Work Text:
Easter: April 5th, 1996 (continued)
“Oh my god,” Mike says, exasperated to catch them making out on the back porch. “Are you serious, guys, c’mon.”
Steve’s mouth is distractingly wet and shiny as he pulls away from him – tempting him to go back to discover its delights again. Billy finds himself staring dumbly at those spit slicked lips as Steve talks. “What, you and Will don’t spend any time just necking anymore?”
Mike scoffs. “Not in front of everybody! What is it with everyone down here? Has Hawkins been filled with sex pollen?” he complains. “First Lucas finds El and Dustin making out in Nancy’s room, and now the two of you- Nobody even realized they were going out-”
Billy and Steve smirk at each other, and Mike says, “Oh my god!” again, this time in exasperation at their knowing looks, before stomping back into his house.
They stare at each other for a moment before they both burst out laughing at Mike’s typical sour disposition. It almost wasn’t any fun, he was so predictable. Almost.
Lazily, Steve plays with the short hair at the back of his neck, idly musing, “I sort of miss the mullet, you know?”
Billy laughs quietly as Steve pulls him in for more kissing. “Don’t tell Max that – I don’t think I’ve ever seen her happier than when I finally cut it all off for her wedding. Mmm…” He breaks off, though he really does enjoy the soft biting going on. “Should we…uh, go back inside?”
Confused, Steve says “No? Why? Are you getting cold?”
That was a fair question – early April in Indiana was very different from early April in California and adjusting back to a region with four distinct seasons was slightly more enjoyable the second time…but mostly because of Lulu. Making snow angels with five-year-old girls was awesome, and he was reasonably sure it was part of the actual recipe for world peace.
“No, not really,” Billy says, hoping he doesn’t look as bashful as he feels. “You don’t mind Wheeler tellin’ everybody we’re out here sucking face?”
Steve sputters out a cackling laugh. “Uh, no. Even though Will and Mike tried super hard to be discreet, any time El wasn’t around, they were pretty much attached to each other by the lips. The old people kissing on the porch won’t bother them at all – anyway, they’ll probably still be in shock over Dust and El.”
“Speaking of happy couples…” Steve nearly thinks he’s gone back to flirting when he continues, “Is Sinclair actually gonna make a move sometime, or has he decided that the third time's the charm, and he’ll just wait till after the second divorce now?”
Steve, despite the years of knowing exactly how Lucas felt about Max, has enough loyalty to his younger friend to loftily say “Who said he wants to make a move?”
“Uh, well a) – because when you thought Ellie had a crush on Sinclair, you practically shit your pants and I don’t think you’d be that upset unless you thought she was gonna get her heart broken. But also b) – you ain’t known this, but I was there the day Max had the party and told everybody she got knocked up and Lulu was on the way. And Sinclair looked like he was gonna murder someone.”
He’s never seen Steve look so flabbergasted. “Wha-I’ve never heard that!”
Billy doesn’t find that surprising - he had been a little more enlightened, in the past six weeks since he returned, to the increasing distance between Max and her childhood friend group, as soon as her relationship with Lucas ended and the one with Justin van Haut began.
“Who would tell you?” Billy says a bit sourly. “It was all the way in Indianapolis, at this fancy hotel owned by someone the Van Hauts knew. Ellie and Sinclair were the only Hawkins people who showed up. And I’m pretty sure Max had too many things on her mind to notice her best friend was tryin’ to stop her ex-boyfriend from murdering her fiancé.”
Feeling awkward around her old friends, Max had avoided them in favor of hanging around Justin’s group rather than letting The Party go through that spot of growing pains of figuring out how they would carry on when she and Lucas broke up. In the meantime, Justin had demanded more and more time and loyalty spent with his own friends and family even as he isolated Max from her own. Her already strained relationship with the Party, and her frayed bond to her mother (and her outright dislike of her stepfather) had only made that easier to accomplish.
The main reason Billy hadn’t noticed this, apart from being several thousand miles away, was because Billy himself was the one exception to all these attempts. She visited him with Lulu two or three times a year no matter how much Justin thought a toddler shouldn’t be on an airplane and made time for phone calls with him at least once a week and all Justin’s whining fell on deaf ears - but only when it came to Max's brother.
"Don't leave me hanging on that!" Steve protests, ripping Billy away from his rather depressive musings. "Aren't you going to tell me what happened?!"
"Well.." Billy scratches at the edge of his facial hair with one thumb. Finally, he says, "I'd guess Sinclair realized that Justin finally got her and that his last chance was gone."
"They were engaged," Steve points out. "I'm pretty sure Lucas was aware that he'd missed his shot."
Billy sighs. "Ain't the same, heartbreaker. Being two teenagers getting married fresh outta high school ain't the same as having a baby. Poor kid musta thought there was a tiny sliver of a chance before that day, but all that was over when she got pregnant. Ellie gotta nosebleed, trying to keep him from actually killing Justin, I think. So she started bleedin', of course, Sinclair had to help her clean it up, and they left. The end."
“Well…” Steve chewed his lip and Billy tried and failed not to find it endearing. “Yeah, he might be interested, I guess…”
“He better make up his goddamn mind, then,” he scowled.
Steve smiled at him, charmed by his overprotectiveness. “It’s so cute how much you love them.”
Grumbling, a bit fumble-footed at being called out, Billy mutters “She’s my sister, what am I supposed to do?” Faux-sternly, Billy adds “And your boy better treat Ellie right, or so help me, I’ll beat the shit out of him.”
He’s joking. Mostly. Mostly, alright?
***
It doesn’t matter how valiantly she tries to hide it, Dustin can see how tired she is. El’s usual speech is broken up with expressive looks and fluid body language, sketching out her words in the air with small gestures and arm movements. Talking with her hands, which she’d picked up sometime when they started high school and her language skills weren’t quite as good as the average teenager yet. It was charming as hell, in his admittedly very biased opinion and Dustin knows when El's hands begin getting sluggish and then stop moving that she’s exhausted.
He waits until Erica and Lucas start getting into an argument - a reliable measurement of time, since it generally happens once an hour - and whispers "Do you want me to take you home? I know you must be really tired."
Although they’ve been somewhat avoiding each other these past six years, Dustin has some idea of a professional baker's hours. Will and Joyce went to stay with her during his Christmas break when the 11th first opened - of course, the Byers no longer had an actual house anywhere Hawkins anymore, but the 11th had an apartment above it with two bedrooms and even a little den. He imagined that El wanted to be sure that her mom and both brothers would have the room to stay there if they visited. According to Will, El usually got out of bed around 3 am to get dressed and immediately went downstairs to check on whatever was left overnight in the proofing ovens before going back upstairs to make coffee and breakfast.
Though Steve would’ve been responsible for most of the main course today, he knows that Eleven and Billy were his main assistants and all three of them have worked exhaustively since the early morning to fix a meal fit for a dozen people.
To his surprise, El shakes her head. Turning her face toward his - he’s still not used to that, it still makes his heart race - she murmurs “Will’s birthday cake.”
Birthday? Oh…well, technically it’s two week late, but it’s probably been awhile since the entire Party was together any time around his birthday. He probably should’ve guessed she would do something grand. She has a thing about birthdays anyway - maybe because she’d never had any before she became a Hopper. Erica has boasted about the incredible creation of caramel, chocolate ganache, and walnuts that she gets each year. Because the rest of them live far away and generally aren’t in Hawkins during their birthdays, she tends to send packages with homemade cookies - a practice that Dustin used to both love and hate.
He hated the idea that El felt obligated to bake for him despite being too terrified to speak to him but he couldn’t bring himself to ask her not to because they were the best fucking cookies he’d ever eaten and store bought weren’t even on the same goddamn planet as hers. His first year away, his roommate found Dustin ugly crying with a dozen chocolate chips and snickerdoodles in his lap at 2 am on a Thursday and that taught him an important lesson about smoking weed before engaging in shit that he knew was gonna make him feel sad.
Dustin goes back to the kitchen to help her and watches El making herself a giant coffee loaded with sugar and cream, only to be shooed away with a wave of her hand when El sees him.
“Surprise,” she says gently, brows quirking upward ever-so-slightly.
He obediently backs out and waits for her to return, now a bit puzzled. That implies that the surprise wasn’t just for Will.
In the kitchen, Eleven gulps down her sugary coffee - she will need all of the short-term energy that she can get while she’s already tired and she can’t imagine anything worse than losing control and dropping it.
Nobody but Dustin notices at first when the kitchen door opens by itself. Slowly in her bare-shouldered dress, hands held out steady in front of her, Eleven hovers out the towering creation that Billy had hidden inside the garage fridge. A beautiful creation of blue-violet frosting waves lightly dusted with silver and gold edible glitter. It’s Dustin’s gasp that makes everyone else pay attention. “El!”
“WOW!” Erica exclaims.
“Pretty,” Lauren says from Max’s lap, wide-eyed.
Billy immediately bolts from the sofa, hovering near her. “I could’ve helped you, boss lady.”
Eleven shakes her head firmly without letting her hands shake, eyes fixed upon the cake as she completes her task. Her fantastical creation finally makes it to the table and she presents it with a magician-like wave, smiling at her brother. Thinking quickly, Dustin passes her a tissue for her nose just as she begins to bleed from the left nostril. “Happy birthday!”
“El,” Will breathes, gazing at it in stupefied wonder. “It’s incredible! You made the Party!”
Set atop the cake and created in incredibly realistic detail were six little figures: paladin Mike with a shining silver sword, ranger Lucas with a knocked arrow ready on his bow, cleric Will in a long white robe, rogue Max with her bright hair spilling out of a dark cloak, bard Dustin complete with a lute and a feather in his hat, and sorcerer Eleven, who holds out a tiny spark of flame on the tip of her finger.
Impressed, Jonathan adds “I didn’t know your decorating skills had gotten this good!”
“Billy,” El says simply, with another little wave at her only employee.
Billy tries to hide his blush as the eyes of the room suddenly all turn to him. “Uh…I always liked shop class,” he mutters, with a little shrug. Steve looks so completely smitten that Dustin would be embarrassed for him if he weren’t secretly thrilled. “Made ‘em out of wood and not food so you can keep ‘em, if you want.”
“Are you kidding? I’m not throwing these out!” Will squawks. “They’re amazing!”
Dustin fully agrees. “Yeah, dude - if he wasn’t gonna keep them, I would!”
“Just sit down, honey,” Joyce says gently, standing from her chair as Eleven wipes the blood from her face. “You can have my seat.”
Eleven drops into the abandoned seat obediently, yawning into her hand. “It’s n-ne-nea-ugh,” she grumbles, face scrunching up adorably in irritation. “It’s ice cream flavor.”
“She means neapolitan,” Billy explains, rubbing her shoulder. He seems to realize that El no longer has the energy to speak in sentences anymore. Unlike the rest of them, stringing language together takes actual work for her. “It’s the ‘super vanilla’ cake she fucking refuses to show me the recipe for, with alternating layers of strawberry and milk chocolate mousse.”
“Oh! That’s my favorite ice cream flavor,” Will gushes to his sister, leaning in to squeeze her and El smiles at him. “You remembered.”
"Of course."
***
“Where the hell does he think he’s taking her...” Billy asks, brows raised high as he blows the smoke out from his cigarette.
Steve turns to follow the direction of his gaze, mouth dropping open as he sees Dustin practically carrying El down the porch stairs leading into the driveway. It’s not entirely clear if she’s drunk or just tired.
“Hey, need to borrow your keys!” Dustin calls, letting her head rest on his shoulder for a moment while he continues bellowing at Steve. “Keys, Steve, c’mon man!”
“Uh…” Steve says, sounding both amused and uncomfortable. “Dustin, I admire your... enthusiasm , and I appreciate that you’re all adults now, but buddy…”
Looking more alert now, Eleven flushes heavily, having understood what Steve is implying.
Dustin sputters with outrage. “I’m taking her home , you dickhead! Some people have jobs , Steven! She’s been up since three in the morning - god, you’re all such assholes!”
“Good,” Billy says sweetly, with a too-sharp smile. “Because if you were doing something else with her, I’d be having a very long, very uncomfortable talk with you, you little shit, wouldn’t I?”
Dustin pauses for a moment to consider that statement, swallowing heavily, eyes suddenly rounded with fear. “Ah…”
“Billy,” El scolds lowly, embarrassed with this behavior - because she knows exactly what kind of talk Billy would want to have.
He’s the only one who knows for certain that El is still a virgin. Until recently, she and Max didn’t speak that much and while she did keep in close contact with all of the others - especially Will - that wasn’t the kind of subject any of them would have wanted to talk about around her. With her. About her. Whatever.
“Somebody has to,” Billy says loftily, but with a hard-edged obstinance in his expression more reminiscent of Old Billy than anything Steve had seen so far.
Ellie’s daddy was gone now, and her mama and both brothers lived on the east coast - Joyce with Jonathan and Nancy in New York, and Will in Massachusetts with Mike. Max had been something like a sister before, and they were slowly getting back to that, but she had her own problems to deal with, too. As far Billy could see, there was nobody left to show her the ways that grown men behaved with grown women, or to stand up for her if she got to the point where she didn’t realize she needed to stand up for herself.
Not that he thought Dustin Henderson could ever escalate to that level of asshole - that kid really was Steve’s spiritual brother, fearlessly earnest almost to a fault.
But Billy had made that mistake with Maxine already, the mistake of his own absence - he wouldn’t make it twice.
