Chapter Text
“Alright, so if you remove Lionel Richie, that should give you enough time to work in Berlin and at least one Bon Jovi song,” Nancy explained, laying it all out in front of Eddie as they sat on the bleachers together.
Jonathan did him a solid and plead their case to the prom committee about the set list that was being presented to the band. It wasn’t terrible, but they needed to do more than just the cheesy love ballads for the couples to sway to.
It was meant to be a dance, right? So let people dance! Let people rock!
“Berlin is still gonna be a slow song, Wheeler. You have to give me something here,”
“I’m trying, Eddie. I am, but this is prom, you know. One final party for the seniors.”
“Exactly! It’s a party -- you used to date Steve, you should know all about those.”
Nancy huffed, closing her binder as more students joined them on the bleachers. The school called for an assembly, one final send-off the final week of school. Eddie normally wouldn’t be caught dead, preferring to hang out in the Hell Fire room or under the bleachers with the rest of the misfits.
Things are different now. He had someone to cheer for, so he took his spot in the middle where he’d be easily spotted.
“We’ll pick this up later,” Nancy stated as Jonathan and Billy hopped their way up the bleachers. The two scooted over, making room for them to join. Steve joined not long after, flopping down beside Billy.
Henderson, Wheeler, and the rest of the underclassmen joined them, though a few levels down. Max shot Billy a small look, a gentle smile, before falling back into a conversation with Jane.
The Principal came over with a microphone, talking about how wonderful the school year was, how sad they were to see the senior class go, and how excited they were to send them off. Blah, blah, blah, a bunch of shit he didn’t mean.
The real show came when the marching band started playing, and the cheerleaders came running out, pompoms in hand. Eddie would deny it under oath, but he knew each cheer, word for word, and even some of the moves.
He had been there for nearly every practice, watching Chrissy rehearse in her room, going over each cheer line for line. This would be the last time she was cheering for the Hawkins Tigers so she wanted to give it her all.
Eddie cheered her on, even lending a hand with the lift when she’d practice around his trailer, tossing her up when she least expected it just for fun.
Those cheers played in an endless loop while he tried to go to sleep, though he didn’t mind too much when it was Chrissy’s voice in his head.
When they finished their performance, Eddie stood and cheered, whistling loudly while Steve did the same for Robin. Billy tugged them down, trying his best not to laugh at their antics as the principal took over for another speech.
He was too focused on making silly faces at Chrissy, forcing her to break her composure and hide behind her pom-poms.
She blew a kiss at one point, and Carver looked over his shoulder at one point, his eyes going up, up, up to where Eddie and the others were sitting. Eddie rolled his eyes, and dramatically caught the kiss, slapping his hand over his lips to accept it.
When the assembly finally finished and the gym emptied, Billy, Eddie, and Steve stayed behind with Eddie slipped into the hall just outside the girl’s locker room as he waited for Chrissy to come out.
A blond came around the corner, though it wasn’t the one he had been hoping for. Eddie straightened against the wall, ready for whatever came along. The school would be over in less than a week, but he wouldn’t put it past Carver to get one final fight in.
“Nice hair cut, Munson.”
“Keep walking, Carver.”
Jason did the exact opposite, stopping directly in front of where Eddie was leaning against the wall. “Counting down the days, you know. The hours, the minutes.”
Eddie looked up, meeting his gaze. “Until you finally pull your head from your ass?”
“Until that crown is on my head and Chrissy is in my arms again,”
Eddie laughed, blunt and right in Carver’s face. “You think one dance is gonna mean anything to her?”
It had been a constant reminder since they announced the nominees. Eddie wasn’t jealous he was thankful his name hadn’t been thrown into the mix. Jason Carver could keep his crown, all that mattered was that Chrissy got hers.
And if they both walked away as true Hawkins royalty, then fine. Eddie would stand on that stage and sing whatever stupid ballad Wheeler wanted from him. What a way to end the school year, right?
“Maybe. Who knows. Maybe it’ll be exactly what Chrissy needs to wake her up.”
Eddie pushed off the wall, moving closer to the other boy. “Trust me, Jason. I know exactly how to keep Chrissy awake,”
It was a blunt comment alone, but Eddie went the extra mile to stick out his tongue, making sure nothing was left to the imagination.
Jason shoved him back then, his back slamming into the brick wall behind him. “You’re disgusting! Why Chrissy would ever want a freak to touch you is mind-numbing!”
Eddie grunted, knowing he’d feel the pain of the shove in the morning. “ Freak ? God, you’re original.”
“It won’t last. The two of you? You said it yourself, Chrissy is better than either of us. It’s just a matter of time until she sees it.”
“That’s the first smart thing you’ve said.” Eddie winced, pushing off the wall behind him. “Believe it or not Carver, I’m well aware that Chrissy is undoubtedly going to dump my ass -- very soon in fact. The difference, unlike you who most likely would’ve proposed at graduation or slept with her in an attempt to baby-trap her into a life she wouldn’t want -- I’m perfectly okay with that. I am more than okay with that!”
“Do you hear yourself? What did you smoke reefer before you came to school?”
“Is it so hard to believe that I want what is best for her? Look around, Jason! Is this really what you want in life? Living in the same shitty town with the same shitty people?”
“There is nothing wrong with Hawkins,” Jason insisted.
“Yeah. For people like you and maybe even like me but not her. She deserves the world, Jason. And if having my heart stomped on is what gives it to her, then so be it.”
“You’re insane,”
“I’m in love!” Eddie replied, laughing like mad. “We love the same girl, Carver. But I’m willing to let her go. Why can’t you?”
Jason didn’t respond. Not right away at least. He was huffing and puffing, his eyes narrowed as he simmered with anger. Anger seemed to disappear at the drop of a hat. His eyes left Eddie’s and drifted down the hall. Eddie followed his gaze, finding Chrissy standing there, watching the two.
The good Lord must have been on Jason’s side as Chase started calling his name from the boy's locker room, allowing him to make scarce.
That meant it was just the two of them, Eddie and Chrissy, alone in the hall.
“Chrissy. Baby,” Eddie said as he approached.
“What the hell was that about?” Chrissy demanded.
“Jason was just trying to cause trouble,” he excused. “You did great, by the way! I knew you’d land that toss. And you were worried about it,”
Chrissy, of course, ignored the praise. “Did you mean what you said to him? You think I’m going to break up with you?”
Eddie groaned, looking around the hall. There were still lingering students around the bed and the basketball players were still in the locker room along with any other cheerleaders hanging around.
“Look, can we just -- hang on!”
Taking her hand, Eddie led her outside, practically dragging her out and across the field to the picnic table.
This whole thing started here so it may as well end here too.
“Eddie! Answer me!” Chrissy demanded as she was pushed down to sit at the table.
“Yes! Okay. Yes, is that what you want to hear? Everything I said to Jason -- I meant every word!”
“Why would I do such a thing?”
“Because!” Eddie yelled, throwing his hands to the sky. “Because you’re Chrissy Cunningham! And you’re going away to college, and you’re going to be focusing on your new life, with your new friends, and meeting a bunch of new guys. You shouldn’t be tied down to your trailer trash boyfriend during a time like that.”
“Don’t call yourself that,” Chrissy ordered. “We talked about this. If I can’t think badly about myself then you can’t think badly about yourself,”
Eddie let out a sigh, his head hanging low. Going back on his agreement from when they first got together hadn’t been how he wanted this to go, but there was a big enough difference between pointing out the obvious in him and the ridiculous she saw in herself.
“Have you felt this way since the beginning?” Chrissy asked softly.
“I always knew you were going to leave,” he answered. The good grades, the popular status. There was no way she wouldn’t get into her school of choice. No way in hell. “I thought we’d at least have a few good months together,”
Eddie was selfish but he wasn’t cruel. He’d take what he could get and be grateful for it, not caring about what would happen when he was alone again. All that mattered was Chrissy.
He moved to take the seat beside her, though he didn’t dare touch her. Didn’t brush the hair from her face or take his hand in her own. “You had to know deep down this wouldn’t work,” he told her softly.
“That isn’t true,” she answered, her eyes shimmering with the threat of tears. “We’re good together. You know that,”
“We’re good together now,” Eddie voiced. “But this is high school. There is a whole world for you to explore,”
“I want to explore it with you!” She insisted. “Is this why you’d been so hesitant to sleep with me? Because you thought I was going to dump you?”
Eddie had hoped that they’d be able to skip over this whole conversation. And maybe if he tried his hardest he could get her to forget about it, but Eddie had found out very quickly that when Chrissy Cunningham was determined, nothing was going to get in her way.
“Look, I know sex is meant to be this cool thing you explore with different people but don’t you want your first time to be with someone you care about?”
And Chrissy, well she laughed right in his face. She had never laughed at him before. With him, of course. Chrissy was a practical giggle machine when he got down to it, but never at him. “I care about you. I love you, Eddie. And you love me, you told Jason you did!”
“I did.” He answered. Leave it to Eddie to confess his true feelings for his girlfriend to her ex before even saying it to her. “I do. I do Chrissy, but please-”
“No Eddie!” Chrissy pushed off the bench, her arms wrapping protectively around her stomach.
“Baby-”
“No!” She snapped, turning around to face him. “My entire life, I have been told what to do, how to feel, what and when to eat. My mom, my dad, my friends. Even Jason! You were the only person to give me any sort of independence. And now I find out that this entire time we’ve been together you’ve just been waiting for something that would never come?”
“How do you know?” Eddie pressed gently. “Chrissy -- we weren’t even friends until a few months ago. And now you’re willing to rearrange your entire life for me?”
“It’s the life I want! Do you have any idea what it was like before you came along? My mom didn’t even want me to go to college. She wanted me to take a temp job at the bank Jason’s parents own. I would be a secretary , Eddie. Getting coffee and answering phone calls. That’s it.”
Chrissy didn’t want a life like that. One where she was the pretty girl who kept her head down, smiling because it was polite and speaking only when spoken to. Had she stayed on the road her mother pathed for her, she would be nothing more than a Stepford Wife. Now she was taking control of the things around her, doing as she pleased, and focusing on the future she wanted.
“And you can have this life without a guy like me forcing you to settle,” Eddie insisted.
There had to be dozens of people on that college campus that could make her smile, laugh, or feel as good as he did. Eddie wasn’t some kind of one in a million types. He was just a dude with nothing to offer but a good time for a small moment.
Chrissy deserved more than him.
“A guy like you? And who do you think you are, Eddie?”
A pathetic trailer trash orphan, no good freak, who has no business caring about someone like her. A royal, a girl with class and a future. He would drag her down, and ruin her life.
“You once told me I was more than a cheerleader. If that’s true then so is this: you are more than some trailer trash freak the world has convinced you are!”
Chrissy broke the distance between them, forcing Eddie to stand on his feet as she took his hand. “I’m not breaking up with you. Not now and maybe not ever.”
Eddie searched her eyes, wanting to see if she was bluffing for the sake of bluffing or if she truly believed every word she said. In the deepest, saddest part of his heart, Eddie wanted the latter to be true. He had never been much of an optimist, but there was a first for everything right?
“You can’t be sure of that,” Eddie pointed out.
Chrissy didn’t look so convinced. She was holding his hand in her own, fingers laced as they were pressed against her chest, above her heart. “I guess we’ll have to wait and see,” she answered.
Eddie could’ve kept on arguing or he could’ve made the final blow himself. Breaking up with her before prom would’ve been cruel but he would have survived.
But Eddie was tired of surviving. He wanted to live. And he wanted Chrissy, in every way they came, even if it meant being a bit more selfish than expected.
“Finally said I loved you and it was to Jason Carver of all people,” Eddie grumbled, pulling Chrissy in close to him.
She laughed gently, tilting her head up to kiss his shoulder. “You can say it to me if you like,”
Eddie took a slow breath, sighing quietly as he kissed the top of her head. “I love you, Chrissy.”
The smile wasn’t wide but it didn’t need to be as the look in her eyes was enough. “I love you, Eddie.” She replied, leaning up on her toes. “Don’t do that again, okay?”
With an obedient nod, Eddie met her halfway, cradling her face gently in his hands as he pressed their lips together.
And for a brief moment in time, Eddie felt like things might be okay. For a while at least.
