Chapter Text
By the time they’d gotten the hell out of dodge, it was apparently all over. The gate was sealed, the Mind Fillet or whatever had been driven out of Will, and they were left to lick their wounds as the first hints of sunlight rose over the horizon.
It wasn’t exactly as peaceful as it sounded. This was not helped by the fact that someone - Dustin – had let it slip without any preamble that Steve had been “hiding his cool powers from them all along,” which wasn’t exactly how Steve was planning to broach the topic with the rest of their group, but hey, when had his plans ever worked out like he’d wanted? And he’d said he was going to stop hiding this stuff anyway, hadn’t he?
Just maybe not the same night they’d had to fend off an inter-dimensional threat. Again.
“So you’re… from the lab? Like El?” Nancy asked, looking at him like he was seeing an alien in Steve’s place. Which, frankly, was kind of fair. She’d just found out her ex-boyfriend had superpowers. “And you knew this whole time?” She directed her accusatory stare at Hopper, who just held out his hands.
“Didn’t get it till El showed up, but yeah.” He sighed. “God, back when I thought a kidnapping was the worst thing to ever happen in Hawkins.”
“Holy shit,” Jonathan breathed, looking about as baffled as Nancy. It was almost kind of cute, the way their expressions mirrored each other, if Steve wasn’t still nursing a little annoyance at the two of them. “I totally remember that now. Mom wouldn’t let me play outside for like a week.”
“Wasn’t exactly a fun time for me either,” Steve said pointedly, and Jonathan had the good grace to look at least a little embarrassed. “Right. Well, now that this is all out in the open, I’m gonna grab some fresh air, yeah?” He didn’t wait for a response, instead heading out onto the Byers’ front porch and letting the door swing shut behind him.
He was better off telling them the truth, he knew – they’d seen enough and been through more than enough that he had no doubts they’d accept it without a problem – but he couldn’t deal with the pitying looks, the sympathy that all but radiated from all of their emotions. Maybe he’d just spent too long bottling shit up, maybe he was fucked up in a permanent way, a way he didn’t know how to fix, but when they looked at him like that…
“What brings you out here?” Billy, sitting on the porch stairs and apparently watching the sun come up, cigarette between his fingers wafting thin curls of smoke, twisted to look at him. There wasn’t any hostility in his gaze anymore, at least not in this moment. It was like they were back at that party again, but this time there was no excuse of drunkenness to smooth out their rough edges.
It was funny, how much a single night could change things between them.
Steve sat heavily next to him, taking the olive branch for what it was. “Smoke break?” he tried, looking hopefully at Billy until he rolled his eyes and passed his cigarette. Steve had never been a huge smoker, but if you couldn’t smoke to calm your nerves after what he’d gone through today, when could you?
They sat in relative silence for a while, just watching the sun come up, passing the cigarette back and forth. It was weird, avoiding people he’d been close to for the last year to seek out the company of someone he’d barely entered into civil speaking terms with, but not in a bad way. He was really, really tired of fighting with Billy.
Eventually, it was Billy who broke the silence. “I should get Max home soon,” he said, still staring off towards the road. “There’s not a lie in the world that’s gonna explain why it took so long.” The corners of his mouth turned down in a grimace. “Neil’ll be pissed either way.”
It wasn’t really something Steve had much experience with. When your parents routinely fucked off and left you with your big house all to yourself, you stopped having much of a concept of curfew or parental concern. Not that parental concern was the issue here, judging by the way Billy spoke. Now, shitty parents, that Steve knew.
“Then don’t go.” The words slipped out without conscious thought, but Steve didn’t take them back. “Not yet at least. Most of Hawkins is still asleep anyway.”
Billy shook his head. “Better to do it earlier.” But he didn’t make any move to stand, and Steve didn’t remind him.
“Harrington.”
“Yeah?”
“Why’d you do that, back in the tunnels?” Billy shifted a little, and Steve couldn’t help but pick up on his discomfort when their arms brushed. “Save my life, I mean.”
Steve raised an eyebrow. “You would have preferred I let that thing eat you?”
Billy glared, his eyes effectively communicating that’s not what I meant, you dumbass. “Look. I’m just saying that if it was me, if some dickhead who’d been shitty to me since we first met was standing there about to get his head bitten off by one of those Demofuckers… I don’t think I would have done what you did.”
Steve actually considered it for a minute. Why had he? He had every reason to hate Billy. If it hadn’t been for the interruption of his powers and that Demodog in the fridge, Billy might have beaten the shit out of him last night. And yet he hadn’t hesitated. When it came right down to it, he couldn’t bring himself to hate Billy at all.
“I don’t think that’s true. I mean, you saved me right before that too.” Billy looked like he was about to protest, so Steve plowed on. “You act like a dick all the time, but you’re not, are you? You only pretend to be an ass because you can’t stand the thought of someone actually seeing you.”
Billy’s eyes narrowed further. “I’m not like you, Harrington. I don’t have shit to hide.” But both of them knew that wasn’t true. Even before tonight, they’d known on some level.
“Aren’t you sick of lying to yourself all the time?”
“I don’t have your weird powers-”
“Fuck the powers! This isn’t about them. This is about you, and me, and whatever the fuck this,” he gestured emphatically between the two of them, “is. And don’t fucking deny it, you already know I’m like a goddamn human lie detector.”
“Fuck off, Harrington.” Billy dropped the remainder of the cigarette, stomping it out with his boot heel. He tried to stand, but Steve grabbed his arm.
“And now you’re running away!” He breathed deep, trying to calm the swirl of his and Billy’s combined emotions in his head. “Listen. I get it. If anyone gets it, hiding a part of yourself, it’s me. And it doesn’t have to be today. It doesn’t have to be me. But just… just try to tell yourself the truth for once.”
Billy pulled free of his grasp, but the fight in his gaze was gone. “I have to go get Max,” he said, and started off towards the house. This time Steve let him go.
~~~
The rest of the month passed in blessed uneventfulness. It took a while, but everyone else got over the powers thing – it wasn’t like it was the weirdest thing they’d ever heard of, and his desire to have kept them secret before was understandable enough. With the year’s Upside Down threat behind them (and no, Steve was not being paranoid by expecting another one next year, he was being perfectly reasonable all things considered), they all tried to appreciate the relative calm.
Billy didn’t talk to him again, not even when they were the last ones in the locker room. He didn’t fuck with him either, which Steve supposed he should have been grateful for. It probably shouldn’t have felt as disappointing as it was.
One thing, however, had changed. Thanks to his babysitting abilities, he’d gotten roped into ferrying the kids around between the arcades and varying basements for multiple-hours-long Dungeons and Dragons games. This meant he was, despite his protests, dragged into their sessions, much to Dustin’s excitement.
“I put up a force field.”
“Your character is a paladin, Steve! You don’t have any force field spells!” Mike bitched, pointing at something on Steve’s character sheet he knew Steve wasn’t even going to glance at, why did he bother? “You can cast Shield of Faith, but it’s not going to do shit against a Beholder!”
“That’s total bullshit,” Steve grumbled. “I can do it in real life but not in the damn game?” He nodded towards El, who was watching the conflict with wide eyes. “And she gets to use her powers!”
Mike rolled his eyes so hard Steve honestly worried he was going to scramble his brains. “She’s a level four warlock, you’re level one!”
“Alright, fine, fine. I’ll hit it with the pointy stick then.” He ignored Lucas’ pointed correction of it’s called a polearm, Steve and rolled. A one stared up at him. Max tried and failed to cover up her bark of laughter. He slumped back in his chair. “Of course.”
The die abruptly spun in place, flipping over to reveal a 20 instead. He raised an eyebrow at El. “Friends help friends,” she said simply, giving him a small smile.
Before he could reply, the doorbell sounded from upstairs. They were all crowded into the Wheeler’s basement, so Steve hadn’t realized how late it had gotten until the noise reminded him that parents would probably be coming by to pick up the kids soon. “Don’t all jump up to get it at once,” he said when the kids just looked at him, rising and heading up the stairs.
The person waiting on the doorstep was not, in fact, a parent, but was instead Billy Hargrove. Upon seeing Steve, he fixed his gaze somewhere above Steve’s left shoulder, radiating discomfort. “Uh, you must be here for Max. I’ll go get her-”
“Wait.” Billy grabbed his arm, fingers closing around his wrist. Steve paused. “I have to talk to you first. In private.” Billy glanced past him, then tugged Steve outside and shut the door. Steve stumbled with the momentum, catching himself before he could look like a total idiot.
Despite his insistence on needing to talk to him, Billy remained silent, just staring at him. It was getting a little weird. “Uh, dude-”
“Shut up.” Billy took a deep breath, then sighed just as heavily. “I thought about what you said. About not lying to myself.”
Steve froze. “Oh?” he forced past his lips, hoping he didn’t sound as hopeful – surprised, damn it, not hopeful – as he felt.
“It’s different here. Than California, I mean.” Billy shifted his weight. “Not that it ever mattered much to Neil where we were but…”
Steve tried not to let his disappointment show. Maybe he’d been an idiot to think Billy Hargrove, of all people, had pulled him aside to have a private conversation that would have ended in some sort of, what? Some big love confession like Steve would have pulled for Nancy a year ago? Even if Steve was being honest with himself – which he was trying to do more often these days – and knew how he felt about Billy, despite his best efforts, it didn’t mean Billy felt any sort of way about Steve. He’d just deluded himself into thinking it, maybe, but he had been so sure of what he had felt that night, down in the tunnels, saving each other’s lives…
“What I’m trying to say,” Billy said, cutting into Steve’s thoughts, “is that it couldn’t be like California. So if this whole ‘open and honest’ push of yours means that’s a deal breaker, then-”
“A deal breaker?” Steve repeated, dumbstruck. Was Billy trying to say what he thought he was?
“Well, is it or isn’t it?” Billy looked supremely uncomfortable, a far cry from his usual casual sprawl. It was a nice change of pace, and Steve might have reveled in it more if his heart hadn’t been pounding in his throat. Because this was – holy shit, this was actually happening, and he was taking too long to answer and Billy was starting to look at him funny and he should really say something-
“Yes!” Billy flinched, and Steve mentally replayed his question. “No, I mean – no, it's not a deal breaker. It is definitely not a deal breaker.” It wasn’t like Steve was exactly itching to come out. Not lying to yourself was one thing; making a reckless decision like that was a whole other.
All of the tension left Billy’s shoulders in an instant. “Cool,” he said, some of his usual blind confidence returning. “That’s – cool. I’m glad.” He paused. “Well, I should probably get Max.”
“Oh, right.” Steve followed Billy back inside, waiting upstairs while he collected her from the basement. As they headed for the door again, Billy glanced back, gave a private little grin, and said, “See ya around, Harrington.”
Steve couldn’t help his answering smile, even if he was sure it made him look like a total dumbass.
“Yeah. See ya around, Hargrove.”
