Chapter Text
Max didn’t expect her life to immediately go back to normal and she was kind of wondering if that was even a possibility now. Even with the gate closed and most of her questions answered, she knew things definitely weren’t normal with Billy. They hadn’t really talked and what few words had passed between them were pretty meaningless anyways. What mattered was that he’d backed off. It also meant she was without a ride most of the time but seeing as most of her friends rode their bikes and she had her skateboard, she honestly didn’t mind. Besides, if she really needed a ride somewhere she could call on Steve or Will’s mom to help out.
That was how things went, past the Snowball Dance and winter break. Everyone was kind of out of their usual routine during that time and it was pretty hard for Neil and her mom to keep perfect eyes on herself or Billy. That changed once school started though. Not right away. There were a few weeks of mostly peace and any hell from home was pushed aside with the time she got to spend with Lucas and her new friends. She’d even gotten to meet Eleven a few more times though it became rarer what with school starting again. The police chief was also pretty damn protective and it seemed she wouldn’t really get to hang out with the girl until a year passed and she was able to take her new name.
Either way, Max didn’t really have time to focus on Eleven or the mystical crap because school was starting to kick her ass now that she had a reason to actually work to stay in this particular one. She stuck with her own schedule, Billy occasionally dropping her off in the morning. A lot of times she would leave before he could though, and after school Steve often took her and the others to the arcade.
It was almost like she had a whole new family.
Not to seem completely heartless, she did love her mom even if she still didn’t forgive her for marrying Neil and moving here. But at least what she felt for Lucas and Dustin and Will and Mike wasn’t really marred by any life altering events, not in a negative way anyhow.
So life…it wasn’t perfect but it was good. Max was pretty damn content and she’d even chalked up the nerve to kiss Lucas again which had felt great. It was all so good…
…for exactly three weeks after winter break. That was how long the good lasted until she’d been a bit late coming home. She saw Billy’s car and Neil’s in the driveway. She didn’t see her mom’s, probably out grocery shopping, so she decided to try and avoid the likely fighting by going straight to her bedroom window.
She’d seen how Billy and Neil fought and it almost always put a smile on her face, watching Billy walk out in anger either towards his car or to his room like some kicked mutt. She’d even caught sight of Neil slapping him once and she’d had to cover her mouth from letting a satisfied laugh out. It was wrong, she understood that and she sure as hell wouldn’t have ever let her own mom or dad treat her like that no matter what. But she’d always figured Billy deserved it for one reason or another. Why else would Neil feel like he had to do it?
Still, she wasn’t in the mood to witness all that so she went through her bedroom window anyways. As she eased her feet onto the floor, a loud bang caused her to drop her skateboard. It came from Billy’s room next door and she silently cursed as apparently the fight was still in progress and they both had to be in there.
Max held her breath, hoping that they wouldn’t come in…just please…please…
He came in without even knocking the bastard. “Maxine. When did you get here?” asked Neil.
“Just now sir. I…I was trying to be quiet.”
“Well it’s alright. How did you get home?”
“I skateboarded,” she politely replied. She could have a pretty bad attitude from time to time with others but she’d decided early on to at least not risk it with Neil.
“Well next time tell me if Billy doesn’t take you home. It’s supposed to be his responsibility and if he doesn’t, I need to know so I can fix it,” Neil said, completely serious. “Understood?”
“Yes sir.”
“Good. Make sure you’re at the table by six. Your mother’s cooking dinner tonight.”
And like that, Neil had disappeared thank god. Max’s shoulders relaxed and she sat on her bed, getting ready to start some homework when she jumped again, another bang coming from Billy’s room. Apparently their conversation hadn’t been finished.
Max decided to stay in her room for the next few minutes just in case before she ran out to grab a drink of water. It seemed to be a good idea as there was another bang and Max wondered if it was Billy or Neil who threw the thing. Just a little longer and…now that she at least knew was the sound of a door being slammed. Probably Billy running off or Neil going to the living room to drink and watch TV.
Avoiding either would be easy enough now and Max went out to grab a glass. She had to pass Billy’s room on the way over and she could see the door must have been slammed open and then the force of the push had caused it to swing back. It gave her a limited view into his room but it was still something. Max could just barely see all the macho teenage stuff that she could give two craps about.
Her eyes fell on Billy right away though, at least what she could see of him. Max froze, now deadly afraid of what Billy might do if he actually caught her staring. But it didn’t seem like he would notice her, not right now as he…cried?
She’d never seen Billy cry. It seemed as possible as the Upside Down had when Lucas first told her but…well since that was real then why couldn’t this be?
Ever so slowly, Max stepped back and quickly went into her room, deciding she’d get something to drink later once her mom was home.
She tried to turn to her homework, it should have been easy, but all she could do was think about those tears and whether or not it had happened before. She started to feel guilt well up over every other time she’d smiled over Neil yelling at him but she quickly pushed those thoughts away. So what if he had? Billy was a dick and deserved it and this was just another messed up day in the Hargrove-Mayfield household.
Yeah, that was it.
After thinking that, Max finally relaxed and turned back to her textbooks.
Max said it in passing when one of her friends mentioned the odd disappearance and Dustin simply snorted, “Good riddance.”
“He do this a lot?” asked Lucas.
“For a few hours, sure, but not days,” sighed Max. So far it had been two since Billy hadn’t shown up and neither her mom nor Neil could find him or his car.
Will’s brow knitted together. “Are you worried?”
“What do you think?” Mike said with a roll of his eyes.
“Course I’m not worried. Like Dustin said, good riddance,” muttered Max. “But it’s been causing problems for Neil which will cause problems for my mom and that’s less cool.”
“What if it’s the Upside Down?” Dustin excitedly whispered.
“Don’t even joke about that!” hissed Mike, all eyes falling to Will for a split second.
If the comment had upset him though, he didn’t show it as he said, “El closed it guys. She defeated the Mind Flayer. We’re good, right?”
“Of course we are,” muttered Lucas. “Billy is just a massive douche who ran off somewhere and we’re better off for it.”
Max shrugged in agreement. “He is only a few months away from being eighteen. He’s talked about leaving before. Maybe he finally just took a chance.”
“From what little we’ve interacted, I wouldn’t be surprised,” Dustin muttered. “And anyways, why are we talking about that ass when we’ve got this tournament still going on. Much better topic.”
“We don’t really need to do this, do we guys? We all know I’ll win anyways,” smirked Max.
“Like hell you will. Come on,” Mike retorted as they all rushed the machine, quarters in hand.
It was easy to forget about Billy as they went back and forth. Even better, Will’s mom had invited everyone over for dinner so Max was busy laughing and joking and teasing each of her new friends through most of the evening. It was great but then, that seemed to be what her life was like. Things were great, until they weren’t. And they always seemed to be ‘weren’t’ the moment she walked into her house.
After Will’s mom had dropped her off at home and she’d gone inside, her eyes fell on her own mom restlessly pacing back and forth. She could hear Neil yelling in the kitchen. Max honestly wasn’t too sure why Neil was getting this worked up considering half the time he didn’t even seem to want Billy around, yet he was cursing up a storm in there.
“Oh Maxine-oh I’m sorry but we’re just—”
“I’m guessing you haven’t found him,” she murmured as her mom came close.
“No, we haven’t. Sweetheart, do you know—”
“Told you everything I did. No idea where he is,” muttered Max. “I’ve got homework I need to finish before I go to bed.”
“Of course sweetheart. Just know you can always talk to me. You know that right?”
Max just shrugged and slipped back out of her mom’s grasp before quickly walking off to her room. Billy’s door was open and she chanced a glance in. The place was a complete mess, probably because of Neil tearing it apart. Max wouldn’t be surprised that if any clues were hiding in there, they’d been unintentionally destroyed by Neil’s chaos.
There wasn't exactly anything she could do so she just turned back towards her room and went inside.
She didn’t think about Billy again until she was ready to go to bed and then Dustin’s comment drifted back into her head. No…it couldn’t possibly be about the Upside Down. For one thing, the gate was closed and for another, if anything strange started happening, the last person that would be involved would be Billy. That she was sure of.
“Where the hell have you been?!” yelled Max after she’d gotten over her initial shock. She was happy that Will was off with his mom, Lucas was with a teacher, Dustin off with Steve, and Mike going with Hopper to visit Eleven because this wouldn’t have gone any better with all of them here. “You’ve been gone for over a week!”
She marched forward expecting…something. But there was no anger or explanation in his eyes. He was just kind of…blank in an odd way.
“Get in the car Max.”
“You haven’t driven me home in a month. I can get home just fine,” she grumbled. Whatever crisis Billy was dealing with and whatever reason as to why he was back, Max didn’t care and she really didn’t want to deal with it. She went by and when Billy still didn’t react, she figured this would actually be pretty easy. No fight, god what a relief—
“Hey!”
Last minute, Billy grabbed her arm. Max tried to pull away but he held tight. His grip was even more painful than last time but there was no screaming that went with it. He didn’t yell in her face or shoot her one of those nasty glares. It…was almost like it wasn’t Billy.
He repeated it. The words not quite calm but…just plain. Plain and expressionless. “Get in the car Max.”
Finger by finger, he let go. Max resisted the urge to pull away, fearing he’d grab her again if she made to quick of a motion. She watched him like a wild animal which was ironic considering the fact that this was the most unruffled he’d ever acted around her minus the time she’d drugged him.
Max got into the car. She didn’t take her eyes off Billy and that brought up even more questions as he didn’t yell anything like ‘stop staring at me’ or ‘god don’t be such a zombie freak’. Nothing rude and unnecessary or cruel. He just started driving and kept driving. He didn’t even turn any music up.
“Where…where were you?” It took ages for Max to gather up the courage to ask that despite how she didn’t even think he’d answer.
…She was right. He didn’t answer. She whispered it once more but he didn’t even react. Usually she would have growled out something. Something stupid like ‘what are you, deaf now?’ but she kept her mouth shut.
This had to be one of the longest car rides with Billy she’d ever had. It felt like hours had passed as he didn’t even react. God, what was wrong with him? Did he get hit on the head? Have partial amnesia and only remembered the bits and pieces? It was the only answer Max could come up with that made some sense and it was obvious she wasn’t going to get anything out of Billy anyways.
She just stayed silent and resisted the urge to bolt the moment they were home and the car was stopped. Some small part thought Billy would grab her again but he didn’t and Max managed to get to her room without any other incident. She really wished she had a lock on the door but if she really needed to, she was pretty sure she could drag her desk over to the door and block it.
Max spent the rest of her afternoon looking at the chapter she was supposed to read for class but that’s all she did. Look at it. She wished she was closer to the other houses. They’d planned to get her a walkie-talkie but even if she already had one, it did little good what with the distance between their houses and hers. She could sneak out the window and go find one of them but as creepy as all this was, she was kind of curious what would happen once Neil and her mom got home. Maybe they’d get the answers she couldn’t.
It was late when they did arrive but Max could tell from the screeching tires outside. Neil had to be driving and he had to have spotted Billy’s car.
Max waited a second to see if the confrontation would happen in the living room or Billy’s. When she didn’t hear anyone storming past her door, she guessed they were all in the living room and carefully crept out. The moment her door was open she heard Neil and it only got louder as she moved towards the living room. She could see her mom first and her heart did a painful twinge. Why did she have to marry this asshole? She wouldn’t have gone through so much damn heartache if she hadn’t.
There wasn’t anything about that which could be done now though and Max didn’t want to run into the middle of this, even if it was to comfort her mom. She stayed in the shadows instead, watched as Neil yelled at Billy the same question Max had tried to get him to answer.
“Where the hell were you?! No one was here to take care of Max! You had Susan worried sick! Why the hell did you just leave!?”
Considering those few times when Max had seen them fight, Billy had been more on the defense than offense so his silence wasn’t too surprising. What was though was how he still looked kind of blank, like he saw what was happening but it wasn’t affecting him.
“I just needed a break from everything.”
“You needed a break? A break son? Did nothing we talk about last time get through your thick skull!!!”
Max flinched when the first hit came and again with the second and third. She’d always assumed that any thudding that came from the Hargroves was them throwing things. They’d done it before. But similar to when she’d seen Billy crying, Max started to wonder exactly how many times Neil had hit his son.
It was on the third slap that Max noticed a reaction-finally! Something that she recognized as pure Billy, anger and embarrassment. So he was still in there. She watched as Billy’s mouth turned up ever so slightly into one of his ugly sneers and emotion came back into his voice.
“I just needed a break—”
“You don’t get to make that call!!!” Neil yelled and he hit him again only this time it wasn’t a slap but a punch, hard and weighted as it connected to Billy’s jaw and he dropped to the ground. Max’s mouth fell open and for a split second she wasn’t seeing her asshole of a step-brother. She was just seeing a kid getting the shit beat out of him by his dad.
She’d been scared to death of the demodogs and the whole Upside Down and Mind Flayer thing but this…this was a different kind of fear. There was no hairs standing on the back of her neck and she felt no reason to scream or flee. She just felt…numb. Numb and cold and though it was a completely different situation, she couldn’t help but imagine if this was what Will had felt. Just this creeping sensation that ran through her veins.
“You do not get to choose when you do and do not accept responsibilities! You will never leave again and you will never disappoint Maxine or Susan again! Do you understand me!? Do you!?”
By this point, Billy had dragged himself back up. He was breathing heavily and Max could see the mixture of anger and pain on his face along with whatever little emotion she’d identified when she’d spotted him crying.
“Yes…sir.”
Neil leaned in and whispered something that Max couldn’t hear but she watched the shiver run through Billy and how he quickly nodded his head. When Neil finally moved back, she expected Billy to run out the front door again but considering this fight had happened because he’d disappeared, Max supposed it made sense that he’d run to his room instead.
Max quickly backed up but she couldn’t help but glance at Billy’s face as he passed and her eyes went wide.
The first few seconds, he looked like how she would expect, enraged and looking like he wanted to either destroy something or start crying. But then he blinked and…Max watched his expression change. It changed from what Billy was supposed to look like to what he had looked like when he’d shown up, when he was in the car. Just a blink of the eye and he was flat…expressionless.
With Billy completely past her, she ran into her room, closed the door, and shoved her desk in front of it without a second thought. She wasn’t sure what she was protecting herself from. Some conversation with Neil and her mom or Billy but she did it anyways, curling up on her bed and gripping her hands so tight her knuckles were starting to lose color.
Her mind ran with all sorts of ideas, both purely rational and ones involving the Upside Down. What the hell was happening?
“Get in you little shit before you make me late.”
Max slowly did, her eyes wide as she stared at her step-brother.
“Stop being such a god damn creep and stare at something else why don’t ya?” growled Billy as he turned on his cassette player and twisted the volume knob until it was almost all the way up.
Had she dreamed it all?
Max couldn’t be sure but the worry she’d felt yesterday was starting to disappear as she just saw asshole, dickhead Billy. Maybe something significant had happened to him while he’d been gone and he’d just been freaking out over it. And whatever had happened didn’t necessarily have to do with the Upside Down or the supernatural. She didn’t think Billy did drugs but hey, drugs would at least make sense and it was an easy explanation.
“I said stop staring you damn freak.”
Max just rolled her eyes and turned to look out the window. She wouldn’t exactly use the word ‘comforting’ but that was the best way she could describe having Billy back. She at least knew how to deal with actual Billy. Not the emotionless one.
She shook her head at the memory and hoped she’d never have to see that again or whatever went down with Neil. If they had more of a connection, Max might have asked about it, tried to find some way to comfort him. She wasn’t stupid after all. She wouldn’t be surprised if Billy was still choked up over that even if his asshole personality was back in place.
But for the most part, Max didn’t care about Billy and vice versa. No point in trying to do something that Billy obviously wouldn’t want.
She just rested against the seat and listened to the blasting rock music as the wind whipped by.
“Hey Eleven, can we talk?”
Max and the kids were at Hopper’s cabin for the first time in almost two months. Despite Hawkins Lab being gone, some talk of new government people coming in had Hopper being more protective than usual. Once that threat was gone though, Hopper had made up for his over protectiveness with having all the kids over for a little party. Despite the fact that Max wouldn’t call her and Eleven friends, she’d been invited too.
Now the boys got their D&D campaign set up that they’d apparently planned for weeks just for this party. It would be Eleven’s and Max’s first time playing so a good chunk of time was going to be put aside to explain all the rules to them but that also meant they had a chance at a moment alone. Max wondered if Eleven would actually accept and for several tense seconds, Max didn’t breathe.
Eleven nodded.
Max’s shoulders relaxed and she followed the girl into her room. It was a bit more private but Eleven didn’t close the door and Max didn’t see a reason to push her to.
“I just…I wanted to say I know I’m the new kid and I don’t think I ever apologized for kind of just…shoving my way in. I do want to be your friend though. If…you don’t mind. I mean, all of them back there are great and what not but having a girl friend my age would be nice. You know?”
Max hesitated, trailing off as she waited for some type of answer. The problem with Eleven was that it was difficult to say when she was talking over her or not. Max started to wonder if she should say more just as Eleven seemed to focus on her again.
“I was new kid. I understand,” she finally murmured. She suddenly stuck out her hand, the motion clearly mimicked from others she’d seen but it wasn’t a familiar gesture. “Friend.”
“Uh cool. Yeah, friend,” Max said with a small smile as they both shook on it.
Eleven walked passed her, apparently marking the conversation as done but Max would count the small talk a victory all the same. It was the most words Eleven had ever said to her after all and that had to count for something.
Max walked out and saw that the guys had left their D&D planning for what Hopper was setting out for them. They were crowded around what looked like mini towers of waffles and sugar. She couldn’t help but make a face despite the fact that she clearly saw how Eleven’s lit up.
“You really like this?”
“Hey, anything Eggo don’t knock it or El will mind bend you across the room,” grinned Dustin.
Everyone rolled their eyes as Eleven was quick to be the first one to sit and scarf down the monstrosity before her. Max wasn’t quite there for it but hey, at least Eleven seemed to be enjoying it.
They ended up bringing their Eggo, sugar towers over to the D&D table and played all Saturday. It took a while for Max to really get into the flow of it all but once she was there she had to admit it was pretty fun.
“Let go of me! Let go!”
Max was screaming it but it didn’t matter. It wasn’t like they were in the school parking lot or at home. Billy had pulled off on the side of the road and as far as Max could tell, there really wasn’t anything nearby.
“Let go!” she yelled again just as Billy hit her hard. She gaped at him. He’d never done that, not this. Maybe if things were normal she would have chalked it up to Billy just going over the unredeemable deep end with no chance of coming back. Instead, something in the back of her mind started to pull up all those strange moments that hadn’t seemed right since his disappearance.
He’d been even angrier and more violent though this was the first time he’d actually singled her out. However, going by Billy’s own warped logic and personality, the anger hadn’t quite made sense. In a normal context, Billy still never made sense but what had been happening also just wasn’t…him.
And she’d like to believe that blank expression hadn’t popped up again but she was just being naïve if she really believed that. It had popped up, here and there, and each time Billy had seemed to come back to himself, he’d just seemed angrier and more distant and less like himself, just in a different way than the blank version.
“You ever inconvenience me again and you’ll regret it Maxine,” hissed Billy. “You’ll get more than a damn knock upside the head.”
Max desperately nodded in compliance but she couldn’t breathe easily even when he let go. Not until she was out of the car and away from him.
It was nearly summer break and it was at that point school was basically done for the year. Less than a week left in total. That meant skipping class was pretty damn easy as Max and Lucas sat underneath the bleachers, kids running around without a care in the world.
“Max, what happened?”
She winced as Lucas tenderly touched her bruise.
“It’s…nothing.”
“It’s not nothing! It looks like it hurts too,” Lucas replied, a frown setting into his face.
“Just family stuff. It won’t happen again.”
“You mean Billy did this?! I’ll kill him Max! I will—”
“No it’s-it’s not like that. It…you know what? I want you to come home with me. I want to show you something.”
“Wait you mean…like be in your room?”
“I’ve been in your room before,” Max muttered with a roll of her eyes.
“Yeah but it’s uh…different when it’s a guy in a girl’s room.”
“No it’s not stalker. It’s just a room. Now do you want to help me or not?”
“Well what are we doing? I know I said I’d kill him but I don’t actually want to go to prison—”
“We’re not going to kill him! There’s just…something I want you to see. It’s weird.”
“Like Billy may be in a drug ring weird or Upside Down weird?”
“Just come with me, will you?”
“Fine! Fine! When do you want me over?”
“As soon as you can. I’m not going to the arcade today so Billy will probably drop me off at home and then run off somewhere.”
“Wait! You’re actually going to get in a car with him. After this!?”
“It took him a while to hit me again. I doubt he’ll do it a third time this soon.”
“You mean he’s done—”
“Just stop arguing with me ok. I’ll see you there in about an hour,” Max replied, giving Lucas their third kiss on the cheek and then running off to the parking lot.
Yesterday Billy had hit her again and she’d had to lie through her teeth that she’d just tripped and hit her head on the edge of her desk. Her mom and Neil had only just bought it but they thankfully didn’t push harder and didn’t seem to make the connection with Billy.
Max had hoped it was a onetime thing, that moment when Billy had pulled over and Max had never felt more scared in her life. But it had happened again, yesterday in fact, and the drastic switch between expressionless and sudden violence was becoming more and more noticeable. She couldn’t ignore it anymore and she had to make a choice now. Either Lucas would assure her that Billy was just a horrendous bully that she should tell her mom about or he’d tell her what she really didn’t want to here.
That something was off.
While in the car, it was one of the expressionless moments and he left the moment Max was out. At least he was gone for now.
Max ran to her room and waited for Lucas to show up in her backyard. She helped pull him through her window and he paused once on his feet.
“So this…this is what a girl’s room looks like huh?”
“Chill stalker,” snorted Max. “Now come on. This isn’t what I wanted you to see.”
She took his hand and dragged him out of her room and into Billy’s.
“Wait, why are we in here?” asked Lucas.
“I know Steve might have been a better option but…well you’re a boy too. I just…things are wrong. Right?”
“Yeah, it’s too clean,” muttered Lucas. “I’m guessing it’s not usually like this?”
“No not…originally. But it’s been like this for the past few weeks.”
“Max, are you telling me things have been off for that long?”
“Longer-but it’s not like he’s hit me the whole time! That’s been a…uh new development.”
“He’s an ass who’s gotten into cleaning then. Easy enough,” Lucas muttered with a dark look.
“So…you think that’s it?”
“What else could it be?”
“Something…supernatural?”
“You’ve been listening to Dustin too much,” groaned Lucas. “We’ve all agreed Billy’s a horrible human being. This is just next level crap. We should talk to Hopper. He can help you press charges and get that ass out of here.”
“Are you sure—shit!”
Just then it sounded like the front door was being opened and slammed shut.
“Hurry,” hissed Max, dragging Lucas out of Billy’s room and back into her own. Before she could whisper the next step of the plan though, she could just barely hear shouting and realized that Neil and Billy were fighting again in the living room.
She looked to her window and thought about just getting the hell out of there. She’d be killed if either of them caught Lucas in her room but…something pulled her to leave and spy on Neil and Billy again. Something was even more wrong. She could feel it in the air even if the sound of the fight made it seem like any other time before.
Max carefully pushed her door open and headed towards the living room as Neil yelled at Billy for something he’d apparently forgotten to do. As she peaked around the corner, she noted that it seemed just like any other fight and she wondered why it felt wrong at all.
“Why—”
She hushed Lucas with a quick wave, her eyes focused on Billy and Neil. There was yelling and shouting and Billy threw something. Pretty typical. Then things escalated a bit and Neil slapped Billy and Max flinched again as she watched.
It was pretty awful but not—
“Stop it!!!”
Max’s mouth dropped to the floor as she watched Billy scream, grab a lamp, and throw it into his father’s head.
Neil went down, the first hit enough to bring the man to his knees but Billy didn’t stop. He picked up the bottom of the lamp and hit him again and again. Blood flew upwards and hit the couch and ceilings and walls. A howl escaped Billy’s throat and he dropped the lamp, resorting to punching instead. Max watched on horrified until she couldn’t take it anymore. She didn’t care about Neil but at this rate Billy would go so far he wouldn’t be able to return.
“Stop it Billy! You’re killing him!” yelled Max as she jumped out from behind the corner.
Billy froze and then oh so slowly straightened his back. He looked over, the crazed look in his eyes disappearing to show just…confusion. His eyes moved back to the floor, Neil coughing up blood and bubbles popping outwards, spraying the blood further.
He looked so confused and lost. It was wrong. It was all wrong!
“Run…”
Max’s head snapped back to Billy. “What—”
“I said run Max!”
He didn’t have to say it twice. She spun around, grabbed hold of Lucas, and ran back to her room. She left her skateboard behind as she launched herself out the window with Lucas right behind her. He didn’t even have to yell at her to get on, she just did and he immediately started to frantically pedal away from her house. They didn’t stop until they were two blocks away, both wheezing and eyes wide.
“We’ve gotta get Hopper—”
“We need Eleven!” interrupted Max.
“Listen, the Upside Down is closed. Billy’s just flipped his lid and Hopper needs to come and arrest his ass—”
“He told us to run!”
“Yeah, cause he wanted something to chase! He’s probably after us right now! We need to get to Hopper—”
“You didn’t see the look on his face,” stressed Max. “He was-confused. He looked like he had no idea what was going on. Something is wrong here and it’s more than Billy’s just gone psycho!”
Lucas hesitated. It was clear he didn’t want to believe her. Dealing with the psychotic Billy was a lot easier than if the Upside Down was actually open again or something equally insane.
Max didn’t back down though. She’d stood by what she’d said and what she’d seen. Something was wrong and not in a normal way at all.
“Fine, Steve’s house is closest though. We’ll go there and get him to drive us to the cabin.”
“What if he’s not home?”
“We’ll call Hopper or Joyce and get them to pick us up,” replied Lucas. “Deal.”
“Yeah, fine. That’s good enough,” Max sighed as she eased back on the bike and gripped him tightly.
The entire way to Steve’s house, both couldn’t help but glance back and all around, wondering if Billy would actually come after them. Max didn’t think actual Billy would. He’d yelled ‘run’ as a warning, not to start some game. But whatever was eating away at him, was making him do this, that might come after them. Max had no idea what it wanted but it clearly fed off of Billy’s anger and what a bottomless pit of energy that must have been.
Sadly, Steve’s car wasn’t in his driveway so Lucas pedaled into the backyard and they both found a window to climb through. Lucas had just run to the phone as the front door opened. They froze as the idea of ‘oh god it’s Billy’ ran through their heads. The idea was completely ridiculous though as Steve walked through instead.
“What the hell?! Did you break into my house?” cried Steve.
“Yep, you should lock your windows more often,” Lucas replied. “Also, we need your car.”
Steve’s eyes fell on Max and they went wide. “Oh no. No, no, and no! You are not driving—”
“Not me you idiot. We need you to drive us,” grumbled Max. “I don’t really have the way memorized anyways.”
“Drive you-hold on. What happened to your face?”
“Nothing.”
“Billy did it.”
“What?!”
“Lucas!”
“He should know. Besides, maybe he can tell us some weird shit that’s been happening since he’s around the guy more.”
“You’ve got a point,” sighed Max.
“Alright first, watch the language. Secondly, what do you mean Billy did that. And thirdly, what weird shit are you talking about?!”
“Language,” Lucas and Max sarcastically mumbled.
“I’m serious. What is going on?!”
“Take us to Eleven and we’ll tell you on the way,” Max replied.
Steve stilled. His hands curled into fists as he carefully swallowed. “Are you sure?”
It was obvious what he meant and Lucas said, “No. I personally think Billy’s just lost it but Max thinks it’s something else.”
“It is something else,” she stressed. “Please Steve. Eleven’s the only one I know who could possibly get us answers.”
“Christ, and it hasn’t even been a year since the last bag of crazy dropped in our laps,” groaned Steve. He covered his face with his hands for a moment longer before letting out a disgruntled sigh and gestured forward. “Come on, we better hurry.”
Max and Lucas followed Steve outside, Lucas going to grab his bike so he could put it in Steve’s trunk before he left.
“So,” sighed Steve as he started the car and pulled out of his driveway. “What does this have to do with your step-brother? I thought he agreed to back off after you drugged him and nearly crushed his balls with my bat.”
“First you,” Max interrupted. “Notice anything weird about him?”
“He’s been getting more riled up lately I think but—”
“What about anything else?” asked Max.
“I don’t know! He’s been missing out on basketball and classes I think but just because we’re both in high school doesn’t mean I see him anymore than you,” Steve replied. “But why do you care? Why’d he punch you?”
“I don’t know,” Max said just as Lucas replied, “He’s psychotic. He beat his dad’s face to a bloody pulp.”
“It looked worse than yours did,” Max admitted.
“Are you serious? Too bad you didn’t have any needles with you.”
Max rolled her eyes at the idea. They would have been helpful but she didn’t really think she could have made it across the room and got to him in time.
“But you think this is something else. Right?” asked Steve.
“We would have just called the chief if it was,” Max said. “Something’s…been wrong for a while but it’s too weird now to have any normal reasons for it.”
“And if anyone can say that for sure, it’s El,” Lucas said. “Personally, I think she’ll look at us like we’re crazy and then we’re going to get Hopper to put the psycho in jail but that’s just my bet.”
Max just shook her head again, not believing that for a second as Steve drove on, eventually getting out to the middle of nothing where the cabin was.
Thankfully Steve had learned the special knock in case of emergencies if Hopper wasn’t there and he did it now. Once the door clicked open, Steve quickly moved in with Lucas and Max right behind.
“El, it’s Steve. We need your help.”
Looking up from the TV program she was watching, a deep frown set into Eleven’s face. “Something is wrong.” She looked back to Lucas and Max. “Something is very wrong.”
“Possibly,” Max said.
“Probably not,” Lucas added. “But on the off chance it is…”
“Listen. We just don’t have any way to contact Dr. Owens and with Hawkins Lab gone, you’re our best bet to find out if anything supernatural is happening here,” Steve quickly said.
Eleven gave them all a questioning look as if to ask what she could do.
“That middle ground place everyone talked about,” Max tried.
“The dark place,” Lucas quickly said. “Maybe you could try and find Billy and feel if he’s…normal or not.”
“Would that work? El’s never met Billy before now,” Steve said.
“I will know,” Eleven replied. “And this is no prank?”
“No El, we’re as serious as can be,” sighed Steve.
“So you’ll do it?” asked Max.
Eleven nodded and walked over to were a bandana was. Max had heard about this, been filled in on a lot of the strange details that revolved around Eleven and the Upside Down and Hawkins Lab. However, like most things in this town, she’d never actually seen it until now.
Max tightened her fists and sat down near to El. There was a weird sense of hoping she was right and Lucas was wrong, and also desperately hoping that her own ideas weren’t true in the slightest.
Eleven opened her eyes to darkness. Months had passed since there’d been any reason to come here and though she’d readily agreed, she certainly hadn’t wanted to. Nevertheless, she’d been able to tell how worried the three of them were. After all, friends didn’t lie and Eleven had no reason to believe that they would.
She knew what Billy looked like for the most part and carefully moved about, searching in the darkness for him.
For a while there was nothing. Even when she’d searched for Will in the Upside Down, it hadn’t taken this long. Was something wrong with her? Or did this have to do with what Max and Lucas and Steve were afraid of?
Eleven moved on. She searched and searched and—
There. She was looking at his backside as he continually walked away from her. It wasn’t hard for Eleven to catch up though. He felt like any person she’d been forced to find and she didn’t understand what had everyone worried. She reached out towards him, expecting something to change, something weird. There was nothing though that seemed to explain why Max and the others had been so worried.
Her hand met with the jacket and Billy should have disappeared just like smoke. That’s what happened every time she came into contact with something in this place.
Her hands pressed into the denim.
Billy whipped around and shoved her back as her eyes went wide. Eleven hit the black water and stared up at the teenager.
“I touched you,” gasped out Eleven.
“Yeah you fucking touched me! Where am I?!”
Eleven just stared, her breath coming in fast and erratic.
“I asked where the fuck am I!” Billy yelled out.
Nothing can hurt you in there.
Papa had told her that the second time she’d gone in. She hadn’t believed it then and after just physically touching someone, she didn’t believe it now.
“Tell me!”
Billy launched himself forward and Eleven jerked back, throwing off the bandana and wiping at her nose.
“El, you alright?” asked Lucas.
She looked around and saw that everyone was eagerly awaiting her response. Eleven slowly put the bandana onto the floor and took several deep breaths. She’d felt him. He’d been right there.
“I felt him.”
Max’s eyes lit up and she leaned in close. “So you found him?”
“And let me guess,” sighed Lucas, “you felt an overwhelming wave of douche-baggery coming from him and nothing else unusual?”
“I touched him,” Eleven muttered.
“Yeah, we get that. You found him,” sighed Lucas. “So anyways, now we can find Hopper and—”
“No Lucas.”
“Uh, sorry?”
“I found him. I touched him,” Eleven repeated with a pointed look.
Max shrugged. “So? I just want to know if he’s normal or not.”
Eleven let out a tired grumble. Max didn’t understand it and Steve seemed to be in the same mindset. She looked to Lucas again and she let out a thankful sigh as she could see he was slowly beginning to understand.
“You couldn’t have touched him though,” Lucas muttered.
“Wait, what do you mean?” asked Steve. “She just said she found him.”
“Yeah but she also said she touched him!” yelled Lucas. “The in between place isn’t like that. It’s…it’s like watching TV. You can see stuff that’s happening in another country but you can’t touch it or do anything about it. Good analogy El?”
“Analogy?”
“Sort of like comparing two similar things. Giving an example. Yeah?”
Eleven nodded. She supposed that for people that never could go to that place, that…analogy made sense.
“What about the other people you’ve found in there? What happens when you go near them?” asked Max.
“They disappear. Smoke,” Eleven said.
“Wait, and you’re saying Billy didn’t?”
“I touched him,” El repeated again with an annoyed sound and a glare.
“I told you something was off,” Max said as she elbowed Lucas in the side.
“Hey! I’m right too! If he’s stuck in the middle then this has nothing to do with the Upside Down,” replied Lucas with a smug look.
Steve let out a groan and rubbed his eyes. “Let’s argue over who’s right at a later date guys. Right now what matters is that if Billy is trapped there, then a) how did he get there, and b) what’s been walking around town looking like him?”
“Right…” sighed Lucas. “Can you find him again? See if you can get any answers?”
“He was mean,” Eleven muttered darkly.
“Leave it to Billy to be a prick even when he’s trapped on another plane of existence,” grumbled Steve and Max nodded in agreement.
“But you can find him again?” asked Lucas.
“Yes but it will take time,” Eleven replied as she wiped away the last bit of blood. It was odd. She’d gotten better at going to the dark place and it usually didn’t take much out of her. Maybe it was because this Billy was physically there. Either way she’d need a few hours before she could try again at the very least.
“We should get Hopper here. Tell him what’s going on,” said Steve.
Eleven gave a quick nod and she turned to look at the radio. She spelled out the letters for ‘code red’ just as Max said, “We’ve got to tell the others.”
“We can’t do that to Will. Especially if he doesn’t have to get involved,” said Lucas.
“Same goes for Joyce and Jonathan,” sighed Steve. “The Byers have been through enough.”
“What about Dustin and Mike?” asked Max, Eleven’s head perking up at Mike’s name.
“We wait until Hopper gets here and then we’ll figure out who needs to be told and who doesn’t,” said Steve. “With any luck, this’ll only take a few days at the most.”
Lucas crossed his arms and rolled his eyes. “When are we ever that lucky?”
“Gotta stay positive kid. Ok? Positive.”
The radio went off again and Eleven turned to look at them. “Hopper will be here soon.”
Almost six normal months and now this. At the very least the Mind Flayer had waited a year after the hell that had come with the Demogorgon. But now this? With the Upside Down closed-and god Jim didn’t know what he would do if it wasn’t-what little knowledge they’d had of the place was now useless. From what he could understand, the place that El could go to was like a void. Nothing should have been there.
But if Billy was stuck there and something else was walking around in his skin, that left two options, neither of which Jim liked. Either the void wasn’t as void as they thought, or there were more dimensions other than the Upside Down.
He’d been terrified upon hearing ‘code red’ come through the radio but it had been difficult coming up with a good excuse to get away. It also didn’t help his temper that the moment he arrived Steve asked, “Where have you been?”
“Doing my job,” growled Jim, his worry only falling slightly upon seeing they were alright; Steve, Lucas, El, and— “You, Max, where the hell is your brother?”
“Step-brother.”
“I really don’t care about the particulars,” growled Jim. “I’ve just come from the hospital where Neil Hargrove’s been beaten completely to shit.”
“Hey, language in front of the—”
“Steve.”
“Right, sorry.”
“Now I’ve got Hargrove telling me his son did that to him. Max, do you have any idea where he is?”
“That’s actually why we called you,” said Lucas.
“You were there-god did he do that? Max are you alright?” asked Jim, his eyes zeroing in on the bruise. He didn’t know what the hell was going on but any irritation over the situation went out the window upon seeing the kid hurt.
“He didn’t. Did. Sort of,” muttered Max, clearly not completely comfortable with the attention Jim was giving her. “It’s kind of complicated.”
“It wasn’t him. Or at least not mostly,” said Lucas. “I wouldn’t be surprised if there was at least a little bit of the douche left in there.”
“He’s trapped in the in between place,” Steve sighed as he skipped straight to the point. “We had El check.”
That was where Jim started coming up with the possibilities of what that could actually mean just as he muttered, “Is that even possible?”
“It happened,” Eleven said.
Jim slowly rubbed his eyes. After the scare a few months ago about some government goons moving into the area, Jim had hoped everything else would be smooth sailing until Eleven could come out into the world. Why couldn’t any of this be easy?
“Alright, just…tell me everything.” Jim waited for their answers, listened to what Max and Lucas had seen, Max’s account of the past weeks, and then El’s explanation of the dark place. And then… “That’s it? Are you…urgh!-kidding me right now?”
“El said she’ll go back in, see if she can find anymore answers,” Lucas added. “We just got to wait.”
“But while we wait, you’re telling me there’s some unknown thing walking around looking like Billy Hargrove?” asked Jim.
“Yes!” cried Steve. “Why do you keep questioning that?”
“Because after getting some of his records that were faxed to me, I can see Billy Hargrove beating the hell out of his dad. What I can’t see is some thing from the void or another place coming to nice and cozy Earth and thinking, “oh, I know the first thing I want to do. Beat the shit out of my host’s dad”,” growled Jim, sarcasm dripping from his lips. “Not kill him, suck his blood, or vaporize him, just beating the shit out of him.”
“Wait, fax you the records? What records?” asked Max.
Steve uneasily gulped. “Oh god. Don’t tell me he’s killed someone or something.”
“What? No! Just a robbery three years ago and a few fights here and there,” sighed Jim.
“Well then what caught your eye?” Max asked. “You just said after reading his records, you could—”
“I know what I said Max and now that I’m thinking about it, I probably shouldn’t have,” sighed Jim.
“I don’t care. Tell me.”
“Max, it’s not my place and I probably shouldn’t have brought it up anyways so just leave it. Now do you have any idea where Billy could be? He left his car this time and just vanished from what I could figure out,” said Jim.
Max crossed her arms, clearly sulking as she stomped over to a chair and fell into it. Jim looked over to Steve as the teen came forward and asked, “Why does it matter if we know of places Billy likes to go? We’ve just established it’s not really him.”
“Yeah but if there is any Billy left in him like Lucas said, then maybe there’s a chance he’ll still feel a reason to go to any of those areas,” said Jim. “It’s the only lead we’ve got so I repeat, where would he likely go if he needed to get away from home.”
“I don’t know,” sighed Max. “Any bars around here with crap IDing? I’m guessing there aren’t any piers.”
Jim snorted. “No, why?”
“Sometimes he’d go walking on the more secluded or empty ones in California,” said Max. “Just to be away from it all.”
“Maybe a hiking trail then? The train tracks? Somewhere in the woods?” questioned Steve.
“It’s a thought,” sighed Jim.
“Are you going to send the police after him?” asked Lucas. “What if he goes berserk?”
“And who else would I send? You lot?” snorted Jim.
Lucas smirked. “Well we did take out some of those demodogs so—”
“Excuse you, I did. And Hopper’s right,” interrupted Steve. “Better to have the cops bring him in and then Hopper can do some cover up about him escaping or whatever so we can get our hands on him.”
“Huh, that’s not a half bad idea,” Lucas said.
“It’s not. Shouldn’t be too hard to do it either,” sighed Jim. “But, until we do find Billy and until El can get more information, I want you three to go back out there and act like everything is fine and dandy, understood? It’s hard enough dealing with one missing kid. I don’t need three others on that plate.”
“And we don’t tell the others?” asked Lucas.
“No, not yet. Don’t tell anyone. Just keep an eye out for Billy and call 911 the moment you see him,” said Jim. “Now come on. It’s late enough and—”
“I don’t want to,” Max stubbornly said. “Mom’s going to be at the hospital and all over Neil. I don’t want to see that.”
“You can’t just stay here,” sighed Jim. “You’re thankfully not considered missing but your mom is worried sick. She’s been putting the word out, hoping you’ll know to come to the hospital instead of home after hanging out with your friends.”
“Please…”
“Max I—”
“Come on chief,” said Lucas. “You can go over and probably convince her mom that she’s fine. Say that she’s staying at a friend’s house or something, and that she’ll be back in the morning. Can’t you do that?”
“Yes, exactly! Please!” Max quickly said.
“Come on Chief. Just let her have a break tonight,” sighed Steve.
“I think it’s fine,” Eleven suddenly said before Jim could argue more. “She can stay.”
“See,” Max smirked. “It’s fine.”
“El, that is not your call to make,” groaned Jim. Nevertheless, he looked at Max and thought about what it must be like having to see her step-brother do that to Neil and then running with Lucas for fear that Billy would go after them. God, these kids were going to get him killed one day. “If you stay, you have to follow the rules just like El. And it’s only for a night,” stressed Jim.
“Deal,” Max replied.
“In that case, Steve I trust you to get Lucas here home. And remember, just because you’re a few years older than these twerps does not mean you can go off and try to find Billy on your own. Leave it to the cops.”
“You got it chief,” Steve nodded. “Come on Lucas. Your mom is probably worried sick.”
“I’ll see you at school tomorrow Max,” Lucas said with a small wave.
She waved back as Steve said the same thing and they both left, leaving Jim to stare pointedly at the two girls. “I’ll try to be back soon. Now stay put and don’t open the door unless you hear me. Got it?”
El nodded as Max rolled her eyes and went, “Fine.”
“And if I’m not back in time, make sure you eat a proper meal before you get out those Eggos.”
“I remember,” El replied, a small smile finally appearing on her lips.
“Good. I’ll see you both later. And be a good guest and make up a bed for Max,” said Jim. He nodded once more, rubbed his eyes and headed on out. He waited just a second, hearing the familiar clicks of the locks before he went over to his truck and got in.
He tried to remind himself that at the very least it didn’t look like the Mind Flayer or the Upside Down was involved. He wasn’t sure that they could survive another encounter with that so soon after the last time. Still, it made him uneasy that something else was out there and he couldn’t help but move his mind back to those rumors about more government goons coming in. He’d checked out all that he could, even asked Dr. Owens about it, but nothing had come up. What if…
No, now he was just being paranoid, making wild connections that weren’t there. But in some ways, that just made this all the more nerve wracking. The thing that had grounded him about the first and second time weird shit went down was that asshole people were involved and he knew how to deal with that. Just an unknown creature that didn’t have any rhyme or reason to be here, at least not any that Jim knew of, that was a lot harder to deal with.
And then the theory Max had of it using up Billy’s anger like a well? Damn, from what he’d heard it couldn’t have picked a better target.
They’d just have to find the kid as quickly as possible and hopefully once he was in custody, they’d be able to figure out what the hell was going on.
Jim drove back to town and went straight to the hospital to reassure Mrs. Hargrove about the whole situation. He went over to the ICU where she was waiting outside Mr. Hargrove’s hospital room.
“Have you found them? Have you—”
“Your daughter is fine.”
“You’ve talked to her?”
“Yes. I…somewhat explained the situation. Don’t worry ma’am I was delicate. But she wanted to spend the night at a friend’s house rather than here. She promised to be back home tomorrow after school and I’ll make sure she is.”
“Oh…oh thank god. And Billy?”
“No word yet but we’ll keep you updated. I promise you that,” said Jim.
“Thank you. I just…I know he had a temper but…but I just never thought…I’m sorry.” Tears welled up in her eyes and Jim wondered who they were for, her husband, daughter, step-son, or herself.
He just sighed in response though and tried to be as calming as possible to help stop the soft weaping. “No, no need for that. We’ll find him and we’ll figure out what happened.”
“I know what happened.”
The voice didn’t come from Jim or Max’s mom. He took a step over and looked into the hospital room. He’d been there at the scene and yet somehow Neil looked worse all bandaged up and in the hospital.
“I believe I had an officer take your statement,” said Jim, “but if you think you left something out on your side I can—”
“I didn’t leave nothing out and don’t talk to me like this is a situation where everyone has a fair view of what happened,” spit out Neil. He took a few wheezing breaths and muttered. “I hope you do find him though. Find him so I can kill that bastard.”
“Hmm.” Jim wasn’t quite sure what to say to that so after an awkward pause, he simply said, “Well, if you need to revise your statement, the office is just a phone call away. Mr. and Mrs. Hargrove.”
Jim turned away before he heard anything else out of Neil. Now that he knew Billy wasn’t Billy, he’d have to figure out a way to protect the kid once they got him back considering the fact that Neil Hargrove was practically aching for blood. He’d heard plenty of bad things about the kid from Max and the others and had even pulled him over for speeding once. However, prick or not Jim wasn’t going to let the kid go through hell again. What he’d seen in that file, no one deserved that and as he drove back to the station to pick up some reports to read over for the night, Jim started to formulate a plan for that.
Of course, all that thinking would only matter if they even managed to get the kid back in the first place.
