Actions

Work Header

I Do, I Do, I Do (I Do, I Do)

Summary:

three couples
three engagements
three weddings
three months apart
ready? steddie? GO!

Chapter 1: One

Chapter Text

Eddie proposes to Chrissy five times. The first is in 2008, when they’re fresh out of school, high as balls, and delirious with freedom.

“Hey,” Eddie says.

Chrissy blows out a huge cloud of smoke. 

Damn, he’s impressed. The blushing, awkward girl who’d stumbled over her words six months ago, wringing her hands and stammering -- that girl was gone. The whole virginal-pure-prom queen thing had always intrigued him. (OK, that’s a fucking lie. He’d been in love with her since middle school, but...like...fuck off and mind you own damn business.) Turns out his perception was right. She was saving herself for marriage or whatever. Marriage to Jason Carver, future frat boy and politician. Then she’d have enough unsatisfying sex to produce five or six towhead brats. 

Her future, in his opinion, had looked bleak.

Then she’d given him the surprise of his life by asking for weed. 

“Bold move, Cunningham,” he’d drawled. “Careful now, princess. Old George W. will be comin’ after you.”

She didn’t get the joke

“Like...Bush. Like...ya know. The president.” He was a super-super senior, twenty years old and dumb as a brick, but...damn. She was slow on the uptake. 

Then she giggled like he’d just said the funniest thing in the entire world. He wanted to hear that giggle for the rest of his life, holy shit.

That was the beginning of a strange friendship. She’d come over every Friday, avoiding the parties she was usually expected at by claiming she had youth group. They’d smoke. She’d vent about her mom, her boyfriend, the pressure she was under.

“Mom wants me to act like a fuckin’ 1950s housewife,” she’d complained. “Jason wants that too.” She’d rolled her eyes. “Nobody’s ever asked what I want.”

So Eddie did the only natural thing: He kissed her and murmured, “What do you want?” against her lips. 

Turned out what she wanted was a lick of freedom. Freedom that a metalhead burnout offered her.

She’d dumped Jason the next day.

So he proposes to her six months after graduation.

After her impressive cloud of smoke, he blurts: “Marry me?!”

Chrissy takes another huge bong hit, holds it in, and blows the smoke in his face. Then she giggles and says, “You’re such an idiot, Munson.”

He laughs and pretends that a nuclear bomb of hurt didn’t just go off in his chest. (You a poet, Freak? he thinks. Some of that high school self-hate isn’t so easy to forget.) “Yeah, I know,” he says, and bops her nose. “Take a joke, Cunningham.”

She just slaps his hand away and laughs.

 

🔔💒👰  

 

Eddie proposes to her again in 2010. She’s twenty years old and they’re basically a boring old married couple already. His buddy Steve and his scary boyfriend are basically always clubbing or drinking or running from cops. (What’s the guy’s name? Bruce? Bill? Ben? He can never fucking remember for some reason. He started calling him Mullet Man in his head.)

His friend Robin and her girlfriend Vickie have basically done that lesbian thing where they’re obsessed with each other by, like, date two.

Everyone’s a couple, but it seems like they’re not in a rush to get married.

Eddie doesn’t know why he’s so obsessed with marrying Chrissy. He’s only twenty-two. It’s not like he’s a million years old and letting his life pass him by. Chrissy goes to college in Indy and he works as a mechanic near her school. They live in a cute little apartment. Even have a cat. 

They’re basically married without the piece of paper. So why is he so hung up on it?

(Of course the answer goes back to dear old Dad, like so much of his fucked upness does. Mom and Dad were horrible, volatile people. Never married, just popped out a kid and fucked off. He’s...he’s gotta make an honest woman of Chrissy. Gotta show himself he can be a good husband. Gotta show her marriages don’t have to be loveless like Laura and Philip’s.)

See? He’s always lost in his thoughts! 

They’re planning out a summer road trip. Chrissy’s tracing Route 66 with her finger, murmuring softly to herself. Eddie likes that about her -- she likes paper maps. Very old fashioned. 

“There’s a lot to see,” she says thoughtfully. “It’s not actually part of Route 66, but I’ve always wanted to see Vegas.”

“We could get married there!” Eddie says way too loudly. “If you wanted to marry me!” Literally why is his voice so fucking loud??

She rolls her eyes and laughs. “Sure, Munson. We’ll get married by some sweaty Elvis impersonator. How romantic.” 

He drops it.

They have a good time on their road trip.  

 

🔔💒👰  

 

The third time he proposes is only a week after they get back from their trip. They’re literally sitting on the couch doing nothing. Eddie’s getting a little desperate. Does she not wanna marry him? Or is she just as oblivious as she was in high school?

He can’t tell.

To test it out, he says, “So, you gonna marry me yet?”

“You’re just a bucket of laughs, Eddie. You know that?” She rolls her eyes at him for the millionth time that day. “Let’s elope,” Chrissy says sarcastically. 

“Yes,” he says. “In a heartbeat.”

Chrissy gives him an unreadable look. He lets it go for now.

 

🔔💒👰  

 

Eddie’s getting a little desperate. Chrissy is twenty-two and he’s twenty-four now. Weddings take forever to plan. Harrington and Mullet Man are engaged now. Robin and Vickie too. They had this crackpot idea of each of them getting married on a different month. 

He’s got a year. A year to convince Chrissy Cunningham to become his wife. Eddie still can’t tell if she doesn’t wanna marry him. She always laughs it off when he mentions married life. Is she uncomfortable? He can’t get a fucking read on her.

So Eddie decides to push it...because he always has to fucking push it. 

They’re drunk as hell, stumbling back into their apartment. He and Chrissy went out clubbing with Steve and Mullet Man (whose name is actually Billy). They both got way too drunk and are...ya know...in the mood. Chrissy goes nuts -- he loves it. She slams him into the door before he even gets his keys out.

They make out like teenagers before their crotchety old neighbor pokes his head out of the apartment and cusses them out.

Eddie just flips the guy off and takes his girl inside.

He’s got business to attend to.

Once that business is over, he flips over to face her. Chrissy’s a vision. She always is.

“You gonna marry me yet?” he murmurs into the quiet of the night. 

“Ask me when you’re sober, Munson,” she says with a big yawn. Then she’s asleep.

Right before Eddie falls asleep, he decides he’s gotta do this right. He’s gonna go buy a wedding ring tomorrow.

 

🔔💒👰  

 

Eddie’s gonna do it. He’s gonna marry his fucking girlfriend. He’ll be twenty-five to her twenty-three. Maybe a little young to get married, but his monster-in-laws got married at eighteen. Besides, they’ve been together for five years. 

A marriage might just be a piece of paper and a judge’s stamp of approval, but it means so much fucking more.

Maybe if he does it right, Chrissy will be that he’s serious, that he means it. He’s gotta get this right.

So Eddie makes an excuse to slip out for most of the day. “I’m gonna get lunch with Vickie and Robin and then drop off some shit at Goodwill,” he tells Chrissy.

She looks at him weirdly and nods. “Yeah. I’ve got somewhere to be too. I’m gonna...uh...go shopping with Nancy.”

Shopping with Nancy? 

Weird. Despite her girly-girl fashionista thing, Chrissy actually detests shopping. The crowds stress her out and hanging out while people try on a million different outfits bores her. They only get clothes once or twice a year. Chrissy’s got psych herself up for it for days.

Is she cheating on me? 

OK, that’s a deeply stupid thought. Eddie squashes it down the second he thinks it. Just because she’s branching out in her interests doesn’t mean she’s stepping out on him. He’s being insane.

So he drives off -- Chrissy says Nancy is gonna pick her up -- and goes to the nearest Kay Jewelers. (Look, they’re not rich. It’s a mall wedding ring or no wedding ring.)

He spends like an hour looking at rings, asking detailed questions to the man working the store. He describes Chrissy’s taste and turns down almost everything. Too gaudy. Too small. Too expensive. Too many gems, not enough gems. Not fancy enough. Too fancy. Not the right color.

He can tell the clerk is getting frazzled.

Finally, Eddie sees it. It’s a simple ring, but it’s beautiful. Silver, small. But the band is made of what looks like branches. It’s perfect.

Eddie buys the ring with cash, thanks the man, and then heads for home. He’s gonna see about proposing to her at the rose garden. When they don't have a lot of cash to spare, they picnic at this beautiful rose garden. It’s “their spot,” ya know?

He comes home and sees Chrissy.

She turns red when she sees him and shoves something down her shirt.

“You...good?” he asks. 

“Yep!” Chrissy says way too quickly. “Doing great! Thanks for asking, honey. I appreciate it!”

OK...what? What is happening? Why’s she being so weird? She never talks like this.

“Oh...kay.” He shrugs. “If you say so. It’s not so bad outside. I was wondering if you wanted to go--”

“--to the rose garden!” Chrissy finishes. She looks a little manic. “Great idea!"

This is getting more and more strange. She’s being...really fucking weird. Are...are they about to break up right now? Is she tired of him? Is that why she’s so off?

He steels himself. If this is happening, he’d better let her speak first. It seems like she wants to say something.

But of course he fucking can’t. Never could keep his mouth shut. Never could stop pushing.  

So they walk to the rose garden and he lays out their picnic blanket. They didn’t even bring food. Crap.

Well...in for a penny, in for a fucking pound. Eddie gets down on one knee, pulls out a ring, and...Chrissy starts laughing. Laughing so fucking hard.

Eddie feels himself turning red. Oh. She really doesn’t want him. 

Chrissy kneels down on one knee too, and pulls out a small box. “Were you about to propose to me, Munson?” she asks, her voice impossibly sweet.

“Sure was.” Oh, my fucking God. They just fucking proposed at the same time. “Were you about to propose to me, Cunningham?”

She giggles. “That’s Munson to you.”

Oh, shit. Yeah. She’s gonna be Mrs. Eddie Munson. He grins. “So, Chris, will you do it? Will you--”

“--marry me?” she finishes. 

“Yep!” they say at the same time, then break into stupid little kid giggles.

When he leaves the rose garden, Eddie’s holding her hand -- his fiancee’s hand.

How’d he get so fucking lucky?