Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

A little coffee with your sugar?

Summary:

“How about some coffee in your sugar?” Billy asked in a deadpan voice.

He didn’t mean to be rude. Billy was a ‘live and let live’ kind of guy, and he was more amused than offended by Pretty boy’s tastes, even if the mere thought of drinking such a concoction was enough to nauseate him. However, he couldn’t help that his tone was curt when he addressed him. First, Billy had to interact with the customers without having had time to mentally prepare for it beforehand, and second, he was out of sorts because of how hot the guy was. The truth was that, if Billy could usually charm the pants off of anyone, he was absolutely useless when it came to men he really did find attractive. Life was a bitch, sometimes.

Notes:

Hey folks! I'm new to the fandom (I'm super late to the party, I know), and I'm really excited! This is my first coffee shop AU (which is very surprising considering my love of AUs ah ah).

I hope you'll enjoy :)

Chapter 1: This shit is bananas

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

As the only baker of the Upside-Down Café, Billy usually kept to the kitchen. And he liked it that way. So, when Heather barged into his sanctuary, interrupting him in the process of frosting a three-layer chocolate cake to let him know she was leaving and he had to replace her behind the counter, Billy was not happy.

“Why in the world are you leaving this early?”

She always stayed until closing.

“Are you serious? I told you last week I have a dentist appointment. You said you’d be okay.”

Had he really said that? Well, that had been a big mistake.

The thing was, he had not been listening properly when Heather had told him about her appointment. He had been in the middle of decorating a batch of sugar cookies with rainbow icing (because he was gay and did what he wanted), which was the kind of delicate work he had to focus extra hard on. He had trouble controlling his strength, sometimes, and that could lead to accidents. So, when he’d registered Heather had finished talking and was waiting for a reply, he had nodded and said “okay” without knowing what he was agreeing to. He could have asked her to repeat, but it got on her nerves when he did that. According to her, he was doing it a bit too often. It wasn’t his fault she always tried to make conversation when he had to focus on a complicated task. Come to think of it, maybe she was doing that on purpose to get whatever she wanted from him. Billy wouldn’t put it past her: she was devious enough to come up with such a tactic.

“Okay… well, see you tomorrow then.” He tried to act cool and unaffected, but his dread was hard to hide.

“Oh, don’t be a drama queen. You’ll survive. Have a wonderful afternoon serving our dear customers!”

Billy groaned. She was really laying it on thick.

“I wish you have cavities.” He said meanly.

Heather laughed, showing perfect white teeth that could have starred in a toothpaste commercial. The audacity! Why was she even going to the dentist?

Billy took his time finishing the frosting after Heather’s departure. Tuesday afternoons were slow, anyway. He had to put the last touch in a hurry, though, because the bell above the front door chimed, indicating the arrival of a customer.

Billy exited the kitchen with the cake, so he could put it on display before taking the customer’s order. He had to multitask now that Heather had mercilessly abandoned him. Traitor.

“Hi, welcome to the Upside-Down Café, what can I do for you?” He asked dispassionately, not even looking at the person on the other side on the counter.

He could lay on the charm as well as the next guy, but at the moment his whole attention was on the triple layer cake he was trying to squeeze between the apple pie and the cinnamon rolls displayed behind the glass case.

“Well I do feel properly welcomed, Hargrove. You might even want to tone the enthusiasm down a bit. Wouldn’t want you to come off as overeager.”

The sarcasm was nearly palpable. It didn’t surprise Billy, considering who was speaking.

“Buckley, fancy seeing you here.”

She rolled her eyes. It was her default move when she was around Billy. It was all for show, though. he knew she liked him, deep down.

“Heather’s not here?”

“No. Dentist appointment.”

“Oh. She didn’t tell me.” Robin pouted like a five-year old.

Ah! She wasn’t so smug anymore.

Billy would have been amused at Robin’s reaction, but the fact she hadn’t known about Heather’s appointment mainly made him suspicious. She claimed she had told Billy about the appointment the week before, but she hadn’t told her friend, whom she had a big fat crush on? Billy wasn’t buying it. Of course, telling her coworker, who’d have to cover for her, seemed more important than telling her crush she wouldn’t be seeing her, but Billy knew better. Heather was so head-over-heels for Robin it wasn’t even funny anymore. If she didn’t do something about it soon, Billy would go nuts. She was always yapping about Robin, and she was so distracted in her presence that she had once dropped a plate of cupcakes Billy had just worked his ass off to finish before the Saturday afternoon rush. She was a menace.

“Would you like to order something anyway, or?” He asked Robin.

“Yeah, sure, I’m actually waiting for a friend. I’ll take a piece of apple pie and an Earl Grey tea, please.”

Billy had already had an inkling of what she was going to order, because Heather had raved to him about Robin’s favorite food and drinks several times before, but he chose not to disclose that piece of information. He was a good friend like that.

“Coming right up.”

While he was cutting the pie, the bell chimed again.

“Oh, here’s my friend. Hey dingus!”

Billy looked up briefly and did a double take. He had to make a conscious effort to not let his jaw hang open. The man who had just come in was gorgeous, and exactly Billy’s type. He looked so pretty in his preppy knitted sweater, it nearly gave Billy heartburn.

Billy had come out of the kitchen with his dirty apron still on, and he was almost certain there was some chocolate frosting on his left cheekbone. He could feel it itching. He was cursed.

“Hey Rob.” Pretty boy hugged Robin and then turned to Billy.

His warm brown eyes widened, making him resemble a deer caught in the headlights. Billy only then realized he’d been staring at him intensely. You know, like a fucking creep.

Billy looked away and cleared his throat.

“What can I get you?” His voice sounded strained, but it would have to do.

“Er… A Mocha and a piece of chocolate cake, please.”

“Sure thing.”

Billy prepared the order, keeping his gaze fixed on the task at hand. He couldn’t look at Pretty boy, lest he make a bigger fool of himself.

He rang Robin and her friend up, and only then could he bring himself to look up… which ended up being a mistake, considering he had to watch, horrified, as Pretty boy poured a shit ton of sugar in his mocha.

“How about some coffee in your sugar?” Billy asked in a deadpan voice.

He didn’t mean to be rude. Billy was a ‘live and let live’ kind of guy, and he was more amused than offended by Pretty boy’s tastes, even if the mere thought of drinking such a concoction was enough to nauseate him. However, he couldn’t help that his tone was curt when he addressed him. First, Billy had to interact with the customers without having had time to mentally prepare for it beforehand (yes Heather had supposedly given him a whole week to ready himself, but he hadn’t quite caught her warning so it hadn’t been of much use), and second, he was out of sorts because of how hot the guy was. The truth was that, if Billy could usually charm the pants off of anyone, he was absolutely useless when it came to men he really did find attractive. Life was a bitch, sometimes.

“Wh-what?” Pretty boy stammered.

“You’re aware mochas have a fair amount of sugar already blended in them, right?”

Billy feared he’d get diabetes just from watching Pretty boy drink this monstrous beverage. It was basically caffeinated sugar at this point.

“Yeah, and what about it?” He replied, his words sounding like a challenge, before he took a sip and then licked off the whipped cream stuck on his upper lip (‘kill me right now, why don’t you?’ Billy thought).

“Nothing. It’s just… diabetes is a serious issue and healthcare isn’t cheap in this country.”
Billy’s conversation skills had unsurprisingly flown out the window, but it was a new low. Here he was, spewing ominous bullshit and stating political facts. What next? A debate? What the fuck.

“I’m very healthy, thank you very much.”

Billy thankfully restrained from replying “for now”. Pretty boy was scowling a bit, nonetheless. Billy’s chances with him had most probably flown out the window too, right along his aforementioned skills.

Pretty boy took the tray with his and Robin’s order on it and went to one of the tables near the windows, pretty close to the register.

Robin stayed behind and stared at Billy with an arched eyebrow, making him squirm.

“Was there something else you wanted, Buckley?” He asked, just so she’d snap out of it.

“No. I’m all set. Thanks.” She narrowed her eyes before turning away from Billy and joining Pretty boy at the table he had picked.

Billy then proceeded to stalk Pretty boy. He could have gone back to the kitchen, since there was no other customer, but he would have to pass up staring at such beauty, and that wouldn’t do (especially since it was the first and probably last time he got to stare at it). So, he pretended to busy himself with wiping the already immaculate counter clean, like a neat freak, while he threw glances at him.

Pretty boy still looked slightly worked up, somehow managing to make everything he did look aggressive, be it taking a sip of his mocha, putting his cup down, or stabbing the poor piece of chocolate cake with his fork.

Before he could start eating, though, Robin held his hand back. Billy then heard her advise him to cleanse his palate with a sip of her tea so the overly sugary taste of the mocha wouldn’t make the cake taste like nothing in comparison. And bless her for that piece of advice because, after Pretty boy had done as he had been told, when he finally put the first bite in his mouth, his reaction was priceless. His scowl disappeared from his face, his beautiful eyes widened again and he outright moaned.

The sound did things to Billy, and he had to bite his lower lip so he wouldn’t make a noise of his own. That would have been embarrassing, and Billy had embarrassed himself enough with his ineptitude at making conversation like a functional member of society.

When they left, Robin threw a “See ya, Hargrove” above her shoulder, and Pretty boy didn’t say anything, preferring to glare at him. He was still mad, then. Billy pouted. As soon as the door had closed behind them, he fetched a chocolate chip cookie from the display case and took a huge bite out of it. It tasted good (duh, he had baked it), but it didn’t magically dissipate his disappointment as he had hoped it would.

This day really sucked, uh?

*

The next day, Heather came to work in an overly chipper mood, unlike Billy.

“Damn, what crawled up your ass and died?”

Billy growled “nothing” while tying his apron.

“Why the long face, then?”

“I don’t see what you mean.” He mumbled, before changing the subject. “Why are you so cheerful, yourself?”

“I got tickets for this band Robin likes! They weren’t available on the band’s website, so I had to wait in line yesterday to buy them. I’m gonna ask her on a date to their concert the second she passes this door.” Heather said, gesturing to the café’s entrance.

“So, there wasn’t any dentist appointment! I knew it!”

“Yeah, sorry I lied. I didn’t want you to mention it by mistake when Robin was there, so I came up with the appointment thing. I shouldn’t have bothered, though, since you weren’t listening to me anyway. But whatever.”

So, that explained why Robin hadn’t known Heather wouldn’t come to work, even though they were texting almost constantly.

Billy was glad Heather would finally get it together and ask Robin out after months of pining. He was also jealous that she had more game than he did, but he chose to ignore that part.

“Robin will be over the moon, I’m sure. She was here yesterday. Asked for you.” Billy informed, as he was taking the ingredients out for a millionaire shortbread.

“I know, she called me in the evening to ask me how it went at the dentist’s. I felt bad about lying to her, but it was for the greater good.”

“Mmh.”

“What was that with Steve, by the way?”

Billy briefly wondered if he had missed part of the conversation again.

“Who the hell is Steve?”

“Robin’s friend? The one that was here with her yesterday.”

Oh, so Pretty boy’s name was Steve.

“Right. Steve. What about him?”

“Well, you tell me. Robin said you were acting rude, and now Steve thinks you hate him. Steve is a sweetheart, you can’t hate him. Plus, it’ll make him all sad and miserable, and then Robin will be in a bad mood because of it. So, behave!”

“Okay, so I wasn’t the nicest. I was pissed off that you had abandoned me. But I don’t hate Steve. That’s a gross overstatement. I don’t even know him.” Also, Billy thought Steve was the prettiest thing he had ever seen and was pretty certain he had a crush on him, but he certainly didn’t say THAT to Heather. He would never hear the end of it.

“Yeah well, be nicer next time he comes by. Or stay in your kitchen like the goblin you are.”

“Sure, whatever. Don’t you have some work to do?” Billy asked so she would lay off his case.

When she had finally left the kitchen, Billy thought about Steve, as he had been doing non-stop since he had met him the day before. He couldn’t believe he had already ruined everything. They had said like… four words to each other and now Steve thought Billy hated him. How had he fucked up that quickly? That must have been a record.

He groaned and poured the flour in the mixing bowl with such aggravation that he spilt about a third of it on the table. He was useless!

Billy kept dropping ingredients and kitchen tools all over the place, and bumping into everything, until Heather interrupted the disaster that was his day, asking him to manage the counter while she talked to Robin.

When he exited his cave, he was surprised to see that Steve had come with Robin again and was the next customer in line.

Billy was silently trying to come up with an apology. It couldn’t be that hard. He’d say: “Pretty Boy…” no, “Steve”… no, he wasn’t supposed to know his name… Er… “Man”. Right, Billy would say. “Man, I’m sorry about yesterday, I was in a bad mood.” And that would be all. Easy.

Billy reached the counter and opened his mouth to apology, but Steve didn’t let him.

“Hi. I’ll take a snickerdoodle and hot chocolate with extra whipped cream and marshmallows, please and thank you.” He was staring right into Billy’s eyes when he gave his order. His own brown eyes were glinting. His left hip was cocked and his arms were crossed over his chest, his fingers tapping rhythmically on his arms.

Oh, so that was how Pretty boy was going to play it.

“No problemo.” Billy nearly cringed at how lame he was. Why was he saying stuff like that? It wasn’t even correct Spanish. He was nearly fluent in the language, so he knew that perfectly well. He sounded like a lame dad, which was not really the vibe he was going for.

Once he got his order, Steve proceeded to pour an insane amount of sugar in his hot chocolate. Billy was not surprised, but still disgusted. This was indecent.

Billy took care of the next customer, and the one after that, and the one after that. He was starting to wonder what was taking Heather so long with Robin. She was keeping her from Pretty boy, who was all alone at their table. The poor thing.

When there was a lull, Billy went to the break room and found Heather and Robin making out. Of course, they were. Billy rolled his eyes but didn’t interrupt them, choosing instead to go back to the counter. Let it not be said that he was a bad friend, after that.

Steve had chosen the same table as the day before, and was facing Billy, just as he had then. At first, he wasn’t touching his drink or food, certainly waiting for Robin. A good fifteen minutes passed before he called it quits and started eating. He moaned again, not giving a fuck that he was in public (which made the noise that had just come out of Steve very inappropriate). Why was he torturing Billy like this? And he’d said to Robin that Billy hated him? Uh, uh, no sir. It had to be the other way around.

When Steve took his first sip of hot chocolate, the extra whipped cream painted his upper lip white. But, this time, he didn’t wipe it away with his tongue, and Billy so badly wanted to lick it off himself. Pretty boy would be the death of him.

When Robin and Steve left, this time, the latter wished Billy a nice day. Well, Heather was there too… so maybe it had just been addressed to her. At best, it had been for the both of them. Still, Billy would take it.

While they cleaned the shop after closing, Heather waxed poetic about Robin. That was nothing new, however. She had already been doing plenty of that in the pining stage of their relationship. Billy listened absentmindedly, with his own head full of Steve and his lush hair and his pretty lips and his eyes, which had been full of mischief earlier that day.

He only regained awareness of his surroundings when he got hit in the chest with Heather’s balled up apron.

“I’m leaving, dumbass. See you tomorrow.”

“See you.”

*

Steve came to the Upside-Down regularly, after that, with Robin but also on his own. Billy was often in the kitchen when Steve came by, so he always had to find an excuse to get behind the counter, even if only for a brief moment, in order to catch a glimpse of him.

Heather caught up pretty quickly, of course.

“You like him.”

“Uh. What? Who?”

“Steve. You like him.” She whispered.

Billy had just come out of the kitchen, in the pretense of bringing a batch of muffins to the shop. In fact, the batch had been ready for an hour, and Billy had waited for Steve to arrive (he came almost every Wednesday) to bring it out.

And now Heather was saying Billy liked him when he was sitting a few meters away.

Billy shushed her without even trying to deny her claim. He knew not to fight a losing battle.

“Don’t worry. He’s grading his pupils’ papers. He’s like… in another world.”

Steve indeed looked engrossed by the sheets that were in front of him, holding a red pen in his right hand, ready to annotate them. And, oh God, he was wearing thick black-rimmed glasses. Billy couldn’t tear his eyes away.

“Jesus. You’ve got it bad!” Heather sounded delighted.

“Shut up”, Billy whined, still not denying it. The truth was what it was.

“Why didn’t you say so sooner? I would have helped you out.”

That was precisely one of the reasons why he had not told her. He didn’t need a wing-woman. Well, he did. But, he wouldn’t be caught dead asking for one.

*

He ended up with one, anyway. Now, every time Steve came by, Heather would make Billy get his order. Thankfully, Steve didn’t seem to notice the stratagem.

He must have been too occupied coming up with more and more outrageous drink choices. One day, he went as far as to ask for a white hot chocolate with extra whipped cream, marshmallows, and caramel drizzle. Billy all but gagged while making it. And Steve had the gall to add sugar. He was deranged! An honest to God maniac!

Billy was surprised Steve’s blood hadn’t yet crystalized with all the sugar he consumed.

“Anything else, pretty boy?” He asked, only noticing his slip-up when he saw Steve’s eyes get wide as saucers.

Billy couldn’t be held accountable for his mistake, alright? Steve really was pretty. Extremely pretty. Also, Billy kept calling him Pretty boy in his head ever since they had met, and he was so appalled by the drink Steve had just ordered that his brain-to-mouth filter was momentarily out of order. Sue him. He was only human.

“I… er… well… I… I’ll try today’s special. Thanks.” Steve stammered.

Everyday, Billy baked something that wasn’t usually on the menu. Today, it was a banana-chocolate cream pie.

As he put the piece of pie on Steve’s tray, Billy added:

“Here you go, sweet thing.” Because he had noticed Steve’s cheeks going beet red when he had called him pretty boy, and therefore he couldn’t help but think he might have a chance, after all.

Steve opened and closed his mouth a few times, apparently at a loss, before he thanked Billy and went to his usual table, nearly tripping on thin air on the way.

Billy was exulting, until he heard labored breathing and saw Steve struggling. What the hell was going on?

Billy went to him as fast as he could.

“Steve, what’s wrong?”

“I’m allergic to bananas.”

Oh God. Oh God, this was bad. This was so bad.

Billy took his cellphone out of his right back pocket and immediately dialed 911.

Notes:

So that's it for the first part. As I said in the tags, I might switch to Steve's POV in the second part, and there might be smut, but I don't know because my relation to it as a fanfic writer is conflictual lmao. I'd be happy to hear your opinion on those matters and on the first part as well of course ;)

You can come yell at me about Harringrove (or about whatever you want ah ah) on Tumblr at https://lightsupinthenorth.tumblr.com/ I'd be super happy to make some internet friends C=

Thanks a lot for reading!