Actions

Work Header

The Flatshare

Chapter 4: Four

Notes:

You guys are literally the BEST, your comments give me life like you don't even know <3

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Billy’s hands are shaking as he dials Max’s number. His chest is tight, his heart pounding, and it’s for that reason that he doesn’t clock what the time is until just after she answers in a groggy tone of voice that makes it quite clear he woke her up.

“Fuck,” he says. “Shit, Max, sorry—”

“Billy?” she interrupts. Her voice comes a little clearer. “You okay?”

Billy’s eyes are wet, he realizes, which is dumb as fuck. This isn’t happening to him. “Yeah,” he says. “Yeah, sorry, I know it’s early - can I come over?”

“It’s six in the morning,” Max says crisply. “On a Saturday, Billy, as in, the one day of the week where I actually get to sleep in later than this.”

“You have Sundays,” Billy says, because even in times of crisis, he has a smart mouth.

He can practically hear her irritation down the line. “Sunday mornings are for sex,” she says, which teaches him to get smart with her. She sighs. “What’s going on, Billy? Are you okay?”

“Yeah,” he says. “Just - can I come over later? When you’re awake? And… if I give you something, will you read it for me?”

“You’re such an asshole, you know that?” Max grumbles. “Come over. I’m not getting back to sleep now anyway. For fuck’s sake. Bring some breakfast and get your ass over here, okay?”

Billy grins, and hangs up the phone.

Forty minutes later, bearing pastries and coffee in one hand and the letter in the other, Billy knocks on the door of Lucas and Max’s tiny apartment. He has a key, but he figures it’s probably rude to let himself in at this time of the morning, when Max is already doing him a favor. Lucas opens the door, smiling sleepily at Billy as he steps back to let him in.

“Hey, man,” Billy says. He and Lucas haven’t always had the best relationship, but he’s kind and smart and treats Max well, which is all anyone can really ask for. “Sorry it’s so early.”

“Don’t sweat it,” Lucas says, although Max, sitting on the couch behind him, glowers. Lucas bends to kiss her, and then takes the food and coffee out of Billy’s hands. “I’ll dish this up, okay?”

“Thanks,” Max says. She pats the couch beside her. “Okay, Billy. What’s up?”

Billy fumbles with the letter in his other hand. On one side is his own name and address; on the other is the name Eddie Munson, with a prisoner number underneath it. He takes a breath. “Just read this,” he says.

Max narrows her eyes at him. “Is this about Neil?” she asks suspiciously.

“No,” Billy says. “Jesus. No. Can you just read it?”

Slowly, still watching him, she takes the letter and begins to read.

Dear Billy, the letter runs. Billy has read it a few times by now, enough that he knows the broad strokes, but still he reads it again over Max’s shoulder.

T’was a dark and stormy night…

Ha! No, it wasn’t, it was just gray and a bit wet, and I was drunk as fuck after a seriously brilliant D&D session with my club. Jeff made actual mead and it was dope as shit. I was walking home alone, and there was this bar, and I wasn’t really ready for the night to end… You know where this is going. I went in, bought a drink.

There was this chick there. She was hot, and you know what? So am I. I spent most of my teenage years known as Eddie the Freak, because of playing D&D (that stands for Dungeons and Dragons, by the way. Don’t know if you’re into the subculture enough to know that.) I’m old enough now to know that all that popularity shit is… well, just that. Bullshit. Steve likes me, even though he was King Steve at school (bet he hasn’t told you that, huh?) and so… well. If I think a girl is hot, I’m going for it, you know? It’s all about confidence.

Anyway, she was into it. I bought her a drink, we danced, she kissed me. I went to the restroom to puke (sorry, gross part of the story, I told you I was hammered) and when I came out of the stall, this guy shoved me up against the mirror and told me to leave her the fuck alone.

I saw him when I came in, actually. Him and his buddies, they looked tough. The kind of people you wouldn’t want to fuck with, if you know what I mean. They stood out because they weren’t drunk like everyone else. They weren’t dancing either.

So I know now that they were there doing business - gang business. They’re called the Bloods. I only found that out inside. Not the kind of shit your average grown-up nerdy D&D player knows about, you know?

I left after that, didn’t want any trouble. I stopped in at a convenience store for a packet of smokes on the way home, and then I walked back to my apartment. As far as I was concerned, the night ended there. But it didn’t, because otherwise I’d be sitting in your famous beanbag chair telling you this like a funny story, right? 

Obviously I wasn’t there, but this is what I think happened: they followed me out of the bar. They must have, because about a minute after I left that damn convenience store, someone with the same sort of height and build as me went back into it, this time with a hood up over their head, and robbed the store at gunpoint.

There’s CCTV of the guy, and I guess at a distance he looks a little like me. He was walking a hell of a lot steadier than I was by that point, though. And his hood is over his face the whole time, so you can’t see any details.

This is where I should tell you I have a record. Nothing bad - I got into a couple fights at school. Always lost, too, but that didn’t matter to the courtroom. There was this whole thing in my senior year - some jackass started spreading rumors about me being in a devil-worshiping cult. All because my D&D club was called the Hellfire Club, and one of the asshole jocks on the basketball team was a religious freak.

Steve protected me from a lot of it back then, but there was shit he didn’t know about. I got in trouble. And juries, as it turns out, don’t like cults. Even fake ones. It took them about ten minutes to bring in a guilty verdict.

Fuck, this is hard to write. I don’t think I’ve ever set it out like this. I’ve talked to Sal, our lawyer, but he’s a piece of shit. You can tell he doesn’t believe me. Doesn’t care, either. We’re sticking with him because he’s all we can afford - my uncle died a couple years ago, and Steve’s parents won’t give him anything. They’ve never liked me. 

I hate what I’m putting Steve through, but he won’t give up on me. Him and Dustin - has he told you about Dustin? - they’re the only people in the world who give a shit about what happens to me. Every time I think about it I get angrier. It’s not just my life that got ruined.

It’s taken me a long time to write this. Maybe you’ve already given up reading it, I don’t know. I know it’s not an easy story to believe, but I hope you do believe me. I don’t know why I care, except - Steve likes you. He’s changed, these last few years. I don’t think it’s just me, but all this hasn’t helped. He’s more insular. He doesn’t go out, doesn’t see people, and he works too hard. My fault, really, because he wouldn’t need to if he didn’t have to pay Sal.

Ah, fuck, I don’t know. Maybe I just want you to believe me because you seemed cool when we spoke on the phone, and I’m tired of no one except my brothers believing me. I hope you can believe me. I get it if you can’t.

Yours (in about eight years),

Eddie Munson

There’s a long, long silence after Max finishes reading the letter. She accepts the coffee Lucas has been trying to hand her for about five minutes without speaking. Then she bends her head and reads the letter again.

“Jesus,” she says at last.

“Max,” Billy says urgently, “you’re a lawyer. A criminal lawyer.”

She bites her lip. “A lot of criminals have really good stories to explain themselves,” she says, but she sounds very unsure. “You wouldn’t believe the bullshit I’ve heard.”

“You don’t think this is bullshit,” Billy says.

Max looks down at the letter again. “No,” she says. “No, I don’t, but…” She looks back at him. “This guy is your roommate’s brother?”

“They grew up together,” Billy says.

“When can you talk to him about this?” Max asks.

Billy tucks a strand of hair behind his ear. “Tuesday,” he says. “I’m taking Joyce - you know, my weird client - to Steve’s hospice, to teach cancer patients how to crochet.” He pauses. “Fuck. What is my life? Dad would laugh his ass off—”

“Who the fuck cares what that asshole thinks?” Max says sharply, and Billy subsides.

I do, he thinks, but he knows Max doesn’t understand it, doesn’t get why he cares. Why he can’t just leave his dad in the past. He says nothing.

“Here, Billy,” Lucas says quietly, passing him a plate with a couple of pastries in it. Billy takes it gratefully. Lucas doesn’t like Neil either - Neil had a few things to say about interracial relationships over the years, although he apologized when he realized how serious Max and Lucas were - but he’s a lot less vocal than Max about it.

For a few minutes the room is quiet. Max is clearly thinking hard, eyebrows furrowed. She keeps looking back down at the letter, finger moving as she scans for particular lines.

Then she straightens up. A decision has been made.

“Okay, Billy,” she says. Her fingers tap the letter, and she nods to herself. “I’ll make some calls.”

Billy reaches out for her, breath leaving his body in a relieved exhale. “Oh, God, Max, thank you.”

“Don’t thank me yet,” she says. “Just… I’ll write to him, okay? You can give it to Steve to send it to him. I’m sure you’ve got your own shit to say. And then I’ll make a few calls, get the court transcripts, that kind of thing. I’m not promising anything.”

“I know, I know,” Billy says. “Thank you.”

She looks at him curiously. “This Eddie guy made an impression, huh?”

“It’s not like that,” Billy says at once, unable to quite explain the shiver of distaste that runs through him at the idea. “He’s straight, anyway. Steve kissed him once, back when they were teenagers. Apparently he was cool about it.”

Max’s eyebrows shoot into her hairline. “Steve is into guys?”

Billy shrugs, although he can’t deny that he reread that particular sticky note a few more times than he needed to. “Yeah, I guess.”

“Huh,” Max says thoughtfully. “Well, then, I guess my original statement still stands.”

“Which is?”

She grins at him, shark-like, the grin she’s learned from him. “Don’t sleep with Steve,” she says. Then her expression turns serious, and she taps the letter. “At least, let me figure this out first.”

*

Stuck on top of an unusually bulky envelope on the kitchen counter, addressed to Eddie Munson but unsealed:

Thanks for the letter. Hope you had a good weekend meeting Murray #2 etc - was he our man? I hope so.

Sorry, I feel a bit awkward, probably obvious. Eddie told me what happened. I wrote back to him. You should read it first, before you send it to him. If you want to send it to him. You can decide, obviously. I was going to wait and give it to you on Tuesday, but, fuck, it seems a bit heavy for a first meeting, right? “Nice to meet you, here’s a letter for your brother in prison.” Anyway. Maybe you should read it before we meet?

Up to you, anyway. Hope you had a good weekend. I said that already. Hope it was really good.

*

Steve doesn’t read the letter.

He should, obviously. As Monday drags on, he keeps seeing it out of the corner of his eye. He takes it to work with him Monday evening, where it burns a hole in his pocket for his entire shift. He loses even more spectacularly at his game of checkers with El than usual, and still he can’t read it.

It shouldn’t matter, what Billy thinks. Steve doesn’t really know Billy, as much as it feels like he does. Sure, they’ve been exchanging notes for months now - but they’re not in middle school. They’ve never met. Billy is a goddamn stranger, and it doesn’t matter what he thinks.

But it does matter. Billy’s notes… they’ve given Steve something to come home to, something to look forward to in his cold empty apartment after his long shifts. He likes the way they talk in small snatches, hopping from topic to topic, never landing on anything for too long. The notes brighten up his days, as much as Billy’s crazy décor brightens up his apartment.

He doesn’t want to lose that. But he will, if Billy doesn’t believe Eddie.

Tuesday crawls by in much the same way. Steve is exhausted, because he hasn’t really slept over the last couple of days. He’s monosyllabic on the phone to Nancy, so she’s huffy with him too. Steve just doesn’t have the headspace for it. He keeps looking at the letter and then away again.

Unfortunately his time is running out, because Billy is actually going to be at the hospice this evening, assisting with the crochet class everyone is so excited about. Steve only told El that his roommate would be there, so of course all his patients know, and they keep expressing their surprise that he even has a roommate. Steve’s not sure what to make of that.

“It’s because you’re so fucking antisocial these days,” Robin informs him cheerfully. “No one expects you to have friends.”

“Thanks,” Steve says tiredly.

Robin frowns at him. He’s usually a lot better at returning her quick wit. “Hey, you okay?” she asks. She tilts her head to one side. “You’re nervous about meeting him, huh?”

“It’s not that,” Steve says, although his stomach lurches. Of course he’s nervous to meet Billy; if it weren’t for the letter, still unread in the pocket of his scrubs, it would be fully occupying his brain. He feels like he’s built up a picture of Billy in his mind, and he doesn’t want to let go of it.

“So what’s up?” Robin asks, and so he tells her. He explains about Eddie talking to Billy on the phone, about him writing, about Billy writing back.

“I can’t handle it, if he doesn’t believe him,” he finishes shakily. “I can’t - I can’t handle another person not believing him, the way—”

Robin’s expression is just a little too knowing. “The way Nancy doesn’t believe him,” she finishes for him.

Steve closes his eyes. The Argument looms in his memory. “He’s coming here,” he says. “Billy, I mean. We’re supposed to meet for the first time, and all I can fucking think about is - what if he doesn’t believe Eddie?”

“Easy solution to that,” Robin says pragmatically. She squeezes Steve’s shoulder. “Read the letter, and then you’ll know. But for what it’s worth, Billy sounds pretty cool. The way you describe him, anyway.”

“You never know what people will think,” Steve says with conviction. “People… people surprise you. And not always in good ways.” He rubs his eyes wearily. “I’ve never even met Billy.”

Robin rubs his arm, and then checks her watch. “Shit, Steve, I have to go,” she says, getting up. “Got my rounds. Read the letter, okay? Whatever it says, you can deal with it. The longer you put it off… It won’t help anything. You won’t know until you see what he’s said.”

He knows she’s right, and yet he doesn’t move to take the letter out of his pocket after she leaves the room. He just sits there, watching the clock on the opposite wall of the break room tick past the seconds. Now Billy will have arrived in the parking lot… now he’ll be checking in at the front desk… now he and Joyce will be getting set up in the rec room.

Billy is in the same building as him. In spite of living together for almost five months, that’s never happened before.

Steve gets up, pacing the room. Suddenly the walls feel too small, too close, and he pushes his way out of the door, leaning against the wall in the corridor outside. He closes his eyes. He needs to read the goddamn letter.

A voice calls out, a little hesitantly: “Steve?”

Steve half-turns towards the sound of his name. There’s an impression of a man standing down at the other end of the long hall, about Steve’s height, with long curly hair and a hand raised in greeting - Steve turns away, face flushing, and fairly runs around the corner.

Was that Billy? It must have been - but Steve can’t face him. Not like this. Not when he hasn’t read the letter.

He’s running, turning down corridors until he’s sure Billy won’t be able to follow him. Fuck, was it obvious that he was running away? Maybe Billy will think he got called to some sort of cancer-related emergency. He doesn’t want Billy to realize he literally ran at the sight of him.

Hands shaking, Steve pulls the letter out of his pocket. He’s near one of the smaller lounges, which nobody will be using because they’re all doing the crochet thing, so he steps hesitantly inside. He’s not going to be a coward about this. He’s just going to read the damn thing.

He opens up the envelope, and slides the letter out.

Dear Eddie,

Holy shit, dude. Thanks for writing to me. Also, holy shit! What a crappy fucking thing to go through. I’m so sorry.

I know there’s probably a lot you didn’t tell me. You can, if you want, obviously - you didn’t say much about the trial or getting to prison or any of that shit, and maybe you need to talk about it? I don’t know, I’m a stranger, I get that. But you don’t have to. The point is, I believe you. Of course I believe you.

This feels totally inadequate - sorry it’s shit, I believe you? You must get that all the fucking time, and it doesn’t help you. I read your letter and I really, really wanted to help, and maybe that’s more about me than it is about you, trying to handle feeling so fucking useless about what you’re going through, but anyway - I spoke to my sister.

Has Steve mentioned my sister to you? I don’t know why he would have done, except that when you know her you feel like you have to mention her all the time. Except Steve doesn’t know her, obviously. He barely even knows me. Anyway, the point is, she’s a lawyer. A good one. 

She looked at your letter as a favor to me. I hope that’s okay, that I showed it to her. You explained it way better than I could. She’s written to you. She has some questions. She’s not taking on your case, or at least, not yet, but she’s interested. Maybe I’m overstepping? The way you talked about your lawyer, it didn’t sound so great, but this is probably me projecting because I want to help. Feel free to tell me to fuck off.

But if you want to, you could write back to Max. She’s awesome, and if she’s on your side usually good things happen.

Either way, I’m sorry you’re dealing with this.

Billy Hargrove

Steve’s breath is coming in harsh pants. He pulls out the second letter.

Dear Mr Munson,

My name is Maxine Mayfield, and I’m Billy’s sister, which I’m sure he’s told you in his own letter. To be clear, at this stage I’m not making a formal offer of representation. However, I do have some inquiries which, if you did want to respond to them, I’d be happy to advise on informally.

  • It appears from the trial transcripts that the friends you played Dungeons and Dragons with earlier in the evening were not called as witnesses. Please confirm.
  • The Bloods are likewise not mentioned in the trial transcript. Your letter indicates you only became aware of the name of the gang while in prison. What information has led you to believe that…

Steve stops reading. His heart is hammering so hard that he thinks it might actually burst out of his chest.

The rest of Max’s letter is much the same - a detailed list of questions, the sort of questions Steve has been trying to no avail to make Sal care about for months. Questions about the CCTV footage, about the testimony of the convenience store clerk, about his juvenile record. Questions that indicate that this woman, this professional lawyer, actually believes that Eddie is innocent.

Fuck. Fuck. Tears are tracking down Steve’s face. It’s been so, so long since he talked to anyone apart from Dustin who really believes that. Even Robin - she doesn’t know Eddie.

Dustin. Steve fumbles for his cellphone. He has to tell him this news. It’s the first hope they’ve had in - God, too long. Too fucking long.

“Steve?” Dustin is alert at once, and Steve feels a stab of guilt. Since Eddie’s conviction, they never talk about non-Eddie things. “Steve, you okay?”

“Yeah,” Steve says, and then he’s crying. Actually crying. He hasn’t cried since the jury returned their verdict. “Jesus, Jesus, Dustin—”

It takes a while for Dustin to calm him down long enough for Steve to actually explain. He presses the phone to his ear like a lifeline, words jumbling over each other as he reads the letters out loud. “Eddie doesn’t know yet,” he says. “I’ll take them to him in person. I’m seeing him later this week. Dustin, this could - it could make a difference.”

“I need to meet this guy,” Dustin says. “And his sister! Is she taken? Can I steal her from her boyfriend? Me and Amanda just broke up - I could date a lawyer. I’d sleep with a hundred lawyers to get Eddie out—”

“I don’t think you need to,” Steve says wonderingly. “I think she might just… help us.” He swallows. “Because Billy asked her to.”

Dustin laughs, half delight and half hysteria. “Thank fuck for Billy, then,” he says, and Steve can’t help but agree.

They talk for a long time, not quite allowing themselves to admit what it could mean - but Steve knows they’re both feeling a swell of hope they haven’t allowed themselves to indulge in since the conviction. They’re the only two people in the world who care about Eddie’s fate - or they were.

Not any more, apparently.

“Fuck,” Steve says at last. “I should - I should find him. I kinda ran away from him,” he explains and Dustin laughs at him at length.

When he heads to the rec room, however, there’s no sign of the curly-haired man from earlier.

“He left,” Robin says. “It’s nearly nine. He was asking everyone about you, though.” She gestures towards El, currently being wheeled out to the corridor so she can go to bed. “He might have displaced you in El’s affections. She’s obsessed with him.”

Steve runs an unsteady hand through his hair. “What… what’s he like?”

Robin grins suddenly. “Oh, you’re going to like him, if you ever actually do meet him,” she says. 

He stares at her. “What does that mean?”

“He’s like me,” she says, “except a guy, and not quite as funny.”

“Oh,” Steve says stupidly. His heart is beating weirdly fast.

She looks at him curiously. “What did the letter say?”

Steve covers his face with his hands. “He believes him,” he says in a muffled voice. “He believes Eddie.”

“That’s a good thing, right?” Robin says cautiously, moving closer.

Steve tips his head back, fighting back more tears. Jesus, he’s not usually a crier - but it doesn’t matter. Today, he’s feeling more hope than he’s felt in so, so long.

“Yeah,” he says, a smile spreading across his face. “Yeah, it’s a good thing.”

Notes:

I knowwwww you were all excited about them meeting at the hospice, I'm sorry! I felt extra bad reading those comments last week when I knew what was coming XD