Actions

Work Header

To Find a Long Forgotten World

Chapter 14: The Knife

Summary:

Thorin has his compass, Bilbo has his knife.

Chapter Text

Tauriel and Legolas were lucky that Dís had more easily believed her mother’s old stories as an adult than Thorin had. The longer their king was gone, the twitchier the guards became, watching every shadow with axes drawn just in case it was a wraith. Thorin had mentioned a few details about the existence of other worlds, but it was easy to forget that in the grip of fear, and he had known very little when he set out.

It was safe to say that the Elves received a welcome as armed to the teeth as they had initially given the dwarves. But it was clear that strange as they were, they weren’t wraiths, so were taken to meet Acting-Queen Dís, though with more guards than they might normally have used. Such a strange, tall folk, Tauriel heard one of them mutter.

“This is pointless, Tauriel,” Legolas murmured, so quietly that only elven ears could have heard him. “They do not know about the spiders, and they are afraid.”

“The King is also afraid,” Tauriel reminded him in the same tone, staring straight ahead. Gailon stayed close on her shoulder. She had the feeling they would shoot first and ask questions later if they saw Gailon go too far from her. “You should know better than I how to speak to people who are afraid, having more experience.”

Legolas gave her a long-suffering look but said nothing.

Tauriel expected to be taken to the throne room, but evidently Acting-Queen Dís had different ideas. When they passed the passage to the throne room, it soon became clear why: despite the narrow path to the throne over a ravine, it was a fairly public space. Whatever they had to say, the Acting-Queen apparently wasn’t going to risk it being public.

“It’s for the best really,” Gailon whispered. “We don’t know how much they know, and they don’t really need a panic right now.”

“Not that we know much more,” she replied wryly, and then they were stopping in front of a door. The guards knocked, once, twice, three times, and the door swung open into a little parlor.

“Her highness is-” the servant who opened the door began, his eyes widening at the sight of the Elves. “Oh,” he breathed, and hurried off into another room. Tauriel heard muffled conversation, and then another dwarf emerged, who she knew immediately to be the Acting-Queen. The fact that she resembled Thorin and her sons had little enough to do with it; there was a solid dignity in her bearing, as if she were the mountain itself and would not be shaken so easily. Tauriel wasn’t confused for a moment by the facial hair, though clearly Legolas was. She knew another woman when she saw one.

“Your highness,” Tauriel said with a gracious bow, Legolas following her lead. He might be the prince, but this was her mission. He was just tagging along. “I am Tauriel, Captain of the Woodland Guard, and this is Legolas, Prince of the Woodland Realm.”

Dís pursed her lips. “None of those names or places mean anything to me, but you look like Elves, and doubtless come from another world, so you’d better come in.”

 


 

Thorin had spent much of their time among Elves feeling short, which was a new and unpleasant feeling, but Glorfindel didn’t make him feel that way. The yellow-haired elf certainly was tall, but where most of the Elves had a distant look in their eyes, like they were contemplating greater concerns, Glorfindel’s eyes were clearly fixed on what was in front of him.

“When Elves die, they are reembodied,” Elrond’s dæmon had told them before they met Glorfindel. Elrond had not been present, and that was extremely alien to them. “Glorfindel died a long time ago, fighting a demon of Morgoth, and he returned to this world with perspective. I think you will find him different.”

An Elf with a mongoose dæmon certainly was different. And the fact that he took one look at Bilbo and offered his hand, saying, “I believe I met your mother.”

Bilbo and Elrond both started.

“Of course, how did I not see it?” Elrond realized, looking at Bilbo with new eyes.

“My mother really did come here?” Bilbo asked, taking the offered hand with a touch of awe.

“Mithrandir brought her, some years back,” Glorfindel confirmed easily. Thorin wondered if the Elves saw the passage of time differently. Bilbo’s mother had traveled before marrying Bilbo’s father, which would have made the meeting more than 50 years ago. Hardly some years back, even by his own reckoning.

“I thought so,” Bilbo murmured, petting Myrtle absently. “Did you tell her about Gondolin then?”

Glorfindel nodded. “She wanted to know all kinds of things, and just the average tale wouldn’t do,” he recalled fondly. “It had to be something extraordinary. The lost kingdom of my people was just barely enough.”

Bilbo looked suddenly thoughtful, and voiced a question that hadn’t even occurred to Thorin. “Why is it called the lost kingdom? We’ve been to many worlds by now, and even Numenor, flooded by the Valar, was easy enough to find,” he observed, rubbing his chin.

“Is it shielded, like Lothlorien?” Thorin asked, though that question raised even more questions. Who would be shielding it?

“No, it’s much simpler than that,” Glorfindel corrected them, shaking his head in mild amusement. “There are just no more portals into Gondolin. They were all closed, to prevent it from being looted, and its treasures being spread around the worlds.”

Bilbo’s face fell, and Thorin was struggling not to do the same, keeping a firm grip on Mingalaz so that she didn’t do anything foolish. Gandalf would not have sent them all this way for nothing, and indeed, the wizard didn’t seem troubled or surprised by this news. That had to be his comfort.

“We were told that you could show us the way,” Thorin reminded the elf, biting down on his frustration.

“And I can,” Glorfindel agreed, pulling a sheathed knife out of an inner pocket of his coat. “Some of the knives forged in Gondolin were discovered to have the power to cut open the walls between worlds. Not all, and they could only be used properly by those who were drawn to open portals, but I have such a knife, and you have such a person.”

Balin cleared his throat. “Could we not simply use this knife to destroy the wraiths? Why go to Gondolin when we have what we came for?”

“You will not destroy the enemy’s forces with a single knife,” Glorfindel answered, handing the weapon to Bilbo, “wielded by an untrained hobbit. You need less picky weapons, wielded by more skilled bearers. No offense intended.”

“None taken,” Bilbo assured him, drawing the weapon slowly and examining it. To Thorin’s more trained eye, it did look different from any steel blade he’d ever seen, and when Bilbo saw that he was looking, he handed it over. Thorin was shocked by the weight: there really was none. A weapon needed heft to some extent, but for Bilbo, it was perfect. He wasn’t going to win a contest of strength, so if his blade met another, he had probably already lost. Thorin handed it back.

“In addition to cutting through the connections between worlds, it will glow blue if orcs or goblins are close, which I imagine will be useful after that last ambush,” Gandalf observed.

“Hmm,” Bilbo hummed, sounding a little unconvinced. “If this knife can cut into other worlds, then couldn’t I just open a portal to Gondolin right here? There aren’t orcs there, are there?”

“Not anymore,” Glorfindel agreed. “But no, that wouldn’t work. It is true that every world is connected, but they aren’t all connected in the same way.”

“A portal to Gondolin opened here might lead you to plunging over a cliff, or being trapped in the sea, or somewhere equally fatal,” Elrond explained. “Not to mention that the city itself has impenetrable walls. No, you must follow Glorfindel to a place where we know it will be safe to cross over, and risk danger for a little longer.”

“So eager to part company, Bilbo?” Thorin asked lightly, raising an eyebrow.

Surprisingly, Bilbo didn’t have a retort ready. He blushed and stuttered, “N-no, that’s not-”

Myrtle huffed, interrupting him. She said something Thorin couldn’t hear, and though he could tell it was intended to calm Bilbo, it had the opposite effect. He got redder, and said nothing more for the rest of the conversation. Myrtle was also quiet, which was rare. Despite the rarity of dæmons speaking openly in dwarven society, Myrtle clearly had no such qualms, and it was influencing Mingalaz.

“Why should I keep quiet?” she asked as they trooped back to their room, Thorin being ordered to get as much rest as he could. “My opinion is worth no less than yours.”

“It arguably means more, which is why it should be shared less,” he replied ruefully. “Hobbits may be honest and simple, but I would prefer it if you kept our privacy.”

“‘Honest and simple’ are possibly the last words I would use to describe Bilbo,” Mingalaz replied airily.

 


 

Simply swinging the blade around did nothing except terrify Myrtle.

Bilbo paced around his small room, trying at different spots in the air, but it made no difference. Unlike finding the portals, this was evidently not instinctive. Either that, or he lacked the instincts. That alone was a terrifying thought, to come all this way and be of use, only to fail right when he was truly needed.

“Stop it,” Myrtle snapped. “It’s no use thinking like that. You need to focus.”

“Very helpful advice,” Bilbo replied sarcastically. “I will apply it immediately. What exactly do I need to focus on?”

Unexpectedly, Myrtle did have an answer. “You’ve watched Thorin read his compass. Maybe that’s what you need to do.”

Though that wasn’t a direct answer, it was more helpful than he had expected, and he went immediately to Thorin’s room. At his knock, Dwalin opened the door and admitted him without a word. Conveniently, Thorin was sitting up in bed, fiddling with the compass, and looked up immediately when Bilbo entered.

“Any luck?” he asked, clearly trying to restrain his eagerness.

“Not yet,” Bilbo admitted. “But Myrtle had an idea. Could I watch you read the compass?”

“What should I ask it?” Thorin was fiddling with the wheels, as if he already had some idea, but it was Dwalin who provided the answer.

“How to use the knife,” he supplied simply, and Bilbo was actually a little ashamed that he hadn’t thought of that. He’d simply wanted a look at Thorin’s concentration, not to have him divine the answer.

But Thorin did as Dwalin suggested, turning the wheels to ask the question, and Bilbo watched apprehensively as Thorin fell into that state of intense focus, where it seemed like he could see or hear nothing but the compass. Bilbo had hoped that watching Thorin concentrate like that would give him some idea of how to do that himself, because maybe it would heighten his ability to detect where portals could be. That didn’t happen, but at least Thorin now had an answer for him.

“It says that you must focus on the very tip of the blade, and slide it slowly through the air until you feel it snag on something,” Thorin explained, rubbing his eyes after the reading was done. “When it snags, you can cut that point open into a portal.”

“No swinging it about at random,” Mingalaz added drowsily. “You’ll just cut someone.”

With this advice in mind, Bilbo sought out Ori next, needing someone to take notes during his second attempt in case it worked and he forgot how to do it again. Ori sketched his stance, took note of the time of day, remarked on how focused Bilbo looked as he moved the knife, but it ended up being unnecessary.

With Thorin’s words in mind, Bilbo became the tip of the knife, and it wasn’t long before he felt the blade snag on something in the air. Opening his eyes, he couldn’t see whatever the blade was caught on, but there was definitely resistance. He pressed the blade against it a little harder, and felt the blade slip free, tearing right. Bilbo and Ori both gasped, and Ori’s dæmon hooted excitedly. There was a gash in the air, where his blade had cut. He brought the blade down, and to the left, and there was a complete portal hanging open in front of them.

“You really did it,” Ori breathed, staring for a moment before scribbling furiously into his notebook.

“I really did it,” Bilbo agreed, staring dazedly into the portal. There was no mistaking the green, lightly rolling hills. “It’s the shire,” he murmured, and Ori’s quill scratching stopped for a moment.

“Were you thinking of the Shire when you cut?” he asked, his quill poised to write down the answer. “Or do you think maybe you just recognize the feel of your own world?”

“I wasn’t thinking about anything in particular,” Bilbo replied, shaking his head. “Just being the tip of the blade.”

Ori nodded and made some notes. Before long, much of the company, as well as the elves, had noticed the sudden hole in the air, and were coming around to investigate. Bofur and his dæmon whistled in appreciation, either of the greenness of the shire or the fact that Bilbo had opened a portal, he did not know which. Bifur gabbed cheerfully in Khuzdul, and Bilbo was assured that he was comparing the color of the grass to emeralds, which Bilbo took for a compliment. He had told Bombur a thing or two about the plentiful food of his homeland, so it was with hungry eyes that Bombur examined the portal.

Gandalf and Glorfindel examined the portal more thoughtfully, and more importantly, taught Bilbo how to close the portals behind him. “It wouldn’t do for some curious fauntling to stumble onto this portal, and worry his parents by disappearing,” Gandalf reasoned, making Bilbo remember that everyone he knew probably thought he was dead.

“And Gandalf’s the murderer,” Myrtle muttered as they returned to their room after the spectacle.

“So while we have the means to go back, we still can’t,” Bilbo observed, studying the edge of the blade thoughtfully. “Lobelia might attack me with her umbrella, thinking the Shire has wraiths now.”

“She might have done that anyway,” Myrtle observed, shrugging her little shoulders. “There’s nothing between her and Bag End now. Not that you care.”

“You’re right,” Bilbo admitted, surprised at himself. “I don’t. As long as I have this knife, I can go anywhere I want. Even if in the end, the dwarves don’t want us around, it should be easy enough to find a pleasant world to call home with this.” Not that he wanted things to end that way, but it was good to have options. He still didn’t fully understand what it meant that the dwarves had shared their dæmons names. He wasn’t a dwarf after all, and had no way of knowing that they weren’t about to let him go.

“We could stay here,” Myrtle suggested, looking up at one of the slender trees thoughtfully. “I think they’d let us, if we really wanted to.”

“We would be honored,” Arwen said with a smile, emerging from a nearby door. “I was here for some of your mother’s visit, and everyone was quite taken with her. Her son would surely be welcome.”

“O-oh, Lady Arwen!” Bilbo exclaimed, bowing a little, which made her giggle.

“You don’t have to do that,” she assured him, still smiling. Bilbo wondered how she didn’t have lines of young men following her. She was exceptionally beautiful, and he said so, which made her laugh again. “Would you like to hear about one of my ancestors?”

Bilbo didn’t know what that had to do with anything, but he was never one to turn down a story. “Of course!” he assured her, and they sat down on a bench.

“She lived thousands of years ago, and was renowned for her beauty. Some say I look like her, and since some of them actually saw her, I suppose I have to believe them,” she said with a little laugh.

“Luthien Tinuviel,” Bilbo murmured absently, remembering the first words Galadriel had spoken in his head, and Arwen looked at him in surprise.

“You know about her? Ah, of course. I told your mother about her,” she remembered, her smile softening. “She died for love, I assume you know that too.”

“Yes,” Bilbo agreed sadly. “And refused to be reembodied without the man she loved.”

“I worry sometimes what being compared to her means for my future,” Arwen admitted, staring into the distance. “There has been peace between the worlds for thousands of years, but there has also been isolation. Am I supposed to fall in love with a Man? How can I, when our worlds are separate, and my father and grandmother forbid me to leave?” She twisted her lips ruefully. “I don’t know why I’m telling you this.”

“You offered me a story, and you’re telling me one,” Bilbo replied, patting her hand comfortingly. “I bothered you constantly during the trip here, so it’s only fair.”

Arwen laughed again. “Your mother told me to just run away. I’m an adult, and should be able to do what I want.”

“Because that’s what she would have done,” Bilbo agreed, smiling fondly. “But you’re still here, aren’t you?” Her dæmon chirped a little song, coming to perch on Myrtle’s head. As with everything, she endured it with grumpy patience.

“I suppose you’re right,” she conceded. “Maybe if you save the worlds, things will be different.”

“That’s a pretty big ‘if’,” Bilbo replied tartly. “Given that we still don’t know how exactly how we’re going to do that.”

“You can do it,” she assured him gently. “Hobbits are kept safe in the Shire for a reason.”

Those words made it very hard to fall asleep that night.