Actions

Work Header

To Find a Long Forgotten World

Chapter 22: Hard Questions

Summary:

There are just too many problems for one dwarf to handle.

Chapter Text

Gandalf arrived sometime during the night, with all the grouchiness and irritability of a man who had been doing something important, only to be interrupted by the children squabbling. Bilbo learned this when he joined the company for breakfast, and found the wizard sullenly smoking his pipe in the corner. Thorin had not yet arrived, and Bilbo suspected that Galadriel had not told Gandalf why she had summoned him. Thorin’s appearance would clear that up, though Gandalf’s mood would probably not improve. The discovery that in your absence, everything had gone about as bad as it possibly could, could not be a pleasant one.

The wizard did brighten up a little when he saw Bilbo though, inviting him to his corner to join him for a smoke. “Bilbo Baggins! I half thought that they called me here to tell me they lost you somewhere!”

Bilbo laughed, but it felt a little strange laughing with Gandalf over the idea that he got trapped in the wilderness somewhere, and no one had noticed until he was far behind. “As you can see, I’m quite well,” he told Gandalf as cheerfully as he could under the circumstances.

“And I am glad to see it,” Gandalf admitted, though Bilbo sensed a ‘but’ coming. “However, I was very close to a breakthrough, and to be summoned only a few days into my research with no indication as to why… I trust I am not the only one who knows that the fate of the worlds is at stake?”

“It’s because the fate of the worlds is at stake that you were summoned,” Bilbo told him, hoping he didn’t sound too impatient. “A lot happened in Erebor while Thorin was away, and a few things happened to us after you left as well.” Gandalf looked ready to scold Bilbo for being deliberately obtuse, but Bilbo simply pointed at the doorway, where Thorin had appeared, without Mingalaz. “You can see there one of the problems.”

Gandalf squinted at Thorin, and then his eyes flew open, his brows drawing back in horror. It was the natural reaction, Bilbo thought, but he wished the wizard could be less obvious about it. For Thorin’s sake at least. “Goodness gracious me. What has happened?”

“I think Thorin would be more comfortable if he were the one to tell you,” Bilbo replied, exhaling smoke. “I imagine that’s why no one else has mentioned it.”

Gandalf made an assenting sound, his eyes following Thorin intently as he crossed the room. “And this is not the only problem, is it?”

“No, only the one we haven’t worked out a solution to yet,” Bilbo admitted grimly.

“Well, well, perhaps calling me back was the right choice after all,” Gandalf observed, putting away his pipe and straightening up. “The situation in Erebor is clearly more serious than I had thought.”

Bilbo did not see Gandalf again that day, the wizard sequestering himself first with Thorin, to hear his explanation no doubt, then with Dís to hear about their other problems, and lastly with Lady Galadriel. That was a conversation that Bilbo wished he could sit in on, but then again, maybe that would be no use. One tended to miss half the conversation anyway where the Lady was involved.

So instead, finding the dwarves deep in preparations for dealing with Khazad-dum and feeling that his only contribution there was to say that he would come and close the portal if they needed him to, Bilbo turned his feet toward the library. Ori drew him a map, and between that and Myrtle’s nose, he found it eventually.

The first thing that struck him about Erebor’s library was the complete lack of organization. Maybe it had only been since Dís had put the elves to work doing research, but there were books and tablets strewn everywhere, and no one seemed to be doing anything about it. It reminded him of the library in Numenor, though with less mold and fewer skeletons. He clutched Myrtle close, fearing to lose her amidst all the clutter.

“E-excuse me,” he addressed a nearby scribe. The scribe didn’t seem to register his words, but his owl dæmon swiveled her head to face him, fixing him with her lamp-like eyes. Encouraged, he went on. “Is this place always like this?” He gestured vaguely at the mess, only realizing afterward that the scribe couldn’t see what he was doing.

“Her Highness said too much important knowledge was buried under or trapped behind other tomes, so we are currently cataloguing every work in our library,” the scribe answered tonelessly, his quill scratching away on what Bilbo now realized was a list.

Bilbo’s fingers itched at the disarray, and Myrtle rolled her eyes, knowing what was coming next. “Is there anything I can help with? I came with the intention of doing research, but with the state things are in, I can see that wouldn’t be productive.”

This time, the dwarf scholar turned to face him properly, scrutinizing Bilbo with a sharp eye. “You’re the hobbit,” the scholar said finally. “You can’t read our language then, but we have many works written in Common. You can help with those.” He handed Bilbo a piece of parchment, a quill and ink bottle, and pointed him toward a pile of books.

“So much for instructions,” Myrtle muttered, waddling over toward the pile once Bilbo set her down. “I suppose you should just write down the titles, and maybe a brief summary of their contents if you can find one without reading the whole thing.”

Bilbo picked up the nearest book. “‘A Brief History of the Economic Relations Between the Seven Dwarf Clans,’” he read wryly. “I see they only write their most exciting books in Common.”

“Wouldn’t you?” Myrtle observed, burrowing into the pile to see if she could find something more interesting. “Obviously dwarf secrets are going to be written in their language, so that outsiders like us can’t understand them.”

Bilbo paused, his quill hovering over the ink bottle. “But when was the last time they saw ‘outsiders like us’?” he asked thoughtfully. “Aside from Gandalf, anyway. Who is really an outsider, when the only inhabitants of your world are dwarves?”

“Probably a holdover from when people did travel between worlds,” Myrtle replied with a shrug. “And traditions, like superstitions, are hard to break, even when your people have forgotten why they were put in place. We know a thing or two about that.”

That was certainly true. Many of his neighbors back in Hobbiton feared going too far from their own doorways, and as far as Bilbo knew, there was no reason for that. Their world was not only peaceful and safe, it was shielded by Elves! And it had always been so, as far as Bilbo knew. His people didn’t even have legends about dangerous things. His most exciting adventure in the Shire had been the day he and his mother had come across a lost mountain lion, and she had ignored them entirely. What were they so afraid of, really?

Bilbo shook his head, and scribbled down the name of the book. No point in dwelling on it, unless he managed to find a book in here that explained it.

Ori found him there hours later, in danger of being buried by the teetering stack of books that he’d added to the list, and somehow still awake despite the dryness of the material. “They want you in the council chamber,” Ori reported with a wistful look at the state of the library. “There’s some disagreement on the plan.”

Myrtle muttered something about “what does that have to do with us,” but Bilbo was already setting down his quill and tidying up the area. Picking up Myrtle, he left the list of books he’d examined with the scribe, who only acknowledged it with a grunt.

“What kind of disagreement?” he asked Ori once they were out of the library. “I don’t know the first thing about planning an attack.”

“You don’t need to,” Ori assured him hurriedly. “But the disagreement… well, it’s about you.”

“What about me?” Bilbo demanded, feeling a chill in his veins.

“Thorin doesn’t want you to come,” Kirthâl replied when Ori hesitated. “He says that Gandalf knows how to close portals just as well, and he could even teach them all how to do it. There’s no reason to risk your life, he says.”

He immediately went from feeling cold with worry to boiling with anger. “Oh, he thinks that, does he?” he said as calmly as he could manage, though Ori flinched anyway. “And I suppose when Gandalf finally determines how to deal with Sauron, he’ll try to leave me behind too!”

“I wouldn’t be surprised,” Myrtle replied grumpily. “The fool must have forgotten who led him to his shiny new sword.”

“Well, we just have to remind him then, don’t we?”

 


 

Bilbo was fuming, and Thorin didn’t think he deserved that.

“We have no idea how many orcs we could face, to say nothing of some demon of Morgoth’s which was know next to nothing about,” Thorin argued. “You have become a competent fighter, certainly skilled enough for the dangers we have faced so far, but this is different. Not everyone will come back.”

“I know that it’s not exactly a Sunday picnic!” Bilbo replied sharply. “If anything, you shouldn’t be going on this mission either, in the state you’re in! But because you’re the king, no one can tell you otherwise.”

Thorin readied himself to give an angry retort, but a glance at Balin and Dwalin revealed that Bilbo had hit the mark. Neither of them was making eye contact. So Thorin changed his tack, unwilling to give up his own place on the mission.

“I cannot guarantee your safety,” he said grimly, giving Bilbo an appraising look. The hobbit didn’t back down under his gaze, and Thorin fought back a bit of a grin. Even with his mind going, and his dæmon turned into a dragon, Bilbo wasn’t the least bit afraid of him. As it should be.

“When have you ever been able to?” Bilbo pointed out. “You need us, and you know it. We can find the fastest way to the chasm, unless you just happen to know how this place is laid out? I thought no dwarf had set foot in this place in generations.”

Thorin gritted his teeth. Of course. He didn’t want to put Bilbo at risk, but he had forgotten that Bilbo and Myrtle could find portals, and that that skill might be, okay would be, useful here to avoid unnecessary confrontations. “Very well,” he agreed finally. “Fíli, Kíli, take Bilbo to the armory. See if you can find something that suits him. Nothing too heavy. We leave in the morning, at first light.”

His nephews snapped to attention immediately, though Thorin heard Bilbo’s protests echoing down the hall as they led him away. Once they faded, he ran his hands through his hair and sighed. A dwarf would have thought this a generous gift, but of course Bilbo would have no idea what he was being offered.

“He’s right, you know,” Balin said, breaking into his reverie. Ranakâl croaked in what was probably agreement.

“I know,” Thorin admitted heavily. “But I can’t stay behind in Erebor while everyone else puts themselves at risk.” Which was probably how Bilbo had felt as well, but he’d done his best to ignore that anyway. Mingalaz wasn’t here to stare and call him a hypocrite.

“What did Gandalf say?” Dwalin asked, changing the subject.

Another sigh. Dwalin couldn’t have asked a worse question. “He said that he doesn’t know, that I am the first case of this that he has encountered,” Thorin replied, rubbing his temples. “But like the Lady, he is convinced there must be a way to undo it. The answer, he said, lies in my mind somewhere, which anyone could have determined.”

Balin looked thoughtful, scratching his chin with one hand. “Is it possible…?” He trailed off.

“Is what possible?” Thorin asked tiredly. Talking with ancient elves and wizards, who had far more questions than answers, had not put him in the mood for vagueness. Not that he ever was.

“Well, Mingalaz changed shape. We associate changes of that kind with pubescence, as dæmons shapes become fixed during that time,” Balin summarized quickly. “What causes them to fix on a shape is generally romantic or sexual awakening, though this is not the case for everyone. If I may ask-”

“Yes, that was the case for me,” Thorin answered, feeling his face grow warm and looking down. He suddenly found one of his rings very interesting. Much more interesting than facing Balin.

“In that case, do you think it is possible that replicating the original change could cause Mingalaz to remember her true form, and return to it?” Balin suggested cautiously.

Dwalin snorted. “Thorin’ll go mad before that happens.”

Thorin couldn’t help but agree. If going into Khazad-dum was more of a risk than he wanted Bilbo to take, he definitely didn’t want the hobbit anywhere near Mingalaz in her current state. Wait a second…

He narrowed his eyes. “Balin.”

Balin looked away.

“You didn’t think it was a secret, did you?” Dwalin asked, an eyebrow raised in amusement.

“And Kíli saw what happened in the cave, with the dragon,” Balin added, still not making eye contact. “I’m sure Bilbo would agree to help, if you asked without barking at him. Perhaps wait until the last argument wears off.”

Thorin wished he had Mingalaz at his side to cuff Daruthâ, who was snickering. At least Ranakâl was just ruffling her feathers and looking away.

“Assuming you managed to hit on the right idea, where Gandalf and Galadriel could not,” Thorin replied sourly.

“It’s just a suggestion,” Balin said with a shrug. “Get some rest. No point in tiring yourself out thinking about it.”

Thorin nodded absently, knowing that sleep would be impossible without Mingalaz nearby. But what could he do? Her current form was still a secret, and he was under strict orders not to show himself without her too much, lest there be talk. In the morning, when they gathered their forces to enter Khazad-dum, they would have to tell the assembled dwarves the truth. Mingalaz could be helpful in her current form, helpful enough that he couldn’t justify leaving her behind. She, like Bilbo, wasn’t likely to agree to being left behind in any case.

He retired to bed anyway, sleeping fitfully, but at least he slept. When he woke, he was surprised to find Dís waiting, sitting quietly in his parlor.

“You brought my sons back safe and sound,” she observed, her eyes fixed on a point on the wall.

“As I swore I would,” Thorin agreed, nodding.

“At the time, I regretted not asking one more thing of you,” she admitted, turning to look at him, her eyes bright. “Since you were able to bring them back safely, do so again. And make sure you’re with them. We have lost too many to the wraiths, and I have no doubt our people suffered huge losses from what waits in Khazad-dum. Do not let it take you too.”

“Dís-”

“I know you,” she cut him off. “You need purpose, a task, something that you must do, in order to keep yourself grounded. That’s probably how that dragon got into your mind: you felt you no longer had a task. Well, I am giving you one. Close that portal, then come home and find out what our ancient schemers have determined is the next step.”

There was nothing else he could say, except, “I will.”

Everyone who was going to Khazad-dum was already assembled when he arrived, even Mingalaz, who received wary looks, but no crossbow bolts. The plan was simple: Thorin and Mingalaz lead with Orcrist to ward off wraiths from the front. Bilbo was in the center of the formation, with Tauriel and Legolas on either side as bodyguards, and Gandalf rode in a circle around the group, creating a three pronged barrier against wraith attack. Once they entered Khazad-dum, their formation would change as the situation dictated it. The first goal was closing the chasm. Fighting anything inside was secondary, and that included the demon. If they encountered it, Gandalf claimed he had something prepared.

When Thorin reached the head of the formation, he saw what Gandalf meant.

“Glorfindel! I thought you had returned to Imladris,” Thorin observed, greeting the elf in surprise.

“I did, and then Gandalf informed me my services might be required again,” Glorfindel explained. “The demon inside Khazad-dum sounds like a Balrog of Morgoth. I fought one once, a long time ago. It took my life, but with Gandalf, we may be able to subdue one at a lesser cost.”

“Then I am grateful for you help and expertise,” Thorin replied, his shoulders sagging in relief. If it could be killed, and someone was along who had killed one, they had much less to fear. Before, he might have asked why Glorfindel had involved himself, but now Thorin had the answer. The chasm in Khazad-dum would eventually drain all worlds, and if the balrog could make more such chasms, that would be it. All life would be snuffed out. And perhaps Glorfindel had a score to settled with balrogs.

Feeling substantially better about the possibility of success, Thorin mounted Mingalaz, stroking her scales as he once petted her fur.

“Has anyone tried to hurt you?” he asked quietly, and she snorted, smoke coming out of her nostrils.

“Gandalf had to throw up a barrier initially, but once he explained, and once they noticed that I wasn’t attacking or flame-broiling anyone, they backed off. And then I might have rolled around in the dirt a little,” she admitted, stretching languidly as she rose from sitting.

“I’m sure they found that very threatening,” Thorin replied, raising an eyebrow. “Do you still feel like a cat inside?”

“I am still a cat inside,” she told him sharply. “Just my outside has changed.”

“Hmm,” Thorin hummed softly, but said nothing.