Work Text:
Steve pops open the trunk to reveal a long rectangular box neatly wrapped with bright blue paper and a yellow bow stuck to one of the corners of it. It’s early evening, Fall is on its way in and there’s a light breeze. They’re standing outside of the Byers house and there’s a birthday party going on inside. On top of the box is a blue envelope with ‘Shitbird’ printed and obnoxiously underlined twice in neat, but bold handwriting on it.
Max pauses and looks from the envelope to Steve with a look of hard confusion sliding onto her face.
Steve looks like he doesn’t know what to say and he’s staring at the envelope as well. Max would have lost her patience if not for how sad his eyes looked. He takes a moment to blink and wet his lips before he begins “B-He…he picked this up. Like, a month or so… before everything happened… He left it at my place for safekeeping. I thought I should give it to you for him…”
Max is still staring at the box and her eyes are already stinging with tears. She reaches in the trunk and her fingers brush over the envelope before she gingerly picks it up. Her hands are shaking and she’s looking at the envelope with a rock in her stomach as she traces the letters with her eyes. It’s like she’s checking for authenticity like she can’t believe what she’s holding is real. Max swallows and hands the envelope to Steve.
“Can you… can you read it to me? I-I can’t, please.”
Steve hesitates then seems to steel himself before he nods silently and takes the letter from Max, who turns her gaze back to the shiny wrapped box sitting in the trunk of the Beamer. There’s a tearing noise as Steve gets into the envelope and the rustling of paper as he unfolds and smooths out the contents. It feels like an eternity before he finally starts:
“Dear Max,
Happy Birthday.
I know I’ve never been the best brother to you. In California, I was distant and just tolerable. Then we came to Hawkins, and I was so angry and frustrated with the shitty hand life was dealing out to me. I took that anger and frustration, and I took it out on you. That wasn’t fair, and I see that now. I know I blamed you for getting us stuck in this shit hole, but that wasn’t fair either. You were just a kid, still just a kid. And you deserve to just be a kid for as long as you can.
I’m sorry Max. For hurting you, your friends, and making you scared of me. I wanna be better. Lord knows I don’t deserve it, but if you’re willing, I’d like a second chance at the whole brother thing. I can’t promise sunshine and rainbows right off the bat, still got a lot of shit in my head I gotta wade my way through. I’ll always be an asshole, Max. But I’ll be an asshole you can depend on.
I hope you like the gift. Here’s to what I hope is a new beginning for us. Happy Birthday, Shitbird.
Your asshole brother,
Billy”
Max was already crying halfway through the letter and by the wobble in Steve’s voice as he read, she could tell it had even affected him. This shit really wasn’t fair.
“I’m scared to open it Steve… it hurts” Max knows it's stupid and irrational. Knows there are people inside right now that would give her weird looks and confused questions about why she would ever ‘waste’ tears on someone like Billy Hargrove. But she looks up at Steve and he’s wiping away silent tears too and suddenly she’s relieved that she’s not the only one crying for Billy. Steve is wrapping an arm around her shoulders and Max finds herself leaning into his side.
“I know Max, I know. You don’t have to if you’re not ready.”
Max thinks about it for a moment. She could save it for her next birthday or the one after that. When she’s processed everything, when she’s healed, and the pain is gone and forgotten. Is that what she wants though? To forget these feelings? To forget Billy?
No, Billy would hate that. He was this loud, obnoxious guy that played his music on high volume, and drove way too fast while his engine roared way too loud for the quiet not-so-quiet town of Hawkins. You would hear him before you ever even saw him, and he’d make damn sure that you remembered him.
“No… no, I can do it. I’m gonna open it.” She feels Steve squeeze her shoulder before letting go to let Max reach forward and start tearing into the wrapping paper. There’s a plain box beneath the sky-blue paper and the lid lifts easily from it. There’s yellow tissue paper that Max must move out of the way before she sees it. When she realizes what it is her breath hitches, and she feels like crying all over again.
“I can’t believe he did this…” She whispers just loud enough that Steve can hear. In the box is a brand new skateboard with new trucks and everything. The one she had asked her mom and Neil for months ago. Billy got this for her. He must have saved up for weeks for it! It was expensive and had been the only thing she had wanted for her birthday. That day came rushing back to her and it just started spilling out of her mouth to Steve.
“When I asked my mom and Neil for this they said ‘no.’ It was dinner time, and the four of us were sitting around the table. I showed them the advertisement and everything.” Max’s stare fixes itself on the skateboard. It was the exact same one she had asked for, colour and all.
“I thought it was because of the price and I kept saying how it was the only thing I wanted and that I didn’t even need a party if I could just get this skateboard. I could tell Billy was getting nervous the more I argued. Sometimes I wish I’d just shut my mouth.” Max grimaced and shook her head taking a moment to breathe. “Neil got angry and started shouting, something about How ‘no daughter of mine will be a dyke!’ And how I ‘need to grow up and start acting like a lady.’” She put on this half-hearted mocking man voice before returning to her normal inflection. “My mom just sat there looking at her plate and Billy was looking between me and Neil like he was ready to jump between the two of us.” Max realizes Billy probably would have if it had come to that and vividly remembers how he stood between El and the Mindflayer with such ferocity.
Wonders if that’s the same reaction he’d of had if Neil had ever gone after her.
“I got angry back and yelled that I wasn’t his real daughter anyway. Got up, grabbed my board, and ran out of the house. I ended up at the quarry, and I think I sat there for half an hour just angry crying.” Max let out a huff and licked her lips. She couldn’t feel Steve’s eyes on her, maybe he wasn’t even listening. She didn’t care, she continued. “It wasn’t even about the skateboard. I was just so mad about how he wanted to control me and make me into something I’m not, and how my mom just sat there while Neil kept shouting about how I’d end up a ‘disrespectful loser’ like Billy.” Max remembered how Neil had spit Billy’s name like it was an insult, like poison. Like his son wasn’t sitting right there. Max also remembered how she saw Billy’s hands gripping the edge of the table.
Max went on, “I heard Billy’s car pull up and I knew it was him because come on, no one else’s car sounds- sounded like his.” She was bitter, the Camaro had been wrecked, and Neil wasted no time selling it for scraps. Without letting Max know. “I was dreading more screaming for him to lay into me just as bad as his dad did. But he didn’t. There was no yelling, no screaming. He just walked up behind me and sat down at the edge next to me.” She thought of how calm he was, and how strange it compared to the simmering inferno he was known to be.
“I was still crying, and he just lit up a cigarette and waited until I stopped. When I finally did that’s when he started talking. And he didn’t sound angry, mean, or dismissive. He just sounded honest and… tired?”
“He said to me ‘Don’t let them change you, Shitbird. Don’t let them tell you who you are. Not Neil, not your mom, not even me.’ He said I was ‘tough as fuckin’ nails and as sharp as a whip. Said I didn’t need to change for no one. Told me I’d never have to worry about ending up like him.” Max lets out a wet laugh as she remembers how he had put it, “said he’d kill me before that happened.” It’s clear Steve was in fact listening when she hears him chuckle. too, just as weakly, just as sadly. His arm is around her shoulders again. Max chokes on a sob as thick tears cloud her vision.
“When we got into the car, that’s when I noticed a bruise on his face. One that definitely wasn’t there before dinner. He drove us back home and put on this dumb station that I liked, and I knew he hated it. I shut up about the board and we never spoke about that moment at the quarry… I wish we had.” She had kind of been counting on having more time.
Max let out a breath and hung her head as her tears leaked from her eyes and fell onto the yellow tissue paper. “I know Billy wasn’t a good person, not by a long shot. He had a short fuse, and he could do and say some really fucking hurtful things. But he was only eighteen.” She hated how wobbly her voice was and forced herself to keep it steady. “He deserved a chance to make things right. A chance to get better, to be better… I just wish other people could see that.”
“I know.” Steve says quietly and there’s something in his voice. Like, he really knows, he’s not just saying that to make Max feel better or feel less alone. He says it like he actually means it like he’s the only one that understands this empty feeling inside of Max.
“We were… we were making plans to run west.” Steve starts hesitantly. “Back to California. We were saving money and as soon as he graduated, we were going to pack up the Camaro and just… drive. Start our life together.” Max’s eyes shoot up to Steve’s face and his cheeks are just as wet and flushed as hers feel. She sees that he’s rolling a pendant between his fingers. A pendant attached to a chain encircling his neck. It reminds Max of Billy’s necklace. Then it clicks.
“You and Billy…” Max breaths out and her eyes are full saucers. Her breath hitches when Steve gives a little nod and refuses to meet her eyes. There’s a beat before Max is throwing herself into Steve’s chest and pulling him into a hug. He returns it tightly and now they’re both crying ugly tears. Max’s tears are soaking into Steve’s shirt and his into her red hair. She feels selfish, but it’s a weight off her shoulders. Knowing someone else is grieving for Billy. Grieving everything that he was and everything he could have been. Knowing someone else will remember him, and not just the bad stuff.
They calm down after a while and Max is kind of shocked no one’s come looking for them yet. Or maybe they did and decided it was best not to disturb the two emotional wrecks crying over a skateboard. They pull away from each other and their eyes are puffy and bloodshot, Max can feel snot leaking from her nose. Steve goes and grabs some tissues that he keeps in the glove compartment, and they try to clean themselves up before they have to face the others. Max is running her fingers over the Skateboard. It’s still wrapped in plastic, and she wonders if she’ll even be able to bring herself to ride it. But she will, eventually. Billy would give her shit if he knew she never took it for a spin.
They’re about to head back in, leaving the skateboard and the letter safely stowed away in Steve’s trunk. Max isn’t ready to be asked about it. Then Max stops right before the porch stairs.
“Steve…” She begins and she’s picking at her cuticles nervously. “I… I never really got to know him." Didn’t get the chance. “Could you tell me about him?”
Max feels relief when Steve immediately responds: “What do you wanna know?”
“I-I Don’t know. Everything? I… I don’t wanna forget him. But there’s so much I don’t know.”
Steve smiles sadly and nods. “He’d be pissed about me spilling his secrets. But I know he couldn’t stay mad at me for long.” He places a hand on Max’s shoulder and gives her a light squeeze. “I’ll tell you whatever I can, just not today. Okay?”
And that’s fine by Max, she doesn’t think she could manage anymore crying today either.
“Okay… Steve?”
“Yeah?”
“Thank you.”
