Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Season of the (Love) Witch

Summary:

With another gentle huff, Steve peeled his gardening gloves off and tossed them into an empty bucket, going back inside his house. It was an old thing, with shutters on the windows and almost a century old, settled quietly in a secluded area. It was littered with dried herbs and flowers, empty vials lining his pantry and a small cauldron resting on his stovetop.

If anyone were to come in here, they’d call him a witch. And they’re not wrong, no. But he’s not a witch witch.

He’s a love witch.

Notes:

For Harringrove Week October 2022
Prompts: Witches x Online Dating & 2020s

Inspired by the film 'The Love Witch' because I believe Steve would resort to love magic, he's desperate for it like that, but I added my own little twist at the end.
Thanks for reading!!

Work Text:

Well, there goes another one, Steve thinks with a sigh, his brows pinched and upturned.

Feeling forlorn is something he’s slowly becoming used to, especially as he holds his bloody athame to his chest and watches Tommy bleed out on his bedroom floor. He can feel the warmth of blood slowly trickle down his hand and arm, taking a deep breath before turning to clean the mess they’ve made. 

I should’ve known, he laments to himself as he wipes his dagger off, he was a Pisces.

Wrapping the body up in his shower curtain had been harder than he expected, the guy was heavy, but Steve managed to get him downstairs and outside, burying him just under the flowerbeds beside his house.

Perhaps he’d make a better fertilizer than he was a boyfriend.

With another gentle huff, Steve peeled his gardening gloves off and tossed them into an empty bucket, going back inside his house. It was an old thing, with shutters on the windows and almost a century old, settled quietly in a secluded area. It was littered with dried herbs and flowers, empty vials lining his pantry and a small cauldron resting on his stovetop.

If anyone were to come in here, they’d call him a witch. And they’re not wrong, no. But he’s not a witch witch.

He’s a love witch.

Because that’s all he wants: to love and be loved. It’s a desire unlike anything else - something even more powerful than the ache of hunger and the call of sleep. It’s like a biological function; love keeps his broken heart beating.

Nobody gets it, which is the most frustrating thing. He’s gone on plenty of dates back in Chicago, he spent literal hours on Grindr sorting through profiles with no pictures and guys who only wanted to fuck. They all want one thing: sex. And while love and sex could and did coexist, the balance was skewed and Steve often found himself aching for more.

He didn’t want just carnal pleasure - he wanted to be held, to be seen, to be heard, to fucking love. He wanted it to be all-consuming. He wanted it reciprocated, most of all.

Because he knew what it felt like to have it not be. He knew the pain of having his heart and soul ripped out of his body by the betrayal of a loved one, of wandering eyes and hearts. His ex-boyfriend had abruptly left him for someone else and he’d been spiraling ever since.

Perhaps it was pathetic, but he had to leave after that, so he left his busy lifestyle in Chicago and traded it in for a sleepy town hours away - in Hawkins, Indiana.

With access to his trust fund, the world was his oyster. He’d taken his car and drove, letting himself go wherever the road took him, and once he’d passed the ‘Welcome to Hawkins’ sign...he felt it. Something was different here, it was in the air and in the ground, like it--like it called to him. Here, he’d find the one. He’d find himself and his greatest love. 

It wasn’t until he moved in and discovered an old book in the basement that Steve learned the power of Love Magic. Perfumes and colognes to entice, potions to mesmerize, mantras and spells to manifest and attract. Everything he believed in when it came to love aligned that day, and he was eager to start his ‘hunt’.

The dating pool in Hawkins was small, especially when it came to bisexual or gay men, but that didn’t deter him. He was certain he’d find love here. 

He had to.

+

Missing posters went up around Hawkins and Steve was miserable. Everywhere he went, he saw his ex! Poor Tommy Hagan, gone without a trace.

Steve sits down in the local coffee shop and opens Gindr again.

Someone with the name ‘You&MyCamera’ messages him, and it’s a little intriguing. Camera? Perhaps he’s into photography? Perhaps he’s the opposite of Tommy and is exactly what Steve needs?

“Hey - are you using this?”

Steve glances up from his phone and blinks, catching sight of the bluest eyes he’s ever seen and a lovely spiced scent invades his senses at the same time. Very nice cologne. Blond curls, lightly freckled nose, cute ears, a silver ring on his hand that’s resting on the back of the extra chair at Steve’s small table.

He manages a small shake of his head with a small smile, “No, I’m not.”

The blond gives him a quick once-over and Steve straightens his back a little, admiring the way the other man smiles at him and mumbles, “Thanks.”

Steve doesn’t look away even as the blond takes the chair and slides it over to the next table, where a younger girl with red hair is sitting and pouting. He can’t really look away from the blond, either, not until his phone vibrates and he looks down to find that Mr. Camera has messaged him about meeting up.

+

It turns out that Mr. Camera is actually named Jonathan, and he’s very much into photography. In fact, when they first meet up, he wants to take pictures of Steve - artsy stuff, too, with shadows and silhouettes, something a little dark. They talk openly about what they want from life and about their fantasies over strong cocktails in Jonathan’s living room.

Which works for Steve because he himself is a fantasy, or at least tries to be. He wakes up early to take care of himself - he’ll pamper his body in a bath with pressed oils and homemade soaps, skincare from the earth, cologne he made himself, and he wears his clothes well. Tailored to his body, as they should be. His hair is always a perfect mess, too. Ensuring that he looks good always makes him feel good.

Jonathan is...not so much into those things. He brushes his teeth and brushes his hair and doesn’t even bother wearing cologne. He’d rather stay up late watching old films or developing his photos, or learning about cameras and how to get the perfect shot. He’s passionate, but other than that, they don’t have much in common at all. 

And Steve is irritated. He likes Jonathan well enough, he’s shy and cute, he’s good in bed, but he’s just...distracted. He should be loving Steve every chance he gets, not fiddling with silly old cameras or telling Steve that he can’t go out with him because his friend Nancy needs his help with something important.

But, not to worry. Steve knows how to fix it. He flips open his spell book at home and gathers his ingredients, following the recipe as his cauldron gently simmers. He invites Jonathan over that night and pours the dark, shimmering liquid into some tea, smiling as he smells the earthy scent of it before it’s gone, masked by the mint and flowers in the tea.

“I didn’t think you’d want me over so late,” Jonathan admits as he settles down on the couch with a smile, “What’s the occasion?”

Steve carefully brings the small tray over to him, smiling at the other man before giving him a little pout, “Am I not allowed to miss you and want you around whenever I want, Byers?”

“I suppose not,” Jonathan laughs softly, taking one of the cups as Steve offers it.

He watches Jonathan take a careful sip, wary of the temperature, but then his eyes cloud over a little and he takes another sip, humming in approval, “’S good,” he mumbles.

“I know,” Steve smiles, leaning back against the couch and brushing his hand over Jonathan’s soft hair, “Drink up.”

Jonathan finishes the tea before it even cools and if Steve could, he’d purr in satisfaction.

+

Things go...well. 

The potion works like a charm, for maybe a week. Jonathan is attentive and wants Steve around all the time, he even takes them out to the pumpkin patch one sunny Saturday afternoon - without Nancy, for once.

It’s a cute date, they take pictures with an old camera and pick out pumpkins, Steve holding his small green pumpkin against his chest as Jonathan goes off to fetch them some hot apple cider - his treat, of course. 

It should be a perfect afternoon and yet Steve is still irritated.

He has no idea why. He stands in his spot, pumpkin held against his coat, and watches Jonathan stalk away in his plain jacket and old jeans, so eager to please Steve now. He’s like an eager puppy and he’s sweet and shy and yet--

Steve jolts forward suddenly, bumped from behind, and whips his head around with a frown - only to blink in surprise.

The blond, from the cafe.

“Oh, shit - my bad,” the other laughs quietly, “I was looking over at the pumpkins and not where I was going—wait,” he furrows his brows a little as a knowing look slowly crosses his handsome face, “We’ve met before, haven’t we?”

“Briefly,” Steve finally says once he’s regained control of his tongue, admiring how that denim jacket sits on the other man’s shoulders, “You stole a chair from me at the cafe.”

“Stole?” The stranger grins, amused, “Pretty sure I asked before taking it.”

“Hm,” Steve hums with a playful look, feeling a cool breeze against his face that carries the strong scent of cologne, something spiced with musk and a bit of floral, and his brain goes blank.

“Billy,” the blond introduces himself after a moment of the two of them just staring, holding his hand out, “My name’s Billy.”

Billy. Steve smiles as he reaches out and takes his hand, feeling the firm grip and the warmth it provides his cold fingers, “Nice to meet you, Billy. My--”

“--I’m back!” Jonathan announces from just behind them.

Steve pulls his hand away from the blond and turns around to smile at his date, about to open his mouth to say something when Jonathan pushes the cup of cider into his cold hands and presses a kiss to his cheek. Steve blushes and glances over at Billy, curious to see the way those blue eyes stare at Jonathan, who is pretty oblivious to the blond as all of his attention is rightfully on Steve.

“C’mon, we can go get lost in the corn maze while we drink these,” Jonathan smiles, tugging on Steve’s arm, eager to go.

And Steve loves that idea so he nods, but casts one last look at Billy, who’s gaze slowly slides from Jonathan and back over to him, lifting a brow in question. But, he says nothing. He shoves his hands into his jacket and gives Steve a small, tight smile before nodding his goodbye, turning on his heel to head back to wherever he came from.

No matter how hard he tries, Steve can’t get that look out of his mind.

+

A week or two passes.

And Steve is annoyed because he’s run out of an herb and so his potion isn’t as strong. Jonathan starts to become distant, stops coming around whenever Steve asks him to, he starts staying home again and skipping dates in favour of hanging out with Nancy. He starts treating Steve like he isn’t a priority.

Sick of it, Steve finds another recipe in his book and realizes that he can get one of the ingredients locally. With a sense of renewed hope, he rushes off to the local flower shop, which is run by a lovely lady named Chrissy. She welcomes him warmly and smells just like a rose, directing him towards the back of her shop where the dried items are kept.

When he gets to the back, he runs into a familiar face, which stops him dead in his tracks.

Billy looks over at him and smirks softly, holding a small packet of dried elderberry as he hums playfully, “Are you stalking me or something?”

“Or something,” Steve chuckles with a small shake of his head, going over stand next to Billy and see what dried goods he could find, continuing to speak, “Although I’m starting to think you’re stalking me.”

“Relax, pretty boy,” Billy hums as he puts the elderberry back and reaches for the rosebuds, “I have better things to do with my time than stalk you.”

Steve rolls his eyes and grabs the pouch of rosebuds that Billy was reaching for, delighted to have Billy looking at him again, even if it’s a sharp look. He smiles with a little shrug, “I dunno, I think I’m worth stalking.”

Billy lifts a brow, barely even blinking as they stare at one another, “You think so, hm?”

“Mhm,” Steve nods, and then gives the blond a curious look, “What are you buying rosebuds for, anyway?”

Turning to face him, Billy smiles meanly as he speaks, “My sister wants them, if you must know. She’s in school right now and Chrissy’s shop has weird hours so I’m grabbing them for her.”

“Aww,” Steve coos just as mean, enjoying this little bit of strange banter as he fails to keep a small smile off his face, “Such a sweet older brother, aren’t you?”

There’s a darkness in Billy’s eyes, blue like a stormy ocean as he smirks at Steve and shakes his head ‘no’ slowly, muttering, “I’m not as sweet as I look.”

Steve licks his lips, feels his stomach flutter as Billy comes closer and that same spiced, floral musk fills his nose. It has him whispering as he stares into those blue eyes, “Yeah...you don’t look very sweet to me, I take back what I said.”

“Good,” Billy hums, and then plucks the pouch of rosebuds right out of Steve’s hands, looking very pleased with himself as he steps around him, “See you around, pretty boy--”

“Steve,” he interrupts, all but whipping around to watch Billy stop and glance back at him curiously from over his muscled shoulder. Steve clears his throat, “My name is Steve.”

Billy looks him over again, slowly, with purpose, until he smirks and says, “I like ‘pretty boy’ better.” And turns to head to the front of the shop to buy the rosebuds, leaving Steve to stand alone and stare.

+

He’s certain Jonathan is in love with Nancy and she is just as in love with him and it hurts.

What does Nancy have that he doesn’t? 

He even considers the possibility that Nancy has whipped up her own potion for Jonathan, but he knows that she is no witch, she’s just a smart girl with a lot of passion. When they had first met, they’d discussed a lot of things - one in particular being love.

“Love is nice, but it’s not something I’ve ever really obsessed over,” Nancy had said as she lifted her teacup to her small mouth, looking at Steve as she did, “There’s so much more to life than romantic love.”

And he had wanted to scoff, to roll his eyes, because obviously there was but everything paled in comparison. Instead, he indulged her as he plopped a sugar cube into his tea and asked, “Like what?”

“Your career, for one,” she said after a long sip, “Your hobbies, traveling, reading - plenty of things.”

Apparently four things was ‘plenty’ to her, but Steve just gave her a small smile as he stirred his tea, glancing over at Jonathan to see clear admiration in those dark eyes as he stared at her.

What did Nancy know about love, anyway. She never spoke about past loves or what her ideal partner would be - although Steve had a sneaking suspicion on what or who that might look like. While she did complicate Jonathan and his relationship a lot, she also never made any moves on him, and Steve had to wonder if she ever would.

Perhaps it was cruel and mean, but he liked having what she didn’t. What she couldn’t.

That was, until he’d caught them, on a Sunday afternoon a few days after purchasing his dried herb.

Steve had spent all morning cooking up the new potion and infusing it within freshly baked lemon squares, eager to see the effect this recipe would give. He was so wrapped up in his own thoughts that he hadn’t seen Nancy’s car out front, too busy fussing with the little box in his hands as he opened the front door with the hidden key under the mat.

When he had opened the door, he heard a squeak, like a mouse, and looked up to see Jonathan pressing Nancy into the wall, his mouth on her neck and her fingers digging into his shoulders, a look of pure desire across her face.

He’d dropped the lemon squares onto the floor and the two broke apart, calling after him as he rushed out of the house, pinching the bridge of his nose to hold back tears.

It wasn’t fair. Even with the use of magic, he was unlovable.

He got back into his car and drove aimlessly for a long time, placing a cigarette between his lips and lighting it, taking long drags until it burned his lungs a little. He drove with it pinched between two fingers on the steering wheel, his brows also pinched as he thought. 

There was something here, still calling to him, but what was it?

Perhaps he was wrong, or maybe his intuition was messed up. Maybe Hawkins was a bad idea.

The sun is beginning to set so he decides to head back home, rounding a curve and nearly slamming on his breaks as he almost rear ends another car parked on the side of the road.

“What the--” he huffs as he pulls over just ahead of the old Camaro and looks in his rearview mirror with a frown, but his eyes widen as he spots a familiar head of blond curls in the driver’s seat.

Billy. 

Steve parks his Beamer and gets out, watches as Billy looks up from his lap and a smile appears on that handsome face.

“Well, well, looks like my knight in shining armor has arrived,” Billy chuckles as he pulls himself out of the car and looks Steve over.

That familiar cologne is in his nose again before he’s even near Billy, almost like he’s expecting it now, and he stops just a few feet away. His eyes go down to the tires on the car and spots the problem: one of the rear tires is completely blown. He glances up at the blond again, quirking a brow, “Haven’t called a tow truck yet?”

“Phone’s dead,” Billy sighs and clicks his tongue, because isn’t that just shit luck, before holding up a paperback for Steve to see, “Been trying to pass the time until someone drove by, and lucky me, someone finally did after two hours.”

“Two hours?” Steve frowns, “What are you doing out here, anyway?”

Billy smirks, “I could ask you the same thing.”

Steve purses his lips, looks away, because the hurt is still fresh and raw and Billy quickly catches his change of mood because he clears his throat and asks, “Could you give me a lift back home so I can grab my spare?”

And who is Steve to leave a man stranded?

+

Having Billy as a passenger is probably the best thing to happen to Steve. The entire drive back to town, they talked - about everything. Where they were from (Billy was from California), what they were doing here (Billy was the legal guardian for his younger step-sister until she finished high school), where their family was (Billy said his father and step-mother were six feet under and his mom wanted nothing to do with him), what they liked to do in their spare time (Billy liked to work out and garden and read), and there wasn’t even a moment where they fell into awkward silence. 

It was easy.

And once he pulled up to Billy’s house, the blond had reached over to place his hand on top of Steve’s on the steering wheel, giving it a gentle squeeze in silent thanks. It made him smile, and he nodded his head towards the house, “Go on, I’ll be here.”

It was odd, to be so willing to help Billy like this when he could be nice and cozy at home, but...he also didn’t mind. He liked helping - he liked being useful, no, needed. He loved feeling needed and wanted.

And Billy needed and wanted him.

So much so that when Billy had finally put his spare on and Steve had chatted his ear off the entire time, the blond had asked him to dinner with a soft, shy, barely-there smile and Steve had sighed a soft ‘yes’.

+

The desperation he felt for Jonathan had lessened and lessened as the days went on, especially when he had Billy.

It could have something to do with the fact that he’d put a curse on the new happy couple, but, it was definitely because of Billy.

The blond was everything he had ever wanted. Strong, smart, masculine - to start. Billy had a burning fire within him, Steve could see it in his eyes, and he was entranced by it. Billy was attentive and caring, cold to everyone else that he didn’t care about, and Steve adored him. He loved it when Billy would stop by with either a book or movie and some wine or beer for them to share.

Steve’s favourite thing to do was put on some gentle background music and drink Billy’s homemade strawberry wine while the blond read to him. It was romantic and thoughtful and everything Steve wanted. It was everything Billy wanted, too.

But, as the days turned to weeks, Steve felt…insecure. Billy was an absolute dream and if his previous loves had fizzled out, maybe Billy would, too - and he couldn’t have that.

So, he made his potion. The herb had grown back better than ever so he cut a few leaves and brought them inside, pulling out his faithful spell book and cauldron.

He knew it wasn’t the best idea, to give Billy this potion when the blond already seemed so invested, but he didn’t want to lose that. He couldn’t risk Billy not loving him.

+

It’s a Sunday night when Billy comes over again, Steve greeting him at the door with a smile and a kiss, letting himself get wrapped up in the blond’s affections and quiet tenderness. Billy murmurs how he’s missed Steve, right into his ear, and Steve melts in his arms.

“We saw each other, like, two days ago,” Steve can’t help but laugh softly, feeling the brush of Billy’s lips and moustache against his neck as he’s kissed there.

“Mm, doesn’t matter,” Billy mumbles, sliding his palm down the curve of Steve’s back, slowly, until he’s grabbing a handful of his ass and Steve pushes him away with a playful look.

“Hands to yourself, bub,” he grins, still letting Billy grab his wrist and pull him back in, although he does rest his hands on Billy’s chest where his shirt is unbuttoned wide open, “You want a drink?” He hums.

Billy nods, smiling softly as they stare at each other for another moment and Steve takes a deep breath of that spiced cologne and sighs dreamily, feeling safe and warm and loved just like he’s always wanted and deserved.

“Tea?” Steve murmurs, peeling Billy off of him with a grin as the blond continues to paw at him, making Steve laugh again, “Enough! I need to make the tea!”

“Alright, alright, princess - don’t get your panties in a bunch,” Billy smirks, giving him a smack on the ass before heading over to the living room to sit down and wait for the tea.

Which, of course, contains a few drops of the new potion. Steve watches it shimmer in the tea, stirring slowly, and places the spoon aside to bring the small tray over to the living room - where he finds Billy touching his neck and wrists from his spot on the couch.

Billy abruptly stops, his eyes wide like he’s been caught, until he spots the teacups and pats the spot beside him. A silent ‘come here’, and Steve eagerly goes, noticing the small bottle Billy shoves back into his pants pocket.

“What’s that?” He asks as he sits, placing the tray down on the coffee table in front of them.

“Just my cologne,” Billy answers, “What kind of tea is this?”

Steve picks up Billy’s cup and hands it to him carefully, letting rough hands take the porcelain. “It’s just mint tea, picked it myself,” Steve smiles.

Billy’s brows lift at that, like he’s impressed, and he lifts the teacup to his mouth but freezes as he gives it a sniff just as his little bottle of cologne tumbles out of his pocket and onto the floor.

Steve’s immediately on it, bending forward to grab it off the hardwood and bringing it to his lap - and he freezes, too.

It’s a potion bottle. Just like his, but smaller, more portable. The liquid is a shimmering red-orange, like a bottled sunset, and he looks up at Billy to find the blond staring down into the tea.

“Is this—”

“Are you—”

They snap their mouths shut and look at each other, eyes wide in disbelief.

Billy’s the one to break the silence first, asking quietly, “What’s in this tea?”

And that makes Steve worried, because most people don’t notice the small shimmer and earthy scent just under the sharp mint. But Billy did the second he lifted the cup to his face.

Maybe it’s immature or stupid, but Steve doesn’t answer - instead, he holds up the bottle in his hand and gives Billy a questioning look, “I’ll tell you if you tell me what this is.”

Surprisingly, Billy looks…embarrassed. Just a little, because he sets the tea down onto his lap and looks away, his brows furrowing as he thinks his answer over. After a moment, he clears his throat gently and says, “It’s a…a love potion. A cologne, meant to entice the person meant for me.”

Steve blinks, shocked.

“Hold on,” Steve adjusts himself in his seat so he’s facing Billy head-on, holding up the bottle between them, “This is what I’ve been smelling for months? It was you?!”

Billy gives a small shrug, “I mean - yes? Unless someone else has placed a charm on you.”

No, Steve certain no one hasn’t. But then again, he didn’t expect Billy to be using love magic on him.

So, he opens the bottle and gives it a sniff - and yeah, that’s it, the spiced cologne he’s been smelling since they had first met in the cafe.

“Wait,” he says as he corks the bottle again, “When did you start this?”

“Just before you came to town,” Billy mutters, “I was working on manifesting and meditating when I saw a, um, sort of…vision. Messy brown hair and big doe eyes. I found a recipe that’s meant to help with attracting the person meant for me so I used it, and the next day, we met at the cafe. And then we kept meeting, almost by chance.” Billy pauses and lifts the tea again, staring down at it as he mumbles, “And now you’re…making me drink a…potion?”

Steve winces, because yeah, he is. “It’s the first time,” he blurts out, “With you. I…I haven’t used any magic with you because I didn’t want you to leave me. But I haven’t had to. You seem to like me as I am.”

Billy looks up again, this time in disbelief, because he says in a matching tone, “Of course I do. Stevie, you know this. I’m here every chance I can get, you don’t need to put me under a spell to make me love you.”

Love you.

Billy loves him.

“You love me?” Steve asks in a quiet, tiny voice.

And Billy gives him a tired, affectionate look. Smiles gently and nods. “You know I do.”

“And I love you. So, let’s stop this,” Steve says definitively, “No more cologne and no more love potion. Okay?”

“Okay,” Billy agrees with a small smile.

As if to prove it, he sets the cologne in front of them on the coffee table and takes Billy’s cup from him, going to the kitchen to make him a new one.

And that should be the end of it. No more potions, charms, colognes.

But Steve can’t stop.

He puts a single drop into the new cup of tea. Billy has to love him. Steve can’t let him go.

Perhaps it’s better this way, he thinks as he returns with the new cup and sits down, watching Billy take a sip, sealing their fate.

When he picks up his own cup from the coffee table, he notices a shimmering liquid in it and a spiced scent just under the mint.

He takes a sip and thinks, yes, definitely better this way.