Chapter Text
Slightly licking his bottom lip, Hannibal suddenly smiled. “You have distracted me from finishing dinner, Mister Graham,” he stated, removing his finger from Will’s chin. With a twist of his Oxford, he circled back to the island, settling behind the ingredients once more. “If we continue these interactions, I may not have enough time to feed us.” He turned his back to him and reached over to the oven, twisting the knob to 325 degrees Fahrenheit and pressing the start button to preheat it. In the process, he made eye contact with the tall bottle of red wine sitting on the cabinet and immediately grasped it by its neck. “But first, I must insist on a drink. It seems as though we’ll be here for a while.”
Will thought about it for a moment, adjusting his glasses. “I suppose,” he stuttered with a nod, “but I really must be leaving soon; I have to feed my dogs their late-night treats before they take their agitation out on my pillows again.”
With a quiet sigh, Hannibal pried open the cabinet near the stove hood, using only a small percentage of the strength he’d possessed. “Dogs are often considered man’s best friend: I’m sure they wouldn’t resent you or your pillows too much for your tardiness.” He scanned the multitude of plentiful glasses before his eyes landed on the ones he desired most: possibly the tallest of them all, with an intricate design crossing from the bottom of the glass to its stem. Feeling the imprinted pattern against his fingertips, he gently took them into his hold and placed them near the vegetables. “Much like dogs, I would rather enjoy my dinner with a good companion than alone.”
Hannibal slid the drawer to his left open, immediately seizing the corkscrew. Using the chef’s knife he used earlier, he sliced into the foil surrounding the top, peeling it away with the tip of his index finger to reveal the lid of the bottle. Opening the lever and pulling out the helix, he placed it off-center from the cork, turning the gadget to the right. A grunt left his lips as he lifted the wood from the bottle, softly chuckling to himself. “There we go,” he murmured, filling both glasses halfway and sliding one to his companion. “Enjoy.”
Accepting the wine with another nod, Will’s gaze dropped down to the glass, noticing Hannibal’s hand still wrapped around the stem. The grasp he held wasn’t threatening or uninviting: it was simply lingering, like the smell of his woody cologne. Reaching over the island, he placed his hand on top of Hannibal’s, feeling his hardened skin. There was a spark of interest glinting in the psychiatrist’s pupils; he knew his patient’s skepticism about him and his motives, and it felt almost relieving to have someone of such intelligence enthralled by him. His counterpart’s eyes flickered with the complete opposite: he felt shame for enjoying such psychotic back-and-forth behavior.
“Don’t be so afraid, Will,” Hannibal soothed, his voice as silky as the wine he’d poured for them. “You have spent years teaching yourself not to recognize certain impulses. I can relate.” Slowly, his hand retracted from the glass, sliding from beneath Will’s. “Though only one of us seems to bottle our emotions and store them away with the skeletons in our closet.”
Standing upright, Will took the glass into his hands, clearly contemplating an answer. Deep down, he knew that the man in front of him was right: he had been trying to silence the evil thoughts that played on the back of his mind like a broken record. Ever since the murder of Garrett Jacob Hobbs, the idea of going on a murderous streak like the Chesapeake Ripper hadn’t quite settled. Seeing the psychiatrist only seemed to fuel those desires rather than tame them.
Raising the wine glass to his lips, he took a sip. The liquid coated his tongue with a bitter taste as he watched Hannibal roll a nutmeg seed toward him and place it on the chopping board. Will could still feel the lingering touch of Hannibal beneath his fingertips; he could still see the intrigued expression upon his face as he removed his hand from the glass; he could still feel his heart thumping in his chest, as a rabbit might thump its foot. He quietly swallowed, taking another sip of the red wine.
“Would you like to aid me?” Hannibal suddenly asked, taking the grater he’d set aside and scooting it in front of him. The rubber at the bottom of the small gadget squeaked softly against the steel island. “You can be my sous chef for the night.”
Obviously not expecting the request, Will nearly choked on the wine in his mouth, looking at Hannibal with a confused expression. “I was never a good cook,” he murmured with a nervous chuckle, placing the glass down as Hannibal wiped his hands on his apron. “I will teach you, as my aunt taught me in France. Grating is much like slicing, which,” he paused, tapping his tongue against the roof of his mouth, “could be risky for someone with below-average skill.”
Will scoffed in disbelief as Hannibal sipped on his wine. “Are you afraid I might harm myself?” The patient inquired, cocking his head slightly to the left. Slowly, he walked around the sharp edge of the island, his boots thudding against the floor. “I have the idea that you’re trying to intimidate me, Doctor Lecter.” A smug smile spread across his lips as he watched him set his glass down; mockery would be the perfect word to describe such behavior. “Either that, or you have little to no faith in me, which I find astonishing, given our past.”
Hannibal tsked. “Intimidation is how we as humans improve ourselves.” Stepping back from the island, he gestured for his patient to stand in front of him. He focused on Will’s movements as he took the grater into his hands, examining it from top to bottom. “I assume you know the name of the object you're holding?”
“I’ll be grating nutmeg, so,” he mockingly thought about it for a moment, “I suppose this would be the grater?” Will turned his head and looked over his shoulder, glimpsing the small smile spread across Hannibal’s face. “That would be correct, my dear Will. I am intrigued by your intelligence,” he teased, untying the apron from his waist and placing it on the counter. “I should have allowed you to aid me in something a bit easier, like mincing the garlic.”
Will hummed, taking the nutmeg into his hold. “I’ll be fine.” He looked down at the grater before turning back to Hannibal. “Trust me,” he whispered, moving his face closer to his.
The psychiatrist nodded, feeling Will’s breath caress his nose and cheeks. “If I didn’t, I would have done it myself.” He glanced down at the grater in his hands, watching his finger gently slide against the holes. “But I must show you how to properly handle it.” Bending down beside his patient’s leg, he opened the cabinet door, grabbing another metallic grater from his unlimited supply of gadgets. The one Hannibal stood with was almost identical to the other, the only difference being the color of the rubber at the bottom. “You will watch me before attempting, understood?”
Hannibal grasped the nutmeg in his right hand, pinching it with his thumb and index finger. He carefully placed the seed against the grater’s sharp teeth. “Beware the holes; once it jabs your skin, you will immediately begin to bleed.” Angling the object at 45 degrees, he slowly grated the nutmeg into a small glass bowl, the light brown dust slightly falling onto the stainless-steel surface. “Messes are bound to happen in kitchens. As my mother used to tell me, a messy kitchen equals good food.”
Will quietly hummed. “Wise words. I take it you live by them?”
“Why wouldn’t I? My mother was a wise woman: she would speak phrases that resonated with my life, even when I was too young to understand.” Hannibal glanced at Will, his eyes carrying a saddened twinkle. It was unlike how he’d normally present himself, especially when he prepared anything edible. “As I’ve grown older, I began to realize just how much I would have benefited from her care, had she not passed when I needed her most.”
Seeing Will’s mouth twitch as if he wanted to add to the conversation, Hannibal cleared his throat and raised the grater higher into the air. He softly patted its back and watched the powder hiding in the holes slowly fall into the bowl. The smell of the spice filled his nostrils as he placed the grater aside, using the dark blue cloth beside the wine to wipe the spilled dust. “It is not impossible,” he lulled, scooping the dust into his hand and throwing it into the trash can. “I can only hope that you followed my every move, Mister Graham; I put much faith in you, though I know you don’t quite think so.”
Scoffing again, Will grabbed the grater, just as he’d watched. “I am unconvinced that grating something so small will be that much of a hassle,” he quipped, a slight smirk on his handsome face. Placing the nutmeg onto the sharp teeth, he copied Hannibal’s movements perfectly, from tilting it to a certain degree to patting it free of any dust that may have been stuck between the tiny sockets. Once he’d finished, he set the grater on its side, the nutmeg in the bowl being slid next to where the chef had laid his.
Impressed, Hannibal chuckled. “Exceptionally done, my dear Will. You’ve blown me away with such skill.” He raised his hand and placed it on his shoulder, giving his muscles a slight squeeze. “We must now move on to something else—since, I imagine, you are thrilled to have successfully completed a crucial part of our meal.”
Will’s muscles relaxed from the touch as he let out a breath. “There’s more?” He teased, turning to face Hannibal.
“Of course,” he stated matter-of-factly, stepping closer. “We have to blend everything we’ve made, strain it, put it in a water bath, bake our beloved dish, and lastly, make the duxelles to drizzle over the top.” Hannibal handed the grated nutmeg to Will, who glanced at the soft, light-brown dust. “Do not fret; the rest is very simple. All you will have to do is listen to my exact words, as you did for our beautifully grated nutmeg.”
With slightly widened eyes, Will gazed at Hannibal as he plugged the blender’s cord into the power outlet. “I’ve never realized the duration it takes to make one meal,” he breathed, setting the small bowls near the other ingredients. He noticed the liver on the chopping board off to the side, the blood almost dried from the cool air surrounding the small kitchen. Lonely, it looked, still being the stark contrast amongst everything else. “You have quite the patience, Doctor Lecter.”
Taking the liver that captivated his patient’s eyes into his hands, Hannibal hummed. “As the old saying goes, patience is key.” He tilted the chopping board into the blender before grabbing the knife he’d used earlier for the vegetables. Using the tip of the blade, he scooted the meat into the plastic, causing the meat to shake the container. It was odd, in Will’s opinion, to see such a large piece of meat cooped up in a blender, which he’d only ever seen being used for smoothies or soups.
“Now, we begin the process of adding our smaller ingredients,” Hannibal stated, looking to his patient to act as his aid. “First, the garlic and shallots.” Will scanned around the area for the vegetable until he found the pan with the warm components. Lifting it by its handle, he gently brought it to the blender and tilted it toward the plastic cup. The aromatic food plopped atop the liver with a liquid sound, almost too disgusting to replicate. As he began to set the pan back on the cloth it was under, he halted, feeling Hannibal’s front pressed against his back.
“I’d prefer to add the rest of the sauce to our batter.” Standing directly behind Will, Hannibal wrapped his large hand around his patient’s forearm, guiding him back to the blender. “Like this,” he whispered in his ear, softly sliding his touch down to his hand. Using a bit of force, he tilted the pan towards the plastic, allowing the little bit of sauce to flow from the steel and onto the liver.
“If we were to be technical, we could have left the vegetables raw. I find that cooking them gives a sweeter, more enhanced flavor,” Hannibal softly stated, his hand remaining on Will’s. He took his time as he placed the pan back onto the cloth, showing the empathetic man how he ought to do it if he ever wanted to replicate the meal. Instead, Will’s eyes never left his, even as he pushed and pulled his hand to his liking. He was almost mesmerized by how Hannibal had taken control of him with little to no effort, manipulating his body as if it were his own. “Focus, Will,” Hannibal suddenly demanded, pulling the other out of his dream-like state.
Snapping his head toward the blender once more, Will blinked. He removed his shaking hand from underneath Hannibal’s. “My apologies, Doctor Lecter. I wasn’t expecting such… intimacy.”
He hummed, as if he were waiting for such a comment. “Do I make you nervous, Mister Graham?”
Will turned his attention elsewhere, silently stunned by the unexpected question. Denying the idea of Hannibal making him nervous wouldn’t exactly be a lie—given how aggressive he could be—but it also wouldn’t be the truth, since he felt he could come to him when in need. “According to the definition of being nervous, I ought to be frightened by your mere existence.” He hovered over the blender, hesitant to add the wrong ingredient to the batter in front of the chef. “I am not frightened by you. I simply find you interesting.”
As he looked down, his eyes focused on the red wine. Its color resembled blood, the deep, almost sensual quality of it glistening under the pale kitchen light. Lying next to it was the chef’s knife he’d used for the vegetables. Two years had passed since he’d shot Garrett Jacob Hobbs to death, yet he still fantasized about what he’d do differently had he not had the gun. Puncturing him with the blade and watching his blood leak out of his wounds as the wine poured into the glass would’ve been ideal, in his opinion. He’d allow the blood to stain his hands as he dug into the warm, rough skin of Hobbs’ stomach, watching as the inhumane smile on his face slowly faded into a straight line. He’d hold him in his arms as he bled out, only ever putting him down when either the smell of the bodily fluid made him ill or the authorities themselves pulled him away.
The knife that sat next to the wine had been in Will’s grasp before he could process it. Glancing at the silver blade shining in his hands, he saw Hannibal, who had been watching him closely with an observant expression. With shaking hands, Will dropped the weapon onto the island, a loud clank vibrating the minuscule kitchen. “I’m sorry,” he stuttered, wiping the sweat from his forehead and around his glasses. “This isn’t who I am, Hannibal. I understand why you put such faith in me, but I deny the thought of fulfilling what my mind desires. The plentiful skeletons in my closet will remain until I’ve become one with them.” Will flicked his eyes from the floor to his psychiatrist’s. “We are not on the same level.”
Hannibal cautiously took a few steps toward him. “I did become quite controlling, yes?” He soothingly asked the question more rhetorically than anything. He kept his focus on Will, who was nearly cornered between the kitchen drawers. “I apologize if I forced you to think of yourself as less than you are; I simply wanted to enjoy a hobby of mine with a good friend. You and I have our similarities, yes, but I have come to terms with the fact that similar does not equal congruent.” Taking another step closer, he scooped the back of his patient’s head into his hand, placing his damp forehead against his. “You carry burdens I’ve never considered worthy of carrying. If I’m being quite frank, your empathy makes you more difficult to understand.”
“You are giving me your pity,” Will seethed, his warm breath mingling with the other’s. The thought of being a variant of Hannibal’s made his heart skip a few beats: if he were to accept that they were alike, he’d ruin the chances of leaving his shadow. He’d forever fall into the pattern of forming a bond with those around him and sabotaging their lives, just as Hannibal had done to him. “Why haven’t you killed me yet? You seem to take a liking to murdering those you share traits with.” He paused, feeling his lips quiver. The tone he used became nothing but a whisper: “What is so different when it comes to me?”
“You are misinterpreting my words, Mister Graham,” Hannibal muttered, using the same tone that the other used. “I am not pitying you. I’ve comprehended that one of your worst nightmares is to find yourself in a position like mine. If I were to serve you such a fate, I would waste both my time and the little you had. I’ve said it before, and I will say it again: I rarely let my friends down.”
“You’ve killed plenty of your friends,” Will stated, the red rim around his eyes glowing just a bit darker. A single tear slid down his rosy cheek as he pushed himself off Hannibal, the tear seemingly going unnoticed by both of them. It fell onto his flannel shirt, staining the area near his chest. “How do I know I won’t become one of the names on your list?”
Hannibal paused, staring at the residue of the tear. “In life, you will have obstacles. The friends you are describing were simply getting in the way.” He took a step backward, allowing his patient the well-needed space. “Rarely have I asked for a friend’s help in the kitchen, let alone allowed them to hear of my life and its tragedies. Comparing you to anyone I’ve ever considered a friend would be catastrophic, not only because it would be a bluff, but because they were meaningless to me; you are not.”
The oven beeped with a loud, penetrating noise, as if it were intended to distract the chef from continuing his lecture. For a moment, Hannibal stood there, watching another tear escape Will’s eye. He’d seen the man cry before, yet this time around, it felt as though a barrier had separated them, with Will drifting farther and farther away from him. The silence only seemed to make matters worse.
Hannibal slowly turned toward the oven and opened it to stop the beeping. Taking his time, he moved back to the island, grasping the bowl of whole eggs and placing it into the blender. He added the egg yolk, nutmeg, milk, cream, and a pinch of salt and pepper before pressing the button at the bottom, blending the ingredients together. After a minute, he removed his finger from the blender and opened the top, examining the liquid for any chunks. Assuming Will had no interest in helping, he unhooked the cup from the blade, pouring the batter into the ramekins.
The scents of the vegetables filled his nostrils, as they did when he first cooked the meal twenty years ago in France. His aunt coddled him—since he’d had no sense of direction—constantly correcting his mistakes and reminding him plenty-fold to butter the ramekins or blend it until perfectly smooth. Of course, those moments hadn’t lasted long, but he’d cherished them the best he possibly could; now, he stood in the middle of his kitchen with Will Graham, trying to come to terms with their complicated relationship.
Once he finished with the ramekins, he bent down to the cabinet with his cooking instruments. With a slight groan, he reached inside, taking one of his beautiful steel pots. “Would you,” he strained, standing to his feet with a sigh, “like to aid me evermore?” He looked to Will, whose attention had been on the clock on the wall.
Silently staring at Hannibal, Will cautiously walked to him. Shock had a tight grip on him, he’d thought: he’d barely gotten over the fact that his psychiatrist showed so much vulnerability, telling him that he’d spared his life simply because he was like no other. It was odd, watching someone as preserved as Hannibal show emotion.
Focusing on him, he watched the man take the pot to the sink, flicking the faucet. Warm water instantly began flowing into the metallic space, filling the large container. Hannibal offered the handle to Will, giving a slight nod. As he reached over to take it, his touch grazed the other’s hand, feeling his rough skin once more. He raised his eyebrow, moving into the spot where the chef had stepped aside. Once he noticed the water was nearly overflowing, he flicked the faucet down, turning it off.
Will carefully brought the pot to the stove, assuming Hannibal needed to boil the water. As he set it on the burner at the bottom left corner, he reached over and twisted the handle to the highest setting, allowing the water to start coming to a boil. “Do you understand what I’m trying to say?” Hannibal suddenly asked, his voice like a boom in Will’s ears. “You are alive because I refuse to give you such a fate.”
Hannibal moved closer to Will, resting his eyes upon him. “As you’ve stated, we have been through plenty. No matter the odds, we will always return to one another.” He carefully placed his hand on the cabinet, watching the other’s mouth softly tremble.
