Chapter Text
“Alright! Gentleman and one lady, may I have your attention!” Eddie called out, clanking two glass soda bottles together until all eyes were on him. “Everyone has chosen a song, correct?”
“Yes, a fearless leader,” Robin replied with a faux Russian accent.
“ Wunderbar !” He cheered. “Now, if you’d please pass your papers to the front of the class so I can read them aloud.”
Billy gathered the papers from Jonathan and Robin, passing them off to Eddie as he walked by. They were sitting in Eddie’s bedroom, putting the finishing touches on their preparation for the battle of the bands. Their performance song had to be prepared before the date and they were down to the wire.
Rather than making the master decision, Eddie wanted it to be a group effort between the four of them. This would be the song that could make or break them, so it had to be good.
“Why do you have a Hawkins Tiger scrunchie under your bed?” Robin asked, lifting it into view.
Eddie snatched the scrunchie from her, placing it protectively on his wrist. “I borrowed it from Chrissy.”
“You borrowed a scrunchie from Chrissy Cunningham?”
“Yes, okay. It’s not hidden knowledge, you know. We’re friends. More than friends. I don’t know. Anyway! We were messing around-”
Jonathan leaned forward, his eyes full of surprise. “You were messing around with Chrissy Cunningham?”
“Not like that! Jesus Byers, get your head out of the gutter. We were hanging out. She took her hair down. I put my hair up as a joke and came home with it. I’ll give it back to her Monday morning.”
“When you pick her up for school?” Billy inquired, his brows wiggling with amusement.
Eddie put his weight onto one hip, cocking his head as he looked at the blond. “Says the one who’s been picking up Harrington every day this week. Asshole as a BMW and yet you’re pretty overzealous to be his chauffeur.”
Robin crawled between the two, a smile on her face as she looked at Billy. “You really should let Steve drive. His car has amazing AC and heated seats.”
“My Camaro is better than any car in this state,”
Eddie clapped his hands repeatedly. “Can we please focus people!”
Robin whined, leaning back on her ankles.
Eddie cleared his throat, helping the papers up to read them off. “Alright, first up we got . . . Van Halen! I like your style. “Jump” is an impressive song, I must say. Personal favorite. Whose is this?”
Jonathan lifted his hand high, earning a surprised gasp from Eddie. “You’re expanding your horizon and I like it. What’s next? In the squiggly handwriting we have . . . “Take It On The Run” by Speedwagon. Now, Robin, you know how I feel about ballads.”
“Is that even a real ballad?” Robin asked around the room.
“It’s not as bad as “Keep On Loving You,” Jonathan mentioned.
“Keep your love songs for prom, kiddos. And last, but not least, we have “I Want To Break Free” by Queen from our lovely drummer Billy. Billy, if you were gonna pick a Queen song why wouldn’t you choose one with a drum solo?”
“Didn’t put much thought into it,” Billy confessed.
Eddie scoffed, his mouth hanging wide as he looked down at the blond. “Not much thought? What could be more important?” He demanded.
Billy raised a brow, saying no more. Eddie’s eyes briefly fell on the drummer's neck, exposed from beyond his shirt. His skin was pepper with purple and yellow hickeys; fresh and lingering from the blond latest sexcapades. Eddie rolled his eyes, looking back at the papers.
“What song did you choose?” Billy asked.
“It was tough, you know. I wanted to pick a song that would highlight all of our talents. Your drumming, Jonathan’s fingerwork, Robin’s spectacular vocals.”
“Name your song, dumbass.”
“Surrender” by Cheap Trick.”
“Isn’t that song about a guy seeing his parents have sex on the couch?” Robin asked aloud. “I’m serious! Listen to the lyrics and you’ll see.”
“Regardless of what the song is or isn’t about, that is my choice. Now! We take it to a vote.”
Robin looked around the room, her eyes squinting. “How are we supposed to vote? Won’t we all just vote for our own?”
“You are not allowed to vote for your own,” Eddie answered.
“That’s not very fair.” She replied, leaning back in her seat on the floor.
“How else are we supposed to pick a song then?”
“Make someone else choose,” Jonathan offered. “Have like an outside source be the judge.”
“And who the hell would we get to do that?”
Hopper, it would seem, was their prime target for the song choice. Jonathan called the chief up and had him drive out to the trailer park to sit and listen. They performed all four songs, not letting him know who picked what song so there would be no possible favoritism.
Hopper leaned back in the chair they had provided for him, sipping on the soda bottle that had been placed in his hand the moment he sat. “I gotta say, you kids are doing a hell of a lot better. I guess practice makes perfect.”
“Thank you, Chief of Police. That means a lot to us,” Eddie replied, his hand over his heart. “Do you have a favorite you’d like to share?”
“Out of those? They were all fine.”
“Fine?” Robin mimicked. “Hopper -- Chief Hopper -- we have to choose a song to perform at the battle of the bands. Fine isn’t going to cut it.”
“I mean, you did great on all of them.”
“Did we happen to do better on one in particular?” Jonathan asked.
Hopper shrugged, shaking his head. “No, they were all good.”
Eddie groaned, his face falling into his hands. “Great. This was great. Thank you, Jim. You’ve been wonderful.”
“If you’re so stressed out about it, why not choose a song you like?” Hopper asked. “You played those songs well, but you didn’t put any heart into it.”
“We put heart into all our songs. We put my heart, soul, and butt into every single song we play because we are professionals.”
Hopper chuckled, giving Eddie a disbelieving look. “Of course you are.” He answered. “I’m just saying. Don’t you have anything a little more fun?”
“Fun?” Billy mimicked.
“Yeah. I mean, you’re kids, right? At the end of the day, this performance is meant to be fun for you. Shouldn’t you play a song that makes people wanna get up out of their chairs and sing along? I liked it, but my ass is staying still.”
“And do you, oh wise one, have any song selections?” Eddie asked through his teeth.
Hopper shrugged once more. “That's for you to decide, little man. Come on, you have been working together for months now, right? Isn’t there a song you use to warm up? One that lets you let loose and get your head in the game?”
The band exchanged looks. They had used an array of songs while practicing, one to help them figure out what sound they were going for.
“He has a point,” Billy said, standing up from his drum seat. “Those songs were good, but they weren’t us.”
“There is no us. We’re a cover band for christ's sake and we’re going to be going up against bands that write their songs, own music.”
“Exactly! So we should pick a song that everybody knows and loves and wants to sing along to!” Jonathan replied.
“So what, we’ll just pick a one-hit-wonder and be done with it? Something so overplayed on whatever Top 40 radio station has on their set list?” Eddie inquired.
“Pick a song that makes you happy, kid. That's the only advice I can give.” Hopper said, pushing to stand from the chair. “A song that, win or lose, you’d be glad you played.”
Eddie didn’t like giving in to the pressure, but he found it harder to go with his gut than ever before. They had a following now. A fan base. People would be coming all the way to see them perform and he didn’t want to let anyone down if things didn’t go their way. Losing hadn’t been an option for him until now. From the very beginning, he had his eyes on the prize and now it was down to the wire and he just….
He had to win. He had to prove himself, more now than ever.
“Hey,” Billy called out, his eyes catching Eddie’s across the way. “We’re enjoying the ride, aren’t we?” He asked.
Eddie fought the urge to flip the blond off. Of course, he’d use his own words against him. There was a big difference between taking in the small pleasures of indulging in their crushes and coming out flat after the performance of their lifetime.
“Money or not, this has been pretty fun,” Robin mentioned, swaying around the mic stand. “I don’t even care if we get paid or not. I mean, we’re in a band . How many other people can say that?”
“Robin’s right. The prize money would’ve been nice but being up on that stage. That’s a big-time, man.” Billy added.
“You’re serious,” Eddie said, looking around at the three of them. “After everything we did, you don’t even care if we win?”
They shrugged, all unphased by the possibility. “I wasn’t even getting any of the money anyhow,” Jonathan noted.
“You weren’t paying him?” Hopper asked bluntly.
“It was up for debate,” Robin stated, saving the chief off.
“You choose the song man.” Billy decided.
“Really?” Eddie pressed. “Even if I choose something completely terrible?”
“Can’t be worse than the shit you were singing while nursing your broken heart a few weeks ago,” Billy commented. “Seriously. Any way you want it, we’ll follow your word.”
Robin snorted then, looking over at Billy. “Any way you want it. Funny.”
That's when the light bulb that rarely ever flickered turned on above Eddie’s head. “Robin, I could kiss you right now!” He announced. “You know, if I wasn’t kinda-sorta dating someone else and you weren’t-”
“Disgusted by the idea.” Robin finished.
Eddie pushed past Billy, rushing back into his trailer. Once in his room, he flipped through his record collection, his eyes widened as the red and blue album started back at him. Hurrying back out, he held it up for them all to see. “Lady and gentlemen! I’ve found our song!”
