Actions

Work Header

A Terrible Time to Fall in Love

Summary:

Billy and Steve aren’t friends. Sure, they acknowledge each other existence, but they don’t really know each other.

But, no one has to know if they sleep together once or twice, right? No one has to know either one of them has fallen hard?

Why communicate when being mad is so much easier?

Notes:

hello! this is my first fic, so please let me know what you think! this chapter is kinda all over the place, but at this point i don’t really care.

Chapter 1: Wistful Thinking

Chapter Text

“I’ve spent a lifetime running”
And I always get away
But with you I’m feeling something
That makes me want to stay”
-Writings on the Wall, Sam Smith

 

Steve isn’t a fan of parties. Sure, they were fun when he was a teenager in a town with nothing else to do, but those days are past him. Loud noises and sweaty people aren’t really his thing.

He doesn’t even know whose house he was at. Could be a fucking sorority house, he has no idea. Steve doesn’t see anyone that he knows at first, but then he spots Dustin and his friends in a corner of the room. They’re a bunch of nerds, but Steve hasn’t cared about that bullshit in a while. They’re his nerds. Not since high school. Before, well, shit hit the fan in Hawkins.

He takes a sip from whatever cheap drink is currently in his red solo cup. Jesus, it doesn’t even taste good. He takes another sip and leans back against the wall, surveying the crowd around him. He sees El and Max dancing awkwardly and trying to pull in Dustin's new girlfriend, Suzie. She seems sweet enough, and Dustin is completely smitten with her. He’s honestly a little surprised to see any of them here in the first place. They’re not really the party type, but then again neither is he.

He lets his eye keep wandering, and he finds Robin. She catches his eye from across the room and flips him off with a grin. She’s draped herself over a girl who Steve thinks is named Sofia, but he’s not entirely sure. She might even be Robin’s girlfriend. All he knows is Robin spends most of her time away from their shared apartment, not that he minds. He loves her, but it’s nice not to have someone constantly insulting him, no matter how good-natured and enduring it’s meant to be. Waving back at her, he makes his way over to her and Sofia. On the way someone bumps into his shoulder.

“Ah shit, sorry. I didn’t see you there-“ Brown eyes meet steely blue ones, Steve’s heart skipping a few beats at the sight of the man in front of him.

No one can deny that Billy Hargrove is stunning. His sun-tanned skin was always on display for the world to admire thanks to Billy’s apparent dislike of covering up. There’s something about him that makes Billy always seem just a little too real, his colors bleeding into the world with vigor. He’s almost too bright to look at. Almost. It’s not like Steve has any problem against looking at bright things, especially when those things have Billy’s beauty.

Billy is basically Purdue’s most desired item. Every girl wants to sleep with him, every guy wants to be him. Steve, ironically,would be fine with both. Not that anyone aside from Robin knows that.

He’s not ashamed. He’s not. But going through all the things that happen when he’s come out in the past make him just a bit paranoid, a bit anxious. The only reason Robin knows is because he couldn’t stand not having anyone actually know who he was. Plus she wouldn’t stop trying to set him up with her band friends. They were all nice enough, but it got old rejecting people over and over. At least it wasn’t like high school where he actually went on dates with girls where he had to come up with an excuse of why he didn’t want to go on another one.

“You had a long enough look, pretty boy?” Billy’s teasing question brought him back to the party. Steve tries to convince himself that the blush is from his drink, not that he’s fooling anyone. Christ, less than a minute in and he’s already a mess. They don’t even know each other that well. Steve is sort-of friends with Billy’s sort-of friend Tommy. A party together here and there, a few mutual acquaintances. There was a night a few months ago where they were the only ones left at a friends house not hooking up in a bathroom, but that was more awkward than anything else.

They’re not enemies or anything like that, but they haven’t really had a history of getting along that well. Steve doesn’t hate Billy, but he does hate the effect that Billy has on him. He can’t decide if he wants to kiss him or punch him, or maybe both.

Clearing his throat, he steps to the side hoping to let Billy pass. He’s holding out hope that Billy will just let this go, but knowing Billy he sincerely doubts that. It’s not like it’s a rare occurrence for someone to stare at Billy. The rare thing is that he stares back. Which, Steve noticed, he is not doing because Billy Hargrove does not let people know what he wants. Not that Steve wants him to. He’ll blame it on the lights or some made up shit.

“Yeah, cause what you need is more flattering, Hargrove.” It’s not his best comeback ever, but with the way his brain is going a million miles per hour right now he’s pretty proud that he didn’t just scream and run away. Not that that’s off the table quite yet.
Just as Billy looks like he’s going to respond to his remark with something likely snarky and a little insulting Tommy H. comes over to them, slinging an arm around their necks.

“Are you boys up for a game of Never Have I Ever? I got your dorky friends to join us Stevie boy.” Tommy gestures in the general direction of the whole party. Steve honestly didn’t know what he expected. Tommy’s always drinking way too much at any party. “Hargrove, anyone you have in mind to play with? I know that junior’s been trying to get your eye for a while.”
“Thanks Tommy, but I’ve got all the fun I need from the present company.” Steve can’t tell whether or not he’s being serious or sarcastic, so he decides to take it as the latter.

“Whatever suits. you man, follow me.” Tommy leads them to a less crowded room with a big rug in the middle and a few couches pushed to the sides. In a circle on the floor is Nancy and Jonathan sitting next to each other and quietly talking (Steve assumes they’re his “dorks”), Tommy’s girlfriend Carol, Robin and Sofia leaning against each other and laughing, a kid named Keith that Billy plays baseball with, and whoever Keith’s date is.

Steve goes to sit down next to Nancy and Jonathan, who have finally noticed his presence and are waving him over, but Billy grabs his elbow and pulls him down on the floor next to him so that they’re sitting next to each other. Nancy looks just was confused as Steve probably does, but he shrugs and goes with it. It’s not like it matters who you sit by in Never Have I Ever.

“Okay, so you all know the rules?” Take a drink if you haven’t done the thing, etc. etc.”

“Thanks for that explanation Tommy. Real useful.” Sofia snorted at Robin's comment, hiding herself in Robin's shoulder. Smiling, Steve rolled his eyes at her and gave Tommy an apologetic grin. He’s pretty sure that Robin is only here because of him too. Robin, Nancy, and Jonathan aren’t exactly friends of Tommy, but he thinks that Carol and Nancy might know each other.

“Enough chatting, let’s get started.” Carol claps her hands together and rests her head on them, thinking. “Never have I ever been caught having sex in a public place.” Unsurprisingly, Billy, Carol, and Tommy all take sips. Out of the corner of his eye Steve sees a blushing Nancy and Jonathan both taking sips. Steve, Robin, and Sofia’ cups are both full.

“At least some of us have a sense of decency,” quips Robin from her spot with Sofia.

“Maybe I’m just good at not getting caught.” Steve scoffs at Sofia’s comment, most likely meant for only Robin to hear. He’s learned that, when inebriated, Sofia is shit at being quiet.

“I only get caught when I want to get caught,” added Billy, looking right at Steve while he said it. Steve has no clue how to take that.

“My turn. Never have I ever cheated or have been cheated on by a partner.” Everyone is looking around, daring the first person to take a sip. It’s Steve who lifts his cup to his lips first. Billy follows, as do Carol and Tommy. Everyone knows Carol and Tommy have had their rough patches, so there’s no real shock there. Bily taking a sip isn’t a shock either. His whole playboy image would be a little less believable if he hadn’t taken a sip. Steve feels like he’s the only one here that taking a sip means anything at all.

No one makes comments at the end of that round, not wanting to cause a scene, or they just don’t know what to say.

Billy is the one who speaks up after a few seconds that seem to last forever. “Well, that was fun. Thanks for that delightful question, Wheeler.” Steve would be mad at Billy for talking to Nancy like that if he felt he had any control of the situation. He does sneak a look at Jonathan, who’s looking slightly like he wants to knock Billy out, but he’s calmed by Nancy’s hand on his shoulder.

Steve’s always been impressed by how easy they’re able to calm each other. A single touch for them can tell the other all they need to know. Steve hasn’t felt comfort with someone like that for a long time.

It’s Billy yet again who breaks the silence. “Don’t sweat it. I’ve got a question that’ll make people more upset.” It’s almost like Billy feels bad for insulting Nancy. Almost. Steve’s not sure Billy’s got a regretful bone in his body. “Never have I ever kissed someone of the same gender.”

All the air leaves Steve’s chest. Billy can’t know, can he? The smirk he’s giving Steve makes it seem like he does, but Billy looks like that at everyone all the time.
“Cheers to you, Hargrove,” Sofia acknowledged, taking a substantial drink from her cup.

“Yeah, fuck you Billy.” Robin's words lack any bite. If anything she looks happy to be taking a sip. The other eight of them look around, waiting for someone else to take a sip. Nancy doesn’t even blink when Jonathan takes a small sip of his drink. As discreetly as he can Steve takes a sip, and Billy soon follows. It could mean nothing that Billy waited for Steve to drink first, just like it could mean nothing that Billy took a sip in the first place, but to Steve it doesn’t. It sends a shiver down his spine, which he tries his best to hide. He’s fairly certain he saw Billy looking out of the corner of his eyes, but that could be wistful thinking.

Whatever this game started out as, it’s not that anymore. The atmosphere feels charged with nervous energy, and Steve can feel himself start to fidget. He picks at his nails, pulling on a loose nail. His mother always hated when he did that. She couldn’t stand the sight of his ragged nails and raw skin.

Steve can see that there's a considerable group of people watching them. It makes sense. Billy, Keith, and Tommy all play sports, and are pretty popular. Robin has a lot of band friends, and he’s pretty sure Sofia is part of a sorority.

Billy seems to notice as well. “Looks like we have a crowd. How bout we make this a little more interesting, play spin the bottle instead. Put on a show. Give the kids what they want.”

“Yeah, cause kids want to watch a bunch of college students make out.”

“Dude, that’s exactly what they want. I don’t think you’ve ever actually met a kid.”

Spin the bottle isn’t exactly Steve’s idea of a fun party game, but he’ll play along for now. “Sure, I’ll play.”
“There you go Stevie. Finally growing a pair!” Tommy earns a punch in the arm from Carol, which he graciously takes.

Everyone else already sitting agrees to play as well, and the game starts. Robin finishes the bottle that she had, and places it in the middle of the circle. Tommy claps his hands together and spins first. It lands on Nancy, who gives him a small smile. They’re kids is nothing special, two seconds and over.

Steve’s impressed Tommy was able to read Nancy’s apprehension. Maybe it was Jonathan’s tenseness.

Next is Robin. She spins and the bottle lands on Carol. The whole groups laughs as Carol makes a show of crawling over to Robin, grabbing her faces and kissing her dramatically. The air is lightened, and any pressure Steve was feeling is gone now. That good feeling keeps him going for almost the whole game. Jonathan and Keith’s girl. Keith and Tommy. Sofia and Nancy. Keith and his girlfriend. Nancy and Steve. Carol and Billy.

Then it’s Steve’s turn. He grabs the bottle with shaking hands, all of his nerves suddenly alight. He doesn’t even know why. It doesn’t make sense.

The bottle spins around, stopping quickly on the shaggy carpet.

It lands on a little to his left. Right where Billy is sitting. Steve has to kiss Billy.

No big deal, right? It’s a game, it’s not like it means anything to anyone. Hell, just a second ago Robin was making out with Carol and both of their partners don’t seem to have a care in the world. Steve doesn’t even have a partner, so this should be easy.

Everyone in the room is watching him. He can’t let them think there’s something wrong with him, that this is something that disgusts him, something that he can’t do. His eyes finally meet the one pair of eyes that he cares about in this moment, and takes a deep breath.

Steve leans over and touches his lips with Billy’s, trying not to overthink it.