Actions

Work Header

The Second Try

Summary:

Billy and Steve try to give their love a 2nd try. They've both longed for each other too long to not have a 2nd go at it.
But there's something festering in the darkness, something that could ruin what they just started building.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Chapter 1: Prelude

Chapter Text

Steve looked at the corkboard that was on the brick building in front of the pool. Hawkins community pool lifeguards all plastered on the board with small pictures and labels with their names just below. Steve couldn’t help but anxiously stare at the photo of Billy. His eyes were squinted from the sun, he had on a gray crop top, and there was a curl on his forehead that looked so stupidly perfect. 

“Hey.” Steve spoke to Max, who was walking past him. The kids were already in the pool area, trying to find enough chairs for all of them. “You sure that Billy won’t be here?” He looked at the redhead. It’s not like Steve was scared that Billy would be at the pool, rather… nervous. 

“Yeah, I mean… hopefully. Like I said, I don’t know when his shift ends. It’s already twelve, and he’s usually home by four, so it has to be soon.” 

Steve nodded, taking one last look at Billy’s photo. One could say he looked kind of cute - Steve wouldn’t say that, though. 

“Steve.” Max said gently, now standing by his side. “I promise you he’s on his best behavior, okay?” 

“Yeah, no, I believe you.” He waved her off, turning his body away from the corkboard. “It’s just- It’s nothing. Let’s go make sure the nerds aren’t drowning themselves.” 

Max giggled as Steve turned her around and pushed her towards the pool. 

 

Billy took the last few drags out of his cigarette. He had been on his lunch break for the past 30 minutes and it was finally coming to an end. He was using his last few minutes of freedom to mentally prepare himself to not get so angry at the dumb kids running around the pool. They were just dumb kids, they didn’t know any better. Billy had also been using his lunch break to nurse the forming bruise on his lower back with an ice pack Heather had given him. 

Earlier this morning, Billy had been searching around for a mug to use when a random one cliff dove off the shelf and smashed against the ground. It was purely an accident, but Neil hadn’t seen it that way. That ‘random mug’ was actually a mug that Max had made her mom in elementary school, and because Billy had (accidentally) broken something of Susan and Max’s, Neil saw that as Billy being disrespectful to the 2 ladies in the house. One firm shove against the counter and now Billy was having to use an ice pack to make sure no one saw the effects of his lovely dad. 

Billy crushed the cigarette underneath his flip-flops. With how hot it was outside, if he didn’t, the cigarette might’ve lit up again. He didn’t care about the heat; it brought him back to California, which was nice. He didn’t think the people of Hawkins liked it so much. The sweltering heat made them throw all their sweaters away because even a glance in their direction made them burn up. It made Billy laugh. How weak were these idiots? He leaned off the prickly brick of the entrance building and grabbed the ice pack that was pressing cool relief against his lower back.

His flip-flops made a smacking sound against the pavement as he walked into the break room to grab his whistle and give Heather her ice pack back. 

“Thanks for the ice pack.” He said, moving through his coworkers to hand the ice pack back to Heather. He had grown a small friendship with her. Out of all the insufferable pretentious assholes he worked with, she was the nicest. 

“Oh, yeah, no problem.” Heather said with a smile. “Can I ask how you got that bruise in the first place?” 

Billy shrugged, grabbing his whistle from her as well. “I’m stupid sometimes.” He should’ve been more careful with the mugs. He couldn’t stop himself from feeling like he deserved to be hurt because of that. Billy could be really stupid sometimes. 

Heather giggled. “You can’t talk about yourself that way. It’s mean.” 

Billy flipped his sunglasses down over his eyes. “Well, I’m mean.” He said before walking out the door and over to the pool area where the town moms were making themselves presentable. It was depressing if he was being honest, but also kind of funny. If none of these women’s husbands were willing to fuck them, why in the world would Billy? And none of them even looked good. That wasn’t even the gay part of Billy talking, that was the fucking truth. The only mom who actually looked good out of the row of cow meat was maybe Karen Wheeler. Billy could appreciate how gorgeous she was. Of course not in the way she wanted him to, because he was gay. 

Sometimes he really wished he could just scream that he didn’t like any of these women, because on the worst days it would make him feel like shit to walk past these women who were dripping wet for him. It made him feel gross and like he was just lying to himself, trying to get attention (even though no one knew. Don’t question his insecurities). 

He walked past the row of women like he owned the place, he practically did. None of the other lifeguards had nearly the amount of respect that these losers gave Billy. None of the people of Hawkins shuddered or imagined fucking the other lifeguards like they did Billy Hargrove. And it was because he was Billy fucking Hargrove, and no one fucked with him-

Something caught Billy’s eye. At first, it just looked like a mother scolding her kids all the way across the pool, but on closer inspection, it was Steve Harrington speaking sternly to his group of nerds he had gained last year. Every day when he dropped Max off or picked her up, he could see Steve with the kids, talking to them like he was their mother. 

Billy had stopped his stride to stare at the group. He didn’t mean to stare; he had just noticed Steve’s body, and he froze in place. The guy had definitely worked out since the last time Billy saw him, toned in all the right places. His biceps were really showing with his crossed arms that laid across beneath his pecs, which were also very nice… really nice… Billy had to stop staring. 

His eyes narrowed in on the group. Max was standing in front of her babysitter in a pose that read ‘annoyed as shit’. This could be his excuse to walk over to the group, to simply annoy his sister. It was weird that she was here in the first place. He had taken the job to get away from her sister so she wouldn’t bother him and he wouldn’t bother her friends. Their promise from back in November. 

Billy continued his stride across the pool concrete, his goal had changed, though. “Hey shitbird!” Billy barked. No one told him off for his swearing - no one had the balls to tell him off for his swearing. 

Max turned around and there was a quick switch of emotions on her face. First there was a sly smile on her lips and in a second it turned into a loud groan. The other children joined in. 

“Why are you here?” Mike whined as Billy planted his feet in front of the group next to Harrington. 

“You’re not supposed to be here!” Lucas added. 

“I’m guessing you children wanted to come here after my shift?” He asked, head leaning in Steve’s direction. He looked good in his dark blue swim trunks that showed off his thighs. Billy knew that his crush for Steve hadn’t disappeared after their fight. It was a small pang in his heart every time he saw the dude, but it was definitely still there. After driving Steve to his graduation party, there was a new glint in his eyes when he looked at Billy, almost like a second chance had sparked in his heart. It made Billy’s heart spark brighter. 

“Max didn’t know when your shift ended, she just knew that it started at nine.” Steve told him, arms crossed. He looked like such a mom. It was too funny. 

Billy looked at his sister with slight confusion. He had definitely told her that his shift ended at 3… right? “Well, you guys are three hours too early.” 

“Three hours!?” Max groaned. “Are you kidding me?” 

Billy rolled his eyes underneath his sunglasses. “Look, as long as you little asshole behave, I’m not gonna fuck with you.” He told them. It was the truth. He usually kept quiet at his post unless a coworker came up to talk to him or he needed to scold some child for being extra stupid. “So just swim and be nice.” 

Max rolled her eyes at her brother, but as she turned away from him and walked towards the pool, Billy could see the slightest smirk. What was up with her? This wasn’t about… no… 

“So,” Steve’s voice came into his ears, “you work here.” 

“Yeah.” Billy nodded, crossing his arms in front of his chest. “I’m surprised you don’t. Weren’t you a lifeguard for three years?” He had heard some of his coworkers talking about how every summer Steve Harrington would come along and be a fan favorite from all the kids because he was so sweet, Billy could see that now. 

“Yep, three summers where I swooned the people of Hawkins with my sick back strokes.” Steve laughed. Billy couldn’t help but smile. 

“So why aren’t you here in my place and I’m playing mother duck?” It had been so long since he had talked to Steve like a normal person. The birthday party was the first time that Steve and him had an actual conversation since that night in November. It had messed Billy up a lot. All the guilt from that night came pouring back in and spent the rest of the party just crying, holding himself tightly as he tried to make as little noise as possible so no one would suspect anything. 

He didn’t talk much at Steve’s graduation party. When everyone was outside and hanging around the pool, Billy was in the kitchen drinking all of Steve’s beer. And when everyone was inside, he was outside, putting a chair on the steps and sitting in the pool without getting too wet. It’s not like he didn’t talk to Steve, though. There was some small talk, talk about colleges, jokes about the basketball team, but that was it. Billy didn’t feel right talking to Steve. There was a pit of anxiety in his stomach every time the guy came into his view. 

Right now was no different, but Billy was in public and it would make sense for the King of Hawkins to at least say hi to his predecessor. 

Steve’s face went a little pink, and he held on tighter to his biceps, like he was nervous. Billy wondered if Steve hadn’t taken the lifeguard job because he had seen Billy applying. If that was the truth, Billy would feel so much more guilty about everything. He was okay with scaring the children around the pool or the other patrons of Hawkins, but Steve? Billy was scared of Steve, not the other way around. 

“Oh, you know, I didn’t turn in my resume on time.” He laughed sheepishly. Steve was a terrible liar. Scratching the back of his neck absentmindedly, Steve knew that was the biggest sign of a liar, right? It made Billy’s stomach churn. Something so innocent made Billy want to flip a table over. 

“You’re that busy packing for college you forgot to apply for a job?” Billy asked. He remembered talking to Steve about colleges. His dad wanted him to go to tech, Steve wanted to go to some liberal arts college in California, learn about music. He was now waiting for the acceptance letter. The hint of sadness in his tone made Billy question if he had gotten the acceptance letter, well… rejection letter. But the idea of Steve in California made Billy grip onto his beer can even tighter. Steve Harrington in California, the moles on body could melt in with the freckles he would get, his hair would probably get lighter from the salt water, he would look great. The thought of it now made Billy want to jump into the pool to get cool. 

Steve grimaced. “Yeah, I didn’t get into tech.” 

“Oh, no.” Billy pouted. “I’m sorry, dude.” 

“No, it’s fine. I didn’t want to go, anyway.” Billy already knew that, but he said nothing. It would be a creep move to bring it something that they had talked about a month ago. Billy had made it seem like he hadn’t remembered every single thing about Harrington because he most definitely had. “But now, I’m playing mother duck to these loser children.” Steve gestured towards the pool where Max, Lucas, and Mike were all playing some sort of dunking game. He would usually yell at them, can’t have people drowning, but seeing his little sister get dunked on by that Sinclair kid was pretty funny. 

“It’s a good look on you.” Billy turned on his charm. What was the harm in trying to flirt a little with an ex? “Being all motherly.” 

Steve went even more pink, edging that red territory. “It’s my day off, so they all forced me to drive them.” 

That sparked a question in Billy’s mind. He knew Steve’s house, had been there on 2 occasions, and when he went outside the Harrington house on both occasions, he was met with a large swimming pool. So why were these loser kids here? If Max had anything to do with this, Billy would wring her like a wet towel. 

“Don’t you have your own pool, Harrington?” Billy asked. “Why come to these crowded, snot filled waters?” The pool here was really gross. He didn’t want to imagine how many children and senior citizens had peed in the pool. That’s why the ocean was so much better, everyone was so spread out, the salt cleaned everything off, it was just so much better. Billy only took the lifeguard job because he had missed the ocean, but sitting up on the lifeguard post and watching all these idiots swim around in this enclosed space made him miss the salt water even more. 

“Yeah, I do.” Steve’s voice went up an octave in awkwardness. It was so stupidly cute. “But Max started complaining that it was too small, and she somehow brainwashed the other kids to agree with her.” Billy looked over at the pool where Max and her nerd friends were hanging out. Oh, she was fucking dead, that son of a bitch. 

It all came crashing into Billy. Max was trying to set him and Steve up again. Steve’s pool was not too small. Who in the world would ever think that about a backyard pool? And the look she had when he came over and then told the kids to leave!? Billy was going to murder his sister.

“Well,” He said with a small smile. “I should get going.” 

“Right.” 

“Make sure no kid drowns.” 

“Yeah.” 

The squeals of children and gossip talk from the moms somehow made the silence between them worse. Billy held his arms tightly and Steve’s hands were clasped in front of his crotch. Billy wondered if there was a reason for that. It made Billy’s ego boost in this awkward situation. A simple conversation made Steve so nervous he got a boner? The things this dude could do to Billy could be labeled as illegal. 

“Well, bye.” Billy snapped his fingers and began walking backwards, hoping that once he turned around, Steve wouldn’t gasp at the bruise forming on his back. His red swim trunks hid most of the bruise, but you could still see some of his peaking out. It was ugly, and Billy hated it. He was sure that everyone at the pool thought the same thing. How ugly was Billy Hargrove? 

“Yeah! See you- uh- see you later!” Steve called out as Billy walked away. 

Billy turned around. Steve was giving him a kind smile. How could Billy be so scared of that doe eyed asshole, how could this puppy-eyed jerk create such a pit in Billy’s stomach that he wanted to throw up? It was unethical; it was disgusting; it was so wrong. Billy had told himself to not become too attached to Hawkins. Once he graduated, he would speed down the highways all the way back to California. He had told himself to not fall in love with anyone there, there wouldn’t be anyone for him to fall in love with anyway, they were all loser hicks. And this candy filled fucker walked into Billy’s life and his entire life plans crumbled like a cookie. 

It was such a small thing, ‘later’. Steve would see him later. Steve wanted to see him later. Why else would he say that? Steve had to know what he was doing by saying that, by looking at him like that with that goofy ass smile, by turning a light pink and keeping his hands in front of his crotch before spinning around to apply his own sunscreen. Billy felt all the air get sucked out of his lungs - oh, how he was puddy in Steve Harrington’s hands. 

“Maxine!” Billy snapped, standing at the pool corner in front of his lifeguard post. He didn’t want to use his whistle because the pool would get quiet and this was a very private conversation he wanted to have with his sister. 

She gave him a nasty glare. “I told you not to call me that!” She said while swimming across the pool to get to her brother. 

“Yeah, I’m calling you this to get your attention, fuckwad.” He knelt down to get closer to her. The pavement burned his skin in a way he missed. “You know my shift ends at three.” He whispered. 

“I know now.” She said so innocently, oh he was going to kill her.

“Listen, you little asshole,” he spoke through his teeth, “whatever game you’re playing at you, better stop it now.” 

“I don’t know what you’re talking about.” 

“Don’t be stupid with me, Max.” 

“He’s so in love with you.” 

Here it was. “God dammit, Max.” he groaned. “Stop messing with my romantic life.” 

“What’s the harm in being your wingman?” 

Max was sweet. She was a great kid and Billy was glad that their ‘nice sibling moments’ had increased. 6 years of knowing the little pipsqueak and only now were they getting close to each other, but this was not something she could get close to him with. He could imagine so many bad things that could happen with Max trying to get Billy and Steve back together. 

“The harm is that I don’t need you doing it.” He told her. “I don’t mess around with whatever weird relationship you have with that weirdo girl.” He had helped her a couple of times, but only when he was asked to help her. That time during Christmas didn’t count. She was very distressed over her feelings and Billy did a good brother thing by helping her figure out what to do. 

Max’s face went red, and she sputtered a bunch of arguments, but none of them landed. Billy went back up to his feet. “Just stop, okay? We aren’t doing this.” Max huffed before going back to swim over with her friends. Steve had gotten into the pool and was hanging around the corner while Lucas and Mike talked his ear off. 

And it wasn’t like Billy didn’t want to get back together with Steve. He just couldn’t. Steve didn’t want to get back together, told him that on his birthday of all days. Billy had respected that, yeah maybe he just did a little flirting, but he wasn’t trying to get back together with Steve. 

Looking at him now though, hanging around all the kids with a smile plastered on his face… maybe Billy could try. 

 

“Please.” Max begged as Billy sat on their couch watching TV. She had been trying to get him to drive her to the mall for the past 10 minutes now. 

“Why should I drive you in the first place?” He asked. “You know your little nerd group hates me, so why would I wanna be stuck in a car with them and then buy them ice cream?” 

“I don’t wanna bike all the way over there! I’m tired and you don’t have to pay for all of them.” She whined. “You just have to pay for me and El, since everyone else has money.” 

Billy lolled his head over to the side to look at his sister. He had to cover someone’s shift during the swimming lessons part of the day. He had been dealing with children for the past 6 hours and he really did not want to deal with them anymore. 

“Please.” Max said one more time. “It would be a really good brother thing for you to do.” 

Billy wanted to tell her he didn’t care about being a good brother, but that wasn’t the truth. There was something in his gut telling him that Max wasn’t telling the entire truth, but he couldn’t say no to her big, pleading eyes. Actually, he could, but what was the harm in simply taking these kids to the mall to get some ice cream. 

“Fine.” He groaned and Max hopped on the balls of her feet in excitement. “But I swear to god Max, all of you better behave in my car or you’re all dead.” 

Max saluted him with a smile. 

 

Steve leaned against the counter, facing away from the customers. Robin was leaning against the counter that had the sliding glass door dividers from their backroom. He had been arguing with her for the past 20 minutes about what was the best ABBA song. 

“It’s most definitely SOS.” He said confidently. He wasn’t getting how Robin was saying it wasn’t.

“It is most definitely not SOS. It’s Dancing Queen. Are you kidding me?” 

“Dancing Queen is so overrated.” Steve rolled his eyes. 

“For a reason, jack wagon!” 

“Yeah, people don’t have good music taste and think that’s their best song.” 

“Holy shit.” 

“So when you’re near me darling, can’t you hear me, S.O.S.” Steve sang the song quietly enough for the other patrons in the ice cream store to not look at him weird. If making a fool of himself meant winning his argument, he’d put on clown shoes and honk a horn. 

“Oh, my god.” Robin laughed, bringing her hands up to her face. 

“The love you gave me nothing else can save me, S.O.S.” He swayed his hips to the invisible beat that was inside his head. He would sing the entire song if the sounds of noisy children didn’t enter his ears. His group of annoying little ducklings had entered the ice cream shop. 

He giggled at her blushful reaction and spun around on his heels. “Ahoy mate-” His heart got caught in his throat and his face went a bright red. This couldn’t be happening, not here, not now, oh Jesus Christ. 

“Steve.” Billy said, a shocked look on his face. 

“Billy.” Steve said right back, not really sure that it was really him. 

“Steve!” Mike cheered. 

“Children!” Steve turned his attention away from Billy, whose abs were showing from the gray cropped top he was wearing. “Do you guys all want your regulars?” The kids had shown up pretty much every day since Steve had gotten the job, and that was only 8 days ago. 

All the kids nodded. 

“I want marshmallows with my ice cream, though.” Mike added, and Steve saluted him while the kids went and sat down. Billy stayed standing up. 

“So,” Steve said, trying to start some small talk with the hot shot of Hawkins while getting the kids their ice cream. “What are you doing here?” He asked. His mind had gone blank with what he could follow up with, so he just asked the most basic thing ever. A question he had asked to so many women in his life before this, Billy Hargrove wasn’t deserving of a simple question like this. Billy Hargrove was deserving of his SOS serenade that he just did to Robin. 

No, Billy wasn’t deserving of anything - well, no, that’s not… Steve was going to explode. This is just like what he felt like yesterday when bringing the kids over to the community pool just after Billy’s lunch break or something. 

“I’m… getting ice cream for the gremlin group over there.” Billy gestured towards the group of children. 

Steve paused putting the marshmallows on Mike’s chocolate ice cream. Holy shit was Steve stupid. “Right!” He put the ice cream in an acrylic ice cream holder where the other kids’ ice creams were. “Right, yeah that was… I don’t know why I asked that.” He mumbled into himself, eyes staring down into the ice cream trays where he started getting Max’s ready. Steve was sure that the heat coming off his face would melt the ice cream. 

Billy seemed to have enjoyed Steve’s awkwardness, because of course the asshole would. “I like your uniform.” He said, breaking the awkward silence between them. 

Steve was going to explode. His face got even hotter because his uniform was some of the dorkiest shit he had ever worn in his entire life. Steve let out a sheepish laugh, avoiding eye contact with Billy. He had to come up with a response quickly or his brain would malfunction and he would pass out. “Well, at least my uniform doesn’t make me half naked.” He tried to take a dig at Billy’s lifeguarding uniform, but Jesus Christ, what was he talking about? Billy rocked those bright red swim trunks like it was his job. Steve had never been more jealous in his life. He was sure that Heather Holloway enjoyed the new view instead of Steve. 

Billy chuckled. “At least my uniform doesn’t make me look like a dork.” He leaned against the counter. 

“I don’t look like a dork.” Steve argued, putting the last ice cream in the acrylic holder. That was a total lie. 

“You totally look like a dork.” Robin said from the back room. 

“Stay out of it, Robin.” He snapped at her. She held her hands up in defense and closed the glass dividers. He really hoped that she hadn’t been watching him this entire time. Steve turned back to Billy and let out a breath. There was a split second where Steve was looking down at the counter and rethinking his life choices. His eyes snapped back up though and his heart was back to beat a million miles per hour when looking at Billy. “Would you like some ice cream?” he asked. All the kids’ cones were done, so why not do one more for Billy? 

Billy’s eyes widened. “Oh, I don’t think ice cream is on my diet plan.” 

Of course, this asshole had a diet plan. “It’s only ice cream. It won’t ruin you.” 

Billy hummed, eyes looking over the different flavors that they had. Steve would be willing to stay here forever if it meant looking over Billy as he concentrated on what ice cream flavor he wanted. 

Steve had been trying to convince himself that he didn’t still have feelings for Billy. That it had been ‘so long’ since they had broken up that Steve had to have gotten over it, but after seeing Billy at his graduation, he didn’t care now. Steve was more than willing to admit that he still had feelings for Billy, feelings that made him want to go insane because why did Billy look so hot concentration of fucking ice cream flavors. 

Billy drew in a breath and looked back up at Steve. “You guys don’t have the flavor I want.” 

“Oh? And what’s that?” 

“Raspberry.” Billy said it so simply Steve wasn’t even sure he had said it in the first place. And yeah, it wasn’t that big of a deal, but it was also the biggest deal ever. Was this Billy’s way of saying that he wanted him? That he wanted to get back together? Steve had the raspberry flavor cemented into his brain after that Halloween night. He had gotten Billy raspberry flavor chapstick and raspberry scented cologne for Christmas. 

Steve could play along. He rested his head on his hand that was propped up on the counter. “We actually have raspberry.” He spoke smoothly, a smirk on his lips, all the normal tactics he used with past girls. 

Billy raised an eyebrow and somehow leaned deeper into the counter. “You do?” 

“Yeah, it’s me and Robin’s favorite flavor, so we like to hide it from the customers.” That was the truth. When Robin and him were just starting to be friends, they found out that they both liked raspberry ice cream. They keep the tray hidden underneath the mint chocolate chip and then, when it’s their shift, they hide it in the fridge. Robin didn’t know the implications of the raspberry flavor. She just liked it. “I can get it for you.” 

“You don’t have to do that.” Billy backed off a bit. Had Steve’s charm made Billy nervous? This had to be some sort of dream. But wait, oh shit, what if Billy thought that Robin and him were together? Oh shit.

“No, no, I want to.” Steve smiled, standing at his full height. “It’s the least I can do since you’re babysitting these psychos for me.” 

“Okay, then I will indulge in some raspberry ice cream.” 

“Good choice.” Steve had half the mind to grab Billy over the counter and plant a kiss straight on his mouth, but that would be idiotic of him. So he turned around and headed for the backroom where Robin was probably listening to music or some shit. They split their shift into 2, with Steve taking the first half most days and Robin taking the second half. 

He closed the door behind him and stood with his back facing the door, taking a second to calm his beating heart. 

“You good?” Robin asked, pulling her headphones away from her ears. 

“Yeah, I’m fine.” Steve said, pushing off the door and going over to the employee’s fridge. “Just need to get ice cream.” 

“What? No.” Robin whined. “That’s for us.” 

“It’s going to be for the customer in 5 seconds.”. He took the tray of ice cream out of the fridge.

“How do they even know about it?” Steve went over to their small storage pantry and took a cone out, flipping his scooper out of the pocket of his apron. 

“Because I told them.” 

“Why would you do that?” Robin whined even more. 

“Because I’m friends with them.” 

He hears Robin walk over the sliding glass and open it while he scoops the pink ice cream into the waffle cone. Sometimes he wished Robin wasn’t always so noisy. She was fun to hang out, but Jesus. 

“You’re friends with Billy Hargrove?” Robin deadpanned and Steve turned around. 

“Yes, yes, I am.” 

“Didn’t he like- beat you up in November?” Robin asked as Steve moved past her. He could put away the ice cream tray later, after Billy left. 

“I threw the first punch, but yeah.” 

“So how are you guys friends?” 

“We just are. Stop asking questions.” He said right before pushing through the swinging door and getting back to the front counter where the ice cream holder was gone and a small pile of money was left in its place. Some crumbled dollar pills atop neatly folded ones. Steve could tell which ones were from the kids and which ones were from Billy. 

“Here is your raspberry ice cream.” Steve handed the cone over while taking the cash and putting it in its correct cash register spots. 

“I added an extra two dollars for my ice cream.” Billy added, before licking at his ice cream. 

“What? Oh, you didn’t have to do that.” Steve kept his eyes as far away from Billy’s mouth as he could. The idea of becoming that ice cream cone was searing into his head, and he didn’t appreciate it. 

“Don’t I have to pay for ice cream?” Billy continued to drag his tongue across the pink ice cream, and Steve was continuing to feel a burning sensation in his stomach. 

“Yeah, but- you know- I could’ve- you know… made it on the house.” Steve wished Billy didn’t make him so nervous. Licking ice cream was a completely normal way to eat ice cream. The way that Billy was looking at him while doing it, though? He had to have known what he was doing. Or maybe the fluorescent lights were just getting to him, evaporating his brain cells to make him short circuit 24/7. 

“You know, I was wondering why hot shot Steve Harrington would choose such a lame job, but I’m starting to see your womanizing ways, Harrington.” Billy teased with a glint in his eyes that made Steve want to sing a million love songs. 

“What?” Steve laughed. ‘Womanizing ways’? God, how obvious was he? How did Billy fall for him in the first place? 

“You probably butter all the women up with free ice cream, huh?”

“Oh.” Steve nodded like that was his plan all along. “Of course, I’m practically a chick magnet over here while scooping ice cream.” 

Billy snorted. The smile on his face was dangerous. Dangerous in that Steve would do anything that Billy ever asked for if it got him to smile. 

“But no,” Steve said sadly, “my dad got a little pissed I didn’t get into tech, so as punishment, he cut me off from his credit card this summer.”

Billy nodded, like this was something totally relatable. Honestly, who was Steve to complain about his struggles in the world? It made him feel like a dick sometimes… because he was. “So after summer you’re going right back to sucking off daddy?” 

Jesus Billy was vulgar. It made Steve squirm in the worst way. He could imagine all the dirty things Billy could say to him during sex. It was disgusting. So disgusting it made Steve want to go to the bathroom to sort himself out. “You are correct.” Steve said, completely ignoring how gross Billy was. “So don’t worry, after summer I’ll be able to pay for all our hangouts.” 

Billy raised an eyebrow. “We’re going to be hanging out more?” 

Shit. Steve hadn’t even thought about what he had said. He had been so caught up in the moment, so caught up with the fact that he was talking to Billy again, that he hadn’t even thought about what he was saying. There was this flower blooming in his chest when he thought about hanging out with Billy. He didn’t know the vines were spilling out of his mouth. 

He started stuttering for an answer that would cover for his stupid self, but Max cut in. 

“Billy, can you take us to the movies?” She asked. 

“Why would I want to do that?” 

“Because it’s an R-rated movie and we need an adult to see it.” 

“Uh, excuse you.” Steve cut in, his motherly instincts taking over. “Why in the world would you think it would be okay to see an R-rated movie?” 

“No, I wanna see where they’re going with this.” Billy lightly put his hand on Steve’s chest and Steve might as well explode right then and there. 

“We just want to see the breakfast movie.” El said cheerfully. She was adorable. 

Billy made a noise of disgust. “You guys should see an actual R-rated movie.” 

“No, they shouldn’t!” 

“Are they playing Children of the Corn?” 

“Billy!” 

“They are!” Lucas said quickly. 

“‘Kay, we’ll see Children of the Corn.” 

“Oh- Dude seriously!” Steve gave Billy a nasty look. “You can’t take them to go see Children of the Corn.” 

“C’mon it’s not that bad.” Billy argued, leaning his head down so he was looking at Steve through his lashes. Oh, he so knew. 

“Well, we should go.” Max said in an annoyed tone, so much sass, just like her brother. “I mean, we could just go see the Goonies or something and leave Billy here with you.” 

There was this tone in her voice, a tone that she knew what Steve was thinking. Like she knew Steve’s ugliest, shameful thoughts and was teasing him about it. Holy shit, was it that obvious that he liked Billy? 

Billy barked out a laugh, a pink color lightly over his face. “Hell no, I’m not spending another second with this dork.” He was teasing Steve, the asshole. It almost felt like they were back together already, playful teasing, longing stares, or maybe that was just Steve. “Let’s go see that horror movie.” 

The children all cheered and started walking out of the ice cream shop, Billy right behind them. 

“Don’t come crying to me when it’s too scary!” He called out after the kids. 

Billy turned his head and winked while licking a stripe up his ice cream. 

Oh, Steve was so fucked. 

 

Sometimes being a lifeguard was super fucking boring, especially when there was no Steve Harrington to ogle at. He had a plan that had been stirring in his mind and it would all be ruined if Steve didn’t stop by the pool today. He could just ask it another day if he really wanted too… but he wanted to do it now. 

The chlorine and urine mixture that was festering in the concrete hole in the ground was really getting to him. His brain was pounding against his skull and making him want to die. Also, the plethora of caring parents taking their kids to the pool, that also sucked because the bruise on his back was now a purple and it was sore. 

The only thing that could’ve been good about today was the heat. Scorching and blistering was always the type of weather Billy longed for. After moving from California and to this shit hole, Billy had learned that their hot days were barely even hot. Maybe warm, never hot. He was glad the Hawkins’ summer gave him something to look forward to, and while most of the days were once again warm, there were days like these where the sweat would roll off of Billy’s body and he’d smile. 

But while the heat washing his body was nice, he starting to prefer the soft, cold glow that was the moon. Back with these stupid analogies or whatever, he couldn’t help it. Steve reminded him so much of the moon. Like the Goddess Selene’s kind and peaceful nature, or now perhaps the Goddess Artemis, with her motherly job to protect all women. In Steve’s case, it was just children. Steve made Billy rethink his entire life. Because Billy fucking despised the cold, but whenever Steve looked at him, he got this cozy, chilly feeling in his stomach. And that was fucking weird because how could the cold be ‘cozy’. 

And like God heard his thoughts, there was a rush of cold air that littered goosebumps all over his body and, 

There he was. 

Mother Steve Harrington was back at the public pool, accompanied by his group of nerdy children, of course. Max was there as well, and while Billy hated the fact that she was playing matchmaker, he had to thank her for letting him see Steve. 

There was a light pink flush over his shoulders, the areas where he didn’t put enough sunscreen. The moles that littered his body mixed in the new freckles he had gotten from the sun damage. Billy wanted to kiss every single one. 

“Harrington!” Billy called out, and Steve looked up at him. 

“Hey!” He waved, patting Max’s shoulder as he moved past her. Max somehow took this as a sign to turn away and push all of her friends in the opposite direction from Billy’s lifeguard post. Little asshole, intentionally leaving him and Steve alone. He couldn’t help but love her. 

“I hope I’m still on your good side after everything that happened yesterday.” Billy gave Steve a lazy smile. 

Steve looked at him confused. “What do you mean?” He asked. “Why wouldn’t you be?” He was leaning up against the lifeguard post and looking at Billy with his big stupid eyes. Billy was going insane. 

“Well, you know, disobeyed mommy Steve, I have to be on some kind of blacklist now.” The red flush on Steve’s face was worth every embarrassing word that just came out of Billy’s mouth. “Right?” He asked, just to drive it in. 

Steve hesitated for a moment, mouth open and closing as the red on his face deepened. He gave an awkward laugh. “No, no, you’re fine.” He said. “Still on the good side.” 

“Good.” Billy rolled the whistle in between his fingers. There was anxiety settling in his stomach. Steve was too pretty for his own good, too awkward and innocent looking. A doe-eyed deer, and Billy was just a simple hunter. He couldn’t take it, he’d ruin Steve, turn the best parts of him evil. Billy didn’t deserve Steve. “Do you wanna hang out later tonight?” He leaned forward, closer to where Steve was standing. 

“Tonight?” Steve repeated. 

“You don’t have to, it’s just- I’m covering for someone’s closing shift and it’ll be pretty boring all alone.” Really, they won’t be entirely alone, they’ll be accompanied by the few adults that liked to swim at night because they’re weirdos. Billy just hoped that Steve would stay longer than that so they could really be alone. Maybe they could talk… about… things. 

“When does the pool close?” 

“Seven.” 

Steve drew in a breath. “My shift ends at nine…” 

Fuck. Billy hadn’t even thought of Steve’s job. What a self-centered asshole, god. 

Billy shrugged. “It’s fine, dude.” He bit back the sadness creeping up in his voice. “It’s not like I’m pressuring you or anything.” Billy leaned back in the wooden chair. His sweat was making him become one with the post, and it was only slightly uncomfortable. 

Steve stood there for a moment, biting at his lip with his eyebrows furrowed in thought. Billy was trying to put his attention back to watching the pool, but honestly, he could give less of a shit. There’d be a drowning kid in the pool and he’d be too preoccupied with thinking about Steve. 

“I can ask Robin to cover for me.” Steve said out of nowhere. Billy leaned over to look at him. “She fucking hates me, but I’ll bribe her.” 

“With what money?” Billy laughed. 

“The money I’ve made, you asshole.” 

“And what? That’s like two cents.”

“I don’t have to hang out with you.” 

“But you want to.” 

“Shut up.” Steve waved him off and walked off at the same time. Billy cackled as he watched the babysitter go back to his kids. Max looked over at her brother with a knowing smile. He couldn’t help but roll his eyes. 

When it was 6pm Billy had thought that Steve bailed on him, maybe not bailed, but he couldn’t get his coworker to cover for him. Billy understood the mall was popular, so she probably didn’t want to be left alone dealing with a bunch of stupid people. If Billy knew how stupid people would be regarding fucking pool rules, he would’ve never taken the job. 

So when it turned 7pm, he was kicking the last 2 pool patrons out of the building and saw a red BMW parked in the empty lot. His heart stopped. Steve’s car was always going to be recognizable to him. After Steve swept him away in the middle of the night to confess his feelings, the red of his car burned into Billy’s brain. 

Steve popped up out of his driver’s seat after the 2 patrons were in their cars. He was smiling brightly and holding up a box of beer. Billy didn’t think the guy was going to show up at all, but obviously he was just waiting for the 2 of them to be alone. The asshole. 

“Hey!” Steve sang as he jogged up to the front of the community pool. “I brought beer.” He pointed to the case in his hands. 

“You do know the pool is closed now?” Billy asked, leaning against the brick with a smirk on his face. Steve had to know. 

Steve’s face fell. “Oh, shit… I wasn’t thinking. I’m sorry.” 

Did Steve actually forget? Did he think Billy’s closing shift started at 7? Didn’t he tell him that the pool closed at 7? “Well, I have to clean the pool and pump it with chlorine so you can hang out while I’m doing that.” He couldn’t stand to see Steve sad, and honestly, it was better this way for the 2 of them to hang out. Billy was impressed with how stupidly smooth Steve was. 

Steve’s face lit up again, like a lantern, and Billy was a moth… he had to stop thinking with analogies, Jesus. “Yeah, that sounds fun.” 

And so that’s what they did. 

Steve sat on one of the pool chairs while Billy got out the cleaning supplies from the storage closet, a closet that could fit maybe 2 people if they were really close together. Billy tried not to think about that, him and Steve were just going to be hanging out. 

Billy walked in front of Steve’s pool chair to begin cleaning out the sides of the pool. Billy could only imagine the amount of bacteria festering from all the snotty children. He wasn’t even thinking about the purple bruise on his back until Steve let out a hiss. “Damn, is that new?” 

“What is?” Billy asked, turning over to look at him. 

“The bruise.” Steve gestured to his own back, where Billy’s bruise was. “Is it new?” He asked again. 

Billy stared at him for a second before breathing out a laugh. “No, I actually got it two days ago, or something.” He turned to scrubbing the pool walls, slowly making his way down away from Steve. 

“How’d you get it?” 

He gripped the pole tighter. It was foreign for someone to care about him, first Max and now Steve. Susan didn’t count. She had done little to help Billy’s situation. And Billy’s mom… He was still unsure if she really cared about him after leaving. There was an inkling of emptiness spreading throughout his body, uncertainty about whether he should say something. Steve might brush it off, say that everyone’s dads do that. Or, he could care too much, start pitying Billy. He didn’t know which one was worse. 

“My dad.” He said simply, staring down at the water. “I broke a mug and I guess it had some sentimental value, so my dad shoved me into the counter.” 

“Damn…” Steve breathed out. “I’m sorry dude.” 

“Yeah, it’s whatever.” Billy just wanted to change the subject. This fun little hang out idea took a fucking right turn into depressing. He hadn’t even thought about putting a shirt on or anything. His brain just wasn’t working properly since he saw Steve’s car. 

“I thought my parents sucked.” Steve said. “I mean, my mom tried to choke me to death once when I was younger.” 

Billy turned around to face Steve. Sparks flew from his brain as the gears in his head stopped rolling. “What!?” He didn’t mean to laugh, but the absurdity of it all made him. 

“Yeah.” Steve shrugged and sipped at his beer. “I had a six-month-old sister and when I was five, my parents left me in charge of her. I guess they forgot children can’t take care of other children and… she died.” 

“Holy shit, Steve.” Billy’s jaw was hanging by his feet. “Are you okay?” He couldn’t possibly piece together why Steve was being so vulnerable to him right now. 

“I’m fine.” Steve gave him a small smile. “I’ll have my sad moments about it, but I’ve come to realize none of it wasn’t really my fault.” 

“Yeah, no shit, it wasn’t your fault.” Billy stared at him with shock, not really knowing how to continue on with the conversation. “My mom left me.” If Steve was being vulnerable to him, why couldn’t he bite back at anxiety and be vulnerable with Steve?

Steve looked at him confused. “Max has a mom. I’ve met her.” 

“Susan is my step-mom.” 

“Max isn’t your real sister?!” Steve sat up with his jaw hanging low. 

“You didn’t know this!?” Billy laughed, going back to scrubbing the pool walls. 

“No! Max never told me!” Steve said. “She always just called you her brother.” 

That was sweet. Billy couldn’t deny that. It also kind of hurt him. Forever he had been denying the fact that Max was his sister and to find out she always referred to him as her brother? Heartbreaking. “Do you think we look alike?” 

Steve shrugged. “You guys are both assholes.” 

Billy cursed at him, looking up to see the guy just smiling at him. Billy couldn’t handle it, couldn’t take it. He was going to say something stupid if Steve didn’t say anything first. 

“Since Nancy broke up with me, I haven’t been able to score any more dates.” 

If Billy read between the lines, he could see Steve saying, ‘Since we broke up, I haven’t been able to score any more dates’. But that would be stupid, because that could mean that Steve still liked him, and Steve couldn’t still like Billy. But he showed up to the pool once it was closed, so the two were alone, he blushed at the thought of them hanging out more, and he really looked like he wanted to hang out with Billy today. 

“I’m still in love with you.” 

Everything stopped. Billy held on tight to the pole of the broom he was using, his knuckles turning white. There was a stinging in his eyes and he knew that in seconds he would start crying, and usually he’d be so good at hiding it. Pushing down the sting and pain and getting a normal resting face, but he couldn’t stop it this time. He couldn’t stop the despair crawling up into his throat as it tightened. He couldn’t stop. Steve was the most beautiful thing Billy had ever seen, and he didn’t deserve Steve at all. 

“My middle name is Miranda.” 

Billy wanted to bite his head off. Holy shit, Steve was so stupid. “What?” 

“My- My middle name is Miranda.” Steve said again, the blush on his face being illuminated by the pool lights. Billy was so in love with him. 

“That’s a stupid fucking middle name.” 

“Yeah.” He sighed. “That’s why I don’t tell anyone about it.” 

For a second Billy thought that maybe that was Steve’s ‘I love you too’. Something no one knew, something that he only told Billy, but that would be stupid. Because everything Billy thought would be stupid, even this stupid hangout idea. He was just glad that Steve changed the subject. He was so happy Steve was here because if he wasn’t, Billy might’ve fallen into the pool and not tried to get up. 

Billy just laughed, and Steve laughed too. And the anxiety didn’t fade away like Billy wanted it to, but the pain was gone. The pain was gone and Steve was with Billy, and they were both laughing. 

That was enough for Billy.

Chapter 2: Raspberry Ice Cream

Notes:

this is really short, but I hope you guys like it anyway. And I know I should probably make their getting back together scene longer, but they're impulsive assholes so it kinda makes sense (let me think that)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Robin’s job was mind numbingly boring, especially today. And she thought boring days would be good relaxing days, but it became very apparent that she missed the excitement of little kids coming to the counter to mess with her and ask to taste the flavors 20 times over. 

She was about to turn around and just go in the back to hang out with Steve when the stinging smell of smoke filled her nostrils, along with the clicking sound of hard boots against tile. Robin turned her head to see Billy Hargrove walking up to the counter. Black jeans, black leather jacket, black boots, black sunglasses- Jesus, who did this guy think he was? And it was like… a 100 degrees in Hawkins and he was wearing all black? Apart from his white Iron Maiden shirt, but Robin doubted that would make a difference. And this dickface was smoking? Who smokes in a mall? 

“Um- you can’t smoke in here.” She was leaning away from him to get as far away from the smoke as she could. Robin couldn’t stand the smell. She didn’t know how people started smoking. 

“Oh… sorry.” He scrunched his nose up before pushing off the counter and dropping the cigarette to the floor, crushing it under his boots. What a fucking asshole. How was Steve friends with this guy? “Is Steve Harrington working today?” 

“Yes…?” Had he just read her mind? 

“Could I talk to him?” 

Robin gave him a look of uncertainty. Why would he want to talk to Steve? Couldn’t he just wait till tomorrow morning? “Yeah… I can go get him-” 

“Could I speak to him privately?” 

Okay, now Robin was really confused and conflicted. Because she didn’t really trust Billy and Steve being alone (cough cough they beat each other’s asses like 7 months ago cough cough), but she was also kinda scared of what Billy might do to her if she said no. The guy was scary as shit. “I can’t really let you go back there.” She cringed. 

“It’ll just be five minutes, and if I go over that time, you can drag me out of there by my hair.” 

He’d probably like that… sicko. Everything about him made Robin want to gag and cower in fear. God. “Okay, five minutes. Can you try not to steal anything?” 

“Oh, I’ll try my hardest.” He gave her a wink before opening the counter and pushing through the swinging door. Robin had no idea what his deal was. 

Steve was doodling in a coloring book Max had given to him as a late Christmas gift while listening to SOS by ABBA (the best ABBA song) when the break room door swung open. He was expecting it to be Robin or something, but instead- 

“Billy!?” He exclaimed and before anything else could happen, the collar of his uniform was grabbed and his face was smashed against Billy’s.  

Sparks flew from Steve’s brain as his lips melted against the blonde’s. He felt like crying because he had absolutely no idea what’s going on. His awareness scale has dropped to 0, and it feels as if Billy had stolen all his brain cells in one kiss. And what makes it worse is that Steve isn’t even sure Billy wants the kiss because it’s rough and hard and Billy isn’t moving his lips, he’s just pressing them against Steve’s, so Steve pushes them apart. 

They stared at each other for a second, panting hard, almost like they were wild animals. Steve knew Billy was one, but what about himself? Was he an animal? Billy made him want to be an animal, Billy made him want to be everything he wasn’t… in a good way. Steve had never felt so good in his life. 

Nancy was beautiful. She was smart, kind, gentle; she was gorgeous. Nancy had made Steve feel good, but not in the way Billy did. Steve didn’t like nice and gentle anymore, he wanted something mean. Something that would bite back at him. He wanted to burn; he wanted his skin to bubble with pain; Steve wanted his entire body to be red with sunburn. 

So, in a moment of pure impulsiveness, Steve tore off his headphones, sprung from his chair, and kissed Billy back. 

His hands fisted in Billy’s collar like Billy had done his, and their feet were moving on their own. Before Steve knew it, they were both in the back hallway, where they got all their supplies and where the kids went to sneak into the movies. Steve was pushed up against the wall and they were actually kissing, pulling away to take quick breaths, only to push up against each other again. And it was pure fucking bliss. Steve couldn’t be happier. Billy was insane, kissing him in the middle of the day when anyone could walk in, but Billy’s insanity only made Steve want to kiss him more. 

It only made Steve want to love him more. 

Fuck it, Steve loved Billy. He loved everything about him, the slit in his eyebrow, his curly hair, his blue eyes, his asshole attitude, his biting sarcasm, his harsh kisses. Steve loved all of it. And Steve’s heart had been longing for Billy even more since last night when he confessed to him, when he said what Steve had been thinking the entire time. 

It terrified that he could love someone like Billy - that he could love Billy, but he did. 

“I love you.” Steve breathed against Billy’s lips. Billy pulled away only an inch away, not wanting to move farther away from Steve. Steve liked to think that it was because Billy was afraid of losing him again, because he was terrified of losing Billy. “I need to know if you’re serious about this, if- if you really want to do this.” He didn’t know if he was also insane for doing this, asking Billy to be his boyfriend in the middle of the day. 

Billy just looked at him for a moment. “I want to do this.” He said so confidently, so much more confidently than Steve could ever say. “I want to be with you.” 

And that just made Steve’s heart soar. “I want to be with you, too.” 

“I’m glad we’ve come to an agreement.” Billy teased, and Steve’s face flushed a bright red. He was too in love. And Steve didn’t care if they were going too fast. Steve wanted to go even faster. 

He pulled Billy back into a kiss, smiling into it as he grabbed the man’s face and made sure that both their lips were melting like raspberry ice cream.

Notes:

Rember I've always up for criticism and I always appreciate you guys who read my silly little stories <3

Chapter 3: She Knows

Notes:

Something sweet about Max finding out about this idiots before we get sad

Chapter Text

Billy was re-reading The Crucible on his bed while Max blasted Queen’s Stone Cold Crazy because she had just recently (20 minutes ago) found the tape and decided it was her favorite song now. Billy didn’t mind that much, he was too busy wondering if he’d be Abigail Williams in this story. Cursed by the feeling of love to do unspeakable things. He’d do unspeakable things for someone to finally love him. He’d do unspeakable things for Steve. 

Maybe he wouldn’t be anyone, a simple bystander as the witch trails went on… maybe he’d accuse someone else so he wouldn’t get hung. Witchcraft, queerness, kinda the same thing, right? Or perhaps he’d be like Giles Corey and in his dying breaths he’d still be an asshole, ask for more weight as the rocks piled on top of him. 

When remembering his and Steve’s ‘breakup’, Billy wondered if Steve could relate to the words John Proctor said to Abigail. “I may think of you softly from time to time. But I’ll cut my hand before I ever reach for you again.” Maybe that’s what Billy was thinking. 

He’ll probably never know. It was too long ago, and he doesn’t particularly like remembering that night. 

“Why do you even have that poster if you’re gay?” Max asked over the music, pointing towards the practically naked woman plastered on Billy’s closet door. 

Billy pulled the book away from his face, staring at his sister with dead eyes. “Why are you still leading Lucas on despite the fact your 5 moves away from dating El?” 

Max gave her brother a dirty look, and he gave her an even dirtier one. They stared at each other for a moment before she finally snapped. 

“Fuck you.” She hissed. 

“Fuck you!” Billy responded as his sister went back to jumping around his room with the Queen song, making his eardrums bleed. He had gotten off work and with Susan and Neil gone on their jobs, Billy wasn’t planning on doing anything today. He had gotten a head splitting headache from a children’s birthday party coming in and now he just wanted to re-read his book and rot in his bed. 

But he suddenly changed all his plans once he heard a knock on his window. His mind paused for a second because he was thrilled about whoever was knocking on his window, but Max was also in the room. 

Billy shot up in his bed at the sound. Max snapped her head towards the window. Her head gravitated towards looking at Billy and a cruel smile appeared on her face. Billy could only give her a dangerous stare. 

Max bolted towards the window, Billy jumped off his bed and was about to grab her, but she was able to pull apart Billy’s blinds before he could get his hands on her. A gasp left her mouth and Billy turned away from the window, biting into his fist. Steve Harrington was outside Billy’s window, standing in their flower bushes, with a look of fear on his face. 

Billy turned back around, and Max was staring at him with glee. He opened his mouth to say something, but she beat him to it. 

“How long?” 

“A week.” It still amazed him they had lasted this long. 

“Since when?” 

“The tenth.” He had that date burned into his memory. 

Max’s smile dropped. “It’s been a week and you haven’t told me!?” She let go of the blinds to slap him. 

“Hey!” He hissed, backing away from her attacks. “I was playing it safe.” 

“Were you ever going to tell me!?” 

Billy stayed silent at that, and Max went to hit him again. Max would never tell anyone, Billy knew that, he knew her. She was always good with the sensitive things in Billy’s life. She never pushed too hard about the fights he had with Neil. When he’d tell her to stop talking about something, she’d stop most of the time, and with Billy’s gay-ness, she had been understanding. She didn’t say it was weird, because if she did, she’d be calling herself weird. And she made sure to never talk about it in front of anyone. Billy could’ve told Max, but he was still scared. He was still scared that maybe one day all of that goodness in her would fade away and she’d rat Billy out to Neil. He could never be okay with being himself. 

“Look, I was half expecting you to find out on your own!” Max had figured out that Billy was dating an old friend from California named Argyle 2 days after they started dating. She told him he hadn’t been obvious about it, that she just knew him. 

“Well, I knew something was up with you.” She snapped. “You look happy and you’re never happy.” 

“I’m always happy.” A lie. 

“Shut up.” Max pushed past him and out of his room. 

He followed her out of his room. “Where are you going?” He held onto his door frame as he leaned away from it. 

“Talking to Steve.” She said, while opening the front door. 

“Uh, no.” He held her wrist. “Talking to him about what?” 

She gave a dirty look. “You, dumbass.” She snatched her wrist out of grasp.  

He looked at her with wide eyes, and she just stared back at him. Billy wondered how many of these little staring contests they’ve had since they met each other. Probably too many. “Don’t be a fucking weirdo.” He said sternly. He couldn’t not let her talk to Steve, she could talk to whoever she wanted to. Billy just really did not want her to say anything stupid to Steve that would make him runaway or something. He had to give it to his little sister, she was fucking scary. 

Steve appeared on their front porch. “Hi.” He waved cautiously. 

Billy gave him a soft smile and waved back. Max cooed at him and poked his stomach before quickly exiting the house. She was going to say something stupid. 

Steve was standing on the porch with Max staring at him as she pressed against the front door. He fiddled with his hands as they kept eye contact with the soon-to-be freshman. She made him really nervous for some reason. Not for some reason, she made him nervous because she was really scary. Narrowing her eyes as she stared at Steve, he was half expecting her to start blasting insults and cursing at him. 

“So, you’re with Billy.” She took a step towards him, so he took a step back. 

“Yeah.” He answered. 

Max hummed. “There were a lot of people like that in San Francisco.” She leaned back against the door. “Billy’s been through a lot.” 

“I know.” They hadn’t talked about it a lot, but Steve knew. 

“You have to be patient with him.” 

“I know.” It was kinda rude to compare him to a frightened animal, but he was. Steve had noticed it as soon as they started talking about the more ‘personal’ parts of themselves. Billy was clinging onto that cruel ‘bad boy’ reputation he got the Hawkins High crown for. 

“He’s an asshole, but he’s an asshole for a reason.” 

“I know, Max.” Steve reassured her. It was funny how she now seemed like the worried one. 

She looked at him with sad eyes. “I just need to tell you.”

Steve’s heart kinda broke at this. It was sweet how worried Max was about her brother. Steve wished he had siblings like that… he wished he had siblings… “I won’t hurt him.” He breathed. “I promise, if anything, he’ll hurt me first.” 

Max laughed at this. “Most definitely. I think he loves you too much to hurt you, though.” 

Steve froze. Max smiled at this. “You think?” He whispered. He was so in love with Billy, he was so in love with him that it hurt at times. 

She nodded. “He looks at you like he’s never seen someone so beautiful. It’s kinda gross.”

He laughed. To hear that Billy’s love for him was so strong that even his sister noticed made his heart soar. He felt hot all over, like Billy was making him get a sunburn while not even getting close to him. That asshole and his goddamn sun.  

“Do you wanna hangout inside?” Max then asked. 

“Oh?” He was kind of planning on taking Billy to the movies, but it wouldn’t hurt to change his plans. “I mean yeah. Are we going to do anything?” 

“I think we have some cookies we could make, or we could watch a movie, or Billy can read us The Crucible.” 

Steve looked at the girl, confused. “Why is he reading The Crucible? Is it for a class next year?” 

“No, he’s just weird a shit. He likes to read weird books.” 

“Huh… I like the sound of cookies.” 

“I do too.” 

Max moved and opened the door to the house, where Billy immediately stuck his head out of his room. “We’re making cookies.” She said, moving into the house with Steve following behind her. 

“Aw, but Steve’s already so sweet.” Billy cooed, kicking the front door closed behind Steve while wrapping his arms around him. Steve was taken aback by the sudden sweetness from Billy, but the sounds of Max gagging meant that he was only doing it to torture his sister. It was still sweet.

“Aww, Billy.” Why not play along? He took Billy’s face and gently kissed him. Max’s gagging increased.

Chapter 4: The Nightmare

Notes:

There will be good things after this don't worry.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

He had just wanted to go on a date with Steve. That’s all he wanted. They had a plan for 9:30 since that was when Steve got off work, they had a plan that Billy would pick him up from his house and they’d go to this cute roller skating rink right outside of town. They had a plan. But now that plan was fucked all to hell. 

Billy pressed his gas pedal to the floor of his car to find the nearest phone booth. His entire body felt numb, and almost like there were needles digging deeper into his skin. His throat felt even worse. He was pretty sure his throat was bleeding. It felt raw and like something had crawled down it. Something probably had. 

He stumbled out of the car and into the phone booth, hands shaking as he dialed 911. He didn’t even know what he was doing. His entire body was shaking and his head felt like it was going to explode. 

There was a clicking sound, and a woman picked up the phone. Billy didn’t even try to wait for her to stop. As soon as the click sounded, Billy was rambling and stuttering through his pleas for help. A spark of pain blew from his head, almost as if someone had stuck a nail in his skull. No one would believe him. No one would believe what had just happened to him. Why would they? If someone came crying to him saying that they just got viciously assaulted by some- some… gloop spider monster, he would think they’re on drugs. He was probably on drugs. Something in his cologne, or maybe his cigarettes were defective. Maybe that weird slime shit on his car was actually a new drug and he was just hallucinating a shit ton. 

Billy was about to hang up the phone when-

“Honey, I’m so sorry. I just can’t stay there anymore.” 

He froze. That was… no… “Mom?” He whimpered out, definitely hallucinating. 

The lights flickered in the booth, his brain pressed against his skull in the most painful way possible. Everything was too loud or too bright, and he felt like combusting into a pile of flames. He stumbled out of the phone booth, but when he opened his eyes, he wasn’t in Hawkins anymore. 

Billy rubbed his eyes a couple of times, seeing stars behind his closed eyelids. He still wasn’t in Hawkins. No amount of muttered ‘no’s could put him back in Hawkins. Billy knew where he was. 

The floor was a deep brown hardwood, and the phone booth that was supposed to be behind was now a little boy’s bedroom. There was a tightness in his chest because he knew where he was. To his left was a big window fashioned with baby blue curtains and that led out to the roof of the house. The sunsets were always the prettiest up there. 

His mom’s voice played over and over again in his head, like a faint whisper that tickled his ears.

“I know, honey. I know.” She cried. “I’m sorry, baby, I’m sorry, but I can’t.”

Billy got to his feet and looked walked to the end of the small top floor. Everything was where it was supposed to be. The bathroom and storage were pressed up against the right wall while the stairs were right across on the left. There was always a gap between the stairs and the front of the house that always made Billy scared to go down them as a kid. Even though there was a railing, he always feared falling down that gap. 

“I don’t know how long, sweetheart.” Her voice was shaking. “Sweetheart, I don’t know.”

When he made his way down the stairs, his mother’s voice was even louder, repeating the phone call he had with her 8 years ago. The garage was right in front of the stairs, when he made a right there was the foyer with the glass sliding door as their front door. Billy’s dad would always remind him to lock it and every time he forgot, that would be a slap. His body burned as the memory of his father’s hand snapped against his skin. 

Billy took another right and there was the dining/living room. There was the TV where he’d watch Captain Cosmic, or some other kids’ show. There was the kitchen where he’d sit on the island and watch his mom make some French food he could never pronounce the name of. He pushed forward, past the kitchen where he was now looking out the back glass sliding doors. There was a porch where he’d sit for hours and talk with his mom and… there was the beach. The beach where he’d surf, burn, and eat ice cream. There was his beach.  

And on that beach was his mom. The woman with wavy blonde hair, pretty blue eyes, and the best smile. His mom’s voice got louder and louder, drumming against his ears.

“I need to go. Dad’s gonna be mad.” That was always her answer. “I’ll speak to you soon.”

“I love you.”

Tears stung his eyes as he opened the sliding glass door, walking out to the beach where his mom’s back was facing him. It felt weird, his black boots digging into the sand instead of flip-flops or sandals. His entire outfit felt so out of place from his sunny golden surroundings. The dirt and blood on his body didn’t make his aesthetic fit anymore. 

“Mom?” He whispered, hesitantly taking his hand to place it gently on her shoulder. She felt so real, but she couldn’t be, none of this could be real. It made him cry. 

Matilda turned around, her face just as soft and beautiful as ever. It made him cry even more, he couldn’t help it. He felt like a pussy. She gently cupped his face with her hand, wiping away a fallen tear with her thumb. 

“I need you to build.” She whispered with a smile, a… a dangerous smile. 

“What?” 

“I want you to build.” 

Billy didn’t understand what was going on. “Build- Build what?” 

She leaned up close to him, her breath tickling his ear. “You’ll see.” 

There was a sharp migraine like pain in his head. 

He gasped and suddenly he was sitting in the back driveway of the Hargrove house. His knuckles were turning white from how tightly he was holding onto his steering wheel. Was any of that real? Did all of that really happen? 

Billy looked in his rear-view mirror. The cuts and scrapes on his face were all healed with slightly red skin where it had been put back together, but the dirt was not. And when he focused on what was in front of him, his windshield was still broken and the hood of his car was still dented in. 

All of that really happened. Holy shit. He couldn’t drive all the way back to Steve’s, because what if all of that happened again? What would Steve say? Steve wouldn’t believe him. No one was going to believe him.  

Billy was going to die with no one believing him. Oh god. 

 

Steve was moping around the ice cream store all day. He felt like shit. Billy had ditched him on their date and when Steve went over to the pool to talk to him, he was being followed into a storage closet by Karen Fucking Wheeler. What? 

Billy had talked to him a couple times about how obsessed those moms were with him, and how he’d play along with their little game and flirt back. Steve knew that this was for keeping up appearances to make sure no one suspected anything, but Billy wouldn’t actually cheat on him… right? Steve always felt paranoid about that, after whatever happened with Nancy and Jonathan, but that wouldn’t happen. Billy wouldn’t do that. 

Steve could’ve been overthinking the entire situation. Maybe Karen followed Billy into the storage closet because he was getting her something. But it still didn’t make sense why had he ditched on their date.

And on top of all that, he had to worry about fucking stupid Russian message. Ugh. 

“Hey!” Max hopped in front of him, with El by her side. “Can I get a large strawberry cone?” 

“And can I get a large vanilla with-” El’s sentence faltered as she forgot something. 

“Sprinkles.” Max whispered. 

“With sprinkles?” El continued. 

“Yeah, sure.” Seeing the kids was always a way to cheer him up. Steve began getting the cones when he stopped. “Wait- are you even allowed to be here?” He pointed at El. 

The girl just shrugged.

“She’s here now, so what’s the point?” Max asked. 

Steve knew El was supposed to keep a low profile, but what harm was getting ice cream going to do? He got their scoops when Robin interrupted his exchange. 

“We’ve got our first sentence.” She said with a smile. 

“Oh?” Steve slid over to the back counter. “Which is?” 

“The week is long.” She said with a Russian accent and raised brows at the end. 

Steve’s excitement dropped. “That’s thrilling.” 

“I know! Progress!” She smiled again before closing the glass divider in his face. 

Steve rolled his eyes and went back to the giggling girls at the front counter. “Here is your strawberry and vanilla with sprinkles.” The girls happily took the ice cream. “Oh, Max,” he leaned down and lowered his voice to a whisper, “can I talk about Billy in front of her?” He gestured towards El, who was licking her ice cream. 

Max immediately got what was asking. “Oh, yeah, she knows about me so.” She shrugged. 

“Okay, well, the next time you see your brother, can you smack him around for me?” 

Max’s face scrunched up. “Why? What did he do?” 

“The asshole ditched me on our date.” Steve whispered to her. 

El’s mouth opened. “Date?” She whispered. 

“I’ll tell you later.” Max told her before going back to Steve. “Yeah, I was wondering why he didn’t sleep over at your house last night. He knocked on my window at like 10 something to let him into the house.” 

That made Steve worry a bit. “Is… Is he okay?” He asked. 

Max shrugged. “He seemed fine last night. Kind of distant, so I assumed that maybe you guys got into a fight, but you guys always make up pretty quickly after your arguments.” 

“Yeah, I thought that-” He was not going to tell Billy’s little sister that he thought her big brother was cheating on him with Karen Wheeler. “Maybe when you see him, just make sure he’s okay.” 

“Will do.” Max snapped her fingers. “And thanks for the ice cream!” She started walking backwards with El. 

“Thank you!” The telekinetic little girl waved at Steve before spinning around and walking out of the store with her friend. 

Steve really hoped that Billy was okay. 

 

Max couldn’t believe it, not one bit of it. She couldn’t believe Billy. It made genuinely no fucking sense to her. He was acting totally out of character. First Steve says that Billy bailed on their date, which is so not like him, then El finds him with a freaked out Heather during their little spy game, and then neither of them are at their jobs? Max didn’t get it, and she was getting really worried about her brother. Luckily, El had found out where Heather lived and, thankfully, Billy was there with her. Well, not really thankfully, it made it almost like Billy was… no… he wouldn’t. 

The way Billy was staring at her and El felt so… unnatural, almost like it wasn’t really him staring at them. And he was all dolled up like some preppy rich boy. It was totally not his style. His shirt was buttoned all the way up and Max was 90% sure it was Neil’s. 

“I’m sorry,” Mr. Halloway cut in. “Who is this dripping all over my living room right now?” 

Billy chuckled, it was dry and so so fake. “I’m sorry. Janet, Tom, this is my sister, Maxine.” Billy knows Max hates it when he calls her that. He only calls her that when he’s trying to get her attention. There was no reason for him to get her attention right now. Something was fucked with him. 

Billy stood up and walked over to the soaking wet girls. “What on earth are you doing here?” He sounded like a goddamn suburban dad. It was going to make Max vomit. “Is something wrong?” 

Is something wrong? Is something wrong!? Max wanted to scream in his face, but instead she lowered her voice to a hiss. “This is what you’ve been doing while bailing on Steve? Having dinner with Heather fucking Halloway?” 

Billy just stared at her. There was something in his eyes… like a glint or something. But it went as soon as it came, and Billy slowly tilted his head. “Who?” He asked, and Max’s jaw dropped to the floor. 

Who!? WHO!? What the fuck did he mean by ‘who’!? Who gave a shit if they were in front of people right now? Billy could at least give some kind of excuse, but instead he had to say ‘who’? Max just couldn’t believe it. There was definitely something wrong with Billy, big time. 

 

Billy’s body was no longer his. Something had crawled inside of him and kicked him out. His mind was festering with squirming vines that traveled all the way through his nervous system. His memory kept fading in and out. He had no idea what was going on half the time. There was so much blood on his hands, so many people were now dead because of him - turned into a weird fucking slimy spider creature. Billy had tried screaming for help, tried to push through the vines, but a hand would grab him by his hair and pull him right back into this little cage he was in. 

He fucking hated himself. He just wanted to grab something and stick it through his skull, pull off the vines on his brain, and bleed out on his bedroom floor. And it’s not like he really liked 4th of July, but hanging out getting drunk at some stupid carnival would be a million times better than sitting in his room alone while the vines dug deeper into his brain. 

And then there was something new - someone new. A new presence, someone sweet, kind, innocent. They felt nothing like the cruel, disgusting, vile vines growing in his brain - slithering through his body. 

He felt his hand being held, yet no one was really there. And then he heard it. 

“Billy?” It was faint, but sweet. Something new to the voices of hatred that swarmed his brain. “Can you hear me?” 

He wanted to say yes, to say that he can hear the young girl talking to him right now. It sounded similar to the El girl that Max was friends with… but why would she be in his brain? He was fighting to open his mouth, but then there was a hand reaching into his hair. No. 

“I want to see.” The girl whispered. He wanted to tell her to run away. “I want to see what happened.” 

Billy looked up at her, or looked up at where he felt she was at. He wants to tell her to run, to turn away now, to let go of his hand. The hand in his hair is balling up into a fist. He knows there’s going to be a tug soon enough. 

Then there’s a tightness, the vines are grabbing the girl, they’re trying to pull her towards him. They’re trying to pull her towards the vines - towards the monster. Billy ignored the hand in his hair, ignored the growing tug, and he used all his strength to let go. He didn’t know what he was letting go of, but he was letting go of something. 

And then his hair was pulled. 

He gasped. There was new air circulating through his lungs, new blood being pumped into his body. The vines were gone, his mind was clear, his heart was happy. 

Billy was laying down on something wet and pillowy, but also hard and rough. His entire backside felt wet, and everything smelt of salt. He sat up carefully, scared that any sudden movements would take him out of this serene place. 

He was on the beach… on his beach. Turning his head, Billy could see the beach house. For a second, he thought that maybe this would be like his dream back when all of this started, but his worry was washed away in an instant. That dream made Billy feel scared. This one just made him feel relaxed. 

Billy was finally home. 

The tears stinging his eyes finally broke through, so did the gasping sounds from his throat. Breathy sobs of relief and pain washed over him. He held his knees to his chest and just sobbed. Months of having to keep in his emotions - years of training himself to not be weak finally crumbled, and he was crying. It was disgusting and ugly. Tears and snot ran down his face as his vocal cords swelled. For the past couple of days, his mind had been silent, deprived of the heavy metal music and the sounds of his annoying sister that he’d usually listen to, but now, everything was so loud. Billy had never been more grateful to hear annoying noises. Seagulls squawking, the waves crashing up on each other, the sounds of his cries. Everything was so perfectly imperfect. 

His tears calmed down a bit, his sobbing turning into small gasps and sniffles. It felt freeing to finally cry so hard, like being back on a beach finally let him be free. The waves washing over his boots and getting his jeans all wet felt so comforting. Billy just wished he could be like the ocean, strong and carefree. If Billy was like the ocean, all of his problems would wash away in a single wave. 

He looked over to his side, and there was a baby blue surfboard in the sand. There was a black stripe down the middle and on the back of the board was a bunch of Hawaiian flowers. Billy only knew because this was his surfboard, the surfboard that Neil had snapped in half when they were 2 months away from moving. He told Billy it was so he could get used to not being able to surf, Billy had wondered if Neil found out he was gay. But if Neil found out was gay, he probably would’ve been the one snapped in half and not his surfboard. 

Billy didn’t know how the surfboard got here in the first place. He didn’t even know how any of this was happening. It had to be a dream, and Billy was just aware that this was a dream, so he had to have conjured this surfboard up. It kinda made sense. 

He looked out at the ocean again. The waves were crashing up on each other. Billy could definitely surf these. And it seemed like an inappropriate time to do so, seeing as his life was basically crumbling before his eyes, but if he was going to die, why not do it while he was happy? 

He stood up and first kicked off his boots and socks, feeling the sand with his feet was such a strange, but familiar, texture. Then came his belt and jeans, throwing them on the wet sand, and then his tank top. The wounds on his arm that were once a black color from whatever was living inside of him were now a slightly darker color from his skin from scarring. It made him feel even nicer that whatever used to be living inside of him was gone at the moment. 

Billy grabbed the surfboard and made his way into the ocean, his walk becoming a run, and his run becoming a sprint as the sea spray tickled his face. He couldn’t believe it. He was home. 

The water was perfect, warm and cozy in every sense of the way. The sun was doing wonders, casting a golden glow on everything Billy’s eyes met. Everything was tinkling, like bright, beautiful stars. The clap of the waves, the slap of the water as he paddled further out. It was all music to Billy’s ears. The comfortable cool warmness of the water as his hands swayed through was enough to put him to sleep. 

He was happy. Billy couldn’t say that very often. Billy could barely say that at all. 

So when the biggest wave started barreling toward him, Billy smiled. Bright and sharp, a smile that his mother kissed at, a smile that Steve and Max have almost seen on him. A smile that Neil will never get to experience. 

His stomach was filled with butterflies as the wave came closer to him, as he stood with shaky feet on his surfboard. He hadn’t done this in so long, but his body was working on its own. Billy was remembering. He could smell the salt everywhere, and taste it where the spray had landed on his lips. His heart beat faster as the wave approached him, and then it happened. 

He was in a tunnel of water, gliding - flying through. His hand touched the inside of the tunnel, memories of past beach hangouts burst into his mind and he couldn’t help the tears that fell from his eyes. Billy could stay here forever, covered in shadows as he moved through the wave. 

But there had to be an ending, and from the way the wave was closing up in front of him, he wasn’t going to make it. So he closed his eyes and let the wave engulf him. They swept him off his surfboard and his body fell into the water. He felt undoubtedly beautiful as the water ate him up, stole the air from his lung, and filled everything with salt and sand. He could feel it coursing through his body, replacing where the vines once were. Sunny, golden blue waters filling up his veins and drowning his nervous system, covering his brain in cool waters that made him feel at home. 

Billy didn’t even try to fight the feeling of drowning as the water took over his entire system. He let the ocean drown the butterflies in his stomach, replace the blood in his heart with seawater, and litter seashells all over his brain. He could only wait for when he got to move back to California - when he got accepted into some English California college and run back home. Run back into the ocean. He’d have to take Max and Steve with him, drag them into the van or plane that he was taking. And he’d have to teach Steve how to surf, how to traverse the waves like how him and Max did. 

And god did he love Steve and Max. He loved them so, so much. But Billy didn’t know if he could love them as much as he loved the ocean. 

But, just as he started peacefully drowning in the salty water, there was a darkness. A darkness that spread throughout his nervous system and made his body feel freezing cold. 

The vines were back. They were sucking up all the water, growing bigger and sprouting from his brain and his bones, making his body ache all over. All he could do was writhe in pain as a hand crawled its way onto Billy’s head, his curls spilling over the fingers of the hand. The hand started tightening. All Billy could do was cry. 

And then there was a tug.

His body was not his. All he could do was cry as he watched himself walk out of a room and into a cabin living room. That El girl was standing in fear as she stared at him. 

Billy’s body was no longer his. He was no longer beautiful. 

 

The drugs that they had been viciously pumped with were finally getting to the harsher side effects after Robin and Steve started admiring the pretty mall lights. They both sprinted to the closest bathroom to vomit out whatever drug they had been given. ‘Truth serum’ or something, Steve was just pretty sure he was on acid. 

He flushed his puke away and leaned up against the cold tile of the bathroom wall. The floor tiles were even colder against the bare skin of his legs. He really hated his work uniform right now. 

Steve could barely see out of his left eye and he was 80% sure that after this was all over, he’d have to get glasses. There was dried blood over his face that made everything uncomfortably tight, and his lip was throbbing in pain. His head felt even worse. He wasn’t sure if the pounding in his head was his brain trying to break out of his skull or his heartbeat beating so loud he could hear it in his head. 

“The ceiling stopped spinning for me.” Robin said. Steve almost forgot she was still with him. “Is it still spinning for you?” 

Steve looked up at the ceiling, surprising everything was staying in place. “Holy shit.” He breathed. “No. You think we puked it all up?” 

He could see that Robin was laying down on the floor in the stall on the right. “Maybe. Ask me something.” She shimmed her way up, sitting up against the stall walls. “Interrogate me.” She said in a Russian accent, and Steve rolled his eyes. But he regretted it because it felt like he was trying to pull his eyes out afterward. God, that was stupid. 

“Okay. Interrogate you, sure. Um…” Steve swayed his head side to side as he thought of a question. “When was the last time you, uh- peed your pants?” 

“Today.” Robin said without hesitation, and Steve laughed in shock. 

“What?” 

“Yeah.” Robin giggled. “When the Russian doctor took the bone saw out-” 

“Oh, my god.” Steve laughed with Robin’s growing laughter. 

“It was just a little bit, though.” She continued giggling like a child. “Just a little. 

Steve scoffed, a smile on his face. “Yeah, it’s definitely still in her system.” He was talking as if Robin wasn’t in the room with him right now.

Robin continued to giggle. “Okay, okay, my turn.” 

Steve sighed. “Hit me.” Was all he could say, mentally preparing himself for whatever embarrassing question Robin was going to ask him. 

“Have you… ever been in love?” She asked, her voice pitching up a bit at the end of her question. 

And what a question it was. It was preparing her to ask him when was the last time he cried, or what was his score the last time he failed a test. Not some heavy question like this. “Um… yeah, Nancy Wheeler. First semester of Junior to first semester of Senior.” He remembered so vividly what happened during that first semester of his senior year. 

“Oh, yeah, you guys broke up.” 

What an amazing reminder. “Yeah, we did.” 

Robin hummed. “She’s such a priss.” 

Steve scoffed out a laugh. He had thought the same thing when he first got with her. Such a sweet innocent girl that turned out to be a gun wielding badass. “Turns out, not really.” 

Robin hummed again. There was a beat of silence between them. There was something uncomfortable squirming in Steve’s stomach about Robin’s reactions to his answers. “Are you still in love with Nancy?” She asked. 

“No.” No, he was not. He was in love with someone totally different from Miss. Nancy Wheeler. It hadn’t been in love with Nancy since he looked up into the sky and found the sun.

“Why not?” 

He could help the smile on his face as he swiped the hair away from his face. “Because I found someone who’s a little bit better for me.” 

“Oh? Do tell.” 

Steve didn’t know what to say - how to say it. His mind was already woozy, but as soon as he started thinking about Billy, he felt even lighter in the head. He was too in love for his own good. “H-” He paused. Steve had to slowly process what he wanted to say so he wouldn’t slip up. “She’s great. She’s so great. I can’t really talk about her in front of my friends because we’re totally different people, and I’m scared that maybe if I talked about her, people would make fun of me.” His mind drifted off. He couldn’t keep it straight. Ha… “But, she’s so pretty - gorgeous, actually. She’s got these pretty golden princess curls, and the bluest eyes, and the pinkest lips that curl up into the most dangerous smile ever. And god- she’s super mean to me, but in a loving way of course. She’s been through a lot and is kind of mean to everyone because that’s just who she is. And she’s way too strong.” He laughs, thinking of memories of Billy. “She just manhandles me and I let her because I’m so in love with him.” 

Robin might’ve still been on a bunch of drugs, but she was pretty sure that Steve just said him. 

“You know, we were supposed to go on a date a couple of days ago, but he totally bailed on me.” At this point, Steve couldn’t keep the words from falling out of his mouth. “I was sitting in my room waiting forever for him and he just never showed. And when I saw him at the work, the other day, he didn’t even acknowledge me, he just walked into the storage closet with fucking Karen Wheeler. I could tell you about that storage closet, but I don’t think it’s very appropriate for you to hear. And- And-” He felt tears welling up in his eyes and a tightness in his throat. “And his sister said he was acting super weird the night of our date, and so I got all worried for him. And now I haven’t seen him in the past twenty-four hours or something and- and I’m so fucking worried about him.” His knees were curled up to his chest, and he was crying into his crossed arms. The tears were stinging the cuts on his eye and lip, but he couldn’t stop them. He was so worried about his boyfriend. 

Robin slid under the stall wall and into Steve’s space. He couldn’t stop crying, even with her now across from him, leaning against the stall. He felt like a total baby, tears and snot running down his red face. 

“Hey.” Robin whispered. “I might just be crazy, but… did- did you say ‘him’?” 

Shit. Steve wanted to cry even more now, and he did. His tears replaced the words that he wanted to say, his sorry excuse for an explanation. Robin probably wouldn’t have believed it, anyway. 

Robin’s face dropped, her mouth open with what seemed like shock. She looked at Steve before leaning her head back against the red plastic wall of the stall. “Are you dating Billy Hargrove?” 

Of course she would find out, of fucking course. It’s not like either Steve or Billy could keep it in their pants any time they saw each other and whenever Billy came to the ice cream shop, he’d ask Robin for a break so the two of them could go hang out behind the mall. God, why did he have to be so helplessly in love with that jerk. 

He sniffled, unable to stop the gasps as he tried talking to Robin. “He’d kill me if I said yes.” Billy was as sweet as he could be to Steve, but he knew that he if ever outed Billy, he’d fucking pay for it. And Steve didn’t blame him. 

“Holy shit…” Robin breathed, and Steve leaned his head against the tile wall, letting the tears stream down his face. She looked down at the floor between them, her foot was pressed against Steve’s. Their blue and red shoes colliding. What a coincidence. “Hey… you know what I said about Mrs. Click’s class? About me being jealous and obsessed with you?” She asked quietly. 

Steve had half the mind to not answer and just continue crying. He was waiting for her to call him gross and disgusting and run out of the stall. “Yeah.” He answered weakly. 

“It’s because there was this girl in Mrs. Click’s class, Tammy Thompson, and she was obsessed with you.” Robin bit at her lip, taking a deep breath. Steve watched her with blurry, teary eyes. Waiting for whatever mean insult she was going to throw at him. “And I was jealous and obsessed with you, because maybe if I was like you, she’d be obsessed with me.” 

It took Steve a couple of seconds to process what she was telling him, but when it finally slapped him in the head, his jaw dropped. “You… oh.” 

Robin nodded, a worried expression on her face. 

Steve couldn’t help but laugh. Her worried expression turned into a confused one as Steve’s laughter increased. “Jesus Christ.” 

“What?” 

“We’re both gay.” 

Robin’s confused face smoothed into one of glee, and she began laughing with him. The two giggling like children as they held onto each other’s knees. 

Steve was just more than glad that Robin didn’t hate him - that Robin was someone like him. And while he still wasn’t sure if he was totally gay, but he could still appreciate a pretty woman, he knew he was too in love with Billy to really care. “But c’mon, Tammy Thompson?” 

“What’s wrong with Tammy?” 

“She’s a total dud!” 

Robin gasped loudly and offendly. “She is not!” 

“Yeah, she so is.” Steve laughed. “She wants to be, like, a singer and move to Nashville or some shit.” 

“Oh, and you’re telling me Billy Hargrove is better?” 

“A million times better!” Steve exclaimed. “You cannot tell me that the hottest bad boy of Hawkins is lesser than Tammy Thompson and her Miss. Piggy ass singing.” 

Robin screamed out a laugh as Steve started singing in a sad excuse for a Miss. Piggy voice. “You see me now tonight-” 

“She does not sound like that.” 

“No, no, you’re right. She sounds like Kermit.” Robin slapped him, but he just started singing again. “You see me and if you could hold me tight-” 

“Billy looks like an angry Rob Lowe.” Robin giggled. 

“And you’re telling me that’s a bad thing!?” 

The two of them continued laughing until Dustin and Erica burst through the bathroom door, staring at the 2 of them in anger.

“Okay. What the hell.” 

Steve and Robin looked at each other before exploding into a pile of laughter, not being able to contain themselves. Steve was just happy he could finally be himself around someone new - someone that wasn’t his boyfriend’s little sister. 

And then everything happened way too fast. They got out of the bathroom, tried to get out of the mall, got spotted by Russian guards, and then hid behind a counter at the food court. Steve was so ready for them to get caught again and then murdered by fucking Russians. How did any of this even happen? How did he fucking get here? God, if Dustin wasn’t so goddamn curious all the time. He was sure that this was it when an alarm started blaring out of nowhere. 

Steve jumped at the sound, his head feeling like it was going to explode. Robin and Dustin grabbed onto Steve’s hands as the car alarm continued to sound off. Why was a car going off, anyway? It wasn’t like someone would be trying to steal the Chrysler right now. That’d be fucking stupid. 

No one said a word as the car alarm continued to echo through the mall, and then, in the blink of an eye, a large crashing sound replaced the car alarm and the sounds of grunts and groans exploded from what Steve could assume was the Russian guards. 

Everyone stayed silent in fear. Steve was the first one to turn his body around and start standing up. Everyone else followed. Steve surveyed the Russian guards, who were now bloody and thrown about on the floor. The group leaned over the counter and saw the flipped body of the red Chrysler leaning up against another food counter at the corner of the food court. Steve’s mind wasn’t all there, so he couldn’t possibly make up an excuse for how the car got there. 

The 4 of them turned their heads to look at where the car had just been when Steve noticed there were people up on the second floor. He grabbed Dustin’s arm in shock. El, Jonathan, Nancy, Mike, Max, Lucas, and Will were all looking down at them. Max was probably the most comforting sight for Steve to see. They really had tightened their bond since Max found out the 2 of them were dating, it was nice. 

They all hopped the counter as the other group made their way to the escalator. Steve split off from the group to get to Max, who looked suddenly very distressed at the sight of him. She opened her arms and grabbed him in a hug, which he quickly reciprocated. He felt a wetness on his uniform and- shit, was she crying? 

“Hey, hey, it’s okay.” He smoothed her hair out with his hand. “It’s okay, what’s wrong?” 

Max pulled away, eyes teary and red. “It got him. It got Billy.” 

Steve’s head felt like a frozen loading screen. He had no idea what Max was talking about. “What got Billy? Is he okay?” 

“No! The Mind Flayer got to Billy!” 

Steve’s heart dropped. No. No, this couldn’t be true - this couldn’t be real life. “What- What? When? Do you know when?” 

Max just looked at him, and Steve knew. Oh, god did he know. It was their date night, the night that Billy had bailed on him. Oh, shit! Steve didn’t know what to do, how to function, how to carry on with that information. It felt like all the air had been sucked out of his lungs, and there was a stinging in his eyes. No, no, no, he couldn’t cry, not now - not here. He couldn’t cry with all these people around. 

Max sniffled, her eyes teary just as Steve’s. This couldn’t be happening. Steve was just glad that no one was paying attention to them, rather focused on their own little bubbles of reuniting. 

“Is no one going to talk about the car!?” Robin screeched.

This was a nightmare.

Notes:

And that's that! I hope you guys enjoyed this part of my Harringrove AU! Stranger Things AU? I kinda want to write more things that fit into these timeline of events. Like how Elmax got together or how Ellumax got together or how Ellumax kinda broke up (obviously after El moved :/)
idk I'll see what happens in the future.

Notes:

heyyy guuuys
check out my tumblr
@ur-fav-alien
for more harringrove stuff yeaaaaaaaahhh
Also! I always welcome criticism for my work since I'm always trying to improve <3

Series this work belongs to: