Chapter Text
The last time Jim Hopper had a cigarette, he had split it with Billy Hargrove in the Upside Down. Now he didn’t even know where Billy was, what the Russians were doing with him, if they were even in Russia, or if Billy was in the same facility as him.
Hopper closed his eyes as he laid on his threadbare mattress and thought of El and her oversized clothing and warm smile and love for Eggos. Flickers of Joyce Byers and her vibrant smile and warm hands and constant smoking ran through his head, and fuck did Hopper want a cigarette. Hopper thought of Billy Hargrove and how scared he was when he had found him in the Upside Down, alone and cowering and in need of an adult. Hopper remembered the first time he realized that Billy’s dad would beat the shit out of him on a daily basis, just as Hopper’s own father did to him. Hopper had turned around too quickly, and Billy had raised his arms across his face as if he expected to be hit. It had made Hopper’s stomach drop and head hurt. When Jim Hopper thought of Billy Hargrove, he knew he couldn’t wallow in memories. He had to think of a way out of this stupid Russian prison, if not for himself then for El, who deserved a father. For Joyce, who deserved a date. For Billy Hargrove, who deserved a childhood.
~~~
“Robin! Robin!” Steve hissed as the ding that signaled the store door opening rang throughout the air and a girl stepped inside. One with glossy lipstick and curly hair and dark nail polish. “Robin! Robin, Robin, Robin, Robin -”
“What, dingus?” Robin asked, rolling her eyes from where she was organizing videos behind their counter. “If you say my name one more time I swear to God I’ll get Byers to come back from California just to beat your face in again. I cannot believe that I’m here on Christmas Eve having to deal with your lack of brain cells.”
“Shut up for a minute, asshole, and look who just came into the store,” Steve huffed out, smirking slightly. As soon as Robin stood up and turned around to see Tammy fucking Thompson browsing movies, her face turned bright red before turning deathly pale.
“You’re friends with her, right?” Steve asked, wiggling his eyebrows.
“I mean, yeah,” Robin said, her voice a little shaky. Her eyes darted around the store, looking anywhere but at Steve or Tammy. “But, like, not the kind of friends who visit each other randomly at work.”
Steve shrugged, his grin a little sloppy. “Then what type of friends are you exactly?”
“I don’t know,” Robin said, her eyes narrowing, “the kind that help each other with homework and only do sleepovers after studying. The kind that talks about boys with each other.”
“Hmmmm,” Steve whispered, “and what boys do you talk about, Robin?”
“Not you, Harrington,” Robin muttered, turning red again, “that’s for damn sure.”
Tammy was walking toward the documentary section of the store and Steve nudged Robin’s arm, “No wonder you like her,” he whispered.
“What is that supposed to mean?” Robin asked, her eyes narrowing again.
“She’s smart and shit,” Steve said. “Why the hell else would she be watching documentaries on Christmas Eve?”
“Shut up, Steve,” Robin whispered, turning red. Steve grinned at her blush. “Tammy!” Robin said loudly, before Steve could say anything else, “are you looking for anything in particular?”
“No, not really,” Tammy said, but her smile was bright. “You didn’t tell me you got a new job, Robs.”
“Sorry,” Robin said cheekily. “Didn’t think it was that important.”
“Of course it’s important,” Tammy said, her eyes wide. “Now come help me find a movie.”
“Yeah, yeah, sure,” Robin said and she flung herself over the counter, easily gliding to the other side, landing on her feet perfectly.
“You’re so cool, Robin,” Tammy said, her tone of voice teasing, her smile feral, her eyes mocking.
“Shut up, Tammy,” Robin said. But Steve knew Robin and he knew that she wasn’t actually annoyed.
“Haven’t you heard that the customer is always right?” Tammy asked, cocking her head slightly toward the right.
Robin sighed and let Tammy lead her toward the type of movie that she wanted to rent. Steve observed them for a moment longer before he continued organizing the stack of videos Robin was sorting through when Tammy came in. For a girl who had a crush on Steve Harrington, Tammy Thompson sure did flirt with Robin Buckley a lot.
~~~
“They’re here!” Max exclaimed as she looked out of the Wheeler’s living room window as the Byers’ car sped into the driveway. “Lucas! Dustin! Suzie! Mike! They’re here!” The boys and Suzie came running into the room and Mike continued running until he was outside, the snow falling into his hair and onto his clothes. Max, Lucas, Dustin, and Suzie followed him outside, eagerly waiting for the Byers to come out of their car. Nancy came out a few minutes later, a winter coat tugged tightly around her body, and she quickly found her place slotted in between Jonathan’s arms, her head tucked under his chin, Jonathan’s back pressed against his car door.
El wandered her way out of the car, allowing her polaroid camera to tap against her chest as she ran toward Max, hugging her tightly, “I missed you, Max.” She said simply, a small, shy smile gracing her face. Meanwhile, Will was exchanging greetings with Dustin, Lucas, and Mike. It looked as though Dustin was introducing him to Suzie, and Joyce stood near the car, staring at the sky, letting the snow fill her hair and dust her shoulders.
“I missed you too,” Max said seriously, leaning away a bit. They looked at each other before they burst out in laughter. El took a step away from Max and took a picture of her. Max looked at El with a question in her eyes.
“Jonathan taught me how to take good pictures,” El said. “I have been scrapbooking lately.”
“That’s really cool,” Max said. El looked up at the sky, watching the snowflakes fall around them. “Snow,” El said. “I missed the snow.”
“Good,” Max said, laughing, “the snow missed you too!”
El’s eyebrows knitted in confusion before she pressed a gentle kiss to Max’s cheek and then ran away to hug Mike, leaving Max to stare after her, holding the place where El had kissed her gently with her fingertips. Her eyes met Will’s, who was currently hugging Dustin and Lucas. She felt a blush creep up onto her face and looked away. Will’s eyes were too knowing, after all.
Max walked so that she was closer to Lucas, Dustin, and Will, and grabbing Suzie’s hand, she tapped El’s shoulder though El was still in Mike’s embrace.
“El,” Max said as soon as she turned away from Mike, “this is Suzie, our newest party member.”
Suzie gave El a little wave before extending her right hand. El took her right hand in hers and shook it. “You are… Dustin’s girlfriend?” El asked.
“Yes,” Suzie said, her voice full of enthusiasm. “It’s so nice to finally meet you!”
“He is your… ‘Dusty Bun’?” El asked, barely containing her giggles.
“Yes!” Suzie exclaimed, much to Dustin’s horror and El’s amusement.
“Let me take a picture of you and your Dusty-Bun!” El said, grabbing her camera to her face again. Suzie laughed along with El, and she and Dustin posed for a picture. Once El was done taking their photo, she leaned forward and tapped Dustin’s teeth with her fingers, “You have more teeth!”
“You like them?” Dustin asked. He purred at El, and she gave Suzie an exasperated look. As El laughed with Suzie and Dustin, Max and Mike shared a look. Tension passed between them before Mike was being pulled into a tight hug from Will, and their eye contact broke.
~~~
“So,” Steve said once his and Robin’s shift was finally over. They were climbing into his car, “You and Tammy, huh?”
“Dingus, what are you going on about?” Robin asked, but her face was turning pink again as she buckled her seatbelt.
“You know, I’m not great with the whole, uh, well, gay thing, I guess,” Steve said, suddenly awkward, “but I can tell you for damn sure that Tammy Thompson is not agonizing over my stupid hair anymore.”
“Whatever, Harrington,” Robin said. “You might not be a boy that I talked about, but you were a boy that she talked about, that’s for sure.”
“So?” Steve said, shrugging. Suddenly, he was feeling very nervous. “Can’t she find both attractive?”
“Find both what attractive, Steve?” Robin asked.
“Both boys and girls, Robin,” Steve said as if it were obvious, as if his heart wasn’t leaping out of his chest as he awaited Robin’s response.
“Steve,” Robin said, her voice suddenly serious. “What are you talking about?”
“Maybe Tammy finds girls attractive. I’m not exactly the definition of masculinity, with my doe eyes and long hair. Plus, I have been known to be pretty,” Steve said, thinking of Billy Hargrove again (he couldn’t seem to get that asshole out of his mind lately) “you know, like a girl. Plus, she talked about me, past tense.”
Robin started laughing, “Steve, you are not a girl, I can tell you that right now.”
“I know that,” Steve said, rolling his eyes as he backed out of his parking space and started driving toward the Wheeler’s house. “I know that I’m a man. All I'm saying is that it’s possible to like both.”
“I know,” Robin said. “I’m just not sure if Tammy does.” She cocked her head at Steve before asking, “Do you?”
“Do I what?” Steve said, hoping that he’d come off as if he were being as oblivious as he usually was.
“Don’t make me spell it out for you, dingus,” Robin said, her voice soft. “You know what I’m asking.”
Steve took a deep breath. He thought of Tommy H. How in middle school, Tommy made Steve feel the same way Nancy used to make him feel senior year, how Robin used to make him feel earlier that year. Images of Billy Hargrove flitted across his mind and he swallowed loudly. He thought of when Robin first told him that she was into Tammy Thompson, thought of when he told her he was “thinking” and how he was so confused. Not because she was lesbian, but because he always thought it was normal to have crushes on both boys and girls. Something normal, but unspoken. It didn’t really occur to him that it was unusual, weird, abnormal, until Robin made it clear that she’d only have crushes on girls. Not boys. Just girls.
“Did you OD over there?” Robin asked quietly.
Steve cracked a small smile, “No. Just thinking.”
“Okay,” Robin said, tugging on her ear. “You know, it’s okay if you do. It’s not weird or anything.” Steve nodded in response, not knowing how to express to her how he was feeling in words. It made Steve feel overwhelmed, how Robin could just tell what he was thinking just by being around him.
“I’ve just been thinking about…” Steve’s voice trailed off and he shook his head. “Nevermind, it’s stupid.”
“I guarantee you it’s not,” Robin said, her voice gentle.
Steve veered his car off of the road and parked it. He turned toward Robin, his eyes wide and his face twisted into an awful smile. “No, it’s dumb. It’s just, you know how Max asked me to help fix Billy’s camaro with her yesterday?”
“Yeah,” Robin said, and though she was really good at piecing things together, she honestly had no idea what Steve was about to say.
“I can’t stop thinking about Billy Hargrove,” Steve said, his voice quiet.
“Oh,” Robin said, knowing that she had to be tactful, “I didn’t know you guys were,” her voice became soft, “ friends .”
“We weren’t,” Steve said, closing his eyes harshly. “We weren’t friends. He didn’t even… we weren’t even… we didn’t… I-I-I-” He banged his head against his arms, which were resting on his steering wheel.
“Steve,” Robin said, putting a soothing hand on his shoulder, “It’s okay. I promise, whatever it is, it’s okay.”
Steve felt like crying. Before he knew it, words were tumbling out of his mouth and spilling into the air. He was telling Robin about the Halloween party, how Billy Hargrove had sought him out, shirtless and wet and drunk, and bragged about how he beat Steve’s keg drinking record. Then, he was talking about basketball and planting his feet and the locker room showers, how Billy was naked and wet when he called him “pretty boy”. He told her about how he was an asshole to Max, how he tried to attack Lucas solely because Lucas had a crush on Max, how Steve had told Billy not to cream his pants. He told her how Billy slammed a plate over his head and punched his face in until he was bruised and bloody and unconscious. He was crying by the end of it.
“Steve.” Robin whispered, “Steve, what can I do to help?”
“I don’t know, Robin,” Steve whispered back. “I can’t stop thinking about him and his stupid fucking tongue that hung out of his mouth and how his mullet filled out this year and how fucking angry he was. It prickled off of him, Robin. That fucking anger. And, fuck, Robin. I haven’t felt like this since Hopper-” Steve couldn’t help the strangled, downright pathetic sound that welled in his throat.
“Steve,” Robin said softly. She pulled him into an awkward hug over the center console of his car. She whispered into his hair, “I didn’t know you had the hots for Hopper.”
Steve let out a strangled laugh, “Well, he is pretty attractive for an old man. Who can blame me?” He paused when Robin gave him a shocked look. “I did not actually have the hots for Hopper, Robin. What the hell?” Steve said. “You know I used to babysit for El. I just, um, well, he was nice to me, treated me like I wasn’t dumb. He’d complain about Mike Wheeler with me and talk to me about one day going to the academy, so I could become a police officer. He knew my parents are never around so he offered to let me stay with him during Christmas. I honestly thought he would have pulled through and saved our asses back in the Russian lab.”
“Oh,” Robin said. She knew that Steve had nightmares about Hopper, but she hadn’t known that Steve felt that Hopper was a better father to him than his own.
“He didn’t save us,” Steve said, clamping his eyes shut. “Dustin did.”
“He would have,” Robin said, “if he knew.”
“If you say so,” Steve said, shrugging helplessly, his shoulders hitting Robin’s collar bones.
“I do say so,” Robin said. She ran a hand through Steve’s hair and instead of swatting her away, Steve sank into Robin’s warmth. “So you’ve been thinking about Hargrove since you fixed his camaro with Max?”
“Yeah,” Steve laughed even though he was still crying, “and it fucking sucks.”
Robin wiped a tear from Steve’s cheeks and licked her finger. He looked at her like she was crazy and they both started laughing. “They’re salty!” Robin said in between giggles.
“I wish he was still alive,” Steve said quietly once they had calmed down. “Then Max would smile and I could punch him in the face.”
“You want to punch him?” Robin asked after a long silence.
Steve thought for a moment. “Yeah,” Steve said, his voice distant. “I want to fucking punch him.”
“Is that like a euphemism for something that I’m not aware of?” Robin asked, her voice teasing but there was a trace of very real confusion that was in it.
“No,” Steve huffed out, running a hand through his hair. “Well,” Steve said, his voice trailing off, “maybe.”
“Do you wanna hold off going to the Wheeler’s house?” Robin asked. “We can meet up with Will and Jonathan and the rest of the shitbirds later. We could eat something, visit Billy, then go.”
“Visit Billy?” Steve asked, his voice weak.
Robin nodded solemnly. “Yeah, visit Billy. He has a grave, doesn’t he?”
“Yeah,” Steve said, nodding his head. “Yeah, he does. Should we bring him something?”
“I dunno,” Robin shrugged. “Do you have something in mind?”
“He wore a dangly earring,” Steve whispered. “On the left ear. His dad, Neil, refused to bury him with his stupid fucking earring.”
“Earring it is then,” Robin said and Steve nodded in agreement.
Steve merged into the street, which was easy since only two other cars were out, and together they headed to Hawkins’ only consignment shop.
~~~
“Okay,” Mike said, “Tell us everything about California. What’s the school like? Do people like you? Are you popular?”
Dustin rolled his eyes and pressed a kiss to Suzie’s forehead, Lucas scoffed, and Max nearly started laughing. El and Will were both a lot of things, but popular was not one of them.
“I have acquaintances,” El said. She was leaning on Mike’s side and her knees were knocking against Will’s. “Will is my best friend,” she announced and Will turned bright red.
“Yeah,” Will said, “it’s a really small town so everyone already has a friend group. It’s pretty much just El and I against the world.”
“Me and Will against the world,” El confirmed. “It’s hot there too.”
“Yeah,” Will agreed, “it’s super hot. It never snows there. It feels like it’s constantly summer, even if we’re in school.”
“Sweaty,” El said, holding onto the camera strap around her neck and Will nodded in agreement. El poked Will’s cheek and they started laughing together. The rest of the party exchanged looks.
“Do you guys have to share a room?” Max asked. She used to live in California so her curiosity was not about the state itself.
“No,” El said. “I have my own room. Small.”
“Tell us how everything here is,” Will said. “How’s Mr. Clark doing? What’s up with the AV club?” And with those questions, the rest of the party save Suzie started shouting about the newest radio tower Mr. Clark finagled for them, talking over one another as they argued over the new arcade games, then screaming about Mr. Clarke’s engagement.
~~~
Joyce was sitting with Karen and Ted in the living room, watching Holly read some of Mike’s old comic books. It was awkward. The silence was almost deafening. Ted was laying across the old sofa while Karen and Joyce sipped red wine and tried talking to one another.
“So,” Joyce said, “I just wanted to thank you for having all of us over for Christmas. I mean, you really didn’t have to let us stay in your extra rooms and all. It’s really kind of you.”
“It’s really no problem, Joyce,” Karen said, her smile kind, “it’s what friends are for. Plus, it makes Mike and Nancy so happy to have Will, Jane, and Jonathan over. They miss their friends so much.”
It was jarring for Joyce to hear El referred to as “Jane” but she smiled and nodded anyway. It was painful for Joyce to be in Hawkins again. She closed her eyes and tried not to think about how much Hawkins reminded her of Bob, of Hopper. For a fleeting moment she thought of calling Murray, of visiting Murray, but she swallowed harshly and the moment was over. “Well, we’re so grateful for your hospitality.”
“Of course,” Karen said, patting Joyce’s knee. “Would you mind helping me with dinner? I think Steve and Robin will be coming over tonight, too. Lots of cooking to do!” she finished with a slight laugh.
“Yeah, of course,” Joyce said and followed Karen into the kitchen. Karen’s normalcy, her red wine and warm house and lovely daughter, made Joyce start to feel a little better about being back in Hawkins, Indiana.
~~~
“I -” kiss “-missed-” kiss “-you-” kiss “-so-” kiss “-much-” Nancy whispered out. Jonathan was on her bed, Nancy sitting on his lap, enjoying how much her lipstick stained his face.
“God, Nance,” Jonathan breathed out, “Fuck, I missed you too.”
Nancy laughed, “I know. You call me every minute.”
“It’s not enough,” Jonathan said. “It’s never enough. Not like how it’ll be next year, when we’re in college together.”
Nancy nodded, “NYU won’t know what hit them when we arrive.”
Jonathan pressed a kiss to Nancy’s forehead before saying, “I love you.”
“I know,” Nancy whispered. “I love you too.” There was a sparkle behind Nancy’s eyes. She leaned in very close to Jonathan’s right ear, bit it lightly before whispering, “I have a very special Christmas gift for you this year.”
Jonathan groaned, “Shit, Nance. Shit .”
Nancy laughed, the noise loud and beautiful and sweet. “Yeah,” she said, smiling deviously. “Shit is correct.” Jonathan pulled her close and kissed her soundly on the lips. Nancy Wheeler never felt happier.
~~~
“Mr. Clarke’s engaged ?” Will asked, his voice incredulous.
“Yeah,” Dustin said, nodding. “Engaged. He’s probably gonna have a herd of kids and will have to stop overseeing the AV Club.”
“Don’t say that!” Lucas said, slugging Dustin’s arm. “He wouldn’t leave us like that.”
“Uh, yeah, he would,” Dustin said. “Especially for a super hot wife!”
“Dustin!” Suzie and Max said at the same time, and Dustin flashed them a sheepish grin.
“He got engaged a few weeks ago,” Mike said, and Will and El followed along to his every word. “She’s pretty cool, from what he told us. She listens to him talk about science stuff, watches nerd movies with him, and can keep up with his mathematical skills.”
“That’s good,” El said. Max nodded in response.
“See, Lucas,” Suzie said, flashing him a toothy grin, “I’m not the only perfect girl that exists.”
Lucas slugged Dustin yet again, “Dude, I cannot believe that you told her that!”
“Of course I did,” Dustin said, “I tell her everything.”
“It’s true,” Suzie said. “Don’t worry, though. The next time you guys go off to save the world, there won’t be a musical number.”
“Thank god,” Will said. “That was horrible.”
Suzie and Dustin started laughing while Lucas and Max protested Will’s statement.
“Horrible?” Max asked incredulously. “More like comedic gold.”
“Exactly,” Lucas agreed with Max, “it’s still something we can make fun of today. It never gets old.”
“Exactly,” Max said. “ Exactly .”
Mike shook his fondly at his friends and El pressed a kiss to his cheek. Will sighed for a minute, wishing for a fleeting second that he could kiss Mike’s cheek before wanting the ground to swallow him whole.
“It was terrible,” Will said, forcing a smile, “And you can quote me on that.”
Suzie laughed, “Okay, okay. Dusty Bun and I will keep our musical numbers to a minimum.”
“Please don’t,” Max and Lucas begged her while Will thanked her.
“I’m afraid we’ll have to,” Dustin said solemnly, “my voice is for Suzie’s ears alone.”
“Ugh, Dustin,” Will said. “Stop being so sappy and gross.”
“Will, I’m a changed man,” Dustin said, “I’m sappy and in love now.”
El and Will exchanged a look before they each rolled their eyes at Dustin’s statement. Dustin, Lucas, Max, and Suzie continued their argument about Dustin and Suzie’s duet when Mike tugged on Will’s sweatshirt sleeve.
“You okay, Will?” Mike asked, his nose scrunched in concern, his eyes boring into Will’s.
“I’m fine,” Will said, even though he knew his voice sounded tight.
“You sure?” Mike asked and Will nodded, fully aware that El was watching them with those wide eyes of hers.
“I’m sure,” Will said, nodding slightly.
“Okay,” Mike said. His concern morphed into a sloppy smile, “I can’t wait for you to see the surprise we’ve been working on for you.”
“I’m excited,” Will said, telling the truth for once.
“Good,” Mike said, still smiling. “Good.”
~~~
Steve and Robin were freezing in Hawkins Cemetery as they placed a silver, dangly, arrow-shaped earring next to a couple wilting bouquets on Billy’s grave.
“Who else visits him?” Robin asked. Her eyes widened and she slapped her hands over her mouth. “Shit, that was so rude.”
“No, it’s okay,” Steve said. “Nancy takes Max here most Saturdays and some holidays. She might take her here today. Probably not though,” Steve sighed, “since the Byers are back. Nancy might be a little occupied.”
“You’re not over her, are you?” Robin said. It was a question, but they both knew it was at least a little bit true.
Steve shrugged, “It’s whatever, I guess,” Steve said. “It’s all just bullshit anyway.” Bullshit. No, you. You’re bullshit. “Anyway, those flowers are what Max brings to him every week.”
“Why don’t you go with her?” Robin asked.
“It’s something she and Nancy have to do together,” Steve said. “They also visit Barb, I believe, and Jonathan used to go with them. But he moved.” Steve ran a hand through his hair.
“Oh,” Robin said softly.
“Yeah,” Steve said.
“Do you have something you wanna say to him?” Robin asked, nodding toward Billy’s grave. Steve shrugged again.
“Uhhhh, you were a prick, and I wish you would’ve put your tongue back in your mouth when you were alive and I can’t fucking stand you, but I forgive you for punching my pretty face in,” Steve was rambling and he knew it, but he also couldn’t stop, “I just wish you were here so I could punch you. Also, you were pretty good at basketball, but don’t let that get to your head, wherever you are. Anyway, uh, rest in peace, I guess?”
“Eloquently put,” Robin said, sending Steve a secret smirk.
“Thank you,” Steve said, his breathing was a little bit easier and he felt as though a huge weight had been lifted from his chest. “For everything.”
Robin patted Steve’s shoulder. She kissed his cheek. “Of course.”
“You’re a good best friend,” Steve said.
“I know, dingus,” Robin said, her voice triumphant.
“Don’t let that get to your head though, shitbird.”
“I won’t,” Robin said, but she was smiling widely. “Promise.”
Steve knocked his arm against hers. She smiled at him.
“Anyone else you need to visit?” Robin asked.
“I don’t think I can handle seeing Hopper, so no,” Steve said. “You?”
“Nope,” Robin said, shaking her head.
“I hope he has a good Christmas,” Steve said, “wherever he is.”
“I’m sure he will,” Robin said, motioning to the earring that they left for him. She took Steve’s hand in hers, and together, they walked through the snow and back to Steve’s car.
~~~
Hopper was running on adrenaline and adrenaline only. He had just broken out of his cell, killing the Russian guard who gave him meals with a fork to the eye, stole the guard’s credentials and was sneaking around the prison, trying to map out an exit once he found where the hell they were keeping Billy Hargrove. Jim Hopper was not leaving prison without Billy Hargrove first. He knew it was stupid, knew that he was risking his own life the longer he stayed in the prison, but he didn’t care if he was discovered. He would be damned if he left without saving Billy first.
He rounded a corner and used his new credentials to open a set of wide, steel doors. The corridor in front of him had two rooms to the left and a stairwell to the right. He made a split second decision to enter one of the rooms before heading down the stairs. Hopper turned around, and, making sure that he wasn’t being followed, he entered the first door on the left, thanking Christ that this corridor wasn’t being recorded by any cameras. He was met by a filing cabinet with only two drawers. The first was labeled “Prasad”. The second was labeled “Byers”.
“Shit,” Hopper said out loud. “Fucking shit.”
