Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

A Broken Search

Summary:

Bilbo committed treachery, now the dwarves of the Iron Hills are after his head.

 

Disclaimer: Read at your own risk.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

Bilbo unwrapped the secret package he had placed on the table. Quietly, the Arkenstone glowed dimly now that Bilbo stepped back from it. He felt.. lighter. How strange. The Arkenstone was not heavy itself, but the burden of keeping it secret was, of the guilt that would often replay in his mind over and over again, until he wanted nothing more than to call out to Thorin and tell him he found the treasure that he so longingly seeks for. But even Balin said it. The Arkenstone would make everything worse for Thorin. So this was the only option, right?


But still, Bilbo tells Thorin himself, to help him  stop feeling so guilty. Maybe, Thorin will see through the gold sickness like he had last night with the acorn. He will see Bilbo's true intentions, to help, rather than to hurt.. Thorin's eyes harden. It's not a slow realization, it's a sharp and piercing gaze. Thorin feels the betrayal washing over him, like a river over stone. The gold sickness takes hold, he doesn't see Bilbo anymore. He doesn't see the Burglar they travelled with for months, he sees a liar; a thief. A traitor.

In his fury, he grabs Bilbo's collar, forcefully dragging him across the cold stone, breath ragged. Bilbo doesn't fight much, he struggles about as much as a 3 foot tall hobbit can struggle compared to a larger, heftier dwarf who is used to carrying much heavier metals than someone as small as Bilbo. 

Gandalf steps through the crowd, commanding Thorin to let Bilbo go, to not harm the Burglar, and Thorin's attention is now turned entirely to Gandalf as he yells out swears and curses Bilbo. He doesn't noticed Bilbo slip away with tears in his eyes. 


The command left Thorin's lips like a verdict carved into stone.

Find him. Bring him to me.

Word spreads outwards, through the desert-like mountainside, whispers through the gathering armies of the Iron Hills. A king's command, relayed by soldiers, getting distorted because of the distance. 

Find him.

Find the Burglar. 

Kill him.

KILL HIM!

The words twist, mutating into something ugly, but still catching like wildfire among thousands of dwarves who never heard the original command, who only hear the anger, betrayal, and fury of their king wronged, their people robbed. 

They don't know who Bilbo Baggins is, nor what he looks like. All they know; is that he is branded a traitor by their king, and he must be killed. It started quiet. Low murmuring among the ranks, it became a low chant, then louder, yelling, until it was almost deafening. "Kill him! Kill the Burglar! Death to the traitor!" The dwarves metal boots thundered against rock, against the dead, dry ground beneath them. So began the hunt without a face, a death sentence without a target. 


Bilbo was standing between the ranks of elves. Just a little ways behind Gandalf, and almost somewhat in the general area of Thranduil on his elk. Bilbo was lost in thought, he understood now what Gandalf meant before, but he still wasn't afraid of Thorin. Sure, he just tried to kill him, but he wouldn't actually do that. The Thorin from the carrock could never harm a hair on his golden curly head. Bilbo knew it was the gold sickness, and he was more afraid that he couldn't do anything to help Thorin.

Meanwhile, Gandalf's eyes were distant and unfocused. He could hear chanting in the distance, but it was hard to make out the words. His ears perk up just the slightest bit so he can enhance his hearing...

"I suppose it's all coming down soon.." Bilbo murmured idly, looking at the thousands of dwarves before them. He was well aware of Thorin's grudge against elves, especially Thranduil. 

Gandalf doesn't answer, because he knows Bilbo is right, and he knows that Bilbo knows it as well.

The old wizard feels it before he can hear it. He feels the hatred of all these dwarves, directing at one single target.. Gandalf's head snaps up, looking in the distance, and clearly seeing Dain Ironfoot in the front of the dwarf armies. Their words finally reach him, in a way he can understand. 

Kill him.

"No.." he breathes, fully aware that his back is to Bilbo, and the small creature cannot hear him. 

Not like this. 

His gaze flicks over to Bilbo, who is still focused forward, towards the ever-growing armies of the Iron Hills, and whatever extra dwarves they picked up on the way. 

Not him..

Gandalf steps closer to Bilbo, who seems to take notice. He's now slightly in front of Bilbo, but more by his side than he was before.

"Stay near me," Gandalf whispers quietly.

Bilbo looks up at him, puzzled. "Why?"

Gandalf forces a smile that didn't quite reach his eyes. One that Thorin was always so good at seeing through, thankfully, he had not taught that talent to Bilbo yet, as the small hobbit studies him with his eyes. "Just an old man's precaution.." 


The armies clash. Elves against dwarves, steel against steel, anger against pride, arrows against brute force. The air is chaos; shouting coming from all sides, clashing blades that always seem to close to the ear, and the metallic smell of blood that crawls its way through your nose, into your stomach, making you sick. 

Bilbo stays low, it's not like he has much of a choice considering he is 3 feet from the ground, but still, he is practically unnoticeable... Well, until he hears a voice in between strikes of metal. 

"You are in grave danger, halfling," the measured, and definitely regal voice belongs to none other than Thranduil. 

Bilbo turns his direction, startled. "What!?"

"The word has spread," the Elven king continues, his cold eyes distant as he watches the battlefield. "Your name is being twisted. They do not seek you for justice." he pauses for just a moment. "They seek you for death."

And suddenly Bilbo feels sick to his stomach, and the world tilts.

Bilbo laughs, a weak attempt to shrug off the dire situation at hand. "That's—not very funny."

Thranduil just gives him a cold stare. "I am not known for my humor."

Bilbo feels his blood run cold.


Far past all the bloodshed, inside the walls of Erebor, the company hears it too. They can't hear the chant, it's too far away, and too much clanking of metal, and screaming from all sides. What they hear are the whispers, the confusion turned into something bitter and evil.. 

Kíli is the first to move. He will not stand idly by while his own people try to kill his friend. He storms into the hall, eyes blazing with the fury of a Durin prince. "You told them to kill him!?"

Thorin freezes, he hadn't been moving much before, but he was still as a statue now. His brows furrow. "I told them to find him."

"That's not what they heard!" Kíli shouts, his voice breaking. "That's not what they're doing!!"

For the first time in years, even since the gold sickness' claws had loosened, Thorin looked.. afraid. 

"I.." his voice falters. "I did not—" 

He had not wanted this. His intentions were never to harm Master Baggins..—

"Master Baggins did nothing wrong!" Kíli snaps, suddenly yelling. "He saved your life! And you—this—This is madness! Master Baggins is going to end up dead!"

The room stills.

"You are right, Kíli, Master Baggins has done nothing wrong," Thorin admits, his voice soft and his shoulders sagging ever so slightly. "Master Baggins has been nothing but helpful to us."

A booming laugh shatters the tender moment. Dáin Ironfoot.

"I've got a gift for ye, cousin!"

Something is thrown. It lands at Thorin's feet.. with a sickening final thud. 

For a moment, no one breathes, no one moves, and everyone just stares down.. at the body that is now Bilbo Baggins.. lying at the foot of their king. 


Thorin doesn't move. It has to be some kind of sick dream that the gold sickness forced him into, right? But the longer he stares, the more sick be becomes.

The world narrows to that small, crumpled form, the curls of golden hair, familiar coat, and a deathly stillness where there should be life.. 

"No," someone whispers, and maybe it's Kíli.. Thorin doesn't know. Maybe Thorin himself said it..

Kíli drops to his hands and knees beside Bilbo, his hands shaking as they roam over Bilbo's very still form. "No— no, no no, no-"

Bofur steps forward, but seeing that Bilbo doesn't get up, his eyes widen.

Fíli’s voice cracks, sharp with disbelief. "Get up. Come on— this isn't the time to be— Bilbo!!"

Óin pushes through the others, he's desperate.. because he knows something... his hands hover over Bilbo's chest, pressing down, he waits.. Nothing. Óin closes his eyes, trying to keep his voice steady.. "He's gone."

The words cause a shift in the room, like something is broken.. and it cannot ever be fixed. 

Kíli sobs, burying his face in his hands, Fíli turns away, shoulders shaking. Dwalin embraces Fíli, trying to keep himself from crying. Balin's crying, holding a hand on Bofur's shoulder. 

Thorin moves. He falls to his knees on the other side of Bilbo. He stares, as if sheer will could bring him back to life..  "I told you.." he whispers hoarsely. "I told you to find him."

Dáin shrugs, unapologetic. “Aye. Found him.”

Something in Thorin snaps. “LEAVE.” The word echoes like a crack of thunder.

Dáin raises a brow.

“I said,” Thorin growls, voice trembling with something far more dangerous than anger, “LEAVE.”

And this time— Dáin does without another word.


The company is left alone with Bilbo..

With what's left of him..

And for a cruel moment, it feels like the world forgot to move, that it could possibly be mourning the death of one of Yavanna's children. But it only lasts a moment, because the grief settles heavy in the room, it's suffocating every single dwarf who stood there in tears, or those who tried not to cry, and failed. But war does not wait to mourn those already lost. The orcs have arrived, and the dwarves are forced to fight for something they aren't sure they want anymore. 


The company fight like ghosts. They lack all spark, everything that makes them a dwarf, the enjoyment of battle is just.. gone. They fight like they have nothing left to lose. For Thorin, that might just be true. 

Steel against steel, metal against metal, it all sings a song of blood, rage, and grief.. leaving a hollow ache, like the ache that Thorin felt when he saw Bilbo's lifeless body at his feet. But somehow, th dwarves win. Thorin defeats Azog, the dwarves, elves, and men defeat the orcs.. but the victory does not feel complete. 

 

The funeral is quiet, there are no songs of triumph, no laughter. Just stone, and a horrific silence that settled over the company since the little being was dropped at their feet. Thorin stands at the front, unmoving, as Bilbo is laid to rest..  normally, he does not speak at all during funerals unless he has to.. but this time, he feels like he needs to.

"You were.. never meant to be part of this world. Kindly child of the west, sleep peacefully in Yavanna's everlasting garden. I am sorry that I brought you into such perils.." his voice breaks. "You made my world brighter for the short time you were in it.." his hands clench, a painful reminder that Bilbo's blood is on his hands. "I was too blind to see it."

The wind would carry the rest of his words away, the ones he could not fathom to say after such a loss.


But the truth is softer..Quieter.. and hidden in a forgotten land that began everything. Bilbo Baggins does not lie in that grave.. Far from Erebor, in the gentle green of the Shire, there lived a hobbit. 

Said hobbit was sitting outside his circular door. The air smells like grass and peace. Bilbo holds a cup of tea in his hands. Saved by the cunning wizard's cleverness, illusion, and a small bit of luck. But it doesn't feel like survival. It feels like loss. Bilbo never truly got to see Thorin reclaim his home.. He sighs, looking out on the green hills, his eyes distant and unfocused. When he thinks of Thorin, he does not think of the gold sickness, the madness, the rage, or the war. 

No, Bilbo thinks of a different moment; a warmer moment. On the Carrock, when the King smiled at him for the first time, when his rough voice, softened slightly, just for him. And a look that meant something that Bilbo could never dare to name. The wind carries away the unspoken words that his heart sings. 

Far away, under stone and sorrow, Thorin will forever mourn, believing the blood of Bilbo Baggins will forever remain on his hands.

And in the quiet of the Shire, Bilbo will ache for the King to hold him gently again, and softly call his name like a memory. 

They live on in separate worlds, bound by a love neither will ever know survived.

That is the cruelest ending of all. 

Notes:

How'd y'all like it? I think this is lowk kinda fire? I wrote this instead of sleeping, it's literally 12:57am rn