Actions

Work Header

the same deep water as you

Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It’s different after that.

First of all, Max notices his change in demeanor almost immediately. The next morning she’s eyeing him over her bowl of cereal, not saying a word until they’re in the safety of his Camaro. Then, she lets it all loose.

“You went swimming, didn’t you?” She demands the second he shuts the door, vibrating in her seat and bursting at the seams to let it all out. “Oh, you totally did—you’re, like, glowing . So where’d you do it? You know they really didn’t find Will’s body in the quarry so honestly—“

“Max,” he glared at her over his sunglasses, “Take a breath, jesus.”

She rolls her eyes so hard it looks like it hurts, before taking an exaggerated breath in and out. “There. Happy?”

He starts the car. “Not particularly. Also, I’m not fucking glowing , thanks.”

“I mean, you kind of are.” When he shoots her a look she throws up her hands. “I don’t mean like, a pregnancy glow, or something. But you look better. And your skin isn’t nasty anymore.”

“Fuck you, it was never nasty .”

“Close to it,” she shoots back instinctively, before making herself subside a little. He can see how much she’s visibly trying to restrain herself and not ask a thousand questions in a minute. “But I’m right, right? You went swimming?”

There’s no hiding it from her, and apparently he never even stood a chance in the first place. Max always notices too much— something she’s just impossibly gotten better at since moving from California.

“Yeah,” he says finally, keeping it purposely vague, “I went swimming last night.”

When he doesn’t continue, she does it for him. “And you were also with Steve last night, so…”

“How do you know that? ” He tries to keep his voice steady, fights the urge to look at her immediately and instead keeps his eyes on the road.

Even though he can’t see it, he knows she’s rolling her eyes again. “Billy. You hang out with him, like, every weekend. You went swimming together, right? So does he know?”

Without thinking, he flicks on his turn signal and pulls off into the side of the road. Max is still staring at him, still thrumming with energy. It’s hard to face her when it feels like all the air is deflating out of his chest.

Because if Max knows, then Neil knows. Whether she tells him— on purpose or on accident, doesn’t really matter— or even if she doesn’t tell him, he’ll know. She’s worse than Billy when it comes to keeping secrets, of any kind, and it feels like the countdown to his destruction has already begun.

“Billy?” She asks uncertainly when he doesn’t say anything. He would if he could, just to cut the tension, but he feels so wound tight he can’t even unclench his jaw.

After another minute, she shifts back. He can tell she’s trying to reign herself in, fold in on herself a little bit. He feels her look away. His fingers relax marginally around the wheel. 

Another minute of silence. Max is picking at her nails now, and he’s got his breathing under control a little better. Right as he’s about to put his foot in his mouth— bark out an order to stay quiet that’ll probably set them back a couple of paces from the tentative peace they’ve been engaging in— when she speaks up.

“It’s not like before.” She says, quiet. She’s still picking at her nails. “I don’t just blab everything to mom or— or Neil. I don’t do that anymore.”

There’s a dangerous wobble in her voice that means tears are almost imminent. He sighs, trying to head it off. “Max—”

“I’m serious,” she interrupts before he can get started, facing him again. She’s trying to hold her own tears back, and her glassy eyes make him look away. “I learned my lesson, okay? I didn’t think… I didn’t think he was gonna do all that. I’m sorry , please.”

His own lip wobbles despite his best efforts to remain in control. He has to swipe a hand over his face and hold it there, breathing in and out slowly before he does anything stupid. 

See, one time he made the grievous mistake of trusting Max. The way he saw it, she already knew about the merman thing so surely the liking guys thing wouldn’t be that much crazier. She was already under lock and key for one secret, so what was another?

What he didn’t account for was how far Max was willing to go to get back at him— which, apparently meant telling his dad exactly where he was under the pier and who he was with.

She’s apologized a thousand times over by now, each more desperate than the last, but they haven’t talked about it since they moved, with Billy choosing instead to maintain radio silence whenever Max would be reminded of something and would get that guilty look on her face; the twist of her mouth and the glance his way telling him she still remembered every detail. It wasn’t even enough that she told his secret in the first place, but now he was supposed to feel sorry for her about it. So, yeah. He hasn’t exactly jumped at the opportunity to just give her some future ammunition to wield— whether she knew she had it or not.

But he also knows that she didn’t really mean to rat on him to Neil back in California. Not if she knew what was coming afterwards. And it’s difficult in that house. Even when there’s not a fight going on there’s that constant undercurrent of tension; the need to protect your neck and desperation to do so by any means possible. Max didn’t know the full consequences, and she’d just been acting on pure instinct when faced with a pissed off Neil. It doesn’t make it alright, but he gets it.

He tells her as much. “I understand, alright? I know you didn’t mean it.”

Her eyes are wide. “Really?”

Jesus . She’s really been thinking about this. The sigh he takes feels heavy, almost making him sag as he rubs at his eyes. “Yeah, Max. I get it.” 

And then, because he knows she’s desperate for it, he gives her an answer. “You were right. Steve helped. He was freaked at first… but he handled it well.”

She looks like she’s holding back a smile, practically vibrating in the seat. “I told you.”

“Yeah, yeah,” he rolls his eyes, not quite willing to concede all that much to her. Then, because he just has to make sure, “You know you can’t even breathe  a word of this, right?”

Now she rolls her eyes. “C’mon, Billy, I already told you—”

“Not just Neil,” he interrupts, “but your friends, too. Including your little boyfriend.”

That makes her clamp her mouth shut. She looks like she’s debating something for a second, chewing on her lip, before she tentatively suggest, “But, they know so much about the other stuff , maybe they could help with—”

“Max, I’m serious,” he warns, looking right into her eyes. He’s not about to be anyone’s science experiment, even if it’s her little friends. “Not them. It’s just too dangerous.”

“Alright, alright,” she concedes, faster than he thought. When he raises his eyebrows, in clear disbelief, she hunches her shoulders defensively. “I won’t, alright? No one else will know. Your secret’s safe.”

Then, after visibly mulling it over, she sticks out her pinky finger, a clear promise.

And he could bat it away. Ignore it and say something rude. But he can see that she’s trying, here, and it’s been a long time since he bothered to try for her, so. He hooks his pinky in hers, pumps it up and down, before withdrawing his hand and starting the car again. It’s silent for the rest of the drive to school, but when he looks out of the corner of his eye he can swear he sees her smiling to herself a little bit.

Max isn’t the only part where it’s different. Things change in the following weeks.

There’s no way they can’t — not when Steve has seen him. All of him. Still, he wasn’t expecting it to be like this.

‘This’ being Steve absolutely fascinated by him, asking endless questions like Max did when she first found out. He asks about anything and everything; once again reminding Billy of how little he actually knows. Luckily, Steve picks up quickly on the fact that bringing up Billy’s mom is a dead end— for multiple reasons.

It’s all just kind of weird. It’s one thing to have Steve as a friend— and all that entails— but Steve knowing about him and willingly hanging out with him even after that? It’s fucking mind-boggling, is what it is.

Steve insists that they swim all the time now. Billy goes from dry and cracking to practically glowing (like Max annoyingly described) from how much swimming he’s doing. And the best part is that Neil doesn’t seem to suspect the cause; it’s March in Indiana and he still thinks it’s too cold to swim. Getting one over on Neil is almost as good as being able to swim again.

It’s also pretty fucking intoxicating having Steve’s attention on him now, more often than not. Before, he’d been terrified of letting Steve that close. Now he was terrified for a different reason. Yeah, maybe the mermaid thing was kind of (actually really) crazy, but luckily Steve had dealt with a similar kind of crazy before. This? Being in love with your best friend who also happens to be a guy? He’s not sure Steve is ready for that kind of crazy yet.

It’s sad but true. What used to be a dangerous crush shoved in the back of his mind is something else entirely. Steve had called him beautiful the first time he saw his tail; Billy’s pretty sure that was when the last piece of the puzzle finally slid into place. And god , it’s even more painful squashing it down, but there’s no way he’s gonna risk letting Steve know— not when he’s one of the only people in this world who knows him and isn’t afraid or disgusted.

So he plays it cool for the rest of the year. Shuttles Max around whenever she pleases and keeps his grades up so his dad is appeased— and then on the weekends it’s a free for all making use of Steve’s pool.

He goes to Steve’s graduation, claps and whistles loud through his teeth, loud enough that Max shoves him in the shoulder, cheeks a deep red. He rolls with it, buoyant in his good mood and practically vibrating from the need to see Steve.

Steve has to talk to his parents, entertain the relatives that flew in for the weekend to see him graduate, but he somehow finds a free moment to grab Billy’s arm and drag him into the corner of the gymnasium, tucked away where no one can hear them.

“Meet me tonight,” Steve says urgently, looking over his shoulder where his parents are trying to crane their heads and see where he’s gone off, “Ten o’clock, at—”

“The quarry?”

“No,” Steve shakes his head, surprising him, “Uh, Lovers’ Lake.”

Billy blinks, a little surprised. They’ve never gone there together .

Steve’s cheeks color a little. He gives a jerky shrug, averting his eyes. “Everyone’s gonna be at the quarry, so…”

“Oh. Okay.” He shakes himself, inwardly chastising himself for acting like a dumbass and jumping to conclusions. Steve’s eyes snap back to him. “Yeah, I’ll meet you there.”

“You will?” Steve’s eyes flick across his face.

Billy snorts, covering up his own giddy trepidation with a halfhearted shove to Steve’s shoulder. “‘Course I will. Gotta provide beer for the graduate, after all.”

Steve grins back at him brilliantly. It’s so bright Billy forgets to take a breath for a second, heart stuttering in his chest. “Alright. See you there.”

He watches Steve even after he turns and walks away, content with staying in the crowd and letting it swallow him as he gets one last glance. Steve looks so good, loping across the gym in the dark green Hawkins’s robes. Cheeks still a little pink, hand running through his hair, big grin notching the one dimple he has. Billy is so caught up in it he doesn’t even register that Steve’s turned back, sending one more smile his way as he waves goodbye.

It takes a couple seconds for him to woodenly wave back, face heating up and feeling like a fool for acting like one of Steve’s groupies. Max looks at him like he’s a freak when he goes to grab her, loudly asking why his face is so red and rolling her eyes when he gives a grunt in response.

For the next couple hours he sits on pins and needles, anxiously watching his bedroom clock as he paces around the room, nervously wringing his hands like he’s waiting to walk the green mile. When 9:50 shines in bright red numbers, he snatches his keys from the dish on his nightstand and keys out of there as quickly as possible, only pausing to shut the door softly behind him. He waits a couple seconds to make sure he doesn’t see a light turn on, and when five minutes pass with total darkness from the house he lets out a relieved sigh and pulls out of there fast, spraying gravel in his exit.

Steve was right about everyone being at the quarry; even pulling up at Lovers’ Lake he can hear the distant echo of music across the water, sounding like whispers in the cool summer night. He stands there waiting, shivering, not letting himself relax until he hears Steve’s BMW pulling up, finally unclenching and letting himself smile, eyes crinkling when he sees Steve back in normal clothes instead of the smart button down and slacks he had on under his robe.

“Hey,” Steve breathes into the dim evening, not as dark as it could be because of summer. It’s light enough that he can see Steve’s eyes, bright with something. “You came.”

“Well, yeah,” he shrugs, feeling some strange heaviness settle over the both of them, making everything seem more intense. He knows it’s probably all in his head, but that still doesn’t stop him from letting out the smallest of shivers. “I told you I would, didn’t I?”

“Yeah, you did,” Steve looks down, digs his feet into the ground and kicks a little at the rocks.

Billy’s mouth is dry. He’s desperate for a lifeline. “Wanna crack into the six pack I bought?”

That eases whatever weird tension was lingering between them, and soon enough they’re reclined on the hood of Steve’s car— Billy figured his dad can afford any possible dents— completely done with the beer and sharing a stale blunt Steve was able to dig out of his glove box.

“Sorry about making you meet me out here,” Steve says into the dark, made partially visible by the burning end of the blunt, “Family’s in town or else I would’ve had you come over to mine.”

“It’s alright,” Billy shrugs. He feels kind of bad for always having them hang at Steve’s, figures one night away was due. “Gives you a break from cleaning out your pool.”

Steve waves a hand, seemingly unconcerned. They peter back into silence for a couple minutes, taking turns smoking and passing the blunt back and forth. The silence feels charged in a way that’s only happened a couple times before; like right when one of them is gearing up to say something but they don’t know how. Billy’s got nothing of any particular importance to say, so he waits it out.

It turns out his patience was warranted, because Steve starts shifting from foot to foot restlessly. Scratches the back of his neck before nervously running a hand through his hair. Billy watches him out of the corner of his eyes.

“So,” Steve finally breaks the silence, “got any summer plans?”

Billy furrows his brow, a little lost. They’ve already talked about their respective summer jobs, already made loose plans to spend time at Steve’s any second they’re both not working. Wary, he takes a deep hit, holding it all the way down to his lungs, before exhaling a smoke cloud into the crisp air of the summer night. “Other than lifeguarding? Not really.”

“Cool,” Steve exhales, turning to him. Billy can barely see him, but he can hear him shifting in the dark. “ So, like… my parents have this lakehouse.”

Billy’s heart starts pounding in his chest. “Oh yeah?”

“Yeah, they’ve got a place on Lake Michigan; right on the beach, kind of separated from the rest of the houses. It’s pretty private.”

He can’t speak for a second. It feels too dangerous to think about what Steve’s getting at; too dangerous to hope that he’s getting at something they can do together .

Like he can sense Billy’s hesitation, Steve barrels on. “And I figure, y’know, if I’m not doing anything… and you’re not doing anything… it’s only, like, six-ish hours away…”

Billy smirks, heart soaring in his chest “Bet I could make it in five.”

Steve laughs, low and easy. “Right. But… we could go up there. Hang out for a couple days. I know it’s nothing like the ocean, and it’s way colder than anywhere you’ve swam in California, but it’s better than my pool.”

“I like your pool,” Billy says before he can stop himself. His mind is going about fifty miles a minute, trying not to let the cloying feeling of giddiness clog up his chest.

“Well, yeah, sure,” Steve agrees, pushing on, “but I bet nothing beats miles of open water, right? Unless you don’t wanna go, then we don’t have to—”

“No, I wanna go,” Billy interrupts in a rush, unable to hear that anxious edge in Steve’s voice develop any further. There was no fucking way he was about to squander a chance like this just because he couldn’t get his shit together. “Let’s do it.”

“Yeah?” Steve sounds breathless. Billy can’t help but feel the same.

“Yeah. You and me, and cold-ass Lake Michigan.”

Steve’s honking laugh echoes around the edges of Lovers’ Lake, bouncing off the surrounding trees and into the darkness. Billy just basks in it, unable to contain the big feeling in his chest at the thought of Steve spending his graduation night hanging out with him , talking about a trip they’re going to take together . Unable to contain himself, he lets out a loud whoop! into the night, tickled when Steve joins him right after.

~

It’s not easy selling the trip to Neil, but with a little help from Steve and Max’s nerd-herd, he’s able to drum up a fake flier about a basketball camp for a week in Indianapolis, sponsored by the school and chaperoned by the coaches. Neil gripes about the supposed money he’s gonna have to fork over to fund the trip, but Billy heads him off by offering his own savings. There’s a terrifying moment where Neil regards him, like he’s trying to sniff out the deception, but the number the kids put on the flier connects to the voicemail of an actual basketball camp in Indianapolis, so he concedes with grunt and a barked order to “not get up to any funny business.”

It’s a terrifying gamble, but all worth it to pull up to Steve’s house with his duffel bag, Steve meeting him at the door with an excited grin that’s infectious. It feels like he’s thrumming under the skin, bursting to the brim with an untamed happiness he hasn’t felt in what feels like forever. Probably since the last time he swam with his mom.

True to his word, he books it all the way to Wisconsin; shaving off about forty-five minutes of the trip even though they had to stop twice for bathroom breaks. The drive there almost reminds him of the one from California to Indiana; brief hours of civilization followed by miles and stretches of empty country roads. That’s where the similarities end, though. Instead of suffocating, uncomfortable silence there’s laughter and jokes, Steve’s voice filling the car with a warmth so intense it’s like a direct opposite from the cold anger his dad regarded him with on the entire ride over. 

Every mile away from Indiana feels like another weight off his shoulders, loosening the permanent tension that rests there from living in a house with his dad. They’re only gonna be there for a week, sure, but he’s committed to making every fucking second count being out of the house.

Finally in the late afternoon they pull up to a substantial two-story, made out of wood and with a large balcony sticking out on the second floor. Inside it’s way more rustic than the high-modern interior design of Steve’s house back in Hawkins, and he can tell even Steve feels a breath of fresh air getting there.

When he notices Billy looking, he gives a sheepish shrug. “Kind of just relieved to be out of Hawkins,” he admits, and Billy feels the same.

After that he only takes enough time to drop his bags in the living room before he’s moving to the back door, eyes on the wide expanse of the view of the lake visible through the back windows. He unlocks the door and walks down the yard, legs carrying him all the way to the shore without stopping, even when he hears Steve faintly call after him. He’s got his mind on one thing: getting into that water.

The sand isn’t the same as the beaches in California, and the water’s a different shade of blue, but there’s still the tangy scent of salt in the air, hitting his face like a breeze. Lake Michigan is a freshwater lake, Steve had explained, but there’s salt deposits all along the coasts of the states where it sits, so it’s not completely salt free. It won’t be the same as California, like Steve said, but it’s still something .

He allows himself one second to take in a deep breath of air, bracing himself for the cold, before he steps towards the water, boots forgotten in the sand a couple paces behind him. He can hear Steve treading in the sand in the distance, but he’s mostly focused on the line of blue that meets the horizon. There’s some tides crashing— they’re small, but still better than anything he’s seen in a while.

The cuffs of his jeans get damp when he steps towards where the water meets the sand, and he doesn’t spare a second thought before shucking his pants down, smiling softly to himself at Steve’s choked gasp right behind him. His shirt goes next, and he flings it to the side without looking back. Finally, he takes a couple steps in.

Steve wasn’t lying when he said it was cold. The water is fucking frigid ; so bracing that a full body shiver runs down his spine, leaving him breathless and covered in goosebumps. He keeps going, though, despite the feeling of pins and needles surrounding his feet.

He breathes through his mouth as he keeps wading forward, only stopping when it’s up to his waist. That's when he stops for a second, taking in a deep breath before spreading his fingers in the water, getting oriented. When he looks over his shoulder Steve’s still at the shore, hands on his hips and goofy grin stretched across his face. He gives a big dumb wave when he sees Billy look, and Billy can’t help but breathlessly giggle back as he sends back his own wave.

Steve cups his hands around his mouth. “I’m dropping the stuff inside!” He calls out, shouting over the wind, “I’ll be out in a little bit.”

And maybe Billy should feel guilty about just basically dropping their shit and heading immediately to the water, but he’s so restlessly giddy he just nods back, giving a thumbs up before turning back around.

After that, he bites the bullet and submerges himself completely, not letting himself overthink it before the nerves get a hold of him. It’s just as insanely freezing as he knew it would be, and almost punches all the air out of his chest. When he opens his eyes it’s murky around him, dark water with sand swirling around the place, and when he breaks the surface with a gasp he almost feels like crying. It’s completely different from California, but still the same in all the ways that count.

The cold water makes him a little numb, so it’s easy to let the Change just happen then and there, crouched in the water with the waves licking at his ears. Since he’s been changing more and more at Steve’s it’s gotten easier, nothing as painful as that first time in the pool. Now it just feels like a light tingle, spreading from the top of his spine to the tips of his toes and fingers. He lets himself go limp, splaying out his arms as his legs fuse together. It takes less than a minute. He gags a little bit at the taste of freshwater in his gills, though.

He does a couple of circles, getting used to swimming in that temperature, but after a couple minutes he’s warm enough to swim further, dunking himself underwater and pushing against the waves.

When he pops his head above water about twenty minutes later Steve is back on the beach, in his swim trunks and dipping a toe in tentatively. Billy hides his smirk in the water before sinking low to the bottom, belly grazing the sand as he stays low and swims towards the shore as fast as he can while he’s still a little numb.

Steve sputters a bit when he pops up a couple minutes later, and gives a halfhearted splash in his direction as payback. He’s got his arms crossed tightly across his chest.

“Fuck, that’s cold,” he chatters a little bit, “how the fuck are you just swimming around in there?”

He shrugs, reclining so his bottom half is submerged while his chest leaves the water. Steve’s eyes briefly catch on it, staring for a couple seconds before looking away with a couple fast blinks. When Billy looks down, confused, all he sees are the water trails sluicing down his chest.

“It gets better when you swim in it for a bit,” he cajoles, wiggling his tail a little, “c’mon, water’s fine. I promise.”

Steve gives him a skeptical look, but still takes a couple steps forward anyway. He yelps when one of the waves crashes into his shin, hopping from foot to foot as he tries to acclimate. Maybe on a different day Billy would be able to suppress the fond smile tugging at his lips, but he’s helpless to it today; too overtaken by the relief of being in the water again and the wonder at Steve being the one to let him.

There’s so much warmth building in the center of his chest, like a fizzy soda after shaking the can, and the feeling is so overwhelming and dangerous that he has to look away— scared that he’s gonna do something insane like plant one on Steve here and now.

“Hey,” Steve says, drawing his attention back to him, “you gonna sit there and prune or do you wanna help me unpack?”

Billy snorts, giving one last splash with his tail and grinning at the ungainly yelp Steve lets out in response.

He decides to just Change then and there; shutting his eyes and shedding his second skin in a way that’s gotten easier since he started swimming again. Instinctively he covers his junk, shivering at the sudden onslaught of cold water there and giving a hiss as his skin breaks out in goosebumps.

When he cracks his eyes open Steve’s still standing there, cheeks link as he pointedly looks away. Normally Billy would push his buttons a little, but the words die on his lips when he realizes that he’s buck naked right now.

They walk back up to the lake house in silence, Billy pulling on  his jeans and shirt straight out of the water and trying not to cringe at the feel of denim on wet skin. He keeps shifting his eyes towards Steve— looking away when Steve catches him and vice versa. He doesn’t know why they’re being so shifty , not when they’re practically in paradise.

All thoughts of awkwardness are quickly forgotten when he gets a good look at the inside of the house.

His jaw drops, and he turns towards Steve, ready to rag on him— but Steve’s already looking at him, finger held up in warning.

“Don’t even start,” he threatens, “or else I’m gonna make you sleep in the sand.”

Billy shuts his mouth obediently. It doesn’t matter if he says anything, really, since he already says enough with the look he gives Steve, anyway. Steve goes red when Billy opens the fridge, tossing a surprised look over his shoulder at how packed it is.

“Yeah, I told the housekeeper we’d be coming down and could use some groceries,” he says sheepishly, avoiding Billy’s gaze, “I know it’s a lot. I just figured we’d be famished after the drive.”

It takes nearly all of his self control not to point out the whole housekeeper comment, and the reason why he stops himself is because… well, it’s just nice.

He can’t remember the real vacation he went on; one that either didn’t involve Neil or one that he actually enjoyed. And it’s all because of Steve. Steve, who wants him here so he can swim, who suggested it in the first place.

So he swallows down the teasing, letting himself get serious enough to say, “Thanks, Steve. For everything.”

Steve goes even more red, if it’s possible. He preoccupied himself with getting out ingredients for sandwiches, shoulders hunching up to his ears as he pulls the bread out of the pantry. “No problem. It’s just groceries.”

Billy shakes his head. “It’s not, though. It’s everything. I just… thanks, Steve.” He rubs a hand across the back of his neck, embarrassed at not being able to get the words right when they count the most.

Luckily, Steve makes it easy on the both of them and waves him off one final time, turning so his back is facing Billy and messing with the food on the counter like he’s not just trying to make himself look busy. “I wanted to do this, so. Yeah. No big deal.”

He decides to let it rest there, for both of their sakes. Instead he shoves Steve to the side, taking over on unpacking grocery duty while Steve moves their stuff to the bedrooms. He keeps them both on the ground floor, so there’s easy access to the beach, and they’re both in guest rooms that sit across the hall from each other. Billy almost has to pinch himself from how unreal it is that he’s with Steve right now on a vacation, just the two of them. It’s too overwhelming and all-encompassing to really grasp so he just pretends he isn't affected and focuses on scrounging up a meal for them.

Steve knows how to start the grill outside, luckily, and Billy fires them up some steaks from the fridge while Steve makes a salad. Neither of them really know what they’re doing (as if Neil would let Billy handle the steaks every Fourth of July), but even though the meat is a little more well done than usual and the salad has a little more dressing than necessary, it’s still the best meal he’s had in a while.

It’s already creeping into nighttime by the time they’ve finished eating, Steve dragging out a pack of marshmallows from the cabinet with wooden skewers. They park it outside, sitting by the fire laughing and talking while they roast marshmallows. It kind of feels like something out of a romance novel, but Bily doesn’t allow himself to keep looking at it like that. Even if Steve sits as close as possible to him on the stump in front of the fire.

When he glances over to the water, he almost stops breathing. It’s smooth, the tides going low and calm while the reflection of the moon shines in the water. He rises to his feet without a second thought, walking languidly over to the water. 

It really is almost like California; so dark the water looks black with the contrast of the white waves and foam, crashing in a pattern and rhythm he seems to recognize immediately. The water’s gonna be even colder than it was before, he knows, but he can’t help himself. He at least has the decency to call over his shoulder, “Going for a swim!” before he drops his clothes haphazardly, feet carrying him to the shore.

It is colder than last time, but it’s still so worth it. There’s something about night swimming that was always just so different; something about the moon hanging over him and making him feel at peace, no matter what. Like in that moment, that specific pocket of time the only thing he had to worry about was warming up his fin.

A splash and a yelp draw his attention to the shallows where Steve is stepping in, arms crossed against his chest and walking in with a determined gait. Billy glides over to him. “You alright?”

“Just fine,” Steve says through chattering teeth. “Just gimme as second.”

Billy wades around languidly while Steve gets acclimated, trying not to make too many ripples or waves so he doesn’t keep getting hit with the bracing water. Finally, Steve seems to warm up, dropping to his shoulders in the water and treading over to where Billy is.

“So?” he asks, voice still a little shaky from the cold, “What do you think?”

He gives a little laugh, incredulous. “What do I think ? I think it’s amazing.”

“Yeah?” Steve’s eyes look brighter, glittering from the moonlight. His grin is soft. “Okay, good. I wanted it to be good for you.”

“Why?” Billy asks before he can stop himself. It’s just… impossible for him to grasp why Steve went to all this effort. For him , apparently. He inches closer in the dark water. 

Steve’s shrug gets lost under the gently undulating waves. “It’s… kind of hard to explain, I guess.”

Billy shoves him in the shoulder, lightly. Steve glides with the movement. “C’mon, try.”

“Fuck. Okay, just,” Steve lets out a sigh, looking away and off into the distance. “I don’t know. It’s just like— the past two years have been such a shitshow with everything from the Upside Down. Like, learning monsters were actually fucking real was a mindfuck— but fighting them off, facing them down… that was just something different. Something else.”

He looks down, still not meeting Billy’s eyes before clearing his throat. “Everything just felt so unreal. Sometimes it felt like I was the only one going crazy over it, y’know? Like, I thought I was gonna have nightmares forever. Just knowing about all this shit was making me feel like I was gonna crack. But…” he trails off.

Billy lets him have a couple seconds before he gently nudges him, both of their skin warm under the water now. “But?”

This time when Steve looks up, it’s right at him, eyes combing over Billy’s face. “But then I saw you that night, all of you, and— I dunno. It was something crazy, but it was still you , and it just… made me feel better. Happier, I guess. That not everything has to be so fucked up.”

It’s quiet between them except for their breathing and the light splashes of them treading water.

Steve lets out a nervous sounding breath. “Fuck. That was weird, right? I didn't’, like, mean—”

“Gimme a sec,” he grits out, interrupting before Steve can start spiraling. He wants to talk. He really does. The words just seemed like they’re lodged in his throat right now, and he’s afraid if he takes too big of a breath he’s gonna start fucking crying , or some shit.

It’s just… he’s felt like a freak for most of his life. Always knew he was different, in a lot of ways. And this was just something he figured he’d always have to just keep buried , a secret that was meant to stay hidden and in the dark where no one else could see it.

And then here’s Steve, telling him the opposite. Telling him that… his freakishness wasn’t actually a bad thing, going above and beyond to give him a place to swim, taking him away from the stifling Hawkins… it’s just too much.

“Fuck,” he swears out loud without meaning to, hating how shaky his voice comes out, “Steve, I…”

Steve inches closer, disrupting the smooth water around them. His hand is firm and warm where it grips onto Billy’s forearm, using it to drag himself closer as Billy holds his breath.

“I mean it,” he says gently, sincerely into the night. Billy can feel each of his fingers where they’re wrapped around his arm. “You did make me feel better. You do.”

“You do too,” he croaks out, resisting the urge to duck and hide his face, at least so he can stay looking at Steve’s. It’s dizzying, being this close to each other under the moonlight, almost makes him lightheaded.

“Yeah,” Steve breathes, a quick hit breath fanning over Billy’s cheek. He shivers. Impossibly, Steve inches closer. “Can I just…”

“What?” He nearly passes out asking. This can’t be what he thinks it is, it’s the only running thought in his head.

Instead of answering, Steve leans forward. Billy holds his breath, eyes slipping shut while his heart threatens to burst out of his chest— not really believing what’s about to happen until it does. Only when he feels the feather light touch of Steve’s lips on his does he finally allow himself to believe that it’s real— and that’s enough to spur him into action.

Without thinking, one of his hands lifts out of the water to twist into Steve’s hair, while the other winds itself around Steve's waist, dragging them closer under the water. One of Steve’s hands mirrors his own, reaching forward to tug into Billy’s curls, but the other… the other hand smooths down the side of his rib cage, before it begins sliding down his scales.

Billy makes a tiny noise into their kiss, involuntarily, another full-body shiver running down his spine that has him gasping into their kiss. That seemed to do something for Steve, too, because he licked deep and covered Billy’s mouth with his own, tasting each other as he kissed languid and slow. Deep, wet kisses that were wide and enveloping, feeling like he was dragging Billy’s breath from his lungs with every graze of teeth to his lips.

The kisses petered off with soft sucks and kisses to each other’s lips, Steve leaving to kiss along his jawline and down to his neck, long enough to give Billy room to breathe and pant before he smacked one more parting kiss to Billy’s lips before backing up.

He felt dazed, like he’d just downed a couple drinks and immediately started spinning in circles. He’d almost believe he made the whole thing up, if it weren’t for Steve staring right back at him, still so close with his chest heaving in the moonlight. They were still so tangled up in each other; hands still winded in each other’s hair. Billy tightened his grip on Steve’s waist, and shuddered in response when he felt Steve smooth a hand down the side of his scales again, making his skin pebble up and having him sway closer unconsciously.

“So,” Steve broke the silence, sounding a little breathless and way nervous, “um, that was…”

“It was good,” Billy said, deciding for them. He felt Steve relax immediately under his grip, all tense limbs going loose under the water. He scooted closer again.

“Yeah?” he sounded like he was smiling, although Billy couldn’t see it in the darkness. He could tell, though. “Good. I was kind of worried my whole plan wasn’t gonna work.”

Billy gave an incredulous huff, eyebrows climbing up his forehead. “Plan? You planned this?”

He felt Steve shrug under his grasp. “Well, I mean. Kind of? I took you to my parent’s lake house so we could go on a trip together . Alone. Are you telling me that’s not totally obvious?”

“Fuck off,” he unhooked a hand from Steve’s hair to give a little splash, “excuse me for not expecting this elaborate plan , or whatever.”

“It’s okay,” Steve chuckled, drawing him closer, “we’ve got the rest of the week. Plenty more time for me to unfold my master plan in seduction. Just you wait.”

He snorted. “Yeah, yeah,” and then immediately gave an embarrassing squeak when Steve’s hand glided down his side, going even lower . Steve swallowed up the sound by leaning closer again, sealing their mouths in another kiss that made Billy feel hazy with contentment, slipping into the newfound familiarity. His hands flew up to grip Steve’s shoulders while Steve moved lower, cupping him at his waist and lower and brushing along the sensitive scales while Billy writhed in his grasp. Their mouths moved against each other, the both of them panting softly under the moonlight as their lips slid against each other, deep and low and unhurried. Completely at ease in the moment, and so natural it was easy for Billy to just let himself be .

~

Leaving a week later was pretty heartbreaking, but it wasn’t that bad when he had Steve’s hand twisted in his on the whole drive back, the both of them exchanging glances and infectious smiles as the future stretched out ahead of them. One way or another Billy was going to make his way back to the sea, or close to it— and this time he’d have someone else by his side.

Notes:

sorry for such a long delay!! this just got out of hand and i was so swamped with work and school it took me forever to edit this. i hope you guys like it!!