Work Text:
The journey to Erebor was a grueling affair, marked by blisters, rain, and the constant threat of being eaten. But for Bilbo Baggins, the greatest challenge wasn't the Orcs, it was the sheer logistical nightmare of being a Hobbit in a company of Dwarves who knew absolutely nothing about Hobbit physiology.
Most folk in Middle-earth knew that Hobbits had large, hairy feet. Some knew they had a penchant for seven meals a day. But very few knew about the ears, and almost no one outside the Shire knew about the tails.
…..
………..
……
…
It began in the Lone-lands. The Company was trudging through a persistent drizzle, and Bilbo was, as usual, miserable. His velvet coat was damp, his handkerchief was a soggy rag, and his boots (which he had been forced to wear for the rocky terrain) were pinching his toes.
"Master Baggins, you look as though you’ve swallowed a lemon," Bofur remarked, walking alongside him.
Bilbo sighed, and as he did, his ears, which were slightly more pointed than a Man's and distinctly plush at the tips, twitch-folded backward against his curls.
Bofur blinked, coming to a dead stop. "Did... did your ears just move, lad?"
Bilbo looked up, startled. His ears instantly snapped upright, the tips quivering. "Move? Well, of course they move. They’re ears, Bofur. They aren't made of stone."
"No, I mean—they folded," Bofur said, leaning in with fascination. "Like a pony’s."
The rest of the Company began to slow down. Even Thorin glanced back, his brow furrowing as he caught sight of the Hobbit’s ears. Currently, they were flared outward, the soft fur on the lobes standing slightly on end.
"It’s a natural reflex," Bilbo huffed, feeling a flush of heat in his cheeks. "They react to... well, to everything. It’s quite common in the Shire."
"Fascinating," Balin mused, stroking his white beard. "I had always assumed they were static, like ours. To have such expressive cartilage... it must be quite a giveaway in a game of riddles."
Bilbo didn't mention that his ears were currently flattened because he was incredibly uncomfortable. He hadn't had a proper bath in a week, and his waistcoat was beginning to chafe. The Dwarves, seeing the flattened, pinned-back ears, simply assumed that was the "neutral" look of a Hobbit. They didn't realize they were looking at a creature in a constant state of sensory annoyance.
….
………….
…………………
……..
..
The ears were one thing, but the tail was an entirely different matter.
Hobbit tails were not fluffy like a squirrel's or short like a rabbit's. They were long, slender, and strong, similar to a lion’s tail but with a finer coating of silken hair and a tuft at the very end. In the Shire, a tail was a point of balance and a secondary indicator of mood. But on the road, Bilbo found it a liability.
He had it tucked firmly down his trousers, wrapped once around his waist to keep it from dragging or, yavanna forbid, being stepped on by a heavy Dwarven boot. It was hot, it was itchy, and it made sitting down on hard rocks a delicate mathematical equation.
"Are you quite alright, Bilbo?" Ori asked one evening by the fire. "You’ve been wiggling in your seat for twenty minutes."
"Just... a pebble," Bilbo lied, his face turning red.
In reality, his tail was cramping. It wanted to lash out in irritation at the smoke from the fire, but it was pinned against his hip by his belt. He adjusted his position, his ears drooping low in a sign of utter exhaustion.
"He’s a twitchy one, isn't he?" Dwalin grunted to Thorin. "Ears always flat, always shifting about. I thought Hobbits were supposed to be merry."
Thorin watched Bilbo. He noticed the way the Hobbit’s ears would occasionally perk up at the sound of a bird, only to collapse back down into that sad, folded position. "Perhaps the Wild is simply too heavy for him," Thorin murmured, though there was a strange, growing softness in his gaze.
..
…..
………
……
..
In the early weeks, the Dwarves had been, to put it mildly, unimpressed by Bilbo’s physical prowess. He had tripped over roots, stumbled on flat plains, and once famously tumbled down a grassy knoll after losing his footing on a perfectly dry patch of moss.
"Careful there, Master Burglar!" Kili had laughed as Bilbo face-planted for the third time in a day. "I thought Hobbits were supposed to be light on their feet. You move more like a newborn calf on a frozen lake."
Thorin had merely grunted, his disappointment written in the sharp line of his mouth. "A liability," he had muttered. "He cannot even walk a straight line without a tumble."
Bilbo had flushed a deep crimson, his ears, which the Dwarves now realized were pinned back in a permanent state of misery, flattened against his skull. He couldn't tell them. He couldn't say, “I’m stumbling because I’ve tied my fifth limb to my thigh and my inner ear is screaming.”
…
……
…………
….
..
The breaking point came in Mirkwood.
The forest was a suffocating blanket of black leaves and hallucinogenic spores. The Company was lost, starving, and huddled together in a tight circle to ward off the oppressive silence. The Dwarves were piled together for warmth, a chaotic heap of furs and braids.
Bilbo was wedged between Bofur and Fili. He was terrified. The giant spiders were somewhere in the canopy, and the lack of sunlight had made his nerves snap.
As he shivered, he forgot himself. The muscles in his lower back ached with the need for release. Without thinking, Bilbo reached into his oversized trousers and unlatched the hidden button he’d sewn into his waistband.
With a soft thwip, his tail sprang free.
It lashed once, twice, hitting Bofur in the arm before Bilbo could catch it.
"Oi!" Bofur yelped, jumping nearly a foot in the air. "Something’s got a whip! There’s a snake in the pile!"
"Snake!" Kili shouted, reaching for his bow.
"It’s not a snake!" Bilbo squeaked, his ears standing perfectly straight and vibrating with terror. "It’s me! It’s just me!"
Thorin kicked a dying ember of the fire to bring a spark of light. The Company stared.
There, held tightly in Bilbo’s trembling hands, was a long, thin tail. It was covered in soft, honey-colored fur, ending in a dark brown tuft. Bilbo was clutching it to his chest like a security blanket, his fingers buried in the tuft.
The silence that followed was absolute.
"You... you have a tail," Fili whispered, his eyes wide with wonder.
"Of course I have a tail!" Bilbo snapped, though his ears immediately folded flat in embarrassment. "Didn't I mention it? Every Hobbit has a tail. It’s for balance! And... and other things."
"You’ve been hiding that this whole time?" Dwalin asked, leaning forward. "Why? It looks sturdy enough."
"I didn't want it stepped on!" Bilbo cried. "Do you have any idea how much it hurts to have a tail crushed by an iron-shod boot? It’s connected to the spine, you know!"
Bofur reached out, his hand hovering hesitantly. "May I?"
Bilbo hesitated, then nodded. Bofur ran a thumb along the silken fur. "It’s warm. And soft as a kitten’s ear."
"It’s lashing," Gloin observed. "Look at the tip. It’s twitching like a cat’s."
"It does that when I'm nervous," Bilbo admitted, his ears twitching in rhythm with the tail.
Thorin stepped closer, his shadow falling over the Hobbit. He looked at Bilbo’s ears, which were currently folded so tightly they almost disappeared into his curls, and then at the tail clutched in Bilbo’s white-knuckled grip.
"You have been uncomfortable," Thorin stated, his voice unusually low. "The way you move, the way your ears fold... it is not your natural state. You have been in pain."
Bilbo looked up at the King, surprised by the insight. "Well... yes. Keeping it tucked away is like wearing a shoe three sizes too small. It’s quite a relief to let it out, even in a place as dreadful as this."
Thorin turned to the Company, his voice a commanding rumble. "From this moment on, Master Baggins will not hide his traits. We shall walk with care. If any man steps on our burglar's tail, he shall answer to me."
…
……..
……………..
……..
.
Now, in the oppressive, pitch-black thicket of Mirkwood, the truth was out. Bilbo sat in the center of the shivering circle of Dwarves, his tail finally free.
It was a magnificent thing, really, long, agile, and currently clutched in Bilbo’s hands. He was running the tufted end over his cheek, a soothing motion that finally allowed his ears to perk up, even in the dark.
Dwalin leaned forward, his heavy brow furrowed as he watched the Hobbit. "Baggins," he started, his voice a low rumble. "That tail of yours. You say it’s for balance?"
"Well, yes," Bilbo said, his voice sounding more confident than it had in weeks. "It’s vital. We use it to navigate the high branches of the party trees and to walk the narrow fences of the Shire. It acts as a counter-balance."
Balin’s eyes widened behind his spectacles. He looked at Bilbo’s feet, then at the length of the tail, then back to the memory of the Hobbit’s many falls.
"Great Durin’s beard," Balin whispered. "The stumbling. The tripping. Bilbo... you’ve been walking the entire journey with your rudder tied down!"
The rest of the Company went still. Fili and Kili exchanged a look of sudden, horrific guilt.
"You mean to say," Fili began, his voice dropping, "that you weren't actually clumsy? You were just... out of alignment?"
"Think about it, Fili!" Kili cried, hitting his forehead with his palm. "Imagine trying to fight with one arm tied behind your back, or trying to climb with your knees bound. He hasn't been clumsy; he’s been performing a feat of endurance!"
Thorin moved closer, his gaze fixed on the tail. He remembered every time he had criticized the Hobbit’s speed. He remembered the sharp words he’d thrown at Bilbo for 'shuffling' when the Hobbit was actually just trying to find his center of gravity without his tail to guide him.
"You hid it to protect it from us," Thorin said, his voice thick with a strange mixture of regret and realization. "And in doing so, you suffered in silence while we mocked your lack of grace."
Bilbo looked down at his feet. "I didn't want to be a bother. And I truly didn't want anyone to step on it. You lot have very large, very heavy boots, and I’m rather fond of my tail."
The next morning, the change was spectacular.
Bilbo didn't tuck his tail away. He let it swing freely behind him, using it to navigate the treacherous, slippery roots of the forest floor. As they moved through a particularly steep ravine, the Dwarves watched in stunned silence.
Bilbo didn't stumble once.
He skipped across a moss-covered log that had Gloin slipping and sliding. His tail lashed out to the side, perfectly compensating for the shift in his weight, and he landed on the other side with the silent poise of a mountain cat.
"Look at him go!" Bofur cheered as Bilbo navigated a narrow stone ledge. Bilbo’s ears were forward, twitching with interest, and his tail was arched in a graceful curve behind him.
"He’s faster than the scouts," Dwalin admitted, his respect for the Hobbit reaching new heights.
Thorin watched Bilbo from the rear of the line. He noticed how the Hobbit’s ears would flick toward a sound before his head even turned, and how the tail would give a sharp, warning twitch whenever the terrain became unstable.
At one point, the path narrowed significantly over a drop. Bilbo stopped, his tail stiffening and pointing straight back to help him steady himself as he peered over the edge.
Thorin stepped up beside him. "Master Baggins."
Bilbo’s ears did a joyful little wiggle at the sound of Thorin’s voice. "Yes, Thorin?"
"I owe you an apology," the King said, his voice barely audible over the rustle of the leaves. "I called you a burden. I saw your struggles and assumed they were a lack of character, rather than a sacrifice you were making for your own safety."
Bilbo’s tail gave a shy, rhythmic thump against Thorin’s leg. It was soft, the tufted end brushing against the King’s heavy boot.
"It’s alright, Thorin," Bilbo said, his ears fanning out in a sign of genuine pleasure. "It’s a bit of a shock, I know. Not many people expect the Burglar to come with an extra limb."
"It is not a shock," Thorin replied, his hand briefly resting near the base of Bilbo’s ears, causing them to vibrate with a happy trill. "It is a marvel. You are a creature of immense balance, Bilbo Baggins. In more ways than one."
….
………..
……………….
…..
.
Once the tail was out, the Dwarves became obsessed with "The Hobbit Language."
They realized that Bilbo’s ears were a constant barometer of his mood. When he was curious, they pointed forward. When he was pleased (usually after finding an edible mushroom), they fanned out and did a little wiggle. But most importantly, they realized that the "flat" look they had seen for weeks was actually a sign of deep distress.
"Look," Kili whispered to Fili as they trekked toward the mountain. "His ears are doing the happy-wiggle. Gandalf must have told him a good story."
Indeed, Bilbo’s ears were fluttering like butterfly wings. His tail was swinging lazily behind him, the tuft occasionally brushing against the grass.
"It’s like having a fifth limb," Bofur laughed. "He uses it to pick up his fallen handkerchief! Did you see that? He didn't even bend over!"
As they grew closer to the Lonely Mountain, the fascination turned into protectiveness. Whenever the path grew narrow, Dwalin would walk behind Bilbo, his large boots carefully placed to ensure the swaying tail was never in danger.
In the evenings, when the wind was cold, the Dwarves would encourage Bilbo to sit in the center of the pile. He no longer had to wiggle or shift. He would sit, his tail curled contentedly around his own ankles, his ears upright and relaxed.
"Thorin," Bilbo said one night, noticing the King staring at him. "Is something wrong?"
Thorin reached out, his fingers grazing the tip of Bilbo’s ear. The Hobbit let out a soft, involuntary trill, and his ears did a sharp, joyful flick.
"I am merely glad," Thorin said, a rare smile touching his lips, "that you are finally comfortable. A King should know the true face, and ears, of his friends."
Bilbo, for his part, had never been happier. The physical strain of the concealment was gone, replaced by a sense of belonging he hadn't expected. He realized that the Dwarves didn't see his tail or his pointy ears as "weird", they saw them as part of the Burglar who was quickly becoming the heart of their Company.
….
………
…………..
…..
..
Being locked in the Elven-king’s dungeons was a test of patience for the Dwarves, but for an invisible Bilbo, it was a test of sheer physical endurance. Thranduil’s cells were cold, and Bilbo’s tail, now free and sensitive, hated the damp stone.
Because he was wearing the Ring, the Dwarves couldn't see him, but they certainly felt him. Cause he couldn't risk being clumsy here
"Ouch! What was that?" Bofur hissed, rubbing his cheek as he sat against the bars of his cell.
"Quiet, you fool," Thorin whispered from the neighboring cage.
"Something soft and fuzzy just whipped across my nose," Bofur whispered back. "It felt like... a silken rope with a tuft on the end."
In the empty air of the hallway, a faint, frustrated huff sounded. Bilbo was trying to navigate the narrow guard-walk, but his tail, acting on its own instinct for balance, kept lashing out to steady him on the slick masonry.
"It’s the Burglar," Dwalin grunted, leaning his head against the bars. "Baggins? Is that you?"
A small, warm pressure rested against Dwalin’s hand, the invisible tip of a tail, twitching in a rhythmic, nervous pattern.
"He's here," Dwalin announced to the others, his voice thick with relief. "I can feel the tail-tuft. He's vibrating like a harp string."
"Master Baggins," Thorin called out softly into the darkness. "Be careful. The Elven guards have keen ears. Do not let your... appendages give you away."
The Dwarves sat in their cells, listening to the soft thwip-thwip of a tail hitting the stone as Bilbo hurried back and forth with keys and information. Every time a Dwarf felt that familiar, furry brush against their arm through the bars, it was a reminder that they weren't alone. It was a signal of hope.
…….
……………..
…………………….
……….
..
When the Company finally emerged from the barrels in Lake-town, Bilbo was too exhausted to hide anything. His ears were drooping so low, and his tail was dragging in the slush of the docks, looking like a drowned rat.
The Men of Lake-town gathered around, whispering and pointing. They had seen Dwarves before, but they had never seen a Hobbit, especially not one with pointed, plush ears that twitched at every sound and a tail that lashed irritably at the cold water.
Later that evening, while the Dwarves were recovering in the Town Master’s hall, Thorin and Dwalin overheard the Master speaking with his counselor in the adjacent room.
"Think of the gold, Alfrid!" the Master’s oily voice drifted through the curtain. "A creature like that, ears that move like a deer's and a tail like a lion's? We could sell viewings to the merchants from the South. Or better yet, I hear the mages in the East pay handsomely for 'exotic' specimens. We could make more from the Hobbit than we will from the Dwarves' promises!"
Inside the hall, the atmosphere turned murderous.
Thorin stood up, his hand white-knuckled on the arm of his chair. Dwalin reached for a heavy poker by the fire.
"They want to sell him," Dwalin rumbled, his voice a tectonic plate shifting.
Before the Master could return, Thorin stepped into the doorway, his regal bearing cutting through the room like a blade. Behind him, the other twelve Dwarves formed a wall of iron and bristling beards.
Bilbo sat in the middle, looking confused, his ears swiveling toward Thorin.
"Master of Lake-town," Thorin said, his voice dropping to a terrifying, kingly register. "Know this. Master Baggins is under the protection of the House of Durin. He is not a 'specimen.' He is a member of this Company. If any man looks upon him with greed, or speaks of 'selling' his features, they shall find that Dwarven axes are very sharp and Dwarven tempers are very short."
The Master paled, stuttering apologies. For the rest of their stay, the Dwarves never let Bilbo out of their sight. Whenever they walked through the streets, Dwalin and Gloin walked on either side of him, and Fili and Kili walked behind, their eyes darting to any person who stared too long at the Hobbit’s tail.
.
….
……….
……
.
When Bilbo stood before Thorin on the ramparts of Erebor, admitting that he was the one who had taken the Arkenstone to Bard and Thranduil, the air in the mountain turned frigid. Thorin’s eyes were no longer the warm blue of the sky; they were the cold, glittering grey of winter ice.
"You..." Thorin hissed, his voice a low, dangerous rattle. "You miserable, tiny... thing."
Bilbo’s ears, which had spent the last year fanning out in joy or twitching with curiosity, now flattened so tightly against his skull they looked painful. His tail, once a proud rudder of grace, was tucked between his legs, trembling with a terror that radiated through his entire frame.
"I did it for you, Thorin," Bilbo whispered, his voice cracking. "To save you from yourself."
With a roar of pure, golden-madness, Thorin lunged. He didn't reach for Bilbo’s throat; in his twisted mind, he wanted to humiliate the creature that had betrayed him. He reached out and snagged Bilbo’s tail, jerking the Hobbit forward with a brutal, sickening yank.
Bilbo let out a sharp, high-pitched cry of agony. Because the tail was an extension of his spine, the sudden, violent pull sent a jolt of white-hot pain through his entire nervous system. He collapsed to his knees, his balance utterly shattered.
"This is what you are!" Thorin screamed, his hand tightening around the silken fur of the tail, dragging Bilbo toward the edge of the rampart. "An animal! A freak of the wild that I allowed into my halls!"
The Company watched in horror. Dwalin took a step forward, his face pale. "Thorin, stop! You’ll break his back!"
Thorin didn't listen. He lifted Bilbo by the tail, forcing the Hobbit to dangle precariously over the drop. Bilbo’s ears were vibrating with a frantic, silent distress, his eyes wide and glazed with shock. The physical violation of being handled by his most sensitive feature broke something in Bilbo’s spirit that the dragon never could.
When Gandalf’s voice finally boomed across the valley, Thorin dropped him like a piece of refuse. Bilbo curled into a ball on the cold stone, clutching his tail to his chest, his ears drooping so low they touched the floor. He didn't look back as he left the mountain.
…..
………….
………………..
……..
..
The Battle of the Five Armies was won, but the cost was written in blood and stone. Thorin lay in the recovery tent, the gold-sickness burned away by the reality of death. His wounds were deep, but the heaviest ache was in his chest.
He had sent for Bilbo three times. On the fourth, the Hobbit finally entered.
Bilbo walked with a noticeable limp. His tail, which used to sway with every step, was held stiffly against his leg, the fur matted and the tuft at the end ragged. But most telling were his ears. They didn't perk up when he saw Thorin. They stayed low, cautious and guarded.
"Bilbo," Thorin rasped, his voice breaking.
Bilbo stayed by the door. "You sent for me, Thorin?"
"Come closer. Please."
Bilbo hesitated, then stepped toward the bed. Thorin’s eyes immediately fell to the Hobbit’s tail. He remembered the feeling of the fur in his hand, the way he had used Bilbo’s own anatomy to hurt him. The memory made Thorin want to weep.
"I am... I am a monster," Thorin whispered.
"The gold was the monster, Thorin," Bilbo said softly, though his ears gave a sharp, involuntary twitch of anxiety.
"No. I laid hands on you. I took the very thing that gives you balance, the thing I promised to protect and I used it to break you." Thorin reached out a trembling hand, but he didn't touch Bilbo. He didn't think he had the right. "Is it... is it permanent? The damage?"
Bilbo looked down at his tail. "Oin says it will heal. It’s a bit stiff, and I get dizzy if I move too fast, but... it will be alright."
Thorin closed his eyes, a tear escaping. "I would give every coin in that mountain to take back that moment. To see your ears wiggle with joy again. To see your tail wag as it did in the forest."
Bilbo watched the King for a long time. Slowly, tentatively, he stepped to the side of the bed. He took Thorin’s hand and, with a deep breath, he guided it toward the base of his ears.
As Thorin’s fingers brushed the soft, pointed tips, Bilbo’s ears did a tiny, hesitant flick. It wasn't the grand wiggle of old, but it was a start.
"I forgive you, Thorin," Bilbo whispered. "But you’re going to have to be very careful with the 'Tail Guard' duties from now on. Dwalin says he’s going to make you wear bells on your boots so I can hear you coming."
Thorin let out a wet, choked laugh. "I shall wear them gladly. I shall be the most ridiculous King in history if it means you feel safe in my presence again."
…..
………….
………………
…….
.
A year after the Battle of the Five Armies, the Great Gates of Erebor were finally thrown open to the caravans of families arriving from the Blue Mountains.
Dís, sister of Thorin, led the procession. She had heard the stories of the "Burglar," but she expected a small, clever Man or perhaps a very thin Dwarf.
As she entered the throne room, she saw her brother sitting on the throne of his ancestors. But he wasn't alone. Standing beside him was a small creature dressed in fine green velvet.
The creature’s ears suddenly perked up, fanning out in a sign of curiosity. Then, from behind the creature’s back, a long, elegant tail swept forward, the tufted end curling contentedly around Thorin’s wrist.
The arriving Dwarves went silent.
"Thorin?" Dís asked, staring at the swaying tail. "Is this... the Burglar?"
"This," Thorin said, reaching out to gently scuff the base of Bilbo’s pointed ears, causing the Hobbit to let out a soft, vibratory trill, "is Bilbo Baggins. And I suggest you do not step on his tail. He’s quite attached to it."
Bilbo smiled, his ears doing a happy little wiggle. "Welcome to Erebor. I’ve made tea and honey-cakes for everyone.”
The newcomers watched in awe as the Hobbit turned, his tail flicking with perfect grace as he led the way to the kitchens.
