sometimes and just plain miserable most. Hawkins was supposed to be smooth sailing. This was going to be a shitty time, sure, but it was just gonna be for a year and a half and then he’d be gone. Home free. That was only if there were no fuck ups along the way. This smells like something that could cause a fuck up. It reeks of unforeseen consequences that he’s definitely not prepared for right now.

He wipes his face before he goes inside and heads straight for bed, determined to put the whole night out of his head, trying to convince himself it wasn’t as big of a deal as it was. Telling himself it won’t matter if he doesn’t do anything about it . Ignore Harrington completely, and he’s in the clear. Just that simple. 

~

Obviously, it’s not that simple. Billy’s never been able to leave anything alone, especially shit he has even half a modicum of interest in. So yeah, the night before he swears to himself he’s not gonna do anything. 

But then Harrington’s in those small basketball shorts the next day, sweating pretty and panting even prettier. Billy can smell the salt from the sweat clinging to him, everywhere, and it only fuels him on more. Almost makes him want to drool.

Harrington is magnetic when he’s riled up. There’s something that’s still kept under the surface that he keeps trying to squash and pretend away, no matter how much it peeks out. And Billy tries to coax it out—well, force it out with a game of basketball. But, just like always, it feels like Billy’s speaking  a different language than the rest of them— like he’s on a completely different wavelength, or something. The words don’t come out right, at all. And every touch is more aggressive than he wants it to be. By the end of the period he’s alone in the locker room, taking his time changing and just thinking why the fuck can’t I be normal?

He’s barely spent a full week in this shithole and he’s already found a tender spot. Harrington, prissy girlfriend or not, is not interested. Not even in the slightest. It’s enough to get him incensed, and then he’s even angrier when he realizes just why he’s in a bad mood. 

It doesn’t help that being this far from the ocean is starting to really grate at him. He stopped swimming a long time ago— it was starting to get too difficult to do it without Neil noticing, and he’d been caught one too many times climbing back into his bedroom through the window, hair still dripping wet. Not to mention the fact that it was something he did with his mom, and nowadays he’s left with a sour taste in his mouth thinking about anything to do with her. It hurts in general not to swim anymore, sure, but it was still doable. He’d be able to inhale the ocean air, always nearby, and that was enough. For a while. 

But now? Now he’s stuck in Midwestern hell, and the closest body of water is the quarry—and he heard they found some kids body in there last year, so yeah; there’s no fucking way he’s about to step foot into that cesspool. What that means for him, though, is that he’s been fucking vibrating out of his body 

His skin is itching, dry and flaky in the parts where his gills usually come out. Has him shifting in his seat, fidgeting when he’s standing, an ever present itch that can’t be scratched no matter how much he tries. It wears at him enough to make him snappier than usual, tension running under his skin like trapped lightning. Neil eyes him over his newspaper every morning as he tries his hardest to keep in check. Max looks wary. Susan averts her eyes. 

Max bears the brunt of it, per usual, but instead of fighting back she waits it out and fixes him with a look. Brows furrowing deep, canny eyes catching every tell. She doesn’t say anything, of course, even if she does suspect. It’s that unspoken rule amongst all of them: do not, under any circumstances, bring up Billy’s… condition. Even now, alone in the car and far away from Cherry Road, the threat of Neil’s wrath lingers between them, making Max scrunch up her nose and keep quiet, no matter how much he knows she has to say. As a peace offering, he plays his music at a slightly less-deafening volume.

But of course things eventually come to a head. He was practically a ticking time bomb at that moment, just waiting to let out some steam. And when Max goes missing a couple days later and Neil slaps him around? Well, he wouldn’t say he’s exactly grateful— more like relieved the inevitable has finally reared its ugly head. Everyone’s been so tentative since they got here, like they’re all afraid of ruining the shaky start they’ve constructed so far. It’s easier when Neil just gives up and gives in—so much more predictable than the tight, pained smiles and beady eyes promising something worse to come. It’s something reliable that he can expect.

What he doesn’t expect, however, is just how the night goes.

By the time he drives up to the Byers’ creepy shack, he’s already feeling fired up. When Steve Harrington walks out onto the porch almost immediately, that’s just icing on the cake for this shitshow of a night. He steps out of the car, and the showdown starts.

“Am I dreaming, or is that you, Harrington?” he calls, before he can help it. There’s just something about him that makes all of Billy’s common sense leave his body for a couple seconds.

“Yeah, it’s me. Don’t cream your pants.” Harrington calls back, and Billy feels a white-hot shiver run through him. Like he’s on autopilot, he strips off his jacket, desperate to feel the chill of the night air on what feels like burning skin now.

Harrington looks good, of course, but he’s looked good practically every day since Billy got here. While it’s not exactly an unpleasant surprise, it is still a little suspicious to learn that he’s out here in the middle of nowhere with his kid sister. Billy can scent her from here—the maple syrup she drenched her pancakes in this morning is no match for his nose. He plays along with it though, until Harrington lies to his face. Then, he’s mad. Mad enough to shove Harrington to the ground, stepping over him to march his way up to this godforsaken house. 

Only…

Only, when he’s stalking towards the house, up the steps and hand on the doorknob, he catches a whiff of something. Unconsciously he tightens his hand on the knob for a second, tuning in to all the firings in his senses going off at once. There’s a thick, rotting smell emanating from the house. It’s not just the stench, though, that stops him in his tracks: it’s the intrinsic knowledge that something is in there… and it’s not quite right. Call it instincts, call it a side effect of being a freak himself, but Billy knows that something is wrong. He’s never sensed anything else like him before, and he’s pretty sure it’s not that. Something worse, if the trepidation in his bones is anything to go by.

It kind of reminds him of that feeling he had when they first got there, stopping him in his tracks there, too. Maybe twice is a coincidence, but it’s not a coincidence he trusts. Not when it comes to shit like this . If there’s something else like him in there, or worse, he’s gotta know. 

He opens the door and gets greeted by a cacophony of noise. Max is screaming at him, some random ass kids are screaming at him, but it’s almost like he’s in a trance—completely overcome by that feeling that something isn’t right here . On autopilot, he follows the stench to the kitchen, ignoring the kids and ignoring Harrington who’s finally stumbled through the front door. He makes a beeline to the fridge and opens it up without hesitation. The whole room goes quiet. Something falls to his feet, and he looks down at it. Takes a couple seconds to process what exactly it is that he’s looking at before inhaling in a deep breath.

“Max,” he says, turning around to see her wide eyes, “You better start explaining, now .”

And that’s how he ends up going from getting ready for a night out, to driving out to this rotted pumpkin patch in the middle of fucking nowhere— the shitheads practically breaking the sound barrier in his backseat while Harrington eyes him nervously and gives directions. He ignores the nerves building as they get closer and closer. It’s a bad idea, but it’d be even worse if the little idiots did it on their own— which was sure to happen if he and Harrington didn’t agree to chaperone. When he gets out of the car he almost staggers to his feet, overcome by the concentration of that rotted scent and everything wrong about the place. 

“Billy?” Max startles him, hovering by his side. Her hand is tentatively outstretched. “Is everything… okay?”

“Yeah,” he grits out, even though he can immediately feel his gums going tender a second later. 

She bites her lip, casts a look over her shoulder where Harrington is trying to corral all the nerds. She steps closer. “Your teeth… and your fingernails, they’re—” another nervous look over her shoulder before she drops to a whisper, “they’re Changing.”

His hand flies up to his mouth, and sure enough he can feel the points of his teeth going sharper. His nails are almost fucked, too, lengthening into something unmistakably inhuman as his instincts pick up on whatever nearby threat there is. “Fuck,” he curses lowly, shaking out his hands and trying to retract his claws. The fangs are a bit more difficult, going a little blunt but still a bit too sharp for normal. 

Max does him a solid and rips the bandana from Harrington’s hands before he can even make the offer, shoving it his way and blocking him a little as he ties it around his face. When he’s sure he’s in the clear, he faces the group and squares his shoulders. 

“Well?” He asks, acting like the thought of the tunnels isn’t already making his stomach turn, “Are we going, or what?”

Harrington leads the front, and Billy takes the caboose. Half so he can keep an eye on Max, and half so he won’t be seen by the others just in case something happens. 

He tries to fight off that wrong feeling as much as he can, but under here it’s like it’s dialed up to a thousand. It’s one thing constantly being on steady ground, it’s another to be going underground , so surrounded by Earth around him that it feels claustrophobic. He’s trembling on the climb down, but trying not to show it. Max keeps looking back at him, like she knows how bad it’s getting, but he keeps his eyes straight ahead—determined to get this shit over with as soon as possible so he can go above ground and maybe not feel like he’s crawling out of his skin, anymore. 

It’s dark and muggy down there, drearier than anything he can imagine. There’s a constant dripping noise in the background, echoing off the walls, and the water coming through the soil on the sides and below their feet smells like sewage. The bandana helps a little, but he still gags a couple of times, eyes watering. 

He hangs at the back of the pack as they set the place on fire, feeling worse and worse by the second. It’s like he can’t breathe down here—he’s getting air but it still feels like he’s about to suffocate. Max stays by him the whole time, hovering and wringing her hands. When they have to make a run for it his body is practically flooding him with endorphins, a desperate adrenaline rush to get the fuck out of there as soon as possible. It’s enough to carry him through to the end; makes lifting the kids and Harrington out of the hole as easy as anything, just driven by the need to fucking get out get out get OUT.

When they’re finally out of it and he gets that first gush of fresh air in his lungs he almost feels manic. He just stands there for a moment, panting and relieved and shaking and—

“Hey,” someone’s touching his elbow and he jumps so hard he nearly gets them in the gut. It takes a second to get his breathing back to normal, not that it wasn’t bad in the first place, and when he finally looks over it’s Harrington standing there, palms up like he’s trying to show he’s not a threat. “Sorry, man,” Harrington chuckles nervously, “Didn’t mean to startle you.”

“Yeah,” he says, still a little jumpy, before he gets his wits back. He shakes his head a bit and lets out an uncomfortable cough. “It’s cool.”

They stare at each other for a second, both seemingly at a loss for words. Harrington anxiously runs a hand through his hair, and Billy tries to quell the blush rising to his cheeks. Even after a crisis, even after going through those tunnels, Harrington looks good. It’s so unfair.

“So… how did you know?” Harrington eventually asks when the silence goes on for too long. 

“Know what?” Billy replies dumbly, still trying to shake himself from the arresting sight of Steve Harrington fixing his hair. 

Steve gives a half shrug. “Well, I dunno,” he says, scratching the back of his neck, “How’d you know something was in the fridge?”

He realizes too late that it’s gone quiet around them. The kids are next to them now, and look curious too. The one with curly hair pipes up, “ Yeah , how did you know where to find the demodog?”

Helplessly, he looks over Harrington’s shoulder to meet Max’s eyes. She looks just as freaked as he feels. He was kind of hoping in the chaos of it all that they would just forget about that part, but now he’s got four pairs of curious eyes pinned on him. Luckily, Max is quicker than him. 

“It smelled like shit in there,” she quips, shouldering past them, “He probably followed the smell. Now can we get out of here, or what?”

Although it’s true, it doesn’t really account for his supernatural sense of smell and the fact that it probably didn’t stink that bad to the rest of them. He can tell the others don’t buy it, curly haired kid especially, but Max fixes them all with a look that would have even him shaking, effective enough that they’re all quick to scramble back to the Camaro. He tosses her a grateful look when the rest aren’t looking, and she just nods back with a grim line set in her mouth. 

The ride back is less frenzied, obviously, since now the kids are bursting with excitement instead of fear, but all he feels is drained. His gums still ache, and it still feels like he’s suffocating. It’s like his equilibrium has been thrown off, and he has no clue how to get back to normal. Harrington’s silent next to him, but Billy can feel his eyes on the side of his head a couple times through the force. He just ignores it and keeps his eyes on the road, focusing on getting back and making sure his hands don’t tremble on the steering wheel. 

The rest of the night is a wash, and by the time he drives him and Max back home it’s well past midnight. He’s too exhausted to even feel scared, figuring whatever shit Neil’s about to dole out would somehow be a welcome respite from dealing with this Upside Down shit any longer. Max fidgets next to him for the whole ride, anxiety palpable. He doesn’t know why she’s nervous; yeah, she’s the one who snuck out, but he was supposed to bring her home . And it was definitely implied that he was supposed to do it before one o’clock in the fucking morning, like he’s doing now. The worst she’ll get is a finger wag and maybe grounded from her precious arcade for a week. He’s not looking forward to what his punishment’s gonna be. 

“You’re not gonna say anything, right?” Max's voice jars him out of his thoughts. When he looks over, she’s fixing him with a look—like her little kitten glare is gonna somehow intimidate him into agreeing. 

As much as he wants to fuck with her and say no , he’s also not stupid. Exposing this means other stuff could come to light, and he’s more than okay with completely forgetting this night ever happened. “Well, duh, Max.” He says back drolly, rolling his eyes a little. 

She huffs, and folds her arms, but doesn’t argue any further. By the time they roll up to Cherry Road they’re both sitting up straight in their seats, wary of what’s waiting inside. He only gives her a quick glance before he sighs, taking his keys out of the ignition and accepting the inevitable. Max walks ahead, and he follows behind her, every step feeling heavier than the last.

~

Whatever hope he has about forgetting that whole night is immediately dashed the next morning. He’s loading books into his locker, contemplating just skipping the entire day and sleeping in his car, when Harrington appears next to him. 

“Fuck, man,” he puts a steadying hand in the locker frame, startled and even more caught off guard with how close Harrington’s standing. “Uh, you need something?”

Harrington shrugs, biting his lip. He looks just as bad, eyebags a shade of deep purple to rival his own. “I thought you might wanna talk today. I know we gave you kind of a half-assed explanation last night, but I can give you some actual answers. If you want, I mean.”

He stares at Harrington, a little in shock, and only jerks back into reality when he sees a flush settling in his cheeks. He can’t hardly believe his luck: for some reason Steve Harrington is offering to talk to him. After being ignored the last couple of days, he figured Harrington would probably just stick with that, and he’s kind of disarmed by the fact that it’s the opposite. There’s that tiny voice in the back of his head that questions why ? but for once he decides to shove it away, determined to try to let himself have at least one good thing right now.

“Sure, okay,” he finally manages, thankful that his voice is at least steady. 

Harrington lets out a quick little breath, bobbing his head like a doll. “Cool. Okay. Bleachers at lunch?”

At this point Billy can only nod, still kind of overwhelmed with the thought that Harrington’s willingly spending time with him—even if it is just to explain the insane shit happening in this town. Harrington disarms him a little further by giving a quick grin and turning to walk away, throwing a, “See you later!” over his shoulder. 

Billy doesn't know how long he stands next to his open locker, watching Harrington’s retreating form in the distance, but it’s long enough that the bell rings and he’s late to home room.

He’s honestly still thinking that it’s somehow a fluke—like this was some long winded way for Harrington to tell him he really didn’t give a shit, and he’d be alone on the bleachers at lunch. But when he’s out there, five minutes into the lunch period, Harrington’s already beat him there, sitting on the cold metal bleachers and messing with a Coke can. 

“Hey,” he says warily as he approaches, still expecting Harrington to somehow say the jig was up, completely prepared for the worst. 

He really doesn’t expect Harrington to offer him the Coke, and he’s too shocked to bat it away; instead, taking it like it’s something important. He rolls it around in his palms a couple of times, focusing on the cold condensation as Harrington sorts out all the details of the atom bomb he’s about to drop on Billy.

Harrington looks nervous right from the start; jigging his leg up and down as he anxiously runs a hand through his hair—a nervous tic that’s been drawing Billy’s eyes every time. “So… monsters, basically.”

It takes all his willpower to keep his face blank. Harrington isn’t talking about him, literally, but it still stings to hear. Makes him think of the thousands of arguments he’s been the subject of since his mom left, almost all of them ending with Neil calling him some variation of a freak or monster. That uncomfortable feeling clogging up his throat—realizing he’s as good as lumped in with those demon dogs—makes it hard to swallow, but he does it anyway. Tries to pretend like he doesn’t feel like he’s been lanced through the chest.

Instead, his face stays blank. Just nods and says, “Monsters,” and settles in for what’s bound to be an insane tale, all the while trying to ignore that constant guilt of lying by omission.

Harrington talks all the way through lunch. When the bell rings, signaling the start of the passing period, they share a brief look. Billy makes the executive decision for the both of them and stays firmly planted in his seat, waving his hand so Harrington can continue. He looks a little relieved to not go to class, either, so Billy figures he made the right choice. By now he’s starting to get a better sense of why Harrington tracked him down to talk: the guy sounds lonely. He skates over some stuff he deems “unnecessary”, and one of those subjects is just how spectacularly his relationship with Wheeler was imploding in the last year. Add into the mix the fact that he really hasn’t kept around many friends—aside from the dweebs that are all Max’s friends, too—and he can kinda see how the guy might be starved for company. Desperate enough to slum it with Billy Hargrove , of all people. It’s at least a little easier to understand.

By the end of fifth period Harrington is finished talking, and they’ve lapsed into a contemplative silence. Even after getting the full rundown, he can tell there’s still some stuff that doesn’t add up—details that are surely missing, but Harrington genuinely looks so exhausted by the end that Billy decides to take pity on him and let it be. It’s a lot of shit to remember, anyway, and he’d probably fumble explaining the intricacies of  his situation, too.

When it’s all said and done, thinking about it just kind of makes him want to laugh. Because, like the whole reason why they moved over here was so that Billy wouldn’t be surrounded by this shit; so subsumed in a plain, Midwestern hell that he becomes “normal” by some kind of osmosis. Only, trust the universe to plant them right smack dab in the middle of the craziest town in Indiana—stuffed to the brim with demon dogs and portals to other dimensions. And now, with a merman added into the mix, even though he and Max are the only ones who know that. It really shouldn’t be funny… but it kinda is. Maybe that’s the reason the hysterical giggle starts bubbling up in his chest—and once it gets started it’s like he can’t stop.

Harrington startles at the abrupt bray of laughter and watches him like he’s a crazy person, doe-eyes going wide and mouth opening a little in shock. After a couple of seconds, though, he gives a snort of his own, grinning broadly. “Fucking crazy , right?” he says, leaning into Billy’s space. “Just like… absolutely fucking bat shit !”

Billy’s been halfway to a mental breakdown ever since he got to this hellhole, and Harrington’s honking laughter is enough to finally push him over the edge; tears budding up and streaming down his face as the laughs just keep pouring out, spurred on by Harrington doing the same next to him. For once, it’s the good kind of ache; tightening in his chest and getting released immediately, the giddy rush following after he takes in a gust of air before he gets dizzy. He hasn’t laughed like this in a while, and for a couple moments it’s enough to forget about everything.

But at some point the laughs subside, and they taper off, and he’s just left feeling spent. He still has the giggles, though, and it takes a couple minutes of firm willpower to stifle them until they taper off. When he’s finally collected himself, smoothing his hands across his jeans, he looks back up and nearly jumps back. Harrington’s looking at him, close and canny-eyed.

“You know… you took this way better than I thought you would,” Harrington admits, “I was kind of a wreck after I first found out about all this shit.”

“Well, ya’ know,” he gives a casual shrug, searching for an explanation that’s better than I’m a fucking merman so it makes sense that there’s other wacky shit out there , “We got some crazy shit in California.”

Harrington rolls his eyes and shoves him in the shoulder. “Oh, shut up.”

“Hey!” he rubs his arm, pretending that it’s tender, “Careful with the merchandise, Harrington.”

“Steve.”

“What?”

Harrington’s still staring at him, weirdly intense, and bites his lip. “You know, my first name? We’ve fought monsters together, I figure you can call me ‘Steve’ now. Right?”

His throat goes dry. It shouldn’t mean jack shit— it probably doesn’t, but it’s still enough to make him clam up. It’s any wonder that he’s able to grit out, “Yeah, alright,” back without sounding like a schoolgirl with a crush, and he shifts his gaze out at the football field so he doesn’t have to look directly into the sun that is is Steve Harrington telling him to call him by his name. It shouldn’t mean anything. It doesn’t. But he feels warm the rest of the day.

Chapter 2

Notes:

sorry for the wait! life just got ahold of me and completely derailed this chapter. i also added a part three, the final part, which will hopefully be put out soon. enjoy!!

Chapter Text

There was a time when he was meant to keep it all a secret from Max and Susan. This was when it was still early days; when Neil was trying hard to ensnare Susan and she hadn’t taken those rose-colored glasses off yet. Neil was trying to have his picture perfect family: responsible older son, loving younger daughter, and devoted housewife. Never mind the fact that Billy was apparently useless, or the way Max was more likely to shove a kids’ face in the sand than hold their hand, or how Susan burned practically everything—even water. Billy wondered if he was the only one who felt like they were on eggshells all the time; wary of when the veneer would crack and Neil would get frustrated enough to show his true colors. 

They eventually moved into Susan’s two bedroom when he was fifteen. It was cramped as hell between the four of them, and since Max was a “lady” she was allowed to keep her room. Billy was shoved into the corner of the living room with a couple of cardboard boxes to hold his things until further notice. They hung up a shawl for his “privacy.” It was supposed to be something temporary until his dad found them a bigger rental, but it seemed like Neil was fine with dragging the process out as long as possible. It was uncomfortable at best and suffocating at worst. Billy didn’t complain, though, because staying in the living room made it easier to sneak out at night.

At that point he wasn’t holding out hope for his mom any more—she’d have found him by that time if she really wanted to. He was still sneaking out a couple nights a week to swim, though; limited by Neil’s ban of swimming in general combined with that aching, itching feeling that came whenever he was away from the ocean for too long. It stung a little, swimming by himself, but it was better than nothing. Sometimes Changing and watching his tail grow felt like opening up an old wound over and over again, but sometimes life wasn’t fair and you just had to mash salt into the cuts so next time they wouldn’t sting as bad. That lost feeling was never gonna change. But at least he was less antsy.

It was the same thing a couple of nights a week: sneak out after midnight and take the half hour stroll to the pier, find his hidden spot near the rocks to Change, then swim until morning light started streaking across the sky. Then, he’d sneak back in and would be tucked into bed before his dad had his morning coffee.

Then, one night after swimming a couple of aimless laps for hours (sometimes he found himself drifting in circles if he didn’t pay attention for too long—like his mom was his only tether in the water) he’d climbed onto a rock near the shore, catching his breath and letting his tail flop in the shallow water. He’d barely had just a second to take a big inhale in, when he heard someone behind him exclaim, “Holy shit .”

He jumped so hard he fell back into the water with a loud splash! When he resurfaced, it was to see Max standing on the edge of the shore, absolutely losing it with laughter and clutching her stomach like she had a stitch in her side. Her feet were bare, the house shoes a couple feet away near his own folded clothes, and the bottoms of her pajama pants were rolled up. “Your face!” she crowed, practically doubled over in laughter at this point, “Oh my god, you should have seen your face !”

“Shut up,” he bit back instinctively, before the situation caught up to him. It was like a lead weight dropping in his stomach. “Max—”

“I’ve followed you here this entire week ,” Max was practically vibrating, beside herself with uncontrollable excitement, “I thought you were meeting a girl or something, but holy shit ! You’re a mermaid! No, wait—a mer man , right? Like that’s what it is?”

“You can’t—” the words got stuck in his throat, the haze of panic and fear clawing its way up his chest and making it difficult to speak, “You can’t tell anyone, please , you have to—”

“Well duh ,” she cut him off, rolling her eyes, “as if I’m an idiot. Besides, who would even believe me?”

His mouth flips open and shut a couple times, searching for what to say. He’d never really prepared for that before, it was pounded into his skull—both literally and metaphorically—just how important it was to keep it a secret. Now, he’s sitting on a rock with his tail out as his eleven year old step sister laughs her head off. 

The night is basically over after that, Billy shoving his clothes and shoes back on as Max just rocks back and forth in her heels, practically bursting with shit to say. 

She peppered him with questions the whole walk back home, skipping circles around him and speaking so fast she got mushmouth. He has no clue how she’s so hyper closing in on two o’clock in the morning, but after a little bit she starts to wear him down, too. Her excitement is kind of infectious. He hasn’t talked about it in forever , and Max doesn’t seem disgusted or revolted or anything—in fact, she thinks it’s cool . Which is a pleasant surprise, seeing as Neil always looks like he’s sucking on a sour lemon whenever they briefly talk about it. 

It’s nice. They usually aren’t able to get along for this long, and Billy finds himself kind of easing into the idea of another person knowing—and not hating him for it. Whatever idyllic mood he’s in is squashed the second they turn on their street, though, to the sight of two squad cars parked in front of their place. 

Billy covers, of course. Tells them something that’s kind of near the truth: he snuck out to go to the beach, and Max followed him. The cops give him a good finger wagging and a lecture on how dangerous it is to swim at night—especially since he’s got a younger sister to look after. It’s almost word for word a lecture he’d get from his dad. It’s easy to duck his head and say, “Yes, sir,” especially when he knows it’ll end there. 

The second they’re out of the house is when the real interrogation happens. Neil of course clocked into the fact that he’s been swimming , and it takes almost no time for Max to crack under the pressure. He can’t even fully blame her, she’s not used to a determined Neil Hargrove. 

Funnily enough, everything coming to light is what finally seals the deal in Neil and Susan’s relationship. Whatever she sees that night, it’s enough to convince her that Neil is “trying his best” or some shit. He knows how his dad probably spun the whole thing: poor Neil Hargrove, left by his actual monster of a wife to deal with their freak of a kid all on his own. It’s what gets them that bigger rental, Billy his own room, and then the absolute explicit ban on anything to do with swimming. And this time, he’s making sure of it. 

He can’t fully blame Max for it; it was his own dumbass mistake sneaking out and thinking that no one would catch on. But it still fucking stings to get it taken away, and then see her sniveling over breakfast in the morning like she’s the one who got whooped the night before. It rankles his nerves. It sets the tone for the next couple of years. He’s a miserable bastard and is content on making her just as miserable, too. It doesn’t help that Billy’s other freak-like qualities come to light, also by Max’s big mouth and penchant for nosing into his business whenever she so pleases.  

They don’t really talk about it after that. Every so often Neil will say something, and Max will meet eyes with him across the table, but that’s about it. Susan doesn’t utter a peep at all. Neil usually just brings it up when he’s trying to make a point about just how much of a disappointment Billy is. The most they’ve spoken about it was actually that night at the Byers, when Max was making sure he wasn’t about to molt there, or something. 

So it’s fair to say he’s a little taken off guard when Max brings it up one afternoon unprompted. He’s fighting for his life trying to get out of the damn student parking lot when she says out of the blue, “I think you should go for a swim soon.”

It’s enough to have him slam his brakes for a second, cutting off Catherine Maroney and holding up the line for a couple seconds, a wave of horns blaring immediately afterwards. He waves them off agitatedly through the window, reversing again and pulling out of the lot fully before he even thinks about loosening his grip on the wheel. He doesn’t look at Max.

“Care to explain why?” he grits through his teeth, trying to keep his cool no matter how much the prospect of blowing his top is enticing.  But he’s been trying lately, and Max doesn’t say stupid shit for nothing. So she obviously thinks she knows something he doesn’t.

“Well, no offense, but you look like shit,” she states, matter-of-fact. His eye twitches without him meaning to. Uncaring of the dangerous waters ahead, she continues, “You looked like shit before, don’t get me wrong, but now you really look bad. Like, your skin is starting to peel around your forehead and it looks gnarly. It’s ‘cause you have to swim, right?”

His hand flies up to his hairline where, sure enough, the rough patch of skin that’s been sitting there for the last couple of weeks begins to scratch underneath his fingernails. Yeah, okay, so he’s a little dry, but it’s nothing that’s not manageable. Just drink a gallon of water plus two showers every day and he’s almost normal… ish.

Max is ultimately right, though. It’s been almost two full years since he stepped foot into the ocean and had a proper swim, and he’s starting to really look worse for wear. Not anything especially noticeable… but it’s enough to spot if you see a person every day and kind of know one of their biggest secrets. Not just the dry skin or the constant cottonmouth, but he’s been feeling so much more on edge, too. He thought it might just be learning about the supernatural goings-on of Hawkins, but it makes more sense that it has something to do with the whole lack of swimming thing. 

He chews on his bottom lip while Max waits him out. After switching lanes, he admits, “You might be right.”

“Of course I’m right,” she gives an over-the-top eye roll, “You’re practically deteriorating before my eyes, so.”

“Fuck off, you’re deteriorating.”

“Ooh, nice one,” Max drawls monotonously, “What’s next: I know you are, but what am I?”

This time he doesn’t dignify that with an immediate verbal response. It’s much more satisfying to jerk the wheel to the right sharply, Max’s arms flying out to steady herself in the front seat where she purposely skipped on buckling up after school. “Whoopsie.”

“Dickhead,” she smacks his arm, not even flinching this time when he jerks the wheel again, “You’re only acting like a jerk because you know I’m right.”

“Okay, sure whatever,” he rolls his eyes back at her, “What the fuck am I supposed to do about it, though? I’m not swimming in the goddamn quarry, and I’m sure as fuck not dipping my feet in the creek by the trailer park.”

“Well I don’t know!” She bursts back, arms thrown up in the air, “Do I have to think of everything for you? I’m just saying. You look like shit. Therefore, you should find some way to swim. Before you shed all your skin, or something.”

“I’m not a fucking snake, ” he hisses at her. 

“You sure sound like one.”

Billy gives her a look that says just how amusing he finds this whole exchange to be. Max, for her credit, just gives him a look back. Even raises her eyebrows at him, like so what? It’s a wonder what playing nice does for him, now. Kid’s not even breaking eye contact. 

With a frustrated sigh, he turns back to the road and keeps his eyes straight ahead. “Fine, whatever,” he bites back, the conversation making a bright spot of pain bloom behind his eyes. “I’ll figure something out.”

Easier said than done, since he’s still sticking to his guns about swimming in the quarry. But she’s right. It’s due time, and now that they’ve brought it to the surface it’s like it feels a thousand times worse . 

“You know…” she begins in a careful tone, which spells trouble more than anything, “You could ask for help.”

He scoffs. “From who?”

“Steve?”

He gives her a look. “C’mon, Max.”

“I’m serious!” she defends, “I mean, you saw him that night. And he’s dealt with weirder stuff from last year. You could tell him about your… thing , and maybe he could find a way to help?”

“I’m not telling Steve about my ‘thing’,” he grouses, keeping his eyes on the road. The only tell he shows that the conversation is bugging him is in the creak of leather around the wheel as he tightens his hands. “I’m not gonna open that can of worms again. And I’m not about to give him another reason to call me a freak, thanks.”

The first reason is implied, and it makes an uncomfortable silence settle in the car. Max drops the subject quickly after that, the smartest move she’s made since bringing up the subject entirely, but it still sticks with him for the rest of the car ride. Carries over into the night, late, when he’s staring at his bedroom ceiling and subtly scratching at the dry skin beginning to collect at his elbow. It rankles his nerves that Max was able to pick up on it, makes him scared to think that if she could see it, what about his dad? He’s already walking on a tightrope for a multitude of reasons, and while she’s right about the water thing—he doesn’t really see any prospects in mind. And telling Steve is a concept he steers away from entirely.

Nothing really changes after that. Wanting the ocean isn’t gonna make it appear, no matter how hard he tries, and no amount of fed up looks from Max is gonna change that, either. He'll find a place to swim. Eventually. It’ll happen; it’s just gonna take a while. And if he happens to drag his feet in the process… well, that’s no one’s business but his own. No matter how much Max seems to be convinced that she has as much of a stake in this whole thing as he does.

She thinks it’s just that simple , when it’s really not. And he definitely doesn’t have the patience for highlighting all the painful reasons why it’s not just getting from point A to point B. Max means well, but she also doesn’t know at all what she’s dealing with. Maybe he doesn’t really either, but that’s not really anything new. 

~

Steve and Billy have been cool for a while. They eat lunch on the bleachers, talk shit in basketball, and sometimes share a smoke at the quarry after school. Or meet up at the diner for a burger. They laugh, joke around, and are generally friendly. They’re friends, by now. And that’s not even Billy being presumptuous—Steve has said himself that they’re friends, so. That’s where he’s at. It makes it a little harder to swallow down that all-consuming crush he has on Steve, sure, but he’s never been one to look a gift horse in the mouth. He expected to move here and be immediately miserable , so it feels like an embarrassment of riches to have an actual friend that he can trust and just forget about everything else going on. Most of the time it’s easy to be with Steve, as long as he ignores the whole life-altering crush thing. 

It’s a little difficult sometimes—like when Steve bites his lip, or their hands brush while grabbing a drink, or when he teases and pushes a little too far and Steve ends up with the most delicious blush on his face, but Billy’s been working on it. Trying to work on it. Baby steps.

He starts questioning about all of his life choices as of late when Steve asks him to come over on Friday night. It’s normal. It’s just a normal thing that guy friends do: hang out at each other's houses and drink beer and probably smoke. But with Steve staring at him from his spot on the bleachers, almost looking shy … well, it’s not normal the way he snorts his Yoo-Hoo through his nose.

“Jeez, man,” he smacks Billy on the back, “Told you that shit was nasty.”

He ignores it, giving another painfully embarrassing cough as he tries to fight past the itching in his throat. “What’d you ask?” he demands instead. 

Steve gives a shrug like he didn’t just say it. The tips of his ears are going pink, though, so Billy wonders if maybe Steve isn’t as casual as he’s trying to come across. The telltale sign is the way that he anxiously pushes back his hair. “I asked if you wanted to come over to mine on Friday night? My parents are gone, so.” His face blooms bright red after he abruptly stops the sentence, like he’s aware of how that sounds. Of the implications . Implications that are usually paired with romance and couples and basically all the shit he needs to keep on a total lockdown.

For once, Billy decides to take pity on him. Teasing him about that would basically be showing his own cards, so he’s not gonna touch that shit with a ten-foot pole. “Yeah, totally. I mean, that sounds cool. Want me to bring some beer?”

“Yeah,” Steve looks relieved, “I got some movies and a joint.”

“Wow,” he can’t help but tease at that , he’s only human after all, “You sure know how to treat a date, huh?”

“Fuck off,” Steve’s cheeks are still red, and his eyes are lingering on Billy’s face, but he’s still grinning. It’s not a bad look. 

In fact, it’s the visual that he holds onto the rest of the week. When he’s late to Spanish and gets chewed out, when his dad bitches at him for drinking the last of the orange juice, when Susan accidentally shrinks one of his favorite shirts. Right when he feels like he’s about to pop, he remembers Steve’s happy, almost excited face, and the rest of the week fades away. 

Friday afternoon has him absolutely sick to his stomach, driving the way to Loch Nora with the radio turned off and his clammy hands gripping the steering wheel for dear life. There’s a small part of him that wants to cancel, give in to that pulsing anxiety in his chest. But there’s a much larger part of him that practically screams no fucking way he’s about to pass up on this opportunity. He rolls up into Steve’s driveway going about 5 miles an hour, yeah, but at least he’s there, right?

Steve’s digs are nice , although he doesn’t know why he’s so surprised. You don’t give a teenager the latest BMW model without having a little extra cash to throw around. He’s seen the McMansions in the Valley, too, whenever they would get invited to the random rich kids’ parties out there—but that’s California money. This? Harrington's huge house surrounded by the forest? That’s old money, established. The wrap around driveway should’ve been his first clue. 

It’s even crazier on the inside, big rooms with tall ceilings that make him stop dead in the foyer—and they also have a fucking foyer— to stare up and see where they end. It’s decorated well, too, at least as far as his limited knowledge of interior design can tell. It’s got that new modern style going through it—Steve’s parents must be real contemporaries. 

Steve nervously watches him take it all in, standing on the outskirts and anxiously twiddling his thumbs while Billy looks around like an orphan from a Charles Dickens novel. He’s got an uncomfortable smile on his face when Billy looks over, like he’s waiting for the inevitable joke—and somehow the expression makes the words die on his lips. For now he just keeps walking, silently taking in everything around him. 

It’s only when he gets to the back of the house that he finally says something. “Damn,” he breathes, and stops right in front of the back window. Tommy talked about Steve’s nice house, and his even nicer pool, but this… this is something else. The wall next to the corner of the kitchen is basically all glass, only partially concealed by some heavy cream linen curtains at the other end, letting the eerie blue light from the pool fill up the room. Outside, in the middle of his large backyard with looming trees, the pool sits there—unnaturally bright and inviting. It looks a little disconnected from the rest of it; this bright shining beacon in the middle of all the darkness. He can see how Steve would use this to pick up chicks—with a flush of his cheeks he acknowledges that he’d probably be just as susceptible to seduction if someone offered him a pool like this . When he looks over his shoulder, to say as much, he’s startled by how close Steve is, now.

“Yeah, that’s the pool,” Steve says, tightly, his bottom lip going firm. He opens his mouth, like he’s gonna say something else, but closes it a second later and leaves the sentence hanging there. 

Billy takes him in: making note of the line of tension in his shoulders and the way he’s restlessly drumming his fingers against his thigh. He considers being tactful for a moment—pretending that he’s not picking up on the bad vibes Steve is putting down—but decides against it. Since when has he ever beat around the bush? He figures it’s best to just dive right into it. “So… what’s the deal, then?”

Steve turns to him, brows flying up his forehead. “What?”

“What’s the deal?” Billy repeats patiently, not letting him sink into any kind of deflection. “You’re, like, fucking glaring at it, man.”

The moment stretches on  a little longer, with Steve staring at him like he’s perplexed Billy even bothered asking. He’s afraid for a second that maybe he really did go too far, until Steve’s shoulders slump with a heavy sigh. “Okay. You remember how I told you how all this shit started? With Jonathan’s little brother going missing, and Nancy’s best friend also disappearing?”

Billy nods, scrubbing back through all the insane shit Steve has told him so far. “Yeah. She died, right?”

Steve’s face blanches a little bit, but he nods nonetheless. “She was killed in my pool.”

His eyes practically boggle out of his skull, sliding his gaze from Steve, to the pool, back to Steve again. “The fuck ?”

“Well, I mean, not technically ,” Steve is quick to amend, taking in the way Billy practically jumps back from the back window. “Like, she died in the Upside Down version of my pool. Not in my actual pool. But, like, still.”

“Oh,” he says, testing it out. “So, like, the nightmare realm version.”

Steve lets out an abrupt giggle at that, verging on hysterical. “Yeah,” he says at last, once he’s tapered off and running an anxious hand through his hair, “basically that. The nightmare realm, or whatever. I don’t really know how it happened. I think she somehow stumbled through a gate and then ended up back there, but… it was waiting, or something. And then it got her here, so. Yeah.”

Billy chews on his lip, gazing back out at the pool for a couple seconds, before turning to Steve again. He just has to make sure. “And you never use it?”

“I mean,” he gives a helpless shrug, looking flummoxed. “I don’t know. Would you? I don’t have nightmares, or anything, but it’s still kind of freaky. Like… maybe the portal could open again, and one of those things just comes crawling out of the pool filter, or something.”

“Hm.” Billy just hums back, eyes fixated on the pool again. Honestly, it probably wouldn't bother him, still. In the water he’s pretty confident on his skills as a predator—and maybe it’s a little cocky, but he’s pretty sure he’d be able to hold his own if any of those petal-faced fuckers ever actually broke through under there. It just seems like a sad fucking colossal waste to have the pool sit here all year round, untouched. No one’s stepped foot in it for at least a year , from the sounds of it, and Harrington mentioned once that it was heated. Location of a supernatural murder or not, Billy would still use that shit day and night.

It’s been so long since he just swam, too. Not even Changing and swimming, but swimming in general. It was just too risky to attempt it in the ocean, unless he was somewhere secluded enough where people wouldn’t notice a fin or his gills reopening on his sides. None of his friends had any pools either, just preferred the good ol’ Pacific any time they wanted to go out on the water. Max’s words from a couple weeks ago crop up in his mind, unbidden. Even she could see he needed a swim. And here comes opportunity knocking; wrapped and tied with a bright shiny bow. His hand itches towards the doorknob, twitching at his side as he fights to keep it there. He’s so drawn to the damn thing his whole center of gravity’s all thrown off, making him list forward unconsciously before he corrects himself.

Realizing he’s probably been staring like a loon, he shoves himself out of his haze. “Well, try to think of it this way,” he says after a moment— looking over to find Steve’s dark eyes already pinned to his face. It throws him off for a second, sending shivers down his spine, recalibrating before he tries again. “Think of it this way: the chlorine’ll probably kill it before it can get too far.”

It’s successful in cutting the tension in the room, getting Steve to snort and slug him in the shoulder. “Har, har, dickhead. It’s not chlorinated, though, it’s a saltwater pool; still think that’ll work?”

It feels like his brain stops short. “A saltwater pool?” he asks dumbly.

Steve gives him a look. “Yeah, you’ve never heard of one?”

He gives a useless shrug in response, heart ratcheting up in his chest and trying to contain his giddy nerves. There’s no fucking way.

Steve gives a careless shrug like he’s not completely upending Billy's world one word at a time. “Yeah, apparently it’s better for your skin and hair or something? I wanted to just drain the whole thing, but my mom ended up breaking her leg last Spring and used it for physical therapy. It’s some stupid rich person shit.” He tosses Billy a wry look. “Think salt will kill ‘em too?”

“Sure,” he can hear himself distantly replying, still staring out at the open pool of opportunity , now, “Should melt ‘em like snails. They’re made out of goo, right?”

After that, Steve ushers him out of the kitchen and dining room, showing him the rest of the house before they park it in the living room. He’s half focused on his surroundings, the other half still locked into position by that back window, staring out into the water and longing to dip his feet in.

But Steve obviously doesn’t give a shit about his pool, and actively chooses not to swim in it. He’s not about to beg and plead with the guy to let him get his toes wet, even though that’s exactly what he wants to do. He doesn’t think it would be dangerous— it’s not really salt water, right? There’s gotta be some kind of chemical component in there, something that’ll make his body resistant to Changing if he ever gets in there. It’s so tempting. Almost too tempting to even allow himself to fantasize about it. But Max’s words keep ringing around in his head, heralding one of the worst ideas he’s had in a longtime to the forefront of his mind. There’s no way he’s gonna convince Steve to swim. Steve doesn’t want to swim, and Billy’s not about to try to change that. Jesus. One glance at a pool and he’s already thrown off his game completely.

He’s good for the rest of the night. Doesn’t even glance towards the back door or what lies beyond. When Steve offers to grab them a couple more beers from the fridge, though, Billy jumps up instead.

“Gives me an excuse to stretch my legs,” he explains quickly, seeing how Steve’s eyes widen, “Let me.”

It takes about three seconds to grab the beers from the fridge, but he allows himself another thirty to just look outside the window again, take it all in. It’s just sitting there, untouched. The water is so smooth and still it’s not difficult to imagine the ripples that would come from jumping in. Or even just splashing his tail. God , he wants to swim so badly. Instead, he just clutches the bottles of beer in between his clenched fists and takes a deep breath, turning back to the living room. Steve’s eyes curiously follow him when he walks into the room, narrowed in an uncharacteristic manner, but Billy doesn’t say anything. Neither does Steve, so it must be nothing.

Next week, Steve invites him over again. Offers it a little more confidently this time, staring at Billy like he’s starting to get a read on him. Billy accepts, of course, since he’d be an absolute idiot to do anything otherwise. It’s not easier the second time around, though, feeling his palms get sweaty and the tips of his ears warming up. But he plays it off a little better this time, no longer nonplussed by the idea that Steve Harrington would willingly invite him over to hang out. After that it becomes the new normal, a new rinse-and-repeat that he could honestly never get tired of, if he’s being real. Hanging with Steve will never lose its shine. 

And if he happens to glance at the pool every so often? Well, that’s just his problem. It’s a little difficult to miss it, though, especially since Steve leaves the pool lights on all the goddamn time and the thing practically glows like a beacon every time he goes into the kitchen or has to leave the living room to go take a piss. Sometimes he’ll just pass by, without a second glance. Sometimes… most times he stops for just a second , and allows himself to fantasize about what it’d feel like. Allows himself to picture the warm salt water on his skin before he cuts himself off—drags himself out of the fantasy before he really lets it develop and ruin his life. He thought he was being subtle this whole time, but apparently not.

Like clockwork, Steve invites him to hang out on Friday night. He seems completely fine with hosting every week, barely ever asks about Billy’s lack of offer for his own house to hang out at, and it seems like everything’s normal. He’s a little twitchier than usual, but it’s not anything Billy really places as extremely out of the ordinary.

Steve meets him right at the door this time, answering before he can knock. Billy stands there with his fist still outstretched, suddenly taken off guard by his sudden appearance. 

“Hey,” Steve breathes, looking a little embarrassed. Billy lets his hand fall. “Heard your car coming, so.”

He moves to the side so Billy can come in, but instead of heading to the living room like they usually do, Steve lingers in the hall. “So,” he says, when Billy just stands there like an idiot, “Wanna go swimming?”

It’s about the last thing he expects. So much so that he just blinks back for a couple seconds, face getting warm when Steve starts cracking a smile. “What?” He finally manages to croak out. 

“Go swimming,” Steve shrugs, like he didn’t tell Billy how much he hates his pool. “You want to, right?”

“But, I mean—” he stutters, before getting a hold of himself, “you hate the pool, right?”

Steve’s face pinkens a little, but he waves a hand like it’s nothing. “I don’t hate it , hate it. Just like… didn’t really have a reason to use it again. Until now.”

Billy raises his eyebrows, unable to fully believe what he’s saying. “And the reason being?”

“You wanna swim in it,” his face has gone full red at this point, but Steve keeps shrugging it off like it’s no big deal. Like they didn’t just talk last week about how fucked the whole thing was. And here he is, offering it up because—“Don’t tell me you don’t wanna use it. C’mon. You’ve been drooling over it ever since you first saw it.”

His mouth goes dry. It’s hard to speak when Steve’s just standing right there, hovering close and staring right at him. From here, Billy can feel the heat radiating off of him. It’s messing with his senses; making his nerves fire off synapses that have him resisting the urge to fidget. The weight of Steve’s brown eyes is heavy. 

“Come on,” Steve tries to cajole him, probably sensing that he’s slowly but surely wearing Billy down, “I’ll even let you borrow some swim trunks.” Fuck. “So? You wanna?”

It sends a frisson of heat down his spine, and this time he’s unable to suppress the shiver that it gives him. Jesus , one offer of swim trunks and he’s practically combusting on the spot. Pathetic.

Not trusting his own voice, he settles for a shaky nod. Fuck it. It probably won’t be that bad, right? He’s making a big deal out of nothing. 

It’s worth it for the smile that Steve gifts him, beaming so brilliantly it stretches his cheeks. “Sweet,” he squeezes Billy’s bicep, unknowingly sending him into another tizzy, “Lemme get the stuff from upstairs.”

Steve bounds off and away, leaving Billy standing in the foyer with his mind racing. “Fuck,” he says quietly to himself, wiping his clammy palms on the thighs of his jeans before running a hand down his face, “ Fuck. ”

He glanced at the staircase, and above. Distantly, he can hear Steve walking around, probably muttering under his breath like he always does. He looks back at the back door and debates for a second. Figuring he may as well face it head on, he walks towards the back door and slips out as quietly as possible, hoping that whatever head start he gets will help him screw his head back on right.

The pool looks just as eerie as it always does at night, but the smell of salt in the air has him drifting towards it, like he’s in a haze. It was a fucking monumentally stupid idea to agree to swimming, but maybe it won’t be so bad. Maybe it doesn’t have to be. Maybe the salt levels aren’t actually high enough to trigger anything. Maybe the chlorine can offset it, or something. Maybe he’s making a big deal out of nothing. Or maybe it’ll be just as bad as he thinks. Fuck. Why did he say yes?

“Hey! Didn’t know you were out here already,” Steve’s voice comes from behind, startling him so badly he nearly jumps off the edge. Steve’s cheeks are pink when he hands over a pair of dark blue swimming trunks and a towel. It’s difficult for Billy to tear his eyes away from the sight of Steve swallowing heavily. “Here.”

They change in the pool house, and it’s a testament to how nervous Billy is—because he doesn’t even give Steve shit for having a pool house in the first place. The air is thick while they’re changing, some kind of tension sitting between them that has his mind working in overdrive. Neither of them really say anything when they get back out; with Steve probably nervous about using his pool for the first time in forever, and Billy… well, Billy fearing the worst.

In the end, Steve turns out to be the braver one of them both. “Here goes,” he chuckles unsteadily towards Billy, the tiniest tremble in his hands, before he takes a deep breath and dives right in.

It takes about two seconds before he’s bobbing up again, wiping the wet bangs from his forehead. “Well?” He grins at Billy, “Coming in or what?”

Taking a deep breath, and saying a last Hail Mary, he walks off the ledge and into the water.

Steve wasn’t joking at the heated pool. The first thing he recognizes is the warmth around him, all encompassing. It feels fucking great, if he’s being honest. He takes a second to stretch his legs a little underwater, kicking in circles until he finally breaks the surface for air.

Across from him, Steve is laughing. “Knew you wanted to swim,” he says confidently, giving Billy a little splash, “Now—”

Whatever he says next, Billy has no clue. One second he’s grinning back at Steve, relieved— so relieved—and then the next, he’s writhing in pain.

It’s something he hasn’t felt in years, pain so white-hot it’s almost debilitating. Has him reaching out and gasping for air before he even goes under. The pain starts at his legs, pins and needles being shoved into every pore as his legs fuse together and the scales start to come out. It’s been so long since he Changed that he forgot the most important rule: stay still and keep calm. Instead, he thrashes around and makes things worse with every passing second.

That’s not the worst of it though— it’s the fucking gills that make him want to die. He hasn’t used them in years, so when they split open it’s like fresh skin getting cut: slits opening in his sides and neck and immediately getting subsumed with the sting of the salt water. The water filters in and out in droves, leaving him gasping fruitlessly underwater as he sinks like a stone, clutching at his sides where he can see the tendrils of blood seeping slowly through the water.

He can’t see anything underwater; eyes stinging from the burn of salt and chemicals while a diluted cloud of blood gathers around him, tinting everything in a haze of pink. For a little bit the only thing he can focus on is the pain. He feels like he’s twitching underwater forever, until someone digs their hands under his armpits and hauls him up, up, up, until he’s out of the water.

From there it’s an overload of sensation. He has to screw his eyes shut as he tries to adjust and breathe in oxygen, the pain in his legs and sides slowly leeching out as he scrabbles around on the concrete lip of the pool. After that, everything starts to edge back in one after the other; the smell of the saltwater, the bleary sight of his tail flopping around in the concrete, and finally— the sound of screaming in his ear.

“—the fuck, what the fuck!” Steve’s voice filters in, almost deafening in volume and definitely on the verge of hysterical, “Billy, Billy, what in the—”

It’s too much all at once, and he has to shut his eyes tightly again as he catches his breath. Blindly, he reaches out and feels around until he can grip Steve’s arm. “Shh,” he manages, eyes still shut, “just—just gimme a sec.”

Steve shuts up immediately, at least, going so quiet so fast Billy would’ve thought that he got up and left if it weren’t for the warm weight underneath his palm. After a second or two, he feels Steve's other arm reach up and wipe some of the stray curls from his face. The touch feels nice, like a balm he didn’t know he needed, and he lets himself sigh and sink into it for a moment, letting his breaths pan out slowly and letting Steve pet his face for however long it takes to stop feeling like everything’s so much .

Finally, after what feels like forever, he cracks his eyes open. Steve’s staring straight down at him, deep furrow in his brow and mouth turned down at the edges as his eyes scan over every inch of Billy’s face. “Hey,” he says shakily, although still way more steady than Billy thought he would manage, “Uh, are you—are you good?”

It takes a couple swallows before he’s finally able to croak out, “Been better.”

Steve lets out a laugh, tinged with a little hysteria and slowly pestering off into some short gasps. It takes him a couple seconds to realize Steve’s having a panic attack, and Billy twists in his grip until he’s sitting up, wincing at the gills in his side being pulled but shoving himself up so they’re at eye level.

“Hey,” he says, firm and unyielding, “Hey, just breathe with me, alright? In, and out. In, and out.”

They do that for a couple of minutes, Steve pressed so tight up against Billy he can feel the fast beating of his heart, like a hummingbird. Slowly but surely it starts to slow down, along with his breathing, and when he looks back up to Steve’s face to confirm he’s okay again, he finds him already looking back.

“You—” Steve starts off with wide eyes, glancing behind Billy to where he knows his tail is laying, stretched out, “You’re a—”

“Monster,” Billy finishes for him, trying not to let his face give everything up. Fighting back tears is a nearly impossible feat at this moment, with all the misery coursing through him, but he can’t let himself lose his cool right now , “I’m a freak, yeah.”

“ No ,” Steve breathes back, immediately. He sounds so insistent Billy has to look up, finding brown eyes seeking his own imploringly, “I thought you were—you started thrashing and I thought the fucking thing had got you, or something,” he shakes his head, glancing back at Billy’s tail again, “But you were—you are—”

“A freak of nature?” he finishes, looking away again. The shame tastes sour at the back of his throat. All he had to do was keep this huge fucking secret , and of course he failed. “I know, alright? You don’t have to sugarcoat it. I’m the freakiest of freaks in this fucking town. I just didn’t want you to know, either.”

Steve shakes his head, grabbing his arm. Billy almost flinches away, surprised Steve would still want to touch him after this. “What are you talking about? You—you’re—you’re amazing .”

Billy stares back at him, mouth opening and closing uselessly for a moment. “ What ?”

“Just look at you,” Steve gestures broadly towards his tail, “I mean… yeah it’s definitely not, like, normal , but you’re—” his cheeks bloom dark pink, and he glances away before landing back on Billy’s face, looking like he’s summoning up the courage for something, “You’re—it’s beautiful .”

Oh .

His cheeks flame hot, too, and he has to look away for a second. Looks back at his tail, tries to see what Steve sees. All his life Neil’s been telling him just exactly how much of a disappointment he is, starting with the fact that he’s an abomination . That’s the one constant that’s stuck with him through all this time; the innate knowledge that something was wrong with him, and because of that he was a monster.

But the look Steve’s giving him right now… the wide eyed wonder as he glances back at Billy’s tail over and over again… it makes him squirm. It’s like looking at the sun again: too bright and makes him wanna close his eyes just to protect himself. Tuck his tail closer to him, afraid that Steve’s gonna take it all back. 

“I didn’t know how to tell you,” he blurts out, ashamed, “After the shit at the Byers’ I didn’t want to… I was afraid that…” it’s hard to finish the sentence, the words getting stuck in his throat. He has to, though. “I didn’t want you to be scared of me.”

“Well, fuck, you nearly gave me a heart attack in the water just now,” Steve laughs incredulously. When Billy doesn’t crack so much as a grin, still looking away, Steve reaches over and nudges him in the shoulder. “I wasn’t scared of you . I was scared of what was happening to you. I thought you were, like, gonna die for a second. But then I dragged you out and…”

He sniffles a little, still avoiding eye contact. Steve’s beating around the bush and being nice about it, per usual. “Saw the tail.”

“Saw the tail.” Steve confirms. “Hey, look at me.”

Billy has to wipe his nose first, but he finally manages to look up. Steve’s looking at him, something so warm and kind in his eyes that it makes him wanna look away again. He’s helpless to Steve’s eyes, though, pinned to his face and willing him to keep eye contact. 

“You’re not a monster,” he says, still looking at Billy in a way that can only be described as tender , as much as that makes Billy want to sink into the ground for good. Steve tentatively reaches a hand out, squeezing Billy's bicep before slowly letting go and letting his hand trail down his skin to his wrist, where he grasps him again. “Whatever you think you are—you’re not. This is amazing , okay?”

“I’m just like them, though,” he sniffs, unable to help it. “I’m… not right. Not normal.”

“First of all, you’re not anything like those things,” Steve says vehemently, lowering his hand even further to grip Billy’s fingers between his own. He has to suppress a shiver. Steve continues on, unrelenting. “And fuck normal. My life hasn’t been normal since junior year. Compared to everything else? This is like a walk in the park.” His expression eases up a little, a corner of his mouth quirking up in a smirk. “Or a swim in the pool, huh?” He judges Billy, waggling his eyebrows with a bright, goofy grin making his face glow.

Billy relents with a smile, rolling his eyes at Steve’s stupid joke, but it’s fleeting. “Yeah, well. You haven’t seen the fangs or claws yet.”

Steve’s silent for a moment, ostensibly chewing that over, before he shrugs. “Can’t be that bad,” he says, like it’s just that easy. His cheeks darken, and he boldly says, “Bet it looks good on you,” much to Billy’s surprise.

Unbidden, the memory of his mom pops up. The pretty kind , she’d said, and under Steve’s appraising gaze he feels the insane urge to flop his tail around bashfully. “Shut up,” he settles on, weak, because at this point it’s just too much.

But Steve must sense that he’s found an in somehow, because he just grins and continues, doubling down, “I’m serious,” he scoots closer, “I bet you make it work. Siren boy; luring in all the sailors with your blond curls and pretty tail.”

“Fuck off , you dickhead,” He shoves Steve with his free hand, still embarrassingly aware that he’s still holding Steve’s hand with his other. When he tries to pull away, though, Steve just tightens his grip. Blond curls and pretty tail rings in his head like a bell, clear and jarring.

It’s silent except for the sound of their breathing and the crickets chirping in the background. It’s so peaceful he almost forgets that he’s spilled the biggest secret of his life. Steve doesn’t look like he’s about to scream or run off, at least, so he lets himself relax, marginally.

“It really is pretty, you know,” Steve says after a moment, dark eyes still pinned to his face. The lights from the pool make them shine in the darkness across from him. He’s only distantly aware of the fact that Steve’s still gripping his hand, too overtaken by the look on his face. “Your tail. It’s like a koi fish.”

Billy’s cheeks heat as he ducks his head. Max had said the same thing on the walk back that night she found him on the beach. His moms tail was deep bronze and gold; glittering amber in the sunlight. 

“Thanks,” he says, hating how shy it’s made him. He never thought just a simple compliment to his tail would have him blushing like a schoolgirl, unable to even keep eye contact—but God , hearing Steve say that has him going red in a second.

“Well now that the cat’s out of the bag, wanna go swimming? For real, this time?” Steve nudges him with his shoulder, tugging him a little by the hand. “It’s okay now, right?”

Billy can’t help but smile; Steve’s good mood is too infectious. “Right. Everything’s okay now.” And that’s just an understatement.

He lets go of Steve’s hand to haul himself over the ledge of the pool, ignoring the way Steve nervously hovers behind him the whole time, wringing his hands like he’s halfway to lifting Billy in himself.

This time it’s just sheer relief when he gets in the water; closing his eyes and relaxing his body before he’s even fully submerged. It’s not perfect, sure, but the saltwater’s good enough to feel like a balm on his chapped skin.

He gives a few idle kicks of his tail, trying to reorient himself and get acquainted with the dimensions of the pool. It feels so good to flap his fin that he gives a trill without thinking, cutting himself off quickly before Steve thinks he’s in pain, or something. After that he does a couple of flips underwater, reveling in that old comforting feeling of the water rushing past his scales. It’s like no other, and he’s been without it for so long that he almost wants to cry. Underwater it’s easy to let himself have that, tears blending in with the saltwater before he even has to wipe them away.

It takes him too long to remember that Steve’s just standing out there, watching him, so he resurfaces before he can go full Flipper on him.

“Hey,” he says, eyeing Steve above the waterline, “You coming in?”

Steve bites his lip and says, “Sure,” but doesn’t move from where he’s standing.

Billy watches him, before wading forward a little. Before, when Steve was trying to convince him to get in the pool— he was all easy and assured confidence. Now it’s cracking at the corners, a little, not that he can blame him. Steve’s anxiety is palpable, even from here. It feels risky to say what he’s about to, but then— this night has already been pretty damn risky, and he’s still doing okay so far.

He takes a deep breath, swimming toward the edge where Steve is still standing and resting his forearms on the lip of the pool. “You know the scariest thing in here is me, right?” He taps his fingers on the edge, taking a chance and letting his claws grow out a little. “And I’m the apex predator, here. Don’t let me ruin this, okay? I won’t let anything happen to you.”

“I know,” Steve says back quickly, before taking a deep breath, “I know.”

He hates that Steve is so hesitant again, especially since it’s because of him. Because he just had to get in the water and Steve had to see him thrashing around like something was actually attacking him. It’s also probably a little jarring seeing your friend transform into a merman in front of your eyes, so. He waits it out a little bit. For extra measure, he holds his hand out, wiggling his fingers.

Waiting does the trick, because after another minute or so Steve tentatively steps in the pool, taking Billy’s outstretched hand and stepping gingerly down the steps until he’s able to jump the rest of the way in. Billy drags him forward, then, careful to keep him afloat and not overwhelm him at first. Steve just glides with him, letting Billy lead them until they’re in the middle of the deep end.

“Woah,” Steve breathes, looking down at where Billy’s still gripping onto them, keeping them buoyant, “This is… you’re really strong.”

And it’s true; in the water Billy feels like he could lift probably ten times what he usually does, treading with his tail and keeping them both above water with little to no effort. It still makes him blush, though, and he has to scoff to diffuse the tension.

They’re only a couple inches away from each other at this point, with Steve gripping onto his arm like it’s a lifeline. Somehow, Billy feels more vulnerable and exposed here more than he did outside of the pool, with everything on display. Like this, he can see the beads of water rolling down Steve's forehead and the moles on his cheek. His throat goes dry. He doesn’t know how long he stares at Steve’s cheeks, watching him get his bearings in the water, but it’s enough to make him jerk himself out of it after a bit, caught out and embarrassed with himself for noticing for too long.

If Steve notices, he doesn’t say anything. Just breathes and stares back, running his eyes from Billy’s face all the way down to where his tail twists below them. “Wanna race?” Billy blurts out, before he does anything stupid.

Steven snorts, and it feels a little less heavy. “The fuck? What kind of a race is that?”

Billy grins. “Thought you were captain of the swim team, hotshot?”

“That was last year, asshole,” Steve shoved him with one hand, laughing, the other still digging little crescents into Billy’s forearm, “And I think you kind of have an unfair advantage, so…”

“Alright,” he concedes, a new idea already bubbling at the top of his mind, “Lemme show you something, then.”

It’s dumb. It’s so stupid . But he used to do it with his mom all the time, and he’s done it once before with Max, so he just decides to say fuck it and go ahead. He drags one of Steve’s arms over his shoulder while turning around, ignoring Steve’s shocked squawk when he does the same with the other arm. Steve instinctively tightens his grip so he’s hanging onto Billy’s shoulders, plastered to his back. Maybe another time Billy would be absolutely freaking out about Steve’s body being attached to him, but for now he’s a man on a mission. He holds Steve’s arms down with his own, locking him down further, before turning over his shoulder.

Steve’s staring at him like he’s lost his marbles. He gives Steve a big grin and a wink, gearing himself up to gain some momentum. “Hold on, I’m about to take you for a ride .”

He turns around before Steve can see the red dusting his cheeks—it sounded way cooler in his head but now he’s like… way too aware of what he just said—and takes off before he can overthink anything else.

His tail’s not as strong as it used to be, since he hasn’t used it in forever, but it’s still strong enough to carry them almost fully across the pool with a couple measly kicks, propelling them forward quickly while Steve let’s out a startled yelp in his ear, followed by a whoop!

“Holy shit!” Steve exclaims, right by his ear. Billy can feel his heartbeat rabbiting fast again. “Do that again!”

Billy laughs, relieved, before acquiescing, shooting them forward to the other half of the pool while Steve excitedly laughs in his ear. It’s dizzying, feeling Steve’s arms tightening around his chest. He tries to stave off the manic grin that spreads across his face, but it’s practically impossible when Steve’s infectious laughter is ringing in his ear, when he’s far too aware of the hands gripping onto him for safety.

It’s just… he never thought he would get this. Any of this. Steve knows his secret. Steve knows his secret and doesn’t care that he’s different, doesn’t think he’s a monster. He wasn’t met with disgust or revulsion or anything that he thought would happen. Billy’s so overcome with just the sheer relief that he stops for a second, gliding to the edge of the pool and holding on to regain his breathing.

“You tired already?” Steve laughs, shifting around Billy's shoulders so he’s no longer plastered to his back. “I thought you’d be able to—hey, what’s wrong? Why are you crying?”

Fuck. He wipes his face immediately, trying to duck out of sight before Steve gets a real good look at his sad face. Max has told him it’s ugly like a million times. “M’fine, everything’s okay.”

But Steve doesn’t take that as an answer, gingerly tugging one of Billy’s hands off his face, showing what’s probably swollen eyes and red cheeks, while Billy sniffles through his stuffy nose like a little bitch. “Seriously, what’s up? Did I do something wrong? Did I hurt you?” His eyes go wide.

“No, Jesus,” he has to laugh a little hysterically, wiping away the rest of the tears and rolling his eyes. Trust that only Steve Harrington could somehow think he was in the wrong for this. “It’s stupid, alright? Just drop it.”

“Well, I’m not gonna until you tell me what’s wrong,” Steve inches closer. 

He lets out a shuddery breath, rubbing his hand down his face before turning to look at Steve. He’s staring back at Billy, big brown cow-eyes going wide and staring at him like maybe if he looks hard enough he’ll be able to see right through Billy. God, it’s too much, and too close. But Steve looks concerned, and there’s no way in hell he’s gonna let him think that this is somehow his fault . Not when he’s the only thing that’s ever made Billy feel okay .

“Nothing’s wrong,” he finally manages after a couple seconds, voice thick with the tears he’s trying to hold back. “You just—I didn’t think it’d go like this.”

“How’d you think it would go?” Steve scoots a little closer.

Billy shrugs, still wiping his face. “Dunno,” he looks down, “Thought you’d probably run away screaming, or something. Call me a freak.”

A line forms between Steve’s brows. “Billy…”

He cuts off the pity party before it can even begin, “Don’t—it’d be a normal reaction, okay? Especially after all the shit you’ve seen.”

“Well, like I said before,” Steve says fiercely, eyes flicking back and forth between Billy’s own, holding contact, “Fuck normal. This is much better.”

That’s it. It’s the final nail in the coffin. There’s no saving Billy after this, someone needs to resuscitate him immediately. Or, actually—leave him to die; it’d be less painful than this. There’s a thousand different things trying to burst out of his chest, and he has to bite his lip hard to keep it all in. Even so, his eyes start prickling and he can feel his throat going dry and heavy to swallow. 

Steve’s just watching him through it all, and Billy does the only thing he can think of that’ll get that excess energy out of him without exposing himself too—he grabs the back of Steve’s head and dunks him in the water. Doesn’t hold on too long, but it’s long enough for him to hide the cheek splitting grin and get his bearings together, wipe his eyes so they’re not as wet.

A second layer Steve comes sputtering up, lifting his arms and trying to get Billy in a headlock to do the same. They wrestle around like that for a couple seconds—the both of them laughing loudly into the cover of night— until they both finally subside, wading over to the steps of the pool.

“You can’t… really tell anyone,” Billy says awkwardly while they stare out at the pool. He’s met with silence, and after a little bit he looks over, Steve's fixing him with a dry expression.

“I mean, no shit, dude,” Steve laughs, rolling his eyes. “I’ll just add it to the never ending list of secrets I’m sworn to keep to the grave.”

Billy chews on his lip. “Sorry,” he gets out. He never meant to be another thing to just make Steve anxious.

But Steve just waves him away. “Nah. I like this secret. Way cooler than everything else.”

This time when Billy tries to dunk him, he ducks under his arm and swims away, splashing and laughing that honk-laugh that never seems to leave Billy’s head, apparently.

Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It’s different after that.

First of all, Max notices his change in demeanor almost immediately. The next morning she’s eyeing him over her bowl of cereal, not saying a word until they’re in the safety of his Camaro. Then, she lets it all loose.

“You went swimming, didn’t you?” She demands the second he shuts the door, vibrating in her seat and bursting at the seams to let it all out. “Oh, you totally did—you’re, like, glowing . So where’d you do it? You know they really didn’t find Will’s body in the quarry so honestly—“

“Max,” he glared at her over his sunglasses, “Take a breath, jesus.”

She rolls her eyes so hard it looks like it hurts, before taking an exaggerated breath in and out. “There. Happy?”

He starts the car. “Not particularly. Also, I’m not fucking glowing , thanks.”

“I mean, you kind of are.” When he shoots her a look she throws up her hands. “I don’t mean like, a pregnancy glow, or something. But you look better. And your skin isn’t nasty anymore.”

“Fuck you, it was never nasty .”

“Close to it,” she shoots back instinctively, before making herself subside a little. He can see how much she’s visibly trying to restrain herself and not ask a thousand questions in a minute. “But I’m right, right? You went swimming?”

There’s no hiding it from her, and apparently he never even stood a chance in the first place. Max always notices too much— something she’s just impossibly gotten better at since moving from California.

“Yeah,” he says finally, keeping it purposely vague, “I went swimming last night.”

When he doesn’t continue, she does it for him. “And you were also with Steve last night, so…”

“How do you know that? ” He tries to keep his voice steady, fights the urge to look at her immediately and instead keeps his eyes on the road.

Even though he can’t see it, he knows she’s rolling her eyes again. “Billy. You hang out with him, like, every weekend. You went swimming together, right? So does he know?”

Without thinking, he flicks on his turn signal and pulls off into the side of the road. Max is still staring at him, still thrumming with energy. It’s hard to face her when it feels like all the air is deflating out of his chest.

Because if Max knows, then Neil knows. Whether she tells him— on purpose or on accident, doesn’t really matter— or even if she doesn’t tell him, he’ll know. She’s worse than Billy when it comes to keeping secrets, of any kind, and it feels like the countdown to his destruction has already begun.

“Billy?” She asks uncertainly when he doesn’t say anything. He would if he could, just to cut the tension, but he feels so wound tight he can’t even unclench his jaw.

After another minute, she shifts back. He can tell she’s trying to reign herself in, fold in on herself a little bit. He feels her look away. His fingers relax marginally around the wheel. 

Another minute of silence. Max is picking at her nails now, and he’s got his breathing under control a little better. Right as he’s about to put his foot in his mouth— bark out an order to stay quiet that’ll probably set them back a couple of paces from the tentative peace they’ve been engaging in— when she speaks up.

“It’s not like before.” She says, quiet. She’s still picking at her nails. “I don’t just blab everything to mom or— or Neil. I don’t do that anymore.”

There’s a dangerous wobble in her voice that means tears are almost imminent. He sighs, trying to head it off. “Max—”

“I’m serious,” she interrupts before he can get started, facing him again. She’s trying to hold her own tears back, and her glassy eyes make him look away. “I learned my lesson, okay? I didn’t think… I didn’t think he was gonna do all that. I’m sorry , please.”

His own lip wobbles despite his best efforts to remain in control. He has to swipe a hand over his face and hold it there, breathing in and out slowly before he does anything stupid. 

See, one time he made the grievous mistake of trusting Max. The way he saw it, she already knew about the merman thing so surely the liking guys thing wouldn’t be that much crazier. She was already under lock and key for one secret, so what was another?

What he didn’t account for was how far Max was willing to go to get back at him— which, apparently meant telling his dad exactly where he was under the pier and who he was with.

She’s apologized a thousand times over by now, each more desperate than the last, but they haven’t talked about it since they moved, with Billy choosing instead to maintain radio silence whenever Max would be reminded of something and would get that guilty look on her face; the twist of her mouth and the glance his way telling him she still remembered every detail. It wasn’t even enough that she told his secret in the first place, but now he was supposed to feel sorry for her about it. So, yeah. He hasn’t exactly jumped at the opportunity to just give her some future ammunition to wield— whether she knew she had it or not.

But he also knows that she didn’t really mean to rat on him to Neil back in California. Not if she knew what was coming afterwards. And it’s difficult in that house. Even when there’s not a fight going on there’s that constant undercurrent of tension; the need to protect your neck and desperation to do so by any means possible. Max didn’t know the full consequences, and she’d just been acting on pure instinct when faced with a pissed off Neil. It doesn’t make it alright, but he gets it.

He tells her as much. “I understand, alright? I know you didn’t mean it.”

Her eyes are wide. “Really?”

Jesus . She’s really been thinking about this. The sigh he takes feels heavy, almost making him sag as he rubs at his eyes. “Yeah, Max. I get it.” 

And then, because he knows she’s desperate for it, he gives her an answer. “You were right. Steve helped. He was freaked at first… but he handled it well.”

She looks like she’s holding back a smile, practically vibrating in the seat. “I told you.”

“Yeah, yeah,” he rolls his eyes, not quite willing to concede all that much to her. Then, because he just has to make sure, “You know you can’t even breathe  a word of this, right?”

Now she rolls her eyes. “C’mon, Billy, I already told you—”

“Not just Neil,” he interrupts, “but your friends, too. Including your little boyfriend.”

That makes her clamp her mouth shut. She looks like she’s debating something for a second, chewing on her lip, before she tentatively suggest, “But, they know so much about the other stuff , maybe they could help with—”

“Max, I’m serious,” he warns, looking right into her eyes. He’s not about to be anyone’s science experiment, even if it’s her little friends. “Not them. It’s just too dangerous.”

“Alright, alright,” she concedes, faster than he thought. When he raises his eyebrows, in clear disbelief, she hunches her shoulders defensively. “I won’t, alright? No one else will know. Your secret’s safe.”

Then, after visibly mulling it over, she sticks out her pinky finger, a clear promise.

And he could bat it away. Ignore it and say something rude. But he can see that she’s trying, here, and it’s been a long time since he bothered to try for her, so. He hooks his pinky in hers, pumps it up and down, before withdrawing his hand and starting the car again. It’s silent for the rest of the drive to school, but when he looks out of the corner of his eye he can swear he sees her smiling to herself a little bit.

Max isn’t the only part where it’s different. Things change in the following weeks.

There’s no way they can’t — not when Steve has seen him. All of him. Still, he wasn’t expecting it to be like this.

‘This’ being Steve absolutely fascinated by him, asking endless questions like Max did when she first found out. He asks about anything and everything; once again reminding Billy of how little he actually knows. Luckily, Steve picks up quickly on the fact that bringing up Billy’s mom is a dead end— for multiple reasons.

It’s all just kind of weird. It’s one thing to have Steve as a friend— and all that entails— but Steve knowing about him and willingly hanging out with him even after that? It’s fucking mind-boggling, is what it is.

Steve insists that they swim all the time now. Billy goes from dry and cracking to practically glowing (like Max annoyingly described) from how much swimming he’s doing. And the best part is that Neil doesn’t seem to suspect the cause; it’s March in Indiana and he still thinks it’s too cold to swim. Getting one over on Neil is almost as good as being able to swim again.

It’s also pretty fucking intoxicating having Steve’s attention on him now, more often than not. Before, he’d been terrified of letting Steve that close. Now he was terrified for a different reason. Yeah, maybe the mermaid thing was kind of (actually really) crazy, but luckily Steve had dealt with a similar kind of crazy before. This? Being in love with your best friend who also happens to be a guy? He’s not sure Steve is ready for that kind of crazy yet.

It’s sad but true. What used to be a dangerous crush shoved in the back of his mind is something else entirely. Steve had called him beautiful the first time he saw his tail; Billy’s pretty sure that was when the last piece of the puzzle finally slid into place. And god , it’s even more painful squashing it down, but there’s no way he’s gonna risk letting Steve know— not when he’s one of the only people in this world who knows him and isn’t afraid or disgusted.

So he plays it cool for the rest of the year. Shuttles Max around whenever she pleases and keeps his grades up so his dad is appeased— and then on the weekends it’s a free for all making use of Steve’s pool.

He goes to Steve’s graduation, claps and whistles loud through his teeth, loud enough that Max shoves him in the shoulder, cheeks a deep red. He rolls with it, buoyant in his good mood and practically vibrating from the need to see Steve.

Steve has to talk to his parents, entertain the relatives that flew in for the weekend to see him graduate, but he somehow finds a free moment to grab Billy’s arm and drag him into the corner of the gymnasium, tucked away where no one can hear them.

“Meet me tonight,” Steve says urgently, looking over his shoulder where his parents are trying to crane their heads and see where he’s gone off, “Ten o’clock, at—”

“The quarry?”

“No,” Steve shakes his head, surprising him, “Uh, Lovers’ Lake.”

Billy blinks, a little surprised. They’ve never gone there together .

Steve’s cheeks color a little. He gives a jerky shrug, averting his eyes. “Everyone’s gonna be at the quarry, so…”

“Oh. Okay.” He shakes himself, inwardly chastising himself for acting like a dumbass and jumping to conclusions. Steve’s eyes snap back to him. “Yeah, I’ll meet you there.”

“You will?” Steve’s eyes flick across his face.

Billy snorts, covering up his own giddy trepidation with a halfhearted shove to Steve’s shoulder. “‘Course I will. Gotta provide beer for the graduate, after all.”

Steve grins back at him brilliantly. It’s so bright Billy forgets to take a breath for a second, heart stuttering in his chest. “Alright. See you there.”

He watches Steve even after he turns and walks away, content with staying in the crowd and letting it swallow him as he gets one last glance. Steve looks so good, loping across the gym in the dark green Hawkins’s robes. Cheeks still a little pink, hand running through his hair, big grin notching the one dimple he has. Billy is so caught up in it he doesn’t even register that Steve’s turned back, sending one more smile his way as he waves goodbye.

It takes a couple seconds for him to woodenly wave back, face heating up and feeling like a fool for acting like one of Steve’s groupies. Max looks at him like he’s a freak when he goes to grab her, loudly asking why his face is so red and rolling her eyes when he gives a grunt in response.

For the next couple hours he sits on pins and needles, anxiously watching his bedroom clock as he paces around the room, nervously wringing his hands like he’s waiting to walk the green mile. When 9:50 shines in bright red numbers, he snatches his keys from the dish on his nightstand and keys out of there as quickly as possible, only pausing to shut the door softly behind him. He waits a couple seconds to make sure he doesn’t see a light turn on, and when five minutes pass with total darkness from the house he lets out a relieved sigh and pulls out of there fast, spraying gravel in his exit.

Steve was right about everyone being at the quarry; even pulling up at Lovers’ Lake he can hear the distant echo of music across the water, sounding like whispers in the cool summer night. He stands there waiting, shivering, not letting himself relax until he hears Steve’s BMW pulling up, finally unclenching and letting himself smile, eyes crinkling when he sees Steve back in normal clothes instead of the smart button down and slacks he had on under his robe.

“Hey,” Steve breathes into the dim evening, not as dark as it could be because of summer. It’s light enough that he can see Steve’s eyes, bright with something. “You came.”

“Well, yeah,” he shrugs, feeling some strange heaviness settle over the both of them, making everything seem more intense. He knows it’s probably all in his head, but that still doesn’t stop him from letting out the smallest of shivers. “I told you I would, didn’t I?”

“Yeah, you did,” Steve looks down, digs his feet into the ground and kicks a little at the rocks.

Billy’s mouth is dry. He’s desperate for a lifeline. “Wanna crack into the six pack I bought?”

That eases whatever weird tension was lingering between them, and soon enough they’re reclined on the hood of Steve’s car— Billy figured his dad can afford any possible dents— completely done with the beer and sharing a stale blunt Steve was able to dig out of his glove box.

“Sorry about making you meet me out here,” Steve says into the dark, made partially visible by the burning end of the blunt, “Family’s in town or else I would’ve had you come over to mine.”

“It’s alright,” Billy shrugs. He feels kind of bad for always having them hang at Steve’s, figures one night away was due. “Gives you a break from cleaning out your pool.”

Steve waves a hand, seemingly unconcerned. They peter back into silence for a couple minutes, taking turns smoking and passing the blunt back and forth. The silence feels charged in a way that’s only happened a couple times before; like right when one of them is gearing up to say something but they don’t know how. Billy’s got nothing of any particular importance to say, so he waits it out.

It turns out his patience was warranted, because Steve starts shifting from foot to foot restlessly. Scratches the back of his neck before nervously running a hand through his hair. Billy watches him out of the corner of his eyes.

“So,” Steve finally breaks the silence, “got any summer plans?”

Billy furrows his brow, a little lost. They’ve already talked about their respective summer jobs, already made loose plans to spend time at Steve’s any second they’re both not working. Wary, he takes a deep hit, holding it all the way down to his lungs, before exhaling a smoke cloud into the crisp air of the summer night. “Other than lifeguarding? Not really.”

“Cool,” Steve exhales, turning to him. Billy can barely see him, but he can hear him shifting in the dark. “ So, like… my parents have this lakehouse.”

Billy’s heart starts pounding in his chest. “Oh yeah?”

“Yeah, they’ve got a place on Lake Michigan; right on the beach, kind of separated from the rest of the houses. It’s pretty private.”

He can’t speak for a second. It feels too dangerous to think about what Steve’s getting at; too dangerous to hope that he’s getting at something they can do together .

Like he can sense Billy’s hesitation, Steve barrels on. “And I figure, y’know, if I’m not doing anything… and you’re not doing anything… it’s only, like, six-ish hours away…”

Billy smirks, heart soaring in his chest “Bet I could make it in five.”

Steve laughs, low and easy. “Right. But… we could go up there. Hang out for a couple days. I know it’s nothing like the ocean, and it’s way colder than anywhere you’ve swam in California, but it’s better than my pool.”

“I like your pool,” Billy says before he can stop himself. His mind is going about fifty miles a minute, trying not to let the cloying feeling of giddiness clog up his chest.

“Well, yeah, sure,” Steve agrees, pushing on, “but I bet nothing beats miles of open water, right? Unless you don’t wanna go, then we don’t have to—”

“No, I wanna go,” Billy interrupts in a rush, unable to hear that anxious edge in Steve’s voice develop any further. There was no fucking way he was about to squander a chance like this just because he couldn’t get his shit together. “Let’s do it.”

“Yeah?” Steve sounds breathless. Billy can’t help but feel the same.

“Yeah. You and me, and cold-ass Lake Michigan.”

Steve’s honking laugh echoes around the edges of Lovers’ Lake, bouncing off the surrounding trees and into the darkness. Billy just basks in it, unable to contain the big feeling in his chest at the thought of Steve spending his graduation night hanging out with him , talking about a trip they’re going to take together . Unable to contain himself, he lets out a loud whoop! into the night, tickled when Steve joins him right after.

~

It’s not easy selling the trip to Neil, but with a little help from Steve and Max’s nerd-herd, he’s able to drum up a fake flier about a basketball camp for a week in Indianapolis, sponsored by the school and chaperoned by the coaches. Neil gripes about the supposed money he’s gonna have to fork over to fund the trip, but Billy heads him off by offering his own savings. There’s a terrifying moment where Neil regards him, like he’s trying to sniff out the deception, but the number the kids put on the flier connects to the voicemail of an actual basketball camp in Indianapolis, so he concedes with grunt and a barked order to “not get up to any funny business.”

It’s a terrifying gamble, but all worth it to pull up to Steve’s house with his duffel bag, Steve meeting him at the door with an excited grin that’s infectious. It feels like he’s thrumming under the skin, bursting to the brim with an untamed happiness he hasn’t felt in what feels like forever. Probably since the last time he swam with his mom.

True to his word, he books it all the way to Wisconsin; shaving off about forty-five minutes of the trip even though they had to stop twice for bathroom breaks. The drive there almost reminds him of the one from California to Indiana; brief hours of civilization followed by miles and stretches of empty country roads. That’s where the similarities end, though. Instead of suffocating, uncomfortable silence there’s laughter and jokes, Steve’s voice filling the car with a warmth so intense it’s like a direct opposite from the cold anger his dad regarded him with on the entire ride over. 

Every mile away from Indiana feels like another weight off his shoulders, loosening the permanent tension that rests there from living in a house with his dad. They’re only gonna be there for a week, sure, but he’s committed to making every fucking second count being out of the house.

Finally in the late afternoon they pull up to a substantial two-story, made out of wood and with a large balcony sticking out on the second floor. Inside it’s way more rustic than the high-modern interior design of Steve’s house back in Hawkins, and he can tell even Steve feels a breath of fresh air getting there.

When he notices Billy looking, he gives a sheepish shrug. “Kind of just relieved to be out of Hawkins,” he admits, and Billy feels the same.

After that he only takes enough time to drop his bags in the living room before he’s moving to the back door, eyes on the wide expanse of the view of the lake visible through the back windows. He unlocks the door and walks down the yard, legs carrying him all the way to the shore without stopping, even when he hears Steve faintly call after him. He’s got his mind on one thing: getting into that water.

The sand isn’t the same as the beaches in California, and the water’s a different shade of blue, but there’s still the tangy scent of salt in the air, hitting his face like a breeze. Lake Michigan is a freshwater lake, Steve had explained, but there’s salt deposits all along the coasts of the states where it sits, so it’s not completely salt free. It won’t be the same as California, like Steve said, but it’s still something .

He allows himself one second to take in a deep breath of air, bracing himself for the cold, before he steps towards the water, boots forgotten in the sand a couple paces behind him. He can hear Steve treading in the sand in the distance, but he’s mostly focused on the line of blue that meets the horizon. There’s some tides crashing— they’re small, but still better than anything he’s seen in a while.

The cuffs of his jeans get damp when he steps towards where the water meets the sand, and he doesn’t spare a second thought before shucking his pants down, smiling softly to himself at Steve’s choked gasp right behind him. His shirt goes next, and he flings it to the side without looking back. Finally, he takes a couple steps in.

Steve wasn’t lying when he said it was cold. The water is fucking frigid ; so bracing that a full body shiver runs down his spine, leaving him breathless and covered in goosebumps. He keeps going, though, despite the feeling of pins and needles surrounding his feet.

He breathes through his mouth as he keeps wading forward, only stopping when it’s up to his waist. That's when he stops for a second, taking in a deep breath before spreading his fingers in the water, getting oriented. When he looks over his shoulder Steve’s still at the shore, hands on his hips and goofy grin stretched across his face. He gives a big dumb wave when he sees Billy look, and Billy can’t help but breathlessly giggle back as he sends back his own wave.

Steve cups his hands around his mouth. “I’m dropping the stuff inside!” He calls out, shouting over the wind, “I’ll be out in a little bit.”

And maybe Billy should feel guilty about just basically dropping their shit and heading immediately to the water, but he’s so restlessly giddy he just nods back, giving a thumbs up before turning back around.

After that, he bites the bullet and submerges himself completely, not letting himself overthink it before the nerves get a hold of him. It’s just as insanely freezing as he knew it would be, and almost punches all the air out of his chest. When he opens his eyes it’s murky around him, dark water with sand swirling around the place, and when he breaks the surface with a gasp he almost feels like crying. It’s completely different from California, but still the same in all the ways that count.

The cold water makes him a little numb, so it’s easy to let the Change just happen then and there, crouched in the water with the waves licking at his ears. Since he’s been changing more and more at Steve’s it’s gotten easier, nothing as painful as that first time in the pool. Now it just feels like a light tingle, spreading from the top of his spine to the tips of his toes and fingers. He lets himself go limp, splaying out his arms as his legs fuse together. It takes less than a minute. He gags a little bit at the taste of freshwater in his gills, though.

He does a couple of circles, getting used to swimming in that temperature, but after a couple minutes he’s warm enough to swim further, dunking himself underwater and pushing against the waves.

When he pops his head above water about twenty minutes later Steve is back on the beach, in his swim trunks and dipping a toe in tentatively. Billy hides his smirk in the water before sinking low to the bottom, belly grazing the sand as he stays low and swims towards the shore as fast as he can while he’s still a little numb.

Steve sputters a bit when he pops up a couple minutes later, and gives a halfhearted splash in his direction as payback. He’s got his arms crossed tightly across his chest.

“Fuck, that’s cold,” he chatters a little bit, “how the fuck are you just swimming around in there?”

He shrugs, reclining so his bottom half is submerged while his chest leaves the water. Steve’s eyes briefly catch on it, staring for a couple seconds before looking away with a couple fast blinks. When Billy looks down, confused, all he sees are the water trails sluicing down his chest.

“It gets better when you swim in it for a bit,” he cajoles, wiggling his tail a little, “c’mon, water’s fine. I promise.”

Steve gives him a skeptical look, but still takes a couple steps forward anyway. He yelps when one of the waves crashes into his shin, hopping from foot to foot as he tries to acclimate. Maybe on a different day Billy would be able to suppress the fond smile tugging at his lips, but he’s helpless to it today; too overtaken by the relief of being in the water again and the wonder at Steve being the one to let him.

There’s so much warmth building in the center of his chest, like a fizzy soda after shaking the can, and the feeling is so overwhelming and dangerous that he has to look away— scared that he’s gonna do something insane like plant one on Steve here and now.

“Hey,” Steve says, drawing his attention back to him, “you gonna sit there and prune or do you wanna help me unpack?”

Billy snorts, giving one last splash with his tail and grinning at the ungainly yelp Steve lets out in response.

He decides to just Change then and there; shutting his eyes and shedding his second skin in a way that’s gotten easier since he started swimming again. Instinctively he covers his junk, shivering at the sudden onslaught of cold water there and giving a hiss as his skin breaks out in goosebumps.

When he cracks his eyes open Steve’s still standing there, cheeks link as he pointedly looks away. Normally Billy would push his buttons a little, but the words die on his lips when he realizes that he’s buck naked right now.

They walk back up to the lake house in silence, Billy pulling on  his jeans and shirt straight out of the water and trying not to cringe at the feel of denim on wet skin. He keeps shifting his eyes towards Steve— looking away when Steve catches him and vice versa. He doesn’t know why they’re being so shifty , not when they’re practically in paradise.

All thoughts of awkwardness are quickly forgotten when he gets a good look at the inside of the house.

His jaw drops, and he turns towards Steve, ready to rag on him— but Steve’s already looking at him, finger held up in warning.

“Don’t even start,” he threatens, “or else I’m gonna make you sleep in the sand.”

Billy shuts his mouth obediently. It doesn’t matter if he says anything, really, since he already says enough with the look he gives Steve, anyway. Steve goes red when Billy opens the fridge, tossing a surprised look over his shoulder at how packed it is.

“Yeah, I told the housekeeper we’d be coming down and could use some groceries,” he says sheepishly, avoiding Billy’s gaze, “I know it’s a lot. I just figured we’d be famished after the drive.”

It takes nearly all of his self control not to point out the whole housekeeper comment, and the reason why he stops himself is because… well, it’s just nice.

He can’t remember the real vacation he went on; one that either didn’t involve Neil or one that he actually enjoyed. And it’s all because of Steve. Steve, who wants him here so he can swim, who suggested it in the first place.

So he swallows down the teasing, letting himself get serious enough to say, “Thanks, Steve. For everything.”

Steve goes even more red, if it’s possible. He preoccupied himself with getting out ingredients for sandwiches, shoulders hunching up to his ears as he pulls the bread out of the pantry. “No problem. It’s just groceries.”

Billy shakes his head. “It’s not, though. It’s everything. I just… thanks, Steve.” He rubs a hand across the back of his neck, embarrassed at not being able to get the words right when they count the most.

Luckily, Steve makes it easy on the both of them and waves him off one final time, turning so his back is facing Billy and messing with the food on the counter like he’s not just trying to make himself look busy. “I wanted to do this, so. Yeah. No big deal.”

He decides to let it rest there, for both of their sakes. Instead he shoves Steve to the side, taking over on unpacking grocery duty while Steve moves their stuff to the bedrooms. He keeps them both on the ground floor, so there’s easy access to the beach, and they’re both in guest rooms that sit across the hall from each other. Billy almost has to pinch himself from how unreal it is that he’s with Steve right now on a vacation, just the two of them. It’s too overwhelming and all-encompassing to really grasp so he just pretends he isn't affected and focuses on scrounging up a meal for them.

Steve knows how to start the grill outside, luckily, and Billy fires them up some steaks from the fridge while Steve makes a salad. Neither of them really know what they’re doing (as if Neil would let Billy handle the steaks every Fourth of July), but even though the meat is a little more well done than usual and the salad has a little more dressing than necessary, it’s still the best meal he’s had in a while.

It’s already creeping into nighttime by the time they’ve finished eating, Steve dragging out a pack of marshmallows from the cabinet with wooden skewers. They park it outside, sitting by the fire laughing and talking while they roast marshmallows. It kind of feels like something out of a romance novel, but Bily doesn’t allow himself to keep looking at it like that. Even if Steve sits as close as possible to him on the stump in front of the fire.

When he glances over to the water, he almost stops breathing. It’s smooth, the tides going low and calm while the reflection of the moon shines in the water. He rises to his feet without a second thought, walking languidly over to the water. 

It really is almost like California; so dark the water looks black with the contrast of the white waves and foam, crashing in a pattern and rhythm he seems to recognize immediately. The water’s gonna be even colder than it was before, he knows, but he can’t help himself. He at least has the decency to call over his shoulder, “Going for a swim!” before he drops his clothes haphazardly, feet carrying him to the shore.

It is colder than last time, but it’s still so worth it. There’s something about night swimming that was always just so different; something about the moon hanging over him and making him feel at peace, no matter what. Like in that moment, that specific pocket of time the only thing he had to worry about was warming up his fin.

A splash and a yelp draw his attention to the shallows where Steve is stepping in, arms crossed against his chest and walking in with a determined gait. Billy glides over to him. “You alright?”

“Just fine,” Steve says through chattering teeth. “Just gimme as second.”

Billy wades around languidly while Steve gets acclimated, trying not to make too many ripples or waves so he doesn’t keep getting hit with the bracing water. Finally, Steve seems to warm up, dropping to his shoulders in the water and treading over to where Billy is.

“So?” he asks, voice still a little shaky from the cold, “What do you think?”

He gives a little laugh, incredulous. “What do I think ? I think it’s amazing.”

“Yeah?” Steve’s eyes look brighter, glittering from the moonlight. His grin is soft. “Okay, good. I wanted it to be good for you.”

“Why?” Billy asks before he can stop himself. It’s just… impossible for him to grasp why Steve went to all this effort. For him , apparently. He inches closer in the dark water. 

Steve’s shrug gets lost under the gently undulating waves. “It’s… kind of hard to explain, I guess.”

Billy shoves him in the shoulder, lightly. Steve glides with the movement. “C’mon, try.”

“Fuck. Okay, just,” Steve lets out a sigh, looking away and off into the distance. “I don’t know. It’s just like— the past two years have been such a shitshow with everything from the Upside Down. Like, learning monsters were actually fucking real was a mindfuck— but fighting them off, facing them down… that was just something different. Something else.”

He looks down, still not meeting Billy’s eyes before clearing his throat. “Everything just felt so unreal. Sometimes it felt like I was the only one going crazy over it, y’know? Like, I thought I was gonna have nightmares forever. Just knowing about all this shit was making me feel like I was gonna crack. But…” he trails off.

Billy lets him have a couple seconds before he gently nudges him, both of their skin warm under the water now. “But?”

This time when Steve looks up, it’s right at him, eyes combing over Billy’s face. “But then I saw you that night, all of you, and— I dunno. It was something crazy, but it was still you , and it just… made me feel better. Happier, I guess. That not everything has to be so fucked up.”

It’s quiet between them except for their breathing and the light splashes of them treading water.

Steve lets out a nervous sounding breath. “Fuck. That was weird, right? I didn't’, like, mean—”

“Gimme a sec,” he grits out, interrupting before Steve can start spiraling. He wants to talk. He really does. The words just seemed like they’re lodged in his throat right now, and he’s afraid if he takes too big of a breath he’s gonna start fucking crying , or some shit.

It’s just… he’s felt like a freak for most of his life. Always knew he was different, in a lot of ways. And this was just something he figured he’d always have to just keep buried , a secret that was meant to stay hidden and in the dark where no one else could see it.

And then here’s Steve, telling him the opposite. Telling him that… his freakishness wasn’t actually a bad thing, going above and beyond to give him a place to swim, taking him away from the stifling Hawkins… it’s just too much.

“Fuck,” he swears out loud without meaning to, hating how shaky his voice comes out, “Steve, I…”

Steve inches closer, disrupting the smooth water around them. His hand is firm and warm where it grips onto Billy’s forearm, using it to drag himself closer as Billy holds his breath.

“I mean it,” he says gently, sincerely into the night. Billy can feel each of his fingers where they’re wrapped around his arm. “You did make me feel better. You do.”

“You do too,” he croaks out, resisting the urge to duck and hide his face, at least so he can stay looking at Steve’s. It’s dizzying, being this close to each other under the moonlight, almost makes him lightheaded.

“Yeah,” Steve breathes, a quick hit breath fanning over Billy’s cheek. He shivers. Impossibly, Steve inches closer. “Can I just…”

“What?” He nearly passes out asking. This can’t be what he thinks it is, it’s the only running thought in his head.

Instead of answering, Steve leans forward. Billy holds his breath, eyes slipping shut while his heart threatens to burst out of his chest— not really believing what’s about to happen until it does. Only when he feels the feather light touch of Steve’s lips on his does he finally allow himself to believe that it’s real— and that’s enough to spur him into action.

Without thinking, one of his hands lifts out of the water to twist into Steve’s hair, while the other winds itself around Steve's waist, dragging them closer under the water. One of Steve’s hands mirrors his own, reaching forward to tug into Billy’s curls, but the other… the other hand smooths down the side of his rib cage, before it begins sliding down his scales.

Billy makes a tiny noise into their kiss, involuntarily, another full-body shiver running down his spine that has him gasping into their kiss. That seemed to do something for Steve, too, because he licked deep and covered Billy’s mouth with his own, tasting each other as he kissed languid and slow. Deep, wet kisses that were wide and enveloping, feeling like he was dragging Billy’s breath from his lungs with every graze of teeth to his lips.

The kisses petered off with soft sucks and kisses to each other’s lips, Steve leaving to kiss along his jawline and down to his neck, long enough to give Billy room to breathe and pant before he smacked one more parting kiss to Billy’s lips before backing up.

He felt dazed, like he’d just downed a couple drinks and immediately started spinning in circles. He’d almost believe he made the whole thing up, if it weren’t for Steve staring right back at him, still so close with his chest heaving in the moonlight. They were still so tangled up in each other; hands still winded in each other’s hair. Billy tightened his grip on Steve’s waist, and shuddered in response when he felt Steve smooth a hand down the side of his scales again, making his skin pebble up and having him sway closer unconsciously.

“So,” Steve broke the silence, sounding a little breathless and way nervous, “um, that was…”

“It was good,” Billy said, deciding for them. He felt Steve relax immediately under his grip, all tense limbs going loose under the water. He scooted closer again.

“Yeah?” he sounded like he was smiling, although Billy couldn’t see it in the darkness. He could tell, though. “Good. I was kind of worried my whole plan wasn’t gonna work.”

Billy gave an incredulous huff, eyebrows climbing up his forehead. “Plan? You planned this?”

He felt Steve shrug under his grasp. “Well, I mean. Kind of? I took you to my parent’s lake house so we could go on a trip together . Alone. Are you telling me that’s not totally obvious?”

“Fuck off,” he unhooked a hand from Steve’s hair to give a little splash, “excuse me for not expecting this elaborate plan , or whatever.”

“It’s okay,” Steve chuckled, drawing him closer, “we’ve got the rest of the week. Plenty more time for me to unfold my master plan in seduction. Just you wait.”

He snorted. “Yeah, yeah,” and then immediately gave an embarrassing squeak when Steve’s hand glided down his side, going even lower . Steve swallowed up the sound by leaning closer again, sealing their mouths in another kiss that made Billy feel hazy with contentment, slipping into the newfound familiarity. His hands flew up to grip Steve’s shoulders while Steve moved lower, cupping him at his waist and lower and brushing along the sensitive scales while Billy writhed in his grasp. Their mouths moved against each other, the both of them panting softly under the moonlight as their lips slid against each other, deep and low and unhurried. Completely at ease in the moment, and so natural it was easy for Billy to just let himself be .

~

Leaving a week later was pretty heartbreaking, but it wasn’t that bad when he had Steve’s hand twisted in his on the whole drive back, the both of them exchanging glances and infectious smiles as the future stretched out ahead of them. One way or another Billy was going to make his way back to the sea, or close to it— and this time he’d have someone else by his side.

Notes:

sorry for such a long delay!! this just got out of hand and i was so swamped with work and school it took me forever to edit this. i hope you guys like it!!