Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 11: All the Nightmares Came Today

Notes:

Sorry it took me so long to update! Life has been a little crazy recently. But the good news is that I’ve now pretty much mapped out everything about this story, and I’ve got a clear idea on how everything happens.

Also, this chapter finally features both Steve and Billy actually speaking to each other. So. Thanks for reading!

Chapter Text

Steve can’t sleep. He’s sure that at least a part of that is because he’s on one of the lumpiest couches he’s ever seen, and also because the crick in his neck never really went away. The other part, though (okay, fine, the much bigger part), is that every time he closes his eyes he sees Billy.

He sees more than Billy, of course. He sees all of it- the Mind Flayer, El being dragged to the front like a sacrificial lamb, kids screaming and throwing fireworks, Billy being hoisted into the air while screaming in pain. He sees Max screaming over Billy’s body. He sees Max crying on Billy’s floor, Billy laying in a bed looking like death. He sees Billy yelling in the car, sees Billy looking like a shadow of himself in Joyce’s house. And, over and over again, he sees Billy’s back. Sees the way he shakes when Joyce and Steve touch him.

And, God, Steve just can’t get it to stop, no matter how many times he rolls over or counts sheep or makes a hundred different lists. He just keeps seeing Billy.

He’s starting to accept this as his new fate- he used to not be able to go to sleep because of demodogs and the way Nancy’s mouth moved when she said “bullshit,” and now he can’t go to sleep because of Billy Hargrove. There are worse things, he tell himself. This, like everything else, isn’t permanent. But every time he closes his eyes he sees Billy’s back and his stomach absolutely wrenches and Steve thinks that maybe this will always hurt just this bad.

He closes his eyes. Starts a new list. Places He Could Bury a Body. #1: The quarry. #2: Behind the school football field. #3: the-

He hears movement and opens his eyes just in time to see Billy close the front door behind him. His stomach drops and he scrambles off the couch. No, he thinks. No, no, no. How could Billy be so hellbent on leaving? How-

Billy is sitting on the porch steps, lighting a cigarette. He raises his eyebrows at Steve, who nearly trips in his rush to get out the door.

“Going somewhere, pretty boy?”

All of the air rushes out of Steve in one big breath, and he feels, for a moment, nothing but relief. He’s not going to have to drag Billy back. Not right now.

“I thought you were leaving,” he admits, and Billy smiles lifelessly at him.

“Can’t.” Billy takes a drag of the cigarette, and Steve doesn’t miss the way he winces when his arms comes above his ribcage. “Max won’t let me.”

He sounds so serious that Steve can’t help but laugh. How is it, he wonders, that he and Billy, arguably two of the coolest people in Hawkins, are constantly bowing to the will of middle schoolers?

He takes a seat next to Billy, reaches out a hand expectantly. “Come on, man, give me a smoke.”

Billy passes the box, eyebrows once again raised. “Didn’t take you for the bad boy type, Harrington.”

“Hargrove, you don’t know shit about me.”
Steve feels so relieved to see Billy like this -beat to hell, yes, but nothing like he is when Steve closes his eyes- that he can’t keep a small smile off his face.

When he finishes lighting his cigarette, Billy’s looking at him like he’s grown a second head. All of that energy that has always defined Billy (the energy that has been deafeningly absent since they came to the Byers) is back, just a little bit, crackling below the surface of Billy’s eyes. Steve feels suddenly nervous. He wonders if Billy’s about to start screaming again.

But Billy just stares at him, licks his teeth in a way that makes Steve feel like they’re on the basketball court. “I don’t know shit about you,” he repeats, voice pitched high. God, is that how he thinks Steve sounds? “Well, you got that fucking right, buddy. So come on. Why don’t you tell me?” He’s sounding a little angry now, and Steve really isn’t sure where this is coming from or where it’s gonna go. Billy breathes deeply, clamps the cigarette between his lips, and says, with gritted teeth, “why you?”

“Huh?” Steve repeats, and wow, if only Robin was here to see him now, she’d have a field day with how eloquent he’s being.

“Why you?” Billy repeats, voice gravelly. “Come on, Harrington. Why you? My bitch sister is calling around Hawkins for someone tall enough to boost her through a window and she picks you?” Finally, Steve understands the question. “Why you?”

His eyes are hot on Steve’s skin, and Steve has to remind himself not to be defensive. He’s been afraid this whole night that Billy was going to try to leave- he can’t be angry with him now that he’s stayed. “I don’t really know,” he answers, trying to be honest. “The brats are always asking me for stuff. Maybe this was just one of those things.”

Billy shakes his head. “Don’t give me that bullshit. Max calls you up to say I need your help and you just hop in your car and come? I don’t think so.” His whole face flinches, so quickly Steve almost misses it, and he blows out some smoke. “Come on, Harrington. What’s the deal here?” He inhales sharply. “What’re you getting out of this? Why are you still here?”

Steve’s stomach clenches again, and, once again, he just feels so damn exhausted with all of this. Of course, he thinks. Of course Billy thinks he’s only here because he’s getting something out of this. He sighs.

“Billy,” he says slowly, “I just wanted to help. I asked if you were okay, and next thing I know, Max called me and I was crawling through your window.” He rubs the bridge of his nose, brings the cigarette back to his mouth. Wonders if he sounds as genuine as he’s trying to. “I’m just here to help.”

Billy snorts. “Whatever.”

xxx

Steve Harrington is full of shit. Billy’s sure of this. Yeah, maybe, it’s possible that he helped Max because he was just trying to be a good guy. But there’s no reason for him to still be here after Max told him he could leave, after it’s clear that Billy doesn’t need a hospital. Billy can’t figure out what Steve’s getting out of this- maybe it’s just the satisfaction of seeing Billy look so pathetic. Billy doesn’t know. Whatever it is, Steve’s not telling him.

“Whatever.”

Steve scoffs. “Whatever,” he repeats. “Think what you want to.” He doesn’t seem angry, though, not like Billy feels. He just seems tired.

Then again, Steve never really seems angry. Annoyed, yeah. Irritated. Not angry, though. Not like Billy. Billy was only able to get him angry a couple of times before- once on the night when he broke his nose. Billy wonders what that’s like- how does Steve have energy for anything? Billy would never have the energy to do a damn thing if he wasn’t angry. Again, Billy just doesn’t understand. How the hell is this tired boy sitting next to him the King Steve that was so hard to replace?

Billy snorts. “Ya know,” he says, snubbing his cigarette butt and lighting a new one, “when I first got to Hawkins, I couldn’t find one damn person in the whole fucking school who would shut up about you. Everyone talked about you like you shit gold or something- I didn’t buy it, but hey, I figured you had to be at least kinda hot shit for them to all be kissing your ass like that when you weren’t around. I was excited to meet you, Harrington. But just- just look at you.” He gestures at Steve’s whole body, noting the vaguely amused look fixed on the boy’s face. “I’ve never been so goddamn disappointed in my life.”

Billy doesn’t really know what he’s going for- to rile Harrington up, to make him mad, to get him to leave. He doesn’t know, okay? The words are coming and he doesn’t have the energy to stop them. What he knows he wasn’t planning on, though, is for Steve to laugh.

Steve’s laugh is soft and real, not cruel or offended. He lays back on the porch, hands behind his head, and his shirt rides up a little bit, showing a strip of his stomach. Billy looks away.

“The problem, Hargrove,” Steve says, waving the cigarette in the air to punctuate his words, “is that you caught me at a bad time. I was hot shit, okay? The hottest. But by the time you got there... well, I was in love and I had already started swinging baseball bats at monsters. I had bigger stuff going on.” He laughs again, returns the cigarette to his lips. “If you had gotten here a year earlier? God, Hargrove.” Steve grins big and wide, eyes closed. “You woulda eaten your heart out.”

Billy likes the sound of that.

“You never would’ve beaten me, Harrington, don’t kid yourself.”

Steve laughs again. “Yeah, maybe not. But I’m telling you, Hargrove. The fight would’ve been good.”

Billy laughs now, can’t stop himself. The idea of him trying to beat out Steve Harrington -who wears Polo sweaters and drives a BMW and probably listens to Cyndi Lauper- and Steve actually fighting back and, well. It sounds fun. A lot better than whatever the hell it ended up being.

Steve, apparently encouraged by the laugh, keeps going. “Hawkins wouldn’t’ve known what to do with themselves. God, Hawkins is a... I don’t know if you realized this, Hargrove, but I didn’t have much competition to worry about here. Both of us? At the same time? We woulda had the school on its knees.”

Billy grins, looking up at the sky, and he can feel Steve’s eyes on him.

Steve pauses, and then says, very quietly: “Maybe we would’ve been friends.”

Billy barks out a laugh, and he knows it sounds harsh, and he wants it to. “Don’t shit yourself, Harrington.”

Steve sighs, closes his eyes. “Yeah, that’s what I thought.”

Billy can feel the anger rising again, and he doesn’t even know why. But the idea that he and Steve would’ve been friends...they wouldn’t have been. That’s all there is to it. They’re not the same, no matter what Steve thinks he was. Steve has to be able to see that, has to be able to see that he and Billy were never gonna be the same, not even before Billy tried to kill him and became an actual monster.

But Billy also feels...something, when he sees the way Steve’s face falls and the bags under Steve’s eyes. Guilt, maybe? He doesn’t know. He wants to hear Steve laugh again, though. Wants him to stop looking like he’s about to drop dead from exhaustion. So, once again, Billy just lets the words come out of his mouth without bothering to stop them.

“Did you know I almost fucked Nancy’s mom?”

Steve bolts up into a sitting position so quickly that Billy has to lean back to avoid being hit, and the look on Steve’s face is so cartoonish that, for the second time tonight, he laughs.

“You- WHAT? Mrs. Wheeler?”

Bills nods. “Karen.”

“KAREN?” Steve actually yells, and then immediately claps a hand over his mouth, looking back at the house. When no lights turn on, he looks back at Billy, mouth open wide. “You didn’t.”

Billy shrugs. “I didn’t,” he admits. “But I almost did.” He grins, loving how wide Steve’s eyes go. “Had a hotel room and everything.”

Steve blinks at him, and then begins- well, the only word Billy knows for it is cackling. “Holy shit!” Steve wheezes, doubling over. “Holy fucking shit, Hargrove! You” -Steve is laughing so hard he can barely get the words out- “you almost slept with Mrs. Wheeler!” He looks up at Billy, tears in his eyes. “Damn, Hargrove, you don’t fucking play around, do you?” He laughs into his arm, and Billy feels something warm in his chest that he immediately tries to ignore. “Did she actually- did she meet you?”

Billy shrugs. He remembers, hazily, Karen saying something to him -an apology- but mostly he remembers trying to keep himself from bashing her head in against his will, so he’s really not sure. “Don’t know. I was on my way when- you know.” He waves at his face, remembers what it was like to have that thing clamp down on his mouth. “It got me.”

The smile drops from Steve’s face, and Billy wishes he hadn’t told the whole story.

“Well, fuck.” Steve whispers, still wiping tears from his eyes. He grinds his cigarette butt under his heel, and Billy watches as the orange glow disappears into gray ash. Steve rubs his face. “Listen, Hargrove. I can’t sleep, and I can’t stay awake, so I’m just gonna go make some coffee, okay? You want some?”

Billy nods, quiet as Steve pushes himself to a standing position. Steve waves a hand at him.

“Just don’t- don’t leave, okay?” he says as he opens the door. “I can’t take Max killing me right now.”

Billy watches the door shut behind Steve, finishes off his second cigarette. Looks up at the sky.

Maybe we would’ve been friends, he repeats in his mind. He knows they wouldn’t have, knows a lot of stuff Steve doesn’t seem to grasp. But. Still. It’s a thought.

Maybe we would’ve been friends.