Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

blow out your candles, make your wish come true

Summary:

He’d thought dying would have easily constituted his 18th year being his worst.

Somehow, re-emerging from hell just in time for his 19th proved him wrong.

Notes:

once again i have not watched season 4 so we are very much *vague hand gesturing* the narrative. but so are the duffers so im fine :)

title from 16 candles by the crests

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Billy Hargrove had never been a fan of birthdays.

Well. Maybe that’s a lie.

He had been a fan of them once upon a time. Back when his mom was still around to do something special every year; a picnic with cake on the beach, a day of mini golf, a trip to the arcade, one very special occasion where she’d managed to get Neil to agree to a trip to Disneyland. They’d made a whole weekend of it. It’s one of the few nice memories Billy has of his dad…

Birthdays stopped being fun after his mom left. Neil didn’t care enough to celebrate beyond a minor acknowledgement, and the day only served to remind Billy of what he no longer had - anyone in his life to give a shit about him.

Birthdays became depressing reminders and he quickly learned they were best to be ignored.

 

Eighteen was supposed to be his year. He’d be graduating high school, be legal. No longer dependent on the piece of shit he called a father. Get out of bumfuck Indiana with his boyfriend by his side.

It was supposed to be his year.

He had been saving up to leave. Still hadn’t had quite enough by the time he walked out of Hawkins High for the final time, and it’s not like Steve had been much better off, having sufficiently been cut off from his own father’s wallet. But that was fine. Billy’d been biding his time for damn near a decade. He could survive one more summer.

Or so he thought.

The universe had different plans, apparently. Which, really, he should have accounted for. Because nothing in Billy’s life is ever easy or goes to plan. But he damn sure could never have predicted the literal hell Hawkins had in store for him.

Three months into 18 and the reaper came to collect, but not before fucking with him first.

He’d always thought possessions were Hollywood fairytales. Practical effects of little girls levitating, heads spinning round and round. And, fine, his head hadn’t done a 360 or anything, but he does vaguely remember hovering off the ground at some point, which was fucked.

There’s a lot of shit about that week that still keeps him up at night, has made him more jumpy than he was even when he had to walk on eggshells around his dad.

He’d thought dying would have easily constituted his 18th year being his worst.

Somehow, re-emerging from hell just in time for his 19th proved him wrong.

There’s supposed to be something flowery and poetic about rebirths. Celebratory, even. And he had felt it. Taking those first few lungfuls of actual fresh air. Untainted. Unpolluted. Breathing new life into blackened lungs.

He was back on familiar ground. Home (and like hell did Billy ever think he’d refer to Hawkins as his home). Had Steve latched to his side, unwilling to let him go - let each other go - now that they had been reunited. All they had to do was get back to Max…

They’d been too late.

Max was alive, but only barely. Had apparently actually died, until her friend, El, had got her heart pumping again somehow (Billy later found out this was a new development for her. Wondered why the hell she couldn’t have discovered this power eight months ago, but whatever. Bygones were bygones or some shit).

His sister looked… fucked up. Was the only way Billy could put it. Limbs bent in directions they were never meant to, eyes bloodied, neck limp…

He’s not surprised she’s not waking up. He just really fucking wishes she would.

They had finally gotten their relationship to a good place before he kicked it. Had been making up for lost time, making plans for the future when Billy inevitably got out on his own, wanted to share that freedom with her, in whatever way he could.

They were happy. Future so bright ahead of them. And every day that Billy had been stuck in that place he had sworn the first thing he would do when, if, he got out was take Max to Cali. Let her see the surf again. Ride her board along ocean avenues. Feel the briney wind in her hair. Eat some good fucking grub, ‘cause God knew Hawkins wasn’t providing.

And now the doctors don’t even know if she’ll wake up, and it’s bullshit. The worst goddamn birthday Billy’s ever had, which is really saying something. He’d take an ass beating from Neil if it meant Max was out of that fucking bed.

So maybe it’s for the best that no one’s actually acknowledged it. Not that he really expected anyone to. The only people who would are in a coma, or worrying about their daughter who’s in a coma. There’s also Steve, but he’s got a lot on his plate, too. Been busy feeding the homeless at the school or whatever the hell’s been going on down there. Billy doesn’t know. Ever since he got back he’s either been at the hospital or sitting in the trailer in a fog waiting to return.

He and Susan trade off shifts since she’s still gotta work. And they want one of them there always in case Max wakes up. Don’t want her being alone.

So that’s how Billy rung in 19.

All things considered, he can forgive his boyfriend forgetting his birthday. There’s bigger shit going on.

But maybe that’s why there’s a small voice in the back of his head wishing he’d at least gotten a phone call.

He shakes off the thought as he walks to the trailer’s tiny kitchen, fresh out of the shower. There’ll be another year. Another birthday. Probably. Maybe. The way things are going in this hell town it’s really hard to tell.

He’s grabbing a beer and a Star Crunch cookie out of the cupboard, getting ready to take his ass to bed and end another nightmare day, when there’s a knock at the door.

He sighs, tosses his shit onto the counter. Makes his way to the front door expecting some shithead kid living up on a dare to get a glimpse of Hawkins’ new zombie boy up close and personal. He honestly hopes this whole town gets swallowed up in some hellmouth, even if it takes him with it.

“Go to hell, you pieces of shit,” Billy starts, unlocking the door and swinging it open. “Didn’t your parents ever teach you any fucking manner-”

“Well hello to you, too, sunshine,” greets Steve from the other side. All striped polo and dopey smile. Instantly making Billy’s day better, even with only a few hours to spare.

“Sorry,” Billy grumbles, stepping away to let his boyfriend in.

“Those kids still bothering you?” Steve asks as he steps inside, shutting the door behind him. Goes to give Billy a quick peck on the lips.

“They’ll get bored eventually. Find some new freak to pick on.”

“Well the good news is this is Hawkins, so you shouldn’t be waiting too long.”

“Thank God this town’s got one thing going for it.”

“Hey! It’s got two things. Huh?” Steve throws his arms out beside him, presenting himself. His eyebrows jumping suggestively like a dork.

Billy’s not gonna deign that with a response beyond an eye roll. But maybe he smirks a little, too. Focuses more on the white box Steve has in his hand that Billy hadn’t noticed until he’d come into the trailer.

“What’s that?” He juts his chin forward. Can’t really make out anything distinct. Just looks like a plain white box.

Steve’s face goes from jovial and just a little bit cocky to something that resembles embarrassed. Brings the box between his hands, tapping on it rhythmically in quick succession. “Oh, um. Well. Okay, so, I had dropped Dustin and Robin off, right? You know we were running around all day collecting shit for the school and helping out and whatnot.”

“You wanna jump to the point, Stevie?” He’s not saying it to be mean. Just knows his boyfriend has a tendency to ramble when he’s nervous. And Billy had learned to just let him, because usually it doesn’t matter, but he’s kinda had a long day and would like to end up in bed sooner rather than later, so.

“Right.” Steve nods. “So. Long story short, I’m a shitty boyfriend.”

Billy sighs, rubbing his hands over his face. “Were you talking to Wheeler again? Babe, I thought we’ve been over this-”

“No. Shut up. Listen.” That has Billy pausing. Snapping his mouth shut and staring at Steve as he awaits an explanation. “I am a shitty boyfriend, alright? Forgot my own damn boyfriend’s birthday. And it’s not because I didn’t remember! I just, lost track of what day it is. Didn’t even know till I passed by a calendar at home, and I know that’s not a good enough excuse, but I ran out to get you a cake the second I realized, except the bakery was closing and I had to plead with the guy to let me in and they didn’t have a lot left but-”

“Steve!” Billy eventually has to cut in, putting a hand up to stop his rambling. He doesn’t know what to say. Doesn’t have words for the immensity of his feelings right now. Feels the heat behind his eyes, tears threatening to spill because. Steve remembered.

And Billy’s still not used to this. Used to people giving a shit about him. But he’s learning that maybe he should be. Old habits die hard or whatever.

“Is the, uh-” He sniffles, wipes at his nose, trying to make it look casual, “-Did you at least get a good flavor?”

Steve’s face slowly scrunches up, like he knows Billy’s not gonna like what he’s about to say. “All they had left was carrot…”

“Christ,” Billy mumbles. And it is by no means his favorite flavor, but maybe he’s also playing up his disdain just to keep himself from crying like a little bitch over Steve’s efforts. “I guess carrot’s fine. Since you went through the trouble and all.”

Steve rolls his eyes, face softening into that smile he does when Billy’s busting his balls now. “I feel so appreciated.” Billy answers with a scrunch of his nose.

“Alright, well, c’mon. Only one thing left to do.” Steve’s taking him by the hand and pulling him towards the kitchen. Nods his head towards the small dining table Susan has set up. “Hop on.”

“Excuse me?” Billy eyes the table that absolutely is not going to hold the weight of his ass on top of it, even if he has lost a lot of his muscle being stuck in a hell world for months on end with no real food.

“Get up on the table,” Steve reiterates. “Can’t do Sixteen Candles without the ending.”

Billy groans. Steve and his fucking John Hughes obsession. Making Billy sit through more Molly Ringwald performances than he ever cared to. “I’m not doing that gay shit.”

Steve, unbothered, seats himself on the opposite end of the table, steadying himself as it wobbles - the thing’s absolutely going to break if Billy gets on, if not sooner - and arranges the cake precisely in the middle, leaving the top open. “I don’t know if you’ve noticed, babe, but you are gay.”

“I’m not this gay.”

Steve fixes him with an unimpressed look. Gaze moving towards the vacant spot across from him, back to Billy.

Billy sighs. “Fine. But if this table breaks you’re buying Susan a new one.”

“Fine, but you’re coming shopping with me.”

Billy can never win.

He climbs on top of the table, holding his breath, as Steve pulls out candles and a lighter from his pocket. Gets the tiny sticks all situated in the cake to light them up. There’s only about five in there. It’s fine. Not like Billy has any reason to be picky right now.

He stares at the cake, glowing under the candlelight. All that thick, white cream cheese frosting that he honestly prefers over regular. Thinks about Steve running around in the dark trying to get him this cake because God forbid Billy end his birthday without one. Because he cares. So much.

“You’re not a shitty boyfriend,” Billy says. Croaks it out, really. Trying to talk past the lump forming in his throat.

“What?”

“You’re not a shitty boyfriend,” he repeats. Looks up at Steve because it’s really important to Billy that he understands this. He’s met with those Bambi eyes staring back at him, yellow-orange glow of the fire twinkling in his irises. “Shitty boyfriends don’t go ‘round breaking down bakers’ doors to make sure their boyfriend has a good birthday. That’s the exact opposite of shitty.”

Steve doesn’t say anything. But his cheeks go a little pink, his smile soft before shaking off whatever warm and fuzzies he’s feeling. “Make your wish, you big sap.”

The corner of Billy’s mouth ticks up for a split second before his eyes cast down on the cake.

What the fuck is he supposed to wish for? The same thing he’s been wishing for since he was ten? That his mother could come back? Or maybe he should wish to feel like a normal person again, if he even knows what that means anymore, it’s been so long, if ever. He wants to wish for Max. For her to wake up. To be okay. He can hear her bitching at him to stop taking so long. Just pick something! He’d give anything to have it be real.

Everything’s so fucked now. No amount of candles on this cake blown out will fix any of it. He could wish and wish and wish until a vein burst in his head, and it wouldn’t make a damn bit of difference.

He’s never felt so helpless. Not when he was curled up on his bedroom floor crying to his mom to come home. Not during any of the countless times he was trapped under Neil’s boot and angry fists. Not even when he was bleeding out on the floor of Starcourt Mall, choking out his last words.

And now he’s sitting here staring at a birthday cake. A birthday cake that his boyfriend ran out to buy him because he wanted him to have something because he cares about him. Because Billy is loved and he feels that love so much looking down at this cake that’s a flavor he doesn’t even like, but he doesn’t care because that’s not the point.

The point is that he’s celebrating his birthday right now. With a boy who loves him. And Max is lying unconscious in a hospital bed, no idea if she’s ever gonna get to see her next birthday. Celebrate it with her boyfriend with some cheesy movie reference she’d definitely take worse than Billy is. And it’s not fucking fair, and-

“Woah, woah! Hey! Bills! Hey!”

It’s not until Steve’s clamoring off the table to stand beside him, manhandling Billy till he’s facing him that Billy realizes his breaths are coming in sharper, that his face is wet.

The instinct to run kicks in, except his limbs feel too heavy. He settles on crumbling against Steve’s chest, face turned to the side so he can stare off into the living room, vacant, biting the inside of his cheek numb to stop his body from racking with sobs.

He’s distantly aware of fingers in his hair, soothing gestures. Steve’s voice calm and grounding repeating “Breathe. Just breathe with me, Bills.”

He tries. Squeezes his eyes shut, feels the steady rise and fall of Steve’s chest against his cheek. Tries to match it. Focus on the hands in his hair. Steve’s words. Stay in the present. Not worry about the future. Things he can’t control. Focus on the here and now. The warmth of Steve against his cheek, the rickety table underneath him, the cake that’s probably got colorful wax adorning the white frosting by now.

“It’s not fair,” is what Billy mumbles when he can finally will himself to speak

There’s a pressure on the crown of his head. Steve’s lips, he’s sure. Holding him in place. Tethering him.

A whisper. “I know it’s not.” A pause. Then, “Was the cake a bad idea?”

“Yes. No. Fuck. I dunno.” Billy pulls back. Rubs both hands over his face to get rid of the tears. To hide. Can’t face the disappointed look Steve’s giving him when his hands fall away. “It’s not- I love it. And I love you for doing it, it’s just. Maybe that’s the problem.”

“I don’t understand.”

Billy fixates on the little wrinkle between Steve’s brow. Wants to smooth it out like he used to do whenever Steve got confused. Can’t find the strength in his arms right now, though.

“Just feels wrong to enjoy anything right now. Not with Max…”

“I know.” Steve reaches out for his hand, holding it gently. Letting it sway between them, his thumb rubbing circles on the back. Billy tries to focus on that feeling. “But I don’t think she’d want you wallowing in misery, either.”

Billy can’t help the soft snort he lets out. “Yes she would.”

It gets a smile out of Steve, too. “Okay, fine. But she wouldn’t want you making me wallow in misery, so.”

Billy stares at their hands. Maneuvers them till they’re palm to palm. Laces their fingers together. Holds Steve’s hand tight.

There’s a swelling in his chest as he looks up at his boyfriend. Could cry all over again from the immensity of his feelings for him in this moment.

Billy’s emotions have always been extreme. Either feels all of it or none of it. And right now he’s so goddamn overwhelmed he doesn’t even think there’s words for the aching behind his ribs.

He wishes for balance. Thinks he’s more than owed some peace in his life after years in the fire. It’s about time the scales started tipping in his favor.

“Is everything gonna be okay?” It’s not a real question. Billy’s not expecting an answer. But he wonders. Has to know there’s something to look forward to because he can’t keep living like this. Taking blow after blow after blow.

“I don’t know,” Steve says honestly. Tucks a stray curl behind Billy’s ear with his free hand. Lets his fingers come down to linger on Billy’s jaw. “But I do know I’ll be here with you no matter what. Me and this delicious uneaten cake.”

Billy laughs. It’s small and quick, but it’s genuine. He brings their hands up to his lips, kisses Steves. “You wanna stay here tonight? I’ll let you feed me some of that nasty carrot cake.”

“Don’t hate on the carrot cake!” Steve laughs. “It’s a perfectly valid flavor!”

“Mmm… might need some convincing on that.”

“Baby.” Steve moves in closer, cradling Billy’s chin in the crux of his thumb and forefinger. “By the time I’m through with you, it’s gonna be your favorite flavor.” Seals that promise with a kiss that Billy can’t help but smile into.

 

Nineteen isn’t the best birthday, but it somehow managed to not to be the worst, either.

He doesn’t know how hopeful he should be for the future. Has seldom ever been given reason to look forward to such things. But maybe he can try.

The impossible suddenly feels possible when he’s wrapped up in a boy like Steve Harrington. Fuckin’ Disney prince come to life.

He can let himself be a little more optimistic about things. Cautiously… but. Willing.

He thinks he’ll talk about this new development with Max when he visits her tomorrow, slice of carrot cake in tow.

Notes:

billys gonna save max via carrot cake. which is wild cuz carrot cake is the worst lmfao

comments and kudos much appreciated! find me on the tumblr @ariesbilly

(also who peeped the gallavich reference ;) )