Actions

Work Header

Upside Down Cupcakes

Chapter 12: Partners in wine

Notes:

I got two prompts from a-magey that didn't wind up fitting into one chapter, so I split them up! This one is "60; “I love you. Please don’t go” Thank you, Giddy! 😊"

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

~ ~

The tragic thing is, Jonathan can't even remember the name of the play they're watching. It's some… he wants to say it's some sort of a community theater thing, but that's not quite right. Nancy's friend from work wrote it and he's pretty sure community theater is a term you use for a community coming together to perform a real play, not… this. 

But then saying this isn't a real play is probably offensive to the people in the play and the person who wrote it. The people who are on the stage are clearly acting their hearts out. Clearly, the guy who wrote this tried his best, clearly, he put everything he had into it, but…

Even so, that doesn't stop it from being the worst thing Jonathan has ever been forced to sit through. The theater they're in (if you can even call it that) is small and dark and smells like feet. And not just normal sweaty feet, either. No, this place smells like the feet of someone who has something seriously wrong with them. Someone who needs a doctor and quick.  

The sets look like they were designed by a four-year-old and like said four-year-old's craft drawer was raided in order to construct them. The actors, even though they're all clearly trying their best, are acting like aliens that have never seen a human being before but that are trying to figure out how to imitate one anyway. Not that the stiff, brittle quality of almost every other line of dialogue is helping any.

In other words, Jonathan isn't much of a play person (he doesn't even know what you call fans of the theater, if they have a specific name for that or what) but even he knows that this play is garbage.

On stage this girl in a hideously patterned navy blue dress says,  “I love you. Please don’t go!" stretching the words out in the most awkward possible way, putting the emphasis in all the wrong places. It's awful. Still, it gets Jonathan thinking, gets him remembering this time in college, when he and Nancy had been separated for a semester for a photography internship he'd been taking in New York. It had been, aside from the time in high school where he'd had to watch her date Steve, the most miserable time in his life.

He'd been excited when he'd signed up for it, thrilled with the idea that he would be getting to work with some of his real-life heroes in one of the coolest cities in the world.

And that part, once he got there, had been great. But…

But he'd had no idea, going into it, how much he was going to miss Nancy or how hard it was going to be on their relationship, going from living together, sleeping in the same bed together, always being within arm's reach for at least part of every day to being hundreds of miles away and only being able to connect over the phone and over text and not as often as either of them would have liked, either.

It was awful, almost the worst things had ever been and their relationship almost hadn't survived it.

And there had been this one time, one of the few weekends she'd actually managed to come visit, where they'd gotten into this huge fight and he'd said basically the same thing to her. 

He'd been missing her every day, every minute it had felt like, sometimes, but she'd surprised him, she'd shown up without warning and he'd already had plans with his New York friends, plans he couldn't just bail on last minute. He'd asked her to come with him, but she'd refused, saying she'd come to see him, not his new friends, not his life without her in it. And this had started a fight. 

A fight that had ended when he'd said, "I love you, please don't leave." Because by this point she'd packed up her things and she'd almost done it, almost left and he remembers, almost like it's happening all over again, the way his heart had thudded in his chest, the way he'd worried that she wasn't just planning on bailing on the weekend, but bailing on the relationship, bailing on him.

But then she'd turned around and she'd stayed. She'd gone to the photography show with him and his friends and she'd gotten to know them and she'd realized (she'd told him later that this had been her concern) that he wasn't moving on without her. That he wasn't out there in New York, living this exciting new life and forgetting all about her and their tiny, little apartment, their quiet, dull little life in Chicago. 

He reaches out across the fuzzy red armrest of his chair and grabs her hand, interlinking their fingers and rubbing his thumb up and down across the back of her pale, slender hand. She doesn't look away from the stage (she seems to actually be enjoying this disaster of a play, though he isn't sure if that's because she's seeing something in it that he isn't or if she's just enjoying it for the trainwreck of it all) but she does smile this small, soft smile he hopes is to do with him. The way she squeezes his hand makes him think that it is. He hopes that it is.

Either way, he leans back in his seat and takes a breath, letting it fill him completely and letting it wash away all thoughts of that terrible weekend, of that terrible time in their lives. 

Because in the end, things worked out. Because they're alright, they're happy and there's nothing else in the world he's ever wanted more. No one has ever made him happier than she does and he knows that no one ever will.

Notes:

The cupcakes for this chapter are Moscato cupcakes. Here is a recipe for moscato cupcakes.