Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Straight A's

Summary:

Billy Hargrove is a straight A student.

AP classes, extra credit, nose-down-in-the-library kind of student.

Come to think of it, Steve doesn’t have a single class with Billy. It’s nothing he’s ever really examined, considering Billy has been a Professional Dick since coming to Hawkins (and maybe even before then), but it’s just… interesting. Yeah. That’s it. That’s the only reason Steve is thinking about Billy being… smart.

It’s just odd, ok? Some brain fodder in Steve’s (thankfully) boring life.

Notes:

new year, new me?

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Billy Hargrove is a straight A student.

AP classes, extra credit, nose-down-in-the-library kind of student.

Steve finds out when he’s waiting outside of Nancy’s AP Eng Lit class. The pile of students coming out are people who’ve never given him the time of day, which isn’t offensive at all, because Steve is a C’s get degrees kind of student, and when Nancy isn’t in the throng, Steve pokes his head into the classroom, curious.

Nancy and Billy are standing at the same table. She’s handing him a book with a small smile, and he takes it, cool and collected and a little bit gruff, putting it into his book bag.

Now… realistically, Steve knows that Billy has to at least get decent grades, or else he’d be kicked off of the basketball team. But to see him in an AP setting is a little jarring. Then again, it’s not like they’re besties. Steve doesn’t really pay attention to anyone outside of his immediate circle, which includes his ex-girlfriend, her new boyfriend, and a gaggle of middle schoolers. That doesn’t even take into account the one time Billy almost fucking killed him by beating him into the ground, or almost killed Lucas by throwing his pre-pubescent body around like a sack of potatoes.

So… yeah. Steve is legitimately shocked to see Billy fucking Hargrove borrowing a book from Nancy, an expression of contrition on his face when in the light of Nancy Wheeler’s friendly, almost maternal smile.

He ducks out of the classroom before either of them can see him, confused as fuck. Since Max almost castrated Billy with Steve’s bat, Billy hasn’t really been around much. He’s kept to himself, been quiet. Even on the team he’s been an actual team player instead of just an asshole on the court. Shit, he’s even passing the ball to other players instead of hogging it to look like a hot shot.

Billy Hargrove has been humbled.

And is, apparently, a straight A student.

Steve hangs out against the lockers opposite of the classroom door, trying to act casual, one hand holding the strap of his backpack against his chest, the other hand slipped into the pocket of his jeans. When Nancy comes out she greets him with a friendly smile, and then Billy’s slipping out of the classroom, obviously trying to be invisible to Steve. His blue eyes are on the ground, and Steve tries to think about when the last time they made eye contact was.

Definitely in the driveway of the Wheeler’s, when Billy had tried to put him six feet under.

“Hi!” Nancy greets.

“Billy’s in AP?” Steve asks.

“Hello,” Nancy greets herself back with an eye roll. “Yeah. Why?”

Steve looks at the crowd of students, Billy gone by now. “Just… seems a little weird.”

“Why?” Nancy asks, adjusting her book bag. He wonders why she even uses it when she has three books clasped in her arm and pressed against her breast.

Shaking his head, Steve shrugs, and then sends her a smile. “Never mind. Tonight you’re gonna show Jonathan how to bake no-bakes, right?”

Nancy snorts. “You don’t bake no-bakes.”

Steve scoffs. “Right! So, we gotta go to the store and get…”

--

The next time Steve sees Billy is when Billy is leaving AP Biology. Come to think of it, Steve doesn’t have a single class with Billy. It’s nothing he’s ever really examined, considering Billy has been a Professional Dick since coming to Hawkins (and maybe even before then), but it’s just… interesting. Yeah. That’s it. That’s the only reason Steve is thinking about Billy being… smart.

It’s just odd, ok? Some brain fodder in Steve’s (thankfully) boring life.

The stupid macho side of Steve that he’s been trying to destroy since Nancy dumped him is convinced that he, too, could be in AP classes if he actually tried. But one day he uses a hall pass to use the bathroom and instead sits outside AP Biology, listening to the teacher, and realizes… fuck, he has no idea what the fuck this guy is saying. It’s gotta be another language. He gets so lost in listening, and just trying to decipher, that he startles when he hears Billy answer a question.

Out loud.

Like he raised his hand patiently and had the answer at the ready.

And then he hears the teacher compliment and praise Billy and- what the fuck.

In the next moment the bell rings and Steve jumps away from the door like it’s on fire. The wooden hall pass dangles from his wrist on its string and slaps against his thigh with a flat sound, and then the door to AP Biology opens and students start flooding out. Lost in the crowd, Steve backs up until he hits the lockers, and no one even looks at him. How far he has fallen from the throne. Now he’s just some idiot like the rest of the students, no more King Steve, and-

He’s really gotta stop thinking like that. Nancy’s voice in his head says it was never about being popular, Steve. You were looking for validation in what you lacked in attention from your parents and he thinks Nancy should be a fucking shrink, not a journalist. Anyway, students filter around him like he’s just Joe Schmoe, and just like the other day, Billy’s the last to leave the class. Steve can see, through all the frizzy heads piling out of the room, Billy talking in soft tones with the teacher. It looks like he’s handed an extra credit assignment. Billy puts it in his bag and then exits the classroom and by now, there’s no crowd in the hallway, so he sees Steve immediately.

Steve, pressed up against the lockers like a goddamn idiot, lips slightly gawped, eyes full of surprise. He’s a gaping idiot. He expects Billy to sneer, to say something sharp and stinging, to mock him for stalking him, maybe… but Billy cuts that ice blue gaze away and heads down the hallway.

It’s then that Steve notices the lack of confidence in his walk. Billy Hargrove doesn’t walk, he struts. Saunters, even. Moves with the liquid grace of a big jungle cat, and incites fear like one. Puts people on edge immediately, grabs attention. Sly smirks and hooded eyes, lashes thick and lower lip always slightly red from being bitten between his pretty teeth, and-

Woah.

Woah.

Not pretty teeth. Objectively nice teeth, straight and white.

Right.

Anyway, Steve doesn’t see any of that anymore. Billy’s a shell of what he used to be, pretty on the outside with nothing inside.

It… It makes Steve’s gut squirm a little bit uncomfortably.

The hall pass smacks against the locker he’s leaning against, and he realizes with a start he needs to return it to the class he ditched.

--

Billy Hargrove is a straight A student and absolutely invading Steve’s thoughts.

It’s not like he misses being harassed or used as a punching bag, ok? He doesn’t. But there was an odd familiarity in Billy’s poking and prodding, something that helped Steve stand straighter and like, defend his turf or whatever. But King Steve has been kicked off his throne and Hawkins High is now a democracy and no royalty exists anymore. Which isn’t a problem, he assures Nancy every time she tries to psychoanalyze him. He’s totally fine. It’s not like being King Steve was all he had to offer to the world, ok? It’s not like King Steve was the only part of his personality that drew people toward him and offered him advantages that the average person didn’t get. It’s not like King Steve, trust fund boy extraordinaire, didn’t have any other defining characteristics.

It was when King Steve was dethroned that Steve Harrington could really shine. Y’know, as like, a really fucking good babysitter.

And…

Well. Not much else.

Because Steve Harrington got straight C’s all across the board and isn’t exactly the brightest bulb in the pack, but he’s got a heart of gold and isn’t a coward.

Right?

That’s what he’s learned with all this freaky deaky Upside Down shit, anyway.

But there was a certain… spice that Billy added to King Steve’s stupid fucking life, and now Billy doesn’t touch Steve Harrington, and it’s just… weird.

Not that Steve’s ever looking for a fight, no- he’s learned that he’s no good when it comes to humans.

Seeing the shell of Billy Hargrove in the hallways must be just as jarring as seeing the shell of King Steve.

So maybe they’re more alike than Steve originally gave them credit for.

And ain’t that a fucking revelation.

--

A backpack hits the table next to Steve. The library is quiet this time of day and Steve isn’t studying so much as just looking for a quiet place to not be bombarded by middle schoolers or his judgy-but-well-intentioned ex. He barely has time to react before Billy straight A Hargrove is taking up the chair next to him, silent and broody. He pulls his things out of his book bag; a spiral notebook, an AP Lit book, a pen, and a book titled Of Mice And Men.

Steve stares.

Billy doesn’t. He just opens both of his books, turns to a blank page in his notebook, and starts… reading.

Steve shifts a little, uncomfortable. He’s got a book for his own English class in front of him, but he hadn’t really been reading it. Just was using it as a prop so the librarian didn’t bother him. But Billy seems to be actually… working. And ignoring Steve, despite choosing to sit right next to him.

“Um-” Steve starts.

Billy cuts those icy blue eyes to him, looking at Steve through thick, dark lashes.

Steve shuts up.

Billy returns to his book.

Unsure, and unable to think of anything fucking else, Steve looks down at his book, and then decides to actually… read.

Imagine that.

An hour later Billy gathers his things and gets up without a word, leaving the library.

Steve’s stunned to notice that he’d read quite a few chapters of his book (he’s a slow reader) and actually… retained the information.

Huh.

--

It becomes a thing. Wednesdays after school, Billy and Steve sit at the same table in the library. They don’t talk. Billy does whatever Smart Things he has to do for his AP classes, and Steve trawls through whatever homework he initially was pretending to do. After a few weeks, Steve’s grades bump up to B’s. He’s getting good grades on his homework and his teachers are noticing. In one class Steve’s teacher compliments him verbally, aloud, in front of like, everyone. The girl that sits behind him--Rebecca? Rochelle?--snorts, and Steve blushes so hard he thinks he’s gonna pass out.

His tests are still a little lacking.

So he takes a page out of Nancy’s book and makes some flash cards, but doing flash cards by yourself is kind of… not dumb, but probably not as effective. So one day he pushes his stack of flash cards toward Billy, who is sitting dutifully next to him with his nose buried in a book, and asks shyly, “Quiz me?”

It’s slow, the way Billy’s eyes break from his book to slide over to Steve. Every move Billy makes, ever, is always so… deliberate. There’s no clumsiness to be found. He’s an odd sort of graceful, elegant Steve’s newly thesaurus-trained brain thinks. Those pretty blue eyes lock Steve down, and then look down at the pile of flash cards. Billy’s expression stays rather neutral, but those eyes go through maybe a dozen different emotions, twitching at the corners. It’s kind of an unspoken agreement (ha) that they don’t talk to each other, so he’s probably trying to figure out if Steve has well and truly lost it.

But then his hand reaches out, ringed fingers long and pretty, taking the stack of flash cards and flipping through them.

“These are shit,” is the first thing he says to Steve in almost three months.

Steve frowns. “What?”

Billy gestures, “They’re not color-coded. You won’t learn shit if they’re not color-coded.”

Steve stares down at his flash cards. Now that he thinks about it, Nancy’s had been color-coded. Even the handwriting on the cards had been different colors. Something about the brain being able to visually categorize things in the memory… something something.

“I’m not exactly artistic,” Steve bristles.

Billy rolls his eyes, opening up his bag. He pulls out a pack of five hi-lighters, all different colors, and then slides them over to Steve. “Just highlight the topics of the chapter and then use a different color to highlight the information below them.”

Staring at the hi-lighters, Steve glances at Billy for clarification, but the other boy is already back to reading. Hesitantly, Steve picks up the blue hi-lighter, thinking that it’s kinda cute that Billy just has organizational tools at the ready.

Well- no, not cute- just um. Quirky.

He hunkers down, working on color-coding his flash cards. It takes him a bit of time, and he finds that when he’s done, he’s actually retained a lot more information from them just by spending time making sure he’s coloring them correctly. Huh.

Fifteen minutes later, Billy packs up his things and leaves the table silently. Steve can’t help but grin, flipping through his flash cards.

He gets an A on his next test, and his teacher is so stunned she pins it up to the chalkboard for everyone to see for the rest of the period.

--

Shutting his locker, Steve nearly jumps out of his skin when Nancy is on the other side, hugging her books to her chest and frowning at him.

“Fucking Christ, Nance, put a bell on,” Steve grumbles, shouldering his bag. She doesn’t say anything, so he raises his eyebrows and gestures with a hand. “Somethin’ on your mind?”

“Billy Hargrove,” she says, primly.

Steve gives her a blank stare. “That’s a student at this school, yes.”

“You’re hanging out with him.”

Now Steve sends her a confused glance. “What? No I’m not.”

“I’ve seen you two in the library together,” she says, shifting on her feet.

“We- we’re not hanging out,” Steve says, affronted, but he can feel the tips of his ears burning. “He’s helping me study.” He fishes around in his bag for a moment, and then proudly shows Nancy the test he got an A on. “Say hello to the first A I’ve gotten in my entire fucking life. He told me to color-code my flash cards.”

Nancy sends him a bewildered look. “Steve, I’ve told you to color-code your flash cards.”

Shrugging a little, Steve puts his test back in his bag. “When a second person has the same advice as the first, I’m a little more inclined to follow.”

“Your best friend tells you how to study and you blow her off, and then your arch nemesis tells you how to study and suddenly you’re getting A’s?” She asks, incredulous.

“What’s wrong with that?” He asks, annoyed. “And he’s not my arch nemesis anymore. He’s kinda not anyone’s nemesis anymore. He’s like a kitten that got his claws removed.”

“You know how unstable he is,” Nancy whispers furiously. “I don’t think it’s smart for you to hang out with him, Steve.”

“I’m not hanging out with him, Nance. We study together in the very public library for an hour after school.”

“Every day?” Nancy presses.

“I haven’t had an issue so far,” Steve says, getting defensive and annoyed. “I think if he was gonna kill me he’da done it by now, Nance.”

“He’s right,” comes a slow drawl from behind Nancy. She spooks a little, clutching her books a little tighter to her chest and whipping around to glare at Billy. He sends her an amused look, “Steve’s a big boy, Miss Wheeler. He can make decisions on his own.” Leaning in a little, his unbuttoned shirt falling tantalizingly open, Billy’s blue eyes are cold as eyes as he stares Nancy down. “You lost the privilege of telling him what to do when you dumped him.”

Nancy’s jaw actually drops, her cheeks coloring. Steve isn’t quite sure what’s happening. Is Billy getting… territorial? Over Steve? What the fuck?

Nancy sends Steve a worried glance. He rolls his eyes a little, playing casual. “It’s fine, Nance. Really.”

Billy sets back on his heels, a smirk on his lips.

Incredibly, Nancy points a finger at Billy so quickly and so hard it actually collides with his sternum. Impressively, Billy rocks a little with it, arching his eyebrow and looking down at her. “If you do anything to him, it’s not your sister you have to worry about.” And then she stalks off, curly hair bouncing, skirt swishing.

Billy watches her go. Then, he leans against the lockers, folding his arms loosely over his chest and sending Steve a charming smile. “Did you pass your test?”

Oh. What a… weird interaction. Steve pulls his test out again, the paper crinkled at the edges. His smile is proud and a bit smug, “With flying colors.” He laughs at his little pun.

Billy takes the test, looking over the answers, blue eyes moving quick. After a moment, he hands it back. “You missed the extra credit question.”

“What?” Steve looks down at the test. He’d left the extra credit question blank. “Well, yeah. I didn’t need to do it. I knew I’d pass the test.”

There’s silence for a moment. Steve looks at Billy’s face, which is its usual cool, impassive mask, but again… his eyes. They’re cycling through what looks like a myriad of emotions. Then, he says softly, “You’ve got enough time to raise your grades up and get into a good college. You should do the extra credit.”

What the-? “I- I’ll be shocked if I graduate with higher than a 3.3 at this point, Hargrove. Why the hell would I be considering college?”

“You gonna show your folks your test?” Billy asks, leveling Steve’s gaze with his.

Steve feels like he got punched in the gut. Frowning down at his test, he doesn’t need to think before he says, “No.” Even though he got his first A ever, he’s not going to show his parents. They’re not even really around, anyway. Steve gets through school without truancy or flunking, and that’s all they care about. Steve had fantasized about college at one point, but then his dad mentioned working for him, and that had been… an easy way out, he guesses. Just have a job be handed to him when he’s eighteen, and fit into the mold of every other rich kid in Hawkins that uses nepotism to move around in the world. Steve’s changed a lot since he was fifteen, but there are some things that haven’t changed, and he hadn’t really thought about… making the effort.

“Right,” Billy says, pulling away from the lockers. He reaches out--Steve flinches--and pats him on the shoulder. It’s not mean or aggressive, but it’s not really sweet or friendly, either.

It tingles either way.

He leaves Steve standing next to his locker, staring down at his first great academic accomplishment.

What does Billy know that Steve doesn’t?

--

Steve knows through the grapevine, AKA putting together bits and pieces from Max, that Billy’s dad hurts him. Badly, and often. Maybe not recently, because Billy doesn’t show up to school with black eyes or split lips, things that the general populace thinks happen because he’s reckless and gets into fights, but Steve had always thought it was weird that Billy would get into fights before first period and then go through the whole day without getting in trouble. Also, there would never be another student wandering around looking like shit, and that was weird, because when Billy fights, he doesn’t lose.

Unless he’s tranquilized.

So Steve puts the pieces together and paints a rather ugly picture.

Billy’s comment about college made him think, too. Billy’s been “behaving”, more or less. Studious with his head down, not exactly friendly but also not an asshole. Steve’s not the sharpest tool in the shed, but he can figure out that the reason Billy’s working so hard to be the perfect student is so he can go to college and move away from this shit town and his shit dad.

What’s it say about Steve that Billy asked him about college? What the fuck does Billy think he knows about Steve’s life?

“You gonna show your folks your test?”

And Steve had answered so readily, it was illuminating, he’s sure. For both of them, probably. Steve is so fucking used to things behind handed to him, he never thought about making an effort in school, because he’s guaranteed a job when he gets out.

But what if…

What if all this effort pays off? What if he can get into a college? Move away from this Hell incarnate town?

The kids pop into his head. He can’t just leave them, not after everything they’ve been through. God, the guilt tears him up already.

He understands why Billy wants to leave, and he gets the appeal even just objectively.

But he can’t leave the kids.

Even though… the threat seems to be over. And they have El, anyway.

No. He can’t think like that.

But…

What if…?

--

The first time Billy kisses him it’s between World Geography and Ancient Literature, in the library. Billy had been looking for a book, and Steve got up to follow him to ask about a math question he had no idea about (seriously, shapes? Shapes in math?), and then Billy had Steve’s back pressed uncomfortably into the shelves, sealing his mouth over Steve’s.

He’s never thought about kissing another boy before. Like, ever. He’s not an idiot, he can tell when someone is attractive, and Billy definitely is that--like, in a major way--but he’s never thought about following through with a boy like he would a girl. And that’s not including the fact that Billy literally almost killed him once. But when Billy kisses him Steve doesn’t even hesitate to kiss him back, reaching up to grip the lapels of Billy’s stupid open shirt that totally breaks dress code. Billy’s hands are on his hips, their mouths sliding together, tongues pressing, and fuck, Steve’s already breathless. So used to being in control Steve gives it up surprisingly easily, letting Billy crowd him, kiss him silly.

When Billy pulls away they stare into each other’s eyes, breathless, cheeks flushed. Billy looks surprised at himself, or maybe at Steve, and Steve can only offer a small, crooked smile. He waits for Billy to hit him, call him a fag, but… it never comes. Instead, Billy bends to pick up the notebook Steve had dropped when he’d been kissed within an inch of his life, looking down at the geometry problem Steve had been struggling with.

He licks his lips, and it’s distracting.

Steve knows what those lips taste like. His heart is thundering. Billy seems calm, but he can see the vein in his jugular pounding against his skin.

“Y’ever build anything?” Billy says, like it’s totally normal they just made out in the school fucking library.

“Um- I mean, kinda?” Does building impermanent shelter to shield him and the kids from weird creatures count as building?

“Here,” Billy takes Steve’s wrist, leading him back to their table. He lets go once they’re in view of anyone else, sitting down. Steve follows dumbly, sitting down next to Billy, watching but not really able to pay attention as Billy grabs a pencil and starts drawing shapes and numbers and formulas on a blank page. Those hands had been on his waist, pinning him to the shelves--

Huh.

This is a development Steve had not been expecting at all.

“Harrington,” Billy drawls, tone slightly annoyed. Steve blinks back to the present, looking at Billy, who has a brow arched. He taps the paper with the tip of his pencil, “Pay attention, dumbass.”

Blushing, but laughing, Steve nods, not missing the tiniest of smiles that quirk Billy’s lips as he teaches Steve about math that has no business being this stupid.

He can’t stop thinking about Billy’s mouth, though. Especially that little smile.

He passes the math test with an A.

--

“I can help you study.”

Steve glances over at Nancy from where he’s standing in her kitchen, waiting for Dustin to come up from the basement. He sends her a quizzical look, “What?”

Nancy tucks her hair behind her ear, shrugging, trying to act nonchalant. She’s a great actor when she needs to be, but right now she’s a bit too nervous to pull it off. “At school. Or even here- we could keep an eye on the kids and study at the same time.”

Confused, Steve tries to work out why Nancy is suggesting they study together after their one botched attempt when they were dating. Since then he knows Nancy gets impatient with his slow train of thought, and she’s really freaking smart, but she’s not always the most patient person. Also she just… talks too much.

Billy is patient.

And quiet.

“Thanks, but uh. I think I got it covered.”

Her thin lips purse, brows narrowed as she pins him to the counter with her gaze. “You mean Billy has it covered?”

“He’s made a huge difference,” Steve says defensively. He’s not sure why he gets so defensive.

“Do you remember that he nearly killed you? And beat up a child?” Nancy presses.

“I’m obviously fine, and Billy’s apologized to Lucas in his own way.”

Nancy blinks. “He has?”

“Well,” Steve shrugs and rubs the back of his neck. “Max says that he takes her to and from the Sinclairs.”

“That’s an apology,” Nancy asks flatly.

“As best as you’ll get from Billy,” Steve reasons.

Nancy looks absolutely bewildered. “What is it with you two?”

“Nothing-” Ah, Steve’s voice is defensive again. He rolls his eyes and folds his arms loosely over his chest, trying to convey nonchalance. He’s not sure it’s working. “He’s just helping me study, and it’s working. I got my first A in math, like, ever, because of him.”

“I just think it’s weird that apparently he’s turned over this new leaf,” she says.

“Wouldn’t you if your kid sister almost castrated you with an apocalyptic bat?”

Now it’s Nancy’s turn to roll her eyes. “I just don’t think you should get too… comfortable.”

Steve tenses. “The fuck does that mean?”

“You’re just spending a lot of time together.”

“In the school library!”

“After hours.”

“You know,” Steve scoffs, pushing away from the counter, “you got a lotta nerve, Nance, trying to dictate my life after you nearly destroyed it.”

That shuts her up. It was mean, and he knows it, but she’s getting too close to the truth and Steve’s scared that the word queer is flashing like a beacon on his fucking forehead. She looks genuinely hurt, and Steve feels genuinely like a dick, but Nancy’s just too observant, y’know? Smart as fuck and Steve knows that if anyone can sense what’s going on with him and Billy (what is going on with him and Billy?) it’s gonna be her.

“Henderson!” Steve shouts down the basement steps.

“I’m comin’!”

“You said that five minutes ago!”

The sound of feet clomping up the stairs is music to Steve’s ears. Dustin comes up, weighed down by his backpack and all the tech junk he keeps in it, sending Steve a huge smile. “Ok, I’m ready.”

Rolling his eyes, he gently pushes Dustin’s shoulder to get him to head out of the kitchen. He sends a glance back to Nancy, who now looks disgruntled. “I’m fine, Nance. And Billy is, too. So just- don’t worry about it.”

He doesn’t give her a chance to say anything before he and Dustin leave the house.

Fuck, that was close.

--

Billy’s started parking his car next to Steve’s. They don’t really make a thing of it, but sometimes when Billy is leaning against the Camaro, smoking a cigarette before school, Steve joins him. They pass the smoke back and forth, but Billy does most of the puffing; Steve hasn’t really committed to smoking in a really long time. But it’s the meaning behind their brief time together before the bell rings, sharing a cig, tasting each other’s spit second hand, that matters.

Steve can feel Nancy’s eye on him almost all the time, now, but to suddenly stop hanging out with Billy like he has been would be more suspicious than continuing on.

“Nancy’s asking about us,” he says one morning. Billy’s leaning against the driver door of the Camaro, Steve across from him leaning against the passenger door of the Beamer. Their cars are parked probably closer than what’s safe, but it allows them to stand fairly close to each other without looking suspicious.

Billy arches a brow. He pulls the cig from his mouth, tongue darting out to chase the flavor from his lips. “And?”

Steve bristles a little. Billy doesn’t seem too bothered. “Just… she’s really smart. Observant.”

Smirking a little, Billy’s foot reaches out to kick Steve lightly in the shin. “You’re afraid of little Miss Wheeler goin’ all Nancy Drew?” His lashes lower a bit, eyes darkening, and it’s the first time Steve has seen that expression and realized that Billy’s eyes don’t convey malice, but a low, simmering arousal. “What, exactly, about us is she asking about?”

Steve turns his head to physically avoid looking at Billy, his gut squirming a bit. “Nothing specific, she just. Noticed we’re spending a lot of time together.”

“Not a lot of time,” Billy reasons, almost casually. “You spend more time with her and the brats than you do with me.”

Feeling his cheeks heat up, Steve shoves his hands into the pockets of his khakis. “At home, yeah. At school, it’s me n’ you.”

“You wanna change that?” Ah, there’s a bit of the threat, but oddly enough… Steve doesn’t feel as though it’s directed at him.

“Not really.”

“Ok, then,” Billy says simply.

Steve moves a hand to cover his face with it, then pinches the bridge of his nose. “I just- I mean, I don’t even know what to tell her.”

“If you didn’t have your panties in a twist, what would you tell her?”

Blinking, Steve drops his hand to look at Billy. He takes in the guarded expression, the slight line of tension in his shoulders. How his lips purse a little tighter around the filter of the cigarette. “Just… that we’ve gotten closer.”

Blue eyes regard Steve in a way that makes him feel fucking naked. After a longer pause than he’s comfortable with, Billy says, “Have we.”

Somehow Steve knows that was the wrong answer, but he’s scrambling to try and find the right one. “What would you say?”

A little sneer crosses Billy’s face, an expression Steve hasn’t seen in months. “I’d tell her I’m a fucking fag and she should mind her goddamn business.” He tosses the cigarette down to the ground, grinding it out with the toe of his boot. He makes to leave, but Steve reaches out and grabs his wrist. He whirls on the other boy, but it’s not violent, just agitated. “The fuck, Harrington.”

“I-” Steve’s panicking a little. “You’d- you’d actually tell someone that? About you- about us?”

“I didn’t say anything about you,” Billy says, yanking his wrist away. “I’m gonna ask you again, Harrington. What about us?”

The way Billy asks implies that there’s definitely a wrong answer, here, and Steve’s suddenly terrified to fuck up. Mouth agape, eyes wide, Steve searches Billy’s face for any indication of what the right answer is, but Billy’s got his old mask on. The one he’s slowly melted away over the past couple months while they’ve been hanging out together. It’s impossible to read him and Steve’s aching for the flashes of vulnerability, the real Billy that he’s been privileged to see, but honestly, he has no fucking clue what to say.

Billy takes his silence as an answer.

“Right.” The blond snorts an unamused laugh, turning his back to head toward the school. “Later, Harrington.”

Steve’s left standing between their cars, confused, hurt, and more mad at himself than he’s been in a long time.

--

They no longer meet in the library. Their eyes don’t catch in the halls. Billy doesn’t brush by him with secretive touches to Steve’s wrists, hips, where no one can see.

Steve’s grades slip, and he struggles to hold on. He’s back to B’s, which is better than before, because he actually retained information that Billy had helped him learn, but it’s still a dip.

He thinks about Billy talking about leaving Hawkins and going to college.

He thinks about how he, himself, started thinking about that, too.

He’d had Billy Hargove at the tips of his fingers, and he let him slip away, like the fucking dumbass he is.

--

Steve gets his final grades for the senior year and is shocked that he has a 3.6 GPA. Absolutely gobsmacked.

Then again, he'd started doing the extra-credit that Billy had suggested.

Billy’s valedictorian, beating out Nancy by a narrow margin.

On graduation day, Nancy makes the valedictorian speech, because Billy’s missing.

Steve tries not to worry about it. It’s hard, though, because the last time he saw Billy the other boy looked like he’d been hit by a train. Or at least lost a fight with one. His name is announced and the principal sets his diploma down on the table with the rest of the absent graduates, and at the end of the ceremony, Steve moves without thinking. He walks up to the table and smiles at the principal, tells him he knows Billy’s out with the flu today but he’ll take his diploma to him so it doesn’t have to be mailed. The principal lets him, because everyone trusts Steve Harrington.

When Steve goes to the Hargroves residence that evening, out of his hat and gown with Billy’s diploma tucked under his armpit, he’s not sure what he’s expecting. Billy’s dad answers the door, and Steve blinks, because… well. Billy doesn’t look a thing like his dad.

“Um- hi,” Steve says awkwardly. “I’m Steve, I go to school with Billy. Um… graduation was today, and I have his diploma.”

The man narrows his gaze at Steve and ah. That’s a family resemblance at least. “Steve. Harrington?”

“Uh, yes sir,” Steve starts to feel nervous. His palms get a little sweaty.

“Neil. I know your father.”

Oh, great. Who doesn’t know Steve’s dad. “Ah- um. Yeah. That’s me. His… son,” he says lamely.

“That Billy’s diploma?” Neil nods to the manila envelope currently suffocating in Steve’s rapidly warming armpit.

“Yeah-” Steve pulls it out. “He made the valedictorian list and um. I was looking forward to his speech today...”

Neil looks genuinely surprised as he takes the envelope. “Valedictorian?”

“Steve.”

Billy appears just behind his father’s shoulder, a stricken expression on his features. Holy shit, he looks awful. Like, should probably be recovering in a hospital, awful. Sallow skin, swollen bruises, poorly healed cuts and scrapes, and he looks… a little on the skinny side.

“You made valedictorian?” Neil inquires, turning to send a raised eyebrow to Billy.

Billy squares up a little, but he doesn’t meet his dad’s eyes. “Yes, sir.”

“Did you ask this young man to bring you your diploma?”

Blue eyes lift to send Steve a fiery glare, one with a message in them. Leave. “No, sir, I didn’t.”

Neil sends a smile to Steve that makes his stomach content curdle. “Well, thank you Steve. Go along now, I’m sure there’s a party you’re wanted at.”

The door slams in Steve’s face. His heart thuds, his gut falling to his feet. Holy fuck. He just saw something that he was never meant to see.

He barely resists running to his car and speeds the fuck out of there.

--

The next time he sees Billy, Steve’s been parked at Lover’s Lake for a few hours. Alone, chain smoking, lying on the hood of his car, back on his windshield and feet dangling by the bumper. The gravel crunches with the sound of someone’s arrival, but Lover’s Lake isn’t unpopular by any means, so Steve doesn’t really think much of it. But then that person climbs atop the hood of the Beamer as well, lies next to Steve, and he’s surprised, but also not, to see Billy.

Wordlessly, Steve hands him the cigarette. Billy looks almost fully healed, his pretty features in full bloom, but his nose might be a little… crooked. They smoke in silence for about ten minutes. Billy lifts a leg to drape it over Steve’s. A few minutes later, he shifts so they’re touching from shoulder to hip. Another few minutes later and Billy rolls over as best as he can, presses his face into Steve’s neck, and starts crying.

Unsure of what to do, Steve flicks the cigarette away and then shifts so he can wrap an arm around Billy and pull him closer.

“You f-fucking tell anyone about this, Harrington, a-and I’ll fuckin’ break your collarbones,” Billy threatens, but it’s a weak threat when it comes through snot and tears.

“I won’t tell anyone,” Steve assures.

He holds Billy through the worst of the emotional waves. When Billy’s tears and hiccups subside, and he’s pressed against Steve in a way that almost makes Steve forget about what a fucking dickhead he is, he speaks softly, voice thick from the cry.

“I got accepted into CalTech.”

“That some fancy school?”

Billy snorts a little. Steve’s neck is a little wet, and it’s kinda gross because he knows it’s Billy’s snot, tears, and drool. “Yeah. In California.”

Quiet settles. Then, Steve says, “Where?”

“Pasadena.”

“They got college for dumb people there?”

A pause, and then Billy slowly shifts to prop up on a hand, looking down at Steve with narrowed eyes. The moonlight behind him gives him an ethereal glow and Steve thinks… this is how Billy should always be seen. Softly lit, cheeks flushed from the cool air by the water, eyes reflecting starlight.

“Why?” Billy asks, suspicious.

Steve rolls his eyes, though his heart leaps up into his throat. “So a dumbass like me can apply and get in.”

“You’d get even better grades if you applied yourself,” Billy drawls, some of that familiar spark flickering through his eyes.

“See, I thought I was on that path, but then my study buddy broke up with me. I totally deserved it, though- I’m. I’m a fucking idiot.”

Billy’s features soften a fraction and this is it. Steve’s free falling. “He was scared.”

“Then he’ll help me fill out an application and get ready for the best road trip of his life,” Steve murmurs, hope flooding his senses.

Billy frowns, and for a second, Steve thinks he blew it. Billy drops back to lie down, but he’s curled close to Steve, one of his hands slipping down to find Steve’s to lace their fingers together. It’s a shy, innocent motion, like something Billy once knew how to do and is slowly re-learning the nuance of.

“Alright, Harrington.”

Steve glances over. Billy’s looking up at the Hawkins night sky, constellations twinkling, the bright moon bathing him. Smiling a little, Steve leans in to press a soft, tentative kiss to Billy’s temple.

They’ve got a lot of shit to figure out.

Good thing Billy’s a straight A student.

Notes:

probably out of character and weird, my apologies, it's been... a long time since i've hunkered down and wrote. trying to get the gears turning again and i'm a slut for this trash ship