Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Jonathan’s Woes: The Wedding Rings Case

Summary:

Jonathan discovers that Steve ordered engagement rings for his partners.
But Jonathan finds out there is no ring for him.
Jonathan’s heart is crushed.

(Of course this is all just a misunderstanding!)

Modern Era OT4 : Jonathan x Billy x Eddie x Steve

Work Text:

Jonathan is the first one to arrive home, in the afternoon. Steve isn't to be expected until the night, since he takes every optional extra class he can. Billy is finishing work late this week. Eddie always leaves work late; Eddie works a lot. But unexpectedly, Jonathan isn't alone when he arrives. There is a parcel on his doorstep. A small parcel, tightly tied up with light string. The address of the Byers-Hargrove-Harrington-Munson household is on it, in neat handwriting.


Jonathan leaps inside, excitedly, with the package in hand, assuming it was something he had ordered for himself. The person who packed it outdid themselves, and Jonathan feels a little bad when he pulls on the string to untie the beautiful knot. Given its size, it the sunglasses that he ordered a couple of weeks ago. He did not expect them to arrive this fast, so he is even giddier; that is a lovely surprise to come home to.


Jonathan marvels at how the knot loosens up and disappears. The box inside is so lovely, it starts giving Jonathan the idea that something is wrong. He didn't pay more than ten bucks for everything, goods and delivery costs. Why did the seller bother to use a holographic cardboard box?


Or... perhaps this isn't Jonathan's order.


This happens to be true, Jonathan finds out when he sees a little card that reads “Thank you for your order: Steve”. The text is printed and Steve's name is handwritten with a glitter pen. Jonathan takes the card in hand to inspect it closer, tilts it a little to see the light reflecting on the glitter. By taking it in hand, Jonathan reveals what's under the card. Red blurred shapes under a clear layer of bubble wrap, of which he decides to lift one end. He takes a quick peek and his heart misses a beat. There are three deep red velvet boxes and... they unsurprisingly remind Jonathan of...


No.


That can't be right.


Jonathan sits down, his head feels suddenly heavy. Swiftly, he looks around the room, checks that the door is locked and that he still has at least an hour and half before anyone else comes home. Then and only then he carefully removes the tape that's holding the bubble wrap in place. He feels stupid when he realises that his hands are trembling. This is nothing. It's just that there are three boxes. And they are four in the relationship. Or at least he hopes they are— no.


He is just overthinking. Steve didn't even talk about this order. It's probably not a big deal at all. It isn't what Jonathan first believed it was. It must be just a little something Steve bought for himself. Just three nice rings he bought himself five months early for his birthday, to put on his own fingers. Jonathan didn't know Steve liked rings. But perhaps Steve got into them recently and he didn't tell anyone yet. It must be because Steve wanted to test jewellery out on his own, at first.


Sure, this has to be true. Admittedly, the package looks expensive, since it is only for trying out. But, surely Steve wants what's best for himself, the cheeky bastard.


Jonathan knows. Jonathan knows that he oughtn't to look in the boxes. They are Steve's inner sanctum. But... now that he's come this far... Steve wouldn't have to know... He isn't going to hurt anyone. Just take a quick look at what kind of rings Steve likes, and definitely not at what he bought for his boyfriends—-


Oh, God.


The first ring looks gorgeous. Jonathan doesn't consider himself a pro, but still, he knows a thing or two about these things. The ring looks perfect, maybe that is because it goes beyond what Jonathan first expected when he opened the parcel. Throat dry, he raises the box a bit, inspecting the treasure inside, just like he did with the glitter ink. That's when he sees it.


Billy.
Billy's name, engraved on the inside of the ring. He can't believe he didn't notice it earlier. As of now, it is the only thing he can see. Did Steve decide, while ordering rings for himself, to also buy Billy one? Or, was Billy to one who asked Steve to take him a ring, when he saw that Steve was ordering some? Why hadn't Jonathan been told about any of this?


Jonathan's insides churn when he sees the heart-patterned cushion on which the ring lies.


*~*~*~*


That's it. He is going to leave the flat and never come back.


Jonathan can't believe that the three rings are for Billy, Steve and Eddie.


That had been his first thought when he saw three boxes, and of course, he should have trusted his first thought. But no, instead he had made sure to dismiss it with theories of Steve having a new passion for rings.


It's too late now because reality is facing him. Each ring has a name engraved on it, and none has Jonathan's. What does this mean?


He thinks he knows. It's a dangerous thought, that he doesn't want to have. Steve bought engagement rings for himself and Eddie and Billy, but he doesn't want to give Jonathan one. That destroys him.


He doesn't know how to react. He thought he was safe and loved there.


For now, he is going to pretend he doesn't know anything. He'll see how things go. Perhaps Steve will tell him. Whatever he has to say about Jonathan not belonging as much as the others. Whatever it is about the fact that it's not Jonathan's fault, if he is not loved.


It hurts because Jonathan hadn't seen it until today. That saddens him to think about how hopeful he had been when, back in the day, his boyfriends had first started showing signs of interest in him. He feels like he is betraying the young Jonathan who hoped for so much. He had no idea things had changed that much on Steve's side. He can't bear to think about it being more than just Steve's idea. The possibility of Billy and Eddie, too, seeing him as less, fills his chest with shadow.


Quick and neat, Jonathan puts the rings, boxes and glitter card back together in the parcel. He even uses some tape to close it well, because he doesn't manage to redo the knot like it was when it arrived. Then, he puts the parcel on the living room table. It's only at this moment that he notices that Steve's name is also written on the package. It's small and under the address. He can't help but think of how he could have avoided all this if he had just paid more attention to the writing. He could have still got to live, naively, in peace.


Jonathan goes straight to bed. He plans on crying and letting it all out before anyone comes back. But Jonathan falls asleep mid-crying and mid-cursing at the welkin before he can get all the relief his tears can give him.


*~*~*~*


“Jonathan. Hi. Jonathan.”


A hand runs through Jonathan's hair. It's soft and it feels so good, that he doesn't want to open his eyes. As long as he keeps pretending to sleep, Billy keeps playing with his hair.


“Hi.” Jonathan says with his eyes closed.


Billy removes his hand. Instead, he leans down to kiss Jonathan on the forehead. “Had a good day? Are you tired?”


He climbs on the bed to keep Jonathan company. “Ew, you drool in your sleep—”


Suddenly aware that there is something wet under his cheek, Jonathan opens his eyes. He lifts himself on his elbow. “What— uh... yeah.” he mumbles, staring at the obvious stain of tears on his pillow.


Speaking of tears, he feels them welling up again. He didn't cry long enough to empty his stocks of tears before falling asleep and that makes him want to curse again.


“Were you crying?” Billy looks at him like it's nothing; not like he doesn't care at all, but like he won't make a fuss and pity Jonathan if he was crying.


Jonathan was supposed to keep silent about it but it seems there's no use when tears start falling on their own. He nods yes. “How was your day?” Jonathan asks to distract himself.


“Good.” Billy smiles tenderly. “You?”


“I had a great day.”


“Hmm.” Billy brings out a hand and when Jonathan doesn't push it away, he removes Jonathan's tears and runs his fingers over the strands of hair framing his face. “What happened?”


Jonathan sniffs and sits up. Every second he gets more and more convinced that he is going to spill everything. Everything he was supposed to keep secret. Will it ruin Steve's surprise if he tells Billy about the rings? It will probably, but Jonathan can't find it in himself to make up a lie that will be convincing enough for Billy to believe.


Jonathan doesn't feel like he usually complains to his boyfriends a lot. Still, the few times that he did could have been too much for them. Suddenly Jonathan is hit with the horrible thought that Billy would prefer Jonathan to tell a lie because he doesn't want to bother listening to the truth. The truth would mean Jonathan crying and complaining and showing how insecure he is. This is not how he wants to be perceived. He has to make an effort...


But Billy is waiting patiently, looking at him with calm eyes. He is a comforting presence.


Jonathan moves a little backwards and leans against the headboard. “I don't know if you knew about the rings...” He looks up at Billy expectantly. He tries to test what Billy knows before speaking more.


“No? What rings?” A smile creeps on Billy's face. “Are there rings somewhere?”


“No, no it's fine. It's nothing.” Jonathan blurts out. He quickly dismisses it with a hand movement. “It's, uh...” he swallows and looks at Billy again, whom he finds this time staring back at him. “When I came back, no one was home, and there was a parcel on the doormat...” he begins, then he is immediately out of breath. Paradoxically, it's also liberating and he feels lighter with each word he pronounces.


Billy only nods. He can't do much with this little information. So he waits for the rest, while Jonathan stares straight ahead as if considering what he should or should not say. It seems to be painful for him to speak. He looks as if he is hiding a big secret, a secret he is guilty of.


“And I didn't look at it well, I just assumed it was clothes or something I had ordered, 'cause I receive, you know, orders every week or so.”


“Yeah.”


“And... when I opened it, there were rings inside. And um...” Jonathan meets Billy's confused gaze. “There was also a card with Steve's name on it, it said, thank you for your order Steve.”


“Wait.” Billy perks up. Jonathan hasn't finished his story yet. But in less than a heartbeat, Billy's mind jumps to the same idea that Jonathan had earlier. He assumes right away that the rings are for romantic purposes. “Steve bought us rings?!”


Billy's face is a mix of surprise and... excitement? Happiness? It breaks Jonathan's heart. How he wants to be happy with Billy about it. But right now all he wants is to break down and cry. “Yeah.”


Billy's brows shoot up.


“I think they were. Engagement-style rings.” Jonathan says in a small voice. “There were names engraved in them.” he says, looking down because he knows this is going to throw Billy in a tizz. For as long as Jonathan has known him, Billy has always said that he didn't want to get married, that marriage didn't equal love, and that it was not for him. Billy doesn't want to get married. He can't, anyway, get married to three men. That doesn't mean he doesn't love romantic gestures, and Steve's rings were a display of his love. And Billy can't pretend he isn't affected by it.


“Our names!?” Billy sounds like he is trying his best not to scream, leaning towards Jonathan, his hands sinking into the bed. Although he could scream, because no one is home except the two of them.


“Yes—” Jonathan croaks out before he is engulfed in a hug by Billy who kisses his cheek eagerly.


“That's great news! Aw...” He holds Jonathan tighter. “We're gonna get married!” he says in a chirping humorous voice, indicating that he knows they aren't actually going to. He kisses Jonathan's cheek again but then stops when he notices that Jonathan is crying with more fervour, nodding at what Billy's saying.


“Jonathan? Are you okay?” He wonders for a second if Jonathan is crying out of happiness, though he doesn't look like he is.


Jonathan feels terrible and a bit stupid for ruining Billy's joy. “It's— I'm sorry...” he says. Billy takes his hand and frowns.


“What is it?”


“It's just that there were only three rings—” His sob cuts him off. “And, and they were only with your names on them. There wasn't one with my name on it.” Fresh tears get squeezed out of his eyes when he says it. He doesn't dare look at Billy who is probably very embarrassed and doesn't know what to answer.


“What. What do you mean?”


Jonathan draws his knees up to his chest as if to hide. “You know what I mean.” He sniffs. “Each ring had one of your names on it, one with Steve, one with Billy, one with Eddie.” Jonathan takes a big breath in. “And that's all. Don't make me say it again.” He looks away. “It's humiliating.” he whispers.


No matter how humiliated he should be, he instinctively allows himself to tell Billy those things. He wants to see how Billy will react to comfort him, even if perhaps it's a fake concern.


“Does that make you sad? I can give you mine if you want.”


“Leave it. You sound like a child.” Jonathan hides his face between his knees, behind his arms. But Billy reaches for him still. He crawls and gets closer, side-hugging Jonathan.


“That's fucked up. I'm sorry.” Billy says.


Jonathan doesn't say anything, though he still savours Billy's determined tone. He's so relieved that Billy is still ready to defend him.


“If Steve said he didn't want me anymore in the relationship. Would you guys—” Jonathan hesitates for a moment. “...what would you do?” he adds in a smaller voice.


Billy looks taken aback. He hasn't prepared for that kind of question, just after coming home after work. Still, he leans his head on Jonathan's shoulder. “In the current state of things, I am not leaving you. I have no reason to. Quite the reverse...”


“But if Steve asked you to choose? Between him and me?”


Billy is about to say that Steve would never do that, although he knows it's not true. It is something Steve would say if he were upset. Billy doesn't answer right away and Jonathan speaks first.


“Forget it. I can't ask you that.” He sniffs slowly, mostly to give himself some time to think. “And Steve hasn't said anything yet, maybe I'm just imagining things...” At that, his eyes start welling up again. He doesn't know. He's so tired. He only found the parcel less than a couple of hours ago, yet he feels exhausted. And tired Jonathan does and says dumb things. So that must be why he feels like such a stranger to himself. “Perhaps I just need to sleep. I'll feel better then.” He turns to Billy who is looking at the blanket on the bed.


Billy looks like he has been thinking hard. Oh, he looks on the verge of tears too. For a second only. The next one, it's gone. “Jonathan.” he starts.


And then he says everything Jonathan needs to hear.


“I have no idea why your ring is missing. But Steve never mentioned wanting to leave you behind. Okay?” He takes Jonathan's hands in his. “If I am asked to choose, I won't leave you behind. I really, really want you with me. I can't express how much you mean to me, but—” He squeezes Jonathan's hands. “Yeah... I don't know what to say. I have no explanation for the rings you saw. But... know that it would feel so wrong to wear mine if you didn't have one. Here—”


He waits for a second in order to catch Jonathan's attention. But he already has it, since he started speaking.


“I promise I won't wear my ring if Steve did buy them only for us and not you. I promise.”


Jonathan wants to snort, to say it's silly to do promises like they're in kindergarten. But to tell the truth, it makes his heart swell so much he can barely take it. Billy is ready to give up his ring for him. “Oh...” he says, his voice wobbly. He presses his lips together and trembles with the start of sobbing. “Thanks.” he manages to say before he bursts out full-on crying. It's a lot, after doubting whether he's still a valuable member of their relationship. It's all a lot.


Billy is kind enough to hug him in such a way that he can't see Jonathan's face tensing up and writhing in repulsive ways while he cries.


*~*~*~*


It's almost 7 o'clock in the evening when Steve comes back from school. Billy is waiting for him. As well as Eddie to whom he has told everything. And they both made Jonathan come with them to confront Steve, even though he first insisted on staying hidden in the bedroom and pretending to be asleep.


“Good evening.” Steve walks inside, happy to be home. His greetings go unanswered. At the same time, he notices the looks on each of his partner's faces.


Jonathan looks uncomfortable. He chews on his lip and avoids Steve's gaze. Billy and Eddie seem rather angry, ready to attack. This is not the sight he excepted to come home to.


“Is there something wrong?” Steve asks. He quickly turns his head and looks around the room to see if he missed something obvious. He doesn't find anything. Eddie and Billy hid the package before he came back.


“We saw the rings.” Eddie says.


Steve immediately looks off. His eyes dart around the room again, this time definitely looking for his parcel. “You found... what?” When he can't find it he looks up at Eddie who doesn't answer him anything.


“The rings.” Billy repeats although everyone knows Steve heard Eddie the first time he spoke.


“Ah.” Steve swallows and thinks for a bit. “You... you weren't supposed to find them now.” He looks at them helplessly. “I thought about giving them on Valentine's day... So..” Eddie and Billy are still glaring at him. Steve's cheeks heat up. He looks very unsure suddenly. “Are the rings the reason why you're mad?”


“Well, yeah Steve. What do you think?” Eddie's tone is so sharp. You wouldn't want to have him playing against you. Poor Steve looks like a desperate dog.


Jonathan assumes that he is embarrassed and upset that they found the gift he wanted to keep a surprise. Plus now, Steve has to admit in front of everyone why he didn't take a ring for Jonathan. And Steve doesn't look ready to do that, at all.


Steve's mind is racing. Did he think everything wrong? Is it too soon, too silly? Is the meaning of rings too important for the current state of their relationship?


“It's okay...” Jonathan murmurs to Billy. Billy takes his hand and Jonathan sighs. He hates the atmosphere that's building up in the room.


Steve knows very well Billy didn't want to get married. But he thought that gifting him a ring would be acceptable and seen as a sweet gesture. He didn't mean to look like he wanted to suffocate him in a contractual relationship.


Steve had thought about building his life with his current boyfriends. He believed they saw him, too, perhaps as a trustful partner that would last. A partner they wanted to build something with. In a way, the rings would have been a way to make it official. But in reality, his boyfriends don't seem to see it that way.


Perhaps, he hopes, they just don't like the rings themselves, not the whole idea of trusting each other that is behind it.


“I'm sorry.” Steve says after several seconds of silence. Wow. Great bad start. “I didn't think it would be a problem for you guys.”


He gets interrupted by Jonathan's sharp intake of air. When he looks up Jonathan is on the verge of tears, shoulders starting to shake.


What? What did Steve miss? Why has Jonathan got in such a state because of rings—


“The fuck?” Billy says. He raises his chin, face twisted in anger. “It's not a problem?” he asks, with an expression showing just how much he is holding back inside.


Jonathan gives Billy's hand a quiet squeeze. Billy glares at Steve. “Okay.” Billy says. “Why did you think it wouldn't be a problem?”


“I don't understand.” Steve says. “I'm sorry if I misunderstood what you've said to me about it.” He looks down. “I didn't think giving you rings would be a problem. Yeah. I already said that. Sorry. I just don't see how they're harmful. I mean, maybe yes, they mean marriage and everything, and that's something you don't want, and I should have known.” Eddie opens his mouth like he is going to interrupt him but Steve doesn't let him. He continues. “But it's obvious we're not getting married right now. I thought it'd be nice if we had rings, just rings. They don't need to mean anything other than rings.”


“Steve.” Eddie frowns. “You're missing the point.”


“Uh?”


“What about Jonathan's ring?” Eddie asks him. Jonathan thinks this is the worst wording ever because there is no Jonathan's ring.


“What about it?” Steve looks around the room. “Where are they? The rings. Why did you open something with my name in the first place.” With quick strides, he gets to the cabinet and looks through the pane. Unfortunately, his parcel is not inside. He turns back to Eddie. “Does anyone know where it is?”


The parcel, to Steve, also represents months worth of savings. The thought of losing it makes his head spin.


Eddie takes a step towards him. “Steve.” He calls. Steve doesn't look up, he is frantically searching for his package in a drawer. “Steve.” Eddie says. Steve looks up. Jonathan is crying again. He makes no noise, but it's obvious he is crying, given the streaks of tears rolling down his face.


“Jonathan?” Steve looks at Eddie, then Billy, hoping one of them will give him an explanation.


“Jonathan, are you okay?” Steve asks. Jonathan crosses his arms over his chest. He tries to look impassive yet underneath that, he just can't speak because of the sobbing in his voice. He tries to articulate a short answer, but the only thing that comes out is a frustrated sniff.


Steve rushes to him, though he looks like he might stop when he catches Eddie and Billy's expressions. Jonathan finds them ridiculous. He should be the one looking upset, not them! But he can't say he doesn't love their support; he wonders what he could have done if they hadn't reacted as they did.


Steve stops in front of him. He doesn't dare take his hand or embrace him. He knows that he is on thin ice. “Do you want to tell me what it is?” Steve asks.


Jonathan looks away as he tears up again.


Billy softly passes his fingers through the hair on the back of his neck. “Would you like me to tell him?”


Jonathan shrugs and nods without looking at him. He shouldn't be so dramatic. Billy said he wasn't going to leave him. Still, he is so sad to be rejected from the group. He should just go back to his bedroom and cry it out—


“You bought engagement rings with our names engraved on them and you didn't take any for Jonathan.” Billy drops the bomb. “And Jonathan is sad and upset because he feels like you don't want him.” He adds. 'This part was unnecessary' thinks Jonathan, embarrassed.


Steve lifts a hand to his hair. He starts scratching. “That doesn't sound right. I bought a ring for him.” Anger passes on his face for a short moment as if he wants to tell them off again for looking through his stuff. But Steve is known for his self-control. Especially when it comes to anger.


Jonathan perks up “Is it a joke?” he asks.


“No, Jonathan. It would be horrible.” Steve locks eyes with him. “I bought a ring for you.”


He takes the last step forward he needs to wrap his arms around Jonathan. “Of course I did. Why wouldn't I buy you a ring?”


Jonathan speaks with his mouth into Steve's shoulder. “You could do it for plenty of reasons. I don't know.”


“Okay.” Eddie calls. “Then why isn't it in the parcel?”


Jonathan's blood runs cold. Yes, why wasn't it in the parcel? He's horrified to think of Steve lying to him about having bought him a ring when in reality he hasn't.


Steve releases him from the hug. “I— um... I don't know.” He frowns. “Let me check on my laptop if they sent anything.”


Steve goes to fetch his laptop in his room and sits at the living room table. Billy, Eddie and Jonathan stand around him, staring in silence.


“Ahh! There it is.” Steve smiles. He clicks on an e-mail he received a few days ago. “It's true, I should check my e-mails more often.” he says to himself.


Jonathan goes behind him and looks at the screen.


Steve reads aloud. “It says that they sent my order but that one product is going to be late...” He scrolls down to the end of the page. “Though they hope they can ship it before Valentine's Day.”


He turns to Jonathan. “Look.” he says while pointing to the list ordered items.


There are indeed four rings. And 'JONATHAN Engraved Elegant Gold Engagement Ring' is the first one on the list. “Oh...” Jonathan says.


Standing at his side, Billy gasps when he sees the total price.


Steve looks at Jonathan. “I'm sorry. I didn't want to make you feel left out. I love you so much.” He smiles.


Jonathan smiles back, lips almost not wobbling anymore. He felt light. So light! Like he had never experienced lightness before.


*~*~*~*


Once the issue is resolved, the four of them eat dinner and decide to go to bed early. They are all emotionally exhausted and an extended night of sleep and cuddles sounds like the dream.