Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

a little mad sometimes

Summary:

Billy Hargrove is not a fan of the horror film genre. 

 

harringrove harvest week, day 6

Notes:

prompt: Invite-Only Movie Marathon in the Backroom at Family Video

or: 4 times horror films fuck billy over and the one time they don't (sort of)
yes this is the exact opposite vibe to my other fic about billy loving horror lit. but i dont wanna talk about that. he's very multi-facetted thank u

I AM SO TIRED

the title is from the psycho quote don't fucking ask idk why either i'm really hanging onto my last nerve here my guys

can be found on tumblr as well

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Billy is nine when he first catches a piece of a horror film. 

He wakes up a couple of hours into his bedtime and just wants to go get some milk but when he passes by the living room he gets stuck watching the television. 

The film can’t have been on for long but his dad is lying asleep on the couch already. 

The movie is black and white like all his mother’s favorite movies are, but none of the films with Marilyn Monroe had ever felt like this.

Billy needs a moment to realize that he’s watching a silent film since the pictures themselves are enough of an impression.

He’s hiding behind the door frame and watches in terror as the monster comes on screen. The person looks grotesque, with long claws as fingers and spiked ears, with sharp teeth to top it all off. Its eyes are dark in the pale face and it scares Billy to the bone. 

But he can’t leave.

Billy’s stuck, frozen to the spot and keeps his eyes on the television. Terror settles in his body when he watches the woman on screen become more and more terrified. 

Later on he never quite knows how much of the film he watched, how long he stood in the door frame before one of his dad’s movements broke him out of his stupor, but he vividly remembers the shadow of the monster walking up the stairs to the lady’s bedroom and the fear the shadow of the claws on the wall had caused him. 

For weeks he dreams of nothing but the monster. Either he relives the film itself in dreams or he sees the creature coming for him or even worse, his mother. 

They ebb away slowly but even as he grows older the dreams come back time and time again. His mother has already left him and he still wakes in cold sweat thinking about sharp teeth sinking into her skin and clawed hands holding her. 

It’s decided in those moments that Billy Hargrove is not a fan of the horror film genre. 



Maxine is a little freak. No normal kid should react like this. She's laughing. Michael Myers just slit someone’s throat and Maxine is laughing.

Billy's fucking terrified. 

He had only gotten a copy of Halloween for the two of them because he was sure Max would be just as scared as he always is when watching any sort of horror movie. 

It’s absolutely not going according to plan and they’re barely half an hour into the film. Max is rooting for the psychopathic killer and laughing at the babysitters that are being killed.

She’s calling them stupid. She’s holding her bowl of popcorn and munches happily, snickering when one of the characters walks right into Michael. 

Billy is so tense it’s almost nice to be distracted by Max’ nonchalant reaction because it means he can’t scream at the film itself. It’s the only reason he makes it through the agonizing time it takes for the masked psycho to work his bloody way to Laurie. Billy honestly feels bad for her, she seems nice enough. 

When Michael Myers appears right behind Laurie, after he has already been sort of killed, Billy flinches so hard he makes the popcorn fall over and lets out a yelp he will deny until his dying day.

Max thankfully only laughs at him for a moment before her attention is back on the monstrosity of a movie. 

When Loomis shoots Michael Billy is really fucking relieved, and then of course the fucking body is gone. Of course no horror film could have an actual satisfying ending. 

The credits roll and the little demon he shares a house with turns to him with a goddamn smile, “Can we watch the other parts too?”

 

When he takes a girl to go see a rerun of Texas Chainsaw Massacre he knows it’s stupid. Billy knows he’ll end up being the scared one but one of his friends came up with the idea and Billy wasn’t about to announce that he gets scared by these films.

Since the fiasco with Max and Halloween he hasn’t even watched a single slasher, but his friends had decided they couldn’t miss the screening of this one. 

At least Billy had the foresight to ask Ashley to come with him and not someone he actually would’ve had to try to impress. Ashley has been in a class with him for years and there hasn’t ever been anything romantic between them, except for how she was his first kiss. An experience that was incredibly underwhelming for both of them. Mainly because Ashley is a lesbian and Billy is gay. 

To almost everyone else they appear like friends with benefits. It works for them when they can’t be bothered to look for another date to keep up appearances. It’s in both of their interests to keep up the idea of them being nothing but heterosexual. Mainly because Ashley’s dad is about as much of an asshole as Neil. 

It’s nice to have someone to complain to if he wants, though most of the time they just get high by the beach together and talk about running away to San Francisco or New York and the gay scenes that they’ve heard about. 

Billy is still nervous when they settle into their seats in the cinema. He’s picked the end of the row, so Ashley can sit next to Maya, who she’s had a crush on for just about a year now, and the rest of their friends are far away from him. Despite tension running high he easily manages to fall into their usual behavior and drapes his arm around Ashley’s shoulders. In return she holds out the cup of Coca Cola that they’re sharing so he can have a sip even if she doesn’t turn to him but instead keeps giggling with Maya. 

When the movie starts he can’t help but tense up, and he can even feel his hands beginning to become clammy. Ashley must notice the change in his body because she turns to him with a questioning eyebrow raised. He just shakes his head.

Pam gets killed on a meathook and Billy can’t make himself actually look at the scene. He turns his head and instinctively hides his face against Ashley’s dark curls. 

“Are you okay?” She whispers into his ear.

Billy swallows before he admits, “Not keen on horror.” 

He’s told her much worse about himself. 

“Shit, why are we here then?” She laughs a little. 

“Didn’t wanna be a pussy.”

“You are an idiot, my guy,” Ashley huffs in exasperation before she slightly changes their position, telling him to scoot down some more. “This way you can hide in my neck and no one will be able to see, or if they do they’ll just think you’re trying to sweet talk me.”

The roaring of a chainsaw on screen makes him jump a little before he can answer.

“Thank you.”

Ashley just squeezes his leg and for the rest of the film does so whenever he can’t help but flinch from the noises or the occasional thing he ends up seeing on the screen despite keeping his face away from it for the most part. 

Even with her support the movie shakes him even more than the others he’d watched so far. The human monsters hit him just a little too close to home.



Billy hates everyone. He hates Max and he hates Harrington and Buckley and he hates himself and all the other brats. He doesn’t hate Munson as much as everyone else but that’s only because Munson has weed. 

If it weren’t for Max and her wish to socialize him, and Harrington’s weird acceptance of it, or Buckley’s funny side comments, then Billy would never have said yes to spend Halloween with these people. But he did and now he’s stuck watching horror films.

They’re in the backroom of the Family Video store Buckley and Harrington work at, they’ve put up a shitload of pillows for everyone to sit on and really the only nice thing about this so far is the fact that Harrington is sitting next to him and their arms are pressed together a little. The contact is electrifying even if Billy really doesn’t want to think about it more. 

The nerds have picked out all the movies, and apparently only invited worthy people to take part in their horror movie marathon straight from hell. Billy scoffs when little Wheeler says they should all be honored. Especially when older Wheeler and Byers show up and it just means that the nerds invited everyone they know. He still gets a dirty look from Henderson for his clear dismissal of such an honor and he’s fairly sure the look is supposed to read something like You Weren’t Even Supposed To Be Invited But Max And Steve Threatened Not To Come If You Couldn’t. 

He gets through the first film better than expected but it’s only because Max’ pick was first and since he was the one to show her Halloween anyway it’s not as bad to watch all the bloodshed again. Harrington doesn’t move away from him the entire time and makes comments to him as well, not only to Buckley, and that doesn’t hurt either. 

The problem starts when the lady in Psycho gets stabbed in the shower and Billy jumps against all of him trying not to. Obviously Harrington notices. But through mind blowing self control Billy makes it through the rest of the film without anymore reactions that could give him away. 

They take a break after that and Max comes up to him when he lights up a cigarette outside of the store, mindful of the shadows around him that look so much worse after the two films.

“You haven’t even screamed yet,” she states with a smirk on her face. 

“Shut up, Max,” He glances around even though he knows they’re the only ones outside.

“It’s not a shame to be afraid of horror films, that’s kind of their point, you know?” Max’ looks way too smug for someone who flinched during the fucked up shower stabbing as well.

“I’m not scared. I survived an actual monster.” It’s good reasoning, he thinks.

Max disagrees. “Yeah, sure and because of that you suddenly are all cool with Michael Myers.”

Instead of answering her he takes a drag of his cigarette and pointedly looks away. Obviously she just sees an invitation to start more shit.

“You and Steve looked comfortable.”

“Max-” Billy looks around again, paranoia now much more real than before. “Quit it.”

“I wasn’t being mean,” her face sobers up a little and she plucks the cigarette out of his hand to take a drag herself. And, yeah, he knows she wasn’t. Not with this. 

“Harrington doesn’t swing that way.” Billy knows, and Max knows, but she still wants to see things that aren’t there.

Before she can argue again Harrington himself joins them outside, just like he felt them talking about him. 

“Can I bum a smoke off of you? Forgot my pack,” He looks sheepish at the admission, hand rubbing his neck and doe eyes hopeful. 

Billy doesn’t hesitate to hold out his half empty pack to him. He even leans in and holds up the lighter for Steve, eyes following the way the other’s cheeks hollow when he inhales.

Max coughs a little and when he looks back at her she has once again found her smug little smile. She holds out his cigarette to him and vanishes inside.

“What’s your favorite horror film then?” Harrington asks. “You probably like the slashers, right?”

“Actually, I’m not that fond of them,” Billy mumbles. It’s become easier to say shit like that to Harrington. Since everything that happened in the summer they’ve talked more and more. It’s been good for Billy’s healing. It’s not been good for Billy’s crush. 

“Oh. Well, that’s a twist,” Harrington laughs, but it’s not mean spirited. “Well, let me know if any of the others are too much we can just head out for a little whenever.”

Billy can’t really answer that verbally due to his throat closing up so he just nods and quickly looks down. 

They fill up the next moments with idle smalltalk until the small Byers comes out and ushers them back in to get started with his pick of the movie night. 

Billy didn’t expect small Byers to betray him like this. But within the first half an hour of The Shining Billy is fucking terrified. And questioning why Mrs Byers let her small son watch this film. 

He’s close to running out, fully accepting that Munson could use that as blackmail to get him to finally listen to his band, when Harrington’s hand settles on his own.

Billy couldn’t name a single other thing that happens in the movie after that to save his life. 

 

 

Billy is on Steve’s couch when he enjoys a horror film for the first time. Or well, at least it’s bearable. 

It took Steve months to convince him to watch this film and he only won because he got Billy the book and it turned out not to be bad. It didn’t hurt that even Eleven apparently liked it. 

Steve is busy putting the VHS in while he’s talking excitedly, “I promise, it’s not as scary as others. I mean you read it. That wasn’t scary. I don’t even know why I like it so much but after Robin made me watch it I just couldn’t get it outta my head-”

Billy lets him talk, he’s heard all the arguments before and it seems much more reasonable to focus on how pretty Steve is when he’s not even trying. He’s only in sweatpants and one of Billy’s Metallica shirts and his hair is falling all over the place. It’s Billy’s favorite style on Steve, his hair is much softer without any product and better to run his hands through. 

Steve still talks when he walks over to the couch where Billy is waiting for him, he absentmindedly grabs a blanket and like it’s the most normal thing to do pulls Billy with him when he lays down. They scoot around for a moment until Billy is between the couch’s back and Steve, though he’s technically mostly on top of him. His head is pillowed on Steve’s chest, close to his neck so he can hide in case everyone lied and the film is scary. 

“Ready?” Steve asks when they have the blanket settled over them finally. 

“As I’ll ever be,” Billy sighs. Steve laughs and kisses the top of his head.

“I’ll protect you, baby,” he says and presses play. 

Carrie starts and Billy tries to relax with his boyfriend’s steady heartbeat in his ear and his hand running softly over his back. 

Billy is about as safe as he can ever be and maybe that was the missing component all the time. Or maybe it was a protagonist he could root for.  

“She’s really a little like El,” he says when Carrie discovers her powers. 

“El has a better support system though,” Steve answers. He’s not wrong. 

When the pig blood comes down Billy feels rage on behalf of the girl who’s so mistreated at home and really no part of him blames her when she goes off on her classmates. Something inside of him even celebrates when she kills her mother. 

The credits roll and Steve is still holding him close.

“Was that alright?”

Billy nuzzles just a little closer, entirely unafraid for once, “Yeah, that was alright.”

Notes:

some context:
the first film billy sees is nosferatu bc it's my fic and i can put in obscure german horror films from 1922 thank u
second scene is about a year after max and billy moved in together
third one is shortly before the move to hawkins

idk if this turned out well at all i am so sorry

Series this work belongs to: