Chapter Text
Billy was re-reading The Crucible on his bed while Max blasted Queen’s Stone Cold Crazy because she had just recently (20 minutes ago) found the tape and decided it was her favorite song now. Billy didn’t mind that much, he was too busy wondering if he’d be Abigail Williams in this story. Cursed by the feeling of love to do unspeakable things. He’d do unspeakable things for someone to finally love him. He’d do unspeakable things for Steve.
Maybe he wouldn’t be anyone, a simple bystander as the witch trails went on… maybe he’d accuse someone else so he wouldn’t get hung. Witchcraft, queerness, kinda the same thing, right? Or perhaps he’d be like Giles Corey and in his dying breaths he’d still be an asshole, ask for more weight as the rocks piled on top of him.
When remembering his and Steve’s ‘breakup’, Billy wondered if Steve could relate to the words John Proctor said to Abigail. “I may think of you softly from time to time. But I’ll cut my hand before I ever reach for you again.” Maybe that’s what Billy was thinking.
He’ll probably never know. It was too long ago, and he doesn’t particularly like remembering that night.
“Why do you even have that poster if you’re gay?” Max asked over the music, pointing towards the practically naked woman plastered on Billy’s closet door.
Billy pulled the book away from his face, staring at his sister with dead eyes. “Why are you still leading Lucas on despite the fact your 5 moves away from dating El?”
Max gave her brother a dirty look, and he gave her an even dirtier one. They stared at each other for a moment before she finally snapped.
“Fuck you.” She hissed.
“Fuck you!” Billy responded as his sister went back to jumping around his room with the Queen song, making his eardrums bleed. He had gotten off work and with Susan and Neil gone on their jobs, Billy wasn’t planning on doing anything today. He had gotten a head splitting headache from a children’s birthday party coming in and now he just wanted to re-read his book and rot in his bed.
But he suddenly changed all his plans once he heard a knock on his window. His mind paused for a second because he was thrilled about whoever was knocking on his window, but Max was also in the room.
Billy shot up in his bed at the sound. Max snapped her head towards the window. Her head gravitated towards looking at Billy and a cruel smile appeared on her face. Billy could only give her a dangerous stare.
Max bolted towards the window, Billy jumped off his bed and was about to grab her, but she was able to pull apart Billy’s blinds before he could get his hands on her. A gasp left her mouth and Billy turned away from the window, biting into his fist. Steve Harrington was outside Billy’s window, standing in their flower bushes, with a look of fear on his face.
Billy turned back around, and Max was staring at him with glee. He opened his mouth to say something, but she beat him to it.
“How long?”
“A week.” It still amazed him they had lasted this long.
“Since when?”
“The tenth.” He had that date burned into his memory.
Max’s smile dropped. “It’s been a week and you haven’t told me!?” She let go of the blinds to slap him.
“Hey!” He hissed, backing away from her attacks. “I was playing it safe.”
“Were you ever going to tell me!?”
Billy stayed silent at that, and Max went to hit him again. Max would never tell anyone, Billy knew that, he knew her. She was always good with the sensitive things in Billy’s life. She never pushed too hard about the fights he had with Neil. When he’d tell her to stop talking about something, she’d stop most of the time, and with Billy’s gay-ness, she had been understanding. She didn’t say it was weird, because if she did, she’d be calling herself weird. And she made sure to never talk about it in front of anyone. Billy could’ve told Max, but he was still scared. He was still scared that maybe one day all of that goodness in her would fade away and she’d rat Billy out to Neil. He could never be okay with being himself.
“Look, I was half expecting you to find out on your own!” Max had figured out that Billy was dating an old friend from California named Argyle 2 days after they started dating. She told him he hadn’t been obvious about it, that she just knew him.
“Well, I knew something was up with you.” She snapped. “You look happy and you’re never happy.”
“I’m always happy.” A lie.
“Shut up.” Max pushed past him and out of his room.
He followed her out of his room. “Where are you going?” He held onto his door frame as he leaned away from it.
“Talking to Steve.” She said, while opening the front door.
“Uh, no.” He held her wrist. “Talking to him about what?”
She gave a dirty look. “You, dumbass.” She snatched her wrist out of grasp.
He looked at her with wide eyes, and she just stared back at him. Billy wondered how many of these little staring contests they’ve had since they met each other. Probably too many. “Don’t be a fucking weirdo.” He said sternly. He couldn’t not let her talk to Steve, she could talk to whoever she wanted to. Billy just really did not want her to say anything stupid to Steve that would make him runaway or something. He had to give it to his little sister, she was fucking scary.
Steve appeared on their front porch. “Hi.” He waved cautiously.
Billy gave him a soft smile and waved back. Max cooed at him and poked his stomach before quickly exiting the house. She was going to say something stupid.
Steve was standing on the porch with Max staring at him as she pressed against the front door. He fiddled with his hands as they kept eye contact with the soon-to-be freshman. She made him really nervous for some reason. Not for some reason, she made him nervous because she was really scary. Narrowing her eyes as she stared at Steve, he was half expecting her to start blasting insults and cursing at him.
“So, you’re with Billy.” She took a step towards him, so he took a step back.
“Yeah.” He answered.
Max hummed. “There were a lot of people like that in San Francisco.” She leaned back against the door. “Billy’s been through a lot.”
“I know.” They hadn’t talked about it a lot, but Steve knew.
“You have to be patient with him.”
“I know.” It was kinda rude to compare him to a frightened animal, but he was. Steve had noticed it as soon as they started talking about the more ‘personal’ parts of themselves. Billy was clinging onto that cruel ‘bad boy’ reputation he got the Hawkins High crown for.
“He’s an asshole, but he’s an asshole for a reason.”
“I know, Max.” Steve reassured her. It was funny how she now seemed like the worried one.
She looked at him with sad eyes. “I just need to tell you.”
Steve’s heart kinda broke at this. It was sweet how worried Max was about her brother. Steve wished he had siblings like that… he wished he had siblings… “I won’t hurt him.” He breathed. “I promise, if anything, he’ll hurt me first.”
Max laughed at this. “Most definitely. I think he loves you too much to hurt you, though.”
Steve froze. Max smiled at this. “You think?” He whispered. He was so in love with Billy, he was so in love with him that it hurt at times.
She nodded. “He looks at you like he’s never seen someone so beautiful. It’s kinda gross.”
He laughed. To hear that Billy’s love for him was so strong that even his sister noticed made his heart soar. He felt hot all over, like Billy was making him get a sunburn while not even getting close to him. That asshole and his goddamn sun.
“Do you wanna hangout inside?” Max then asked.
“Oh?” He was kind of planning on taking Billy to the movies, but it wouldn’t hurt to change his plans. “I mean yeah. Are we going to do anything?”
“I think we have some cookies we could make, or we could watch a movie, or Billy can read us The Crucible.”
Steve looked at the girl, confused. “Why is he reading The Crucible? Is it for a class next year?”
“No, he’s just weird a shit. He likes to read weird books.”
“Huh… I like the sound of cookies.”
“I do too.”
Max moved and opened the door to the house, where Billy immediately stuck his head out of his room. “We’re making cookies.” She said, moving into the house with Steve following behind her.
“Aw, but Steve’s already so sweet.” Billy cooed, kicking the front door closed behind Steve while wrapping his arms around him. Steve was taken aback by the sudden sweetness from Billy, but the sounds of Max gagging meant that he was only doing it to torture his sister. It was still sweet.
“Aww, Billy.” Why not play along? He took Billy’s face and gently kissed him. Max’s gagging increased.
