Chapter Text
1885
Bilbo had always considered himself an intelligent hobbit. He was a renowned scholar throughout the Shire. His library was one of the largest and his intellect was outmatched by none.
In this world, however, Bilbo felt like an abandoned fauntling, unable to survive with no one there to guide him. Twice now he had found Thorin, and twice he had lost him.
Somewhere, in the back of his mind, Bilbo had the niggling feeling that this was his punishment. But punishment for what? How it irked not to remember.
Could he recall why he had been banished to this world, Bilbo would greatly accept his fate, for surely it was well earned. But this was torture. Every year ticked by without cause nor reason. The city grew around him, always changing.
And yet Bilbo remained the same. No new lines on his face, no gray hairs, now new aches or pains that came with aging.
He was the only constant in this world.
“Excuse me,” a small boy said, looking down from his window at Bilbo, his arms dangling down and a wide smile on his face. “Mr. Gardener!”
Bilbo looked up from the bush he was trimming, wiping his brow with a dirtied handkerchief. “Good morning,” Bilbo called back. “And how may I be of assistance, young master?”
“May I pick some flowers?” he asked.
“Why should I let you?”
The boy pouted. “You work for me,” he complained. “So you have to do what I say.”
“Master Thurston,” Bilbo chided. “I’ll come up there and box your ears, don’t think I won’t.”
Thurston yelped, ducking below the window sill so Bilbo couldn’t see him. “You can’t do that,” he shouted back. “I’ll tell mama on you.”
“And Mistress Ackerley will agree that I was within my rights,” Bilbo replied, putting his shears down and searched his pockets for his pipe. “Are you coming down, or aren’t you?”
“Yes, Mr. Baggins, sir!”
Bilbo chuckled to himself as he watched the boy duck out of the window, no doubt running through the halls in his rush to the garden.
Though once a gentlehobbit, this was not a world in which one could remain idle, and Bilbo entertained himself as a gardener. He was taught by his mother and father before him, as well as from the old Gaffer. They had all agreed he had a green thumb, and what had once been an idle hobby became his only means of survival.
He had wandered from estate to estate, claiming experience at the previous household, but never the one before that for he had spent many long years there and had not aged. It was a risk he was willing to take, as long as he had a roof over his head and food to feed his belly.
It wasn’t much of a life, but it was all he had.
Young Thurston ran towards Bilbo, a smile on his face. He had the biggest blue eyes Bilbo had ever seen, with hair as dark as night. He was a beautiful boy and Bilbo knew that in time, he would be a most heinous heartbreaker.
“Mr. Gardner,” Thurston said, huffing and puffing. “I wish to inspect the garden.”
“You may call me Bilbo,” Bilbo told him, not for the first time, nor the last. Thurston made a face at him and Bilbo knew it was not likely to happen. He enjoyed calling him Mr. Gardener far too much.
“And when I finish, Mr. Gardener,” Thurston continued, “You may assist me in my bouquet.”
“What is this bouquet for?” Bilbo asked, following Thurston as he inspected the flowers, making sure he didn’t step on any of his plants. He worked hard on the garden and he didn’t need the boy to ruin his livelihood.
Thurston stared thoughtfully at one of the rose bushes, head tilted pensively. “Father’s coming home,” he said. “You haven’t met father, have you?”
Bilbo had not. Mistress Ackerley had hired him, admitting that she admired the work he had done at the Lockhart manor, and that she was in desperate need of a gardener. Her husband was away on business but she wanted the garden to be in full bloom upon his arrival.
She visited with Bilbo every morning, checking up on his progress and enjoying the flowers in full bloom. She was gone for the day, leaving Thurston and his sisters in the care of his governess.
“I haven’t,” Bilbo agreed.
“Father loves the garden,” Thurston told him. “He spends most of the morning walking down the paths, but the last gardener was fired for stealing. You’re not going to rob us in the middle of the night, are you Mr. Gardener?”
“I’m not a burglar,” Bilbo huffed. The cheek of the lad.
“I thought as much,” Thurston deflated, genuinely upset that Bilbo was not going to rob his family blind. Bilbo would never understand children. “I want to give him flowers so he’ll know how hard you worked.”
“I’m sure Master Ackerley would appreciate the flowers more where they belong,” Bilbo said, but plucked a daisy from the flower bed and handed it over to the boy. “Now off you get, I’ve work to do.”
Thorin lay in his cot, breathing shallow as Bilbo sat beside him, clinging tightly to his hand.
“You’re going to be fine,” Bilbo repeated as Thorin’s grip became weaker. “Please, Thorin.”
“What a shame,” came a soft voice and Bilbo looked up in surprise, searching the tent for the owner of the voice but found it empty.
Bilbo swore he had heard someone speak. He carefully lay Thorin’s hand back on his chest and cautiously walked towards the tent flaps, pushing them aside and looking at the dwarrows, elves, and men rushing past, most exhausted from the battle.
The guards at Thorin’s tent looked at Bilbo and he smiled sheepishly at them before returning to the interior. He heard a voice. He was sure of it.
“A complete waste,” the voice piped up, deep and slithery, echoing in Bilbo’s ears. He turned around frantically seeing no one, but feeling something akin to a hand falling onto his shoulder. Bilbo stiffened under the touch as the voice continued:
“Gone before his time. The Valar had plans for that one.”
“Who’s there,” Bilbo asked, a tingle running up his spine. The hair on his arm stood at attention and a prickling pinched at the points of his ears. “Show yourself.”
“I can save him,” the voice said.
Bilbo felt himself freeze. Save Thorin? Was it possible?
“He’s so close to death. But I can stop that. I can make him live again.”
“How?”
A low pitched laugh reverberated through the tent. “What are you willing to give?”
“Anything,” Bilbo replied.
“Anything?”
“Yes,” was Bilbo’s quick response.
The air in the tent suddenly grew heavy as black shadows built before Bilbo, billowing and rising into a manlike shape. Bilbo took a step back, the back of his knees hitting Thorin’s cot. He took hold of his dwarf’s hand, shielding his eyes as the smoke cleared.
Eyes like embers looked down at him in glee as the figure said, “Perfect.”
He had heard, rather than saw, Mr. Ackerley’s arrival. Thurston’s shouts of joy echoed on the park, causing Bilbo to chuckle under his breath as he pruned the shrubbery. Little Ava’s shrieks soon joined in with her brother’s and Bilbo was certain that the family reunion was going splendidly.
Bilbo wiped his brow with a handkerchief, setting his shears to the side and pulling out his pocket watch. It was half six, nearly time for supper.
He packed his things away, placing his kit in the shed before trudging up to the house, wiping his boots as he stepped into the kitchen, the sweet scent of freshly baked rolls cooling on the table. He was quickly shooed out for a good scrubbing and Bilbo obliged, taking his turn at the water pump, damp curls dripping water as he returned to the house.
“The master wants to see you,” the housekeeper told Bilbo just as he sat down for dinner. “Once you’re done eating, of course.”
Bilbo nodded, swallowing nervously. He hoped that the garden was up to snuff. Supper was a nervous affair as Bilbo wondered why the master of the house would want to see him.
His questions were answered that evening as he stood in Master Ackerley’s study, the fire in the hearth dwindled down to nothing but embers, leaving the room chilled and dark. Bilbo bit his lip nervously, clearing his throat as he waited for some sort of response from the shadowed figure sitting in the oversized armchair before the dying fire.
“You wanted to see me, sir,” Bilbo tried, clammy hands rubbing absently on his rough trousers.
The shadow moved and Bilbo could just make out the sharp profile of his nose, causing Bilbo to take a step back.
No. No, no, it couldn’t be.
“Mister Baggins,” Thorin rumbled, slowly rising from the chair, his familiar form morphing before him. “It is you I have to thank for my garden.”
Bilbo nodded absently. How he wanted to reach out his hand and run his fingers through those wavy locks. How he craved to nuzzle his face into his neck and feel his warm embrace. But this was not his Thorin, just a phantom of his mistakes, he knew this now.
“My wife wrote poetics of your skill and I did not believe her,” he continued, a small smile lighting his harsh features. “I am in your debt.”
“Hardly, sir,” Bilbo murmured. “It is my job, and it pleases me to know you take pleasure in my work. You may repay me with your admiration of the gardens, nothing more, nothing less.”
Thorin looked at him with suspicion before laughing breathily, tension quickly deflating. “You are indeed an odd one, just as Lillith said.”
Bilbo simply nodded. It was unfair. Two times he had run across Thorin, and now he was finally having a conversation, but couldn’t reveal who he truly was. How could he? Thorin was so content with his wife and child.
“It grows late, sir,” Bilbo said. “If I may be excused?”
“Of course,” Thorin assented, nodding his head and turning back to his armchair, sinking slowly into the velvet material .
Bilbo stood in the doorway as an idea came to him. “Would you like me to light the fire, sir?” he asked, looking over his shoulder.
Thorin looked back at him in surprise.
“I know it’s not my place, but the fire is nearly dead and it does not appear that you will be leaving anytime soon,” Bilbo replied, knowing that it was highly likely that Thorin would throw him out of the room for overstepping his bounds.
But Thorin simply nodded, gesturing towards the fireplace and Bilbo offered him a smile.
Bilbo was snuggled warmly in his bed when he was awoken by the fire bell. One moment he was back in Bag End, serving Thorin a slice of apple pie, freshly made, and the next he was watching as flames licked at the brick mortar of the manor.
He stood in the garden in his night shirt along with the stable hands, the only other staff that didn’t live within the manor proper, eyes taking in the horror.
Thurston stumbled out of the manor, his mother by his side, faces and clothes covered in ash. The rest of the staff followed and Bilbo could do nothing but gape dumbly.
Where was Thorin?
Bilbo’s blood ran cold and he knew then he was dead.
Was this his fate? Was this truly his punishment? Was it not torturous enough to watch him die once, but over and over again? Was the Valar so cruel?
He bit back his scream and turned away from the dying house, walking off the property, not caring where he ended up, as long as it was as far away as possible. If he had to live as a recluse, so be it.
But he couldn’t stand it any longer. He would not risk the chance of watching Thorin’s death once more. He was old, and he was tired.
