Actions

Work Header

To Find a Long Forgotten World

Chapter 8: The Isle of Dead Men

Summary:

Puttering around the library isn't the worst way to spend the day, even if there are very decayed bodies lying around.

Notes:

Oh no I'm starting to run out of backlog chapters (currently writing chapter 15)! I'll try to keep up this update pace though.

Also, because someone asked in the comments, I'll just repeat it up here for everyone: the dwarves' daemon's names will be translated as part of the story, which is why I haven't been making a khuzdul glossary. Never fear, you will know what they mean in time. Also, a note about writing systems. The two main writing systems in ME are Cirth and Tengwar, used primarily by dwarves and elves respectively, though that wasn't hard and fast. Based on descriptions of the library in Gondor, it seems reasonable to say that they'd have writings in both scripts, and written in a variety of mediums.

Thanks again to Niffstral for going over this chapter when she's got finals she should be studying for.

Chapter Text

The company was spread out across the sprawling library, looking for any tomes or tablets that still had readable words on them. Mingalaz had finally been forced to relinquish her hold over Myrtle, much to Thorin’s relief. It wasn’t like her to behave that way. She talked back to him all the time, but refusing to drop Myrtle went deeper than that. He really didn’t want to consider what it could mean.

He sincerely hoped Bilbo wasn’t considering what it meant.

A crunch underfoot alerted him to a wayward stone tablet, which he rescued more gently. The runes were still sharp, but they were unfamiliar. Maybe Gandalf could read them, he decided, and held onto it. He came across several books with papyrus pages that were damaged but readable, and some of them were even written in runes he could read! His arms full, he stumped off to find a table to set them on, Mingalaz sniffing around disinterestedly.

“Please behave around Myrtle,” he begged her quietly. “I thought you wanted me to stop distancing them, but they’re going to start distancing us if you keep it up.”

Mingalaz sniffed as if this did not concern her in the least, and did not respond. Wasn’t an unresponsive dæmon generally a sign of madness? But Mingalaz wasn’t silent, she was just pouting. Or waiting for him to ask the right question.

Thorin sighed, setting the tomes and tablets on a table. “Why are you doing this?”

“Balin shouldn’t be teaching Bilbo how to fight,” Mingalaz replied immediately. Why did she have to be so difficult?

“You want him to be helpless, then? Myrtle was certainly helpless while you were carrying her,” Thorin pointed out.

“I didn’t say that,” Mingalaz continued doggedly. “You should be teaching him.”

Thorin was temporarily dumbfounded. She was throwing a temper tantrum because he wasn’t teaching their portal finder how to fight? Mingalaz really did resemble his sister. “And why have you decided this?”

“Because Ranakâl can fly,” Mingalaz argued. “She can stay out of his way easily, but Myrtle is earth-bound. Bilbo’s fast, but she’s slow. She could get in the way of his footwork, or get kicked by an opponent. They need to learn from someone with that kind of experience.”

“Those are fair points,” Thorin agreed as they returned to the search. “But Dwalin, Dori, Nori, Glóin, and Bifur, not to mention Fíli and Kíli, all have earth-bound dæmons.”

“Yes, for argument’s sake, lets exclude the excitable dog duo,” Mingalaz muttered. “Dingoes and coyotes are too fast. Rams and boars are too slow, even if Bifur could communicate with him. Raccoons are too mobile all around, that cat is stronger than Daisy, and of course Daisy is far too aggressive.”

“You seem to have forgotten your own size and strength,” Thorin observed mildly, wresting another promising tome from a long dead scholar with a silent apology. Whether he agreed with Mingalaz or not, it was better to just let her talk.

“I was not always this way,” she said sternly, picking her way through the rubble with a lithe, feline grace. A strange dæmon for a dwarf, some used to say behind their hands when they thought no one important could hear. “When we were young and for some reason I could not get very big, Shathinh and Abkund liked to pick fights with me. Your brother and sister could never beat you in a fight, but I was different. I was small, and often I was also slow. Even now, I’m smaller than Daruthâ, but I’ve never let her beat me.”

Thorin dug out another tablet before answering, considering the truth of Mingalaz’s words. He had always wondered about his dæmon, being the only feline in a family of canines, and what it said about him. But she was right. There probably was some logic in their being the most qualified to train Bilbo and Myrtle. The question was, if they would accept the attention, after Mingalaz’s earlier behavior.

He didn’t get a chance to respond, because they had made it back to the table, and found the rest of the company gathered around it, poring over tomes and scratching their heads.

“Ah, Thorin!” Gandalf hailed him, his little moth dæmon fluttering over a clay tablet. “As it turns out, I can read most of the scripts here, and there are a good number of pieces written in the common tongue.”

Several of those pieces turned out to be ancient farmers almanacs, if what Dwalin read back before tossing them unceremoniously aside was any indication. Ori found a series of tablets carved with ancient myths, which he put in his writing satchel gently, to examine more later. Gandalf found some old trade documents, which were only interesting because of what they implied: trade between worlds.

It was an interesting, if not terribly productive few hours. If nothing else, it was good practice for Gondolin, Thorin reasoned. There too, they would have to dig through the relics of a long dead culture. Even longer dead than Numenor, if the snippet Bilbo unearthed was any indication. Gandalf had translated it, revealing that Bilbo had found a record of a failed expedition to find the lost kingdom of Gondolin.

“They didn’t know where it was either,” Fíli observed, leaning over to look at the tablet.

“Then what chance’ve we got?” Nori wondered, his fingers twitching. Thorin wondered how many relics were hidden in the thief’s clothes somewhere. Not that they would be missed by anyone.

“Chance doesn’t come into it,” Dwalin replied coldly. “We do it or we don’t.”

“I doubt they had that compass,” Bilbo pointed out, tracing the lines of a rune thoughtfully. “Thorin’s starting to figure it out.”

“Do you really think it can give anything as complicated as directions to another world?” Balin asked, his eyebrows raised.

“It told Thorin where the library was,” Bilbo pointed out, pursing his lips.

“Right you are, laddie,” Balin agreed, raising his hands in surrender.

Mingalaz looked up at Thorin, her eyes glittering with mirth, and he kicked her lightly under the table. “We should move on,” Thorin suggested heavily. “Does Myrtle have the scent of another portal?”

Bilbo nodded. “It’s still a way off. I don’t think we can make it before nightfall.” There was a faint note of something- fear maybe?

“Wraiths don’t just come out at night,” Bofur assured Bilbo, sensing the source of his discomfort. “If they were here, we’d’ve seen ‘em by now.”

“Probably,” Bombur agreed.

Thorin noted that Bilbo didn’t look the least bit comforted.

In the end, the question of whether they could make it by nightfall or not was settled by the weather. As they were approaching the edge of the city, the sky had opened up, and unceremoniously started pouring. Several members of the company were weighed down by very old books, so they were forced to take shelter in the nearest mostly intact building they could find. There was no question of starting a fire; with the streets as choked with plant life as they were, trying to find dry wood would be a quest of its own.

This being their camp for the night, most of the company settled into their familiar groups. Thorin had expected Bilbo to sit a little apart, like in the Goblin Tunnels, but maybe something had changed while he had been recovering. Bilbo and Myrtle walked right over to Ori, to join him in looking over the ancient myths, while Dori made sure they had dry clothes, and Nori looked over his newest acquisitions.

“They look cozy,” Mingalaz observed casually.

Thorin ignored her, and went to talk to Balin. “What do you think?” he asked without clarification or preamble.

Balin sighed. “I think Gandalf is holding back,” he admitted tiredly. “A wizard has a right to his secrets, but I’m beginning to suspect that we’ve been given a greater task than we thought.”

Thorin nodded slowly. Trust his oldest advisor to share that feeling. “Should we continue?”

Balin looked at Thorin appraisingly, and Ranakâl matched it with her beady eyes. “I don’t think we have much choice in the matter,” he said with an air of resignation. “Once, I might have urged you to turn back. We could move our people to another world, and hope that the evil didn’t spread. But the darkness is everywhere.”

Unconsciously, Thorin reached for the compass, drawing Balin’s gaze. “Are you really starting to understand it, or were you just guessing?” he asked, his eyebrows raised.

In answer, Thorin adjusted the knobs until the hands were framing the question, “will we succeed?” He watched the needle move, feeling almost a trance-like state come upon him, and the answer soon became clear: “If you keep to your purpose.”

“It’s been getting clearer since the sun sickness,” Thorin admitted, putting the compass away. “Simple answers at least.”

Balin gave a small exhale of laughter. “Well then, the wizard may keep his secrets, but apparently he was right about one thing.” Ranakâl hopped around on his shoulder, and whispered something in Balin’s ear, which made his mouth twist to the side a little. “So, there’s something else you wanted to discuss?”

It was with a sharp look at Mingalaz that Thorin said, “About Bilbo’s training…”

 


 

“This word appears a lot. I think it must be an archaic form, because I’ve never seen it before,” Ori admitted, scratching his head. Bilbo traced the lines of the rune, as if that would illuminate their meaning, though of course it wouldn’t. This wasn’t a pictographic writing system.

“‘The Valar feared the spread of evil, so, hoping that this was the lesser evil, they-’” Bilbo recited, shaking his head when he came to that troublesome rune. It was the last rune they had to work with. Everything after it was too worn to read on this particular tablet. It sounded rather like what Gandalf had said about the fall of Numenor, but why would there be records in Numenor’s library about that?

“One word ain’t gonna tell ya much,” Nori argued. “Probably a waste of time.”

“You don’t know that,” Ori shot back, as if he’d had a similar conversation with Nori dozens of times.

“It says ‘sundered,’” Dori offered casually, only glancing briefly at the rune before returning to grooming his dæmon.

Ori’s dæmon hooted agitatedly. “How did you know that?” Ori demanded, nevertheless writing the word into their translation.

“Saw it in an old book once,” Dori said with a shrug, wrestling a particularly difficult knot out of his dæmon’s fur.

“So the Valar sundered something,” Bilbo murmured thoughtfully.

“Doesn’t sound like what happened here,” Myrtle observed.

“It’s not a lot to go on,” Ori noted with a sharp look at Nori, “but it’s more than we had before.”

Ori jotted down a few more notes, and when he looked up from his journal, he jumped in surprise. Bilbo glanced over and saw that Thorin had joined them, accounting for Ori’s discomfort. Not that Thorin looked any more comfortable, shifting back and forth on his feet.

“A word, Master Baggins?” he said, jerking his head away from the rest of the company.

Bilbo wondered briefly if refusal was even an option. Thorin had gone from distant, to a little patronizing, to maybe a little friendly when he’d been bedridden? And then Minty had picked up Myrtle and refused to drop her, whatever that meant. It was exhausting, trying to keep up with the dwarf king’s moods, though he had liked the more friendly Thorin. Was it worth it?

Thorin was waiting, but he didn’t look angry that he was being kept waiting, so Bilbo rose and followed him. He picked up Myrtle just in case, not missing the predatory gleam in Minty’s eyes. Thorin led him to a distant corner of the building, up to an edge where part of the ceiling was missing. They could watch the rain there and stay dry, Bilbo realized, the corners of his mouth twitching into a smile. Numenor was still rather picturesque in the rain.

“Call me Bilbo,” he burst out when Thorin turned to stare out at the city, surprising him into turning around. Thorin’s mouth was slightly open, and a thought crossed Bilbo’s mind that he stomped down on quickly. “Call me Bilbo,” he repeated. “Everyone else does.”

“Even after what M- she did?” Thorin asked, with an amused look at his dæmon.

“Well, some kind of explanation for that might be nice,” Bilbo replied, matching Thorin’s tone and lifting Myrtle up a bit higher. She put her short arms around his neck, burying her snout in Bilbo’s neck.

“That was actually why I wanted to speak to you, Bilbo,” Thorin admitted, and Bilbo tried to ignore the little flutter in his stomach. It didn’t mean anything, really. “My dæmon believes that we should be teaching you and Myrtle how to fight.”

Whatever Bilbo had been expecting, it wasn’t that. “And that’s why she, er, kidnapped Myrtle?”

“She’s never been very good at using her words,” Thorin explained apologetically.

“Not unlike a certain someone,” Minty muttered, earning a light kick from Thorin.

Unaware of Thorin’s inner turmoil, Bilbo saw no reason to refuse. It seemed like Thorin was finally starting to trust him, and while he couldn’t say why that idea made him so cheerful, he wasn’t going to risk it by refusing Thorin’s generosity. Personal lessons from the dwarf king were probably considered a rare honor back in Erebor.

“I’ll take any help I can get,” Bilbo admitted. “No one says so, but I think they’re convinced I’m hopeless.”

“Fíli would not have lent you a knife if he thought it would be wasted in your hands,” Thorin assured him, some of the tension leaving his shoulders. “I would have him teach you next, if my dæmon did not think that his dæmon is too light on her feet to properly instruct Myrtle.”

“And Minty isn’t?” Bilbo asked, digging the knife out of his pack. It was as good a time as any to have a lesson, and Minty’s attentive posture suggested that she at least had exactly that in mind.

“She was small and slow when we were young, and our dæmons fight often at that age. She thinks it gave her some perspective,” Thorin explained. “She won’t actually hurt Myrtle, I swear it.”

“If she does, I won’t be around to complain,” Bilbo observed, assuming the first stance Balin had taught him while Minty walked a short distance away with Myrtle. Thorin was immediately shaking his head.

“That’s for a sword,” he corrected, adjusting Bilbo’s limb positions without even a by-your-leave. “Even if we gave you a sword and you could lift it effectively, your arm is too short for you to fight as if you were using one. I know that’s what Balin taught you,” Thorin assured him when he saw Bilbo opening his mouth. “I am not criticizing you.”

Once he got used to Thorin’s teaching style (Balin had preferred to demonstrate, rather than adjust Bilbo’s stance himself), Bilbo found himself enjoying the lesson. He had liked Balin’s lessons, the kindly dwarf being a patient, understanding teacher, but Thorin wasn’t as harsh an instructor as he would have thought. He was quick to point out problems, and direct praise was rare, but it meant more because it was so infrequent. If Bilbo’s earlier lessons with Balin had left him feeling tired but proud, Thorin’s lessons multiplied both feelings. He was sore and sweaty, and about ready to try stabbing Thorin, but he also thought there was a chance that if he tried, the blow could land. Myrtle was also strangely quiet afterward, and he could tell his dæmon was mulling over what Minty had taught her. He’d been too focused on his own lesson to listen in to theirs, but her thoughtful air suggested that tonight was not the time for those questions.

When Bilbo returned to his bedroll, ready to crawl in and call it a night, the royal siblings intercepted him, both of them slinging an arm around his shoulders.

“So, Bilbo,” Fíli began casually.

“We understand Uncle’s giving you sword lessons now,” Kíli observed. Not that it required much observation, Bilbo thought grumpily. It wasn’t exactly a secret.

“Knife lessons technically,” Bilbo corrected them, frowning as Myrtle burrowed into the bedroll. No help from that quarter, apparently.

“He tell you why?” Fíli asked, fixing Bilbo with a stare that seemed more fitting for his uncle.

“He thought it would help me get better, obviously,” Bilbo replied tartly. “Why else would he do it?” He thought Thorin’s explanation about Minty was a bit too private to be shared, even with his nephews. They hadn’t been around in those days. Probably they wouldn’t know, and he wasn’t going to betray what little trust he had earned.

“He tell you why Minty grabbed Myrtle?” Kíli pressed, his dæmon sniffing around in Bilbo’s bedroll for Myrtle. She was going to get scratched that way, but Bilbo suspected that she wouldn’t learn without experiencing it first. Like Kíli, who was going to get in trouble someday soon.

“I think that’s between Minty and Myrtle, thank you,” he said stiffly. “Now really, can’t anyone get a little privacy? If your uncle didn’t want to tell you, what makes you think that I feel differently?”

They at least had the decency to look a little abashed at that, both of their dæmons’ tails going between their legs. It made Bilbo regret being quite so harsh. They probably got a lot of scolding from Thorin, and it couldn’t be entirely good for them.

“Now I’m sorry for being blunt, but I had to speak my mind,” Bilbo said, and instantly they perked back up, as if he hadn’t scolded them in the first place. He was made to regret his easy forgiveness, as the pair of them pestered him with questions well past the time that Bilbo would have preferred to fall asleep, until Thorin gave them a quelling look and they retreated.