Chapter Text
When Steve was seven, his parents took him to a puppet show. It was one of the last things he can really remember doing as a family before he became an obligation, little him squished in between his parents as he watched these little marionettes on strings dance along to some music. He remembers the moment one of the puppeteers messed up, hand dipping down low enough that Steve could see it beneath the valence curtain. He remembers the walk back to the car, skipping happily with both hands held up in his parents’ while they asked him questions about the show.
“Do the puppets get sad?” he’d asked when he got back to the car, sitting in the middle seat so he could lean forward and stick his head over the center console.
“What do you mean, Stevie?” his mother asked from the passenger seat, an amused smile on her face and a twinkle in her eye that disappeared sometime after Steve turned twelve and got his first C- in English class—when ‘little Stevie has so much potential’ turned to ‘Steve, be quiet and try not to embarrass us too much’.
“Do they like being controlled? I wouldn’t like it,” he pressed with far too much seriousness in his voice for a kid. “I don’t wanna be a puppet.”
His dad laughed, eyes focused on the road but the sound pulled a little laugh from Steve too. His mom shook her head, fondness in her gaze as she reached around to give Steve’s chubby cheeks an affectionate pat.
“Oh, honey, you don’t have to worry about that. You’re a real person, you can’t be controlled like a puppet. We wouldn’t let anything like that happen to you, we’re always here for you.”
If Steve could, he’d call his mother now and tell her that she was full of shit. Because this? This was Hell on Earth. Ever since the night at Brimborn, Steve hadn’t quite been in as control of his body as he should be. He could still see, and sometimes he had moments of clarity where he could act like himself, but for the most part that other Dark Steve was in control, moving his limbs like a phantom puppeteer.
Please, let me out! I need to tell Hopper, I need to get to Billy.
Yes, let’s go to Hopper and Billy. Let’s build together.
Except no, no he didn’t want to get to Billy. Because this Thing was making him do horrible things, making him take people back to it to be taken over too. It had already made him grab Robin before their shift started at Scoops and God, God he hoped she was okay because he couldn’t live with himself if she wasn’t a—
No, he had to stay far away from Billy for as long as whatever was in him still had control. He’d managed to hold the thing off from Billy when he found him outside of Brimborn, had screamed in agony in his head as the Mind Flayer dug its claws in deeper to try to restore claim. It took everything in him not to close the distance to Billy even as the Mind Flayer said such horrible things, even as he saw the hurt and fear flashing across Billy’s face like beacons. He just had to hope that the others could figure this out, that they would realize something was wrong and they could get whatever this was out of him before he lost control completely.
As the Dark Him took them back home, Steve’s mind drifted to last November when Will Byers was sick. He’d seen him then, in that shed thrashing while he was tied up in a chair. Will was sweet and quiet, traumatized after whatever he’d experienced in the Upside Down. How he acted in that shed was decidedly not him, just like the words Steve had thrown back at Billy when he saw him at the ironworks building.
The Party had called it the Mind Flayer. So much had been going on that night that Steve didn’t fully understand it all, especially since large chunks of that night were missing ever since Billy had beat his face in. But he remembered the kids all gathered around that table, talking about strange solitary creatures and parasites and taking over the mind. He’d heard about how they’d gotten it out of Will, had seen the haunted look on Mrs. Byer’s face for weeks afterward because she’d had to hurt Will to get it out.
He thought they’d killed it when they closed the Gate, or at least trapped it away where it couldn’t hurt anyone anymore. God, he hoped it wasn’t that thing, wasn’t sure the team could survive another run-in with it.
Something told him it was.
Ever since the thing took control, Steve had far too much time to think. It was like it placed him in a holding pattern, sitting him down in the dark on his bed, feet planted perfectly on the ground just like Billy had once told him to do and back so straight it made Steve ache. It would just stare at the window, like it was waiting for something. These were the times when Steve had more awareness, but still couldn’t fucking move an inch .
He didn’t think he’d ever be able to watch Pinocchio again.
Steve didn’t know how long the Thing had him sit there, but eventually, his eyes glazed over and his vision blurred out from them being open for so long. He wondered only briefly if there would be lasting damage from doing that.
He’d had enough lasting damage for a lifetime. It was a phrase the doctors liked to use with him, like maybe it softened the blow of you’re gonna be fucked up for the rest of your life somehow. The doctor had used the phrase when Joyce dragged him to the hospital in November. Apparently, all the head trauma scared her, and it was a good thing too because the doctor started talking about migraines and possible seizures and that the pain behind his eyes might never quite go away. Steve never had seizures, but he did get frequent headaches, and when it was cold out the spot behind his eyes ached.
That got slotted down on the list of things he’d never tell Billy—along with the smack from his dad and how Nancy still liked to call him an idiot even when they all have to know how much that stings, and the time he’d gotten so trashed Freshman year that he’d climbed the top of the school in nothing but his briefs. He could already see the guilt weighing down Billy too often—dark flashes of it that made the other man try to distance himself from Steve like his very presence could hurt him the way it had hurt him in November.
Billy was undoubtedly the strongest person Steve has ever known. He’d have never let this happen to him , Steve thought miserably. He’d have fought it off, never stopped fighting until the Thing was out of him. He’d have never let it hurt people the way Steve did, of that he knew for sure.
Maybe this was the best role Steve could play in the world. The thought sounded strange in his brain, like maybe it was coming from the Thing but fuck did it sound just like all of his other thoughts. It sort of made sense, too, because what could he really contribute here?
He’d barely graduated high school and honestly, part of that was Billy practically doing some of his homework in April to bump up his grades. He knew the teachers caught the change in work, he also knew they’d let him slide by because who wanted to hold back a Harrington? He couldn’t help solve the mysteries from the Upside Down. All he could do was tag along and make sure the important people didn’t get hurt. He could throw his body at some Demodogs and take the hits because he was Steve Harrington, the expendable one. His only friends were middle schoolers and he had no fucking clue what he was going to do with the rest of his life. He knew what he wanted, but that was so far out of reach it physically hurt to think about sober. Even now, he’d hardly been able to fight off the Mind Flayer. Maybe it was better this way, not having to worry about controlling himself. He could sit back in the passenger seat, and let his mind roam while his body did all the heavy lifting.
Good, Steve. Let’s build together.
It was terrifying how quickly this Thing was melding with his brain, making itself sound like him most of the time. Steve hardly noticed he was walking until he was standing in front of the kitchen wall, phone tucked between his ear and shoulder. “Hello?”
“Steve, I’m sorry, okay?” That was Billy. It sounded odd to him, Billy was a lot of things but he wasn’t the type to apologize. At least, not with so many words. He used his actions most of the time, wanting to make up for anything he did by showing how much he cared rather than telling it to people. Steve could count on his fingers how many times he’d heard those two words from Billy’s mouth. “Let me make it up to you?”
“I’m busy, Billy,” the Thing spoke for him. It felt odd on his lips, like when the dentist would inject an anesthetic in his gums before a cavity filling.
“I won’t take no for an answer, pretty boy.” Billy’s voice was strained, tight like it hurt to get the words out. He was hurting and Steve couldn’t be there to help him. He couldn’t get near him because the Thing would get to him and Steve wouldn’t be able to stop it. He thinks he’d die if anything happened to Billy because of the Mind Flayer, because of his own hands. “I’m closing at the pool tonight. Come by around 9, men’s locker room. I’ll make it worth your while, I promise.”
No, no he couldn’t. He can’t go and he can’t do whatever Billy’s planning because it’s not him an—
“I’ll see you then.”
No! No, I can’t go I can’t do this please don’t make me do this!
We’re building, Steven. Don’t you want him by your side?
No, not like this!
It’s too late though. The Mind Flayer just goes back to sitting on that damn bed and when the sun sets to give rise to a beautiful night sky full of stars, it stands Steve back up. It hurries him to the busted Beemer and it drives him all the way to Hawkins Community Pool where Billy is waiting for him. Steve screamed in his head, banging his fists against the wall the Thing put up between him and the outside world, begging it not to do this. It can take anyone else, hell he’ll help it take anyone else if it means sparing Billy from more pain. Billy needs to make it to California. He needs to get out of Hawkins where he never wanted to be in the first place, he needs to know freedom and happiness, even if that doesn’t include Steve.
Billy can’t lose everything because of him, Steve knew he’d never forgive himself.
“Billy?” the Thing called out with his voice, seeing nothing in the immediate pool area. The last time he’d been here was a week ago, when he’d brought the Party to the pool mostly so he could visit Billy at work. The kids had a great time splashing in the pool together—though Steve shuddered at the thought of sharing a pool with so many people at once—and Steve had gotten to recline in the sun, with Billy in those red shorts reminding him to sunscreen up every so often ‘to protect that pretty boy face’ .
“In here, pretty boy!” Billy’s voice called out from the locker rooms.
Other Steve let out a huff of amusement, striding forward to pass the metal doors that would lead to the men’s locker room. It was as gross as he remembered—the smell of day old sweat and chlorine mixing with the harsh chemicals the cleaning staff had used on the floors before close.
The harsh chemicals stung Steve’s nose, made him want to puke knowing that those same smells would be coming from his stomach right now. He swore he could practically feel the cleaner his hands had grabbed from under the sink at home, throat still burning and weeping a—
“Billy? Where are you?” he called out again, walking past the lockers and down the hallway where he knew the showers and sauna were. He could hear Billy’s laugh, the one that always let Steve know the other boy had a devious plan in mind.
‘You’re trouble, you know that?’ ‘I also know you love it.’
He did, he loved it so much that his heart ached now, feeling ready to crumble under the weight of it as he stepped closer and closer to the sound. He didn’t want to do this, didn’t want to feel Billy’s struggling arms under him in the same way he’d felt Robin, as he let that Thing take the people he cared about most.
“C’mon, Stevie, what’re you waitin’ for?”
He was in the sauna. Steve rolled his eyes, “Billy, I’m not getting in the sauna with you.” The Thing’s defense mechanism. Steve could feel it panicking now, could practically hear its mind racing as it fought to get out of this situation knowing what a sauna would do to it.
And oh, maybe this was his chance. So Steve dug in further, tried to leap and climb over that mental wall for just long enough to take two steps directly into the sauna—where a CPR dummy strapped to a radio was waiting for him.
“I’m sorry, Steve,” Billy’s voice called out from behind him, making Steve wheel on his feet to see the man shutting the sauna door hurriedly, trapping him in.
Other Steve was panicking now, making their heart race and their hands slick with sweat. It was thrashing, angry at Steve. Why would you do this to us? DO YOU KNOW WHAT YOU’VE DONE? It took back control easily, shoving Steve back over the wall and leaving him powerless once more.
“Billy, please. What’s going on?” Other Steve begged, softening their features to give what Steve knew to be the doe eyes that Billy had called irresistible on more than one occasion. “Billy, let me out. C’mon, this isn’t funny.”
“It’s not him,” another familiar voice called out. Steve stepped closer to the door to see who it was, entire body pressed to the metal so he could see out the little window. Billy was right in front, barely an arms reach away from him. Max and El were close to him, standing just behind Billy’s outreached arm like he was protecting them from him .
Good, Billy please protect them. Don’t trust me, it’s not me it’s not me it’s not ME!
Even further beyond them, was the rest of the Party. Dustin had spoken judging by the pained look in the boy’s eyes. The last thing he wanted was for the kids to see him like this, for them to be standing directly in harms way for him. He wanted to tell them to run, to leave him behind and make sure the rest of them stay safe because the Thing was screaming at him again, telling him to build, build, build and he didn’t know how long he could resi—
“Please, it’s too hot. Please, Billy you’re gonna kill me like this!” Other Steve screamed as the sauna was turned to maximum power, the sweltering heat making sweat soak through his clothes. Billy winced, eyes looking just over Steve’s shoulder as Steve pounded on the door, begging each of them to let him out.
The heat was rising, rising, rising and it was going to kill them, it would and there would be nothing left to salvage a—
—and then there was a moment of clarity. It was longer than a moment of clarity, but rather like the band at snapped and catapulted Steve completely over that wall. He was back, having fallen to the ground in his heat exhaustion but there, really there for the first time since Brimborn. It wasn’t a permanent fix, he could still feel the Thing fighting, clawing painfully at his mind to get back in control. But he had time, he could warn them, he could get them away.
“You have to go, please,” Steve whimpered, and Billy must have understood the switch because he stepped forward closer to the door, hand up against the window of glass like he could feel Steve through it.
“It’s gonna be okay, Steve, you hear me? We’re gonna get whatever the hell that thing is out of you,” Billy told him.
“It’s back, it’s back, Billy,” Steve practically sobbed, chest heaving with the equal fear and relief of having control back. He wasn’t quite sure what to do with it, arms flopping oddly over his knees as though he’d completely forgotten how to move them. “That thing that was in Will, it’s in me I can feel it.”
“I know, I know, pretty boy.” Billy looked near tears. Maybe he was matching the streaming tears on Steve’s face, everything was a little too blurry to fully see it. “We’re gonna help you, okay? We’ll get it out like they got it outta Little Byers.”
Steve whimpered then, remembering the burns that Will had sustained in the process. He was already in enough pain, feeling the Thing fighting back against even this. How badly would it hurt him to rip it out now, when it had already dug its roots deep into him?
“I’ve done so many bad things, Billy,” Steve cried, head falling forward to rest against his arms and oh God, oh God he could feel it coming back. The Thing had broken through the wall and it was digging its hooks back in deep and he only had a moment before— “I love you, please, I love you.”—
—before the Thing regained control.
“I know, we know, Stevie. It wasn’t you, it was that fuckin’ Thing. None of it’s your fault, Stevie,” Billy was still saying, practically chanting it like a prayer for Steve to write into his heart. But Steve wasn’t there to receive it, only that Thing who was keeping their head down but whose arm was reaching reaching reaching for the broken scrap of the sauna tile, palm bleeding from how tightly he’d gripped it. “We’re not gonna leave you alone, Steve, you hear me? We’re gonna get you outta there and we’ll leave for California in the morning. I promise, pretty boy.”
“Billy, get back!” Max shrieked and Steve would forever be indebted to the girl because right then his body was flinging forward, fist punching through the glass and swiping the broken ceramic tile in the spot Billy’s head had been moments before.
Other Steve let out a wild growl, yelling and screaming like a wild animal as he swiped their arm through the window pane, cutting up the skin on the glass remnants. When that didn’t work, their body was moving, hands gripping the handle and pushing hard enough to bend metal. Steve could hear the others screaming, trying to work out a plan for when he inevitably escaped. He could hear himself laughing, bitter and cold in a way he never thought possible. He could hear Billy, too, yelling for the ‘stupid brats’ to stay back and out of the way, to get out of the room .
Steve once would have loved to see Billy try to wrangle those kids. He’d tried on more than one occasion to make it happen but it seemed Billy only really had a soft spot for Will, Max, and El. He hated seeing it now, knowing it was born from pure necessity because he himself had become this Thing, this monster that was trying to kill them. And how could he possibly let this Thing kill his kids after everything he’d protected them from before?
The chain around the door broke, sending the metal flying as Steve stepped around it. Almost immediately El’s hand was thrown up, the tips of her fingers flexing inward as she used her powers.
Steve had once wondered what it would feel like, to have her powers used against him. Now he thinks he was better off not knowing, feeling nothing but powerlessness and fear as an invisible hand gripped around his throat, feet lifting off the ground a few inches. He was still laughing, slightly wheezy around the chokehold but there, taunting.
The Mind Flayer had powers too. It forced her off of him, enough that his hands could grab her and throw her across the room to hit the wall with a harsh ‘smack’. And then, fuck and then he was on Billy, sending a wild punch to the face.
“It’s okay, Steve!” Billy shouted out, hands up to fight him back. There was one flaw though that would completely destory the boy—even now as Other Steve flew punch after punch his way, Billy was holding himself back, pulling his punches. He’d once promised to never hurt Steve again, because he’d never wanted to end up like his father.
Steve wished he would now, wished he could beg Billy to please just hurt him, it’s okay it’ll be okay just do it.
Instead they ended up on the ground, a sad echo of that night in November except now Steve could feel the cracking of Billy’s face under his knuckles, could hear the sounds coming from him and oh God, please stop It’s gonna kill him. It’s gonna kill him like this and it’ll be all Steve’s fault.
“Get off of him!” Max yelled, little body colliding into the side of Steve’s with enough force to knock him off of Billy’s body. She was far too brave for her own good, that girl. When all of this was over, Steve hoped he had the opportunity to thank her, to tell her to not risk her life for them anymore because she’d been hurt enough by life already, because none of these kids could get hurt on his watch.
El had recovered. Even the Mind Flayer knew this was a losing battle, so it didn’t fight as she wrapped that invisible pressing force around their neck again. Steve looked at Billy then, and the Mind Flayer allowed it, allowed him to hold the boy’s gaze even as he choked in the hair. It’s okay, it’ll be okay, he tried to tell Billy with that one look, though from the pained expression pulling at Billy’s face he wondered if it looked a little more like, save me, please, I don’t know how much longer I can take this.
Steve supposed it didn’t matter anyway, because in the next moment their body was flying through the wall of the poolhouse to land several yards away in the dirt. Even though he wasn’t in control, Steve could feel the agony swiping through every cell of his body as he landed, could feel a couple bones breaking and his lungs deflating with air as the ground offered no cushion from the throw.
The Mind Flayer, The Thing, Other Steve recovered far quicker than Steve would’ve. It picked them up off the ground and took off in a sprint Steve’s body should have never been capable of in this state.
Steve could only feel relief, knowing that It didn’t make him take anyone back to Brimborn. He could only feel guilt, knowing what Billy’s cheekbone felt like under his fist.
