Work Text:
San Diego, California 1999
Spring
Steve dashed down the hallway, uniform prescribed jacket with his name stitched onto it fluttering behind him as he rounded a corner of the building that had become familiar to him over the last seven weeks.
He’d tried to get off work in time, recognizing that today was an important day, but as an emergency paramedic, he rarely got to dictate the state of his own affairs during his working hours.
Heavy boots thudding as he sprinted across the tile floors, Steve clocked a familiar looking man standing outside the propped open door, scanning the sugar and creamer options at the table that was always set up with coffee carafes and day-old pastries.
“Marcus,” he panted as he dropped to a jog. “Please tell me I haven’t missed anything important,” Steve begged, peering around him into the familiar room. The chairs were arranged in a circle like usual and people were milling about.
The bald man shook his head as he continued to stare at his options. “Nah man, Cassie was late today because something came up. So, it’s just been some catching up and the usual opening spiel about why we’re all doing this and how to be supportive of each other as we embark on the next steps of our respective journeys,” he waved a hand as if to say the usual shit, and Steve’s breathing evened out as he put one hand on his hip, relieved.
“Your boy’s in there,” Marcus added, now glancing up at Steve with a skeptically raised dark brow. “Not sure he’ll be too happy you missed the beginning, but certificates haven’t gone out yet.”
Steve thanked whatever deity was up there and clapped Marcus on the back. They had become close friends since he and his wife Dionne were similar in age and neither seemed to be particularly bothered by his relationship.
“Thanks man,” Steve chuckled, peering over his shoulder. “Grab me a donut will you, I gotta go start the begging for forgiveness process.”
Marcus nodded before finally deciding on half and half for his coffee. “If you’re lucky he’ll only make you get on your knees for a minute or two.” He chuckled and Steve laughed sardonically before stepping into the open room.
The walls were covered with pictures of kids and happy families, rules and tips were printed in large font that was even easy for him to read given the years he struggled with getting the letters to stay in the right places. He saw the usual group he had come to be familiar with milling around the room and talking in pairs as their leader Cassie organized her folders at a table set up in the corner.
When Steve spotted him, Billy was sitting casually slumped in his chair, one leg crossed over the other. His golden curls flopped on his forehead, now smooth shaven in the back and around the sides. He wore his glasses, and Steve suspected judging by the leather bag at his feet, that he’d been reading a manuscript in a café nearby before it was time for their meeting.
He was chatting casually with Dionne who was leaning close to him, brushing her massive curls behind her ear as she laughed, undoubtedly gossiping if Billy’s smirk and raise of his brows was a giveaway. Marcus and Steve frequently bonded over their respective partners’ love for scandal.
Dionne was the first to spot Steve as he waved to a few of the other folks in the room and made his way towards them. He narrowed his eyes once she pointed out to Billy that he was there, turning and catching Steve like a spotlight, which Dionne seemed to find hilarious.
The brunette put his hands up as if to begin placating from afar, a mollifying smile on his lips. “Hey Blue,” Steve tried gently as Billy’s unimpressed gaze landed on him. “That seat taken?” Steve pointed to the chair next to him that had Billy’s jacket thrown over the back of it.
“Actually, it is,” Billy chided, eyes still narrowed behind his frames.
“Come on Bills,” Steve whined, hands dropping to his sides.
Dionne giggled to herself before swatting Billy in his arm. “Oh, let the man sit down, he can’t help that some driver probably went into cardiac arrest right as he was about to clock out.”
“Thank you,” Steve sighed, shoulders sagging. “And actually, it was a three-car pile-up on The Five, and it was right by the exit to Sea World so it was actually kind of a shit show I’ll have you both know.”
Billy rolled his eyes and motioned for Steve to take the chair. “I’m sure Flipper is grateful to you,” he praised sarcastically. Steve chuckled and slid his jacket off, plopping down happily in the seat next to Billy before wrapping his arm around his partner’s shoulders and leaning in to kiss his temple.
The blonde flushed and Dionne grinned at them, just as Marcus crossed the circle of chairs and handed Steve his donut and settled next to his wife. The rest of the group was starting to come back to the circle.
“What did I miss,” Steve whispered, glaze covered lips hovering near Billy’s cheek as he leaned over to glance down at the man’s notebook. Billy’s clean cursive handwriting documented a few bullets, but Steve gleaned quickly that it was the usual stuff. “Anything important?”
Billy shook his head, his anger at Steve’s lateness seeming to melt away the longer Steve was wrapped around him. He glanced at the gold ring on Billy’s left ring finger as he tapped the pen along the notepad. “Not really, we’re just about to get started. Cassie said she had some paperwork for all of us and then we’d get our certificates.”
Steve noted the wariness in his lover’s voice as he stared through the smart looking lenses down at his own handwriting. He wanted to kiss his furrowed brow smooth, but he knew that Billy was sometimes uncomfortable with public displays, wondering especially in these meetings how it would make other potential parents view them.
“It just…” Billy’s voice was low as he looked up and scanned the room, all the seats nearly filled as the social worker who had been assigned to their group training came back and started walking around to distribute the packets. “It’s just becoming…real.”
He tightened his arm, just as Cassie stopped in front of Dionne and Marcus next to them, chatting briefly and handing them their papers.
“Hey,” Steve whispered, leaning in close. “We’ve got this. You’ve got me, and I’ve got you. And no matter what kid we have the incredible opportunity to get, they’ve got us. That’s all we need.”
Billy nodded, and Steve beamed when he saw the corner of his mouth tick up. He pulled away as Cassie walked up and stood in front of them. She was older than them, somewhere in her mid-forties and she often wore flowy skirts and pucca shell jewelry, her almond shaped eyes often accented by her colored liner.
“Hey Steve! Glad you could make it, save any lives today?” she asked in the bubbly way she always did as she handed them the papers.
“Actually, I did. Though Bills won’t ever give me credit for it,” he faked a glare at the man who would legally be his husband if the state allowed it. He settled instead for their domestic partnership that was nearly a year and a half old. The matching gold rings conveyed everything that he wanted people to know though: this man is mine, and I am his, forever—till death do us part.
She laughed and Billy sighed, rolling his eyes to her. “I give you credit for saving lives, I just wish people could need EMTs in a timelier manner when we have things to do.” He smacked Steve playfully with the paperwork and he grinned before finishing his donut off in a couple more bites.
“Cassie it’s our last session today, can you believe it?” he asked her, licking dried sugar from his lips. Billy reached up and wiped some from the corner of Steve’s mouth with his thumb.
The woman held the papers close to her chest and grinned at the two of them. “I know, I’m so excited for everyone. This is the paperwork you’ll need to fill out and submit to complete your application for the license. It shows that you did all your pre-service training.”
Billy skimmed the text, chewing on the corner of his lip. Steve could see all the cogs and gears turning in his mind, the worry and eagerness rolling into one.
If someone had told him the day that blue Camaro rolled into the Hawkins High parking lot, and out stepped every teen girl’s blonde, sun-kissed, mulleted California Dream of a boy, that he would fall in love with that boy and watch him die saving the world; only to sit next to him in a hospital bed for weeks and spend time together nearly every day his last year of high school; well Steve might have believed them, because by that time he was well aware that nothing in this world was as it seemed. That stranger things have happened.
But he never envisioned it, even back then, after he’d managed to amass all the courage his previously broken heart could take to tell Billy how he felt, that someday the two of them would be living in southern California together, wearing matching rings and working towards the goal of starting their own family.
He had always dreamed of it, being a dad, even back when he was with Nancy. Sure, during his time pre-Billy, when he was the King of Hawkins High, he’d done his fair share of messing around. But on nights when he lie on his back and stared up at the ceiling, listening to the sounds of his empty house settling, he would comfort himself by saying that there would come a time where he’d never be alone again.
He knew some day that he would have a real family. Now he laughed to himself, realizing that at present, it probably looked drastically different than anything he could have predicted while staring at his blue plaid walls.
“What are you thinking about?” Billy asked him softly as Cassie moved on, passing the paperwork out to the next couple.
Their certificates of completion were next, and then after they discussed what needed to be turned in, the home study evaluation that would follow, and all the other logistics, he and Billy would probably go out for a drink like they usually did with Marcus and Dionne to debrief on their class and the monumental decision they were making.
“Just about you, and us, what’s coming…” Steve felt his face warm aided by the balmy feeling spreading from the center of his chest. “We’re not in Hawkins anymore,” he mused jokingly.
“Yeah, thank god,” Billy chuckled. He thumbed over the paperwork and then reached between them grabbing Steve’s hand, entwining their fingers. “But I guess I’m kinda grateful,” he shrugged. “Without Hawkins, we wouldn’t be here now.”
Steve felt the lump swell in his throat, but he knew Billy would tease him if he cried—he was emotional, so sue him—so he just kissed his lover’s knuckles silently and nodded, holding the fist right over his heart. Billy knew without saying what that meant, the apple-colored flush on his cheeks told Steve that was true.
Summer
Billy took a deep breath as the ocean breeze from the open window fluttered into the small room, carrying the paint fumes out that hovered over where he lie on the rug in the middle of the floor. He listened to the sound of the people making their way to the shoreline with one hand over his heart, pressing to his beater and his mother’s Virgin Mary necklace.
Some days the old scarring right there over his heart from where the Mind Flayer had pierced him, was tight and sent new aches reverberating across the old wounds. Some days he felt too big for his body, and he had to tell himself or listen intently to Steve when he held him and whispered that the gate was closed, that he was Billy, that he was human, and warm, and here.
He took in another breath of summer breeze, knowing that if he strained his ears, he could hear the ocean itself and he pictured himself on the board, balancing as he glided through a tunnel of water.
The sounds from this room resonated deeply inside of him and behind his closed eyes he dug through his memory to the time he slept in this room as a small boy, when his mother or his grandmother would tuck him in and tell him stories. He ran down the halls and through the living room, laughter carrying on the wind that blew in through all the open windows.
He was shocked when he’d gotten the call from Susan. The call where she told him that in all the divorce paperwork she was filing with Neil, her lawyer had found he’d been hiding a house in San Diego from them.
“Do you know it, Billy? The house at 473 Oceanside Boulevard?” she’d asked through apologetic tears. It was his grandmother’s house. Apparently, she’d left it in his name all those years ago when she’d died, not long after his mother—of a broken heart, everyone had said.
He had been standing at the phone in the kitchen, in the shitty studio apartment he’d lived in with Steve while he was in his third year at UC San Diego. His boyfriend was taking classes at the local community college to become a paramedic, working every night that he could at an Italian restaurant near campus and on the weekends as a lifeguard at the beach since he wanted Billy to focus on school more than anything.
They’d moved into his grandmother’s house immediately after all the paperwork to transfer the property to Billy had been signed. With Steve at his side, they took their meager things with them to the airy and spacious three-bedroom house that overlooking the shoreline in the La Jolla Shores neighborhood. He remembered the feeling of walking barefoot through the house, fingertips skimming the walls as Steve opened every window in the entire place.
The two of them had slept on their ratty mattress that night in the master bedroom, legs intertwined, window open to let in the cool evening breeze. Even though it had been hot, Billy had clung to Steve as the brunette slept, soft snores emanating from his sleep drunk visage.
He’d cried that night into Steve’s neck, his sobs muffled by the warm skin of the boy he loved, and he thought that maybe everything that he’d been through up until that point: Neil’s hatred, his mother’s death, leaving the only place he’d ever loved, fighting the Upside Down, and fearing he might lose the boy he wanted to give his entire self to, just might have been worth it to be where he was now. In a new home, where he felt safe, with a boy he loved and a future ahead of them.
Perhaps his mother and grandmother took pity on him. They saw the way Billy Hargrove suffered, and decided, much like Steve reminded him: that he was good. That he deserved good things. It was the only pity, he reasoned, that he would accept with open arms.
“Oh,” he heard Steve say to himself as he stepped into the room with bare feet. Billy sat up abruptly, brushing away the tears that had been streaming across his temples. “I like this color, what’s it called?” he asked, eyes searching over the walls and falling to the buckets of paint and half dried rollers.
Billy hadn’t heard him come home, but instantly felt better knowing he was nearby. He walked to the center of the room, still scanning the walls that Billy had just finished painting a light-colored green.
“It’s called, Sage Advice,” Billy said tiredly as Steve made his way to the rug and sat down with what looked to be carry out and a couple of beers. Billy smiled at him softly, “Tacos?”
Steve nodded and bit down on the beer bottle, flipping the cap off with his teeth. Billy always told him he was going to fuck them up doing that, but Steve always assured him as a paramedic with substantial training, that he’d be fine.
“Yeah, from that little stand you like by the volleyball court.” He opened the other beer as Billy unpacked things, setting the napkins and plastic utensils down beside the circle that they’d made. “You know Bills, painting the nursery again isn’t going to make the process go any faster. This is what, like the fourth—”
“Third,” Billy glared with a bite of taco in his mouth.
“Okay third time you’ve painted in here,” Steve corrected. “First it was the pinkish color,” Steve counted on his thumb.
“It was salmon you numb nut,” Billy interjected.
Steve took a bite of his taco and raised his pointer finger, “Then it was the pale yellow.”
“Sunshine baby,” the blonde nodded, pushing around his beans and rice.
His husband—that was what he called Steve even though he knew the state didn’t legally recognize their domestic partnership as a marriage, but goddamn it what else was he supposed to call the man he lived with, and went grocery shopping with, and fucked and got fucked by, and paid bills with and said vows to, who now wore a matching gold ring—sat there, unamused as he took a swig of his beer and stretched out, taking the walls in again before his honey brown eyes landed on Billy.
“And you always seem to feel the need to do this after a visit with Cassie,” his voice was gentle, thoughtful. After years of being together, Billy knew that Steve knew how to read him, no matter how much he tried to hide.
Billy took another bite of his taco and downed a few gulps of his beer. The carbonation made his nose burn, but he liked the way the beer tasted mixed with the salt of the sweat on his upper lip.
“Thanks for the great psychoanalysis,” he rebuked. Billy avoided Steve’s gaze and squeezed the lime on his food before fitting the slice down the neck of the bottle.
Steve sighed as he looked to the window. “To be fair it is a really nice color. I think I like this the best. Not to mention that when I come home to find my husband completely covered in paint, there’s no choice but to take a shower together,” Steve grinned before taking a drink. Billy licked his lips as he watched Steve’s throat work, pink lips puckered around the mouth of the bottle.
He caught himself though and looked away just as Steve’s eyes set on him. A moment went by, and the linen blinds rustled in the breeze and Billy felt Steve’s toe poking his bent knee. When he raised his gaze to take in those eyes, Steve was smiling gently at him.
“Come on baby, tell me what’s on your mind. We had a good visit with Cassie yesterday, she told us that things are coming along. We already handed in all our boring paperwork—the health check, the background check, the financial statements,” Steve numbered off. “Now they’re just working on the interviews while we get things in order.”
Billy sighed as he continued to eat before wiping his mouth in the corner. “Hopper called earlier while you were out and said that he and Joyce got the call to schedule their phone interview.”
Steve grinned thinking about their wayward parental figures back in Hawkins. The last time he and Billy had gone back to the place was a couple years ago to attend their wedding.
“See that’s good! You know that Hop is going to tell them about how great we are, and that will probably mean a lot seeing as he’s a Chief of Police and has kids himself. What about Heather and Robin, you said you talked to Heather recently.”
He nodded and brushed his hair from his face. “Heather got confirmation that their interview had been fully documented and added to our paperwork.”
“That’s great,” Steve cheered, opening his arms. Billy let a half smile through before motioning that he should eat his food. “And the kids told me that they’re all almost done with their letters.”
Billy chuckled, remembering how he’d been curled up on the couch with a manuscript he was editing for work when Steve had burst in excitedly, still wearing his uniform. “The kids said that they would write letters to the agency for us!” He’d immediately shot down the idea from behind the many pages of the novel he was reading, red pen poised in hand.
Apparently, the kids wanted to help, but since they were all too young and not directly tied to them in a way meaningful enough for the agency to interview, they had to get creative. “Dustin looked it up,” Steve had sat down on the couch, gripping Billy’s knees. “That you can submit letters from references who don’t do interviews, it can help your case sometimes.”
After a phone call with Max that had mostly consisted of her whining despite being in her late twenties at this point, Billy had caved on the idea of the Brat Pack submitting letters to detail how capable Billy and Steve were at taking care of a child.
“I swear to god Steve,” Billy groaned, falling on his back again next to his takeout. “If those little fuckers jeopardize this adoption for us by telling them some stupid shit like I was possessed by an interdimensional monster: I will kill all of them.” He glared at his husband from the rug and Steve laughed, sweeping Billy’s curls away from his forehead.
“I got you Blue,” he chuckled softly. “All the kids will send their letters here and we’ll go through ‘em first before we submit them. I promise that if Dustin tells them about the time you smashed a plate over my head, we can leave his out.”
“Jesus fucking Christ,” Billy moaned, covering his face with his hands. Steve laughed and threw himself on top of Billy, sitting on his waist and attempting to wrestle his hands away.
Eventually he complied and stared up at his lover. Steve studied his face as Billy searched him before reaching up and pushing his brown locks back right at his hairline, rubbing the faint scar with his thumb. “You know I’m fucking sorry for that don’t you?” he whispered miserably. “For all of it.”
Steve pulled Billy’s hands to his lips, kissing his fingers gently. “I know baby,” Steve breathed. “It’s been a long time. I know,” he leaned over, bracing himself on either side of Billy’s head as he dipped down for a kiss. “It was a bad joke sweetheart, I’m sorry,” Steve murmured with a faint grin against his lips.
Billy knew he was being sensitive. He knew that Steve had forgiven him, that maybe he had well before he’d apologized to the boy, right after the world had tried to end again, from a hospital bed with all kinds of tubes and wires connected running through him.
He hadn’t been expecting to see Steve of all people at his bedside when he woke up, but he couldn’t deny the fluttering in his chest when he saw the boy, mostly because the heart monitor had picked up on it and started beeping so rapidly nurses thought maybe he was going into cardiac arrest.
And even though it had been years, and they’d had many more fights, and even broke up for a time during Billy’s senior year, only for both of them to go crying back to each other—sometimes Billy couldn’t shake the feeling that he didn’t deserve Steve Harrington.
Maybe he was worried that this deep dive into their lives for the adoption would reveal that to someone else and confirm all the fears he tried to lock away and shove deep down, and he’d lose the child he wanted so badly as well as the man he loved so profoundly.
“Hey,” Steve said jostling him a little. He stared into his boy’s honey eyes and felt grounded once more. He could feel the rug brush against his shoulder blades, smell the salt on the wind and their food going cold next to them, taste the beer on Steve’s lips. “I love you baby, we’re in this together. And it’s going to work out, it’s just taking some time.”
Rather than continue to voice his insecurities, to bring his fears into the light, he just nodded and let Steve hug him there on the floor. They lie there until Steve whispered a dirty joke into his ear and he shoved the man off with an annoyed groan and they fell into a fit of laughter.
“They should have named this color salsa verde,” Steve recommended as he scanned the pale green walls, mouth full of taco. “It’s like, exactly the same.”
Billy glanced at his husband before turning back to study the wall, letting the laughter from his chest bubble up and float out of the window towards the sea, like he had all those years ago when he was a child.
Fall
Steve let his eyes sway from the road to examine the quiet man in the passenger’s seat beside him before focusing back on the traffic ahead. The drive from the Children’s Bureau was a familiar one now, but since they’d started this journey around this time last year, it had never been so silent.
Billy was turned toward the window, watching the cars go by, and frankly Steve was more unnerved by the reserved Billy than the rambunctious and rowdy one he had become used to. His husband stared despondently past the glass of their Jeep, an upgrade from his old BMW, one that was more kid friendly they had decided, that would allow them to haul around all the things that being parents entailed.
“Bills,” Steve tried, though he expected very little. Billy could be stubborn when he wanted to be, and this time he understood. He reached over and took Billy’s hand in his, let it rest between them. He felt the way his lover’s fingers were intertwined with his, and the small squeeze of acknowledgement Billy gave him.
He didn’t know exactly how to discuss what had just happened, his own feelings were roiling inside of him: anger, frustration, doubt. They’d been told about a month or so ago that it was likely they would be chosen for the placement of a newborn.
They were leaders in the pack, Cassie had told them, beaming with excitement at the meeting. They were a domestic partnership, the closest two men could be to a marriage; their finances looked great, especially because they owned their house; Steve worked as a paramedic and Billy was an editor for a publisher that was based in downtown and had the flexibility of working from home up to four days a week; and their entire community was adamant that they would be great fathers.
Cassie echoed repeatedly that any child would be lucky to have them as parents, and they had let themselves get excited. Steve had begun to stand in the nursery, imagining a crib in one corner, a rocking chair in the other, a changing table against the wall. He pictured falling asleep with a baby on his chest, small and warm, brand new to the world.
Though Billy wouldn’t let on too much, a few more baby books had been added to their collection, Steve finding them all over—in their bedroom turned to a chapter on feeding, on the kitchen counter with a page marked on sleep training, even in the bathroom in the basket with the newspapers open to a dog-eared page about bonding with a newborn.
And then, today they had gone into their check-in with Cassie. It had been less than an hour ago, but Steve’s eyes drifted to the setting sun, and noted that it seemed like another world now.
When they had gotten to their appointment, now about a month out from the due date of the mother, they had sat eagerly with Cassie, awaiting their update. Maybe it would be news on how the mother was doing, or an ultrasound picture the two of them were secretly craving but never dared to request.
Instead, they found the usually cheerful woman sitting across her desk from them with her hands folded and her brow drawn down in the middle. “I’m sorry,” she said delicately. “Things like this happen throughout the process and it’s never easy, but it doesn’t mean you shouldn’t get your hopes up again.”
Steve felt his stomach drop and when he looked to Billy, the man was stone. “It’s my fault, honestly, I didn’t really anticipate it. That she would have a problem with you two being a gay couple.” Cassie raised her eyes to them and shook her head. “We spoke to her, asked what she wanted, and she was very adamant that the placement not be with two men.”
Steve had felt like the wind was knocked out of him. Of course, there were still people that didn’t like queer people, his own parents included initially. Though his mother had begun to warm up as Steve’s life took a more solid direction, thanks mostly in part for his desire to provide stability for Billy. But it just seemed so shocking…a child in need of a home, just not theirs.
“Are you serious?” he asked, feeling the anger swell up in him. “I—We—Billy and I are going to be great parents, being gay has nothing to do with it.” He curled and uncurled his fingers, leg jackhammering as he shook. “What the fuck, I mean—come on, it’s 1999 for Christ’s sake, it’s not like it’s the Dark Ages.”
Cassie pursed her lips and peeked up at him from beneath her brows. “I understand Steve, it’s frustrating, but relatively common unfortunately in the current adoption system. Families like yours are often low priority—no matter how wrong that is, the state and federal system still allow for that type of discrimination. But agencies like ours are doing our best,” she offered them a weak smile.
“I know you and Billy will be great fathers,” she added sympathetically, reaching out to put her small hand over Steve’s. “And we’ll keep trying until we find a kid that’s just right.” She sighed and grabbed the file for the newborn that was on her desk and put it back into the tall cabinet behind her. Steve felt like he’d been kicked in the gut.
Billy had been silent since the news, Steve’s heart shattering even further. Billy had been eager, just like he was. They both knew this process would be difficult, they’d done plenty of training talking about how to manage their emotions and expectations along with a child’s. But somehow it was still so painful.
With a squeeze of Billy’s hand, Steve merged into the far lane and turned off their normal route. He watched the blonde perk up just a bit, recognizing they were headed toward the beach rather than home.
Steve threw the car in park when they got to the sandy parking lot and stepped out, the salty wind blowing back his lightweight jacket. Fall in San Diego meant it was still warm outside, even near the water as the sun was beginning to set.
After a moment, Billy got out and joined him, watching the sun dip on the horizon as they leaned against the front of the car. Without a word, Steve bent down and slipped his sneakers and socks off, tucking them together before standing up and observing Billy beside him.
The last few years in California had been good to Billy. His skin had absorbed the deep glow it had the first day Steve had noticed him in the parking lot of Hawkins High. His blonde curls were now much shorter, but the setting sun cast a halo behind his head.
His freckles were endless and appeared everywhere across his body from the bridge of his nose to his shoulders. Steve could feel their heat when he kissed them, mapping each dot like a constellation to the next one. Somehow California made Billy’s eyes shine bluer, competing with the ocean waves for the truest blue.
He walked with confidence here, sand ahead and the sunshine at his back. He was the best Billy that Steve had seen, he was comfortable, had lost that antsy, restless sort of feeling that made him crouch defensively in Hawkins. Steve was more in love with Billy Hargrove than he ever thought he could be. The lack of a child wouldn’t change that.
When Billy had taken his shoes off, Steve extended his hand for his boy to take. He thought about all the times in the early days where they competed for dominance, where Billy had slapped his hand away, like at basketball practice when he’d offered to help him up off the court after a foul. But now, he knew the soft and sweet Billy Hargrove, so he wasn’t surprised when his lover reached back and took his hand.
The walked down the sandy and grassy embankment to the shoreline and strolled slowly with their shoes in their hands. They ambled for a while, not saying anything to each other, but instead taking in the waves and focusing on how their feet sunk into the wet sand.
At one point, before they had gotten too far, they stopped, and Billy stared down at their feet as the chilly water rushed up over them, tossing sand and shells and debris between their toes. Billy leaned down and reached into the sand, picking up a broken seashell and rubbing the granules off it with his thumb.
“I wanna take our kid to the beach a lot,” Billy finally said. His voice was even and calm. His eyes traced each groove of the shell and Steve watched him, before those blue eyes were meeting his.
He nodded, lips pressed together as Billy returned to the shell. “I wanna teach ‘em to swim, and to surf. And I want to play in the tide pools and show ‘em all the weird shit that grows there.”
Steve watched him without a word as he gripped the shell tighter. “And I want us to come and have picnics at the beach and get sand in the Jeep when we get back home, and I want them to know what the best sunsets look like, and know what it’s like to be so tired from a day in the sun.”
“Hmm,” Steve hummed as he rocked back and forth, shoes and socks still in his hand. “Like so tired that they pretend they’re asleep when we get home and try to wake them, so we have to carry them to bed to avoid breaking the spell.”
Billy laughed, and Steve’s heart pounded like it was his first time hearing the sound. “Of course you did that shit,” he teased, though the nostalgia painting his words told Steve that Billy was just as guilty. And he smiled to himself, hoping their kid would someday be the same.
Winter
Billy hated winter a lot less now that they lived in San Diego compared to when they lived in Hawkins, but the few months at the end of the year and beginning of the new one were still his least favorite. He chalked it up to having Neil as a parent for so long, and only just now finding some sliver of normalcy at the holiday season.
He’d been lamenting the seasonal change’s effects on his allergies while packing up his desk so he could go home and get started on dinner, when his secretary poked her head in and told him that he had a call on line one that seemed important. With a sigh he picked up the phone and pressed the blinking button, “Billy Hargrove, Butler Publishing. What can I do for you?”
“Billy, I’m so glad I caught you!” he heard Cassie’s familiar voice and let his shoulders fall.
“Hi Cas, what’s going on?” he furrowed his brow, heart throbbing, though he tried his best to stave off the feeling of hopefulness that bubbled in his blood.
“Can you and Steve meet up with me tomorrow? I realize it’s a Saturday, but it’s urgent and I think I have some good news about a potential placement.”
Billy leaned forward on his desk, glancing up to see his secretary waving to ask if he was okay. He nodded at her, and she disappeared. He did his best to take a deep breath away from the mouthpiece of the phone. “Uh yeah, Cas that sounds good. Just tell us when and where.”
Steve was abound with anxious energy as he nearly hopped into the café Cassie had selected for their breakfast meet up, while Billy was just a bundle of nerves. He’d gotten his hopes up last time and felt like he’d fallen to pieces, which he knew was not wise during a process like this one because rejection was a part of it—but that didn’t mean it hurt any less.
Cassie spotted them as they walked in and waved from her table as the two came over and took their seats. They ordered politely when the waitress arrived, but Billy could barely stomach his cup of coffee as he watched Cassie reach over into her bag and pull out a manila folder.
“Now, I don’t want you two to get your hopes up,” she said with a pained sigh. “But due to the circumstances, which are honestly truly unfortunate: I think we have a decent chance.”
“What does that mean?” Steve asked warily, unsure whether he should be offended or relieved. Billy chewed on his thumbnail as he glanced nervously between his partner and their caseworker.
She opened the folder and slipped out a picture that was pinned to the top with a paperclip. Easily, Cassie turned the picture around and slid it across the small table to Billy and Steve, past their coffee mugs, right between them.
Billy couldn’t deny that he felt something soften when he took in the little girl in the photo. She couldn’t have been more than four years old. She didn’t smile and her large round chestnut brown eyes seemed to stare past the camera.
She had curly ringlets the same color as Steve’s hair and at a glance he wondered if like his lover, it grew lighter in the summer after being in the sun. And hell, with those eyes and that hair she could have easily been Steve’s kid. Maybe that claimed Billy’s heart even more.
He thought there might have been something familiar about her, but he couldn’t place it. “This is Opal,” Cassie said, eyes turned toward her file. He felt Steve shoulder up next to him to get a better look at the picture. Billy chewed on the inside of his cheek as he looked into those eyes.
“She’s four years old, birthday May 6. She entered the system relatively recently; it’s only been about four months or so.” Recently, Billy wanted to say, but he held his tongue. He knew people like Cassie were working as hard as they could for these kids.
“She’s currently in a group foster home and has been waiting for more specific individual placement, which is more likely since she’s so young.”
Steve raised his brows and looked up to Cassie. “So why do you think our odds are so good? What’s the circumstance?”
The woman in front of them sighed and ran a hand through her dark hair. “Opal’s chances of getting adopted by someone else are slim. She’s almost five years old and most folks as you know prefer the kids to be babies or very young, and she’ll likely start school next year. In addition to that, Opal is mute.”
“Mute?” Billy echoed, surprised.
“What, like she can’t talk?” Steve turned to him; brow furrowed in confusion. “Was she born that way?” he asked, eyes focusing back on the picture.
Cassie shook her head. “Those unfortunate circumstances? Opal entered the system by court order. Her father was on trial, he went to jail recently. Got a fifteen-year sentence for manslaughter.”
She paused for a moment, eyes directed down at the file before she collected herself and returned her gaze to both shocked men across from her. “He killed her mother. Opal was hiding in the closet when they were fighting and was present for it, though they are still trying to ascertain how much she saw. Ever since the incident she hasn’t spoken, the psychologists are calling it traumatic mutism, a form of selective mutism.”
Billy felt immobile as he sat there, Steve’s hand in his below the table. His eyes fell from Cassie’s serious face to the photo of Opal that sat between them. All of a sudden, those eyes staring past the camera made a lot of sense.
He thought briefly to the time spent at his grandmother’s house when he was a kid, of sitting in the backseat of his mother’s station wagon while she did her best to sing along to the radio, telling him they were going to “Granny’s house” when he asked why she had thrown their things in a suitcase and peeled out of the driveway so wildly. He remembered the warble in her voice as she sang, and the hat she wore that sometimes hid the purple and red splotch on her forehead.
They would do that, go to Granny’s house sometimes. And his grandmother would always open the door and give him a hug. She’d squeeze him tight and say she was glad to see her “Billy-Boy.” She told him that she had peeled oranges for him in the kitchen, fresh from the trees in the backyard and then she would set him in front of the TV with his bowl and turn the volume up loud enough to mostly block out the sound of his mother’s sobs from the other room.
When the splotches on her forehead or her throat or her shoulders were gone, they’d go back home again. He’d hug his Granny goodbye and she would hold him just a little bit longer than when he arrived. He remembered the smell of her perfume and the brush of her hand against his cheek. His mother seemed better on the drive back, though if he tried, he could still hear the discomfort in her voice when she sang.
They’d arrive back home to Neil’s warm greeting, an offer to go out to dinner or toss the baseball until sunset propositioned right next to a vase of beautiful flowers. Back then, he didn’t understand why they would go to Granny’s house so often or eventually why the vase went missing and his mother had to get stitches across her temple.
It only started to make more sense when his mother got sick and the visits to Granny got less and less frequent, and Neil’s discipline got sharper and more violent. And soon he was left alone, no Granny, no mother, and during the nights where it hurt his bruised eye too much to cry, he would close his eyes and wish he was somewhere with them.
“Opal is a special case,” Cassie was saying when the high-pitched whine had disappeared from Billy’s ears. “She’s been through a lot, so it’s likely she won’t adjust easily and she’ll require a lot of attention due to the mutism. She won’t be like a regular kid,” the woman added with a shrug, as if to ask what regular really meant. “And frankly that will make getting her adopted pretty difficult.”
“But,” her smile was warm when Billy let his eyes leave the picture. “I know that you two aren’t exactly a regular couple either,” she chuckled playfully. “Steve, I thought that your expertise as a paramedic could come in handy. You have the bedside manner to work with a kid who needs some extra patience, and Billy—” he wondered if Cassie would bring up his own background as a reason.
It had become clear in the interviews during the home study that Billy had experienced abuse at the hands of his father and had grown significantly since he and his stepmother cut off contact with the man. Cassie had commended him for taking care of himself and Max when she noted the interviews in their file, reassuring him softly that his own history wouldn’t affect their chances at adoption like Billy worried it might have.
Because some days, he wondered if that hatred Neil had towards the world was genetic. If one day, he would grow into a person he despised. He’d hurt Steve physically during their teenage years, bullied Max, and frightened Susan. The years had passed, but in the back of his mind he wondered if some day he was destined to become like Neil.
Steve comforted him when he voiced those worries, told him that he saw Billy slay the Mind Flayer, told him he felt guilt, was introspective and was constantly pushing himself to be a better person. He reassured Billy that someone like that could never become like Neil.
“And Billy, you’ve got the job flexibility to give her what she needs in terms of time spent together at home. And despite what you think, I think you have the temperament for a kid like her who will communicate minimally,” Cassie continued.
She flipped through the file and put her hands flat. “Look, it’s going to be a challenge. If you two decide that this is what’s right for you then I can also recommend a psychologist through the Bureau for you to work with and we can set up medical assistance for that once placement has been decided. Of course, we’ll be in touch with her caseworker too who will have some recommendations.”
Cassie brushed her bangs out of her eyes. “I know this is hard, this entire process, the system. But I’ve been doing this for nearly twenty years now. The point is to find people who want to love a kid, and pair them up with a kid who needs those people to love them. You two have clearly shown that through all the months of training and certification,” she grinned, and Billy felt Steve squeeze his hand beneath the table. “If it isn’t Opal, there will be someone else. I just thought that maybe you two were the people for her.”
The two of them both kept to their thoughts as they walked to the car from the beach and drove back home. When Billy stepped in the house, he slipped his shoes off and immediately headed past the living room and kitchen, opening the door on the right before the bathroom.
He felt Steve following him as he flipped the light and walked in, staring at the walls painted pale green. Billy stood in the middle of the room and closed his eyes, pressing his palm to his chest. He could feel the chain with the Virgin Mary on it, hands poised to pray.
The laughter of his childhood echoed through the room, the sound of the ocean that lulled him to sleep at night and soothed his worries. He thought of his grandmother and how she’d gently stroke his head in this very room until he fell asleep.
Steve crept up behind him, and Billy felt those solid arms wrap around his torso. His lover pressed closely, rocking the two of them, nose at his ear. “Gonna paint the room again?” Steve’s voice was a low rumble that resonated at the center of his chest. The question was genuine, no sense of judgement.
Billy gripped Steve’s arm with one hand, the other pressing the chain to his pounding heart. “Nah,” he breathed. “I like the green.”
He felt his lover nod, forcing his head in some way to do the same. They were quiet for a long time while they stood there until Billy turned in Steve’s arms, throwing his own lazily over the other man’s shoulders.
“You know,” he stroked back Steve’s dark hair and stared into his waiting eyes, lost in a sea of honey, and yet he had never felt more grounded. “My mother, she was born in October,” he mused.
Steve bobbed his head, eyes still searching Billy’s face. “Her birthstone was this really striking iridescent jewel. She wore it all the time as her earrings and rings, complimented the Virgin Mary necklace really well.”
“Oh really,” Steve considered, brows raised.
“Yeah,” Billy whispered as they swayed in each other’s arms. “It was the same kind of shimmery as the underside of seashells when you hold them to the light, this beautiful reflective color. She would hold it up to the light and colors would dance everywhere.” Steve smiled at him tenderly. “She used to tell me that to make the stone you had to catch a rainbow, that’s how special they were.”
Steve cupped his face, stroking his thumb over the man’s cheek, and it wasn’t until then that Billy realized he was crying. He let his head fall to his husband’s shoulder, tears trailing over the bridge of his nose to drip on Steve’s collar. “Her birthstone,” Steve’s voice was mellow as he closed his eyes. “What was it?”
Billy wrapped his arms around Steve tightly as they stood there in a room that he hoped would not be empty for long. His breath was wet when he whispered it, but he did so with a smile on his lips. “Opal.”
~
The park was even more crowded than they’d predicted, with carnival games set up near the rest of the normal park activities. Billy took a deep breath as he squeezed Steve’s hand, and they walked over to the ticket booth where they saw Cassie setting up with some of the other Bureau of Children workers who looked familiar from their months of trainings.
“Steve, Billy, it’s good to see you guys!” she greeted them cheerfully, wearing another brightly colored flowing skirt despite the cooling temperature. “I’m excited that you guys decided to come. Opal and her foster family are already here, come on, I’ll introduce you.”
They followed Cassie as she navigated through the carnival and Billy could feel the pit growing in his stomach as they walked. He knew that Steve had picked up on his anxiety and was clinging to him more than they normally did in public, which he found comforting today more than annoying.
“Are you nervous?” Cassie asked over her shoulder with a smile. Clearly Billy was easier to read than he thought. “We’ll do the carnival today, and if things go well, then we’ll schedule another couple of visits and bring her on a home visit to you all. Just one step at a time, be yourselves.”
“It’s going to be great Bills,” Steve assured him, large brown eyes searching over his face. Billy nodded, giving a half smile as they continued walking. “I mean I got you to fall in love with me, I think that means my odds are pretty good as far as anyone else goes.”
Billy rolled his eyes with a sigh and pushed Steve away right as Cassie led them up to a face painting booth. She introduced them to Opal’s foster mother, a woman who the courts worked with frequently when situations like this happened, and the couple of kids that were there. All of them preoccupied with flipping through a book of pictures, trying to decide what they wanted to get painted.
A few feet away was the same girl from the picture Cassie had shown them. She was small, with curls down to her thin shoulders and a purple bow to pull her bangs back. She stared up at the wall of designs in front of her, seemingly unconcerned with the presence of the other children.
“Hey Opal,” Cassie called out, motioning for Billy and Steve to follow her. Cassie crouched down as the child turned around and she grinned, pointing to herself. “Remember me? I’m Cassie, we’ve met before.”
Billy watched Opal’s big mahogany eyes scan Cassie’s face. She was adorable, even as she nodded without a word. Her cheeks had a natural flush, her nose small and button-like and those eyes that he’d quickly fallen into.
He recognized the distant look she wore, one that was hesitant of those around her, like maybe she questioned if the adults who stood tall over her were safe. Billy chewed on the inside of his cheek. He’d known what that felt like.
“These are my friends, Billy and Steve. We’ve talked a lot about you, and they’re really interested in getting to know you. Why don’t we hang out with them today?” Opal studied them slowly, and Billy felt his heart pound in his ears. He did his best to smile at her and wave as Cassie brushed off her skirt and stood back up. “I’m going to tell Linda about it okay?” Billy felt her squeeze his shoulder as she brushed past them, giving him and Steve a chance to talk with Opal alone.
While Billy hesitated, Steve immediately jumped into action, and he was reminded instantly of all the time he spent carting the kids around back in Hawkins. Steve squatted down and grinned at her, pushing his dark hair that matched Opal’s, off his forehead.
“Hi Opal, I’m Steve!” She watched him warily saying nothing back.
Billy thought about the conversation they had with Cassie after they decided that they wanted to learn more about Opal. He had stayed up that night, reading everything there was in the file that Cassie had sent. Even before the traumatizing incident where her mother was killed, Opal’s life hadn’t been great.
There had been a history of drug abuse with both adults. The violence against her mother was suspected to be frequent and the court seemed unsure if it had also extended to Opal. Cassie had told them that it would be an endeavor to take care of a child with needs different from her peers, and that her foster mom had been teaching her some sign language to help with that when she had time.
The next day Billy had ordered several books on sign language, one on psychological trauma and mutism and another on parenting a child with a disability. Steve said they were lucky that he got a discount on books published by his company, but to Billy it seemed like so much that they didn’t know. Cassie had told them it would be okay though, to just start with yes or no.
“Do you want to get your face painted? I think that would be really fun,” Steve grinned at her. Opal paused for a moment and glanced to Billy before looking back at Steve and chewing on her thumb. Her eyes scanned him, and Billy knew she was determining if he was safe or not. His heart ached, but he knew what it felt like to be in that position and did his best to stay present, rather than trap himself too much in his own memories.
Eventually she nodded and Steve turned to the big poster of options. “What do you think you’ll get? Should I get my face painted too?”
He pointed at himself, and she raised her brows as she rocked back and forth on her feet. Steve played like he was thinking, making a silly face as he looked at his options. “What’s cool here,” he scanned the board. “What do you think I should get Opal?”
Her cheeks flushed when he turned back to her, and Billy knew that feeling too—how it felt to have Steve Harrington’s undivided attention. It was both maddening, nerve-wracking, and exhilarating.
Opal turned back toward the poster and then reached up, pointing to a drawing of a teddy bear’s face. “Oh, you think I should get the bear? Hmm, that’s an excellent choice.” He put his hand out for a low-five and she stood there watching him, hands clutched to her chest. There was a long beat and Steve took his hand back, still smiling.
“That’s okay, we don’t have to,” he reassured her. But before he took his hand away, Opal leaned forward, pressing her palm against his slowly. With the way his boy beamed, Billy thought maybe he fell in love all over again.
“So, Steve’s getting a bear,” Billy chimed in, leaning down so he wasn’t standing over Opal. “Which one do you like? What’s your favorite animal?”
She pressed her lips together and pushed her curls out of her face before shifting nervously and pointing to the small bunny that had a glitter tail. “Bunnies are really cute,” Billy added with a smile. “Those are your favorite?” She nodded sharply and Billy couldn’t help but laugh. “Well let’s find someone to do your paint,” he suggested, heart floating in his chest.
The volunteers had done the designs on each one of their cheeks delicately and handed both Steve and Opal the mirrors for them to see. “Wow Opal,” Steve had exclaimed in amazement. “Your bunny looks so good! It has a glitter tail just like the picture. Do you like it?” Billy watched as she turned her head in the mirror, he held for her before nodding in satisfaction.
Billy couldn’t deny that he was surprised Opal wanted to continue going around the carnival with them after the initial face painting activity. They’d helped her out of the chair and Steve had mentioned something about finding a snack or playing games as Opal watched them, staring up between the two.
“Do you want to see more of the carnival with us Opal?” Billy asked gently, nervous for her response.
She looked over to her foster family getting their faces painted and Cassie and her foster mom waved at her. Opal’s brown curls bounced as she turned back and gazed up at Billy, something about her seeming a little less distant. She nodded and he felt fireworks go off in his chest.
After leaving that tent, they wandered through the carnival trading tickets for games and snacks like popcorn and cotton candy. Opal seemed to grow more comfortable with their questions as she walked with them, and Billy and Steve tried to figure out what she liked without pressing too hard.
When some older boys ran by, dodging between them and sending Opal to her knees, Billy felt a swell of protective anger boil underneath his skin. But she said nothing as she pushed herself up and Billy knelt to brush her off. When he stared up at her face from his knees, he saw her eyes on him—that familiar detached gaze. He didn’t know what he expected, perhaps that she would cry or scream or get angry herself. But she said nothing, just tugged down her shirt and pushed her hair out of her face again.
Hesitantly he reached up and pulled her hair bow out, sweeping her bangs back from her forehead and pinning it back in its place. He wanted so badly to tell her that things would be okay, that she wasn’t in the place she used to be where the adults were mean and hurt each other and her.
Billy wanted to tell her that she could join their family; that being two men they were okay with being a little different; that he and Steve had seen crazy things that no one would believe, things they still didn’t know how to talk about or address, so it was okay not to have the words sometimes. That neither of them would punish her for that.
Opal reached up and touched the bow he’d placed gently in her hair, and he brushed the back of his hand tenderly across her cheek. The smile formed softly on his lips, but he didn’t have the courage say those words trapped in his heart.
Maybe it was because he didn’t want her to get her hopes up, maybe he was afraid for his own. How was he even supposed to know if she wanted them? At her age, he wanted Opal to choose them as well.
When he finally pushed himself up off the ground and surveyed the carnival to find Steve a few feet away with his hand on his hip giving the boys what seemed like a solid talking to, he felt a sense of relief wash over him.
He checked his watch, realizing that they weren’t far from the day being over and yet he still felt like everything was beginning for them. There hadn’t been enough time, enough yes or no questions to ask to learn what she was like, and he was reluctant to say goodbye.
As he sighed and stood up straight and took a step toward Steve to tell him to let the boys go, he felt something small and soft slide into his hand. When he glanced down, Opal was staring at his hand, studying the gold of his ring, her own hand nestled in his. Billy stood there, motionless, afraid that moving any further would break the gentle moment that she’d decided to reward him with.
She took her other hand and ran her fingers over Billy’s gold ring before raising her gaze to him. Then she turned to where Steve was and she pointed, head tilted in curiosity, dark eyes moving back to Billy’s face.
He felt himself nod slowly. “Yeah, Steve and I both have rings, we’re married,” he replied, simplifying their partnership for the sake of her understanding.
Opal of course said nothing, but blinked slowly as if processing the information. Her delicate long lashes fluttered and in this afternoon light, the faint freckles across the bridge of her nose were more visible.
“He’s my person,” Billy added, letting his gaze flit back to the fluffy haired brunette who waved the boys away after their lecture. His husband turned back to them, playfully shrugging his shoulders as if it couldn’t be helped.
Billy felt himself smirk before looking down at the young girl who in only a few hours had wormed her way into his heart. “He has a way of just knowing, of understanding, even when I don’t know myself.”
The last time something like that happened, he’d been gifted a fiery red-headed little sister. So perhaps that boded well for his future.
“Everyone needs people,” Billy’s voice was warm, and he wasn’t sure if he was talking to himself or to the child who had placed her hand in his, and he felt the weight of the gravity that came with that gesture. “Someone who understands us or tries their best even when they don’t. We all deserve that, Opal. People, a person, someone who is willing to try for us.”
He took a step toward Steve and felt the small hand squeeze his firmly. When he glanced down, Opal was staring ahead at Steve and he wondered if it was a trick of the sun preparing to set, but he was sure he noticed a sparkle in her eyes.
San Diego, California 2000
Spring
Steve was setting up their blanket on the sand, the wide square cloth fluttering in the cool springtime breeze while his husband and his daughter held hands and splashed in the shallow waves a few feet away. Of course, it was Billy’s nature to rush to the water whenever he was near, Opal following right after him quietly but just as eager.
The last few weeks had been overcast and both his blue-eyed boy and brown-eyed girl had been cooped up in the house since it was too chilly to go to the beach.
He often caught the two of them lying on the floor of her room, surrounded by a puddle of toys: dinosaurs and dolls and coloring books and little toy cars because “it’s almost the new fucking millennium Steve, our daughter should be able to play with cars.”
He'd walk in to tell them to wash up, that dinner was almost ready to find the two of them lying on their backs, window open and playing the sound of the ocean. He knew that it soothed Opal, when she had a fit and the tears flowed, and her mouth opened and closed like a little fish as only blubbering noises came out of it.
The psychologist they saw once every two weeks as a family told them that Opal’s selective mutism was a normal manifestation of her post traumatic stress, that there were chances she’d overcome it the longer she stayed in a stable environment, the safer she felt, but that they should prepare for a life where she never found the words.
And he knew Billy must have understood that, nodding silently beside him as Opal colored in the adjacent room with the assistant. Steve often wrapped an arm around his shoulder, or brushed his curls from his head, his lover giving him a tight-lipped smile, his ocean eyes stormy.
They didn’t talk much about Billy’s parallels to their child. Steve never asked him when he had started to feel safe, but he had a feeling that it was at the end of that summer back in Hawkins, after he’d died and come back and gotten kicked out of the only home he’d ever known, the one that was ironically more like prison.
It might have been when Hopper and Dr. Owens had helped set him up with a small ratty apartment near Main Street, and old ladies brought him baked goods because he was “such a hero to save all those kids in the mall fire”, or when the local mechanic offered to teach Billy how to fix cars and encouraged him to go to college if he liked “spendin’ so much time buried in all those books”, or maybe when he smiled at Steve with a warmth that the older boy had never seen as they waited at their cars to pick the kids up from the arcade.
Steve thought that was maybe when Billy shed his skin, the angry one he’d always worn as protective armor. He considered that “new” Billy, who was soft and invited Steve over to his apartment for cold beers on hot days, and how those hours spent talking and watching TV became quiet whispers and stolen kisses, which snowballed into breathless make out sessions and burning desire, until Steve said the words he never thought he’d say again.
He wondered, as he smoothed their blanket out and set down the cooler filled with their snacks, if Opal would shed her skin someday. When he raised his gaze, Billy had lifted her up and was dipping her in the water, pretending he’d drop her all the way. She clutched the stuffed bunny to her chest; the one Steve had picked out for her at the store when they were shopping for her bedroom furniture.
“Look!” he’d exclaimed, darting over, and pulling the stuffed white bunny with a bow around its neck off the shelf. “Think she’ll like it?” he’d asked, staring at the toy and second guessing himself. After the carnival and visits to her foster home and supervised outings, he wanted to give her something that felt like them.
Billy had rubbed the rabbit’s ear between his thumb and forefinger. “I think she’ll like anything her Papa gives her, pretty boy.”
It turned out that Opal and the rabbit, that they had affectionately deemed Mr. Bunny, were inseparable. He rode with them in the car on errands and slept next to her at night. Billy had to do his best to wash the rabbit on the fastest cycle during bath time before Opal noticed he was gone. He even accompanied her to the beach.
“Come on you two, I know it’s sort of cloudy but you still need sunscreen!” Steve called after them from his spot on the blanket. When Billy turned around, his smile matched their daughter’s and Steve thought that he’d never get tired of the sight.
The first time Opal had smiled up at him, he thought he would nearly cry. They had been at the grocery store and an older woman had dropped some coins from her purse. Opal had walked over, picking them up easily and presented them to the woman with both hands. She took the coins and patted Opal on the head, thanking her.
“What a sweet girl,” the woman cooed down at her. She glanced to Steve and smiled, “Your daddy must be so proud of you!”
The little girl, with a halo of chocolate curls turned back to him, lips pressed together in a shy little grin. She nodded and stepped back, taking Steve’s hand in hers. He squeezed it tightly and nodded to the woman, his voice trapped in his throat. “Very proud,” he finally managed, his voice nearly a whisper.
As the old woman began to walk away, Steve crouched to his knees and wrapped Opal in a hug. He knew that she was still adjusting to prolonged touch, but he did his best to make it brief before stroking the curls that reminded him so much of Billy as he gazed into her eyes, cupping her cherub cheeks in his palms. “You know I love you right? Papa loves you so much.”
Opal nodded her head, brows slightly raised as if she was somewhat surprised by his display of affection in the middle of the grocery store. She smiled at him tenderly, and raised her hand, making the sign for I love you, waving it back and forth just slightly.
It was one of the first signs that they’d all learned together and practiced every night before bed. She had been improving drastically with practice and was even able to sign her full name with some patience: Opal Harrington.
Opal came running toward him from the waves, standing on the blanket, granules of sand covering her little feet and Billy plopped down on the blanket beside him, his oversized knit sweater falling off one shoulder.
He had Mr. Bunny in his hand and set the rabbit gently away from the sand. “Come on Papa, you’re killing the vibe,” he groaned, snagging Steve’s sunglasses off his head.
He rolled his eyes and grabbed the tube of sunscreen from their bag, uncapping it and squeezing a bit into his hand. “UV rays are not a joke baby. You’ve got to protect yourself even when there’s clouds out. That’s how they get you. Come here Opie,” he rubbed the sunscreen between his fingers and motioned for his daughter to come closer.
She stood between his legs and closed her eyes, presenting her face to him as he smeared the solution across her cheeks and her nose. It smelled like coconuts and made him think of warmer days, where the sun beat down harshly on the pool in Hawkins and he tried to convince the kids to go there every day. Maybe looking back, it was because he’d had a thing for the blonde lifeguard all along.
“Do Daddy next Opie,” Billy smirked, raising his sunglasses. She grinned at him and held her hands out to Steve and he squirted some of the formula into her tiny palms. Opal leaned over and rubbed them against Billy’s cheeks as Steve did his own face.
“Oh man that’s cold!” Billy exaggerated, scrunching his face up as she massaged the cream in and rubbed her small fingers down the bridge of his nose. Her shoulders bounced with a quiet giggle and Steve laughed to himself before taking what was left on his hands and lifting her hair to get the back of her neck and around her collarbone that poked from beneath the long sleeve striped shirt she wore.
Once they were done with sunscreen, Steve began unpacking their snacks, peeling oranges, and opening cheese sticks as Opal munched and pranced around, kicking up sand with her feet. Eventually she unearthed her pail and shovel and stood up quietly, brushing cracker crumbs off her shirt. She walked over to the shoreline, Mr. Bunny tucked under her arm.
Steve leaned back, legs stretched out on the blanket and watched her as she remained focused, scooping wet sand around and watching it plop into the oncoming waves. Mr. Bunny supervised from his spot under her arm, close to her chest, the fluff of his little tail getting wetter each time the waves kissed the shore.
“I don’t know why you wanted to come to the beach today so badly,” Steve spoke softly, taking in the form of his lover stretched on the blanket next to him. “It’s not really even that sunny today.”
Billy wore one of Steve’s large knit sweaters and a pair of tennis shorts, warm from the cool breeze and thick clouds that passed the sky. Steve bit his tongue, wanting to make a joke about how preppy his hair metal husband had seemed to get over the years. Billy wiggled his sandy feet and tilted his head back, closing his eyes.
He took a deep breath and sighed. “I hate the winter,” he eventually breathed towards the vast blue. A few birds flew overhead. “You’re trapped indoors, like an animal in a cage. Just pacing, looking for a way out.”
Steve watched his Adam’s apple bob as he spoke, longing to steal a kiss at his throat. “Feel too big for my skin. Out here the world can accommodate what I can’t handle. I can spread out all the things that I fold in on myself. There’s room here,” he took a deep breath and opened his blue, blue eyes to take in his lover. “I can breathe.”
Steve pulled the sunglasses gently from where they were tangled in Billy’s curls, and he set them down on the sandy blanket. Leaning over, he pressed his lips to Billy’s for a moment, just long enough to be comforting.
When Billy sat back up, he moved closer, resting his head on Steve’s shoulder as the brunette pulled his legs to his chest. “You think Opie feels the same way?” he whispered as his gaze fell back to the curly haired girl who was flinging scoops of sand into the water.
Steve felt his lover nod. “Can’t say for sure, but I’ve felt that way since I was a kid. Think my mom knew. That’s why we spent so much time at the beach. It was easy to forget here, to catch a tall wave or find a cool shell. I think she felt like she could breathe here too when things got to be too much.”
Steve bobbed his head in understanding, watching as Opal stood and flung clumps of sand as far as she could. She seemed entertained just doing that and he wondered if she breathed better here. Not for the first time was he glad that he’d followed that denim clad blonde with a mullet all the way to the sunny shores of San Diego all those years ago.
“I told Opie that her granny lives here,” Billy’s voice was soft, and Steve turned, feeling his curls brush against his jaw. “Her mom too. That they’re in the ocean, so whenever she wants to be close to them, we can come to the beach.”
Steve took a breath and closed his eyes, taking in the scent of Billy’s hair, picking up on the coconut sunscreen. “You think your mom would have liked her?”
Billy laughed and raised his head, eyes crinkling in the corners were his smile met them. “She would have loved Opal,” he remarked confidently. “She would have loved you too Stevie. She loved it when I was happy, and I can’t think of anything that makes me happier than you two.”
Before Steve could reply, they heard a shrill scream bounce across the sky and looked up to find Opal on her knees in the shallow water, pulling on Mr. Bunny’s arm as a large dog pulled on the rest of the stuffed rabbit between his teeth. The dog yanked the toy, shaking its head back and forth in what it thought was likely a game, as Opal did her best to hold onto the rabbit’s arm.
“Shit,” Billy exclaimed, pushing himself from the blanket. Steve jumped to his feet and the two of them sprinted over just as Opal fell back onto the wet sand, the severed rabbit arm clutched between her tiny fists.
The dog pranced off toward the water, shaking the rabbit’s torso, cotton stuffing falling into the oncoming waves. Billy dove to the sand and wrapped Opal in his arms as she shrieked, tears running down her face. Steve turned his attention on the dog as a man jogged over and whistled between his fingers.
“Are you serious!” Steve snapped as the man’s dog ran over to him. The dog shook wildly, spraying water and stuffed rabbit entrails between them. “That was my daughter’s favorite stuffed animal.”
“I’m sorry man,” the dog owner apologized. “I’m so sorry. Percy is usually really good with kids. I think he must have thought she was playing with some kind of toy.” He whistled and the dog stopped, staring at attention and the man crouched down. “No Percy, bad dog,” he reprimanded.
Steve still heard wailing and glanced over his shoulder to find Billy bouncing an inconsolable Opal on his hip. He tucked her head under his chin as he rocked her and rubbed her back, glaring over the top of her head at where Steve was standing with the dog owner, his blue eyes icy with a glare that said, I’ll kill him.
“Just, please, don’t let him tear any fucking more of it,” Steve’s tone was sharp as the man pulled on the stuffed rabbit from the dog that still seemed to think they were playing a game. “And maybe keep your dog on a leash over here. The dog beach is like another two miles down.”
“Yeah man, totally. I’m really sorry,” he knit his brows together apologetically once more before pulling on the rabbit. “Percy, drop it!” he commanded.
The dog suddenly choosing that exact moment to listen to its owner, dropped what remained of Mr. Bunny onto the ground. Sand granules stuck to the dog’s slobber, coating the stuffed toy in a fine layer. “Jesus,” Steve murmured to himself as he reached over and picked up the rabbit.
The man echoed another apology and Steve waved him away with his dog. “Seriously, get out of here because if my husband gets his hands on you then you’re fucking dead.”
The guy raised his brows abruptly and scurried in the opposite direction as Steve did his best to dislodge the debris from Mr. Bunny’s cream-colored fur. He had anticipated having to get the ocean water smell and sand out of Mr. Bunny in the wash that evening, but dog saliva and a ripped arm was definitely not something he’d predicted.
Steve did his best to clean the rabbit up and put what was left of its stuffing back in his body. For the most part, the tear was pretty clean. With some added stuffing and a needle and thread it would probably be fine. Steve thought of the best way to explain this to Opal, as he approached, but when he came upon his lover and child, both were crying.
“Jesus Christ, what’s wrong? What happened?” he glanced frantically between the two of them, crocodile tears still flowing from Opal’s glassy brown eyes and across her ruddy cheeks. Billy looking as though he was laughing between sobs. “What happened?”
Billy chuckled and Steve must have looked at him like he was crazy because he sniffed and wiped his face with his sleeve before rubbing the fabric across Opal’s face, her lashes clumping together and snot smearing across her nose. Billy snickered again and Steve felt like he had truly lost it.
His lover kissed their daughter’s temple before resting his forehead against her. “Can you tell Papa what happened, just like what you told me?” his voice was gentle but hesitant. “It’s okay.”
Steve scanned his daughter’s face, cheeks tinged pink and nose snotty as she pushed her damp curls out of her face, the corners of her mouth downturned like when she pouted. She sniffed, shoulders shaking as more tears came and she opened her mouth.
“P-Papa sa-saved,” she hiccupped, shoulders trembling. “Mr. B-Bunny,” her tears wet her lips and Steve felt the familiar prick behind his own eyes. Billy grinned at her; his blue eyes deeper than the waves that crashed at their feet. “Da-Daddy sa-saved O-Opie.”
“Yeah,” Steve felt himself breathe; the air knocked completely from his lungs as warm tears sliding across his cheeks. His heart swelled so large in his chest that he thought it would explode, and he gripped his sweater in a fist over that place as if that would soothe the ache. “Yeah, Daddy saved Opie,” his voice broke as he cried, and Billy chuckled as fresh tears streamed down his cheeks, magnifying his freckles.
Steve fell into them, wrapping his arms around Billy, with Opal in between. She continued to cry, mostly out of confusion they suspected, clutching the severed arm of Mr. Bunny to her chest. To see both of her dads cry like that must have shocked her, but Steve couldn’t think of any other way to respond to hearing that little voice for the first time.
“I’m so proud of you Opie,” Steve’s voice quivered as he lifted his head to kiss her hair. She snuffled and reached up, brushing the tears from his cheek, slowly calming down in Billy’s arms as he rocked her.
Steve stared into those big brown eyes that were still watery, and felt his smile meet with the tears in the corners of his own. Glancing up to Billy, who observed him with the same kind of shock, they shared a look agreeing not to say much more about her first words for fear of upsetting Opal any further.
“And Mr. Bunny is going to be okay,” he laughed, trying to come back to himself despite his heart pounding as he pulled Billy tighter. Steve wiped his eyes with the heel of his hand and stepped back, holding out the rest of Mr. Bunny that he’d secured.
Opal didn’t look convinced, and instead took a shuddery breath like she was preparing to cry all over again. “It’s okay Opie,” Billy soothed, bouncing her with his lips pressed to her temple. He stroked her curls back and scanned her face.
“Papa is a paramedic, remember?” he reminded her softly. She nodded her head reluctantly and took a calmer breath. “That means he saves people, right? So just like he saved Mr. Bunny, he’s going to stitch him up and have him back in no time. Isn’t that right Papa?” Billy raised a brow at him, blue eyes twinkling with joy.
Steve wiggled the rabbit at Opal with a grin. “Yup. Because Mr. Bunny needs a brave girl like Opie by his side, to fight for him and keep him safe.” She nodded slowly as if she understood and reached out to grab the other part of her stuffed toy. “Just like Daddy has Papa, and Papa has Daddy.”
He leaned forward, one hand squeezing Billy’s shoulder, and kissed his husband’s temple, pausing for a brief enough moment for Billy to exhale into his body, sharing the relief and joy, and thankfulness that swelled within each of them like the waves that roared a few feet away.
When he pulled back, Steve and Billy watched as their daughter squeezed the rabbit in her arms before looking between them with brown eyes that held profound warmth and all the feelings for which they had no words.
“And Daddy and Papa b-both got Opie,” she added.
Her voice was still small, even fragile, but her smile reflected theirs. And Steve knew that with time and the love he and Billy shared, the love that had helped them both find themselves, that voice might one day become just like the waves that crashed at their feet: an immeasurable crescendo.
