Actions

Work Header

The Party

Chapter 2: Max

Notes:

Sorry for the slowness. Working remotely is hard when no one else seems to understand how computers work!
I am cursed with understanding. ^_^'''

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Summer had hit Hawkins hard. It was hot and sticky and the steam seemed to rise off the roads more often than not. Back before all of the tragedy and investment, Billy would have simply scorned Indiana; would have said that it couldn’t even do heat right. That the heat here was oppressive and horrible whereas the Californian heat was sweet and freeing.

Now he just felt beyond that shit.

From living with Hopper and El, Billy had learned a great deal more about the group’s dealings with the Upside Down; had learned about the strange situation between Hopper and the girl Billy, until recently, had believed to be his daughter. He quickly got on board with the house the rules; the ‘don’t be stupid’ rules. While El scowled and acted like they were the worst, Billy knew that they just weren’t. Neil’s rules had been the worst: the ‘do exactly what I say’ rule; the ‘be Max’s full-time guardian’ rule; the ‘do not exist’ rule.

All the same, the summer heat seemed to soften the rules; melt them like wax. More and more, El was being allowed to go to public places. More and more, she was pushing her boundaries and, more and more, Hopper was letting her.

With school having finally finished, Billy had little to do except give El and the nerds rides about town. Unlike when Neil had demanded he do it, this was his choice. While Max had her skateboard and the boys had their bikes, El was still a ways away from persuading Hopper to let her have either of those. It only felt right, therefore, that Billy drove her about. It only felt right that he drive the rest of them about too; or at least Henderson, El and Little Byers. Little Byers so that Billy had a chance to catch up with Jonathan and Joyce on a near-daily basis, Max because, even with Neil having finished with him, it still felt like his responsibility and Henderson…

That strange connection between him and Henderson was still a thing. Billy felt it was only right he give the little lisper a ride now that Steve wasn’t here to do it; now that he knew how much Henderson wished Steve was here to do it.

The first time he’d pulled up outside of the house on Cherry Lane, Billy was gripping the wheel tightly. Neil’s car wasn’t on the drive but he still felt like the old bastard was going to come charging out like a bat out of hell. As he watched El walk up to the front door -as he watched Susan answer and definitely spot the Camaro- his knuckles turned white. Little Byers was sitting in the back and Billy could feel his eyes on him in the rear-view mirror.

It always felt like that kid knew something. The way he looked at Billy made him feel this strange pull of discomfort. He remembered Steve babbling on about Nancy and Jonathan thinking the kid was queer too and maybe they were right. Maybe he was and he had a radar for shit like that; maybe he knew about Billy and Steve.

Or maybe Henderson had just told him. It wasn’t like it mattered anymore.

As much as life was still trudging on, that fact still hadn’t shifted from Billy’s brain: nothing mattered anymore. Not really.

And yet that didn’t feel right to even think anymore. Things did matter. Nancy and Jonathan and El and Henderson and Hopper mattered. Fuck, the whole fucking gang of people that he’d been left with mattered in their own ways.

It was just him; just Billy that didn’t matter. Nothing to do with his past, his present, his future, seemed to matter anymore. It wasn’t a self pitying thing; it was just how it was. The meaning -the future- that he’d found for himself had died with Steve and that was all there was to it.

So Billy didn’t growl anything at the pasty kid in the back seat when he stared at him. He let him look; let him see.

In the end, Max came out of the house no problem. She looked at the Camaro for all of thirty seconds before nodding and following the little psychic down the path towards them. Threw herself into the backseat with El as if there was nothing amiss. Even chatted with the other two a bit during the ride to Henderson’s. Billy glanced in the rear-view mirror a couple of times but she wasn’t looking in his direction; it was like he didn’t exist anymore.

But that didn’t matter. Billy didn’t matter.

Only when they arrived at Wheeler’s -only when they had all clambered out and started towards the house- that she said anything.

“Billy…” she said rather bluntly, causing him to turn. He hadn’t planned on going into the basement and watching the nerds play but he had wanted to see Nancy and Karen and, hell, even Tiny Wheeler. The little thing was actually starting to warm to him in her own way, now only staring at him rather than hiding and peeping like she’d done almost the whole time he’d lived in her family’s house.

Still, he turned to look at the girl who’d been his step-sister. With Neil’s dismissal of him, Billy wasn’t sure what that really made them anymore. Had they been closer -had there been less bad blood- maybe nothing would have changed but… it felt different.

“Max?” he replied, hands gesturing out in a gesture that looked put-out. It was like his body was still stuck in its program; unable to shake those seasoned responses. Still, Max’s face looked unchanged., that little determined frown on her face. She was steeling herself for something.

“Can we talk?” she asked, motioning towards the Camaro.

It felt a bit dramatic, having to climb back into the car to have this ‘talk’, but, then again, between the two of them they were pretty fucking dramatic. So, Billy dutifully walked back round to the driver’s side and climbed back in. Max climbed into her old place in the passenger’s seat and sighed, hands instinctively going for the belt before she stopped herself.

There was a tense silence but neither of them broke it. Billy’s mind ticked over the various things that Max could want to discuss with him. There was so much: him leaving; him being here; him in general. And that was before he started to even think of the shit that was probably happening back at Cherry Lane.

There was so much.

“You okay?” Billy finally heard himself ask. It came out of him unbidden but -fuck- there had been an itch under his skin about her; about Neil having no one to beat on anymore. As much shit as there was between them, Billy still couldn’t bear the thought of Max being the new channel for Neil to vent his frustrations at the world.

“What, since you left?” she answered sharply, her face twisting up a little.

“Yeah. Since I left,” Billy agreed. There was no use in arguing semantics with her. If she wanted to believe that Billy simply left her, there was probably no fighting it anyway. It didn’t matter what she thought of him. He didn’t matter.

“I’m fine,” she said with a huff, her gaze turned to look right out the windscreen. She scowled and folded her arms and shuffled in her seat. Billy simply sat and watched. She wanted to say something. “I just… I want to know why. Why did you leave? Why did you move into Mike’s house? Why did you move into El’s house? You always said you were going back to California when you could. Why the hell are you still here?” she started and it sounded like the floodgates opening. All the questions; they’d clearly been circling in her head for a while.

“I…” Billy started. What answer could he give? The truth was hard to verbalise; hard to explain without just telling her fucking everything. “I couldn’t live there anymore…” he tried because it was true. Nancy had been the one to force the issue but, goddamn, it had been a long time coming. Steve hadn’t wanted him living there; would have probably let him move into the Harrington Manor if Billy had asked.

“But then why didn’t you go back to California?” Max pressed and she was looking at him now, an angry, hurt, confused expression on her face. “Back to San Diego where you were happy. Back home,” she continued and it started to sound wistful; like that was her plan too.

Perhaps she was mad that he could go and she couldn’t. Perhaps she was made that he didn’t go and didn’t take her with him. Perhaps she was just fucking mad.

“I… can’t…” Billy tried but every explanation was so wrapped up in Steve. He was the heart of it; he was Billy’s heart. There was so California without Steve. Not anymore. That had been their dream. His old dream of going back to was just a memory; would have just been trying to step backwards into the past. San Francisco had bee a future; had been a way forwards.

Max stared at him for a long time as if she was expecting him to go on. The silence surrounded them but all Billy could do was sigh. It was a lot. Everything was so much. It had been 37 days since Steve had died. 37 days where Steve Harrington hadn’t been alive. 37 days in which Billy had felt his absence over and over in so many fucking ways.

Yeah, he didn’t have a total meltdown every day anymore, but -god- he could feel Steve not being there in every fucking thing he did. Steve was gone not just in the negative spaces that he would have occupied; he was gone in the spaces where other things existed. It hurt so much every fucking day and Billy was so fucking exhausted from it.

He hung his head low, still feeling the weight of Max’s eyes on him.

“Dustin said this is about Steve…” she started and it sounded like she was hesitant; like she thought he would explode at her or something. “He told me that I should talk to you… that it wasn’t his place to say anything…” she continued and Billy was an honest mixture of touched and amazed that the little kid had been so fucking loyal.

“Yeah…” he sniffed, his shoulders coming up a little. “It’s about Steve…” God… his name felt so sad on his tongue. The way he said the name had changed; it was just so fucking sad.

“Just... why? I know you two were friends near the end but...” Max sighed, leaning back in her seat as her hands came up in a despairing gesture. There was a small slapping sound as then came back down against her thighs. “God, Billy, I thought you hated him? If I hadn’t used that needle on you in November-"

Hated him? Hated Steve?

Billy could remember the conversation they had. The time that he’d called Steve perfect and told him how much he’d hated him when they first met. How that had meat something so different from how Max thought.

No. He couldn’t have her think that.

“I was in love with him, Max,” turning to face her properly, he said it. It was true. It was real. It was the epicentre of all of this. Billy was in love with Steve; was still in love with him even 37 days later. 37 days after Steve had died and left this world, Billy was still fucking in love with him.

“What-?” the red-head snapped as if she hadn’t really comprehended what he’d said. Then she paused, taking in his expression, eyes widening a little as her mouth hung open. “No... you weren’t... you...” she stammered, every phrase punctuated with little halting sounds. She was processing; she couldn’t fucking get it. “What?” she finally asked and it didn’t sound hateful. It didn’t sound disgusted. It just sounded confused; like her mind was utterly blown.

“Me and Steve; we were together. I was in love with him...” Billy repeated the last sentiment because she needed to know that. He didn’t hate Steve; he never truly hated Steve. Not when he’d had him pinned to the Byers’ floor, punching again and again, and not when he’d held him in his arms at the end of it all.

“But you're-" Max stammered, eyes widening still.

“A guy?” Billy sighed but she was shaking her head.

“-An asshole!” she corrected and Billy rolled his eyes. Really? That was her only roadblock in believing it? He and Steve couldn’t be a thing because he was an asshole? “You’re... You’re not lying, are you?”

“Do you really think I’d lie about this?” Billy asked flatly because, honestly, of all the things to make up, being a faggot really wasn’t a choice. There was no doubt in his mind that, with telling Max and Henderson already clued in, the rest of the nerds weren’t going to be unaware much longer; if they even were now.

“... so, your dad’s...” Max started up again, puzzling it out for him to hear. “All this time, when he called you a- When he called you those things... All this time, he actually...”

Billy knew she’d heard what Neil called him -the old bastard wasn’t exactly quiet when he was firing off at him- but it felt strange her acknowledging it. It was like he’d been able to convince himself that she wasn’t that aware; that she didn’t know everything. Yeah, she’d seen the results and that bad beating after he’d grabbed her, but maybe she didn’t know everything.

It felt weird that she’d heard it all.

“Yeah, he meant it,” he said grimly. It was true after all. The way Neil spoke about gay people had totally shaped the way Billy spoke -the way Billy thought- about himself. Even now, after Steve and Nancy’s admonishments, the word used in his mind was faggot.

“I thought it was just what he called you...” she mumbled and Billy could hear the shame in her voice; like she couldn’t believe her own naivety.

“For a while, yeah, at the start. But...” Billy accepted, running a hand through his hair in a gesture that was so Steve that, upon realising what he was doing, his heart panged with pain. Fuck… “After he caught me with Alex...” he continued but suddenly Max was jolting in her seat, leaning closer like he’d just spilled some hot fucking gossip.

“Alex? As in Alex, Alex? Alex Hayes?” she rushed and it suddenly occurred to him that, yeah, she hadn’t known about them either. Still, the reaction was too big. It was too loud.

“Do we know another Alex?” he snipped but Max wasn’t deterred.

“There’s one in my grade. Alex Delacourt.”

“Well, no, Max. Neil didn’t fucking catch me with fucking Alex Delacourt!” he couldn’t stop himself from shooting back. Goddamn, even in this state -this pathetic, broken state- Max was still able to wind him up like no one else.

He supposed this was the ‘sister’ effect; that there was a certain link between siblings -and, in their case, step-siblings- that just meant they knew where each other’s buttons were. Apparently, although many parts of Billy had been destroyed by Steve’s death, that particular button was still there and still working. Apparently, Max could still piss him off.

“Okay! Jesus!” she sighed, holding up her hands in surrender and Billy rolled his eyes at her. Honestly, how did she make him slip back into this? He didn’t know whether to be grateful for the return of something normal or to feel guilty that he wasn’t still mourning. “So... you and Alex were together? Like, together, together?” she added and Billy felt a second wave of irritation.

“What part of Neil catching me with him did you not get?” he snarked but she was suddenly looking like she was working something out. Billy braced himself for whatever conclusion she drew; she could be thinking fucking anything at this point.

“... when did he catch you?” she asked and he felt his body go cold. Here it was: that terrible truth that, even when he’d fucking hated her, he’d shielded her from. The truth about it being her fault. Goddamn, this wasn’t something he wanted to share. This wasn’t what he thought they’d be talking about.

“Max-"

“When, Billy?” she pressed, asking in earnest like she knew the answer was dark. Like she knew the weight of it; the significance of it.

Billy sighed and clenched his hands. The now-familiar pain shot up his forearms and he tried to focus on that. Today was the 15th of July. It was 37 days since Steve had died. It was also 10 days since the anniversary of Alex’s death. There was a lot of feelings right now.

“That night I didn’t get you. The night you walked home and told him where we liked to hang,” Billy explained shortly.

No. He couldn’t tell her. He would never tell her.

Alex had been dead for a year and laying the blame at Max’s feet, no matter how much it belonged there, wouldn’t change shit. Knowing that you caused someone’s death -especially someone you care about- was the worst feeling in the world. Billy knew it all too well now. There was no way he was going to tell her.

He would take it to his grave.

“Oh,” Max said simply and Billy could hear her understanding. At least in that, she sounded like she knew her role. She didn’t need to know that’s what led to Alex’s death. This was enough. “He really went for you that night... I just thought it was because you left me-"

“Max, I didn’t leave you-" Billy tried because, once again, the story was warping out of shape. Like with her saying that he’d hated Steve, her view of the world was just wrong.

“Yeah, yeah...” she waved him off and Billy clenched his fists as tight as the pain in his arms would allow. Once again there was silence. Once again they both just sat there and processed. The Wheelers and the nerds were probably wondering where they were. Hell, they’d probably peeked out of the windows to see them both sitting in Camaro like a couple of weirdos.

Suddenly Max was sitting back in her chair and running both her hands over her face with a dramatic, “God...”

“What are you thinking?” Billy asked when she didn’t say anything else; when the silence threatened to consume them once more.

“How it all makes so much sense now? How nothing makes sense at the same time? I mean… You and Alex were so… Alex was...” she spoke, her hands gesturing like each rambling sentiment needed some kind of visual interpretation. “But…You were always talking about girls,” she tried, turning only her head to gage Billy’s reaction.

“Max...” he said with a sigh and her eyes narrowed in concentration.

“You weren’t talking about girls… You were talking about each other...” she concluded aloud. Honestly, like so many other things with Alex, Billy couldn’t remember they kinds of things she was talking about. Maybe they had thought they were really clever one day and talked about a ‘hot blonde’ or something but, honestly, Billy couldn’t recall. It felt sick and wrong that he couldn’t remember. It felt sick and wrong that, after months as boyfriends and years as friends, so much was forgotten already. It felt worse that, having only been together a matter of weeks, shit with Steve would probably fade away too. Like writing in the sand on the beach, it would be washed away forever. “Ew! You were flirting right in front of me and I didn’t know it!” Max cried out, bringing Billy back into the moment.

“You make it sound like that’s all we did,” he said, still unsure whether or not that was the case.

“Well...” Max shrugged and Billy felt none the wiser. “God... it makes so much sense. Alex was obsessed with you. He would always talk to me about you. I always just thought he was trying to get dirt on you...” she explained and Billy couldn’t stop the small smile in the corner of his mouth. It was just a small one, just a reaction to the memory of Alex being such a shit.

Some things were lost but not that. Not the way they’d laughed and messed around and really been friends as well as boyfriends. Like how things had been with Steve…

“He probably was, to be fair,” Billy said, fighting to keep control of the emotions that were just yo-yoing inside him. It was fucking exhausting.

“But you two were... And Steve?” Max continued and they were back here again; back to her not quite believing it all. Fuck… it felt so fucking weird that, after all his efforts to conceal it, now he was having to convince someone that they had been together. “You were with Steve as well?”

“Yeah...” he said simply. What more could he say?

“But he was with Nancy. She’s a girl...”

“Yeah... He liked both,” he offered with a shrug. Nancy’s key word: bisexual. Billy wasn’t certain he felt like explaining that particular piece of vocabulary to her right now.

“Both what?” Max asked with a tilt of the head.

“Both girls and guys,” Billy shrugged again.

“Seriously? Is that a thing?” Max shot back, genuine and a little confused.

“Apparently,” Billy nodded.

“And he was with you?”

“Yes,” Billy replied tensely. Once again, his hands were clenching. Once again, there was a spark in his gut. God, she really could get under his skin.

“Seriously?” And that was the last straw.

“Yes, Max, he was with me -I was with him- why is that so hard to understand?” he snarled and Max drew away a little, the brief widening of her eyes betraying the underlying fear that she still had towards him. Goddamn, he really was her version of the boogeyman, wasn’t he?

“Because you’re horrible,” she replied with a cross little face, masking her fear with anger; just as he did. They were too similar. That was probably the root of her ability to wind him up so much, really. She was too much like him. She knew which buttons to press because they were so much like her own.

There was a tense silence before she suddenly softened. Her eyes drifted down from Billy and back into her lap, the corners of her mouth turned down.

“And he was nice. He was really nice...” she sighed and Billy could hear it there in her voice. That loss. Yeah, she was doing better than him and Henderson and Nancy and Jonathan but she wasn’t not cut up about it. She wasn’t made of stone. Steve had been a big part of the whole Upside Down gang; he’d been the one left to protect them back in November. There was a bond there that Billy could see now.

“He was... Too nice for an asshole like me,” Billy sighed, unclenching his fists and feeling the blood flowing freely through them once again. It felt weird; so close to pins and needles but not quite there. “But we were together, Max. We were together and I was in love with him,” he repeated again because there couldn’t be any doubt about it. He hadn’t told people when Steve was alive; hadn’t made Steve feel cherished enough when it mattered. There was no way that, now he was gone, Billy would let it go unsaid.

He loved Steve Harrington.

Max looked back at him sadly and nodded.

“That’s…” she started but bit her lip when her voice wobbled. A tear skipped down her cheek and, with a sniff, she wiped it away. “And now he’s…”

“Gone,” Billy finished for her and she nodded again.

“Just like Alex,” she observed, vocalising the pain that Billy had to deal with now for the rest of his fucking life. He gave a curt nod.

“Yeah…” he said and, god, it hurt. It hurt to know that the two boys he’d loved were both gone. Like his mother before them, they had gone before their time and it was all his fault.

A few seconds passed and Billy had to shake his head to force his way out of the spiral. They were about to go into the Wheeler’s house. He’d promised himself that today -on day 37 without Steve- he wasn’t going to cry on either of the Wheeler women. He couldn’t show up in tears now. There was no way.

“I couldn’t stay, Max. Neil was going to- be Neil again and, without Steve, I just couldn’t…” he sighed, bringing them full-circle, back to the place where they’d started. She’d asked him a question and, now that she knew, he owed her an answer. “I wouldn’t have been strong enough… He would have killed me…” he admitted and he knew she must know it was true.

“And California...?” Max asked and the meaning was so plain. How many times had he said that Hawkins was just a temporary thing? How many times had he bragged and boasted about leaving this shit hole?

How much had that changed since Steve had come into the picture? How much had it changed when he left the picture once again?

“That… wasn’t the plan anymore…” he admitted quietly. The ball of pain in his gut was forming once again, that cancerous hurt that threatened to consume him.

“You were going to go with Steve,” Max guessed and Billy nodded weakly.

“Yeah…”

“Why couldn’t you just tell me this? I could have helped you!” she sighed and it sounded so fucking stupid when she said it.

“Max…”

“Why does Dustin know this? Why didn’t you talk to me?” she continued, ignoring him. He could explain how Steve had been the one to tell -explain that Billy himself had told no one- but there really was no fucking point. She wasn’t really asking. She was just hurt. “We used to talk-” she said and, god, it once again sounded like a place where he could tell all. But no. No fucking way. “Although, I guess we didn’t…”

“Max, you do realise what people generally think of faggots, right? I know Neil’s an asshole but…” he started off with frustration in his words but it quickly petered out. He was so feeling tired from all the emotional ups and downs. “This isn’t something I’m exactly proud of, you know,” he added.

“Do I look like I care that you’re into guys?” Max scoffed and, for the second time in recent memory, Billy felt genuinely surprised. He knew not everyone was like Neil but, honestly, he really hadn’t expected another person that he knew to just… not care that he was into guys. Between Max, Karen and Nancy, anyone would think that it was normal. “I care that you’re an asshole. I care that you hurt Lucas. I care that, at every opportunity you get, you make my life worse,” she continued and this time Billy couldn’t argue with her. “I don’t care who you’re getting off with.”

“Well… I do,” Billy said in a moment of honesty that she hadn’t actually asked for. “Or I did… I don’t know anymore…”

“You really loved him?” she asked and Billy nodded, biting his lip.

“Yes, Max. I really loved him…” he sighed, wiping at his eyes before they could start to fucking water again. Goddamn, he really didn’t need this.

“I’m sorry Billy… I’m sorry he’s gone…” Max said glumly and Billy sniffed pathetically.

There was another lull. Another quiet between them. Max’s words circled his mind over and over. Ever since Alex had died, he really had treated her like shit. At the time, it had felt justified. At the time, he knew she’d deserved it. If she hadn’t told Neil about where he and Alex hung out, Neil would have never found out about them. He would have never hired those fucking guys and had Alex beaten to fucking death.

It had been so clear that Max was to blame for all of it.

But, god, after all of the shit with Steve… it just didn’t feel like her role mattered so much. Neil was an asshole who was going to find out sooner or later. Max couldn’t have known what was going on; couldn’t have known what Neil was going to find.

“I’m sorry too Max,” he said. It was time he said it. It was time he put it all aside.  

“Yeah?” she almost whispered, sounding like she hardly dared interrupt him.

“I’m sorry I’m an asshole. I’m sorry I make your life worse… I… I’ve just been so mad since…” he continued. It felt strangely freeing to say it.

“Since Alex died?” Max finished for him and he nodded.

“Yeah… since then.”

“Is that why you broke Bobby’s arm? Why you got us moved here?”

“Max-!” Billy sighed. Still her narrative was off. But, without that key piece of information, it always would be, wouldn’t it?

“Billy, I need to know! Please, we’re finally talking,” she pressed and Billy sighed again. At least he could straighten it out a little, right? Take that shit Bobby Day down off the pedestal that Max had plopped him up on for being the poor, wounded victim.

“Your precious Bobby Day put graffiti on Alex’s grave, Max. He wrote ‘rot faggot’ and was laughing and I just-” he started but Max’s eyes were wide again, leaning closer with recognition on her face.

“He wrote that?” she gasped. “Bobby was the one who wrote that?”

“Yeah,” Billy stammered, not having expected that reaction. It wasn’t exactly a publicised event and Hayes’ had cleaned that shit off pretty quickly. Billy honestly hadn’t expected her to have known it had ever been a thing.

“You should have broken both his arms…” Max said decidedly and Billy felt his mouth twitching into a smile again. For all her faults, Max was still pretty badass. He’d been right to take her seriously when she’d threatened him with Steve’s bat.

“Believe me, I wanted to,” he replied and Max nodded.

“I still blame you. For us coming here, you know,” she sighed, leaning back in her seat to look at the road.

“Okay,” Billy replied, copying the action. Things felt… different. Not close or friendly but different.

“But I’m sorry for being a dick about it. I know there are monsters and it’s cold and it smells but… there are good people here too,” she said, still not looking at him. There was a small tinge to her cheeks and he wasn’t sure if it was the thought of apologising to him or the thought of Sinclair that was causing it. “I like it here.”

“I was starting to…” Billy admitted and Max exhaled deeply.

“I’m sorry Billy…”

“Yeah… me too…”

Notes:

Lots of people were wondering whether or not things would clear up between these two.
This wouldn't fix everything but it's their starting point.

Series this work belongs to: