Chapter Text
They stayed up late. Dustin invited Steve to play some computer games whilst Mrs. Henderson watched her TV evening programme. Fews kept them company, purring in Steve’s lap, only moving when he lost and got worked up about it.
Dustin seemed agitated even after winning six times in a row. He had knitted his eyebrows together and threw sideway-glances at Steve whenever he did as much as clearing his throat.
‘Steve?’
‘Yes?’
‘What exactly happened ten years ago? I just know what all the others know, and it doesn’t make sense. There must have been something else – so what happened?’
The silence between them hurt. Steve tried to concentrate on the video game, failing to ignore Dustin’s determined look.
‘I made a mistake ten years ago, and it still haunts me. That’s all, okay?’ he listened closely, but the TV noise from the living room seemed to have ended, ‘I should go to bed.’
‘Sure,’ Dustin yawned, ‘just don’t think I’ll let it go.’
Steve ruffled his hair and left Dustin’s old bedroom to retire to his couch. He curled up and tried to force himself to fall asleep. Coming back to Hawkins had borne the risk of bringing everything to light, Hopper seemed suspicious to say the least, and Dustin didn’t call himself the party’s grey matter for no reason.
He fell asleep after lying awake for a few more hours. It was no dreamless, quiet sleep. Instead, he woke up three times in cold sweat, and had to try and find a more comfortable position on the sweat-soaked sheet to go back to sleep. His dreams never changed and still, he woke up with a lump in his throat and his heart in his mouth.
When he woke up for the fourth time, he felt relieved to see the sun peek into the living room through the blinds. Dustin had mentioned meeting up with the party for a D&D-afternoon, and they seemed to have agreed on their second day in Hawkins. He was running around in the kitchen, throwing nibbles and finger food in a backpack.
‘Hello, Sleeping Beauty, it’s past two! Are you gonna be okay? We are at the Byers’, if you wanna join us later on. I’m sure Nancy and Jonathan would be happy to entertain you – where has she put the car keys…?’
Steve put a pair of jeans and a shirt on, combed his fingers through his hair and cleared his throat, ‘Do you want me to give you a ride? For old times’ sake?’
Dustin nodded silently, grabbed the backpack and left the house yelling a goodbye upstairs. Steve followed after grabbing his jacket from the pile that had grown on his bag. He didn’t waste another thought on his suit that was still crumpled up in the depths of it, and that he had only packed because he thought that he might have to impress his former classmates.
They talked about Harvard and Dustin’s newest project, just like they had discussed homework and school projects, AV club or Snow Ball dates. Dustin asked about his plans for the day and frowned when Steve couldn’t tell him what he would do.
‘Try exploring the new Hawkins. There are a few new shops, you might find something for that empty shelf you have in your flat. Or maybe you run into some former classmates.’
‘Yeah, I wouldn’t hope for that to happen. Too many unpleasant memories,’ Steve pulled up into the Byers’ yard and patted Dustin on the shoulder, ‘go get them tiger.’
Dustin looked at him, deadpan. With a final purr he got out of the car.
‘I told you to stop that fifteen years ago,’ Steve yelled after him, but Dustin just flipped him off and went inside.
Steve backed out of the driveway. Dustin had been right to doubt his ability to find something to occupy him with. In the end he just didn’t want to admit that he had no idea what to do in Hawkins. If anything, he needed anything to kill some time before returning to watch the kids play their Dungeon game.
He drove around aimlessly, looking at the shops to both sides of the street. Of course he knew most of the ‘new’ shops from New York, the only difference was the lack of yellow cabs. A few of the faces he saw walking up and down the street seemed familiar, he could just hope not to meet any of his parents’ acquaintances.
Swallowing against the new lump in his throat he set a turning signal. Dustin would tell him to rip the bandaid off without further ado, to bite through it all and just face it. He hit the gas pedal resolutely, turning and speeding down one of the roads towards Maple Street, only to take another turn right just before, into Cornwallis. He felt a distant tug at his heart as he drove down the road, just up to the point where he could see up the driveway from the curb.
The wooden planks were still painted grey, the windowsills white, and the door red. The driveway looked as clean swiped as ever, no pebble was out of place and a polished car stood in front of the garage driveway. Steve parked and leaned forward, looking up to the house. Something heavy seemed to weigh him down, he felt tears sting in the corners of his eyes. Looking up there reminded him of everything, of his first birthday party, the long afternoons spent at his desk, playing basketball alone in the front yard, and swimming in the pool late at night. He remembered his mother staying home when he fell ill as a kid, his father disappearing in his study, both of them leaving for another business trip, both of them returning with a souvenir and a smile for him. When he closed his eyes, he could smell his mother’s apple pie, his father’s cigars that he got out whenever he expected business partners, the way the chlorine clung to their towels after an evening in the pool.
It all was gone now, he reminded himself, as he saw a shape walk by the kitchen window. What could they be doing in there? It was a warm, sunny day – spending it poolside seemed the best way to cool down. He had been right, it all came back to kick him in the ass.
Steve clutched the steering wheel and rested his head on top of his hands. Confronting his demons seemed no longer a good idea, it had just remembered him of how it had been too painful from the start. The tears were no longer just burning in the corners of his eyes, instead he could feel them drop onto his thighs and soak through his jeans.
A car pulled up next to him, the engine loud enough to have him expect the SUV. Looking up, he realized that he had been sitting in his car for longer than he had thought, it had begun to dusk and his muscles hurt from remaining in their position for hours. He felt empty, like a sponge that had been squeezed long and hard enough to shed its last drop, his skin felt taut and his hands shook after he detached them from the steering wheel.
‘You look like you could do with a cup of coffee. Do you want to come down to the station with me?’ Hopper leaned against the Beemer.
Steve blinked a few times, just to reassure himself that he wasn’t seeing ghosts again. Then he nodded, wiping briefly at his eyes to dry the last traces of his tears. He waited until Hopper was back in his SUV and started the engine again. With a last glance back to his childhood home, he followed the police car down the road he had driven up hours before.
Hopper walked him through the lobby of the station, into his office. Nodding to his visitor chair he went back to get coffee and a few leftover doughnuts from the box they had passed on their way in. Steve took the cup of coffee from Hopper with the attempt of a smile. Neither of them said anything. He began to look around in the office, taking in the mostly empty case files, the framed photos on Hopper’s desk showing the party, Jane, and all of them together at Steve’s graduation because his parents hadn’t been able to make it, and the mess of notes and slips of paper.
‘How are Powell and Calaghan?’ he asked once he could trust his voice again.
‘Powell retired four years ago, made the smart choice. Calaghan got transferred,’ Hopper grabbed a doughnut and ate half of it with one bite.
‘What about Flo? Is she still around to annoy you into eating something healthy, and drinking something but coffee?’
‘Died two years ago. Didn’t Jane tell you? She’s working as our secretary now.’
Steve stilled in his chair. The weight on his chest was back, he felt it rear up again until it had almost closed his throat, ‘Jane? Didn’t she and Mike live in Indianapolis? That’s what Dustin told me, that Mike is an electrician, and Jane is a social worker. Yesterday, she spoke about troubled kids coming in.’
‘I guess she gets those when they come here to talk to an officer. In that way, she is a social worker. And Mike is an electrician – they moved back to Hawkins six years ago, have their own place close to the ‘Nova’, they helped Lucas and Maxine reopen it.’
‘Excuse me?’ Steve felt the blood leave his face, ‘What are you talking about, last time I asked, they were in California –‘
‘They never left. Instead, they took on the re-opening of the now most popular restaurant in Hawkins. Lucas is a great chef and Max does everything related to management.’
‘Why didn’t they tell me?’ Steve scratched his forearm absentmindedly, a mechanism he had come to use whenever he needed to ground himself, ‘I mean, I thought I knew what they did all those years – Dustin still goes to Harvard, right? I didn’t dream that up?’
Hopper nodded, his brows knit together, ‘Listen, kid, I don’t know why they wouldn’t tell you what is going on in their lives, and isn’t my place to attempt an interpretation. But they will have their reasons.’
‘I haven’t been here in ten years, I would never know what is true and what made up. How should I know if they lied to me? Why would they lie?’
‘Those kids still adore you, Steve,’ Hopper reached out for another doughnut, ‘never forget that. They know what you went through, and that you are still dealing with a lot. Hell, they have experienced enough to know that you are going through worse. I can imagine that they don’t want to worry you.’
Steve looked at him with hopefully enough suspicion to show Hopper that he didn’t buy a simple solution, ‘Still, something is off about it. It doesn’t seem like them to lie to me. Dustin in particular. He’s been my contact into Hawkins, he has told me whatever happened. He told me about Nancy and Jonathan becoming teachers, about Will’s career as the most popular nurse in all of Hawkins – he told me about Mike and Jane, and Lucas and Max as well, but why would he lie when it came to them?’
Hopper got up and opened a mini fridge in the corner, ‘Beer? Listen, kid, don’t beat yourself up about it. Yes, it was Max’s dream to go back to Cali just like her brother wanted to. In the end she and Lucas ended up here because of family issues I don’t need to elaborate, that’s not for me to tell. But think about what you would’ve said. You were the one to encourage them to follow their dreams, no matter what would happen. Yes, I know about the late night conversations, I’m not as stupid as you all seem to think. You always said you would end up behind a desk, leaving behind your dreams. But what did you really abandon, hm?’
Steve leaned back again, a cool beer in one hand, and the other curled into a fist, ‘So apart from the slight location changes I haven’t missed anything? You haven’t Joyce Mrs. Hopper, and Jane and Will siblings yet?’
‘At some point, kid,’ Hopper took a swig of his beer and patted his shoulder, ‘you remember the promise to be Jane’s maid of honour?’
‘Break a promise I made a girl that could snap my neck with one thought? I don’t think so,’ Steve raised his bottle, ‘I would repeat it anytime.’
‘That’s good,’ Hopper still looked at him like he could read his inner turmoil, ‘Steve, kid, you know you can come to me, talk to me, if you ever need to. If you still struggle with what has happened –‘
‘I’m fine, Hop, really.’
‘I wasn’t finished. You don’t stay away ten years without reason, now, you know we are all here for you. Still, you decided to leave and asked Joyce and me to take care of everything. We respect that decision, kid, but we will not watch as you ruin yourself to follow whatever self-destructive path you’re on.’
Steve opened his mouth to defend himself, stopped by one wave of Hopper’s hand, ‘Come on, you can’t come here and expect we don’t see that you’re even skinnier now. ‘Working long hours,’ guess what: I know what that entails.’
His radio cackled, interrupting the silence between them with the usual distortedness of a voice, ‘Done with my patrol. I’m turning in for the night.’
Hopper reached for the radio with an apologetic glance at Steve to answer, ‘You fucking will not, Hargrove! Do your damned job and come back to the station!’
Steve felt a shiver run down his spine. His fingers grabbed the beer bottle tighter, the moment during which he waited for Hopper to set down the radio again seemed to last a lifetime.
‘Hargrove? As in – Billy Hargrove?’ he knew his voice failed him, but it seemed too absurd to just expect the worst.
‘Yes, I took him on after Calaghan got transferred, almost ten years ago, honestly. He asked me to give him a chance to get his life together and now I have a very capable deputy.’
‘Well, I should head back, Dustin was under the impression that I would come by Joyce’s to watch them play. I actually might have to pick him up anyway. Thanks for the coffee. And the beer.’
Steve got up, grabbed his jacket and left the station. He all but ran towards his car, pulled the driver’s door open and got in. His hands shook again as he fumbled with the keys, trying to start the engine as fast as possible.
A car approached the police station as Steve backed out, another police vehicle, he realized with a look in the rear view mirror. He felt sick to his stomach, disgusted by the way he had once again run away.
The party was still on their quest when Steve arrived, but agreed to postpone it until the following day. Dustin argued that they had little else to do with the reunion going on at the High School. Steve had pushed the reunion back into the farthest corner of his mind, hearing about it in the kids’ conversation knocked the air out of his lungs. He masked it with a cough, but Jane looked at him funny nonetheless.
‘Are you looking forward to seeing all these people again?’ she asked with a concerned look, ‘I thought you didn’t like many of them.’
‘Well, a reunion is always an opportunity to look how all the others have failed to reach their goals. You can feel so much better about yourself if there is someone who always spoke of becoming a sports superstar who turned out fat and unsatisfied when you yourself have accomplished at least one of your goals,’ Steve shrugged.
‘What did you accomplish?’ Jane’s honest interest made it impossible for Steve to throw her a sarcastic comment.
‘I live in New York, I have a job and I can manage my affairs. That might be more than some of the others have come to have. I just think that I might no longer seem boring next to all the others.’
‘You are not boring,’ Dustin chipped in, ‘just grown-up. It’s pretty cool that you actually managed to leave Hawkins…’
‘Yeah, about that,’ Steve moved forwards on his chair, ‘why on Earth would you tell me that Lucas and Max live in California, and Mike and El are in Indianapolis when really you all were here?’
‘Oh shit, did Hopper really tell you?’
‘Wrong answer, Michael!’
‘Did you just call me Michael? Dude, we just wanted to keep you believing that we were pursuing our dreams. You worry so easily, and Dustin pointed out that we would be able to tell you anything because you mentioned that you didn’t want to come back. If you knew that we came back to Hawkins, after you left…we thought you might feel the need to move back, and you clearly needed the distance.’
‘You can’t just lie to me to keep me away,’ Steve raked his fingers through his hair, no matter how nice you think you are! Dickheads! Friends don’t lie, did you just conveniently forget that? Honestly, I don’t get it! I would have complimented you on your food, Lucas, if I knew you had come up with it!’
Jane pursed her lips and nudged Max to say something. Max poked Will, who gave Lucas a stink-eye. Eventually, it was Dustin who spoke up, ‘Okay, we did something shitty for all the right reasons. Can you see beyond that or are you going to be a bitch about it for all eternity?’
‘Fuck you, Dustin, honestly,’ Steve pushed past him on his way out, ‘Get Mike or Lucas to drive you home!’
