Actions

Work Header

Wheelers

Chapter 2: Karen

Notes:

People don't seem to like Karen all that much.
I've had this headcanon since before season 3 and, even when writing the main story, I've largely ignored that season.
While there were some awesome parts to it, I really think some characters got shafted, Karen Wheeler being one of them.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Billy had always gotten on well with Karen Wheeler. Yeah, it was based heavily on the fact that she was definitely into him, and, yeah, they hadn’t had all that much to do with one another really. Just the manipulation in November, a couple of exchanges in front of her house and when they’ve bumped into each other in town. Nothing major really. But the fact was that, out of all the bored housewives that Hawkins had to offer, Karen seemed like the nicest; the one with most genuine kindness to her.

Not only that, Billy had always sensed something else in here; some kind of sad, forgotten yearning that she kept just beneath the surface. Before all of this, Billy had thought about that thing he’d seen in Karen Wheeler, even if only in passing. He’d thought about that barely-hidden longing that caught his attention so starkly. Although they’d never acknowledged it, Billy had felt a connection with the woman over it. They both wanted more. They both hated this fucking town and felt trapped here.

Karen was trapped here by her family; by her life and her responsibility. Billy was trapped here by Neil; in a way, like her, he was trapped by his responsibility. Only difference was that Billy was still, technically, a kid; he, in theory, had his whole life to spread his wings and fly away. Away from Hawkins and Neil and all the fucking responsibilities that weighed him down on the daily.

To fly all the way to San Francisco and live with the boy he loved by the sea.

At least… that had been the difference. Now that Steve was gone, the links were even stronger. Over the last week, Billy had come to the stark realisation that his wings had been clipped. He couldn’t fly anymore. Not without Steve. Probably never could in the first place. He, like Karen, was stuck here in Hawkins. He, too, would have that longing just beneath his skin; there for any kindred spirit to spot.

Or maybe she was just a loose, old whore who liked her boys young.

Either way, as he lay there, uninvited in her bathtub, he knew that their whole thing was over now. He knew how this looked to a mother of a teenage girl, especially when that teenage girl was sitting there like being around him while he was naked was the most normal thing in the world.

It didn’t look good.

“Mom…” Nancy spluttered, having the sense to straighten up from where she’d been leaning on the tub but too shocked to do much more.

Karen’s face was a fucking picture. As predicted, her eyes flashed downwards at Billy and then, colour rising in her cheeks, she forced herself to look at her daughter instead, pushing her hair behind her ear in a heated gesture. Billy shifted too late to cover himself. Fuck the damage was done already.

“Nancy-” Karen stammered, her voice sharper and higher than Billy had ever heard it.

“Mom, I can-” Nancy started at the same time and now was on her knees about to get up. Billy just watched the two of them speechless. Really, what could he say right now?

Karen held up her hand, eyes closing as if she was too fucking angry to deal with the situation. Nancy held fire, both teens seeming to be holding their breaths in anticipation of what the older woman was about to say; what she was about to do.

“Mom, I-”

“Ah, ah-!” Karen hushed her daughter before she could even start; eyes still closed, hand still raised.

She took in a deep breath, held it a beat longer than Billy expected, and then released it. As if that was all it took to reset her mind, her eyes opened and fixed on her daughter. There it was. The look of determination that Nancy wore so well; Billy could see where it came from now.

“Nancy, let’s speak outside. Billy-” her eyes slide over but went no lower than his jaw this time. “-you finish up and get dressed.”

The way she spoke was so much calmer; so much more in control. It was like she’d entered a special ‘mom mode’ and there was no denying her right now. As if she was powerless to resist, Nancy got up and followed her mother out of the room, only turning briefly before leaving to offer Billy an apologetic look.

His body working on autopilot, Billy did just as he was told: dunking himself under the water to remove any remaining lather that he might have forgotten about while he’d been wallowing. Pulling the plug out, he stood up and grabbed the towel Nancy had given him before this whole mess had started; before she’d felt the need to come in and check on him.

If he wasn’t such a fucking mess then Nancy would have been outside. She’d have seen her mom coming home and would have had a plan for dealing with it. Now everything was fucked and it was all Billy’s fault once again.

By the time he was dressed, presentable and heading out of the bathroom, Nancy was nowhere to be seen. Karen was standing, back to the wall, eyes fixed on the space that Billy was now occupying like she’d been waiting a while. With a small nod of her head, she pushed off the wall and headed down the corridor, down the stairs, not looking back to check Billy was following.

Follow he did, though. While this wasn’t the overly dramatic hell that he’d prophesised, it still didn’t feel good. It felt starkly like he was going to get his ass thrown out of the Wheeler’s house without so much as a goodbye.

Karen took him past the front door, however, leading him through the blessedly-empty kitchen and into the room that Billy hadn’t been in before: the office. Flicking the lights on, Karen moved round to sit at the desk that Billy assumed Mr Wheeler rarely used, turning the chair so that she could face him. There seemed to be a layer of dust everywhere that supported the idea of the man of the house not exactly being the working from home type.

The two of them looked at each other for a tense moment before Karen motioned towards the only other chair in the room. With a small nod, Billy moved it into a position opposite her and lowered himself down. Fuck. This felt ominous.

“Billy-” she started, her tones and expression so business-like that Billy couldn’t stop himself from interrupting.

“I’m sorry Karen. I- I don’t want you to think- I’m not…” he stammered, feeling all kinds of out of sorts.

Before everything -before Saturday and Steve and the Upside Down- Billy knew how to talk to moms. He knew how to swing them round to his side. He’d been caught in, if not worse then, similar levels of awkward situations before. The time he and Ingrid had been smoking weed out of her bedroom window and her mom had come in, for example, and how they’d had to pretend that they’d been fooling around so that Ingrid’s mom hadn’t known about her casual drug usage. He’d been able to talk his way round there; almost got Enid’s blessing before the older woman’s sharp eyes had caught the zippo on the window sill.

Now, however, he just didn’t know what to say. He was still feeling too shitty; about being caught, living here, Steve… everything. He could no more persuade Karen that he was a decent person than he could persuade himself.

“Billy, Nancy has told me that you’re not sleeping together,” Karen said flatly.

“We’re not! I- She-” Billy agreed, desperate to add some kind of explanation for what the older woman had seen without talking about the Upside Down or any other nonsense. God, he wished Nancy was in here with him. Karen held up a hand to stay his babbling and Billy stopped at once. It wasn’t like he was making all that much sense anyhow.

“And that’s about all she’s told me,” she added, rising to pace around the room. Billy sat, stock-still, just watching her. He felt strangely like a wounded animal being circled by a predator or some shit. After a couple of steps, however, Karen paused and sighed deeply. “Me and Nancy don’t talk. That’s nothing new. I wish it was different but…” she put her hands on her hips and shook her head. Billy could feel the regret from her. It felt so similar to that feeling he had with Max; that strange desire for things to be better but the knowledge that they couldn’t. Yet another thing he had in common with Karen Wheeler. The parallels were so oddly clear today. “But right now, she isn’t talking to me in a different way. It doesn’t feel like she’s not telling me things because of us… It feels like she’s not telling me things because of you…”

“I’m sorry…” Billy replied because he was sorry. Because he knew how it felt and he hated that he was making shit worse. Nancy was protecting him; not wanting to spill the beans about Steve… about him being a… about Billy being gay.

The next second, Karen was moving to kneel in front of him, her eyes intense and locking with his own.

“Talk to me Billy,” she said and her voice was a plea. There was now a slight feeling of panic in the air; what on earth could she be imaginging? “Why were you in the bath in my house at four in the afternoon? Why is there a bag of your things in my daughter’s room?” Fair questions both but hard ones to give a straight answer to. “Why did Nancy almost scream at me when I suggested calling your father?” she finished and Billy’s heart froze.

“Please don’t-!” he gasped and his face must have given everything away because Karen was shaking her head and taking his hands in her own.

“I’m not going to call him, Billy,” she soothed but Billy’s heart was pounding now; he was gripping onto her hands like his life fucking depended on it. Hell, it probably did. “I just want answers. I want to know why it looks like an eighteen year old boy has been living in my house without me knowing about it. That’s all,” she explained softly and the panic seemed to seep out of both of them in an instant.

“I…” Billy started, wanting to answer; wanting to help. But what could he say?

“Does this have something to do with Steve Harrington?” she asked, hitting the nail squarely on the head in a way that made Billy’s heartrate pick right back up again. “Your arms…. Your chest….” She started, turning his hands so that his forearms were facing upwards. Even though he was wearing one of the few long-sleeved shirts that he owned, they both knew what was under there. Karen had seen everything after all. “Were you in the car crash?”

The car crash. That was the line that had been fed to the people of Hawkins. Steve Harrington had died in a horrible car crash on Saturday night. Nancy and Jonathan had drip-fed him pieces of information about it all -shielding him from being exposed to too much too soon- but, from what they’d told him and what he’d seen around school, it seemed like people were buying it.

“I can’t…” Billy breathed with a shake of his head. His voice cracked and he could not start crying right now. Not with Karen so close. Not with her eyes on him.

“Or… is it to do with your father?” she asked with a hesitancy that told Billy that, at least on some level, she knew. That, somehow, she could tell that Neil was a piece of shit; that Billy, despite all his fucking bravado and muscles, was fucking terrified of the old man.

“He didn’t do this,” Billy objected, taking his hands back and unconsciously rubbing at where the wounds were. He owed her some kind of explanation. He had to tell her something; make it less weird that he had been hiding out in her home. “But…” he started but failed again. What could he say? What would explain it enough for her to understand but not so much that she went running to Hopper?

“But… he might do something else if you go back?” she suggested and Billy bit his lip. Goddamn these Wheeler women. They really knew how to cut him right to the core.

“Yeah…” he admitted and Karen tilted her head to one side.

“Something bad?” she asked, again, in a way that told Billy she knew; that she was just seeking confirmation.

“Yeah. Something bad…” he said and it sat between them for a long while.

“Okay…” she breathed, standing up and pacing again. He could feel the stress in her every move; could see the wheels turning as she tried to figure out what she was supposed to do. Once again, he was becoming someone else’s problem; a burden to yet another person who deserved better. “You have a sister, Maxine? Is she-?” she started but Billy cut across. This was too much.

“She’s fine. He doesn’t-” he started but -goddam- saying it felt wrong. Implied was bad enough; inferred was uncomfortable. He couldn’t bring himself to admit out loud that his dad was a monster. “She’s fine,” he finished and Karen gave a small nod, returning to her seat.

“How long have you been here? Living in my house, I mean,” Karen asked after a long pause, leaning forwards where she sat. The way she asked almost sounded like she was begging him to let it only be a day or so. Maybe it was her pride or something.

“Since Monday…” Billy replied honestly because, hell, there was no point in lying.

“Monday…” she looked at him for a long time and Billy couldn’t help but look away. It was like she was trying to get a read on him; see all the things he wasn’t saying. Fuck. “This is to do with Steve, isn’t it?” she asked and Billy could already feel the emotions building up. They were never all that far from the surface, after all. “You two were friends, weren’t you? It seemed like Nancy was going to see you, Steve and Jonathan every day only last week.”

“We were… He-” Billy stammered over his words again. This was too much. He couldn’t give himself away like this; he couldn’t sully people’s memory of Steve with his own patheticness.

“Billy…” Karen started, her voice calm and controlled as ever. When he looked up at her face, he could see a slight crease to her brow; like she was thinking carefully about how to phrase what she was saying. “I had a friend in middle school. Joshua was his name. We dated for about a week in 8th grade. Before it counted, you know,” she started and, honestly, Billy wasn’t sure where she was going with this. “He moved away after high school. Got into a good college, I can’t remember where…” she trailed off and Billy waited for the story to continue. “Now he’s living just outside of Chicago. Very successful, too, I believe.”

“Yeah?” he sniffed. What was she saying?

“Never really settled down. Last time I saw him -oh, must have been a couple of summers back now- he and his buddy David had decided to house share,” she said and suddenly the story had meaning. Suddenly, it sounded quite familiar; quite close to the mark. “Makes sense; two bachelors splitting the costs of living. Keep each other company too, you know? I think- I know they’re much happier than they would be alone. They get on so well…”

Something felt like it was being left unsaid. It felt like Karen was reaching out through this story; probing gently for something she wasn’t entirely sure was there. It made Billy feel… odd. It made him feel strangely curious to see her reaction. Nancy had known all along; Steve had gone to her about all the confused feelings he’d been having right at the start. She must have got that from somewhere. Just like Neil had passed his homophobia down to Billy, could Karen had passed something more open-minded down to Nancy?

“Sounds like a couple of queers,” he said, testing the waters; watched the slur hit her and her not even flinch.

“Well that’s none of my business, now, is it?” she said as if it was the most simple thing ever. The way she said it made it sound okay. It was like she was saying ‘yeah, they’re gay and what?’ He’d never seen an adult be so casual about homosexuality before; not outside of the regulars at Dynamo; not outside of actual gay people. Even his own mom had acted like it was a terrible thing when Neil called him faggot; like it was the worst thing he could call their son. “All I know is my friend from middle school is happy living with his best friend and isn’t that all that matters?” Karen continued with a small shrug and gentle smile.

“Yeah…” Billy had to agree. Heart beating fast, he made a decision. “Steve was… He was my best friend…” he breathed, his voice starting to shake from a mixture of nerves and that every-present pain.

He was. Over the course of their relationship, Steve had become Billy’s best friend, his boyfriend, his world. Seeing the understanding instantly spreading over Karen’s face, Billy couldn’t halt the choked-up sob that burst out of him.

Arms open and there, Karen returned to her spot in front of him. As he continued to cry, she pulled him in close, crossing the line that they’d never crossed until now. It felt so strange that this was how Karen finally got her arms around him. There was no flirtation here; no inappropriate comments or looks or anything. This was just a mom looking after a kid as he cried.

“Billy…” Karen sighed a heartbroken sigh. “I’m so sorry…” she said and, goddamn, she got it. She knew what Steve meant to him. She knew and she didn’t care that they were both guys; she just cared that Steve had gone and left Billy behind.

Who knew Karen Wheeler was like this?

“We were going- going to move to San Francisco… After I graduated, you know? We were going to go there and- we were going to-” Billy started to babble, drawing more parallels to Karen’s Joshua and David story that didn’t need drawing anymore. She’d got it but, fuck, it sounded so much like what they’d planned. Weren’t they going to run away together? Find a place where no one gave a shit if they were roommates or lovers? Fuck…

“I see,” she hummed softly, a hand running up and down his back in a comforting, maternal gesture. It was crazy how good it felt. Still a fucking mess, Billy leaned into it; savoured that feeling that he’d lacked through all those years of only having Neil.

“But now- Now he’s-” he gasped but Karen was shaking her head even as she still held him close.

“Shhh…” she hushed as her hand kept stroking; as her hold on him tightened a little. “It’s going to be okay,” she tried but Billy wrenched himself free at that.

“People keep saying that! ‘It’s going to be okay’! They keep saying that but-” he cried, akmost shouting in the poor woman’s face. He felt so fucking tired of being this mess. Now Karen had seen him. Now he’d shown how fucking broken he was and it felt so fucking stupid; so pathetic. “But it never was before- Before Steve and I got- Before we were best friends, it never was okay. He made it okay! He made things feel okay; made the future look better. How can it be okay now?” he continued.

Karen’s expression stayed calm; like the face of a cliff as the sea crashed and raged against it. Her hands gently squeezed on inside of Billy’s elbows where they’d ended up, thumbs circling in scaled-down reminders of how her hands has stroked his back.

“It can’t. Not now,” she said simply, sadly, and with a wet, shuddering breath, Billy leaned back into her. Once again, her arms were around him; holding him close. Goddamn, it felt too close to comforting; too close to actually making a difference. “Billy, it hasn’t even been a week. Your best friend died and it hasn’t even been a week. But I promise you: it will get better. Time will heal this. Time will heal you,” she promised and Billy closed his eyes and held on tighter as the tears continued to fall.

As with all of these episodes, Billy lost track of how long he cried in Karen Wheeler’s arms. It seemed like, once the floodgates opened, there was nothing he nor anyone else could do but wait it out. Karen had held onto him like he was her own son, hands and voice gentle and caring as she soothed him.

He really could see where Nancy got it from. Karen Wheeler was something else.

When he was finally more or less back to a ‘normal’ state, Karen had taken him by the hand and led him to the basement. As they walked down the stairs, she explained how she wasn’t going to send him back to Neil; how he could stay with them for now at least.

“You can stay down here for now. There’s a couch and I can get the spare sheets out for you. I know it’s not ideal -I mean, we will have to figured something else out for the long term- but, for now, this will have to do,” she explained as she motioned towards the couch.

Billy looked around the room. He’d only been down here once or twice to pick up Max, never really taking the time to look at the surroundings. There were toys all over the place; some of them clearly liscenced shit like Star Wars and others that looked handmade. There was a table set up with a board and other shit all over it.

This was the nerds’ base of operations. It felt so fucking weird that he’d be staying here.

“Thank you, Karen,” he said all the same. It was so much better than being thrown out.

While he didn’t doubt that Joyce would take him in, that would lead to questions; could lead to Hopper making a thing of it. So far, Karen had made no mention of calling the cops and he really wanted to keep it that way. After all, at the moment, the only injuries he had on him were caused by Steve. There was no evidence of what Neil liked to do to him.

“You can understand why you can’t carry on sleeping in Nancy’s room, right? Ted would hardly approve on that,”

“I get it…. Karen-” he started. It was a stupid thought; a pathetic thought- but, god, he really didn’t need this going further. Karen might not be bothered but what about her husband? What about her son? As broken and obvious as he was being at the moment, he really didn’t need shit being confirmed for people. Like, ever if he could help it. “About… About Steve and me-”  

“Don’t worry, Billy. I won’t say anything,” Karen smiled, already at the foot of the basement stairs.  “Like with Joshua and David, it’s none of my business.”

Billy half-smiled. Every smile felt like half a smile; like the other half had died with Steve. Billy wondered if Karen had been right. Whether time would heal him and his smile or not.

“I’m sorry Karen,” he said and she tilted her head to one side.

“For what?” she asked gently and Billy balled up his fists.

“For- For leading you on. For flirting with you all the time… I dunno,” he said, feeling stupid; feeling like a fucking kid in front of her now.

“Billy,” Karen sighed and she was crossing back over to him to rest a gentle hand on his cheek. “You don’t have to apologise to me, Billy. It made me smile. You have nothing to apologise for.”

“Still…” he started with another shrug.

“Billy, I had no expectations with you. You’re my daughter’s age, for goodness sake,” she laughed, giving his cheek a couple of soft pats before staking a step back away from him. “It just felt nice to be noticed, even if it was by you,” she said lightly but Billy could once again feel that longing beneath her skin; that secret hurt that she hid so well.

“You deserve to be noticed, Karen,” he said and saw the words resonate within her. The whole moment felt deep. He shifted his feet. “I mean… You’ve got a rockin’ bod…” he tried to laugh it off and Karen giggled in the way she used to for him; like his flirting was still doing the trick even though she knew what he was; even though she had seen him.

“Billy-!” she protested from behind her hand and Billy felt his smile reach sixty percent.

“What I mean is… Thank you,” he added, genuine and meaningful.

“Hmm…” Karen hummed in that strange mixture of happy and sad that Nancy also managed to balance. There was a pause for a moment before she shook herself off and headed back to the stairs. “Dinner is at six thirty. You should join us tonight. I’ll make extra.” And, with that, she was heading up and out of sight.

Notes:

In the absence of having his own, I wanted Billy to have a mother moment.
I know that Joyce would be a perfect choice but I... just have a soft spot for my interpretation of the Wheeler women.