Chapter Text
When I finally returned to the mountain I found the whole of the Company waiting for me, having been told the approximate time of my arrival by the ever-helpful Ravens. I quickly filled them in on all that I had seen, causing Thorin to swear in Khudzul and mutter something unpleasant about elves.
“What is there to be done except what we’ve been doing already?” I said, since with regard to weapons we were well supplied, and there did not appear to be any way to increase our stocks of food by foraging in the surrounding areas, since the desolation of Smaug had suppressed the growth of plants and bushes that might have borne fruit.
“Dwarves know siege-craft laddie,” Dwalin told me. “There are fall-backs and baffles we can build, deeper in. This part of Erebor was not designed with defence in mind if the gates were breached, but other halls are. In greatest need, there are always the mines.”
“We shall send further messages to our kin,” Thorin said. “Dain in the Iron Hills is closest – doubtless he will have already received our first tidings, but he is not given to hasty action. None of his folk will have set out yet. There is time to ask for aid.”
It seemed quick for the Raven to have got that far, but when I actually tallied up the days since we had gained the treaty with Smaug I realised it had been nearly two weeks, though we had been so busy that I had scarce noticed it. Even so, without knowing how long it would take the Elves to gather their army it would be unwise to count on any outside aid. And at that, what of Gandalf? He had promised to return to us once his business was done, whatever it was. As a wizard, surely he would have the skill with words to avert this bloodshed. But then, would he approve of what I had been doing with the Ring? He had been sympathetic to the plight of the dwarves and how the elves had wronged them, but equally he had been friendly with Elrond, although Rivendell was not Mirkwood, and the two peoples hardly the same. Exactly whose side would he take when he eventually arrived? And with this realisation I had just given myself something else to worry about.
I would not trust to the good will of the Istari, the Ring whispered to me, being no comfort at all.
“Loath as any of us would be to destroy the works of our forefathers,” Balin was saying. “It may be necessary to sunder some of the walkways to cut off their routes of attack. We can always make repairs, but hopefully it will not come to that.”
“Perhaps we can lure them in front of Smaug’s throat,” Kili suggested, gesturing a torrent of fire with his hands.
“And what if they don’t come in?” Fili pointed out. “If they just sit out there and wait for us to starve?”
“We deal with that as it comes,” Thorin said. “For now, we follow Dwalin’s expertise.”
As jobs began to then be parcelled out, and Balin left for the watchtower and the Ravens, Hoarmurath approached from the shadows. “Little Master,” he greeted me, with a respectful bow of his head. “The dragon has been asking for you.”
“Then I’d better go see what he wants,” I replied, and set off following him forthwith.
The main treasury doors had been shut up once more, but there were other small gates easier to open. Passing through, I was struck by an unexpected heat. Of course the room had always been warm with the combined natural heat of the mountain and Smaug himself, but this was noticeably greater than it had been. As I ascended a flight of stairs to a better viewpoint I saw the dragon, again half-buried beneath gold, but also seeming to possess a rather unusual glow, a soft ruddy warmth that magnified the red of his scales. Indeed his long throat and chest were glowing dully with his inner fires, a more sedate version of what could be seen when he let loose his deadly breath. His eyes slitted open to watch me as I approached.
“Are you alright?” I asked him. “You seem... feverish.”
“That is one way to say it,” he replied. “I am not ill. But I am... heated.”
I frowned. “Heated? In what way?”
He stretched his head out languidly towards me, huffing out a hot burst of air that ruffled my hair. “I admit it unanticipated,” he said. “But it seems intent is not necessary for the One to awaken this.”
“So this is something I’m causing,” I replied, looking down quizzically at the plain band on my finger, sending it a mental query. “Well I’m very sorry to have been causing you discomfort without meaning to. I’ll stop straight away as soon as I know how.”
“Oh, there’s no need for that,” the dragon purred before the Ring could make any answer. “No, I think I quite like the opportunity this has given me. And you, in holding to our bargain.”
Awakening into my awareness, the first thing the Ring did was laugh at me. Wonderful, it whispered, stretching itself out to skate just above Smaug’s scales like someone feeling the heat of a candle with their palm. Oh, such a song I shall teach you to sing for this!
“Will the both of you stop being quite so cryptic and give a straight answer for once,” I said, getting somewhat exasperated. Smaug chuckled, such that I felt it reverberate in my chest.
“How much do you know of dragons?” he asked me.
“Evidently not enough,” I replied.
“For all the power you have won, your lack of knowledge is the greatest danger you pose to yourself,” Smaug told me. “Well, then what of those the younger races call gods? Of the Ainur; the Valar and the Maiar?”
“Hobbits don’t really have much truck with religion,” I explained. It embarrassed me to admit my ignorance, but equally there was a kind of defiance, an anger or irritation that I should be shamed at all. Knowledge was no measure of the worth of a being, yet that was the impression I had from creatures like Smaug and elves. A creature’s character made a better judge of such things, if you asked me. “Still, I have come across a few elvish legends in my time, which speak of such beings. And there is the one the dwarves call Mahal.”
“So much to learn,” the dragon said. “You should take lessons with the One more often. The Ainur are those which existed before this world was sung into being. Some elected to come down to reside within it in the earliest of days, when the idea of days was new. Spirits of varying natures and strengths. All had been one people in the time before, but soon rough groupings began to form. Divisions.”
I noted the significant look he gave me at that point, and I was having none of it. “Don’t go trying to test me by saying that war and hate is the natural state of things,” I told him. “People will dislike other people, I know. There will always be conflict, and I’m not saying I want to stamp that out. But it can certainly be settled by means other than violence! All these massive armies... Why, and I will wager half of those who fight on each side had no grievance with each other beforehand, and would never have had one if their irresponsible Thain-equivalent hadn’t dragged them into it!”
“Ah, I have angered you,” Smaug said, smiling. “Good. You will need that strength when you go out to stamp your mark on Arda. But I spoke of gods. There are the Valar, who are greatest in strength. And there are very many Maiar, those of air, those of earth, those of water, those of fire, and others besides. The one you know as Gandalf is such a being, a Maiar of knowledge, who was named first Olórin.”
“So dragons are one of these peoples of the Maiar then,” I said, seeing where this must be going. “But I thought you said something about hatching from an egg.”
“Patience,” Smaug told me, a little snappish at the interruption. The fires of his throat glowed a little stronger for a moment. I reached out for the power of the earth-blood merely as a precaution, noting though how quickly it came to my grasp now, after repeated use. “All will be revealed in time. Yes. I am a Maiar, residing in this physical shell.” He settled himself a little more comfortably, returning to his lecturer mode. “Of the fire Maiar there were three tribes. The Valaraukar are shadow and flame, named Balrogs by the elves, most favoured of Melkor. The Urulóki are the blood of the earth, and we are dragons. The others had no name to themselves, for they were disparate individuals, though many apprenticed themselves to Aüle and were the Ururauta. Mairon was one such.
“Once there were many of my kind in Arda,” Smaug continued. “In the early ages we swam without form in the great sea of fire that lies far beneath the earth. Perhaps some still do, but nothing has been heard from them in an Age. After a time a number of us arose to discover what was passing in the world above. We made forms for ourselves, and ranged forth in the cold of the far north where Arda bleeds and none ventures to quiet its glory. It was Glaurung who went first to Melkor’s stronghold Angband for news from the south.”
I still did not see what any of this had to do with his strange feverishness, or eggs, or anything of that ilk, but I did not want to be so rude as to interrupt him again. Besides, we were not wanting for time. Dwarvish skill would serve the Company’s efforts better than whatever aid I might be bringing.
“Melkor told him many things,” Smaug said, then sneering; “but to spare your mortal patience I shall speak of them another time. Suffice only that Glaurung then went forth against advice to see the new-born races of Elves and Dwarves and Men for himself, for he was young and curious. But he was also Fire, and Elves have no love for Fire that lives, unbound by hearth and stone. They drove him off, back to Melkor’s protection, and hearing thus many of us swore ourselves to Melkor’s cause.
“After that many years passed without incident, an account that meant little to we immortals. Melkor had no use for war at that time, and the other races were content with what they thought their siege, and so it would have remained if not for Thrangorodrim. For at the southern gate of Angband there rose three mountains with great fires beneath them that were given this name, and Melkor was long occupied in calming their rage. Yet the power of the earth cannot be denied forever. One day ash and fire and fury came forth, darkening the skies, and the blood of the earth swept over the plains of Ard-Galen, destroying the old and bestowing new life in the years to come. Once that bounteous land had belonged to the uruch, orc-tribes and allies of Morgoth, but not sworn to him. Their own feuds with the Elves had led to their slaughter when the Noldor came from over the sea. It was not only his own ills that Glaurung went out to avenge, heralded by the roar of Thangorodrim, but theirs also, and those of every creature named dark by the children of the stars.”
Smaug became more roused with this part, and his throat glowed fully, and fire could be seen behind his teeth, yet not spilling out.
“War came then, and it was glorious, with many great and fell deeds done on either side, and the blood ran red and black like water. Chaos came to the ordered lands of the Elves! The treasons and treacheries that ever periled their hearts were made plain to each other, though they blamed it all on Melkor’s doing, as was their wont. But once the plains of Ard-Galen and the passes that led to it were retaken Melkor tired of the bloodshed, for his plans had not been thus, and sent forth envoys suing for peace. Ever Elves and Men turned them away, but nor could they win aught back, and so the war turned slow and cold.”
I could not deny that this was all very interesting, since I had a passion for old stories and legends, but having asked for a succinct explanation, although this was not exactly succinct I could see that more was being missed out. I now realised that there were many details and events here that I knew nothing of, and meanings that must be escaping me. Still, for all that names of places sometimes confused me, Smaug told tales well, and his vast, low, rumbling voice was easy to listen to.
“This un-peace held,” the dragon continued, “until it came to pass that one of the Silmarils, most cursed of all jewels, was stolen from Melkor’s safe-keeping; and of those we must speak again in the days to come! But the taking of this gem bore up the hearts of Melkor’s enemies, and gathering their forces they marched forth again to war, and the fifth great battle of that Age. There Glaurung fought again, and many others of my kind, and amongst the great host were a phalanx of dwarves from Belegost with armour they had made to resist flame. It was their King, Azaghâl, who first taught us that our bodies might be slain, when he wounded Glaurung with his fierce axe, smiting his belly where he was soft.
“Death is a curious thing,” Smaug mused. “It differs between each race. Men leave Arda forever and go none know where. The spirits of Elves go to Valinor and the Halls of Mandos, and rarely may be given new bodies and return, as did Glorfindel of Imladris. Dwarves are taken to the halls of their ancestors, the location of which only Aüle knows. And we go not quite beyond Arda, yet not quite of it either. After the wounding of Glaurung we spoke amongst ourselves and resolved that we had no wish to be trapped there, so with the aid of Melkor, whose songs were powerful, and Mairon, whose smithcraft was great, we forged spells to draw our kin back into eggs that we would lay.
“For myself, I died first in the war that came later against the forces of the Valar, and Mairon and Turcosú of the Uruloki sang me back to rebirth at the ending of the Second Age. I would have fought there at the battle of the Last Alliance, save that I hatched too late. And now, with that kin-power so close, and so many of my fellows perished, the need to lay has come upon me.”
I looked at him with astonishment. Admittedly his words had made me think something of that sort as he went on, but it was still something of a surprise to hear it said aloud.
“So do both male and female dragons lay eggs then?” I asked.
“If you want to apply such terms,” Smaug replied. “But yes, we though it more convenient.”
“Well... congratulations,” I said, as one might to any expectant parent. “Do you know yet how many new little dragons will be running around the mountain...?”
“That depends on you.”
“Me?”
“Yes,” the dragon purred. “You don’t imagine I will be singing my kin back alone do you?”
“Oh! Yes. Well. Of course I’ll help,” I said, feeling rather out of my depth and not sure what to do about it. This is all your fault, I told the Ring. It projected smugness back to me.
nd what better way to inaugurate your new dominion, it said. You will certainly be needing the help.
As if things weren’t complicated enough already.
I would have questioned Smaug more on exactly what was expected of me, but he dismissed me before I could ask, yawning hugely with a great show of teeth and citing tiredness. I thought over how much I should tell the others as I headed back towards where I had been assigned to work today, but still knowing only the basics I thought it better to wait. This would surely mean the treaty would need to be changed however, and that was likely to cause even more problems.
I would need to take some quiet moment to talk to the Ring and interrogate it on the matter, but such a moment was not due to come until the evening. In the meantime I occupied myself with fetching and carrying stone and heavy wood and various unfamiliar shapes of metal and tools for Dori, Ori and Nori, overseen by Dwalin, in the corridors linking the main halls with those less impressive and expansive further in.
----
Balin came back from the watchtower that evening with news from the Ravens. Tauriel had left for Mirkwood and they were following her now on her journey. They intended to venture their watch as far into the forest as they could, but did not know how successful they might be. The control this new king had over his domain was as yet unknown.
After our evening meal Thorin and I went to bed, and thence had a great deal of fun until we were both quite tired out. I still had something to do however, and once he had fallen asleep, I roused myself enough to begin my conversation with the Ring.
As I understand it, I said, for I’d had time to think about this, you were with Mairon still at the end of the Second Age. So you must have seen this whole process, yes?
It is so, it replied, seeming eager to talk to me. But ask your questions and I will answer, as fully as any might wish.
What exactly is it that will happen next? I asked. And what will my part in it be?
Dragon eggs are not like the eggs of birds or lizards, the Ring replied with a thoughtful air. They are shaped of crystal and stone. The last time this happened, materials were brought from the bowels of Orodruin, broken up so they were easy to swallow. It is likely this will be a request made of your dwarves.
Again, I repeat, not my dwarves, I replied, sighing internally. But that seems simple enough, though I’ll not pretend to know how stone can become something alive.
Why, the Ring said, laughing, dwarves were stone once, or at least that was the base of them, since Aüle had not the gift for crafting in flesh that his wife Yavanna possessed.
I could not help but reflecting with this new surprise that all this talk of ancient days and creation and gods was very far from my life as it once had been; a simple gentle-hobbit of means. But it seemed that that life was far behind me now, and indeed I could barely conceive of going back to it. There was a certain sadness in that, in being so changed by my experiences, but the friends I had in the Company, and Thorin, and everything that the Ring had given me and that I intended to do with it was such that all these new joys entirely made up for my losses.
Well, I’m sure getting enough stone will not be a problem, I said. Does it have to be a particular sort?
Quartz, or chalcedony. But of course that is only the first step. After that comes the song. The duet.
I’ll need your guidance for that.
My voice is yours, the Ring told me. I shall lead you in this as I have the other songs of magic you have learned. Have no fear that this shall be anything less than a success.
Then what? Once these Maiar souls have gone into the eggs, will they take very long to hatch?
Not particularly, the Ring replied. But they will need other materials for their bodies once they emerge. For Smaug, the orcs brought forth gold and copper, obsidian and charcoaled iron, and many hard gems also, and poured them into a great crucible over the mountain’s fires, from which he forged himself to the plan of his own desiring.
If he expects that from the dwarves he’ll have a hard time of it, I warned. We’ve not even got the mines open yet, much less started to pay their tithe to him.
An answer to that I cannot give, the Ring said.
Perhaps Smaug had finally found a use for that vast hoard of his then than simply sitting on it. He had said himself that he would not part with it for other races, taking it as the rightful property of his own kind, but since it would be more dragons he was making, or summoning, or whatever the correct word might be, he might let these newborns have some small amount of it. As to the iron, steel, obsidian and whatever else, we certainly had enough arms and armour sitting about unused. What better way than to armour potential new allies with them? I doubted there would be a problem there.
I would check on the details of all this tomorrow, I resolved, and tell the Company after. With that decision made, and feeling less uncertain of my role in all this, I finally allowed sleep to claim me, and sank down into the glorious warmth of Thorin’s bed and his arms around me.
----
“You do not mean for us to surrender the works of our forefathers to the dragon!” Thorin said, angry and surprising me with his rage. It had all been going so well too. Smaug had been pleased that I had asked the Ring about what was to happen, and that he did not need to bestir his rest to tell me more stories. The egg-fever was making him particularly slothful. He had even agreed, with an easiness that seemed almost suspicious, that the precious materials for physical forms should come from the treasury. I had gone forthwith to tell the others, and ask about iron and other metals, and unfortunately this was the reaction that had ensued.
“No!” I exclaimed, “that’s not it at all! Just some of the weapons and armour, nothing of high quality or sentimental value.”
Thorin sighed, and I could see from the disapproving looks on the faces of Balin, Dwalin and the others that this must be some point of dwarvish culture that I was missing entirely. “Bilbo, there is no work of dwarven hands that has no meaning attached to it,” he said. “Everything is of significance. Everything has meaning to the family of those who made it. All dwarves are craftsfolk; those who cannot make the thing they need barter like with like to acquire it. That is why gifts mean so much to us. The only things we make without meaning are those we sell to outsiders, serej, empty, and there is none of that here.”
This did make things clearer. Nor could I criticise the strength with which they would hold on to such things, knowing now their meaning, not since Smaug had forced them to give up so much. I could find no argument against it either, not one that was not cruel.
“Is there no other iron that hasn’t yet been used?” I asked. “No ore not yet smelted, no ingots stockpiled?”
Thorin thought on this. “It has been so long,” he said. “Nor were the base metal forges ever my responsibility. I suppose it is possible...”
“Supply and demand were ever well-matched,” Balin said. “But aye, I would not rule it out.”
“And there’ll be whatever was in the system when it was shut down,” Bofur chimed in. “Mind, I am of Ered Luin born and bred. These are not my mines, nor the forges I knew, but the principles are the same. I’ve had time enough to survey it here too. Ore is brought up by great waterwheels, and whoever had charge of this place had sense enough to pull the emergency stop before they left. It’s all in good order, and the buckets have whatever was in them ‘afore.”
“That will have to do,” I said.
“Still, having a load of dragons within these walls...” Gloin said. “I can’t say it sits well.”
“Indeed,” Dori said. “We have no guarantee they will respect the treaty.”
“And why should we supply any of this to Smaug?” Thorin said. “His crimes have been ignored for the sake of Erebor, but I see no reason we should do him any favours.”
“A favour for a favour,” I argued. “We may need him soon enough if the elves come, and what then if he delays out of spite?” For as much as he and I were getting along for the moment, I had no illusions as to his nature. “And as to the young ones, Smaug will be around to keep them straight,” I reassured them all. “And who knows that they’ll stay here once they get a little bigger? They might want to seek their own homes. Or... there are things I have to do, once all this is over. Not,” I added hastily, seeing Thorin’s face, “that I intend to leave Erebor, or at least not for long. But it was a promise I made to Smaug, and these other dragons may agree to help me keep it.”
“I am not sure of the wisdom of this,” Thorin said. “But we swore this oath; that Smaug should share our home, and no dwarf will break their word. He may do as he will in his part of it. As for stone... there are rose quartz statues in parts of the treasury, and if he can find them, he can have them. It will be hard to know he has destroyed them, but we have given them up to him already. The rest, iron and obsidian, we shall take that from the damn beast's tithe and let him sit a coward if it comes to battle!”
I sensed this was just about as good as I was going to get, so I let it lie and made no further argument. The power of my words had done so much more for the relationship between the dragon and the dwarves than ever might have been expected, and what right did I have for even more? So that seemed to be that, and I was glad we had found some solution, even if it was a compromise. The ores might even be more useful than that which had already been forged, having more possibilities in what might be made of it, although that much was only guesswork, and optimism.
With the outcome of this news, our schedule was repurposed, and soon the buckets were moving again to dump their loads at the forges. The hoard-stuff would be brought in with the eggs nearer the time, under Smaug’s watchful eye, to be guarded there until they hatched. Apparently he trusted either the Nazgúl to be adequate guards on the rest in the meantime, or the eggs meant more to him than gold – which entirely made sense to me, since obviously family was much more important than useless, if pretty, metals.
The only thing to do now was work and wait. Wait for the eggs, and wait for the elves, and hope that no doom would come from all this.
----
“Glorious, are they not?” Smaug sounded very smug, and indeed he had a right to be.
“Ten!” I exclaimed, gazing upon the numerous orbs, each a rough sphere the height of a man, looking so much like rocks I would have been pressed to tell the difference had I not already known of it. “I hadn’t expected...”
“Nor entirely did I until it happened,” Smaug confessed. “But there are many of my kin trapped in that space between worlds, and no other of the Urulóki left to sing them free. Cold-drakes are all very well, as cousins, but they are not kin enough to do this.”
“Yes,” I said, still somewhat discombobulated. “The song, of course. When do you wish for that to happen?”
“Have you aught else you would rather be doing?” Smaug asked me, his voice silk over steel. As a matter of fact I had only come to see him in order to check how he was and if anything had changed, but he was right that nothing I had been intending to do could not be put off for a little while. The minor inconvenience of it was, perhaps, a small revenge for the price the Company was charging for his necessary materials.
“If you want to do it now, I suppose I have no objection,” I replied, giving the Ring a little mental nudge to bring it to wakefulness. I felt the power of it stretch out beneath my skin.
“Yes, little mage-apprentice, now,” the dragon said, and curled himself with a great ripple of scale and wing in a circle around the eggs, with myself inside. Already a low bass thrum was starting to come from the depths of his chest, and his eyes slitted half-closed as his head swayed like a serpent’s.
What do I do? I asked the Ring, and as it had before it swept me up with itself, guiding my mind after its own with a light touch and a burst of wordless music that seemed to come from no instrument but the very vibration of the universe itself. I followed on, unresisting, trusting it as I never would have before I had had bested it and became its Master, before it had proved itself loyal to me.
We go to the edges of Arda, it told me. Not a matter of distance, but of stepping out, as you have stepped into the realm of the spirit many times before. Here, feel the Maiar beside you even now. And as it said it, I perceived. Smaug shone red and gold, a vast and liquid thing like a streamer of fire, like the truth behind the earth-blood echo that I had called upon those times. He moved through the substance of the place – for we were travelling, though I had scarce recognised it – as an eel through a river. The song of the mountain was around us, welling up from deep below, singing notes that I knew instinctively as gold and diamond and much else precious besides, with borrowed knowledge that would not fade. As we swam out, we swam down too, through rock that was at the same time fire and smoke and ash that rippled with memory, down to greater heats, to that which was molten in truth, slumbering beneath clogged and forgotten ways, unable to seek the surface.
With their kinship upon Arda we will call them, the Ring told me. With the blood of Arda they share.
And even then, Smaug began to sing.
It was a bellow of unutterably complex sound, but that was only the beginning of the melody. As it went on, I perceived how strains of thought were picked up and blended in, like a conversation, like an argument, like a great treatise on the subject of all that the Urulóki were and might be expressed as. I recognised there the song of Erebor above, of the earth-fires below, of Smaug himself, and of the Ring and the kinds of power it knew. Then the Ring was prompting me, for the arrangement was only just begun, and I had my own part to play in it.
No mortal words set down here can convey the majesty of what was wrought beneath the mountain that day. Only song, only that song, was capable of expressing it. It could not be distilled, could not be compressed, could not be understood by anything less than what it was. It was the greatest work of magic that I had yet imagined, and never would I have thought myself capable of it were it not for the Ring guiding me, indeed, as much as working through me.
Particular themes began to make themselves known as the piece went on. I recognised them as the form of names, true names, as Maiar would have them, rather than the simple syllables of elf-wrought languages, as venerable as those might themselves have been. We called on creatures and powers that I truly did understand then as akin to gods, but also I knew that I had the soul of my own god buoying me up in Mairon’s Ring. However had I managed to defeat such a thing, I wondered in that moment? That a mortal should make such a thing bow.
Yet it was but an idle question, a fleeting thought, when all else was taken up by the song. And here forth came the Maiar, the Urulóki, the dragons, and danced with us in that place not quite beyond the world, and slowly, so slowly, we brought them back with us as we returned.
