Chapter Text
The Elves were impressive drinkers. On that point, Thorin had to concede defeat.
It had been a long time since he faked his way through a drinking contest, but waking up without a headache, with all the elves still snoring, made him feel that as cowardly as it was, it had been the right choice. His fellow dwarves were also stirring, and a quick glance at their portal-finder revealed that he was already awake. Bilbo, as far as he was aware, had not faked his way through the drinking contests. That merited just a little bit of grudging respect.
“Which way?” Thorin hissed, and Bilbo pointed. The dwarves trooped out of the room as quietly as they could. The evening before, when the party had not yet been in full swing, Bilbo had mentioned quietly that Myrtle smelled another portal, somewhere within the Palace. Kíli had taken that moment to ask Captain Tauriel if there was any way they could get a tour, but she refused. Moreover, Thorin had mentioned some of Thranduil’s strangeness during the audience, though he had not mentioned “the sundering,” deciding to wait until Gandalf rejoined them to open that can of worms. So they had taken it upon themselves to “help” the Elves get to sleep, while they explored.
Myrtle led, waddling doggedly forward, no doubt or hesitation in her gait. They had not gone far before it was very clear that without Myrtle, they would have gotten hopelessly lost down here. Something was addling his stone sense, and Mingalaz looked a little unsteady on her feet. He glanced back at the company. All of the flying dæmons were being carried, and none of them looked particularly well.
“The sooner we get out of this place, the better,” Mingalaz muttered, and Thorin scratched behind her ears.
“Something is definitely not right in this world,” he agreed quietly. “As friendly as our hosts were.”
“Was it the spiders or the fact that all of our dæmons were terrified from the moment we entered?” Glóin grumbled, and they all fell silent again.
The descended deep underground, stopping finally in a wine cellar. There was no sign of a portal, Thorin observed ruefully. Maybe Myrtle had been thrown off as well. But the badger sniffed and scratched along the wooden floor, stopping finally on a trapdoor, her snout pointed straight down.
“It’s right underneath this,” Myrtle declared confidently.
“Can you tell how far?” Bilbo asked nervously.
The badger scratched her chin with her claws in an oddly human gesture. “It’s a bit of a fall,” she admitted finally, waddling off the trapdoor as she noticed Bofur moving to the release lever. Bofur tugged it, and the floor tilted down, revealing a fast flowing river beneath. The morning light was decent, but there was no sign of a portal.
“It’s underwater again,” Bilbo muttered, rubbing his temples. “Because hobbits are known for being strong swimmers.”
“We’re not much better,” Bofur pointed out, entirely too cheerful.
“Uncle, why don’t you ask that compass again?” Fíli suggested. “Where the portal is exactly, or if it’s safe to jump down…” His dæmon was scurrying around the room excitedly, sniffing everything she came across and occasionally just jumping in place.
“No sense of danger, that one,” Mingalaz muttered, but Thorin took out the compass anyway. Ori was instantly at his side, quill at the ready, but Thorin struggled to think of a question. He might not be able to understand any of the answer if he asked the wrong question, and then what would the point have been?
Thorin shook his head. He could ask as many questions as it took. “Where is the nearest portal?” he asked, frowning when the needle only moved once, onto a symbol that looked like waves. Underwater then. Unambiguous enough. “Should we enter that portal?” The needle moved much more this time, and even with the symbols assembled in front of him thanks to Ori, he had no frame of reference.
Bilbo was peering around him to look at the book, and he stepped aside to give the Hobbit room. Bilbo’s brow was furrowed in deep concentration, and it was almost cute- Thorin banished the thought. He remembered the way Bilbo had hidden himself under tree roots instead.
“Maybe the arrow here means continue?” Bilbo suggested suddenly, breaking Thorin’s train of thought. He was tapping the line of symbols thoughtfully. “Maybe it’s saying, if you don’t want the elves to catch you, or, if you want to continue. Those both sounds like yesses.”
“If your interpretation is correct,” Thorin observed. “It could mean that if we drop down there, we will be shot full of arrows.”
Bilbo’s face fell. “Oh, I guess you’re right,” he admitted.
“I think we’ve found the solution to that!” Kíli announced. It was with dread that Thorin looked over at his nephews, finding them standing in front of empty wine barrels.
“With these, we can control our descent some, and if they start shooting, the wood feels sturdy enough to repel an arrow or two,” his dæmon explained, bouncing around excitedly.
Thorin gritted his teeth. It wasn’t a bad idea, not by Kíli’s usual standards, but his nephew was too casual. His dæmon addressing the company when there was an outsider among them was not the least bit proper. Myrtle could speak freely because clearly hobbits did things differently and saw no harm in the physical manifestation of their souls speaking to strangers, but Kurdaz needed to keep his tongue reined in. They would need to have a word or two about it, but later.
For now, he simply said, “Move the barrels into position,” raising his voice as the company protested. “Any who wish to simply jump down there are welcome to.”
It was a tight fit in the barrels for some of them, their dæmons large enough to merit a barrel of their own, but the risk of being separated and dying from the bond snapping was too great. Thorin was snug with Mingalaz, but at least she didn’t have horns. Glóin was less fortunate, but his dæmons’ large horns did solve the problem of how to pull the switch to open the trapdoor: by putting them in the last barrel, his dæmon could simply turn her head and hook the handle with her horns.
Then they were plunging down, into frigid depths. There was no rain of arrows, so grudgingly, Thorin privately admitted that maybe Bilbo had been right: when they surfaced, they were clearly in another world. They were still on a river, but there were no trees anywhere. The barrels sat in a calm spot on the river, bobbing up and down gently, but not floating off in any particular direction. To their left, beyond the beach lay mountains, and to the right, flat scrubland as far as the eye could see.
“Which way?” Mingalaz coughed, spitting out water and shivering against him. Thorin repeated the question to Bilbo, who shrugged.
“Myrtle’s too close to the portal we came through to sense anything else,” Bilbo said apologetically.
“The mountains seem more promising,” Balin suggested. “Do you see anything in the other direction?” he asked his dæmon, who was flying above the company in an attempt to scout. She just shook her head and flew back down.
“No towns,” she croaked. “No woods. Just grass.”
Well that settled it. “Make for the mountains,” Thorin ordered, and the company began the slow process of paddling their barrels toward the shore.
Bilbo Baggins was soaked. Straight to the bone, if he felt like exaggerating, and frankly he did. It was starting to become a theme with him, and wasn’t that an unpleasant thought. At least this time the dwarves were all in the same state, but it wasn’t enough to keep the doubts at bay. Maybe they shouldn’t have left Mirkwood so hastily. The Elves had been thoughtful hosts, and they’d had a very enjoyable evening. But even without Thorin’s tenuous doubts about the Elvenking, the way their dæmons reacted to the place was reason enough to move on. Bilbo knew that. But it was hard not to feel any resentment. Thorin’s nephews, and Bofur and Bombur, had been friendly and welcoming the night before, and beating them all in the drinking contest had been enough to earn their camaraderie in the morning, but still Thorin watched him with an unfriendly eye.
“It’s nothing personal lad,” Balin said, surprising Bilbo out of his reverie. “Thorin appreciates that you’ve more skill and sense than he initially thought, but he’s slow to trust. A king must be, you understand.”
“I don’t really,” Bilbo admitted. “We don’t have kings in the Shire, so it is hard not to take it personally, but if you say it isn’t, I suppose you know best.”
“If you manage to find Gondolin, Thorin will be so overjoyed, he might ask you to marry him,” Balin’s dæmon croaked, with what sounded like a hoarse laugh.
“Don’t say that where he can hear you,” Balin cautioned with a chuckle of his own. “But our Thorin never does anything by halves. So when he decides you can be trusted, you may wonder what you have to do to get rid of him.”
Bilbo accepted this information with a nod and a blush, saying nothing. It was heartening to know that Balin was so certain that Thorin would eventually thaw towards him, though he hoped Balin’s dæmon was joking. What a change that would be! It was hard to imagine.
It was especially hard to imagine at the moment, in the company of 13 very soggy dwarves, not a one of them with dry clothing. Their dæmons were not much better off, particularly Dori’s. Thorin had ordered them to make for the mountains, but it was clear very quickly that this did not mean they were up for exploring the mountains at the moment. What they needed was a sheltered cave and a warm fire, and blessedly Daisy found a cave fairly quickly. Glóin and Óin soon found sufficient firewood, and before long good cheer was restored by having a warm fire and somewhere to hang their wet clothes.
The day was still very young, the sun not yet near its peak, and the weather was fine, so it didn’t take long before the younger dwarves grew tired of the cave, and took to roughhousing on the beach. Even their dæmons got in on the action, their playful nipping looking much more dangerous to Bilbo. Initially it was just Fíli and Kíli, with Ori off to one side practicing with his slingshot, but before long the cave was mostly empty, the other dwarves joining in for some sparring. In the end, it was just Bilbo and Thorin left in the cave, Bilbo jumping every time Balin’s dæmon snapped at Óin’s, or when Glóin’s dæmon caught Dwalin in the chest.
They were all clearly having fun, if the cheeky grins and wide smiles all around were any indication, and that was what calmed Bilbo down. Moreover, their dæmons seemed to have recovered from whatever it was that had troubled them in Mirkwood, every bit of sluggishness gone. “I don’t understand why they seem to enjoy pain so much,” Bilbo observed to Myrtle, forgetting Thorin was still there. “But I suppose cheerful, half-naked dwarves are nicer to deal with than soggy, irritable ones.”
“It is not the pain they enjoy,” Thorin replied, startling Bilbo, who very luckily did not jump up or shout. “It’s the exercise, the feeling of testing your strength against a worthy opponent…” Thorin trailed off, and Bilbo looked over at him. Thorin was gesturing with one hand, as if he were grasping for the words.
“You are weak, and would not understand,” Minty muttered, her voice a low growl. The words felt like a slap, but Bilbo couldn’t deny their truth. He looked back at Thorin, and noticed that the dwarf’s mouth was pressed into a thin line, as if he agreed with the sentiment, but wanted to chastise his dæmon for her lack of diplomacy.
“You’re probably right,” Bilbo agreed with a hand over Myrtle’s mouth so that she couldn’t interject. Thorin and Minty both looked a little taken aback by his frankness. “What? Is it so strange to be aware of my own deficiencies?”
Thorin shook his head. “No, but it is strange to admit to them easily. We are a proud race. Some might think such an admission makes them lose face.” There was something in Thorin’s eyes as he said this that Bilbo couldn’t place. It wasn’t strong enough for admiration, but maybe just a little bit of respect?
“Well, we have a saying in the Shire,” Myrtle said, freeing her snout from Bilbo’s grasp. “The first step to fixing a problem is admitting you have it in the first place. If there are weeds choking your tomatoes, it’s hard to keep your tomatoes alive if you refuse to admit that those weeds aren’t part of the tomato plant.”
Thorin was watching them both intently now, and it was a point of pride for Bilbo that he didn’t look away first. “You wish to learn to fight?” Thorin seemed surprised that he was even asking this question, his eyes narrowed in suspicion.
“It probably wouldn’t be the worst idea,” Bilbo admitted. “There’s no need to learn in the Shire, but I was helpless against the spiders. That didn’t feel good. Not that I have a weapon anyway.”
Thorin considered him silently for a moment, though Minty groomed herself disinterestedly. Bilbo wondered which of them was being sincere. Maybe both? Dwarves were different, after all.
“If you truly wish to learn, we have weapons enough,” Thorin said finally, rising. Minty stretched languidly, following suit. “I will speak to Balin about it.”
“Thank you,” Bilbo said, and Thorin gave only a little nod of acknowledgement. Still, it was something.
Their clothes and supplies were still damp after their lunch of fish, fresh caught from the river, so Bilbo’s lessons were to begin immediately. He was given one of Fíli’s apparently copious knives, with an assurance that the dwarf prince was stuffed full of them, so he didn’t need that one back. Bilbo wasn’t sure he could do much damage with something that small, but he also doubted he could lift anything bigger, so it would have to do.
His lessons were an object of interest for the rest of the company, who watched Bilbo ineptly try to match the positions Balin taught him, and shouted words of encouragement. It was distracting, which was not helpful, and Myrtle kept up a near constant stream of muttering about the uselessness of dwarves, but Bilbo didn’t mind. They actually cared about the outcome of his training, which meant they hadn’t written him off yet. It didn’t occur to him at the time that maybe all the shouting would draw attention. After all, the elves had been friendly enough.
The residents of the one other world they had visited being friendly was not enough of a sample to be basing their behavior on, as they would all soon learn.
Eventually, as dwarves started checking their clothes and finding them dry enough to be putting back on, Balin finally called a halt to the day’s lesson. Bilbo was sore in places he’d never been sore in before, sweat-soaked, and exhausted, but at least he knew how to hold the knife correctly, and maybe even a few of the positions. He wondered, as he pulled his jacket back on, what his relatives would say about all this. Or what they were even saying right now. He had vanished from Bag End without a word to anyone. Someone probably saw him get thrown into the river... but he hadn’t come up again. Oh.
“Myrtle, we can’t go home, can we?” he asked her quietly as they broke camp.
“They might think you’re some kind of shade, or a wight,” she agreed unhelpfully. “Though I suppose shades don’t usually have dæmons. But Gandalf said he thought we’d find our home out here somewhere, so there’s no time for regrets of that kind.”
“We can’t get back even if we try,” Bilbo realized, squeezing Myrtle a little tighter than was comfortable for either of them. “The portal back to Mirkwood leads to the forest river, and who knows where it leads. I guess there’s no choice now.”
“That’s the spirit,” he heard Bofur say somewhere behind him, but he didn’t turn or acknowledge the comment. It was a little exhausting, realizing that there was really no going back.
For once, Bilbo wasn’t leading, the dwarves depositing him safely in the center of the pack with Ori. Dwalin and Daisy led, the wolf dæmon keeping a sharp nose out for any sign of trouble as they looked for some kind of mountain pass, or a cave that led deeper. Bilbo would have expected Thorin to lead, being in charge of this quest, but Nori informed him discreetly that their leader had a rather poor sense of direction. The bird dæmons scouted ahead as far as they could without straining their bonds, but the owls could see little in daylight, and the other birds confirmed there wasn’t much to see. The mountains were tall and stretched for hundreds of miles to the north and south, and that was about all they could report.
Still, eventually Daisy found a path, which led to a pass through the mountains, or at least they hoped it did. Bilbo heard at least one dwarf grumble about the prospect of walking back down if this pass didn’t pan out, but finally, as night was falling, Ori’s dæmon found another cave for them to shelter in. Just in time too, as Bilbo’s legs were just about done. He’d always been a good walker, but he didn’t usually climb mountains after being taught to fight.
“Are you okay there, Bilbo?” Most of the dwarves were helping with the fire or gathering the materials for dinner, but Dori had apparently noticed the panting, slumped hobbit despite all that. His cat dæmon was already sauntering over to check on Myrtle.
“Just a little winded,” Bilbo replied, waving his hand dismissively. “It’s not every day hobbits climb mountains, you know.”
Dori nodded. “Don’t stay up too late after dinner,” he advised Bilbo. “Until Myrtle picks up a scent, we don’t know how much more mountain there is to go, so you’ll need your strength.”
This was agreed to easily enough, along with the generous portion of dinner. Bilbo did miss the usual hobbit meals, but it was hardly practical to stop every hour for food, especially when they didn’t know whether anything in the next world would even be edible. It was an adventure, and some sacrifices were going to be necessary.
“Do you smell anything yet?” he whispered to Myrtle as they settled in for the night.
“I might,” she admitted. “It’s faint, and I think it’s inside the mountains somewhere.”
“I’ll mention it to Thorin in the morning,” Bilbo decided, and that was when the ground dropped out from under them.
