Chapter Text
Joyce is running through the hallway, towards the porch, towards the voice, when Steve barrels out of the bedroom, almost running into her. (Steve was in Billy’s bedroom, which is...that’s interesting, but she’ll think about it later). He slams the door behind him and looks at her, panic in his eyes.
“It’s Neil,” he whispers, “it’s Billy’s dad, it’s his dad, he followed Max-“
“BILLY!”
God, the man must be on the porch by now. Nancy and Jonathan stumble out of Jonathan’s room, and Joyce can see Eleven and Will, eyes wide and frozen still, at the end of the hallway.
Joyce points at them. “Go to Will’s room,” she whispers, “and lock the door. Do not move from there; you understand me?”
Eleven wants to protest, Joyce can see that clearly, but Eleven has no powers and, for once, this fight isn’t about her.
“Go,” she commands, and Will pulls at Eleven, and Joyce waits until she can hear the click of their door locking.
“Who is it?” Nancy hisses, and they all jump as someone begins pounding on the front door, yelling: “BILLY! I know you’re in there!”
“It’s his dad,” Steve says, voice cracking, as if the answer isn’t obvious. “It’s Billy’s dad.”
Nancy nods once with a tight face and disappears back into Jonathan’s room, leaving Steve, Jonathan, and Joyce to all stare at each other.
“He can’t see Billy,” Steve pleads. “He can’t, he’ll kill him.”
“I know,” Joyce says back, heart pounding in her chest. She wishes Hop was here. “I know.”
xxx
If Billy walks out of that room, Steve will kill him himself. That’s what he’s thinking as he walks out onto the porch—if Billy willingly places himself one foot closer to this man, Steve is going to kill him. Steve’s not sure if he’s ever been this scared in his life. There’s been worse times, sure; the time when he saw his first flower faced demon monster, the time he thought Dustin was about to die, the times he thought they were all going to die. But those times had an accompanying adrenaline, something that kept him from fully realizing how terrified he was. In those moments, he did what needed to be done. It was only afterwards, in the emptiness of his house, that he realized how awful it all was, how scared he felt all the time.
Now, though, he knows. He knows how scared he is, because he’s looking at this man, who’s only human, and he’s normal, not even Russian, not even a government guy in a suit, and he knows that he, Joyce, and Jonathan are the only things standing between this monster and Billy, and, honestly, he’s not sure they’re enough.
He won’t lose Billy. He won’t.
Steve’s not sure what he thought Neil would look like, but it wasn’t this, because this man looks like someone Steve could walk by in a grocery store without flinching, someone Steve could serve ice cream to without thinking twice. He seems normal. He seems normal, but Steve knows he’s one of the worst people in the world.
For a moment, everyone is quiet. Neil breathes through his nose, sizing them up, one by one, and Joyce clears her throat.
“Can I help you?”
“I’m looking for my son,” Neil spits out, and it’s such a weird formality, what they’re all doing now, pretending everyone on this porch doesn’t already know. “You’re keeping him in your house.”
Joyce clenches her jaw. “I’m afraid I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
Neil laughs. “I think you do. My son? Billy? He ran away, and you’ve been hiding him. It’s time for him to come home.”
Every muscle in Steve’s body is tense, and his heart is in his throat.
“Your son is not-“ Joyce starts, and Neil shakes his head.
“He is. My daughter’s here, right? I saw her walk in this house. They’re coming home with me. Now.”
“Man, they’re not here,” Steve sneers, and oh God, he’s done this before, he’s lied to a Hargrove on the porch while hiding Max inside the Byers’ house, and, Jesus Christ, last time didn’t go well, either.
Neil stares at him. “Who the fuck are you?” His voice is quiet, but Steve feels like Neil knows everything about him, like Neil sees straight through the bullshit and knows who Steve is and hates Steve, hates him enough to kill him, hates him enough to leave him bleeding and broken on a mattress in a locked room for a whole week. Billy lives with this? Billy spent his life with this? Finally, Steve feels some adrenaline kick in.
“I’m Steve fucking Harrington, and I’m telling you, Billy’s not here.”
Neil just stares at him, and Steve hates him, he hates him so much that the only way to keep his hands still is to clench them into fists at his sides and bite the insides of his cheeks.
“I’ve heard your name before,” Neil says. “You were there at Starcourt, right? When the place burned to the ground?” He rubs his hand at his jaw. “You wanna tell me what you were doing at the mall with my son and a bunch of kids?” His mouth twitches. “You a pervert, too?”
Steve takes a step forward and Jonathan wrenches him back while Joyce places a small hand on his chest. “Calm down,” she whispers, but her eyes are huge.
“Your son isn’t here and I want you off my property.” She says confidently, raising her chin.
“You can lie all you want, lady, but we both know he’s here.” Neil focuses his glare at the house. “MAX!”
“She’s not here,” Steve mumbles, but even as he says it, he’s looking at Max’s bike thrown at the front of the house, a gift from one of the boys, one of their hand me downs, passed to Max because they weren’t sure her skateboard could make it all the way to the Byers. Neil looks at it, too, and his face is red.
“You will not hide my daughter from me,” Neil says, and he takes a step forward, a step towards Joyce, and Steve and Jonathan both converge in front of her, but Neil’s not stopping, and shit, they’re gonna have to do this, huh?
The door opens behind them and Steve’s heart shrinks. No. Fuck.
“Neil?” Max’s voice is smaller than Steve’s ever heard it, and she moves in between them and Neil quicker than they can stop her, moves enough that’s he’s out of Steve’s reach and he takes a step towards her and she pointedly dodges his grasp. “What’s wrong?”
Neil looks at her, and for a moment he looks like a normal man again, and Steve hates him.
“Where’s Billy, Max?”
“I don’t know,” she says, still in that small voice. “I thought Mom said you hadn’t found him yet.”
Neil looks at her like he’s going to murder her. “I know he’s here. I know you came to see him.”
Max shakes her head. “I came to see my friends,” she whispers. “El and Will. They live here. I just came to see them.”
Neil rubs his jaw again. “Then why didn’t you come when I called?”
She’s shrinking in front of them; Steve is watching Max melt into the earth.
“Well, I was,” she stutters a little, “I was scared.”
Something snaps in Neil’s face. “You little fucking bitch,” he hisses, and he lunges, and it all happens at once. Joyce reaches out and grabs Max and pulls her in and Steve steps out and catches a backhand to the face- a backhand meant for a 14 year old girl, what the fuck- and then Steve has Neil on the ground, and they’re both kicking and shoving and punching and everything is red and Steve can’t see straight and then there’s a hand on the back of his neck, pulling him back, shoving him away, and then there’s a body between him and Neil, and it’s Billy, of course it’s Billy.
xxx
As soon as he saw Neil’s eyes go dark Billy was out the door. He knew what that look meant, knew Neil was about to hurt Max, knew it didn’t matter anymore that she’s the favorite and that she’s perfect and that she is a child. Billy sees it happening and fucking sprints. But Steve stops it before he can, Steve protects Max, Steve fucking tackles his dad, and Billy is so mad and so grateful and so nauseous all at once. He sees Neil land a good punch on Steve’s chin, and he’s not even sure what he’s doing, but he’s in between Neil and Steve now, and his dad is going to kill him, and Steve could’ve been really fucking hurt, so it’s worth it, it’s okay. Neil had been about to hit Max. Neil had hit Steve. Neil can have Billy, for all Billy cares.
“Dad,” he says, “you have to leave.” This is it, this is what he’s been afraid of this whole time, that Neil would hurt Max, that Neil would hurt Steve, that Neil would want to hurt Joyce. These are all his worst fears recognized; this is it.
Neil just looks at him, and Billy knows that face, and he wishes he didn’t care, wishes he didn’t automatically tuck his chin and wish he was dead.
“So this is where you’re hiding?” Neil gestures at everything behind Billy, at all the people who have tried to keep him alive. “This is it? You get scared, so you run? You can’t even stand your ground? You run, and you run to this?” He laughs. “Some skinny boys, a woman, and children? These are who you hide behind? You always run, Billy, you’ve always been a fucking pussy. You’re pathetic. Do you see that? Hiding behind these people? You’re pathetic.”
“Yes sir,” Billy says, and he hates that he says it, hates that it’s automatic, and he hates the way he can hear Steve and Joyce behind him but he can’t actually hear what they’re saying.
Neil’s jaw works. “Here’s what’s gonna happen. You are going to get in this car, and your sister is going to get in this car, and we are going to go home, and you’re gonna fucking apologize to me, and to Susan, and to these people, for all the fucking trouble you’ve caused because you were too scared to do anything for yourself. Okay?”
People are saying no and other things and there’s a horrible crack in Steve’s voice but Billy is already nodding. “Yes sir,” he whispers, but he knows they can’t, because he’s not letting Max live in the house with this man, he’s not letting Max in the car with him, he can’t do this.
“Billy,” Steve says behind him, and he can’t look away from Neil’s eyes, ‘cause Neil hates when he does that, hates when he’s too scared to make eye contact. “Billy, look at me, please, Billy, please.” He can’t. “Billy,” Steve whispers, and this is Steve, who cried for Billy, who keeps staying, who doesn’t leave, who holds his hand and held him last night. This is Steve.
Billy turns to look at him, and as he does, he knows.
“I couldn’t hear you,” Neil says, because Neil’s not content with just getting Billy back, he has to humiliate him, too, but it’s too late.
Billy turns back to Neil. “No.” He swallows. “No, sir.”
Neil’s hand shoots out and grabs him by the neck and Max screams and Joyce is yelling and even Jonathan is speaking, holy shit, Billy didn’t know he talked, and Steve, of course, rushes forward and has a knee in Neil’s stomach and a hand wrenching at the arm that’s trying to cut off Billy’s lungs, and then everything freezes and everyone goes silent.
Someone’s speaking, calmly and quietly, and even Neil is watching, and he lets go of Billy, and Steve pulls Billy into himself and they both stare at the porch where Nancy stands, calmly pointing a handgun at Billy’s dad.
“You need to leave,” she repeats, and Steve wraps his arms around Billy, holds him to his chest, moving them away from Neil, and Neil looks at them and KNOWS, Billy can see it in his eyes.
A soft click. The gun is cocked. “Mr. Hargrove,” Nancy says, and she doesn’t even flinch. “I’m a very good shot. And I’m telling you to go.”
Neil stares at her, and then at Billy, and then back at her. Finally, he holds his hands up and nods. He looks at Billy. “The next time I see you, you’ll wish you were dead.”
Billy nods. He knows.
And then Neil is gone, and everyone’s screaming, and the kids are running out of the house and Joyce is trying to hug him and Steve is freaking out and Nancy is still holding a gun but all Billy cares about is Max. He reaches out for her and she appears, and he’s not scared right now, not for himself, and he’s not confused. He knows what needs to happen. This isn’t over. They have to go, and they have to go now. He’s not gonna let people get hurt for him. Not anymore.
