Chapter Text
Thorin had never once doubted that Erebor was the greatest kingdom the world had ever known. That the world seemed generally short on other great kingdoms was either incidental or proof of just that, he could never decide which. Yet his mother had always been full of tales of other worlds, and it made his world seem so large, because clearly there was more out there than anyone could ever see. Age made him realize that his mother had just been spinning tales, and suddenly the world shrunk into tight, well-defined borders. So of course Erebor was the greatest kingdom in the world. The world was small, and there was no competition. The other kingdoms were crumbling ruins, held together by increasingly bitter dwarves.
Then the air had grown cold, and suddenly a group of dwarves making routine journeys to the other dwarf kingdoms had not returned. This had never happened before. The roads were safe, guarded from brigands and wild animals. Accusations had been bandied about, and for a time it looked like war was imminent. Obviously one of the other kingdoms was picking them off, it had been said. No one doubted it. What else could be going on? Jealous of the wealth and strength of Erebor, they took petty, impotent revenge, and the line of Durin would teach them what real revenge looked like.
Except a survivor appeared, cutting through the growing tension like a knife. Their story made little sense, claiming that their party was surrounded by shadows that their weapons couldn’t hurt, and that the shadows stole the life of the others. He claimed that his weapon was steel, while the others carried iron, and that for some reason, his steel had stopped the shadows where the iron did not, but few believed him. It was a ridiculous story, like something out of one of his mother’s tales. It was enough to dispel the threat of war, anyway. Most likely a drunken brawl on the road, gone too far. That was what his grandfather said publicly, but Thorin saw the doubt in his eyes. Something was happening. Something no one could explain.
Another band of travelers disappeared without a trace, and people began to whisper. No survivors appeared this time, filling the hearts of the dwarves with cold dread. Another group, this time with children, vanished on the safest possible road, and whispers turned to shouts. What was going on? Why were the roads not guarded? They were guarded of course, but the guard was doubled and tripled. More people vanished, the guards having little effect, but one good thing came of it. Multiple guards saw the shadows draining the life out of travelers, and suddenly it could not be dismissed as the words of disoriented drunks. These people had been attacked by something otherworldly.
They began to call the shadows “wraiths,” and the watchful nights began. They were not nearly watchful enough.
King Thror was quite old, but he insisted on getting some air one day. It was not a usual request for him, but his guards humored him. Thror’s mind had been going for some time, and no one really liked arguing with him when he got in one of his moods. When Thorin learned of it, dread coiled in his belly, and he had run out of the mountain in search of his grandfather. He had found Thror on the ground, his guards run off or killed, a wraith taking what was left of his lifeforce. That was how Thorin learned that steel did indeed ward them off: he drew his blade and slashed at the wraith, and rather than just going through it, it felt as though he struck something, and he heard an unearthly cry. The creature had fled, but it was too late for Thror.
Years would pass, the walls coming up, and the dwarves hiding from their wraiths in their mountains, but it would be too late for Thrain and Frerin not long after. Thorin, king suddenly of a kingdom surrounded by strange beings that they could not kill, did the last thing anyone wanted: he left on a journey. It didn’t matter how many people shouted “You’re needed here!” There wasn’t anything he could do in Erebor, so he set out to find the source of the wraiths. Maybe their steel could not kill them, but if they could destroy wherever the wraiths were coming from, the problem would be nominally solved.
Thorin didn’t really believe that, of course, but he was a king now, and he was utterly out of options. He had to stop the wraiths somehow, and he could not do that locked inside Erebor. When Gandalf appeared, claiming swords forged in Gondolin were the key to their salvation, he was past the point of questioning anything Gandalf said. If Gandalf said there were other worlds, and he needed to find them, he would do it. He could accept the existence of other worlds, because it was necessary to protect his people. Nothing else mattered.
Including what they would do after finding Gondolin, because Gandalf hadn't mentioned that detail.
As he related the entire tale to Bilbo, Gandalf’s apparent world-connection finder, he began to have doubts. Not about Bilbo necessarily, though the strange creature with his bare, hairy feet did seem rather helpless. He wasn’t even armed! But the idea that the Elves of Gondolin had forged more powerful blades did not sit right with him. His mother had always told him that dwarves were the best forgers of iron and steel in all the worlds, and he now had proof that she had not lied about there being other worlds. Why would she lie about this? Oddly, it was Bilbo who first voiced the question.
“Why do you need swords from Gondolin? Even in the Shire, our tales say that the Dwarves made the best weapons, though I do not know how we could have known,” he added bashfully. Thorin felt himself warming to the Hobbit, and realized that Mingalaz was seated at Bilbo’s feet. That was probably why. Proximity to his dæmon. That was it.
“It is true, the steel of the Dwarves is unmatched,” Gandalf agreed. “The Elves of Gondolin learned their craft from the Dwarves, and while they were never able to perfect it, they added something of their own: the magic of the high Elves. The steel may be a little poorer quality, but the magic more than makes up for it, creating a weapon that can kill wraiths.”
This explanation was more than satisfactory on one point, though it raised more questions on another. How had his people taught the inhabitants of another world how to forge steel? Until a few days ago, he had not even known for certain that other worlds existed, how could regular contact between two worlds have been possible? And furthermore, had there been wraiths in that time, or had the effect been unintentional? Gandalf was clearly not telling them everything. Not even close.
But Bilbo was speaking again, and Thorin had to put his questions to the side. “That’s all well and good, but what does all this have to do with me?”
Thorin bit down on his irritation, though Mingalaz was less willing to do so. She stretched, watching Gandalf’s moth dæmon with a predatory gaze. She would undoubtedly be pleased to swat the creature out of the air for the insult of bringing them an unwilling helper. Thorin nudged her with his foot, and she settled down a little, giving him a wounded look. Of course the hobbit would not be immediately willing to help them. His world was still untouched.
“Thorin and his company must find the Lost Kingdom of Gondolin, and for that, they need someone who can see the connections between worlds,” Gandalf said matter-of-factly, though Bilbo still looked mystified.
“Gandalf told me that he would find such a person, and he brings me you,” Thorin observed, bitterness creeping into his tone. “Apparently that was a mistake.”
“Apparently!” Bilbo agreed, his voice a little shrill. “I know nothing about the connections between worlds. Until this morning, I did not even know there were other worlds!”
The other dwarves and their dæmons groaned, and it was hard not to join in. “Confounded wizards,” Mingalaz murmured, and Thorin distinctly shared the sentiment.
“Now wait just a moment,” Gandalf insisted. “If I say Bilbo Baggins can find the connections between worlds, then he can. I have not sent him here on a whim. This world is no place for a Hobbit, or for any living creature, so long as the wraiths hold sway. When Bilbo agreed to come, I gave him a test. There is a river in his world that contains a passageway to this world, but it is easy to avoid, and because it is underwater, it cannot be seen. Myrtle swam right to it, and Bilbo followed.”
Thorin relaxed fractionally. “That portal was already open,” he argued, though his heart was less in it than before. “You said we needed someone who could find the portals that are not yet open.” Though Gandalf hadn’t mentioned how they were supposed to open those portals in the first place.
“And I believe, based on my test, that Myrtle can sniff them out,” Gandalf continued, undeterred. “You must trust me on this.”
Mingalaz hissed, but Thorin nodded.
“Just give me a bit to think,” Bilbo said faintly. Thorin turned away to do just that, letting Bilbo get swarmed by his companions.
“What do you think?” he asked Mingalaz as she followed him to the other side of the room, seating herself gracefully beside him.
“He is no warrior,” Mingalaz observed, licking one of her paws in apparent disinterest. “He won’t be much use.”
“Fighting is not the only skill worth having,” Thorin replied, but the words sounded hollow in his own ears. Like he was trying to convince himself. He supposed, technically, he was.
“He doesn’t know a portal from a hole in the ground,” his dæmon replied contemptuously.
“Neither do we,” Thorin reminded her. “That is why we need him.”
Mingalaz halted mid-lick, and looked up at him, her feline eyes glittering with amusement. “You like him.”
“I don’t know him,” Thorin replied irritably. He realized as he said it that it wasn’t exactly a denial.
“Oh that is certainly true,” she agreed easily. “But your heart leapt when he came to the defense of the skill of the dwarves. ‘He has never even seen a dwarf before, and he is defending our honor,’” she said mockingly, pitching her voice lower. “Just admit it.”
“I will admit to nothing,” Thorin said stubbornly.
“Oh come now, there’s no shame in liking your prey soft,” she said with a feline laugh, baring her teeth. “You could certainly use the occasional ‘hunt’ now and again…”
Thorin buried his face in his hands, relieved that his company was making too much noise to notice the state he was in, or hear what his dæmon was saying. “We are not having this conversation.”
“Self-denial is so boring,” Mingalaz whined, examining a claw. “You’re a king, on a quest to save your world. Live a little.”
“When I asked what you thought, this is not what I meant,” Thorin scolded. “This is the exact opposite of helpful.”
“What I think,” Mingalaz began calmly, “is that you like him, and whether he ends up being useful or not, you want him around. It’s a miracle I ever settled on a form, as clueless and indecisive as you are about these things.”
“It’s a miracle I made it this far without throttling you, killing myself in the process,” Thorin muttered sourly. Mingalaz simply chortled, but it really didn’t feel like he had the last word. It never did.
He wondered what it said, that his dæmon reminded him of his sister.
Rather than think, Bilbo suddenly found the himself being introduced to the other dwarves. They had been quiet and distant for the most part while he hashed things out with Thorin and Gandalf, the lone exception being Dwalin, whose comment about Minty had earned him the earlier introduction, but now they were all clamoring for his attention. The most eager, he soon learned, were Fíli and Kíli, the princes and Thorin’s nephews, and the first thing he noticed was that both of their dæmons were some kind of wild dog. They were different species by the look of it, but that was all he could tell. He would have expected them to match their uncle more, but as they barely matched each other, the one with fair coloring and the other dark, they couldn’t be expected to match Thorin.
Then there was Balin, Dwalin’s more sedate older brother, with his raven dæmon perched on his arm. It watched Myrtle with a beady eye, but made no reply to her polite greeting. Like all the dæmons that followed, Balin’s raven did not introduce herself, even after Myrtle had given her name. Bilbo supposed they would have to get used to that. At least Balin seemed nice enough.
Then there were Óin and Glóin, both a little on the loud side. It made sense though: Óin was rather advanced in years, and his dæmon was a barn owl (which evidently did not much care for speaking, but rather enjoyed shrieking), so he was quite deaf. Glóin, with his very large and fluffy ram dæmon, probably always had to shout if he wanted to be heard and understood.
Next he met Dori, Nori and Ori, a family of three very different brothers. Dori fussed about him almost immediately, and his dæmon, a huge, very fluffy cat, started grooming Myrtle without an invitation. In Nori’s case, Bilbo was glad he had been tossed into the river without any valuables, because he got the impression that the dwarf and his raccoon dæmon were sizing him up to see if he had anything good. As for Ori, Bilbo thought the lad might have fit in in the Shire, between his tiny owl dæmon sleeping in his knitted scarf, and his shy demeanor. Myrtle could have swatted the poor dear out of the sky and had her for dinner.
Last of their party were Bifur, Bofur and Bombur, and a more eclectic family could not be found if he was looking, Bilbo suspected. Bifur had an axe embedded in his forehead, which as his cousins explained, was why he could only speak the language of the Dwarves, and his boar dæmon could not speak at all. Bofur, friendly and at ease, explained how his canary dæmon was useful as a miner, thoroughly unsettling Bilbo’s stomach. He was entirely too cheerful about the matter, considering that it was the death of a canary that told miners not to dig any deeper. Lastly, Bombur’s dæmon was easy to miss, the little bat hanging off the bottom of his circular beard. It didn’t seem to match the cheery, rotund dwarf, but Bilbo left it alone.
Dwarves were strange folk, judging by the veritable menagerie of their dæmons. He had never seen such variety before. Myrtle seemed rather dull by comparison, though at least she wasn’t a rabbit, but the dwarves actually seemed to like Bilbo better because of his dæmon. Badgers were adept tunnelers, and they had evidently decided that Myrtle was made to tunnel between worlds. Myrtle endured their scrutiny patiently enough, but when one cheeky raccoon got too close and the claws came out, Bilbo decided that was enough of that.
If he went with the dwarves, he could see if his mother’s stories had been true. He could see worlds that he had long since assumed were just fairy tales. And since they would be leaving this world behind, it would probably be safe. Gandalf hadn’t mentioned the wraiths being in other worlds, after all. There was nothing wrong with a relatively safe adventure.
Probably.
“Gandalf,” Bilbo said, pulling away from the cluster of excited dwarves. “Are you sure I can do this?”
“I would not ask it of you if I wasn’t,” Gandalf replied seriously. “Your mother’s dæmon was adept at finding portals, and clearly Myrtle is the same. I have every confidence in you.”
The comment about his mother’s dæmon meant more to Bilbo than anything else he could have said. His mother had been able to find portals! He took after his mother! He had always known that in some ways, but here was a useful way. Here was a way that he could actually make a difference, instead of moping around the Shire for the rest of his life. His heart hammering in his chest, Bilbo knew his decision was made. Gandalf had found his weakness. But there was one more thing he needed to know.
“Why me, Gandalf?” he asked. “Is it just because I can find portals?” Not that that was a bad reason, but surely there were others who could do the same. More adventurous folk.
Gandalf considered him thoughtfully for a moment. “No,” he finally said. “There is a saying about dæmons in another world. ‘Your dæmon will show you the way home.’ Have you ever really felt at home in the Shire?” Bilbo shook his head. “I made your mother a promise, to do what I could for you once she was gone, and I believe this is that. I believe you and Myrtle will find your real home, if you go on this quest.”
There was nothing for it then, but to tell Thorin, and sign the contract. The dwarves cheered a little, though Thorin and his inscrutable dæmon just watched him silently. Their portal-finder found, there were new questions to be raised.
“How are we to find Gondolin?” Balin asked, stroking his beard thoughtfully. “If, as you say, there are an untold number of worlds out there, how are we to know which is the right one? It is called “the Lost Kingdom” for a reason, no doubt. Myrtle won’t simply be able to sniff out the right portal, and it’s possible that our world isn’t even directly connected to that one.”
Gandalf pulled something from and inner pocket, and handed it to Thorin. It was cylindrical, and looked like it was made of gold. Bilbo leaned close as Thorin popped open the lid, revealing a dial with strange pictures around the edge, three hands that could be moved with little wheels on the back, and a long needle that moved when Thorin adjusted the hands . He could tell by the looks on the faces of the dwarves that like him, they had never seen anything like it before.
“What is it?” Thorin asked, gingerly showing the object to Minty, who sniffed it curiously. He tried to hand it back to Gandalf, but the wizard raised his hands, suggesting that Thorin should keep it. “This was not made by dwarven hands.”
“Call it a compass of sorts,” Gandalf said good-humoredly. “You ask it questions, and it answers. It will take some time to learn to read it, if you have the knack for it, but by then Bilbo and Myrtle will have found a few portals, and you will have seen a few worlds, and be more prepared for what you must do. Once you have learned to read it, you can ask it for directions, to give Myrtle some guidance.”
If that thoroughly cryptic remark bothered any of the dwarves, they didn’t show it. He also totally ignored Thorin’s comment about who made it.
“What have we gotten ourselves into?” Bilbo whispered.
“Trouble,” Myrtle answered decisively.
