Actions

Work Header

A Terrible Time to Fall in Love

Chapter 5: Tell Me I Can Say These Words

Summary:

“Hey Stevie, what’s your favorite classical song?”
“What the fuck? Billy? Why are you asking me this?”
“I should be asking you why you’re still up this late. I have a real excuse, I’ll bet you don’t.”
“It’s not late, it’s…3:00?”
“Baby, go to bed.”
“No I’m busy.” Steve knows his tone doesn’t sound convincing at all, but he doesn’t really give a flying fuck.

Notes:

YALL I AM SO SORRY THIS TOOK FOREVER i was working on something else and i just really wasn’t feeling it since the last chapter. anyway, our boys are learning how to talk yayyy.

there is a tw for this chapter, mentions of homophobic parents, mentions of abuse, description of scars and some angst. take care of yourself babes, and pit a comment if you want me to write a summary of what happens so you don’t have to read it.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“so for once in my life,
let me get what i want
lord knows it would be the first time
lord knows it would be the first time

so, please, please, please
let me, let me, let me,
get what i want this time
lord knows it would be the first time.”
-Please, Please, Please, Let Me Get What I Want, She and Him

 

Steve’s conversation with Dustin went better then he thought it would. Sure, it was awkward as hell, but it was worth it if he was able to be completely honest with his people.

His relationship with Billy hasn’t changed much, except now he sees him less because of baseball. He feels like he’s missing some big part of him, which is strange because he didn’t really think Billy was that important to him before. Billy let certain things slip a few time, too many for it not to be intentional at this point. He’ll call Steve after a lecture Steve was dreading to see how it went, he’ll remind Steve to pack a lunch, and more.

Steve’s been trying to repay the favors the best way he can. He fills up Billy’s water before practices, he puts ice packs in Billy’s fridge when he’s over at his apartment after they meet up, he invites Billy over so he can have food to eat after practice.

Steve’s currently sitting at his tiny kitchen table and trying to get some reading for his english lit class done. It’s surprisingly easier than he thought it would be. He wants to quit immediately.

Luckily he gets a call from his phone. He doesn’t even check who it is before he answers it, happy to be distracted temporarily.

“Hey Stevie, what’s your favorite classical song?”

“What the fuck? Billy? Why are you asking me this?”

“I should be asking you why you’re still up this late. I have a real excuse, I’ll bet you don’t.”

“It’s not late, it’s…3:00?”

“Baby, go to bed.”

“No I’m busy.” Steve knows his tone doesn’t sound convincing at all, but he doesn’t really give a flying fuck. It is three in the morning, after all.

“Oh yeah, that’s why you answered your phone.”

“You’re the one who called.”

“Yeah, speaking of that tell me your favorite classical song and I’ll let you get back to what you were doing.”

“Fine. Why exactly do you need to know this?”

“To prove a point.”

“And what point is that?”

“I’ll tell you after.”

“What are we considering classical?”

“Mostly Orchestral and classically composed.”

“Gee, thanks.” Steve stops to think about his answer. “I love clair de lune. It’s a hard one to pass over.”

“Pretty boy, I hate to say it but it sounds like you’re a basic bitch.”

“Hey! I’m your basic bitch, so be careful. Plus, I didn’t say that was my final answer.

“Sure baby.” Steve is reeling how Billy just… let him say he was his and not have any fight in him. He sure as hell doesn’t know what they are anymore.

“So what’s your answer?”

“Does Cavatina count?”

“Did I say guitars counted?”

“No.”
“That answers your questions.”

“You sound like my teachers.”

“Come on Stevie, answer my question.”

“Jesus, fine. Adagio for strings.”

“Good.”
“Now can you tell me what this is for?”

“I’m trying to prove to some fuckers that cool people actually listen to classical music.” Steve can tell by the way that Billy says “some fuckers” he’s talking about his teammates, most likely on the bus back from some game.

“Aw, you think I’m cool.”

“Don’t push it. I tried four other people before I settled on you.”

“I’m touched. Are you on the bus?”
“Yep.”

“Well you should probably get some sleep, I’m guessing you’ve got practice tomorrow?” Steve tries not to let the hopefulness in his voice creep through too much.

“Actually, no. Coach decided to stay with his family for the weekend so we have some time off. I can come over tomorrow night if you want.” In the background of Billy’s voice the sound of his teammates whooping and hollering is loud, and Steve hears Billy shushing them. Steve’s guessing they don’t know it’s him on the other end of the phone or else they would be having a different reaction.

Their call ends, and Steve decides he’s actually going to get some sleep. It has nothing to do with the fact that Billy told him to, no sir. He just got tired all of a sudden.

The next night Billy comes over with beer, and Steve has pizza ready. Of course, Billy comes over looking like a goddamn model. He’s wearing a jean jacket, covered in the back with vintage patches over a black t-shirt that Steve can’t imagine he got anywhere but an antique store, which is an image in itself. The top part of his hair is tied up in a bun, the bottom half curling around his face.
They don’t have a plan or anything, but Steve doubts anything is going to happen. They’ve… slowed down with the fucking are are suddenly more committed to getting to know each other.

“You wanna eat on my roof? I don’t really want my apartment to be smelling like pizza for hours.

“Sounds good”

They walk upstairs in silence. The air is warm against Steve’s face, and he takes a deep breath in against his racing heart. Odd how Billy makes his heart beat so quickly both when he’s there and when he isn’t.

Steve drops the pizza on one of the chairs, and Billy drops the beer next to it. They walk over to the rail, overlooking the campus from a distance. Billy leans one of his hips against the rail, facing Steve.

“There’s something I’ve been wanting to talk to you about.” These are the words that Steve had been dreading. The inevitable I’ve found someone better, someone less complicated, someone that won’t cause me my future.

“Okay, shoot.”

“Well, we’ve been doing this,” Billy mentions between them, “for a while. I just feel like…” He trails off, and Steve doesn’t know if he wants him to finish. He catches Billy’s eye, and gives him the most encouraging smile he can.

“If you feel different just let me know. I’m not looking for any pity. You’re a great person, and I don’t want us to loose any good thing we have, especially not if it proves a bunch of bastards wrong. What I’m trying to say is, despite my best efforts, you mean. a lot to me. I know we agreed at the beginning of this that we wouldn’t do this, and if that’s what you want then I can’t give that to you. I-“

“I want that too. I, God, I think I’ve wanted this for a while, and I was scared to tell you because I didn’t know if you-“

“Of course I do.”

Steve is useless to do anything but smile at Billy, blushing embarrassingly. Luckily Billy is just staring at Steve with a dopey smile on his face. A part of Steve is recognizing it as love-struck.

A sudden fear goes through Steve. Relationships mean spending the night, they mean knowing, truly knowing a person, possibly more than anyone’s ever known him. Best to get that over with now, right? That’s how these things are supposed to work, right?

“Now that we’re, uh, doing this thing you should probably know something.”

“Okay, go ahead.”

“Well I think you know I wasn’t that close to my parents. They weren’t very available for me, emotionally or physically. They don’t really have an excuse, they’re just shitty at being parents.

So, naturally, they weren’t supportive when they found out I was gay. I didn’t even tell them or anything, they just found out. Maybe they had some

sort of monitoring app or some shit, I don’t know. My mom stopped looking at me in the mornings, stopped meeting me in the eye.

My dad, well he’s a different story. He started pushing me out of the house, keeping me away from anyone that could ruin his position, like he was some big businessman in New York and not a mildly successful small town salesman.

During my senior year it got worse. He didn’t want me to be at school, didn’t want me to have any chance of not feeling alone. I wasn’t allowed to go anywhere, I wasn’t allowed to see people, and everyone just stopped remembering to ask if I was okay. He kept insulting me, pushing me away but keeping me in that fucking house, staring at the same walls, watching the same movies.”

Steve doesn’t really have anything else to say. There is not much else to it.

“Steve” Steve’s hands are fluttering at his side nervously, cautious of Billy’s tone. It’s not often that Billy calls Steve by his first name, generally preferring nicknames and insults, and it doesn’t sit well. “Steve, I’m so sorry that you’ve had to go through that. It’s fucked up that there are still people like him. It’s no surprise but my dad wasn’t so great about me coming out either. He… wasn’t a great person by any means, and probably an even worse father.” Billy’s tone hardens, his face turning impassive and stony. “He actually hated me. Couldn’t stand that his son was gay. Better to have no son at all in his eyes. He told me not to act out, to try and at least pretend not to be a freak. After that didn’t work he tried to beat it out of me.” Steve wishes to God Billy seemed like he was lying. The pain on his face is real though.

Steve feels his breathing pick up, and his eyes get that painful prickle at the back that means she’s trying to hold back tears. Rather unsuccessfully too.

Steve can’t breathe. The look on Billy’s face is breaking his heart, He doesn’t even seem upset. Somehow Steve is the one needing comfort through this. Billy walks over to him, wrapping an arm gently around his waist and cupping his face with a touch soft enough to make the tears fall from Steve’s lashes. He buries his face in Billy’s shoulder, trying to stifle sobs for the pain that Billy’s had to go through.

“Hey, pretty boy, it’s okay, I’m okay now. I’m here with you now, yeah? My strong boyfriend who isn’t going to let anyone but him talk shit like that about me.” Billy’s trying to deflect, trying to take care of Steve, but that’s not what Steve wants. Steve wants to see Billy, wants to take care of him, so he picks up his head and looks into beautiful blue eyes.

God, those eyes. Hiding so much from everyone else but open so Steve. Far more familiar to him than his own eyes, containing multitudes of lives being lived at once. Brother. Boyfriend, Baseball star. Life of the Party. Caretaker. Friend.

Steve wished he didn’t understand how anyone could hurt Billy. Wishes they lived in a world where they could just be them, or where they could walk down the street and not get whispers and looks.

Billy untangles himself from Steve’s arms, wiping away one of Steve’s tears. He reaches behind his head to yank off his shirt, revealing a crisscross of scars on Billy’s torso and back. Scars that, somehow in the months of digging his nails along lines, he had never cared enough to notice. Or, even worse, he had brushed off.

All the moonlight in the world couldn’t hide the scars crossing Billy’s back. Scars that Steve hadn’t cared enough to notice until now. Steve knows those are scars from baseball or any other sport Billy’s played. Those aren’t from the fights he used to get in, or the few ones he still gets in. No, those scars criss crossing his back are from one person, a repeated offense against his boyfriend.

“You’ve sat there and listened to me talk about my shitty dad when you had to go through this? Jesus, Billy, I thought my dad was an asshole.”

“He was.” Billy’s sentence is final, not leaving any room for Steve to respond, which is fair because Steve was definitely going to try to. “Just because my situation at home might of been worse than yours doesn’t mean that you’re wasn’t bad. There’s not enough time on earth for us to feel bad for each other’s past and say that the other had it worse.”

Steve does know what to say. He’s angry at himself for not knowing about this part of Billy’s life. When he finally does speak it comes out much weaker than he intended. “But he hurt you.”

Billy’s reply is just as soft. “Baby, people get hurt all the time. We’ve hurt each other, but that doesn’t mean I don’t love you.” Steve must make some sort of indignant noise because Billy shushes him softly. “I know it’s bad. I know that. I’m not going to try and say it doesn’t matter or that I don’t let it bother me, because it does and I have to live with that every single day. I’ve been through hell, but that makes my time with you so much better.”

His voice got incredibly softer. “Bambi, just because you can see my scars doesn’t mean they’re more painful than yours. Even if they are it doesn’t matter because we’re together now. You take care of me, I take care of you, that’s what this means.

Steve doesn’t know what any of this means. Apparently they're together now? Is this some sort of cruel trick of desire, the one person he’s told about this knows what it’s like?

Maybe his life’s sliding away into the hands of Billy. Maybe he can let him take care of him. Maybe he can have someone to trust, someone to help, someone to love.

No, he can’t go there, not tonight. This is just some consequential emotion from spilling his heart and reviving the numb honesty in return.

Steve doesn’t know what’s happening, but Billy’s hugging him close and he smells like the leather from his car and pizza. His hair is soft from where Steve’s face is tucked into it. His hand is warm and strong where it’s pressed against Steve’s back.

He can’t focus on being anything but Billy’s right now. Anything that makes him think too much seems like it’s going to make him cry, and he wants to avoid them as much as possible.

He’s Billy’s now. He has someone to lean on. Maybe it’s not so bad to fall in love

Notes:

I GOT IT OUT A DAY BEFORE it was going to be a month since i last updated yikessssss

they’re happy! they’re communicating!! maybe we’ll see some more of them in a next part ;)

Series this work belongs to: