Actions

Work Header

For Propriety's Sake

Chapter 3

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo supposed he might be acting a little immature, but he told himself that Thorin deserved it. 

After all he had let Bilbo come to truly care about him when he'd apparently intended to leave him as soon as they'd reclaimed the mountain. He had to have. No one lacked the power to think ahead so hugely as it would take to make an oversight of that scale. Not even Thorin, the most stubborn, foolish, charming dwarf he's ever had the displeasure of meeting.

But when Bilbo had announced his intention to leave the mountain to the company, there had been an uproar.  He had expected that, after all not every dwarf was as deceptive as Thorin, and the company had come to like him given time.  What he had not expected was the nature of their requests.

"Please Mister Bilbo, just stay three more days."

"To… give us time to send you off properly!  We'll throw you a feast!"

"Just a few days, Mister Bilbo, we're begging you!"

And so, Bilbo had agreed to stay three more days. Though if his friends were planning to give him a proper send-off, they were doing a pretty poor job of it, Bilbo thought bitterly to himself as he sat alone in his room the following evening.  Dwarves, Bilbo thought tetchily, I won't miss their confounding ways in the slightest.

Meanwhile down the hall, Balin was entering Thorin's quarters in a huff. 

"What did you do?"

Thorin looked up at him, "What?"

"I came in here telling you that your council is acting ludicrously, so you end your courtship with Bilbo?  The poor lad's beside himself!  He came to the company the other night telling us he plans on leaving to go back to the Shire!"

Thorin stilled. "What," he repeated in a deadly tone.

"Well if you don't like it, you best go tell him.  He's set to leave two days from now."

Thorin slumped back in his chair.  Bilbo leaving the mountain, never to see Thorin again.  How could he?  Betrayal washed over him and he quickly recovered from his shock, sour resignation sweeping in to take its place.

 "I cannot. If he thinks me so dishonorable as to lie to him about my feelings, he cannot forgive me. Nor is there any reason for him to stay here. I must do what is proper."

Balin didn't bother to contain his frustration.  "He's hurt, you thick son of Durin! He didn't mean any of what he might've told you afterwards! The lad's as crazy for you as you are for him, you must know that he would never truly suspect you of such dishonor. Besides, the people will accept whatever you do. You've won their loyalty as sure as you've won mine and every other member of the company's- including Bilbo's.  He would not reject you if you gave him the chance to make a choice!"

"He said himself he believed I lied, I made no mention of my honor. He raised the point himself,"  Thorin ground out. "And as for loyalty, it is something I have to earn daily. I learned that many years ago, on the journey West. And I have earned it by acting with propriety. So that is how I will continue to act, never mind my personal desires."

Balin threw his hands into the air, and said gravely, "Fix this, laddie, or you and Bilbo both will regret it till the end of your days."

And with that Balin marched out of Thorin's rooms before he did something improper himself, like whacking the King of Erebor over the head with a rolled up parchment like he used to when Thorin refused to do his lessons.

*** 

Curse these dwarves and their convoluted halls and their secret doors, Bilbo thought to himself as he tapped his fingertip against the great stone door that had just shut unexpectedly behind him, trying to discern where the door had gone off to using echolocation.

This was his last night in Erebor and the Company had sent him an invitation a feast in his honor.  Bilbo had had half a mind not to come, after they had demanded he stay and then left him sitting alone in his room for three days without so much as a word of contact.  But, ever the proper Hobbit, Bilbo had decided it would be rude of him to not attend a party thrown entirely for his benefit, and followed the convoluted directions down into the depths of Erebor. Notions of propriety strike again, Bilbo reflected bitterly as he gave up looking for the door and sat down on the floor with his back against the wall.  He would have to just wait here for someone to find him. 

Where he found himself was in the deepest reaches of Erebor, just above the mines. Bilbo knew from the maps he had looked over when they first found the library that he was somewhere near the prison. He had never visited these levels himself and never had the desire to. But this is where the directions had led, so with some obviously misplaced trust he had followed them. When he smelled food he had followed the scent to this room, figuring the company would be there when he rounded the corner, but there had been no one. Then, the door had fallen shut behind him. Now he was trapped and alone.

Food, however, there was an abundance of.  There was a table in the center of the small, dark room laden with all sorts of roasts and platters. The table was lit with two tall candles, setting the numerous shadows flickering. Bilbo wondered where all this food had come from in these times when food was still a precious thing in Erebor.

Bilbo, alone, near the prison blocks, and apparently trapped in a trap laid by an unknown trickster, began to feel truly unsettled.  

 There wasn't anyone in the prisons that he knew of.  Erebor's population was still to small yet for such happenings to be a normal occurrence, but all the same Bilbo feared what might be down here. He unsheathed Sting, feeling like a fool for fearing ghosts of his imagination after all he had been through.  He fingered the ring in his pocket to reassure himself.

A noise from the other end of the small room made him jump a foot in the air, his hand set to shaking on the hilt of his sword.

"Is someone there?" he squeaked, then remembered his lessons in personal defence with Thorin and Dwalin.  "I'm armed and I will hurt you!"  He couldn't use the ring now, he realized. The figure knew he was here even if it was blind and there was nowhere to escape- even for an invisible Hobbit.

The noise repeated, a sort of stone on stone grinding, and the shadow of a figure started to form from the darkness. Before he could second guess his actions Bilbo launched himself at it, swinging his sword wildly as he went.

The figure caught his first blow in the chest, but didn't even flinch.  Bilbo heard the crash of metal on metal and realized the mystery person must be wearing armor.  Before he could ponder how a ghost or an escaped convict could be wearing armor, the figure had caught the hilt of his sword in his hand and twisted it from his grip gently.  Bilbo flailed and with a grunt and in a scuffle the two fell to the floor as one.

"Mister Baggins," a familiar voice grunted against Bilbo's elbow as his collided with his assailant's face. "I see your lessons in fighting have done you some good after all, though not very much."

"Thorin!" Bilbo cried, slumping in relief against the floor. "You should've said something! You nearly scared the life out of me."

"I would've if you'd given me time to do so. May I inform you, it may not be the wisest course of action to attack a person before you know who it is.  After all, your greatest ally in one-on-one combat-" 

"-is knowledge of your opponent.  I know, Thorin."

The pair realized they were laying on top of one and other, and simultaneously remembered that they shouldn't be.

Bilbo pushed himself up in a hurry, retreating to the other side of the room into the light of the candles sitting on the table. "What are you doing here?"

 "I might ask you that question," Thorin grunted, following Bilbo off the floor and moving to stand across the table from him, hands behind his back, surveying the feast with obvious confusion.

"The company was throwing me a going-away feast," Bilbo stated stiffly feeling twice as trapped as he had before.  "This was where their directions lead."

Thorin glared at the door. "I wondered why Balin wanted me to inspect these rooms."

 The two fidgeted awkwardly, feeling like fools for falling for the company's obvious deception.  After several moments Thorin sat down at the table.  

"We may as well enjoy the feast the company has gifted us with.  Food is too scarce to come by in Erebor yet, and if they have wastefully gathered so much someone might as well enjoy it while it's still edible."  He glared wordlessly at the walls as if the company was behind them and could hear his condemnation.

"Far be it from me to wrong your people," Bilbo muttered unhappily, but he sat across from Thorin anyways, helping himself to the roast and carrots. He had thought that same thing earlier, despite his sarcasm. It would've made his chest swell with happiness a week ago, to know he and Thorin were so close in mind to one and other, but now it sent his gut twisting. Here was the man so resolved not to court him on behalf of such a folly notion as propriety.

Bilbo resolved he would not let Thorin see his unhappiness. Thorin's the one who doesn't want to talk anyways. It's only proper to let him have his way and avoid conflict. That was how polite acquaintances behaved.

They ate in silence until neither could eat any more.  Then, they settled back in their seats, staring pointedly at the walls, the silence in the room getting thicker by the minute until both of them tried to speak at once. 

"I'm sorry for-"

"I hope that you-"

They stopped as one to let the other continue. When neither complied, Thorin told Bilbo to go on. Bilbo sighed.

"I'm sorry for attacking you before. I didn't hurt you did I?  I hit you in the chest with my sword."

Thorin snorted, "No, you did not hurt me, Halfling.  Your hit landed on the flat of your blade."

 "Ah," Bilbo said, blushing.  This couldn't be more embarrassing if he tried.

"I hope you are happy when-" Thorin paused, clearing his throat. He looked up at Bilbo from behind his lashes and tried again. "From what I've heard of your homeland it seems like a very lovely place."

"Oh, you would hate it. There hasn't been a battle there in over forty years," Bilbo bated, hoping Thorin would take up the attempt at conversation and ask him about it. But true to form Thorin merely sat silently, looking sadder by the second.  Bilbo's chest hollowed as he watched him, until he couldn't stand it any longer. He couldn't convince himself to act with propriety around Thorin no matter how he tried- from the moment when he heard the dwarves singing in the living room at Bag End to when Thorin growled the dwarven vows of courtship in his ear that night in the woods with the company not far away. Thorin was too much; too full of life and passion for Bilbo to behave with any sense of polite detachment in his presence.

"If you don't want me to go, you could just say," Bilbo nearly whispered, unable to believe he was willing to put his heart on the line by trying to talk about his feelings with a man who had already rejected him once. He was in far too deep, he realized then.

Thorin shut his eyes and shook his head slowly, hair falling forward in an inky black curtain.  "You would not forgive me." 

"Well I think that's quite for me to decide, isn't it," Bilbo said waspishly, tired of Thorin asserting his kingliness in their personal life. Being a king should have no bearing here, where they were trying to share something so obviously fragile.

Thorin's head raised as he realized what Bilbo had just insinuated before Bilbo himself did. Oh well, he thought, deciding that if he was going to drip his toes in he might as well jump in, even if it meant drowning.

"I understand, Thorin," he sighed, standing and turning to face the wall behind him, unable to look at Thorin while he spoke. "I understand your need to put your people first.  I've always admired that in you and I've no right to be angry about it now. But even so," he paused to collect himself. "There is a part of me, a traitor part, that can't help but feel a bit betrayed that you don't think what we have is worth the trouble of defending my place by your side to others. You would let me go back to the Shire- without even a farewell, apparently- all for the sake of your propriety. It's grotesquely ironic. Propriety has ruined my life, you know. It's taken both my homes from me, now I'm not wanted in either of them."

There was the noise of a chair scraping against the ground, and Bilbo turned to see Thorin standing, leaning forward on the table.  "You think I'm doing this because I don't think you're worth the effort?" He ground out, glaring at Bilbo wildly.

Bilbo stared at him, waiting for him to explain why else he would be ending their courtship with what he considered admirable patience.

Thorin grappled with his frustration for a moment before he spoke. "What if there's dissent among my people because of us, or even something I do independent of you, and they take it out on you?  What if I can't protect you in my own kingdom, against my own people?"

Bilbo gaped at him.  Is that seriously what this is all about?  He had the urge to laugh but swallowed it, sensing Thorin wouldn't appreciate laughter at a time like this.

"May I remind you I am quite capable of protecting myself.  I save your skin numerous times, you know!  You and all thirteen of your company!" he cried, incredulously, sounding slightly hysterical. 

Thorin caught his humor despite his efforts and gave him a perplexed frown, "I know, Bilbo. And I thank you for that.  But that does not-"

"Besides, your people adore you," Bilbo cut him off. "Even an outsider like me can see that. And what you're afraid off… that's only if it ever comes to violence against your rule, which, I am assuming, you have no actual evidence for possible occurrences of besides your own wild beliefs." 

The two stood in silence, Bilbo daring to hope Thorin would see he was speaking the truth and they would recover from this. He was still unable to believe they had been so foolish. What had he said, and almost done, all for nothing? Thorin merely looked at him with an unfathomable expression until Bilbo sighed and spoke again.

"Thorin," he said firmly. "I will leave if you want me to leave," Thorin opened his mouth but Bilbo raised his hand calling for silence. Thorin complied. "I will stay if you want me to stay. But don't make the choice alone. I would gladly fight the current of a hundred Erebors if it meant staying by your side, you must know that."

"But you shouldn't have to," Thorin murmured softly.

 "I would do it, though.  For you."

"It's your choice," Bilbo continued quietly. It took several moments for Thorin to respond.

He rose from his position leaning on the table and went to stand before Bilbo, bowing his head to look his in the eyes.  

"Bilbo," he murmured.  Bilbo felt his breath ghost across his face as he shivered at the sweetness in the tone. "I'm sorry for making you doubt me, and for getting so worried about so little. When we sent you down from the doorstep into Erebor for the second time to meet the dragon, I swore to myself that I would never place you in harms way again. And then," he paused to swallow thickly, settling his gaze somewhere on the wall to the left of Bilbo's head. "I broke that promise myself."  Bilbo rubbed Thorin's arm habitually in comfort as he listened.

 Thorin continued. "I can't bear the thought of you injured. But after considering what my life would be without you for the last three days, I can see clearly enough now to know I could never want a life such as that. I've been stubborn and refused to hear the truths spoken to me by the people I trust most, and almost losing you is all I need to regret that fact.  I understand now you only said the things you said out of hurt. Hurt that I caused." He paused before looking back into Bilbo's eyes searchingly. "Would you do me the honor of renewing our courtship even though I am a great oaf of a dwarf who doesn't deserve you in the slightest?"

Bilbo laughed, feeling his eyes water dangerously,  "Of course, Thorin," he breathed, feeling as if he had sat down by a warm fire after walking a mile in a rainstorm. "Nothing would make me happier."

At that moment the entire company fell through the air vent in the ceiling.  

"Finally!" Dwalin exclaimed, rubbing his back as he hopped off the pile of Ri brothers that had broken his fall. Dori whined wordlessly in protest at the jostling, and help a disoriented Nori out from underneath him.

"That was as bad as the barrels," Bombur moaned as his cousin pulled him through the relatively small opening.  Bilbo wondered how he had moved through the vents at all.

"And equally as nauseating, there towards the end," Fili said, earning a round of agreement from the group.

"No one told you to listen in on our private conversations," Thorin growled as Fili thumped Thorin's back in congratulations.

"Aye, they did not.  But if we didn't who would keep you two from ruining each other's lives with your stubbornness and surprising lack of communication skills for a King and a quick-witted Hobbit?" Bofur stated.

Thorin, unable to think of a suitably scathing response, settled for rolling his eyes instead. The company crowded around them offering congratulations and he swatted them off irritably, without any real venom.

Bilbo was too happy to be angry about much of anything. He caught Thorin's hand in his own and smiled up at him fondly until Thorin caught his mood and smiled tentatively back.

"I'm sorry, Bilbo," he said  "I know that you can take care of yourself, and that I sometimes think myself the king of you, instead of the lover. I will try to listen to your opinions if you promise to remind me when I don't. And if it ever comes to such a time that we have reason to worry about your safety, I promise I will protect you at all costs. No one will ever lay so much as a finger on you again- they would have to kill me first." 

"Let's not get carried away," Bilbo cried, cringing at the image of Thorin in a medical tent, pale as the sheets and begging for forgiveness with ragged breath. "I do promise," Bilbo continued. "And I'm sorry too. I should've never let this get so out of hand, I know you would never act with the dishonor I accused you of. It was immature and petty of me to say such things." 

Thorin hummed and squeezed Bilbo's hand tighter. 

"Let's get out of these dark halls and back to where we belong."

The next morning Balin came by Thorin's quarters to apologize for causing the whole thing, an apology that Thorin waved off.  It was completely his own fault, he insisted, and though Bilbo unhappily complained that it was his as well Thorin would have none of it.  

Balin assured the pair that they are fully prepared to deal with any consequences of their courtship from the council, but he doubts their complaining will last for long.  There were other, more pressing issues that would steal away their idle concerns, what with the caravan of dwarves from Ered Luin set to arrive in less than a fortnight.  And if they became interested again afterwards, then Bilbo would have the extra defense of Lady Dis- who's known for her sharp tongue and even sharper wit- on his side. 

Balin had even taken a precautionary poll on the matter and determined that there was nothing but contentment among the people, even on the subject of the king's courtship.  They are as loyal to him as ever, and much too thankful to Thorin for his leadership and services to dwarven-kind both, to care about such small things as proper succession and preferential treatment of his company in the court. 

Balin concludes that the dwarves of Erebor would rather have a happy king than live without a Hobbit in the mountain.  As for the council, it may not be easy to take them off the subject of the King's personal life, but when has anything ever been easy for them?  And they've done alright so far despite it all.  

Bilbo thinks they've done quite a bit more than alright, and he says so.  And though it may not be proper for courting couples to kiss in front of guests, Bilbo has had enough of propriety for one lifetime, so he does it anyways.

Balin merely chuckles and excuses himself, going to inform the company that they've averted another disaster successfully and hoping that it will be at least a few weeks until their intervention is needed once again.  The kitchens only have so much food to trap angry Hobbits with after all.  

Notes:

Finally something came out of all my writing, unedited as it may be. Check out my blog if you like at http://earlgreyhaught.tumblr.com/