Actions

Work Header

The Color of Possibility

Chapter 4

Notes:

The amount of talking in this chapter is almost obscene, but... hopefully satisfying. One more to go!

Chapter Text

“Balin, why are you keeping our burglar from me?”

From under the couch, Bilbo grimaced. It was comforting to know that apparently Thorin was as much a victim in this conspiracy as he was, but he really could do with a bit of tact. More than a bit, really. How was he supposed to be king if he still couldn’t manage to be more diplomatic?

Balin froze in place for a moment, then sighed deeply. “Has Dáin been on his nonsense again?”

“Dáin has spoken of nothing except for repairs, and what preparations need to be made to move the settlement in Ered Luin,” Thorin replied, eyebrows raised. “Of what nonsense do you speak?”

That surprised Bilbo. Apparently despite his claims that he would set everything to rights, Dáin had been stopped at the door. What had Balin told him, to make Dáin take a step back?

Balin grimaced. “Oh, very well,” he said with an exasperated sigh. “Yes, we have been trying to keep the two of you from seeing each other.”

“Who is ‘we’?” Thorin asked. “And why?”

“There are those of us who believe that your charge into battle, your apologies, all of that, is proof that the dragon sickness has been purged from you, never to return again,” Balin began, rubbing his temples. “And then there are those of us who know that running toward your death is just instinct at this point.”

It was a sentiment Bilbo had a hard time disagreeing with, though he couldn’t see what that had to do with him.

“What are you trying to say?” Thorin asked, glancing in Bilbo’s direction.

“That I doubted whether or not you were truly well, and I wanted to make sure of it,” Balin explained, looking away. “Bilbo bore the brunt of your dragon sickness, and it was clear to all that you considered him part of your hoard. Separated from the gold, separated from Bilbo, would you get better? Would you get worse? Either would suggest that you weren’t fully well.”

Thorin nodded slowly, looking far calmer than Bilbo would have been under the circumstances. In the end, the entirety of the company had forgiven him, but half of them didn’t trust him, and Bilbo had just gotten caught up in the middle. Well, perhaps they’d been trying to protect him too, but that was incidental. When it came down to it, was a week enough time to judge Thorin’s stability? Was there any reason Bilbo hadn’t been allowed in on the secret? Or in some small part of Balin’s mind, had he thought that maybe every part of the hoard should be sent away for good, just to be safe?

“So, it was a test,” Thorin surmised, looking down at his hands as if remembering the horrors he had wrought with them.

“Yes,” Balin admitted, squaring his shoulders. “Though we also wanted to prevent Bilbo from being added back into your hoard. In hindsight, perhaps we were wrong about that, but if you need to be away from this place, away from the gold, I would not want you to force yourself to stay. You’ve done so much for your people, reclaimed the home the dragon stole so long ago. You’ve earned the right to rest, if you need it. Even though your condition hasn't changed, I would still suggest it.”

Thorin gave Balin a wan smile. “There’s still work to do before that day comes,” he pointed out, running a hand through his hair. “Work that might have been easier with Bilbo’s help.”

Even from under the couch, he looked unspeakably tired to Bilbo. How had Thorin looked so relaxed before? Had it been an act? Or was it impossible to work up the energy for worry or anger in the light of day when night was given over to guilt and fear?

“Fair point,” Balin allowed with a soft chuckle. “Though in what capacity? Unless Dáin told him, he still doesn’t know what you meant by giving him that mithril shirt.”

Thorin’s blush only added to Bilbo’s confusion.

“If I am allowed to see him now,” Thorin began with a meaningful look at Balin, “I will make that clear.”

“I shan't prevent it,” Balin agreed. “And I suspect it is already too late to try,” he added, glancing over at the couch, causing Bilbo to retreat further underneath even though he was completely invisible. “You have less than an hour until you’re needed elsewhere, do try to make the best of it.”

Balin’s footsteps receded, though Bilbo waited until his footsteps were no longer audible to remove the ring and wiggle out from under the couch.

There was an embarrassed silence following Balin’s departure. Despite the fact that they had a lot they needed to say to each other, now Bilbo couldn’t find the words. Thorin was right there, looking at him with an expression he couldn’t read. Should he apologize first? Was there anything he really needed to apologize for? Thorin hadn’t been avoiding him, after all. But did that mean he wasn’t angry?

Bilbo opened his mouth to speak, having no idea what he would say, when Thorin beat him to it.

“I imagined what I would say when I finally had the chance, and now none of the words feel adequate,” Thorin admitted, looking unusually vulnerable as he broke the silence. “I have lied, I have mistreated you, I have led you into terrible peril… and I am truly sorry for all of it. I still don’t know why you stayed for the battle instead of fleeing at the first opportunity, especially after how I treated you.” He bowed his head, as if expecting the executioner’s blade.

“Don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo insisted, crossing the room toward Thorin as if pulled by an invisible string, and Thorin immediately looked back up at him. “I was glad to share in your perils, and there is nothing to forgive. You were not yourself.” Though the contrition in Thorin’s voice helped. “You aren’t angry at me?”

“Angry?” Thorin let out a choked laugh. “For what? For saving my life? For trying to bring me to my senses? No, you have done nothing to earn my anger. If anyone has the right to be angry, it is you.”

“You aren’t angry that Dáin is calling you Thorin Bagginshield?” Bilbo asked, finally allowing himself a small smile.

Thorin snorted at that. “It is an honor to bear the name of Baggins, even if it is one I don’t deserve.”

Bilbo suddenly found it hard to breathe. Dwarves, he had to remind himself, did not have proper surnames, or at least not ones that they shared with the world. More than likely, Thorin just didn’t understand what he was saying.

“That reminds me,” Bilbo began, feeling the back of his neck warming with a blush. “Balin said something about what you intended by giving me this.” He tugged on a section of the mithril shirt, where it peeked out around the collar. “What did he mean?”

Now it was Thorin’s turn to redden and turn away. “Do you know much about mithril?” he asked.

“Well no, only that apparently it does in fact make it much harder for orcs to stab you,” Bilbo joked, though Thorin did not laugh.

“It was the source of the wealth of Khazad-dum, the great kingdom of Durin,” Thorin explained. “After that kingdom was taken by Durin’s Bane, there was no other source for mithril in all of Middle Earth, and even when it was relatively plentiful it was highly prized. As a result, after the Arkenstone, that shirt is probably the most valuable thing under the mountain.”

The mostly healed bruise on Bilbo’s back throbbed. “And you gave it to me.”

Thorin nodded. “And I gave it to you, at a time when I feared being robbed by my own kin. Balin and the others all knew what it meant, even if I lost the courage to say so when you did not seem to understand. And I am certain that when Dáin heard of it, and that you used the shirt to save me, he drew his own conclusions.”

“Thorin,” Bilbo said, his heart pounding in his chest. “Did you, according to some bizarre dwarven custom, propose to me?” Even saying it sounded ridiculous, but Thorin seemed to be dancing around the subject. What other meaning could such a gift really have?

“I did,” Thorin agreed, finally meeting his eyes again. His gaze was steady, but hard to read. He wasn’t overflowing with love, or aching with regret. Thorin was just watching and waiting to see what Bilbo would do, with the caution of someone trying to approach a wild animal.

“And did I, by accepting it, agree?” Bilbo asked.

“You did, though I would not hold you to-” Thorin began, but Bilbo put up a hand to interrupt him.

“And did I, by throwing myself in the way of a blade meant for you and showing the shirt to everyone who hadn’t known about it, tell all of the dwarves of the Iron Hills that I had agreed?” His voice cracked near the end of the sentence. Whatever his feelings might be, this is not how he would have chosen to become engaged. Where were their damned contracts now, where every detail was neatly written out and enumerated? Or was that something to be saved for the wedding night?

“You implied it, but I haven’t made an official announcement,” Thorin replied firmly. “I told Dáin to ensure you were treated as kin, but I gave him no details. It remains little more than a juicy rumor. One that I do not expect you to honor, and that Balin did not want you to know about. You would have been able to leave with fewer complications.”

“He didn’t want me to know that I’m engaged to you?!” What was worse, Thorin looked remarkably okay with that. Resigned at least, his expression still far too guarded. That wasn’t helpful at all!

“As I said-”

“Thorin!” At some point, Thorin had gotten up from his desk, and between that and Bilbo’s unconscious approach, they were nearly touching. It was distracting in a pleasant sort of way, but there was one thing Bilbo needed to know before deciding if letting Thorin distract him was okay. “Did you mean it?”

Thorin started. “What?”

“Did you mean it?” Bilbo repeated, a little more slowly. “Would you do it again?”

“Of course,” Thorin replied, eyes wide as if surprised that Bilbo would doubt his intentions. “I love you. I would ask as many times as I had to, though it might be hard to find something as valuable to give for a second proposal.” He smiled self-deprecatingly.

Bilbo’s breath caught, his heart pounding almost painfully. He said it so easily, the dumb dwarf. He didn’t have years of hobbity restraint to fight through, didn’t have to tell himself that it was okay to want something that wouldn’t make sense to his neighbors. Though Thorin too now bore the name of Baggins, it didn’t weigh him down. Not in the way ‘Oakenshield’ had. It made Bilbo want to be just as honest, no matter what it might cost him. His respectability was already torn to shreds, so it hardly mattered what he said or did now. Following his heart and running out of Bag End had been a sound decision. It was obvious then that he should follow his heart more often.

“Then, I see no reason to change my answer,” Bilbo told him matter-of-factly, though he felt his cheeks warm. “Though you’re going to have to explain such things to me in a timely manner from now on. I don’t want to find out from Dáin that we got married without my knowing.”

“Bilbo…” Thorin stared at him with so much wonder, as if he couldn’t believe his own eyes and ears. Maybe he couldn’t. They had betrayed him before, after all.

“I… love you, Thorin,” Bilbo finally admitted. “If you didn’t want to see me again, I was going to try to just be glad you’re alive and well-”

“Only because of you, my brave, loyal hobbit,” Thorin interrupted, smiling warmly.

Bilbo had always felt that Thorin’s smile, when turned up to full intensity like it was now, was like looking into the sun. He couldn’t look away, but looking directly at it was almost painful. It was no wonder then that his eyes, such a piercing pale blue, had always reminded him of the sky. ‘The color of possibility,’ the unnamed poet had written, and Bilbo found himself agreeing. There were thousands of possibilities suggested in those eyes, an adventure all their own. An adventure he’d run out of Bag End in search of, if he was being completely honest.

“You seem lost in thought,” Thorin observed, his smile undimmed.

“I was just thinking of a poem, from a book Balin gave me,” Bilbo admitted. “The second verse seems written for you.”

“Tell me,” Thorin said, almost an order. After a look from Bilbo, he added, “Please.”

“The unknown cloudless sky,
Like pale sapphires
The color of possibility.”

Surprisingly, Thorin gave a short laugh. “It was written for me. My father wrote that poem for my birth,” he admitted. “He always said that my eyes were ‘mingalaz,’ that is, of the sky. A strange thing for a dwarf.”

Bilbo started. “Your father wrote that? And wait, Thorin, did you just teach me something in khuzdul?”

“My consort can’t be ignorant of our language,” Thorin pointed out, toying with one of Bilbo’s curls. “And I know you’ve been curious to learn.”

His thoughts stuttered to a halt. It had slipped his mind that marrying Thorin meant marrying a king. The raven crown, a familiar sight during Thorin’s sickness, sat on the desk, and he had not been wearing it when Bilbo had encountered him in the hall. It must sit heavily on his head, a reminder of the dragon sickness he shared with his grandfather. But then, being Thorin’s consort would just mean helping and supporting him as he tried to carry that weight. He could do that, couldn’t he?

“Bilbo?” Thorin was watching him curiously, his head at a slight tilt, almost reminding Bilbo of the ravens.

Bilbo shook his head lightly to clear it. He could do it. There were all sorts of things they would have to work out, but they could be left for later. “You’re going to leave dealing with the elves to me, aren’t you?”

“As you wish,” Thorin replied with a smirk, as if it had been Bilbo’s idea.

“Well I can’t leave it to you, now can I?” Bilbo asked, pulling Thorin’s head down by his thick braids and lightly tapping their foreheads together as he’d seen the other dwarves do with each other, noticing the way Thorin’s breath hitched. “I saw you lollygagging and dillydallying on your way to meet Thranduil, remember.”

“Only because I heard Dáin and Balin shouting the day before, and when neither of them would speak to me of it, I suspected foul play,” Thorin argued, leaning into the gesture so that their noses touched. It was definitely more intimate than Bilbo had expected, realizing only then that he was probably being incredibly forward. Not that Thorin seemed to mind.

“What does that have to do with dawdling on your way to meet Thranduil?” Bilbo pointed out, Thorin’s scent filling his nose and leaving him breathless. Maybe he shouldn’t have gotten so close. It was hard to think straight, especially now that everything was out in the open.

“I hoped I might see you,” Thorin admitted, his eyes half-lidded. “And then decide if Balin was right, and you really didn’t want to see me.”

And they had seen each other, if only for a moment. That moment had convinced Bilbo to take action, had led to where they stood now, Thorin’s braids wrapped around his hands like reins. Not that Thorin seemed to mind, and something about them had always fascinated Bilbo.

“What did you decide?” Bilbo asked. His tongue felt thick and sluggish in his mouth. Did he really want to hear Thorin’s answer? He was too warm, his skin feeling too sensitive. Even the light touch of Thorin’s breath against his face sent heat flooding through him.

“That Balin might just be wrong,” Thorin replied, his voice barely more than a murmur. “I bribed Nori to get everyone out of the way, and Dwalin to let you in if you tried to come.”

Even with his thoughts muddled, Bilbo had no trouble believing that Nori had played all sides of the fence. He was just glad he hadn’t been forced to pay the tricky thief for the pleasure. He was the only one in this with no share of the treasure after all. What did he have to offer?

The heavy bells that announced the hour clanged somewhere in the deep, reminding Bilbo that he should check on Fíli and Kíli, and Thorin likely had responsibilities he was neglecting. But it was so hard to move with Thorin’s glazed eyes staring at him so intently. They had been through so much, hadn’t they? Would a little indulgence be so wrong?

It wasn’t so easy to defeat the Baggins in him. “I have to tend to Fíli and Kíli,” Bilbo admitted, unwinding Thorin’s braids from his fists but struggling to take his hands off that broad chest.

There was no disappointment in Thorin’s expression at those words, only a softening of the corner of his eyes. “Let me accompany you,” Thorin suggested. “I have never been able to see them before nightfall.”

Bilbo started, remembering something. “When I saw you before, you looked so relaxed. I wondered how that could be, with Fíli and Kíli barely hanging on to life.”

“I knew they were in your care,” Thorin admitted. “And you would not give up on them, even if everyone else did. I should know. I am afraid for them, and they are always my first concern at the end of the day, but there is nothing my worry can do for them that you can not. To do my duty to my people, I must trust that you will do everything you can, and try not to think about it until my tasks are done.”

It took some doing to fully separate, especially after that little admission. Neither of them really wanted to, having spent so long within arms reach before without stepping any closer, but they could hardly go out into the hall glued together. Or maybe they could, Bilbo mused as he led the way, Thorin just behind him. Their presence together already attracted attention, and more than once the bows to Thorin covered whispers of the word ‘Bagginshield.’ If they had been openly affectionate, the Iron Hills dwarves just wouldn’t have bothered whispering, he suspected. If they encountered Dáin, he certainly wouldn’t.

Tauriel was waiting in the infirmary, looking a little unsure of what to do when they entered. Thorin stiffened behind Bilbo, apparently unaware that his nephews were regularly visited by elves, but what did he expect really? Tauriel had been the one to protect Kíli when he had fallen, the one to carry him back into the mountain when it was discovered that he was still breathing. She wasn’t likely to just leave after that.

“Any news?” Bilbo asked, a little more cheerfully than necessary, with a subtle jab to Thorin’s ribs.

Tauriel hesitated. “I believe… Fíli may have opened his eyes for a moment.”

“Really?” When Bilbo reached Fíli, the dwarf was as silent as always. Thorin was already filling a goblet with water for his nephew, though he drank with no more animation than usual.

Tauriel nodded. “Kíli made a sound, and Fíli turned toward him. His eyes flickered open, just for an instant, before turning back and closing them again.”

Thorin snorted, smoothing a section of Fíli’s hair. “How like him, to only hear his brother in pain, even as he lies unconscious.”

But it was something. A small something perhaps, but Bilbo wasn’t one to discount the value of small somethings. Especially as he mopped Fíli’s brow and found Thorin’s hand settling over his.