Work Text:
Max didn’t mean to go into the Upside-Down with Eleven, but she was half asleep, and her nightmares were so vivid, after Billy—afterwards—that she grabbed for Eleven’s hand as Eleven shook her awake, and then they were both running.
They ran and ran, their feet and hearts pounding, as Max wiped her eyes and hissed, “Where are we going,” and Eleven shook her head, squeezing Max’s hand.
“I don’t know,” she whispered back, her eyes wide, somehow visible in the darkness.
Then Max saw Billy, and her heart nearly thudded right out of her chest—Billy walking, alive, and she screamed his name and fell towards him, and...out.
She awoke, sweating and panting, and stumbled out of her room to go and stick her head under the kitchen faucet, only to thud into Billy’s chest, warm and solid, in the hallway. She let out a shaky gasp, and he clapped a hand over her mouth.
“What gives, shitbird,” he hissed, lowering his hand, with a glance down the hall towards his father’s door.
“How are you here,” she rasped out, pinching his arm hard, and he swore, glaring at her.
“The fuck does that mean,” he growled back, and she grabbed his arm and drug him back to her room. “Whaddaya want, Max,” he snarled, under his breath, but he came, and she shoved him back on the bed, then paced back and forth, thinking.
“I gotta go, shitbird,” he whispered, checking her clock. “I need to get some crap togeth—”
“Stay there,” she told him, grabbing his arm again, and he looked weirded out, but he sat back down. “Wha—you—you’re okay,” she breathed, trying to fill her lungs, but they shuddered, like a baby’s, and her eyes stung like she was gonna cry.
“What the fuck,” he whispered, his eyes narrowed, and suddenly she registered how chilly it was in her bedroom.
“Why is it cold,” she blurted out, staring around and wondering, as her vision started to blur with tears, whether she was still somehow in the Upside-Down. “It’s August, it’s hot as Satan’s asscrack here, why is it cold—”
“Max, it’s June,” he hissed, grabbing her shoulders, and shaking her, just a little. “What the hell—did you have a nightmare—”
“...It’s June,” she whispered, and then repeated, jubilantly, “Billy! It’s June!”
“I know,” he told her, raising his eyebrows as she grabbed at his hand, squeezing it.
“It’s June, and you’re still alive,” she sobbed, leaning into his shoulder, and he stayed perfectly still, frowning down at her like she’d lost her mind. “Sorry,” she giggled, panting, and squeezing his hand again. “You’re such a fucking shithead. I missed you.”
“I don’t know what the fuck kinda sick joke this is,” Billy muttered, shaking her off, and looking a little shaken himself. “I gotta go.”
“Okay, yeah,” Max said, clearing her throat and nodding. “Yeah. Fuck. Who even wants you, right?” she asked, but she still reached out and clutched at the sleeve of his shirt, and her lungs still made a weird noise.
This time, she swore, things would go different—and they did. By the time July rolled around, she knew to be suspicious. She followed him after work, to Heather’s house, and saw him kill.
And then she banged on Eleven’s door.
This time, she started following him sooner, climbing right in the car with him, and he was furious, but also consented to take her to movies, and out for ice cream, when she told him he was the only brother she had, and she was making the most of it. Remembering him bleeding out on the floor under the dome was enough, usually, to get her after him again—and he’d watch her face, and take her down to where the river flood runoff management was dried out for the summer, and they’d skate in the massive pipes.
It was worse, when he died, because she’d never liked him before. Loved him, sure, growing up in a house with Neil—they’d been like the Allies against the Axis of Evil, she’d thought once, writing a paper about WWII—warring between themselves, but united against fascism. Watching Billy die was crushing in a different way this time, knowing they’d watched shitty sci-fi movies together, sneaking out after Neil went to bed to munch down sleeves of crackers, since popcorn was too loud.
She banged on Eleven’s door, wiping her eyes. “How far do you need to go back?” Eleven asked, immediately, and Max hugged her, shaking her head, and shrugging. She fought back tears, and made an awful wet sniffling noise into Eleven’s shoulder.
“We’ll figure it out,” Eleven told her seriously, taking her hand.
Making friends with Billy hadn’t been the answer, so she made lists—people he talked to, places he went. The time she crashed his interview at the pool, he was furious, but he started acting like a freak three whole weeks later than usual, so the time after that, she followed him every damn day.
It was Karen Wheeler, she finally realized. At some point, he’d talk to Karen Wheeler, agree to meet her at a motel—Max gagged like a cat the first time she figured it out—and he’d run into the Mindflayer. He wouldn’t talk about Karen Wheeler—not that Max really wanted to—but it made it hard to warn him.
Even if Max interrupted every time, eventually, Billy ran into Karen Wheeler alone.
Max set him up on dates. She found Steve Harrington and grilled him on people that might date her brother. He stared, and he and Robin laughed at her—until she promised to climb in their windows at night with pliers, and steal their teeth. Steve was more forthcoming after that, writing a list of names with his other hand over his mouth, and Max stalked around Billy’s room as he got ready, straightening his jacket. She packed him off with flowers.
The Mindflayer still got him.
Max cried on Eleven’s bed, punching her pillow, and Eleven sat with her arms crossed, thinking. “We could cut his dick off,” she suggested, and Max choked, laughing.
“He doesn’t care who it is,” she sighed. “Even if he goes on the dates, he’s a slut, he’ll always go with Karen Wheeler—”
“We could tell Nancy,” El suggested, steepling her fingers. “I could tell Mike.”
Max considered, then sighed. “I don’t think getting his dick shot off would help, either.”
The only other teenage guy Max knew was Steve, so they went back. “How do I keep my brother from wanting to fuck Nancy’s mom,” she asked bluntly, and Steve stumbled, vanishing behind the ice cream cabinet with a loud smack noise and then scrambling back up to glare at them through the glass.
“He what now,” asked Robin, and Max explained, again, that she was from the future. Billy never believed her—it ruined their friendship, usually, because he was so suspicious when she was nice to him anyway—but Steve nearly always did, nodding like it somehow made sense.
“So he’ll die if he tries to fuck Nancy’s mom,” he said, crossing his arms, and narrowing his eyes.
“I mean, so worth it, though,” said Robin, pushing herself up to sit on the counter with a sigh. “If you need somebody else to go seduce Nancy’s mom—”
“I could tell him I heard she has herpes,” Steve offered, and Max was desperate enough to give it a go. She brought Billy down to the mall—they always ended up sitting somewhere they could look into the ice cream place anyway, so Steve could see they were there. He was totally natural—as natural as anyone could be, walking out and handing their nemesis free ice cream they hadn’t ordered, and saying something like “So I heard Mrs. Wheeler’s been spreading the ol’ herpes.”
Billy stared at him, holding the ice cream, and then at Max.
“...if you don’t want that, I do,” she said, trying not to laugh, or cry, because if Steve’s plan didn’t work, she didn’t know what to try next.
“...what’s going on,” he asked, flatly.
“I don’t know what you mean,” she said, reaching for the ice cream cone, and he grabbed it and bit half of it off, chewing it at her defiantly, his mouth open.
“Why is Steve Harrington talking to me,” Billy asked, once Steve walked off. It seemed like the less important question, given what he’d said, but Billy looked serious. “Did you—did you bribe him? The fuck is going on, Max?! Why would he—ever—” he paused for emphasis, and she realized his ears were turning red, “—ever ever talk to me, Max Mayfield. Tell me what the fuck is going on, or I will force this ice cream—”
“I just told him you were lurking around Karen Wheeler,” Max blurted, out of self-preservation, and he glowered at her, but relinquished the remaining ice cream. It was strawberry. “He said you should know something.”
“He wanted me to know that?” Billy hissed, glancing in at Steve, who was frowning back. “D’you think it’s true, or—”
“He’s worried,” Max told him, which was technically true—both in the sense that Steve wanted to help Max, and wanted to keep Billy’s manwhoring paws off his ex’s mother.
“Why the fuck would he be worried,” Billy hissed, leaning closer, and glancing into the ice cream shop again. Robin had joined Steve in leaning on the counter, their heads together as they watched Max and Billy. Billy’s cheeks started turning pink too. “Does he ask about me?!” he whispered, lowering his voice, and kind of slurring, like he was afraid if he moved his lips, Steve would see.
“Why do you care?!” Max hissed back, feeling like the message had been lost, after the considerable trouble of getting it delivered. “You gonna stop hitting on her?!”
“Who?” Billy asked, pulling his stare back off of Steve Harrington, and frowning at Max. “Oh. Why does he care who I fuck?”
“...it’s a public service announcement,” Max told him, woodenly. “With complimentary ice cream.”
“D’you think if I keep hitting on her, he’ll come beat me up?” Billy asked, his smirk widening into a grin, and Max groaned into her hands.
“I think he’ll—” she began, and then registered the way Billy was watching Steve Harrington. It was the way he'd watched the half-naked cavemen in awful sci-fi time travel movies, the time they’d been friends—only after Neil had gone to bed, only if Billy was half asleep—but she remembered it.
She banged on El’s door again, even though Billy was still alive, even though he’d been so quiet on the drive back from the mall.
“I need to go back earlier,” Max told her. “I have to keep him from beating Steve up. I, uh...I think it’ll help.”
“Because he’ll know about the Mindflayer,” El nodded, smacking her fist in the flat of her other hand like Max was a genius, and Max bit her lips together, and nodded.
“...that, yeah,” she said, hoping it worked, hoping Steve didn’t hit Billy with the nailbat, and Billy didn’t get eaten by demodogs. She stepped out of the Upside-Down the afternoon she’d snuck out with Lucas, and instead of running, she circled back to Billy’s window. She watched Neil yell at him, gritting her teeth, and then when Billy flattened himself against the wall, she hissed, “Lucas!” and he helped her up, frowning in bewilderment. She clambered in Billy’s window, panting and gasping, “No! No, sorry, Billy, you don’t have to cover for me—I’m sorry—”
Billy and Neil both stared at her, but Neil left him alone, and came over, so angry his jaw and hands were shaking.
“There you are!” Susan said, with false brightness. “He was just trying to be a good brother!”
“He’s teaching her to be a liar,” Neil hissed, and Max shook her head, but Billy made the mistake of opening his mouth again, and Neil spun on him. “You aren’t going anywhere,” he said softly. “We need to have a talk.”
Billy bared his teeth, and Susan tried to beckon Max away, but she wasn’t watching her brother die again. “You weren’t here to ask,” she told Neil, trying to make her eyes big and soft, like Will’s, “—so he said I could go if I was back soon! I hurried. Dustin’s mom lost her cat—”
She ignored the weirded-out glare Billy shot her, watching Neil’s face—and finally it worked, and her mom touched his shoulder.
“They’re getting along,” Susan whispered, sounding thrilled. “W-want to go—watch your show? I’ll make popcorn.”
The door thudded closed after them, and Billy turned to scowl at Max. “The fuck was that,” he hissed.
“I need your help,” she told him, and he snorted a laugh, elbowing by her to pout at himself in the mirror. “You already made me late,” he told her, and she gritted her teeth, and played the last card she could think of.
“Steve Harrington needs your help,” she hissed. “Please. Billy. Come on.” He stilled the way he had at the mall, glaring suspiciously at her, and she grabbed his jacket, and hauled him towards the window.
“The fuck would Harrington want,” he asked, barely audibly, with a glance at the door. “If this is a fucking joke I will cave your skull in and dry it out to eat cereal—”
“It’s not, I swear,” she whispered back. “Please.”
He drove she and Lucas to the Byers, and Steve came out with his bat, looking wary. “I brought Billy to help,” Max yelled, half-falling out of the car door in her anxiety, but Lucas helped her up, still with the disbelieving glower. She squeezed his hand. “He’s here to help!” she yelled at Steve, who raised his eyebrows.
Billy rolled his shoulders, glancing from Max to Steve with the beginning of a snarl, but Steve held his hand out.
“Thanks,” he said, earnestly, and Billy stared at his face. “I’ve got a ton of little shitheads in there, and the sheriff left me alone here—”
“You’re not alone,” Dustin yelled from the window.
“Completely by myself with these rug rats,” Steve told Billy, and Billy snorted a laugh. Once inside, Steve handed Billy another baseball bat—nail-less—and he stared, so Steve and Dustin showed him the demodog in the fridge.
The next week, Steve drove by, Billy sauntered out and got in his car, and Max began to relax for the first time in...she shook her head and wondered, leaning her head in her arms, whether she got younger as she travelled back through the Upside-Down, or if she kept trying, maybe she’d end up fifty years old, just from reliving the summer of 1985 over and over for decades.
For a while, things seemed to get better—Billy was hanging around Steve, and then right when he got the pool job, right when it mattered, they had a fight, or something, and Billy fucking tried to meet Karen Wheeler, and got flayed.
Before she went over to Eleven’s, Max screamed, “This is all your fault, I hate you,” into the living room at Neil and her mom, and then ran out of the house. They followed—not fast enough, yelling after her—but she didn’t stop.
The next time, she got Billy a few hours sooner—she wanted to make sure he made friends with Steve, and after they fought the demodogs off in the junkyard, Billy couldn’t stop asking questions, and Steve threw an arm around his shoulders. Max watched them. She was exhausted—not so much from lack of sleep, but from lack of hope, because every change she made, she thought, this time. Surely.
This time, it was kind of weird. Billy was weird—he’d pull Steve down alleys, not to fight, Max discovered, the first time she sprinted after them, just...talk, softly, apparently? Steve started showing up and climbing in Billy's window at night—Max stared at the connecting wall, horrified by his choices, because she’d seen Billy toss a cigarette, miss his ashtray, and pour old flat beer on his desk to put out the smoldering, crumpled homework and dirty socks. She’d seen it that very afternoon.
Billy brought her along for ice cream, sometimes, and she tried not to watch as he leaned across the case to lick the sample spoon into his mouth while it was still in Steve’s hand.
Then Steve started getting along with Robin, and Max saw the problem. What was worse, she saw the solution, and she had to set her jaw and play matchmaker. Not having to watch her brother be skewered saving Eleven would be worth it, she told herself, as she listened to him describe the perfect globes of Steve’s ass. She remembered sitting in Billy’s empty room after the EMTs zipped him into the body bag, and it warmed her enough to suffer through his angst over Steve’s tan. She’d made friends with him again, and he knocked on her door late at night after dates with Steve, a phrase she never thought she’d imagine, to tell her where they’d gone—with a pause for Billy to grin vaguely—and describe things Steve had said.
Max listened, watching her brother happy, and alive, and the next time Karen Wheeler showed up at the pool, Billy had his lips fastened under Steve’s jaw around the side of the building.
The Mindflayer finally got a city inspector that went out to the Steelworks, in September, but Max remained vigilant even after Christmas, when she and Eleven could go and rent a movie, instead of travelling back in time, and Billy was always there, leaning across the counter to tease Steve Harrington, and renting porn.
