Chapter Text
Ever since the Halloween bash everyone in Hawkins knew who Billy Hargrove was or at least the act he slips into. So it wasn’t unexpected that Tonya’s nosy blonde long haired hard of hearing friend, Sydney Mcrof, had news to share about him in their second period honors history class. Sydney Mcrof’s hearing aids were of spectacular working condition because she was always overhearing some news to share.
Tonya thought it over carefully. They made sure to plan out their approach step by step. If what Mcrof told them is the truth they need to interrogate Billy and learn more about it themself. Billy and Tonya have spent a lot of time together and at this point Tonya would consider them close enough. They didn’t really have anything to fear about what response they’d get from Billy.
Hence when Mr. Harden had finally sat down in his seat because he had finished the required amount of teaching to still keep his job at the high school. Tonya turns their focal point towards Billy.
“Guess what? A nosy, Sydney Mcrof, tells me that a certain Hargrove made the basketball team” Tonya tells Billy. “ Is that true?”
“Maybe it is, maybe it’s not, Sinclair.” Billy’s answer neither confirms nor denies Tonya Sinclair's question. So Tonya tries asking him again but in a different manner. “Sydney Mcrof also told me that you made our varsity team so easily because it’s rumored you took your team to nationals in California.” Billy minimizes Tonya’s statements, says something like it’s no big deal. “Wow so my new found friend was never gonna tell me they were a basketball prodigy.” Tonya added.
“guess we both have the worst of luck Sinclair because My new found friend was never gonna tell me she’s class president.” Billy jokingly retorts. Unfortunately Tonya becomes uneasy after hearing the unduly familiar four letter word. They can feel their carefully constructed illusion start to peel as they physically revolt to being perceived as a woman. Tonya quickly pulls themself together and remembers the Tonya Billy knows is a girl so they better act like it.
“Maybe I am, maybe I’m not.” Tonya mimics Billy’s non answer once they are out of their temporary funk. Then they rush to change, course of the conversation. “At any rate I find it hilarious how my little brother Lucas can’t shut up about MadMax, your little sister.” Tonya says to Billy putting air quotes around “MadMax” .
“ She’s not my sister. ”
Tonya pauses. Did they accidentally just poke one of Billy’s nerves? It’s not long before Billy speaks up and answers Tonya’s inner monologue. “Her whore of a mother married my dad and now it’s my responsibility to look after her.” Billy moans.
“Well if true that would still make her your step sister.” Tonya spills the beans to Billy. Although, they don’t hound him on the point for too long. Because Tonya comes to the conclusion that the two siblings' relationship must be complicated. The teens maintained the flow of their inconsequential discussion but as the two walked towards the cafeteria Billy asked something that kinda took Tonya off guard.
“Do I like Steve Harrington?” Tonya re-asked Billy’s question and Billy nods his head. “Not for the life of me Hargrove! I’d rather get hit by a bus than crush on Harrington!”
Billy shakes his head and clarifies “No I mean in terms of what your history with him is like, Sinclair. Hagan told me he used to sit at your guys’ table but then they had a falling out so Harrington found some place else to eat his lunch. I’m just asking. curious.” Billy finishes then gives Tonya his no good, up to something, Devilish looking smile.
Tonya smelled something fishy going on real fast “Okay yeah but why Harrington I know a lot of other kids in this godforsaken town. Why him?” After they ask the question, Tonya can see Billy’s body get tense as he decides on how to answer their question “Well just between you and me I heard he was the king… was hoping… I don’t know that we could be friendly.”
Tonya releases a short laugh. “Okay Hargrove… I’ve known Steve since elementary. We were always pretty close but he was always closer to Heather and Tommy. When Tommy and Steve fell off I guess the two of us just naturally fell apart but I wouldn’t say there’s any underlying grudges between me and him. Does that answer your question, Hargrove?”
“guess so.” Billy says while shuffling his feet. “I want to know who this Wheeler chick is but I’ll ask about that later”
Billy and Tonya are right outside of the cafeteria about to head in before Tonya stops the two to forewarn Billy about seeking out friendship with Steve “ Look Here, Hargrove, trying to be best friends with Harrington might not be the best idea. The whole gang, but for the most part Tommy and Carol, has bad blood that ruins deep. I just don’t want you to get in the middle of it. But do what you want I can’t stop ya.” Tonya says suspecting nothing too bad could come from Billy’s pursuit.
At the lunch table, the topic was still somehow on Steve Harrington. However nobody seemed optimistic about their future relations with Steve except for Heather Holloway who was defending Steve at every turn. Tonya does find Billy's refusal to join the conversation strange though especially after what they talked about. Carol Perkins had no problem putting her two cents in on the conversation however.
“I also heard Nancy and Jonathan ran off together and left poor Stevie all alone at their lunch table.” Carol bad-mouthed. Heather once again steps in “look guys we know nothing about the situation anymore it’s none of our business now. If we keep smack talking all we’re gonna end up doing is spreading false narratives.”
“Loosen up Holloway. I speak the truth.” Carol snaps with an edge to her tone.
Tonya doesn’t like how Perkins speaks to Holloway. Carol always tries to push Heather’s buttons when the group is together. Tonya doesn’t let her get away with it. Neither does Hauman…
“Watch it, Perkins,” Desiree warns.
“Yeah that’s our friend you’re talking to and Heather brings up a fair point we’re detached from the situation and we don't know exactly what’s what.” Tonya says backing up their two friends.
“Oh I mean I just wanted to bring up the topic to see if maybe Tommy, Alejandro, and Billy ,here, could ask him about it more in practice.” Carol back tracks. Smart move knowing the three musketeers’ track record speaks for itself. Tonya catches sight of Billy in his seat looking uncomfortable at the prospect of cross examining Steve in the locker room. Tommy on the other hand is jumping at the opportunity to terrorize Steve. He prompts Alejandro and Billy on if they will help him question Steve. Alejandro glances at Heather then declines the offer. humorously saying he’s had enough of drama Queen Tommy for the day and that he just wants to get through practice. Tommy tells Torres he’s no fun and puts all his focus on Billy and the decision he will come to.
Billy hasn’t known Tommy as long as Torres has and must want to stay in Tommy’s good graces or at least that's the only reasoning Tonya can come up with to understand Billy’s choices. “Sure why not, I’d love to solve a mystery.” Billy accepts the request. Tonya’s not gonna lie Billy switching up kinda confuses them. If Hargrove wants to be Harrington’s friend surely he knows bullying him in the locker room won’t make that a reality.
When Tonya gets home they spread themself out on their bed. They feel drained from the school day so to rejuvenate themself they take a short nap. Once Tonya awakens they open up their school books and continue their studies. Tonya pulls out their cassette and starts to relay their vocabulary and thoughts on tape so that they can replay the tapes back to themself later.
Nonetheless Tonya finds themself lingering in concern over Billy’s reaction to the group’s discussion at the table today. The subject matter at hand being about their old friend Steve Harrington. Tonya wonders why Billy was suddenly so intrigued by Steve Harrington. What put Tonya on edge the most was how quickly it appeared Billy gave up on becoming Steve’s acquaintance after being peer pressured by Tommy.
Tonya doesn’t agonize over it too long before they find themself right back in the books paying attention and trying to study.
~*~*~
commission of Tonya Sinclair studying made by Honestly-half-Weirdo
