Actions

Work Header

I Don't Care

Chapter 29: We Could Have Been So Good Together

Summary:

The plot twist everybody saw coming except for Steve

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

2nd March, Saturday

After they had returned home from their cold hike, Steve asked Billy if he wanted to stay over for awhile. He was trying to give this friend thing a go, now that he had finally come to terms with Billy Hargrove, the Billy Hargrove, being his friend. Okay, maybe he was still coming to terms with it. Who was he kidding, he was trying to come to terms with the fact he loved Billy, and could never act upon it. He remembered the definition of being a friend. Doing something for the other person.

“Listen, Billy, this friendship has been pretty one-sided. And I've been...you know me, a failure at everything, especially at being a friend. I want you to be more ha...”, he stopped himself, happy wasn't the right word, he was not going to turn into a mushy friend. “I want you to become less annoying.”

“Is that so”, Billy took a bite from an apple, looking slightly amused.

“Let's get the girl.”

“The girl?”, Billy seemed confused now, and a bit worried, “What girl?” Steve rolled his eyes, seriously why was Billy so cagey about all this, wasn't in his character at all.

“The girl, your girl, the one where your face lights up when you talk about her.” Like Steve did when he talked to Billy.

“Oh that girl”, Billy laughed, “Sure, we'll get the girl”, he shook his head taking another bite.

“C'mon Billy, I'm doing something nice here. 20 questions, c'mon, I'll guess who she is.”

“You never will”, Billy sounded pretty sure of himself.

“Try me.”

“Okay, the girl will be at the party tonight. She'll stand outside. She won't drink. She'll have a mixtape in her car. She'll be worried about her brother, and his friends”, Billy had been avoiding his glance, but now he turned towards Steve, “She'll overthink everything. She'll be nervous and anxious, but she'll still go.”

“Why?”, Steve asked breathlessly, somewhat enthralled in Billy's narrative of the mysterious girl.

“Because she thinks she doesn't deserve anyone's love.”

“How do you know so much about her?”

“We've talked.”

“What?”, this was entirely new information, Billy had a lazy smile on his face now. “Why haven't you told me yet? Friends are supposed to tell each other everything”, Steve knew that he was exaggerating, but right now he didn't care he was channeling his inner Mike, he needed to get the point across.

“I'm not sure she feels the same way, Steve”, Billy looked at him expectantly. As if Steve could give him a great relationship tip with his track record being so abysmal, but he was here to help, there was an off chance this might just work.

“Well, you have to find out, right? Take the chance. I mean if she doesn't feel the same way you'll have to watch love movies with me, and eat ice cream like I did with Dustin.” Billy didn't say anything, time seemed to have slowed, a pang of jealousy when Steve thought about the perfect girl. Again he wasn't the one, again second choice, he shook his head, Billy would still be his friend even if he had a girlfriend, right? Right? The selfish part of him wanted the girl not to date Billy. Feeling guilty for even thinking that he took a deep breath trying to push personal feelings on the matter aside.

“Just come to the party, Steve. She'll stand at the pool”, Billy sounded sad now.

“It'll be okay, you know the effect you have on girls”, Steve tried to give him a pep talk, “And she sounds really nice.”

“Yes, she's perfect, I don't deserve her, you know.” Billy put his hand next to Steve's, coming a little closer, but not too close.

“Are you okay?”, Steve was more than a little confused by how mournful Billy seemed. “I mean she hasn't even said no yet. You don't have to be...”, he tried to find a better word than sad, but his brain remained blank, “Sad.”

Billy shook his head, “Come to the party, and you'll understand”, he checked his wristwatch, “I gotta go, Steve. You know where the party is?”

“The one at Claire's house?”

“Yep, see you at ten”, Billy quickly walked to the door, none of the usual Billy swagger left. Steve stayed on the couch for awhile longer trying to understand what had just happened. Had he gone too far, was Billy mad he intruded his love life? He'd just wanted to help. Maybe he wanted to help himself as well. If Billy were to have a girlfriend Steve's feelings towards Billy might grow colder again.

“Dustin, come in. Over”, he knew the boy could help him, he seemed to understand people better than Steve.

“Hey Steve, everything alright? Over.”

“Ahm...this is a little awkward to explain, okay if I had a friend who is in love with this girl, and I volunteered to get them together...”

“This is about Billy? Over.”

“No...wait how did you know that?”

“Because you either hang out with us, or Billy. Over.”

“Okay, fine Billy is the friend. Anyway I volunteered, and he wants me to meet her at the party. But he thinks she's not in love with him. Over.”

“Why? I mean it's Billy. Almost every girl loves him. Over.”

“Right? That's what I said”, Steve ran a hand through his hair, “He was pretty torn up about it. Do you think I overstepped a boundary? Over.”

“I don't think so. I mean why would he want you to meet her anyway? Over”, Dustin sounded honestly baffled.

“Maybe he wants to....Hell, I don't know how his mind work, he's pretty mysterious most of the time. Over.”

“Part of his charm”, Dustin huffed, “Well just go there, meet her. Probably you'll understand why he thinks she won't say yes. Maybe she's a straight A-student, nerd girl. Over”, Dustin laughed.

“That would be something. Over.”

“Or a Mum. Over.”

Now Steve was getting a little more nervous, “I hope not. Over.”

“Tell me how it went. Over”, Dustin said a little louder, getting excited.

“Okay, I'll talk to you tomorrow, thanks. Over and Out.”

“Have fun. Over and Out.”

 

Steve threw his bat in the trunk, and started the engine. The mixtape coming to life. His mind was partly on the mysterious girl, but also on Dustin, and the kids. They seemed to be doing alright, but he should check up on all of them make sure the icebreaking incident hadn't brought about long-lasting scars. He hadn't done it before because especially Mrs. Henderson, Joyce and Hopper had been pretty concerned for their kids, talking about it all the time. As he thought about all this he realised the party was at the same house the Christmas party had been, when he'd crossed paths with Billy and Max. After he had humiliated himself in front of them. Steve got out of his car, he was nervous now, didn't even know why. It seemed to him this would be a turning point in Billy's life, and also in his. Would she even like Steve? Girlfriends required time, and freshly in love everything else dims, only the girl is on your mind. Who was he kidding, Billy would probably lose interest him. He'll just be Steve, a boy he had to make up to, he peaked into this boy's world, only to get the girl and take her to California.

But he still had to go because Billy was his friend, and he wanted to see Billy happy. It didn't matter the personal cost. He shoved his hands into his pockets, head held high, 'I don't care'. This time around he didn't get as sick from the strobing lights, or the loud music. But he was still glad when he crossed through the crowd of people without anybody talking to him, and the ringing in his ears subsided as he stepped onto the porch. The pool opposed to his pool was actually filled with water, even though it was still the middle of winter. Who in their right mind would even go outside, it was just above the freezing point. And he was only here because of his, how had the doctor put it, still healing brain that couldn't stand the commotion inside. Coming to think of it why were they meeting outside? And what type of girl would Billy even fall in love with?

He waited, rubbing his hands together, trying to keep warm, his breath came out as a white puff in the dim light coming from the house, muffled music coming from inside. He looked at the teens, dancing, kissing, making out, having the time of their lives. And he was here on the outside like always, it reminded him of his old life. Steve shuddered, he didn't care, he was here for a friend. His hands were itching for the bat, he took a deep breath directing his eyes towards the stars, and not the neverending darkness of the woods.

The porch door opened, Steve turned around, expecting the girl, but it wasn't her, it was Billy.

“Hey, you came”, still this sad smile on his face as if he knew something Steve didn't.

“Of course I came. Where is she? It's eight past.” Billy came closer, eyes fixed on the smooth surface of the untouched water in the pool, stars reflecting in it. “Billy?”, Steve asked, not sure what to make of the situation. He finally looked up again, his face serious. “Billy, if you don't want to meet her today, we don't have to. I didn't mean to push you”, Steve said. Billy nodded, and Steve went towards the door, ready to open it, when Billy grabbed his wrist.

“Wait. Steve, come back”, his voice trembling.

“Okay”, in the dim light Steve couldn't check for any bruising, but the thought of maybe Billy's father having to do with the state of Billy was in creeping up on him. Billy didn't say anything, he hadn't let go of Steve's wrist, holding onto it, he took a deep breath, then looked at Steve, nervously biting his lips.

“She is right here”, he finally said, it sounded like it had taken him everything to say it out loud.

“Right here?”, Steve turned his head around, maybe he had not spotted her, would she come out of the shadows? But there wasn't anybody else outside. “Billy, we're the only ones here”, was Billy drunk? His brain racing with the sheer amount of possibilities.

“She has a bat in her car.”

“Really, that's weird”, Steve didn't know any baseball clubs in the area. Billy laughed, pained it sounded wrong in the cool night air.

“A spiked one.”

“A spiked one?”, why would anybody need a spiked bat apart from the obvious reason of hunting demodogs of course.

“Don't you get it?”, Billy desperate now, tears in his eyes, the grip tightened, “It's you. You are the girl, Steve!” Steve's racing mind came to a halting stop midthought, he felt a little lightheaded, not understanding what Billy was trying to tell him. Billy waited for him to say something, but he didn't know what to say.

“Dammit, Steve, I love you!”, Billy almost shouted, “How dense can you be?! I pretty much told you countless times already.”

Steve gaped at him, “I thought there was a girl...”, he said weakly, his head spinning.

“I sent all the signals, and you didn't notice them. I mean it was adorable at first until it wasn't.”

“The signals?”, Steve asked in bewilderment, remembering a few instances, the touches, the excuses to spend more time with him. Billy's rather passive aggressive comment that Steve wouldn't notice flirting if it hit him square in the face. He could hear the music in the background going on as if nothing had happened, as if his entire world hadn't changed. “So there never was a girl”, he spluttered out.

“No, of course not”, Billy almost sounded mad now, but his grip still on Steve's wrist grounding him in the moment, he prayed Billy would never let go. But if the girl had been Steve all along that meant the way Billy's expression changed when he talked about her, like she was the only thing that mattered was in fact Steve, it slowly sunk in. Billy shook his head.

“I'm sorry”, he leaned forward cupping Steve's face, coming so close like all the other times, their foreheads touching, but this time neither of them pulled away. Transfixed by the sensation of being so close, directly looking into Billy's eyes, as his mind was screaming at him to make sense of this rollercoaster. Mere inches between their lips, Billy's hand resting softly on his cheek, he leaned in and kissed him. Steve couldn't move, completely frozen his system in shock, the butterflies in his stomachs going wild it felt like a surge of electricity going through him.

Billy pulled away, a tear rolling down his cheek, and letting go of Steve's wrist, and turned around disappearing into the night. Leaving Steve standing there, it was colder now, he missed Billy's touch, his hand around his wrist and the touch of his lips. Steve knew he should catch up with Billy, run after him like in Mrs. Henderson's love movies, and kiss Billy back. But he couldn't move, he was meant to lose Billy tonight, but not like this. He wanted to make Billy happy, but he didn't know it was also his happiness. That he wasn't second best for once in his life, but first choice.

Standing alone between the forest, and the house full of people he softly whispered, “What just happened?”

Notes:

AWWW, they finally kissed♥ I just have way too much fun writing slow burns...and with fun I mean trying not to get too emotionally attached and frustrated. I was getting pretty impatient myself *looking at you, Steve*. I hope I let nobody down, and you enjoyed it as much I did writing it....There is more to come though, because true love's course is never easy, hope to see you all next chapter