Work Text:
Catch Up, Ketchup
Steve sat around the bonfire, grip lax on his beer. He didn’t get out much after befriending a nerdy pack of monster-fighting middle schoolers four years ago. Just normal, everyday kind of stuff in Hawkins.
Shit, he was getting old. Those menaces were in high school now.
He absently observed a group of people near the water, messing around, pretending to push each other in when Robin dropped onto the log next to him.
“The answer to a question I used to ask myself, ‘what am I missing at these parties the cool kids go to’? Not much," she sighed.
He snorted, clinking his bottle against hers. “Could have told you that.”
“Yeah, but then it sounds like one of those things a cool kid says to downplay the situation,” Robin countered.
Steve’s nose wrinkled up. “Wait, am I the ‘cool kid’?”
“Depressing, right?” Robin nodded. “Because if your lame ass is the coolest person I know, the landscape is bleak out here.”
Steve glanced back towards the pier. Watched Billy Hargrove undo the one singular button keeping his shirt together and strip out of his pants. He dove into the water like a fucking pro, perfect form, strong lines. Stayed under long enough for Steve to get a little uncomfortable before he broke the surface again.
A few of the other guys jumped too, pulling in their shrieking girlfriends.
“Billy’s cool,” Robin mused, beside him. “An asshole of epic proportions but really fucking cool.” She cocked her head. “Actually, he’s not all that bad these days.”
Steve narrowed his eyes where Billy floated around in the reservoir. “I guess,” he shrugged.
“You guess,” Robin scoffed.
As if he could somehow sense someone talking about him, Billy waded closer. “Just gonna watch all night, pretty boy?” he called out.
Steve hurriedly averted his gaze. “Smooth,” Robin mocked.
Billy reached water he could stand in, moving forward until it hit his calves.
He looked fucking obscene.
Golden skin slick in the moonlight, almost naked, his underwear not doing much to preserve his modesty. Then Steve remembered very abruptly that the guy was shameless as he licked his lips, tongue slipping out while he ran a hand through his curls. The muscles in his arm shifted, abs pulled taut at the motion, defining them further.
“Okay,” Robin whistled beside him. “I’m gay as fuck, but I will be the first to admit that Michelangelo would weep at this sight, my God.”
Billy cocked his head, waiting for Steve’s response. “Whatta say, Harrington? Wanna get hands on?” he asked, sliding his palm down his chest as he spoke, fingers splayed wide.
“I’m good here,” Steve said, hoping Billy would stop staring at him while he was trying to stare at him.
Billy raised his eyebrows, grinning. “Alright,” he said. “I’ll make sure to give you a good show, then,” he winked before spreading his arms out, arching back like he just needed to get in a stretch before he resumed his swim, like he wasn’t blatantly flaunting himself.
The sight made Steve realize that if given the opportunity, he would not hesitate to let Billy Hargrove put those huge fucking hands of his anywhere he wanted.
“Oh, what the fuck,” he muttered to himself, standing abruptly.
“I’ll, uh, be right back,” he told Robin. She rolled her eyes and went to scrounge up a bag of BBQ chips.
Steve stomped through the woods, guzzling half his beer in one go. He needed a moment. Or apparently a few, because he made it all the way back to his car. Steve put the beer down and shoved his hands against his eyes.
“What the fuck, what the fuckkkkkkk.”
This put things into a perspective he had not seen coming.
Steve synced his Bluetooth and sat in the Beemer, resting his head against the steering wheel while blaring the Angsty Teenage Girl playlist on Spotify. He mumbled along to Avril Lavigne, only turning slightly after he detected the clanking of bottles outside his window.
Tommy H. offered him another beer. “You good, man?” he asked, frowning once he recognized the playlist.
Steve took a swig. “Yeah, I’m fine. It’s just. Have you ever had a moment of ‘oh shit’ that kind of changes everything you thought you knew?”
“For sure,” Tommy nodded. “Like that flap on the fry box. It folds back for ketchup. Mind fucking blown, man.”
“Whoa,” Steve blinked, before he climbed out of the car to sit on the hood with Tommy.
“Right?” Tommy said, fingers held up to his eye like a monocle for some reason. “Wait, is your thing like that or something else?”
Steve shrugged. “No, it’s like that,” he said. “You just found out you never need an extra plate for ketchup again and I found out that I want Billy Hargrove to touch my dick. They’re basically the same thing.”
“We’re both learning a lot these days,” Tommy agreed. “Well, lucky for you he’s been trying to get you to drop your pants for years.”
Steve spluttered on his next sip. “What?” he gaped.
“Years,” Tommy repeated, drawing the word out. “So, really you just need to walk up to the guy and say ‘hey, you’ve got big dick energy, wanna big dick in your mouth?’, boom.”
“Jesus, I hope Carol never breaks up with you if that’s the kind of line you think works,” Steve snorted.
Tommy considered his critique before shaking his head. “Yeah, but I’m not you hitting on Billy Hargrove. Steve, you could literally just point at your fucking dick and be like ‘you want in on this?’ because he wants in on all of that,” he said, gesturing to Steve’s entire being. “He actually likes you, not just your dick.”
“I’m still processing,” Steve told him.
Rummaging in his jacket, Tommy pulled out a joint. “Are drugs and alcohol part of processing?”
“Hell yeah,” Steve agreed. They each downed three beers and passed the joint back and forth until it burned down to ash.
While wandering back towards the quarry, mostly steady, they discussed their top five ranking for best fries in the state. Steve heard the music change as they got closer and burst into the clearing.
“It’s Britney, bitch!” he announced loudly, arms thrown wide. Everyone cheered.
Robin made her way over, carefully scanning them both. “How goes it?”
Steve now spread his arms out like a T. “Fucking–,” he began, before clapping them up above his head, “–fantastic.”
She snorted and patted Steve’s cheek. “Oh, boy. I love cross-faded Steve.”
He reached out to mirror her position. “He loves you too, Rah.”
“Who says he’s cross-faded?” Tommy asked. Steve frowned before nodding with emphasis. Actually, Tommy made a good point. They were beneath the radar right now.
Robin rolled her eyes. “Because Steve starts adding interpretative dance to everything he says while over articulating the shit out of his words.” Then she pointed to Tommy. “And because you look like you’re stuck inside a phone booth doing a Tae Bo routine but you only remember the arm movements.”
Steve realized Tommy was, indeed, over there punching rhythmically at the air for no reason. “Huh,” he mused. The song changed again, Lizzo’s ‘Boys’ blaring.
“Billy!” Steve shouted, whirling around.
Tommy’s eyebrows furrowed in confusion as he fought to find his words. “Wait, I thought you were processing. Are you confessing through Lizzo?”
“No,” Steve scoffed. “This is Max’s favorite song right now,” Steve said, still searching through the people milling around. “Billy!”
The man himself wandered over to him, still almost fucking naked and gorgeous. Steve could not handle this right now.
“You rang, Harrington?” Billy asked, taking in the sight of him, amused.
“Your sister fucking loves this song,” Steve told him, as if sharing this information was of vital importance.
Billy laughed, shaking his head. “Yeah, I know,” he said. “But do you know the dance?”
“Don’t you dare insult me like that,” Steve said, starting to follow the steps Max choreographed. Despite his lack of substantial clothing, Billy somehow still had his phone on hand. He lifted it as Steve danced his way through the routine like a goddamn champ.
He crossed his steps over, swung his hips, dropped low and brought it back up, hit the beat on tempo. Wondered why he didn’t fucking become a professional dancer, he was killing this.
Tommy joined in, mixing up his random punching motions with a continuous, aggressive shimmy.
All the hip action and chest popping got Steve overly warm and he struggled to pull his sweater off. Tommy reached out to help and once he was free, Steve tipped his head back exaggeratedly, now down to a black tee. He resumed dancing, swiveling around and doing something that most experts would agree qualified for best twerking of all time.
“I really don’t remember all this pelvis in the original choreo,” Robin said, transfixed as if she didn’t know whether to stop him or start recording too.
Steve threw in an extra hip roll. “Creative liberties, baby.” The song ended and he panted, hunching forward. “Shit, that was intense.”
Tommy kept shimmying, nodding his agreement.
Billy tilted his head from behind the camera. “Gonna give us something to remember you by, Harrington?”
“Billy Fucking Hargrove,” Steve said, drawing his name out. “Wants something to remember? I’ll give you something, that’s for sure.”
He blew a dramatic two handed kiss and once his arms were extended, he flipped Billy off with both hands. Then he turned around, keeping his middle fingers facing Billy as he stomped with his right foot, then his left before thrusting his ass backwards in a triumphant finale.
Steve spun around. “Tag me in that shit,” he said.
“Oh, I will,” Billy promised.
Steve picked up his discarded sweater. It was a good one, dark green and soft. He draped it around Billy’s shoulders. “You need to come with a fucking warning,” he said, vaguely aware that he was standing way too close
Steve could feel Billy’s body heat radiating, see the beads of moisture on his bare skin, the fucking freckles scattered across the bridge of his nose.
Billy licked his lips. “Yeah, what kind?”
Steve blinked at the sight of Billy’s tongue, always with the fucking tongue.
He poked it back into his mouth because that’s where tongues generally resided. Blue eyes wide and startled, it took a moment for Billy to react. Then he gently closed his teeth around Steve’s finger, slid his goddamn tongue against it, warm and wet.
Billy released him after Steve made a soft noise, confused and turned on. “Sexuallllllllly explicit,” he said, making a hand motion like he was directing airplane passengers to the exits.
“You started it, pretty boy,” Billy countered, quite unbothered by that fact.
Steve rolled his eyes. “That’s your warning,” he explained. “Your existence is sexually explicit.”
“Told you he’s down,” Tommy reminded him. Steve narrowed his eyes at Billy like he'd be able to see if that was true if his vision was slightly less blurry.
He rested his hand on Billy’s chest because it looked nice. Solid and inexplicably warm under his palm, he was not disappointed. “I recently realized that you have been making sexual overtures towards me for-,” he trailed off, turning to Tommy for the next word he wanted.
“Years,” he supplied.
“Years,” Steve repeated.
Billy stared at him. “Overtures?”
“Dustin put me on the distribution list for his SAT word of the week so I can expand my vocabulary,” he explained.
Billy sighed, running a hand down his face. “Is that why you’re blitzed? You got freaked out?”
“Big words do freak me out,” Steve agreed. “But–,” he said, pulling the sound out. “Less and less.” Steve then used his hand to make a butterfly, wings flapping away. “Everyday.”
Billy looked towards Robin. She shrugged. “Hey, you’re the one that’s into him.”
“You’re really into me?” Steve asked Billy. He could tell he was doing that big-eyed, slow blinking thing Tommy always said made him look like a dumbass but Robin insisted was actually integral to his himbo evolution.
“Jesus fucking Christ, how did you not know?” Billy asked, frowning at him.
Steve raised his finger like E.T., waited for Tommy to meet him in the middle, their pointer fingers pressed together. “How would I know? You’re very subtle,” he said.
“He’s not,” Robin countered. “At all. Do you see this guy?” she asked, gesturing at Billy. “Nothing about him is subtle.”
“Processing,” Tommy reminded Steve, pushing slightly on his finger.
He nodded. “The fry box flap is for ketchup and I want you to touch my dick,” Steve announced because that’s what they were processing. He was merely stating facts.
“Oh my God,” Robin said, hiding her face.
“We’re enlightened,” Tommy agreed, stumbling into a bow. Steve raised both his hands over his head in a prayer position.
Billy, meanwhile, looked a little stunned. Steve still stood all up in his business but he had yet to move back. Actually, Billy never moved away from Steve. If anything, he figured out ways to get closer. That was probably something else he should have noticed.
“You’re really fucking out of your head right now,” Billy managed, eventually.
Steve pointed to the left with both hands, striking a pose. “What? Nah, I’m right here with Google Earth.”
“Always watching,” Tommy said, nodding. Then he resumed punching the air in a confined range. He even threw in a little kick.
Carol made her way over. “Wow, the variety,” she said, actually impressed. “I’m going to steal my boyfriend now because he’s super fun like this. Tommy, babe, why do we call more than one goose 'geese' but we don’t call more than one moose 'meese'?”
“Shiiiiiit,” Tommy said. He reached out for a fist bump from Steve as he passed. “Luh you, bruh.” Steve drew a heart through the air in response.
“Okay,” Robin said. “Well, I should probably get him home,” she said, jerking a thumb over her shoulder and hip checking Steve.
He glanced towards the fire where Heather still sat toasting a marshmallow. “Nah,” Steve said, shaking his head. “Stay, flirt, have fun.”
“I can drive him home,” Billy offered.
Steve perked up at that. “Your car is sexy as fuck,” he told Billy. “Like you, man. Just like you.”
“Uh,” Billy said, glancing at Robin. “I’ll get him home and not touch his dick, even if he asks.” Then he paused. “Not until he’s sober,” Billy amended.
Robin made a face. “Great, so glad we’re still talking about dicks.”
***
Steve blinked against the sun streaming into his bedroom window and groaned.
His head throbbed. His mouth tasted like death.
Cross-fading always seemed like a good idea at the time but hit twice as hard on the other side. He dragged himself into the shower and then bumbled his way downstairs to make scrambled eggs and toast.
Steve poured himself a glass of orange juice, then froze when he saw Billy Hargrove asleep on his couch, wearing only his underwear and the green sweater Steve brought to the party last night.
What the fuck.
He grabbed for his phone, hoping something in there would make more sense. Instead, he only found a horrifying video of him and Tommy dancing to Lizzo that Billy tagged him in. Everything else was just a steady stream of mockery and a few compliments from the party.
The toaster popped, waking his unexpected house guest.
“Mornin’,” Billy greeted, voice low and scratchy.
“Uh, hey,” Steve said. “I’m making breakfast if you want any,” he offered, not sure what the protocol was here. Billy had been over at his place before but never alone.
Nodding, Billy pushed up off the couch, then disappeared down the hall to use the bathroom. Steve had about a minute to panic before realizing he wasted part of it staring at Billy’s ass as he walked away.
He dialed Robin and Tommy in on a conference call.
“Good morning, sunshine,” Robin greeted. Tommy grunted unintelligibly. “I’m guessing you’re calling because you blacked out and have no idea why Billy’s in your house?” she asked and wow, he really was that predictable.
“Billy’s at your place?” Tommy asked, more alert now. “You bang yet?”
With sudden clarity, Steve remembered that he told Billy, straight to his face that he wanted him to touch his dick. “Oh my God,” he groaned. “For future reference, I should not use drugs and alcohol to process.”
“I thought you knew that after Hop had to call in the fire department to get you out of the dome climber after high school graduation,” Robin pointed out.
A long silence stretched. “My bad, I forgot about that,” Tommy apologized.
“That’s probably because you were still passed out in the slide,” Robin reminded him.
Steve jolted in place when the bathroom door opened. “Shit, he’s coming back. Got to go,” he said, quickly.
“Fucking get some, man,” Tommy encouraged. “Then we'll get fries later.” Robin just laughed at him.
They ate breakfast at the kitchen island in complete silence.
Steve remained entirely unable to stop shooting sidelong glances at Billy. He sat there next to him, hair mussed and still wearing Steve’s sweater, the neckline askew from how it twisted as he slept.
Billy looked soft, touchable. He didn’t know how to handle this situation.
“So,” Billy said, spreading strawberry jam on his toast. “Since you keep staring at me with your big fucking Bambi eyes, I’m going to assume you’re struggling to find a topic that doesn’t involve your dick or the fact that you loudly informed everyone you want me to touch it.”
“That’s...yeah,” Steve agreed.
“You could tell me again,” Billy suggested. “If you meant it.”
Steve laughed, turning to face him. Golden curls loose on his forehead, Steve’s sweater dipping low enough to show his collarbone, weirdly endearing and still enticing somehow. Billy looked hopeful, but his nerves still slipped through, like he didn’t think Steve would say it again.
But Steve fully processed now, he could do this. “You want in?” he asked, pointing at his dick.
Billy’s warm hands slid beneath Steve’s waistband in response. Yeah, he definitely wanted in.
