Chapter Text
Hannibal removed the pan from the heated burner and stirred the thick spread. “My aunt considered this to be one of the finest dishes in all of France,” he stated, reaching over to the drawer with his utensils and grasping a metal spoon. He dipped the tip of it inside the pan and allowed the mushrooms to coat the dinnerware. “Though I’d say she was a bit biased, given that the dish was invented by her family only generations ago.” Steadying the spoon with his other hand, he guided it to his patient’s mouth.
Will looked down at the paste with a skeptical expression. “Are we going to ignore the fact that you just recommended that I listen to positive affirmations?”
Clicking his tongue, Hannibal moved the spoon closer, his gaze focused on Will’s mouth. “I garnered from your expression alone that you’d rather change the conversation.”
Hesitantly accepting the savory paste, Will wrapped his lips around the utensil, his eyes remaining on Hannibal. Immediately, every ingredient they’d added rushed to his tongue, the pungent garlic and shallots blending with the mushrooms in an overly salted way. He couldn’t help but shut his eyes and swallow the concoction. “It’s delectable,” he stuttered, feeling his mouth begin to water. “It's thick like a stew, yet… salty like a curry. I think it’ll pair fondly with the liver cakes.”
“There is that expression again,” Hannibal nagged, grabbing the towelette that hung upon the oven handle. “You are hiding your genuineness.” Turning on the sink, he allowed the warm water to rinse the spoon before wiping it clean with the fuzzy cloth. “Another rule in the kitchen, whether you’re cooking the food yourself or simply taste-testing, is honesty. You must give your honest opinion, no matter how harmful it may be.” The chef folded his arms as his tone mimicked that of a disappointed parent: “You are a horrendous liar who cannot refrain from bluffing.”
Shocked by such a statement, Will scoffed. “Oh, I’m a liar?” He pointed to himself, his brows furrowing in disbelief. “My apologies; would you like me to be more honest? Due to your insistence, I’ll be genuine for once: this is ridiculous. We stand in this kitchen conversing with one another and cooking meals as if we aren’t cannibals who enjoy their prejudiced ways! You tie this apron around my waist and spoon-feed me your creations like we’re old friends catching up! We argue, we gather somewhat of an understanding of each other, and then pretend we’re on good terms!” His chest heaved with frustration as he untied the fabric from around his waist and shoved it into Hannibal’s chest. “This is madness—beyond madness!”
Holding the apron in his hands, Hannibal tilted his head slightly. He had to tread carefully with his defense; if he didn’t, his peer might just explode before he could sit at the table and eat his dinner. “Will,” he soothed, gently placing the apron on the island, “I understand your thoughts precisely—”
“Do you?!” Will cut him off, “Because I don’t think you comprehend it!”
“I can assure you, I do.” Hannibal’s took the smallest step he could possibly take toward Will. “You are exhausted, Will. These are your exact thoughts, which you yourself are attempting to understand, given that you’ve bottled them inside for so long. Accepting who you are is the only solution to surviving; this, you seem to struggle with.”
Rubbing his hand over his face, Will chuckled out of spite. “This is exactly what I’m talking about, Hannibal! You stand there and take whatever I desire to say with a puffed-out chest, attempting to reconcile with me!”
“It is not reconciling with you, Will. I agree with you because I have conceded with the points that you are making: you are uncomfortable with living a life such as this, and I understand your discomfort.” Hannibal could see the rage written across his patient’s face as if it were drawn with red ink. It was intriguing to see him so infuriated. “Your morality is beginning to control you, Mister Graham, and you are experiencing agony as a result.”
“My morality is a reminder to contain my urges.”
“You fail to realize that your morality is worsening your mental health.”
Looking back at Hannibal, Will huffed. “Your constant questioning of it is what causes my mental health to decrease. I am not unintelligent, Doctor Lecter; I know of the possibilities that may unfold if I were to let myself go.”
The oven suddenly beeped, causing both of them to turn their heads toward it. Hannibal was the first to move, grabbing the dark green oven mitt and slipping his hand through it. “I observe your capability, though you would rather not maneuver your life around it.” He pulled the door by its lever, unleashing the buttery aroma of the savory gateau. “As your psychiatrist, it is my duty to allow you to become what you most desire; in your case, I must persuade you to accept who you’ve already become.”
Watching him gently remove the baking dish from the oven rack, Will’s eyes flickered. “What if I did accept my desires?”
“Fear of them controlling you would wreck your perception.”
Will chuckled slightly. “I suppose that would be accurate.”
Holding the scorching tray in his mitted hand, Hannibal twisted his heel and seized another mitt, plopping it onto the island. “I am offering you the gateway to living your life freely, without the fear of being judged.” He set the tray onto the fabric and immediately removed the mitt from his hand, hanging it back on the wall near the oven. “If you and I were to pair, we would leave this country and settle elsewhere, away from the reputations we’ve built surrounding our names.”
The offer hung loose in the air. Will’s gaze moved down to his hands, watching them shake due to adrenaline. His crucial mistakes led him back to the only possible solution that might just work: fleeing with Hannibal. But he couldn’t help but wonder what would happen if he left with someone as powerful as the murderer; if he were to find himself in desperate need of help, neither Jack nor Alana would be able to rescue him.
“Your plan is to go back to Italy,” he whispered, swallowing what felt like a large lump in the back of his throat.
“Precisely.” Hannibal removed the pan from the stove and placed it beside the baking dish before looking at Will.
Will’s eyes widened. “You are willing to abandon the memories we’ve made here? Did Abigail’s and Beverly’s deaths mean nothing to you? What is the difference between them, you, and me when it comes to curiosity?”
“The difference between the four of us is that two ventured too far into the world of inquisitiveness; the other two chose to settle and allow the events to unfold rather than investigate.” Hannibal turned to the cabinets ever more and opened the door leading to his plentiful porcelain dishware, taking two white plates into his hands. “We have the capability to become more than we lead on. We answer to the calling of our human nature rather than shunning it, as Abigail and Beverly supposed."
Will’s furrowed brow slightly lightened as he considered the situation. For years, he wanted to desperately to investigate the man; he desired to allow the man to seep into his vulnerability and take note of where he drew the line—if he’d ever done it. Simultaneously, he could not surrender to such a life; he could not blatantly accept his behavior without fearing the outcome, as Hannibal predicted.
Beverly and Abigail were deceased because of him. He’d drilled into their brains that Hannibal had been the villain in their stories. He’d allowed them to explore until the murderer took their breath away. Even though the guilt had been burying him alive, he’d still wanted to take part in Hannibal’s life, despite the various troubles it could lead to.
“And if I were to go with you,” he quietly began, his gaze fixed on the ramekins sitting on the island, “how would I come to terms with myself?”
At the sudden question, Hannibal’s ears perked up. “You want to learn about accepting your nature?” He rhetorically asked, watching his patient reluctantly nod. “I can aid you in that field, Will. You seem to be on the correct path to amenability, and with my guidance, we will dominate whatever force that we may face.”
Placing his hand on Will’s shoulder, he began walking toward the door. “Our dinner is beginning to cool off,” he whispered in his ear, bringing him to the large oak table in the center of the dining room. Pulling out the chair closest to the head of the table, Hannibal gestured for him to take a seat. “Please. I will prepare our meal along with another glass of red wine in the kitchen.”
Will looked down at the chair before giving Hannibal a short nod. “Thank you,” he murmured, moving his foot in front of it and taking a seat.
With his Oxfords quietly stomping against the floor, Hannibal walked back to the kitchen. He immediately settled behind the sink once again and flicked the faucet on, warm water rushing onto his hands. Pumping a bit of soap into his palms, he scrubbed his calloused hands free of any dirt and germs before wiping the water away with the towel he used earlier. This could be the night, his internal voice reminded him, that he could potentially have Will to himself without the worry of any obstacles preventing them from being together.
After a few minutes, the door leading to the kitchen suddenly burst open, and Hannibal walked into the dining room with both plates in his hands. He loomed over Will and placed the white dish in front of him, the appetizing appearance of the meal seizing his attention. In the center of the plate was the gateau with the duxelles and parsley neatly drizzled over the top, along with two sprigs of rosemary beside it, giving the dish a wonderful sense of color. “It looks delicious,” Will stated, looking up at Hannibal.
Seeing Will’s soft expression, Hannibal’s lips lifted into a half-smirk. “I am glad you think so,” he stated, placing his own plate at the head of the table. “Albeit, it is the taste that must be beneficial in meals; the duxelles may be suggestive, or the gateau may appear to be fully cooked, yet raw once cut down the middle.” Heading back into the kitchen, he grasped the wine bottle and glasses by their necks, bringing them out to the table. He set them beside each other as he popped the bottle open and poured enough to fill half the glass.
“Your dishes have always been cooked—or baked—to perfection, Doctor Lecter. I have not eaten anything you’ve prepared that was raw, unless intended.”
Hannibal slid the wine glass to Will, a soft chuckle escaping his throat. “All the practice I’ve put into my meals has paid off,” he murmured, scooting out the chair at the end of the table and settling himself in it. On his face, there had been an expression that one could describe as pleased as he draped the napkin beside his plate over his lap. He had a feeling his guest would begin the conversation from where they last left off, so he’d decided to remain silent.
Will unraveled his own napkin, revealing both a fork and a steak knife. He slowly grabbed the handle of the blade in his right hand, examining the sharp utensil. It resembled the chef’s knives he’d used to mince the vegetables, with the exact rubber grip at the end and a metallic design running down the middle. He glanced at Hannibal, who had been preoccupied with preparing himself for dinner. “So you are planning to leave Virginia and head to Italy? That is quite the distance, don’t you think?”
“Yes,” Hannibal murmured, raising his glass to his lips and taking a sip of the burgundy colored wine. Through the crystal, he could see Will’s expression shift into a more melancholic one. The amount of pity emanating from his guest was almost laughable as he set the glass down on the table with a quiet clank. “It is approximately 4,450 miles away. Although it may seem lengthy, it will lead us from the beaming spotlight and allow our essences the room to shine as they have never shone before.”
Contemplating Hannibal’s words, Will placed the blade against the meal. “And if I decide to stay?” He suggested, slowly slicing through the fluffy flan. Inside had been a dull pinkish-brown color sprinkled with dark green parsley, just as it did with the duxelles. The smell had been divine, almost distracting Will from speaking about his anxiety. “Fleeing to somewhere as foreign as Italy seems a bit extravagant for me. You are accustomed to its environment, whereas I know nothing of it. What if then I am… misconstrued by its natives?”
“The natives will only see what you allow them to see.” Hannibal mimicked Will’s actions and cut himself a small piece of the gateau, a hint of a smile on his lips. “I’ve grown with them from a teenager to a young man; they will not bother themselves to investigate your malicious ways.” Bringing the fork to his mouth, he watched Will drop his own fork onto the table with a loud bang.
“I’m malicious?”
“Maliciousness is one of the many wonders we acknowledge when maturing.”
Adjusting his glasses, Will picked the fork up in his hand once again, unhinging his jaw and placing the cake inside his mouth. He could immediately taste the duxelles as it coated his tongue, the saltiness he’d tasted earlier completely gone and replaced with the mixture of the liver and garlic. It was delectable, if he were to be honest, despite the horrendous emotions they’d gone through to make it. “This is delicious,” he muttered, chewing the buttery components.
Swallowing the liver cake, Hannibal placed his fork on the side of his plate. “There are plenty of meals that are equivalent to this in Italy.”
Will swallowed the food as well, slicing through the gateau once again. “You speak as though you’ve already planned on my confirmation.”
Silence settled over the table as if Hannibal himself welcomed it as another guest. Will took a moment to stare at him before hesitantly taking another bite of the dinner, his movements slow and deliberate. From the look in Hannibal’s hooded eyes, he’d been caught off guard by the question—possibly dreading the mere thought of answering it. The psychiatrist reached over for his glass of wine, letting out a soft, barely audible exhale.
“There is a large, secluded house I’ve prepared in the city of Florence with a garden that needs desperate tending. It has two stories, three bedrooms and bathrooms, a garage, a basement, and plenty of space if you’d prefer to be acquainted with your animals.” He sipped on the beverage, holding the glass by its long stem. “Nearby is the Arno River, housing plenty of fish for your hobby.
Will’s eyes flickered with realization as he placed the fork down in haste. “You knew that I would comply,” he stated, staring at Hannibal with a slightly horrified expression. “You carefully calculated the house we’d stay in just for my comfort; how do I know this isn’t some sort of bait you’re dangling over my head to distance me from everyone?”
“Distance is well needed at the moment, Will. The people you surround yourself with do not have the same thought process as you. What you need is sustainability rather than acquaintances who run rather than strike.”
“So, you agree that you’ve articulated this?”
“I anticipated it.”
“What’s the difference?”
“Articulation centers around planning; planning centers around certainty.” Hannibal paused, folding his hands on his lap with an unreadable expression on his face. “I was never certain that you’d comply. I considered your submission with the additions you may bring without relying upon it.” Slightly tilting his head, a fragment of a smirk was painted on his lips with a dull hue. “If you desire to continue your work with the authorities, there are many agencies that could benefit from your wondrous gift.”
Will looked from Hannibal down to the half-eaten cake resting on his plate. The lingering taste of the liver and garlic remained on his tongue as he considered Hannibal’s exquisite offer.
“When do you plan on leaving?”
“Most preferably tomorrow.”
“Tomorrow?” Will echoed, his tone rising ever so slightly. “You weren’t going to tell me, had I not come here tonight?”
Hannibal hummed. “I would have told you tomorrow morning, so as not to pressure you to rethink every life choice you’ve ever made.” Taking the glass into his right hand, he tilted it toward his lips, tasting its bitter flavor. “You overthink to the point of mental collapse; the plane is leaving at six thirty in the morning, and had we had this exact discussion, we would’ve missed our flight.”
Will looked down at the half-eaten supper resting on his plate. Everything felt so sudden: packing, preparing his passport, figuring out a way to bring his animals along with him, and leaving all of Virginia’s memories that still swaddled him as a mother might her child. He’d flee from the life he’d spent years scoping for himself, specifically the people he’d grown attached to and his small farmhouse on the outskirts of the city. It would be a life-changing decision that he might possibly never overcome.
He noticed the pale pinkish liver peering out from the duxelles and parsley, a question suddenly popping into his mind on short notice.
“This isn’t chicken liver, is it?”
Hannibal’s gaze never left his patient’s. “Is there a specific reason that led you to this conclusion?”
“You’ve fed me enough human meat for me to recognize the flavor.” Will stood from the chair, a look of pure horror on his face. “It’s… her, isn’t it?”
“Her?” Hannibal questioned, standing up as well. He adjusted the sleeves of his dress shirt, folding the cuffs back to the position they’d been in when he was preparing the meal. “Who would be this woman, Will?”
“You know exactly who I mean when I refer to ‘her’.”
Hannibal grasped his glass by its crystal stem, taking a sip of the red wine. The silence that settled itself in the room was unbearable, and he could sense the dread residing within Will. His expression said all it needed to say without him having to open his lips once more to argue the heinous crime he’d just committed—or participated in.
“It was her from the very start. It occurred to you the moment you laid your eyes upon the liver when you walked into the kitchen.”
“I didn’t think it to be true!” Will yelled, placing his hands on either side of his face. “For some reason, I didn’t want to believe you would do such a thing!”
Taking a few steps closer, Hannibal stood in front of Will, watching a single tear fall down his cheek. “She will always be with you, now,” he whispered, bringing his hand to his face and swiping the warm water away with his thumb. Their eyes connected as he rubbed his calloused skin against the other’s, both of them having differing emotions.
“Why?” Will asked, trying to tug his head from Hannibal’s grasp.
Hannibal’s hand remained where his patient’s face once was before he’d placed it at his side. “You will fall down an endless descent trying to retrieve her, Will. You must accept the fact that she is gone.”
The comment left Will dumbfounded. His eyes scanned Hannibal’s face, noting the eerie calm of his expression, the eccentric spark in his pupils, and the small smirk on his lips. He wanted him to feel serenity from his words, yet all the empathetic man felt was guilt with a hint of fascination. They thought of themselves as alluring on the first day they’d met, but nothing could compare to what Will felt for Hannibal at the moment.
“You wanted me to acknowledge your wrongdoing.”
“I wanted you to acknowledge that you and I are much more similar than you think.”
Glancing at the plate, Will audibly swallowed. The meal had been growing colder as each second passed by, the duxelles beginning to crust over the crisp brown cake. Garlic, shallots, and the taste of the liver lingered on his taste buds, just as Hannibal’s touch lingered on his face before he’d moved. He could still remember the look on his psychiatrist’s face when he saw him make eye contact with Abigail’s organ.
“You’re a monster,” he muttered, feeling his stomach churn with disgust.
“I’ve established that long ago,” Hannibal responded, his tone holding little to no resentment at the harshness of Will’s comment. “Your choice to join me in the preparing and eating of our meal was not unconsensual.”
Will scoffed. “You twist your words to disguise your intentions; I bet lawyers hate the slight mention of your name."
“I’ve never been named in a lawsuit.” Hannibal’s smile widened ever so slightly as he reached over and picked a fuzz from Will’s shirt. “My intentions are rarely underlying. I only state my meaning as is.”
For a while, the consideration of leaving crossed Will’s mind. All of this would be behind him: Jack would adjust to his new life without him in it, hiring another asset that would benefit him more than Will ever had. Alana would find someone who could fill the void that she desperately needed without the burden of the unprofessional relationship she’d had with him. His animals would find an owner who didn’t go into mental asylums for months at a time or go to court to fight off a case as horrendous as murder.
“You will leave whether I stay or go.”
“Precisely.”
Will nodded, his eyes flickering between the plate and Hannibal. “I assume you don’t plan on coming back.”
Hannibal noticed the expression on his face and placed his hand on his shoulder, slowly pushing his body against his patient’s. “I’m afraid not.”
Accepting the hug, Will wrapped his arms around the murderer’s waist, closing his eyes. “I’ll be there with my bags packed.”
