Chapter Text
“All I am saying is that you can not deny that I have all the sexual prowess of a Greek God!”
Billy threw a fry from across the table, smirking as Eddie yelped when it made contact. They were at Benny’s, grabbing dinner with the others to go over the approved set-list Nancy had created. It wasn’t as terrible as they had originally thought it would be, though the number of slow songs they were being asked to play was making the entire band uneasy.
They weren’t a ballad-playing band, they had been very upfront with that. Eddie, being the lead guitarist, had put his foot down when it was time to pick a song for the battle of the bands, but this was a whole new ball game.
It was a tough pill to swallow, having to give in to the man, but Eddie was willing to compromise if it meant being able to pick which songs they’d get to perform.
Somehow the topic of love songs transitioned to Eddie openly admitting his latest sexcapade with his girlfriend, much to the chagrin of everyone else at the table.
“Going down on your girlfriend doesn’t make you a sex God,” Steve pointed out.
“If it did, then Robin over here would be crowned Athena,” Billy added.
The blond opened her mouth to dispute such a claim but quickly closed it, accepting the praise.
“This is a band discussion, kindly keep your thoughts to yourself,” Eddie requested, yelping as another fry flew across the table.
“You’re the one who brought it up. And besides, I’m the one who suggested you do it in the first place!” Steve pointed out.
Robin leaned over the table, looking past Billy to get to Steve. “Why are you giving him advice anyway? If anyone should be helping this poor idiot with his girl troubles, it should be me!”
“You really wanna give sex advice to the guy dating your girlfriend's cousin?”
“They don’t call it ‘all in the family for nothing.”
Billy lifted his hands, pushing both Robin and Steve back into their seats. “Enough! Can we please just focus on the music?”
“Nancy said we can add more songs if we need to,” Jonathan spoke up from the corner. “She’s trying to be as lenient as possible. It’s gonna be her prom too, you know. She wants us all to have a good time.”
“Oh yeah. I’m gonna have an absolute blast singing Air Supply all night,” Eddie grumbled, slumping back in his seat.
“Cry us a river,” Billy replied.
“Look, it’s not like we’re gonna be able to dance with our dates anyway,” Robin pointed out. “I’ll sing all the sappy love songs and you can play your rock and roll. Does that sound like a fair trade?”
“And who will play guitar for those songs, hmm?”
“Nancy has a backtrack for a lot of songs,” Jonathan pointed out. “Think of it like karaoke without the lyrics on a screen.”
“And besides, Steve offered to lend us a hand if need be,” Robin added before taking a bite of her grilled cheese.
Eddie straightened in his seat, leaning across the table to get a better look at Steve’s face. “You know how to rock?”
“I can play the keyboard. And a bit of guitar.”
Eddie clapped then, looking around the table for the others to join him. “Elton John everyone! Giving Billy Joel a run for his money.”
“You're funny. I’ll remember that when Carver dances with Chrissy after they win Prom Court,” Steve fires back, shutting Eddie up for the time being.
Harrington’s beeper went off then, causing a frown to form on his typically smiling face. Tossing down his napkin, he stood. “Gotta jet. Mother dearest needs me home,” He admitted, going into his wallet to pull out enough cash to pay for his and Billy’s meals.
“I’ll walk you to your car,” Billy said, glancing over to Jonathan. “Make sure the box munchers don’t touch my plate,” He ordered, standing from the table and following Steve out.
Harrington parked around back, being the last person to come. He hadn’t originally planned on dropping by, but with his parent's home, everything was a bit more hectic. Billy understood as his own home life was equally chaotic depending on what mood his dad would be in.
They had their fun Saturday night into Sunday and saw each other all week during school. That was enough for Billy.
“Am I picking you up tomorrow or what?” Billy asked as he walked with Steve to his BMW. “We got practice afterward, but you’re welcome to hang out.”
“Am I your official groupie now?” Steve teased twisting around to walk backward so his eyes would stay on Billy’s.
“If that’s what you wanna call yourself,”
Steve stopped walking then, resulting in Billy crashing into him. Before he could comment, Harrington’s hand gripped the front of his shirt, tugging him along until he could twist them around and push Billy up against the BMW.
“Jesus Harrington,” Billy breathed, his throat going dry as Harrington closed the gap between them.
Steve’s eyes stayed on his; warm brown crashing with cool blue in the darkness of Benny’s back parking lot. “Go to prom with me,” he said.
“Is that a request or an order?” Billy asked.
And Steve laughed, playful and sweet, the sound dripping like honey. “I’ll show you a good time,” he promised.
“Like you did Saturday night?”
“And Sunday morning,”
Billy didn’t have to be asked. It wasn’t like they’d be going to prom together for real. There wouldn’t be any dancing, no solo pictures taken by that ridiculous backdrop the committee was painting. The only thing Billy had to look forward to was the money they’d be paid for performing and the party afterward that may or may not even be happening now that Harrington’s folks were back in town.
Sure, there would be other parties; plenty to go around but none with the safety net; none that came with the promise that he’d be able to touch Steve whenever he wanted. He’d be back to playing it safe, in keeping a distance. And with the days winding down and time running out, Billy wanted to get his fill while he could.
“I need an answer, Hargrove,” Steve insisted, his beeper going off one again.
Billy let out a long-winded sigh, offering the brunet playfully painful look. “Sure, Harrington. I’ll go to prom with you,” he said at last.
That wide smile was back; the one so big and bashful it made Billy’s heart pitter-patter like feet on tile. It was the smile of a guy who always got what he wanted and Billy would be damned if he didn’t say he was the cause of it.
Steve kissed him then, his hand on Billy’s face to hold him still. It didn’t last long but left the blond dizzy when the other pulled away. He was still tasting Steve as he went back into the diner, a smile on his own sitting on his face as he plopped back into his seat. His plate was untouched and the others were deep in conversation, but he didn’t mind. He’d hop in soon enough.
Billy hadn’t planned on going to prom, having all the expectations to leave as quickly as possible, using all the money he saved up on gas to get him to California.
Now he was going through what he had in hopes of renting a suit that would be good enough to go along with whatever Harrington would be wearing. He was sure the jerk was having something tailored for him, to fit his slim frame perfectly. He didn’t know what colors to go with or where even to go, but he’d figure it out.
Billy was getting ready for work a few days later and spent the early Sunday morning looking for any advertisements in the paper that might help him out. Any suit store that had a sale so he wouldn’t have to rummage through the stores at the mall.
“Billy!” His father shouted from the garage. “Come here a sec?”
Neil didn’t have an office, so he usually worked out of the garage or kitchen. Billy had moved his weights to the corner, giving the man more space for the time being. Neil was cleaning out his toolbox; the dirty rag wiping away any grime that had collected since its last use.
“Yes sir?” He asked, standing at attention in the doorway.
“Have a seat son,” Neil requested, gesturing to the chair in the corner.
Billy had gotten used to doing as Neil asked over the years. He picked his battles when he felt the need, but when it came to the easier stuff, like taking a seat or cleaning up his room, it was better to just do as told. He walked through the garage and sat down, watching as his father continued to wipe down his tools.
“Your sister told me the prom is coming up,” Neil mentioned.
Neil had been an old-fashioned guy and still kept photographs of his prom from back in the day. While he hadn’t mentioned it previously to Billy, as he didn’t take interest in Billy’s schooling, the blond wasn’t surprised his dad took notice of the end-of-the-year activities.
“Yes sir,” Billy answered.
“Plan on asking anyone?”
“I’ll be going with a group,” Billy answered smoothly. “The band -- we’re going to be performing for the prom, so all tickets are paid for already. We’ll be going together.”
Neil hummed, putting one tool down to pick up another. “So no one has caught your eye?”
Billy shook his head. “No sir,” he replied.
Neil turned then, his own eyes dark and full of judgment. “Then why is it Tom Holloway told me he saw you and that Harrington boy outside of the diner the other night?”
Billy shifted in his seat, his teeth clenched as he fought to keep his father’s eye contact.
“Tom said it was dark out there, but still thought I should know what he saw. And what did he see, Billy?”
“Dad,”
Billy’s words were cut off by Neil throwing down the tool he had been polishing. The loud bang sent a shiver up Billy’s spine and he closed his eyes inhabit.
“I thought we were done with this!” Neil shouted. “We haven’t had an incident since we moved here. I thought you were done with all that shit!”
“Dad,” Billy repeated carefully.
“It’s bad enough you do it in private but where other people can see?”
“It won’t happen again,” Billy answered, because it was just easier that way, right? Picking his battles, winning the war. Getting as far away from Neil as he could.
“You said that last time. When you were found on the beach with that boy between your legs,”
A gut-punching sound left Billy’s lips. It had been long ago, before Hawkins, before Susan and Max, when Billy was trying to let himself be happy. It was a mistake, thinking he could savor a moment of normalcy while Neil was around. He had gotten smarter since then or at least he thought he had.
Billy thought of what Neil would say if he told the man that Steve had been here. That he and Steve did a lot worse than just make out on the beach, right under Neil’s roof, but Billy kept quiet. He was spiteful, but not stupid.
“I’ve had enough, Billy. Something has to change,” Neil told him, turning back to his toolbox. “You walk around here, with your earrings, your hair, the flowy shirts. Had you been born a girl you would’ve been branded a harlot,”
“I’m not a girl,” Billy answered, choosing to leave behind what he was called now was a hell of a lot worse than being labeled a slut.
“No, you’re not. But you certainly act like one,” He looked over his shoulder then, eye Billy carefully. “Almost look like one too,”
When he turned around fully, he had another tool in his hand. Billy’s eyes widened when he realized what it was he was holding.
“Dad,” he begged softly.
“Quiet Billy,”
Billy straightened again. He wanted to get out of the chair, to leave the garage, go to work, and pretend this whole conversation never happened. He stood but fell back as his father’s palm made contact with his cheek.
“Sit down!” He ordered. “And shut up!”
Billy did as he was told. When he dared to look up, Neil was holding the shears delicately in his hand. Bring the scissors up, he pressed the pointed tips into Billy’s cheek. Billy didn’t flinch as Neil swiped them across, the feeling of blood dripping down his face was something he was unfortunately used to.
“Let’s see if we can’t fix this, shall we?”
And Billy closed his eyes, accepting his fate.
He didn’t go to work that day and he didn’t leave his room. He didn’t even make it to his bed. He crumbled up in a ball on the floor of his room, engulfed in the silence as he didn’t bother turning on his radio. Music wouldn’t make this better, if anything it would only hurt more with any lyric piercing his chest like the knife his father plunged into his back.
Max found him to tell him it was time for dinner. He didn’t respond, letting her voice fall to deaf ears. She came back a little while later to find the mess that Neil had recreated. Gone were Billy’s golden locks that would fall around his face; the curls he had gotten from his mother and styled in such a way that it made all the girls in school pout their lips and ask him for advice.
Neil had cut away his hair like Deliah had done to Samson, with as much malice and cruelty one mortal man could muster.
“Can I help?” Max asked quietly.
And Billy, having no idea how anyone could fix a problem like this, gave her a nod. She left then, coming back a few minutes later with a pair of dull scissors and a comb. She sat him on his bed and worked carefully, evening out what she could and snipping away the pieces that were beyond repair.
She talked to him, keeping his attention. She told him about her best friend, the Chief's daughter, and how she had short hair once. She had grown it out since but was too scared to let anyone give her a haircut. The two of them sat in her kitchen, styling Jane’s hair like the model in the magazine. Hopper was stunned when he came home but didn’t get mad. Said he liked it.
If she could help her then maybe she could help him too.
When Max was finished and more of his hair was thrown in the trash, he looked in the mirror. His hair had never been short; his mom had let him grow it out since childhood and Neil, up to this point, allowed him this one aspect of independence.
Now that his hair was gone and he looked at his reflection, taking in his new do. Without the hair falling at his shoulders, his face would be the main focus. The cut of his jaw, the sharpness of his cheekbones. Any imperfection he may have could no longer be hidden away.
Billy didn’t cry when his father cut his hair. He sat there like the man his father wanted him to be, silently willingly the man to take the shears and running them across his neck, putting them both out of their misery.
“Do you like it?” She asked, standing next to him.
Billy caught her eyes in the reflection of the mirror, his lips rolling back as he was unable to find any words to fit. Bobbing his head, he tugged on her sleeve, pulling her into a hug. Over her shoulder, he saw the unopened letter from Cal State.
His fingers itched to take it, to open it up or rip it apart.
Billy closed his eyes and pulled Max in tighter, finally allowing himself to cry.
