Chapter Text
That morning Billy was awaken by many sounds all at one time. His watch he set before sleep was chiming rapidly with his alarm, and Max was standing over him, hands on her hips.
“Wake up!” She widened her eyes like she was old enough to be that exasperated by anything. “Why would you even set an alarm if you don’t wake up to it? Billy!”
With a groan Billy lifted his head from the pillow. He blinked sleep from his eyes as he took in his own bedroom, and his step sister standing over him with anger red as her hair. “About time. I was going to smash that watch.”
“Do it and you're dead, shitbird,” Billy’s words were not really threatening this early.
“Whatever. Mom’s got breakfast ready.” She said as an invitation and it was cute.
Billy glanced down at his watch and noticed he didn’t have much time to really enjoy a meal before he should be at the shop. “What did she make?” He sat up on his bed, his old band shirt clung sweaty to his torso, and a knitted blanket fell around his waist. Strange, he didn’t remember covering up with any blanket before he went to sleep.
“Pancakes and bacon. Better hurry I won’t save much for you.” Max was already at the door ready to leave but she replied over her shoulder.
Billy ran his hands through his long curls as he considered how to start his day. “I’m late. Can you bring me just like... a pancake with some bacon rolled in it?” The order was a little bit of a joke, but saying the words out loud Billy actually considered it might taste okay.
Max looked at him like he had two heads.
Their relationship was never the best, but they lived together and existed together as cohesive as they could.
After the night Billy broke into the Byers’ house and showed his true colors to the whole group, Max has been keeping him in check. Both with kindness where he needed it and mostly with threats. It’s been extremely helpful in more ways than one. She was the one who ordered Billy to apologize to Steve for turning his face a pretty shade of blue and purple.
She huffed out of his room with her hands in the air. Billy assumed he had a 50/50 shot of her actually coming back with that food.
He shifted more in his bed, deciding that he should finally move, and started pulling the blanket off his legs and gathering a change of clothes from the drawer before he made his way to the bathroom. He was in his top drawer when Max actually came back with a soft knock on the wood. She pressed the door open with her elbow and stood holding a glass of orange juice and a paper towel wrapped around a pancake with 2 strips of bacon in the middle.
“You are so fucking weird,” was all she muttered as she passed the food off to Billy who was wearing a shit eating grin.
“Watch your mouth, brat.” Billy should say thank you but he didn’t have that word in his vocabulary. Instead, he drank the orange juice whole in a few quick gulps just to show off how weird he could be, and also how thankful he was for the drink.
Max made a big show of rolling her eyes before she turned to leave again. Billy called out for her to wait, then he reached back over to his bed and grabbed the knitted blanket. The material was soft to the touch, smelt like Susan’s favorite fabric softener, and was colored neon pink and orange. He balled it in his hands to throw it hard right at Max’s face. He should say thank you for bringing him a blanket last night. “Might want to wash that,” is all he could get out.
Max replied with calling him a big idiot but her smile was obvious as she closed the door behind her.
After eating and showering Billy went straight for his car, trying and succeeding in not having to great the remaining members of his family. He was plenty on time but Billy really wanted to put on a good face by getting there early for Spencer. So he pressed the gas and drove quick to the shop.
When he got close, however, his heart sank down to his stomach. There was a ring of police cars around the small shop, their red and blue lights flickering off the metal of the garage doors. Billy groaned as he spotted Jim’s Jeep in the front of the pack.
The Camaro slowed as he drove up, a part of Billy wanted to turn back and pretend he was never there, but there was another part of him that could feel his name being whispered through the fallen leaves. Beckoning him to come closer and see for himself.
Billy pulled into the small space left behind a police cruiser and killed his engine. The hat that was given to him yesterday sat in the passengers seat looking squished, lonely. He tried not to notice it as he climbed out of the car.
“Police only by this point,” a thin officer with glasses tried to hold his hands out to block Billy, “sorry fella.”
There was a second Billy felt like being his old self. He could see himself crystal clear pushing this officer to the ground and kicking him in the stomach just for good measure, but he forced himself to remember that pancake with bacon rolled in it.
“Let me talk to Hopper,” he growled.
The thin guy opened his mouth but nothing could come out before the voice of Jim was interrupting them.
“Hargrove,” Jim was standing in the door way. The same open screen door Spencer watched the Camaro speed away from yesterday. Jim motioned his hand in a wave.
Billy shot the officer a shit eating grin as he pushed right past him going up to where Jim was standing.
He wasn’t overtly friendly with Jim, but he knew enough about him that he never looked scared. Yet now, as he walked in front of Billy to lead him into the tiny corner office of the shop, there was only the word scared on his face.
The metal desk still stood in the corner of the office as Billy remembered, but it’s chair was tipped over on its side, and the man who was once sitting it was sprawled out on the ground. Billy was standing back looking in from the doorway but he could see the lake of blood formed under that old mechanic jumpsuit. And he could see the blackened stump of a neck. And he could see no head.
Billy felt his feet move before the electricity in his brain told them to move. He lunged back out into the morning sunlight quicker than coming up for air from a dive. Billy stood a foot away from the open screen door just breathing.
Jim followed him slower, a morose look heavy on his face as he watched the boy collect himself. “Sorry. To show you that.” He mumbled around the butt of a cigarette.
Billy knew his hands were white knuckle fists at his side. “Is that...,” he needed to ask.
“Spencer. Spencer White, full name. He was up working late last night. Crunching some numbers and some papers. Some with your name on it, Hargrove. I was going to call you but this... works too.”
Billy forced himself to pull the business card he kept secure in his shirt’s front pocket. With tight movements he handed it over to Jim. “Yesterday he- he offered me a job.”
Jim turned the card over in his hands a few times reading it. He ran his thumb over the ink on the back. Then he let out a long sigh.
“Hoof prints behind the garage. Missing head. All signs saying we have a serial killer in Hawkins. Someone playing a damn game.” He grumbled low almost to himself. “This keeps coming back to you, Billy. But I know this is a small town. This could be nothing. Or it could really be something.” Billy watched as Jim’s posture changed, his shoulders took on a square shape and his eyes darkened as he looked down the inches he had on the younger boy. “It better be nothing.”
That was a threat, completely black and white. Billy had heard similar from his fathers mouth, back in California when he was asked why he never hanged around enough girls. The words rang like warning sirens echoing through the now tainted streets. Billy’s eyes were already wild from the scare of seeing a corpse, but now they were furious.
“You gonna ask me where I was last night, officer,” Billy put a smear on the word as if he was saying a curse. “You wanna call Stevie up and double check what time our date ended?”
Jim’s face was taken aback with that quickly, his shoulders lazed and his mouth slightly falling open. Billy knew he was close to snarling at the officer, or maybe he already was. “No, no, Billy... I-,”
“If you want to ask me go ahead,” Billy held his hands out and presented himself in front of a firing squad, “I’m gonna tell you right now I ain’t got shit to do with this. You either believe me or you don’t. I couldn’t give a rat’s ass.”
There was a moment of silence, a moment Billy feared he might have let his words take the situation too far, but Jim had nothing to reply. Billy put his arms down in a flurry, enjoying the loud noise of his hands slapping denim clad thighs. He continued to glare daggers into Jim.
“I ain’t insinuation, kid.” The older man ran his hand across his face in a show of exasperation. “I just don’t believe in coincidences.”
Billy sucked at his front teeth. That was as good as a yes from the small town cop. Yes, it seemed like he was at both scenes, and yes he was being treated like a suspect. Billy felt his throat swell from the sour betrayal he had to swallow down. After all Billy had done for the other man: saving his daughter then trying to sacrifice himself on the 4th of July when he finally came up from under the spell of the upside down. Billy thought he would be sitting in the good graces from the party, but he couldn't even sacrifice himself right.
He had thought wrong.
“Once a killer always a killer, hum, Hop?” Then on his old combat boots Billy turned tail and ran back to his car. He didn’t, couldn’t, hear the reply from the other. He just had to leave as quick as he could. Pushing with a hard shoulder past that same thin cop, he slammed his door shut behind him before spinning his tires to kick up as much dirt and mess and anger as the Camaro would allow.
Billy didn’t turn back into Hawkins. The old dusty town was full of ghosts as far as he was concerned. Ghosts, and handcuffs with his name on it. Billy drove until the red around his eyes started fading away and the water on his cheeks dried up.
He checked around at the street signs realizing he had driven a few county’s over. Nothing surprising, nothing he hadn’t done before.
The sun was setting now. Washing the sky in brilliant oranges and reds. Billy pulled into a small diner and just watched as the colors turned. Orange gave way to pink, purple, then a dark blue encased most of the sky. The night was coming and Billy just watched as it crept up. He leaned forward on his forearms, pressing them hard into the steering wheel, and found himself praying. Not to the god his father believes in, or even to the god his mother believed in, he was praying to a god in human form. A god with chocolate brown hair and moles on his skin.
Billy didn’t know why but he turned the key in the ignition and turned around back to Hawkins. He didn’t know why but he felt himself driving home. Billy felt like an absolute coward as he crawled back the only way he knew how.
It was a little after the sun finished setting, not so dark but dark enough the street lights were flickering on. Billy drove his street for the thousandth time without expecting anything different, maybe a sheriffs Jeep waiting for him, but he fully wasn’t expecting a little red BMW parked brazenly across from his front yard.
Steve stood in the street, leaned back against his drivers door, with his arms crossed over his chest facing the house. The brunette boy had his hair styled back cleanly and a brown coat with tawny fur lining around the collar stretched with the effort of crossing his arms. The jacket was a nice outfit choice, Billy thought painfully, because the way Steve seemed to bristle with anger mirrored the messy fur around his neck.
There were hours before his show started so he had the time, but Billy wished he didn’t waste it on him.
The Camaro settled into silence on the other side of the street. He got out slowly, chewing his lip as he looked around at the house. Sure enough, Neil’s truck was parked meaning the man was home. Now was not the best time to be nursing Steve down from a fight.
“Billy,” Steve opened with a sharp voice as he lowered his arms to walk towards the other, but before he could Billy was already crossing the street in long strides.
“You shouldn’t be here,” Billy breathed out.
“What?” Confusion on the doe eyed boy looked so good it was distracting. “I shouldn’t be here? I came here to find you! Hopper has been calling me non stop begging me to-,”
Billy cut him off with a dismissive flick of his hand. “I don’t give a shit about Hopper,” he dragged the name again, “and whatever he said to you it’s not true, okay? He’s just a bullshit small town cop that gets easily worked up.” Steve had his confusion gone and replaced with a tight lipped glare. “You know you cannot be here.” Billy enunciated each word with a point towards Steve’s chest. Hopefully he was pushing his point, but Steve never backed down easily.
“Are you done?” The annoyance in his voice was knife sharp. “Hopper told me enough. He said you were the one who jumped to conclusions. After everything do you really think we would label you a killer?” His eyes grew soft as he spoke, all the emotion overflowing into each word. “Everyone you saved-“
“I’m the one who jumped, hum? Did he tell you all about how good old Spencer from Spencer’s Shop got his head taken off? How that leaves me 2 for 2 at being at the scene of a crime?” Billy felt his words roll out hot and heavy without care that he was spitting them right into Steve’s face.
“He didn’t-“
“Yeah I figured. Doesn’t fucking matter though, the only thing that matters is I need you to leave!” Billy was just below shouting.
Steve took a step forward into Billy’s space. There already wasn’t much room where he had huddled the boy up against his car door, but now Steve pushed himself closer, wrapping his cold thin fingers with a bruising grip around the collar of Billy’s jacket.
“Billy,” his voice, lowered now to a whisper, almost drew a whimper from Billy’s throat. “If it’s something to do with the mind flayer. The upside down. Tell me. Please, tell me. I’ll fight it with you! You don’t have to be alone, not like last time. We’ve won before and we can do it again-“
Their lips were inches apart when Billy separated his in a growl. “You shouldn’t be here...“
And as if on cue, Steve’s fingers went lax on their hold, his body going a step back into the metal of his car. Billy didn’t have to turn around to see that Steve was looking at the porch of the Hargrove house. The night around them seemed the only grow darker.
Billy took a step back into the road, letting his eyes linger on Steve’s sunken face for a moment more, before he turned around and stomped up his yard. Neil was blocking his path by standing in the door way. His mustache was coiled tight under his nose and he watched unblinking as Steve got in his car to drive away. Then his eyes turned to look at his son.
“Harrington?” He asked.
Billy felt his body hurt all over. He never wanted his father to see or speak about Steve. He tried so hard to keep them separated, warning with fire in his eyes for the boy to never come to the house. Now hearing his name on his fathers lips was like nails being hammered inside of his skin.
“Yeah,” he managed through chewing and swallowing those nails.
Neil kept his cold eyes on Billy as he stepped off the porch and started to the back of the house. There was a hill beside the Hargrove house that almost hid a car port, almost being key because Billy could still see the tail of that ugly truck from the street. He followed his father with heavy footsteps.
“Why was he here? Why didn’t he come inside?” Neil had many questions. Billy couldn’t give him any answers.
Instead of accepting silence, each question was enunciated with a fist to Billy’s gut. The car port was one of his favored places to manhandle the boy because it couldn’t been seen from looking out the screen door above them. Not from Susan, not from Max, as long as Billy was quiet. So he grit his teeth and stayed quiet.
“Your prissy rich boyfriend thinks he’s too good for us?” Neil was spitting across Billy’s face with his words. The spit was mixing with tears running down Billy’s cheeks. “You god damn faggots have no respect for anyone!” With that it wasn’t so much the punch that sent Billy over, but that disgusting word directed at Steve, that finally knocked the boy to his knees.
Billy clutched his stomach as he groveled on the ground, taking long gulps of air between sputtering breaths. Neil stood over him flexing his hands like he won a fight. They stayed like that, winner and loser, until a soft voice called out from the screen door above.
Neil turned to the porch to make sure they were not joined. Then with a tilt of his head he looked down at his son. “Get up. Inside your room, boy. No dinner.” He spoke each string of commands crueler than the next.
Billy struggled to find his hands then struggled more to pull himself up from the dirty driveway. He didn’t look at Neil as he went. Inside he ran past Susan, neither chanced a look at the other, it went without saying that she simply didn’t want to know.
Billy finally got to the safety of his room, closing the door behind him, then let himself fall back onto the floor. He cried there, noise muffled into the carpet. There was no strength in him to change clothes, crawl to the bed, check the time, or even turn on the radio. He just laid there letting his tears soak into the dirty tuffs of brown and he didn’t know when he finally fell asleep.
Neil had gone inside to eat with his family like nothing was wrong. He laughed with Susan and asked Max about school work. He ate his fill of meatloaf and green beans and then excused himself back outside with a kiss on top of his wife’s head. Never once did he check in on his son.
Warm from a good meal, Neil went outside into the cold October air where his swollen knuckles got some relief. There was the same fog from the nights before rolling, what seemed like, from out of the trees and down the street. Neil opened the door to his truck and switched on the radio. He turned the dial a few times trying to tune to just the right station before a clear voice let him know when to stop.
“Now with that boring weather out of the way, I’ve got a special surprise for you guys listening! So I was able to convince the producer at the station that because she ripped my heart out and stomped on it not once, but two times! That she owes me a favor! So I’ve opened the phone lines again.” Neil felt his skin bristle from hearing Steve Harrington’s preppy voice and soft laughter over the air. It made him want to lumber back inside and and start round two in teaching lessons about responsibility and respect. But instead he pinched the cigarette he was smoking between his fingers and listened intently.
“I don’t trust myself entertaining you tonight all alone. Don’t want to be a wet blanket. So Hawkins, can you do me a favor, too? Can you call in the station and let me know if you’ve ever been in love?”
Neil’s grip on his cigarette was white knuckle, his breath mixing with the smoke and the fog around him like dragon’s anger. He didn’t notice that the fog had rolled down into their quaint little car port. Didn’t notice the heavy falling of horse hooves down the street.
The sword went silent through the air and Neil almost didn’t notice until he absolutely had too. His body slumped forward and collapsed into the ground, not unlike how Billy was laid out earlier, but Neil’s head didn’t tumble forward with his body. The car’s radio kept playing into the night like nothing happened.
“So, while I’m queuing your calls, I’m going to play some of my favorite songs. Starting with ‘I left my heart in San Francisco’. I bet they don’t have such terrible weather over there.”
