Chapter Text
Nancy refuses to let Billy take the gun without her and Jonathan refuses to let Billy, Nancy, and the gun be alone, which should be annoying but seems, given the history, entirely fair, and so now Billy is in a car that little miss priss is driving with a gun in her lap and her living ghost of a boyfriend (and possibly Billy’s future roommate) in the backseat.
Billy’s dreamed of having the courage to do what he’s about to do so many times—dreamed of it without believing it was possible, dreamed about it in the same way he dreamed about running away to California or having a family one day. In every version of this dream, though, he’s been alone. He doesn’t know how to reconcile any of this, and his hands feel twitchy. Billy resists the urge to tell Nancy to turn around.
“So,” she says, lips pursed in a distinctly middle-aged way, “you and Steve.”
“What?” He asks with a scoff, and she frowns.
“Billy. You. And Steve.”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“Cut the bullshit, Hargrove,” she snaps, and a quiet laugh floats from the backseat. “I pulled a gun on your dad earlier; I think we can be a little more honest with each other.”
“Well I’m gonna need you to elaborate a little bit more on what you’re asking, sweetheart,” he drawls, and he feels a pinprick of satisfaction when he sees it get under her skin.
“Fine, then,” Nancy responds, tapping her fingers on the steering wheel. “How long have you two been fucking?”
Billy’s mouth clicks shut, and now she’s the one looking smug. He tries not to let it last too long.
“Don’t act like you know something you don’t, Wheeler.”
“Then tell me what I don’t know,” she says, a little bit softer. “Because I’m trying to understand, and I CARE about Steve, and-“
Now it’s Billy’s turn to laugh. “Sure have a weird way of showing it,” he says with a gesture to the back seat of the car, and Jonathan tenses.
“Don’t talk to her like that,” he says quietly with a current of steel, and Billy feels a little relieved to see this display of backbone. Nancy doesn’t seem bothered by any of it.
“Billy,” she says again, “I know Steve. And I know what it looks like, when… he cares about you. What’s going on?”
Billy remembers, remembers the way Tommy used to talk about Steve and Nancy, the way Steve used to trail after Nancy in the hallways. He remembers hearing about a King Steve and seeing nothing. He remembers (because he absolutely cannot shake it) when Max said that Steve and Dustin were brothers. And he thinks, well, what the hell? Who better to ask?
“What was he like? When he dated you?” Billy asks, and even he is shocked by how softly it comes out, and Nancy is stunned enough by the tone that he’s able to stack more on top of it. “Because Tommy said… he said he changed. That he stopped…what was he like?”
“Tommy’s a dick,” she responds with an air of finality, as if she won’t take any criticism on that particular concept. “Because Steve was a good guy, okay? And Tommy hated that.”
“But they were friends before. And then they weren’t.”
“That’s not my fault! That’s because…because Tommy was a dick. And Steve stopped being a dick. And things happened. And there were monsters. And things—Steve changed, and Tommy didn’t.”
“And then you cheated on him,” Billy says, unwilling to let it go, and Nancy winces.
“Hey-“ Jonathan starts, and Billy waves him away.
“No. It happened. You broke his fucking heart, the whole town knows it, and he forgave you, because of whatever. I don’t give a shit about that part.”
“Then stop bringing it up,” Nancy says, voice right, and Billy shakes his head.
“Steve had friends, Nancy, and then he dated you, and then he didn’t. And now he has a family, and…come on. What was he like? Just tell me.”
Nancy just her chin out. “Why?”
“You pulled a gun on my dad, I think we can afford a little honesty.”
“Fine,” she hisses. “He was a great guy, okay? He just…we didn’t work. Together.”
Billy rolls his eyes. “Again, with the elaborating. Give me some real words, here.”
Nancy sighs, but she pauses, like she’s actually considering it this time. “He was sweet. He came to Barb’s parents’ house with me, even though he didn’t know them, and he stopped being friends with Tommy and Carol ‘cause they were dicks to me and Jonathan. And he…he tried really hard with stuff, yeah? He was sweet, if that’s what you’re wondering. He IS a good guy, which is why-“
“I know he’s a good guy,” Billy says tersely, and what he wants to say is: of course he’s good. Anyone looking at Steve can see that he’s good. He radiates it. He’s good and he’s kind and he’s sweet and APPARENTLY he spent his relationship with Nancy just trying to be the person that Nancy wanted him to be, and now…
“We’re here,” Nancy whispers, as if it isn’t obvious, and Billy nods. Right. Of course.
“Okay,” he whispers back, as if Neil hasn’t already seen the headlights in the driveway, “my turn with the gun.”
There’s a brief debate over whether or not Billy can actually go alone, and he has to, because if someone’s going to see this, he can’t stand for it to be Nancy or Jonathan, but they don’t want him to be alone, for, again, reasons that are entirely fair. What they all land on, then, is that he can go in the house alone, but they will not leave the driveway, and the car will stay running, and if he’s not back in five minutes they’re coming in, and Nancy brought Steve’s baseball bat. (Secretly, Billy appreciates this plan, because it means he only has to make it five minutes, and he’s pretty sure that’s all he can take).
Neil meets him at the door, and Billy doesn’t hesitate, just shoves the gun again Neil’s chest and hisses “inside,” and he hates the way his heart is pounding and the way his hands clam up and the way his throat constricts when the door slams behind him.
Neil’s been drinking, because of course he has, because he had a gun pulled on him this morning, because his wife has left him, because he’s been betrayed by his stepdaughter. He must have been sleeping on the couch, because everything looks wrong and disheveled and Neil is blinking like he just woke up. Billy takes a deep breath and raises the gun, leveling it at Neil’s chest. He breathes in. He breathes out. “You-“
Neil doesn’t let him get the words out. “Oh, so now you grow a pair?” He says, and he sounds irritated, not afraid. “Is this your plan, William? You’re done being a pussy? You’re going to kill me? Your father? The only person who’s ever protected you?”
“That’s not true,” Billy says reflexively, and his dad looks disappointed.
“Who else has been there for you like me? Your mom? I’m the only person that’s never left you, son. And this is how you treat me?”
Billy aims the gun higher, tells himself the bullet would hit Neil right between the eyes. “You almost fucking killed me,” he growls, “you tried to fucking kill me.”
Neil finally has a real reaction; he finally looks angry. “Is that what you think?” he sneers. “You think that’s half bad? Do you have ANY IDEA what my dad would’ve done to me? You think you almost got killed? Boy, you’re LUCKY you’re still walking, you fucking-“
“SHUT UP!” Billy yells, something inside of him snapping. He could’ve died. He knows he could’ve. And he could’ve died and not known Joyce and not been with Steve and with no one who loved him and without Max calling him her brother and he could’ve died without ANY of that and it would’ve been Neil’s fault, he knows it. “Shut the fuck up because I’M the one with the gun here.” He waves it a little bit to prove his point and is shocked to realize his hands aren’t shaking.
Neil goes still, so something in Billy’s voice must have sounded true, but he still doesn’t look afraid. “You’re not going to shoot me,” he says quietly, “you’ve never had the balls.”
Billy swallows. He could shoot him, really. It would be easy. And maybe he’d go to jail but Neil would be dead, and Max would be safe. And Steve would miss him, and Joyce would blame herself, and- no. “You’re right,” Billy admits. “I’m not gonna shoot you.” His voice is clearer than it’s been this whole time; for the first time in weeks, he can look at his dad and speak with his whole chest. “I’ve got too much going for me right now. This is just a warning, okay? I’m not gonna shoot you now. But next time? Next time I will.”
Neil makes a face, but Billy notices that he’s gone stock still, not moving a single muscle. “Next time? Next time what?”
“Next time I see you,” Billy says easily, and again, he realizes that it’s true, that he fully believes the words he’s about to say, words he’s never believed possible. “This is the last time you’ll ever see me. Because I’m going to leave. And I swear to God, if I ever see you again, I’ll kill you.”
Neil’s face is turning red, but he’s still not moving. “You think you can walk away from this family? You think-“
“You don’t have a fucking family,” Billy barks, and then he can’t help but smile. “It’s my family now, yeah? I finally learned what you wanted: I’m taking care of Max. Because listen to me: you will never touch her or see her again, or I’ll shoot you, okay? Either of us. If you ever talk to me or Max again, I’ll-“
“You think she’s on your side, here? You think she cares about you? You think she’s not afraid of you, you-“
Billy cocks the gun. He means it, too, and Neil goes pale. “That’s my fucking sister,” Billy says in a low voice. “And if you see her again, I’ll kill you.” He smiles again, like he used to, in that dead eyed, toothy way he knows scares people. “You shouldn’t’ve tried to hit Max, Dad. Because now I swear to God there’s nothing in me that wants you alive.”
Neil is still pale, but he’s angry, too. Billy’s never seen him like this. He’s still terrified of the coolness in his own chest, of how sure he feels of his own movements. Is this what his dad feels like, usually? When he’s the one standing over Billy? Billy’s throat constricts minutely.
“That boy,” Neil spits out, after a moment. “At the house. You and him…”
“Right before I came here I sucked his dick,” Billy says, and he levels the gun a bit more when Neil’s face goes red. “And I’ll probably do it again. So fuck you.”
“You fucking…” Neil splutters for a second, unable to find the words. He wants to lunge at Billy, Billy can tell, he knows the look on Neil’s face, but they’ve never had a gun between them before. “The next time I see you,” Neil finally says, “you’re fucking dead.”
Billy shrugs. “That’s fine with me,” he says. “Because I’ll die taking you with me.” He looks at the clock over Neil’s shoulder on the wall. “Anyways, that’s five. I just wanted to let you know,” he waves the gun around, keeps that grin that Steve hates plastered on his face, “that I’ve got a gun and I want you fucking dead. And, you know, to say goodbye.” He winks. “So bye, Dad. I hate you. And you had better fucking pray I never see you again.”
He turns on his heel and walks out, and he knows he shouldn’t turn his back on his dad, has known that since he was 7, but he’s got the gun, and he’s got Nancy and Jonathan in the car, and…
His dad doesn’t even yell as he leaves. Billy’s never seen his dad like this before, and he’s not sure what it means. He hopes, with a deep bitterness in his mouth, that that’s what Neil looks like when he’s afraid.
xxx
Steve wakes up to no Billy and a mild panic. Billy’s in the bathroom, he tells himself, and then he gives Billy exactly 30 seconds to return from the hypothetical bathroom trip before he stumbles out into the hallway, telling himself it’s all fine.
There’s a car pulling up outside, he can hear the engine, and his first thought is that it’s Neil, that they’ll never have peace, and he sprints to the porch, looking for his bat, but it’s nowhere, and-
And Billy and Nancy and Jonathan get out of the car, calm as can be, and Nancy has the gun in her hand. The four of them all stare at each other for a second, the sun having risen just enough for them to all see each other’s faces in the cool blue light. Steve looks desperately at Billy’s face, trying to find any new injury, and sign of distress. But Billy meets his gaze evenly, and in the sunrise light, he looks…he looks soft, but he looks sure. He looks like yet another version of Billy Steve’s not totally familiar with.
Nancy whispers something to Jonathan, and then they make their way up the stairs. Nancy pauses briefly next to Steve, her lips pursed, and she says, “I don’t think your boyfriend likes me very much,” before she lays a comforting hand on Steve’s shoulder and then keeps walking.
And then it’s just Billy and Steve, in the porch steps, in the light of dawn, yet again. Billy smiles, a soft, crooked smile, and sits on the steps, gesturing for Steve to sit with him.
After a second, Steve complies. “Where were you?” He asks, even though he thinks he knows.
“We went to Neil’s house,” Billy says quietly. “And I told him if he ever tried to see me or Max again I’d shoot him.”
“Oh,” Steve says, as if this is normal. “And do you think it will work?”
Billy shrugs. “No idea.” He inhales deeply. “What matters, I think, is that I meant it, and he knows it. So. I guess we’ll just find out how much he cares about living.”
Steve sucks in a breath. “So you-“
“I swear, Steve, I’ll kill him. I meant it. I’ll go to jail, if…I’m not going to be afraid of him anymore. And I won’t…he’ll try to kill me, I think, so it’s mutual.”
Steve nods, still going for a cool casual response. “Okay,” he says as evenly as he’s able. He swallows. “How are you?”
“I feel like I’m gonna hurl,” Billy says, “but it’ll pass.”
Steve smiles and wordlessly lifts an arm up. After a second, Billy leans against him, and Steve wraps his arm around Billy’s shoulder, plants a small kiss in his curls.
“I hate him,” Billy whispers, “so fucking much. I almost died. I almost died before… if you hadn’t…if Max hadn’t…”
Steve shakes his head. “Max and I were always going to bring you here,” he says, and he’s not sure what words match up to the concept he’s trying to get across, but he believes it deeply. “This was always going to happen. You were…you were always coming to this house, Billy, you were always going to be a part of this family.” There’s a lump in his throat. “I would’ve never let him take that away from you.” He kisses Billy’s hair one more time. “You are supposed to be here. Max and I would never let him take that from you.”
Billy settles into his chest. “Say it,” he whispers. “The thing from the car.”
Steve smiles. “I love you, Billy Hargrove,” he says, and Billy straightens up enough to look at him. There’s something unreadable on Billy’s face, but he’s smiling, and that’s all Steve really cares about.
