Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Blue Eyed Murder in a Size Five Dress

Summary:

Eddie Munson hadn't meant for them to get that drunk when he'd volunteered to bring some beer over to Steve's house for him and his boyfriends to share. But it was a warm summer night, and he, Billy and Steve had nothing better to do than to drink, smoke a little weed, and play a game of truth or dare on the back porch. Only, during one of Billy's dares, Steve's parents came home from their business trip early, and walked right in on them.
Goddammit.

Notes:

Part four is finally here! I had to put it on hold until I finished another story, but it's done now and I really hope everyone enjoys it. I went to great lengths (looking the clip up on YouTube) to make sure I got the dialogue right from that scene in The Seven-Year Itch, and (with a Google search) making sure I got the actor's names right from Saturday Night Fever as well. Anyway, you know the drill, drop a comment if you enjoy, they make my day, and the title for this one comes from the song Unchained by Van Halen (which is 100% a Billy song, by the way).

Work Text:

TW: Graphic depictions of violence, mild threatening, and use of f-slurs and other homophobic language. Also, there is a reference to Saturday Night Fever, which is a 70's movie that, despite the look of the movie posters, is not just about John Travolta dancing his little heart out, it's actually a very violent and sexual movie, much like Eddie mentions in the story, and even though it's not discussed in the fic, there are instances in the movie dealing with suicide and rape. Just throwing that out there as a warning, because I don't want to accidentally trigger anyone while they're reading this, it's all supposed to be just a story that I wrote to continue this series. Please be wary of the tags and this warning, and remember to stay safe and sane, brochachos!


Steve couldn’t believe how lucky he was to be here right now, on his back porch with his two boyfriends, just drinking and smoking and having fun on a warm summer night. They’d been dating for a little over a month at this point, and they’d come a long way in that time. Robin had said they literally personified the trope enemies/friends/lovers , whatever that meant, but honestly, Steve couldn’t have been happier. He glanced between the two boys sitting across from him, the campfire they’d built lighting up their faces as the sun sank lower and lower, giving them an almost ethereal glow as they threw their heads back in laughter at a joke Steve hadn’t been paying attention to. But their laughter was infectious, and Steve found himself giggling along with them, taking a sip of his beer as they calmed down and settled into a nice, quiet stillness that only lasted a few moments before Eddie began to speak again.

“I’m so boooored,” he whined, flopping around on his chair, “We should do something fun! C’mon guys, help me think of something!”

“What, we aren’t entertaining enough for you, Munson?” Billy joked, leaning over and smacking Eddie’s thigh lightly.

“Bill, honey, you and Stevie are the most gorgeous people I’ve ever seen, but you can only stare at a painting for so long before you gotta leave the museum and appreciate the beauty of nature,” Eddie replied, waving his hands around as he spoke.

“Eds, what in the genuine fuck are you talking about?” Steve asked, another round of giggles building up in his chest.

“I don’t fucking know, I’m high as balls right now! But that’s not the point, the point is I’m bored and we need to figure out something to do before I fall asleep in your faces and you have to carry me inside so I don’t catch hypothermia,” Eddie said, taking a drag from the joint he’d just lit and passing it off to Steve. 

“Why don’t we play, like, truth or dare or something?” Steve asked, passing the joint to Billy and exhaling the smoke.

“What are we, little girls?” Billy asked, rolling his eyes.

“No, but I don’t want to be stuck trying to lug 155 pounds of dead weight inside if he falls asleep out here, and no one’s offering up any better things to do, so why the fuck not? Besides, it’s not like you got anything better to do,” Steve shrugged, taking another sip of his drink.

“It’s 154 pounds, actually, thank you very much,” Eddie said, “But you’ve got a point. Anyway, I’ll go first. Stevie, since it was your brilliant idea to play, I’m asking you first. Truth or dare?”

“Truth,” Steve said, not exactly loving the grin Eddie got on his face as he did.

“Ooh, I’ve wanted to know this for a long time!” He said, then asked, “How old were you when you popped your cherry, and who was it with?”

Billy nearly spat out his drink as he cackled, and Steve’s face went as red and hot as the flames as he tried to think of how to phrase his answer to make it less embarrassing.

“I was fifteen,” he said, “My parents were hosting a dinner party for some of their friends and one of them had a daughter named Louise, I think. The party got boring, so she and I slipped up to my room and were back twenty minutes later. It wasn’t exactly my finest moment.”

“Ah, Jesus Christ,” Billy said, his laughter finally calming down a little as he wiped a tear from his eye, “Oh, Stevie, I haven’t laughed that hard in a while, I needed that!”

“Oh, shut up! It might not have been as romantic as Hollywood makes it out to be, but I doubt your first time was much better!” Steve huffed, crossing his arms.

“Alright, alright, you got me there. Anyway, it’s your turn,” Billy said, brushing his hair from his face.

“Billy, truth or dare?” Steve asked.

“I’ll do a truth,” he replied, leaning forward so that Steve could literally see the fire in his eyes. It had died down a lot since they’d first lit it, but it was still bright enough to light up Billy’s face, making Steve’s heart flutter.

“Alright, let me think for a sec,” he said, then asked, “Why did your family move here from California?”

“Oh, come on, Stevie! You can think of something better than that!” Eddie said, “Ask him something more juicy!”

“No, I genuinely want to know this! Besides, who’s turn is it to ask a question, mine or yours?” He said, then turned back to Billy.

“Eh, Munson’s right though, the story’s not that interesting. Basically, Max saw me and my friend Tim under the boardwalk one day, and we were just making out, but I made her promise not to tell anyone, ever. She said she wouldn’t, but a little while later, we were having a big fight and she went to throw it in my face, and my dad overheard. A few weeks later, once my broken wrist healed, we started packing. Dad had already bought the new house, he was just waiting for my wrist to heal so I could help him move the boxes and furniture,” Billy explained, biting his lip and staring into the flames for a moment before seeming to come out of a trance and turning to Eddie. “Alright, pretty boy, truth or dare?”

“Well, since I’m not a coward like you two, I’m gonna do a dare,” Eddie said, lightening the moment a little and making Billy grin.

“Okay then, you got two choices for this. Option one: You take off your clothes and go skinny dipping in the pool. Option two: You jump in with all your clothes on, including your shoes and jacket. Either way, you gotta stay in until the next time you’re asked a question,” Billy said, eyeing Eddie up and down as he made his choice.

“Well, as much as I’d love to show off my absolutely gorgeous body, I don’t need Steve’s neighbors to call Chief Hopper down here to book me for indecent exposure, so…” Eddie grinned as he sauntered over to the diving board, taking a running start off of it and yelling, “Cannonball!”

He jumped into the pool and curled his body into a ball in the air, making a huge, loud splash that was almost big enough to reach where the other two were sitting on the porch. It took Eddie a moment to resurface, his clothes weighing him down, but he eventually did, and tossed his head back to get the hair out of his face. He swam over to the side of the pool, leaning on the edge of it with his head in his hands and smiling up at the other two, and said with a wink, “Hello there, handsomes. Care to take a swim with a pretty little mermaid like me?”

“Not a chance, Munson,” Steve said, but he had to resist the urge to jump in with him, if only to kiss him stupid while underwater like in that mermaid princess movie Disney had just announced.

“You’re no fun, Stevie. Truth or dare?” He asked, pouting a little until Steve answered, saying he’d take another truth.

“Ugh, you really are a coward,” Eddie wrinkled his nose, but he smiled before asking, “How did you figure out that you were bisexual?”

“Oh, that’s an easy one,” Steve says, “I think I always kind of knew in the back of my mind, but the first time I ever really had a crush on a guy was when I was 11. I had a nanny who really liked the movie Saturday Night Fever , and I was absolutely in love with both John Travolta and Barry Miller. Tony was sexy and Bobby C. was just so sweet, I was head over heels for them both.”

“Your nanny let you watch Saturday Night Fever when you were 11? Jesus, isn’t that movie, like, not only super sexual, but like, violent, too?” Eddie asked, his wet hair clinging to his forehead as he tilted his head.

“I mean, yeah, but it wasn’t a terrible movie plot wise. Although, Jeannie is in prison now, I think, so I think showing me an R rated movie is far from the worst she could’ve done to me. Anyways, Billy, truth or dare?”

“I’ll go with a dare this time,” Billy said, “But remind me to bring up the whole your-old-babysitter-went-to-prison thing later.”

“Okay, gimme a second to think,” Steve said, thinking for a moment until a sly smile spread across his face, “Alright, I think I got something, but I need you to answer a question first. What’s your favorite old movie? And when I say favorite, I mean like you could quote every word if you wanted to.”

“Um…” Billy said, eyes to the sky as he thought, “ The Seven Year Itch , I guess. My mom used to watch it with me.”

“That’s the one with Marilyn Monroe in it, right? And the dude cheats on his wife with her or something?” Eddie asked from where he was still at the edge of the pool.

“Yep, that’s the one,” Billy said, then looked back at Steve.

“That’s also the one where she stands over the subway grate and her dress flies up, am I right?” He asked, grinning evilly and doing his best not to laugh as realization flashed in Billy’s eyes. 

“Oh my God, Stevie. If you ask him what I think you’re about to ask him, I’m gonna let you top me for the next two weeks as a thank you,” Eddie giggled from the pool.

“Billy, I dare you to go upstairs into my mom’s closet, find a white dress, and re-create that scene from the movie for me and Eds,” Steve said, finally letting himself laugh as he said it. Eddie was laughing, too, but Billy just got a determined look on his face and stood up, downing the rest of his beer.

“Alright, challenge accepted,” he said, flashing his white teeth as he waited for the other two to come inside with him. Steve got Eddie a towel as he pulled himself out of the pool, then walked inside with Billy as Eddie dried off as best he could. He led Billy upstairs and to his parent’s bedroom, unable to wipe the grin off of his face as he pulled open the doors to the humongous walk-in closet.

“Most of this stuff still has the tags on it, so whatever you can fit into is fair game. I’m gonna go get Eds a change of clothes and set up the living room, just call down when you’re ready so we know you’re coming,” Steve said, pulling the chain to turn on the closet light. He turned and grinned at Billy, who returned it and started to take off his jacket as he perused the clothes.

“Alright, pretty boy. Now get out of here so I can change,” he said, winking.

“I’m going, I’m going,” Steve said, putting his hands up in surrender. He left the room and pulled the door shut, going to his bedroom and grabbing a pair of sweatpants, boxers, socks and a shirt for Eddie, along with one of the 3,000 hair ties he’d stashed in his desk, before going downstairs and handing them to a still slightly damp Eddie. He thanked him and went to the bathroom to change, giving Steve time to slip down to the basement and bring up the box fan he knew was stashed down there. He had just gotten it set up at the bottom of the stairs, lying flat on the carpet so that when he turned it on, it would blow air directly upwards. Eddie came out of the bathroom just as he turned the fan on, and they heard Billy’s voice above them from the top of the stairs, but they couldn’t see him when they looked up.

“I’m just about ready,” he said, a hint of mischief in his voice as a piece of paper drifted down towards them from over the banister, “But if I’m gonna do this right, you two are gonna need to know your lines. Whenever I stop talking, one of you has to reply with what I wrote on that paper, got it?”

“Got it,” the other two said in unison, then began to giggle excitedly as they took a seat on the couch. They had a perfect view of the staircase, the fan was humming quietly, and soon they saw Billy slowly begin to descend the stairs, their eyes nearly popping out of their skulls.

“Didn’t you just love the picture? I did,” Billy said as he slowly walked down the stairs, his voice pitched up a little higher than normal, “But I just felt so sorry for the creature at the end.”

Billy paused on his way down, and the other two were practically drowning in drool as they stared at him. He had on a white dress, as promised, but he took it a step further, squeezing his feet into a pair of white heels Steve knew his mother had never worn, and using some of the probably previously unopened makeup to paint his lips cherry red and draw a beauty mark on his face where Marilyn always had hers. They were so busy staring at the way the dress hugged his torso, accentuated his arms, and swished around his legs that they almost forgot to read the lines Billy wrote on the paper for them until he nodded at it to remind them.

“Oh, uh,” Eddie said, looking at the paper and getting into character as he read, “Sorry for the creature? What, did you want him to marry the girl?”

“He was kinda scary looking,” Billy continued descending the stairs, “But he wasn’t really all bad. I think he just craved a little affection, you know, a sense of being loved and needed and wanted.”

He stopped again, and this time Steve read from the paper. “That’s a very interesting point of view,” he said, and looked up at Billy, who was now standing on the bottom step, a grin plastered on his crimson lips.

“Ooh, do you feel the breeze from the subway?” He asked, rushing forward so that the ends of the dress were just barely fluttering from the air of the fan, “Isn’t it delicious?”

And with that, he moved to stand directly over the fan, giggling and holding the dress down in the front just like Marilyn did in the movie. He nodded at the other two again as he stepped back a little, encouraging them to read the next line.

“Sort of cools the ankles, doesn’t it?” Eddie asked, a little breathless.

“Well, what do you think would be fun to do now?” Steve added, a lot breathless, and trying not to let it sound like an innuendo.

“I don’t know, it’s getting pretty late,” Billy said, feigning innocence.

“It’s not that late,” Eddie immediately said, he and Steve both so enthralled that they didn’t hear the sound of a car door closing outside. Billy, standing so close to the fan, didn’t hear it, either.

“The thing is I’ve got this big day tomorrow, I really have to get to sleep,” Billy said.

“What’s the big day tomorrow?” Steve asked.

“Tomorrow I’m on television. You remember, I told you about it, The Dazzledent Hour,” Billy said, as a key was shoved into the front door lock, “Oh, here comes another one!”

Billy stepped over the fan again, laughing and throwing his head back as he did. This time, he tried a lot less hard to keep the dress down, and he didn’t regret it one bit as he saw how it affected his boyfriends. That is, until the front door was shoved open, and an exhausted Peter Harrington made his way into the room, his wife Marjorie close behind him.

“What in the hell is going on here?!” He yelled as he saw the scene in front of him, and suddenly three heads snapped over to look at him, their cheeks flushed darker than the rubies Marjorie was wearing around her neck, and their jaws dangling in shock. Everything in the room was still for a brief moment, nobody even daring to breathe as it sunk in for everyone. And then Steve was moving faster than he probably ever had before, grabbing hold of Eddie and Billy’s hands and dragging them as fast as he could up to his room in a panic.

“Shitshitshitshitshitshitshit!” He kept saying as he shut and locked the door, praying that the inch of wood would be enough to stop his father if he followed them up there. Eddie and Billy moved as fast as they could, Billy yanking the dress off over his head and kicking off the heels before yanking on his jeans and jacket, completely forgetting about his t-shirt. 

“I thought you said they weren’t gonna be back until tomorrow night!” Eddie yelled as he was yanking on his shoes and struggling with the window, fumbling with the lock as his fingers shook and finally lifting the pane enough for them to be able to slip out.

“I thought they were! They must’ve gotten an earlier flight or something!” Steve yelled back, tossing Billy’s keys at him as he heard his father’s footsteps coming closer. “Look, you can give me shit for it later, but right now, you gotta go! Be careful, and drive safe, I’ll call you guys as soon as I can, alright?”

Eddie and Billy didn’t bother to respond as they took turns climbing out of Steve’s window and jumping to the ground, booking it to the Camaro and thanking whatever little voice told Billy to park it on the street instead of in the driveway that night. Steve waited until he heard the engine roar to life and the tires squeal as they sped down the street and away from his house to shut his window and go back over to his door, taking a deep breath before he opened it and came face to face with his father. Steve avoided his eyes as he tried to stare him down, and he hung his head as he followed him back down to the living room, where his mother was waiting on the couch.

“Care to explain what that was that we just walked into?” Peter asked, annoyance more present in his voice than anger.

“We were just messing around,” Steve said, deciding that it would be in his best interest to sugarcoat this as much as he could, “They’re my friends, and we were just hanging out, but I guess we got a little drunk and we decided to play truth or dare since we got bored. That was Billy’s dare.”

“Stephen, you know what I’ve told you about the people you choose to surround yourself with. If anyone were to see you with them, it would reflect badly on all of us, your mother and I included. You should be friends with people that are respectable young ladies and gentlemen. Obviously, Billy whatever-his-name-is and that Munson boy do not fit into that category.” 

“You don’t even know them, dad! Eddie and Billy are so much better than anyone like that! Billy’s dad even works in business, just like you do! You’re judging them without even giving them a chance!” Steve protested, stopping only when Margie put a hand on his knee.

“Stephen, I’m too tired to deal with this right now,” Peter said, rubbing his eyes with one hand and holding the other out towards his son, “We’ll make this simple. You’re grounded for a week, and I want your keys, you can’t have your car for another week after that.”

Steve wanted to argue some more, but he bit his tongue, and instead handed his keys over to his father with a sigh. 

“Alright, now I’m going to bed. Goodnight,” Peter said, putting Steve’s keys in his pocket and walking back up the stairs. Steve watched him go, running a hand through his hair with a sigh and then turning to look at his mother, who was still seated next to him.

“Aren’t you going with him?” He asked.

“I will then,” Margie said, “But I want to make sure you’re okay first.”

With that, she opened her arms, and Steve fell into them, not quite crying, but a lump began to form in his throat as his mother began to stroke his hair.

“Do you want to talk about it?” She asked as Steve finally pulled away. She already knew he was bisexual, and she didn’t care (Steve was born in the sixties, after all), so as long as he made sure to keep himself out of trouble and keep it under wraps for his own safety, she couldn’t care less who he fell in love with. 

“I’m gonna be fine, mom, getting grounded isn’t the end of the world,” Steve said, biting at the inside of his cheek, “I’m just worried about them. I really care for both of them, and if this gets out to anyone, we’re all gonna have targets painted on our backs. And I never would’ve even dared him to do it, but I thought you guys weren’t getting back until tomorrow, so I thought we’d just do it and that’d be the end of it, you know?”

“I know, baby, and I’m sorry, I was going to call ahead and tell you that our flight got switched, but I just didn’t have time. But I won’t tell anyone, and I’ll make sure your father doesn’t, either. As far as I’m concerned, this never happened, okay?” Margie said, standing up and leaning over to kiss Steve on his head. “Now, it’s late, I’m gonna go to sleep, and you should, too. Brush your teeth before you go to bed, and drink some water, that’ll help with the hangover. And I know your father said you’re grounded, but if you want to call those boys real quick and check on them, I won’t tell him. Goodnight, baby.”

And with that, Margie was gone, walking up the stairs and into her bedroom. Steve heaved a sigh of relief as he followed his mother’s instructions, drinking two big glasses of water and brushing his teeth before settling down in his bedroom, picking up the phone and calling Eddie first.

“Yello?” He asked as he picked up the phone, and Steve was relieved to hear the relaxed tone of his boyfriend’s voice.

“Hey, Eds,” Steve said, “I just wanted to make sure you got home okay and everything.”

“Oh, yeah, I’m fine. Actually, you just missed Bills. I helped him get all that makeup off before he headed home, and he literally just left like two minutes before you called,” Eddie said.

“Was he okay? I’m gonna call him in a minute, too, but did he seem alright when he left?” Steve asked.

“Yeah, he was fine. A little shaken, but nothing he can’t handle,” Eddie replied, and Steve smiled at that. 

“That’s good,” Steve said, twisting the phone cord between his fingers. “Oh, hey, my parents are leaving again the day after tomorrow for another trip, and this one I’m sure about the departure time. Do you want to come over and we can hang out?”

“Sure, Stevie. That sounds good,” Eddie said, “Night, handsome.”

“Goodnight, Eds,” Steve chuckled, blowing him a kiss through the phone and putting it back in its cradle for a few minutes before lifting it to his ear again and dialing Billy’s number.

“Hello?” Max asked through the phone, yawning soon after.

“Max? What are you doing up so late?” He asked.

“Dude, it’s only, like, 10:30. But if you must know, I was just about to get ready for bed when you called, so what’s up?” She replied.

“I, uh, was hoping to talk to Billy. Is he home yet?” Steve asked.

“Didn’t you guys, like, just see each other?” Max asked, the eyeroll clear in her voice.

“Yeah, but that’s not the point. Is he home yet or not?” Steve asked.

“He just pulled in,” Max said, the sound of the Camaro’s engine dying clear in the background. “Hang on just a sec,” Max said, and Steve did as he was told, listening to her slightly muffled voice telling Billy that his ‘clingy-ass boyfriend’ was on the phone for him. 

“Hello?” Billy asked a moment later, exhaustion creeping into his voice.

“Hi, babydoll,” Steve said, “I was just calling to make sure you got home okay. Eds said you were still a little shaken up, are you alright?”

“Yeah, I’m fine. Just tired. But as long as this stays between us, I should be fine. Are you alright? Your dad didn’t hurt you or anything, did he?” Billy asked, and Steve cringed when he heard the fear in his voice.

“No, he didn’t hurt me, just grounded me for a week, but he’s gonna be gone again in two days, anyway, so there’s nothing to worry about. And speaking of which, Eddie’s gonna come over that night, do you wanna join us? I’ll order pizza and we can watch a movie or something and then you guys can spend the night?” Steve asked, holding his breath a little. He knew how Billy got when he felt like he was backed into a corner, how scared he could get if he felt he was being put in a situation that could come crashing down on his head, and he hoped that he didn’t feel that way right now.

“Yeah, that sounds great, Steve. I’ll see you then,” Billy said, his voice a little lighter.

“See you then,” Steve agreed, and blew him a kiss through the phone, “Goodnight, angel boy.” Steve hung up the phone after that, smiling to himself as he turned off his light and wrapped up in his covers, falling asleep easily and dreaming about his two favorite people in the world.

After that, Steve honestly forgot about all the drama that came out of that night, his hangover made sure of that. He still avoided his father while he was home, but that wasn’t much different than normal. He went to the country club with his mother the day after and had tea with her and her friends, and then went with her to the movies, even though he was supposed to be grounded. His mother had always been a bit of a soft touch, so she treated him to popcorn and dinner at the one nice restaurant in town, and he honestly felt a little sad as he went to bed that night and remembered that she was going to be leaving again the next day. Even his father seemed to be in a better spirit when he got home that night, even if he did disappear to his study as soon as he got in. 

The next day, Steve helped them pack their bags in the morning, and he helped his father load up the trunk of the car by noon. He both was and wasn’t anxious for them to leave, excited to see his boyfriends later that day, but also going to miss his mother once she was gone. Still, he didn’t say anything, just smiled and hugged her goodbye.

“You’re sure you’re going to be okay if we leave again so soon? I can switch my flight and meet up with your father in a few days if you want me to stay,” Margie said as she kissed his cheek, brushing some hair from his eyes.

“I’m sure, mom. Go with dad and have a good time, everything’s alright. I’ll be fine,” Steve replied, kissing her back and letting her wrap him in one more bone-crushing hug before he watched them leave from the front step, waving as the car drove off down the road.

As soon as he saw the car turn the corner at the end of the street, he ran back inside, immediately starting to straighten up the living room and once he was satisfied, he grabbed the phone and dialed the number of their favorite pizza place. He ordered one large pie, a third of it with extra cheese and black olives for Eddie, a third with peppers and mushrooms for Billy, and a third with pineapple and onions for himself. He waited patiently for both the pizza and the other two boys to show up, nearly sprinting to get the door when the bell rang. It was Eddie.

“Hey, Stevie!” He said as he walked inside, placing a soft kiss to his cheek, “I missed you!”

“I missed you, too, Eds,” Steve replied, shutting the door before kissing him properly. “How have you been since the whole… thing?”

“Oh, I’ve been fine. I told Wayne what happened though and he laughed his ass off at us. I love the old coot but he can be a real pain in the ass when he wants to be.” Eddie said, a fond smile gracing his face.

“But he wasn’t mad or anything?” Steve asked.

“Nah, he couldn’t care less. Besides, I told him about us a while ago. He says as long as we’re careful about keeping it from the townsfolk and as long as I steer clear of your dad, he doesn’t care who I date. As long as I’m safe and happy, of course, which I am,” Eddie beamed, wrapping his arms around Steve’s neck and kissing him again before heading to the living room. They sat there together and argued over what movie to watch until the doorbell rang again, and Steve left the room again to go answer it. It was the pizza guy, and after paying for the food and giving him a good tip, he brought it to the living room and set it and the two-liter of Coca-Cola on the coffee table as the bell rang for the third time.

“Eds, can you go grab us some cups from the kitchen while I get the door?” Steve asked, smiling as Eddie obliged his request and he walked to the door, where Billy was waiting impatiently, if the continuous ringing of the bell was anything to go by.

“Jesus, I’m coming!” Steve muttered under his breath as he threw the door open, his good mood immediately crushed as he saw Billy on the other side of the door. He didn’t say anything as Billy pushed past him into the house, too shocked at what he’d seen to even try to form words.

“Is that Billy or did you order Chinese food, too?” Eddie called in a joking tone as he walked back into the living room at the same time as Billy, Steve following close behind. His optimism quickly evaporated as he took in Billy’s face, and he almost dropped one of the glasses he was carrying as he tripped over his own feet in the living room doorway.

“Bill,” he asked, his voice going quiet, “What the hell happened to you?”

Billy didn’t answer him, just stared as his lip began to quiver. The air in the room suddenly felt stifling as none of them dared to move, and the silence felt suffocating, until it was shattered by Billy as he let out a pained sob. Suddenly everything seemed to be moving at once, Eddie and Steve both rushing to his side and guiding him to sit between them on the couch, their hearts shattering into millions of pieces as they assessed his injuries. 

He had a black eye, dark purple and swollen almost completely shut. His nose had a bandage over the bridge and a bit of old, crusty blood still staining his mustache. His lip was split and it began to bleed a little as he cried, deep red drops flowing sluggishly down his chin. He had cuts and bruises all over his face and the bits of his chest and arms that they could see, and probably many more that they couldn’t. His pinkie and ring fingers on his left hand were wrapped in metal splints, and they were bent a little to the side, obviously broken. His left earlobe was wrapped tightly in a bandage, and the silver dagger that usually hung there was nowhere to be found. He was having trouble getting his breath from the mixture of aching bruises on his ribs and from crying so hard, and his voice sounded raw and sore as if he’d been screaming and crying for hours on end.

“Oh, angel boy,” Steve whispered, holding Billy and stroking his hair as he bawled into his shoulder, soaking his polo shirt with tears. “Shh, it’s okay, you’re safe now. We’ve got you, you’re safe now.”

“Who did this to you, sweetie pie?” Eddie asked, gently lacing their fingers together on Billy’s uninjured hand and drumming soothing beats on his thigh with his other hand.

“Wh-who do you think? My fucking father ,” Billy spit the word out like it was a smoldering charcoal caught on his tongue. He winced as he sniffed, and even more so when he tried to wipe some of his tears away, until Steve had to take his hand to stop him from touching his face. Eddie leaned over to the coffee table and grabbed some of the napkins that’d been delivered with the pizza and tenderly wiped them away himself, making sure his touch was as light as possible so as not to hurt Billy.

“Why did he do this, baby? What happened?” Steve asked, helping Eddie to wipe away the blood and tears from their boyfriend’s face.

“L-last night, when I got back from playing basketball with Lucas and M-Max after school, he sent Susan and her to the store, and as soon as they were g-gone, he laid into me,” Billy paused, swallowing thickly and taking a second to get himself a little more under control. He was still crying, but it wasn’t the heaving sobs that had been wracking his body like before, just a few sniffles here and there as tears flowed freely from his eyes. Steve and Eddie were patient, giving him all the time he needed to get himself ready to speak again. He took a deep breath, as much as he could breathe deeply, and let it out on a slow hiss before continuing.

“Apparently, he got a call earlier that day from your dad,” he said, refusing to look anywhere but at the floor, “They know each other through their businesses and he told my dad that we know each other, too. He said he didn’t want me hanging out around his house or his son anymore, and asked Neil if he would keep me from coming around anymore. He told him all about the drinking and the pot, and he told him about how I’d dressed up in your mom’s clothes and makeup while we were playing that game. And then as soon as Susan and Max had left, he started whaling on me. He ripped out my earring and punched me so hard I fell backward, and that’s when he stomped on my hand and broke my fingers. He beat me worse than he ever has before, and when I started crying, it only made it worse. Eventually I managed to get away and I ran to my car, and he would’ve followed me if Mrs. Trenty from next door hadn’t been out walking her dog and would’ve seen him.”

“Oh, darlin’,” Eddie said, holding his hand a little tighter, “Where did you go?”

“As soon as I knew he wasn’t following me, I went to the 24-hour free clinic on the other side of town. They did what they could, stitched up my ear and set my fingers back in place and stuff, and they helped me clean up as best as they could. I didn’t have anywhere to go after that, so I went up to the quarry. I figured he wouldn’t think to look for me up there if he came out to find me, and I spent the night in the Camaro and just hid up there until I could come here,” Billy explained, starting to shake a little.

“Why didn’t you come to one of us, baby? Or you could’ve gone to Chief Hopper or called one of us. We would’ve helped you,” Eddie said, his big eyes full of worry.

“I-I know,” he said, his lip starting to shake again, “I was just so scared, I wasn’t thinkin’. And I didn’t know if Neil was following me or anything, and I didn’t want to put you in danger if he was.”

Billy continued to cry after that, and Eddie continued to try and comfort him. Steve was trying, too, but he’d gone quiet since Billy began his explanation, a white-hot fire igniting in the pit of his stomach and spreading quickly throughout his body until he couldn’t feel anything but rage. He tried to extinguish the flames long enough to calm Billy down and make sure he was okay, but it was a losing battle, and it soon became too much for him to handle.

Fuck it, he thought, and placed the softest kiss he could manage to Billy’s forehead as he stood up.

“You two can go ahead and relax, make yourselves at home,” he said, “I’ll be right back.”

And with that, he left the room, running up the stairs two, sometimes three at a time, and into his parent’s room, immediately opening his dad’s sock drawer and digging around at the back until he found his car keys. His dad always thought he was so clever with his hiding spots, but he was becoming predictable at this point. He stopped in his own bedroom and grabbed his nail bat, propping it on his shoulder as he pulled on a pair of shoes and heading back downstairs, his jaw aching a little from how hard he’d been clenching his teeth.

“Stevie, where are you going? And why do you have your bat with you?” Eddie asked from the couch, his and Billy’s eyes widening as they saw him. They’d never seen him looking so pissed off, so vicious, but they must’ve known better than to get in his way as he mumbled something about running an errand and left, slamming the door so hard, it rattled on its hinges.

He opened his car and tossed the bat over into the passenger’s seat, not even caring that one of the nails ripped the fabric of the seat cushion. He slammed his car door shut and didn’t even bother with his seatbelt as he peeled out of the driveway, barely braking enough to shift gears as he sped off down the street towards the house on Cherry Lane.

“Max?” He asked into the walkie talkie the kids had given him to keep in contact, “Max, come in.”

There was nothing but silence on the other end of the radio, and Steve sighed heavily as he pressed the button down again and spoke, “Max, do you read me? Answer me, Max!”

Still, there was nothing, and Steve groaned in frustration as he tried one more time. “Goddammit, Maxine! Do you copy?!”

“Jesus Christ, Steve, what do you want?” Max’s voice finally came through the static, sounding annoyed.

“Finally! Look, are you and your mom home right now, or are you out?” Steve asked, holding the steering wheel and the walkie both with a grip so tight it could crack walnuts.

“No, my mom’s at work and I’m with the rest of the Party, why? Is something wrong?” Max asked, the sass draining from her tone immediately.

“How long are you guys gonna be out?” He asked, nearly driving straight through a stop sign.

“Mom works until six and we just got to the arcade, we’ll probably be here for at least a few hours, why? Tell me what’s going on, Steve,” Max said, but Steve ignored her.

“I can’t tell you anything, Max, just trust me. Stay at the arcade, okay?” He said, making a sharp turn onto Cherry Lane with one hand.

“Steve, you’re scaring me, tell me what’s going on!” Max pleaded, but Steve was already pulling into the driveway, and he switched off the radio as he parked in Billy’s usual spot. He grinned the way a jungle cat might while stalking its prey as he grabbed his bat and made his way to the door, lifting up the mat and finding the key he knew was hidden there. He unlocked the door and walked inside like he owned the place, hearing the TV playing loudly in the living room and following the sound until he was standing in the doorway, finding Neil sprawled on the couch with a mostly empty bottle of Jim Beam in his fist. He startled as he noticed the boy that seemed to miraculously appear in his living room, jumping to his feet and lifting the bottle up defensively.

“What the hell? The fuck are you doing in my house?!” Neil yelled, stepping forward with shaking legs. Steve didn’t say anything, just walked into the room with his bat propped on his shoulder, still grinning like the cat that ate the canary and using his other hand to deck the man right in the face, sending him flying back into the couch. The man looked at him with wild eyes as blood began to trickle from his nose, and as soon as he found his footing, he launched himself at Steve. 

Steve dropped his bat to the floor and planted his feet as he dodged the brunt of the man’s attack. He had an advantage, being sober as a priest on Sunday, and he used it for all it was worth, making sure he stayed light on his feet but could plant them if he needed to, and he was better able to predict where the other man’s blows were going to land before they’d even gotten started. He planned out his own attacks and set them into action, letting some of that rage that had been festering in him since he’d seen Billy’s beaten face out in every punch that hit its target. He had taken a few hits himself, but he could hardly feel them, the only thing he felt was adrenaline and the euphoric feeling of his fist colliding with the other man’s face. Finally, he’d fought him to the ground and twisted an arm around his back, his knee digging into his back and making him grunt in pain as he reached out for his bat again.

“Now you listen to me,” Steve growled, his voice as cold as ice, “If you ever lay a hand on your son again, or if you ever try to hurt your wife or your step-daughter, I won’t be going so easy on you next time, do you understand me?”

“Ah, you’re the Harrington boy, aren’t you?” Neil slurred, a humorless laugh coming out of his throat, “You got some nerve breaking into my house and laying your hands on me like that, not to mention threatening me, and for what? For that fuckin’ fag my whore of an ex-wife gave birth to? I’ll tell you what, you really got a set of balls on you, boy. I might’ve even had a little bit of respect for you, if you hadn’t put yourself on the line for that fuckin’ bitch of a kid I have to call my son.”

Steve let out an even darker laugh than Neil had, grabbing him by the hair and yanking hard on it so that he had to look him in the eyes, “Say one more fuckin’ word, you bastard,” he paused, brandishing his bat dangerously close to the older man’s eyes, “And maybe there won’t even be a next time for you to look forward to. Maybe I’ll just bash your fuckin’ head in right now, save the rest of the people who have the misfortune of sharing your last name from having to deal with your bullshit any longer.”

“You won’t. You’re too chickenshit,” Neil said, letting another laugh past his lips, but this one was laced with fear, “Ain’t no way you’d go to prison for my fag of a son. And I’ll tell you what else, boy, the second you leave here, I’m gonna call up your daddy, let him know what a fuckin’ pansy-ass bastard you are. And I’m sure you know how quick gossip spreads in this tiny little town, and I know you know how fuckin’ twisted up and violent some of these folks can get when they find out they got a bunch of candy-asses livin’ amongst ‘em. If you really wanna protect yourself and that fairy son of mine, you’ll leave right now, and all this can just stay between us. Otherwise, I’d watch my back if I were you, cuz boy, you don’t even know what kind of a shitstorm I could stir up if I wanted to.”

“Oh, but you won’t,” Steve’s grin was downright homicidal, “You’re too chickenshit. Yeah, you could cause me a bit of inconvenience, I’ll give you that. But Chief Hopper is a friend of mine, and I got connections at the Hawkins Post. Two phone calls is all it would take to discredit you, get you arrested, and chalk anything you say up to the ramblings of a monster who was trying to cover his own ass. One more phone call, and anything you own, your house, your car, your business, even the goddamn clothes off your back are gone. My father already practically owns your ass, what with being your boss and all, and ten little numbers punched into a piece of plastic and a few carefully chosen words are all it will take to leave you with nothing. And if all else fails,” Steve paused, striking the bat down on the floor mere inches from the older man’s face with a sickening smack, “I’ve still got my baby over here. Do we understand each other?”

“Jesus Christ, you’re insane!” Neil yelled, unable to hide the fear in his voice even if he’d tried to.

“Ha! Maybe,” Steve said, standing up again, but keeping his grip on Neil’s hair and held it so that they were face to face when he bent at the waist, “But I’m dead fuckin’ serious. And unless you want me to stick Miss Louisville so far up your ass you’re spitting out nails for the next month, I suggest you don’t fuckin’ test me on that.”

Steve threw his head down to the floor as if he’d been burned by it, then straightened up and walked out, whistling as if nothing had happened and flipping his bat around in impressive little moves he’d learned when he got bored at batting practice for the school team. He got to the door of the house and slammed it shut, then dropped the key back under the mat and drove home, feeling better than he had in a long time.

When he walked back into his living room after his little excursion, Steve felt his heart clench with too many muddled up emotions. The lights were off and the pizza was gone except for the slices with his toppings on them, as was most of the soda. The TV was playing one of the movies Eddie had been wanting to watch earlier, painting him and Billy in streaks of blue and purple light where they rested on the couch. Eddie was sitting up at one end, a pillow on his lap so Billy could rest his head there. He was lying on his back, his head tilted so that his injured ear was towards the ceiling, and Eddie held an ice pack on it while Billy slept. There was another ice pack placed on his right side over his ribs, held in place by Billy’s left hand so that the ice could soothe his broken fingers as well. He stayed asleep as Steve walked into the room, but woke up as Eddie shifted a bit to grab the TV remote and shut off the set, then turned to flick on a lamp.

“And just where the fuck were you?” Eddie asked, clearly annoyed and worried out of his mind if his thoroughly bitten nails were anything to go by. “We were worried sick! And now you come home almost an hour later with a shiner to match Bill’s and cuts all over you! What, were you hitting yourself in the face with your bat?”

“No, actually, I just had something to take care of,” Steve replied, sitting down next to Billy once the other boy sat up and peppering hundreds of soft kisses all over him, in every spot that he was hurt.

“You went to talk to my dad, didn’t you?” Billy asked, reaching out to gently touch the darkening skin around Steve’s eye.

“Yeah, I did. And believe me, I gave him what he had coming to him, but obviously I had to take a few hits in the process,” Steve replied, a sheepish smile coming to his face. “I don’t mind it, though, especially since it’s my fault that he did all that to you. It was my stupid dare that started all this, and it was my father that relayed the message to yours. I had to go and make sure your dad knew who he was messing with.”

“No offense, Stevie, but as much as I love the thought of you being my knight in shining armor, that was fuckin’ stupid. Now he’s gonna have, like, a whole vendetta against you. He’ll do anything in his power to make your life miserable, and he’ll stop at nothing to make that happen,” Billy said, his voice full of dejection.

“No he won’t, angel. I made sure that that wouldn’t happen,” Steve said, brushing some of his hair from his beautiful blue eyes, “Look, I’m sorry I didn’t tell you where I was going, but I knew you’d try to stop me if you knew, and I had to be able to go and try and fix this. So I went to your dad and I told him exactly what I’d do if he tried to cause you, me, Eds, or anyone else any more trouble, and I made sure he understood me before I left. It was my fault that this whole thing started, and I love you both too much to let anyone get away with hurting you that easily. And I told him that if he ever laid a hand on you, Susan or Max ever again, I’d be back, and next time I wouldn’t go so easy on him.”

Neither Billy nor Eddie had anything to say after that, they didn’t even take notice to the fact that Steve implied he would kill a man for them. The only thing they could think about during and after that whole speech was the fact that Steve had told them he loved them. 

None of them had ever said that to the others before. They’d felt it, sure, but to voice it, to put it out in front of them and tell the others with the actual word was a whole other thing. They’d all been too afraid up until now to even try. But Steve couldn’t let himself be afraid anymore, not when he realized how close he’d come to losing one of the people who held his heart in their hands, and all because he had a father incapable of loving him as much as Steve did. He wasn’t going to let that go unsaid for a second longer, not when Billy needed to hear him say it most.

Billy still couldn’t say anything as he took the ice from his ear and held it up to Steve’s bruised jaw, leaning in and kissing him with every word he couldn’t bring himself to say just yet. His eyes were full of tears as he pulled back, but he was smiling, and he didn’t let it fade as he settled back into the couch next to Eddie, sitting this time and leaning his head on his boyfriend’s shoulder. Steve sat back on his other side, crossing his legs underneath him and holding Billy’s hand on his thigh, careful to avoid hurting his broken fingers. Eddie turned the movie back on and they continued to watch it, only a few minutes passing when Billy squeezed their hands.

“I love you both, too, by the way,” he said, his voice barely loud enough to be heard above the TV. “Y’know, just in case you were wondering.”

“Same here,” Eddie said, grinning, “I love you both with all my heart. Even if you do run off and make it nearly jump out of my chest from time to time.”

“Good, because I meant it when I said it earlier. I’d quite literally go to Hell and back to make sure you’re both safe and happy, that’s how much I love you,” Steve said, gazing at the both of them fondly.

After that, they were quiet, just watching the movie and shifting around a little so that they were all comfortable on the couch. Eddie laid down so that his back was to the arm of the couch, a pillow propped behind him to make it a little more comfortable on his back. Steve moved to the middle and laid down on his back between Eddie’s legs, his head resting on a pillow on Eddie’s stomach and one of his own legs draped over the backrest of the couch. He had a pillow on his stomach as well, and Billy laid the right side of his face on it, lying on his stomach with his ankles hanging off the other couch arm and a blanket tossed over him. They’d all taken their jeans off so that they were more comfortable, and Steve had gotten Billy an old oversized t-shirt to wear instead of the one that was still covered in blood. 

When Marjorie Harrington walked into her living room that night, having decided to skip the trip and come home early to make sure her son was okay, she found them all still lying in that position, the TV playing nothing but static and the empty pizza box and soda bottle still out on the coffee table. They were fast asleep, wrapped up in blankets and pillows and curled up around each other, even though both Steve and the blonde-haired boy both appeared to be injured. Margie shook her head at them with a fond smile on her lips, tip-toeing through the living room so as not to wake them as she turned off the TV and cleaned up the trash and dishes. 

Margie watched them for a while once she had the living room cleaned up, smiling as the other boy, the one with the long hair, snored loudly the whole time, and the blonde one was drooling all over the pillow and the front of Steve’s shirt. She remembered their names, Eddie and Billy, but she couldn’t remember which boy was which. She figured she could learn them again tomorrow over breakfast, and she sighed and shook her head again as she went back over to the couch. She kissed all three boys on their heads and left the room then, walking to the stairs so she could go to bed herself.

“You sure know how to pick ‘em, Stevie,” she said as she went, and allowed herself a little laugh at her son’s expense. 

Series this work belongs to: